9 ms·
Being a retail customer on Wall Street is a fool's game. The large finds have access to legal data and insights that you don't have. Just invest in an index fun
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Being a retail customer on Wall Street is a fool's game. The large finds have access to legal data and insights that you don't have. Just invest in an index fund or large mutual fund.
- samstave 9y agoIsn’t that Vanguards Rule?
- Pokepokalypse 9y agoIt's anybody with common sense's rule.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Being a retail customer on Wall Street is a fool's game There are time periods [1] and strategies [2] in which individuals outperform. (That said, most people should just track the marker.) [1] https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_papers/JFE%20ARTICLE%2004052016.pdf https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_... [2] https://www.alexandria.unisg.ch/231425/1/14_08_Soderlind%20et%20al_Individual%20Investor%20Activity%20and%20Performance.pdf https://www.alexandria.unisg.ch/231425/1/14_08_Soderlind%20e...
- jxm262 9y agoI'm interested in your first link but it seems down (404). Would you happen to have an alternative, or just post the title?
- ipsin 9y agoThe URL has an extra "Q" at the end. https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_papers/JFE%20ARTICLE%2004052016.pdf https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_...
- craftyguy 9y agoYour first link is broken. I think maybe you meant this? https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_papers/JFE%20ARTICLE%2004052016.pdf https://www.eurofidai.org/sites/default/files/pdf/EUROFIDAI_... (there was an extra 'Q' at the end)
- achamayou 9y agoInvesting in an index fund effectively means letting a financial services company such as S&P Global manage your investment without you being their customer. And if you're not paying for it... Sure, you'll pay a low fixed commission to the fund, but they're just tracking what S&P publishes. It's not necessarily a bad idea, but it's hardly a panacea with perfect incentives.
- walshemj 9y agoAbsolutely if you can only afford $50/$100 a month the an index tracking the FTSE or the DOW makes sense. Once your portfolio gets bigger start having a minimum investment amount of $1000 you need to start thinking about diversification.
- tc313 9y ago> start thinking about diversification Buying an index fund composed of 500 large U.S.-listed companies is pretty diversified. I suppose you could diversify internationally, but no need to stray from index funds if you're not managing your money full-time.
- achamayou 9y agoStocks aren't the only asset available for investment, regardless of geographical location. They're also fairly volatile, so retail investment often consists of blending that with more stable fixed income assets.
- walshemj 9y agoI meant in different countries and sectors I did very well with a commercial property trust a few years back when the sector was out of favour.
- dlubarov 9y agoYou can use an international stock index fund like VT. That will include some real estate companies like EQR, but if you want extra real estate exposure, there are index funds like VNQ for that. Or if you want bonds, there are index funds like BND.
- adamnemecek 9y agoI wouldn't be so diffident. In my experience, Wall Street for example doesn't understand tech that much. E.g. exactly a year ago, Nvidia had a three month dip. After I listened on the earnings call, all the WS people were asking "why are people still buying gpus and why is it accelerating". They didn't know about ml, gaming and crypto. Wall Street is too oriented on the next 3 months, not the next year.
- useranme 9y agoIf one has the ability to trade when the price moves, one makes more by selling Nvidia in the beginning of a dip and buying it on the uptrend. Wall Street not understanding tech that much isn't as important if Wall Street can react to the price change.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoOPs point is still good though. Retail investors can often have “one-up” on the industry. Investing into that edge can be a real advantage.
- sgt101 9y agoThe OP is deluded. Yes, on the earnings call they're not sitting there saying "guys, girls, Nvidia stock is going to be driven up by ML" but that's not because they don't know, it's because there is no value at all in them disclosing this. Everyone on the call knows it, what they are trying to do is to shake lose some info on one of the cashflow facts that can then be used by an activist to squeeze the Nvidia board into cutting investment and issuing a dividend. If you think you have an edge on people who are paid to do a job I suggest that you take up cage fighting - it will provide a set of instructive lessons on the limits of amateur capability. Some people get lucky, most people get poor, everyone else invests in indexes.
- adamnemecek 9y agoWall Street might be aware of ml but they underestimated how much of an impact it would have on GPU sales. > If you think you have an edge on people who are paid to do a job As I said, they are too concerned with the next three months, not the next two years. Also, like how many people on wall street specialize in nvidia analysis? And I do think that it's possible for an amateur to beat a professional under certain circumstances. Also please listen to the earnings call. It should be the Q2 one.
- paulie_a 9y agoNot to boast, but I have consistently done better retail investing on individual stock than my IRA well ever do. I divested from a couple funds they couldn't even beat inflation.
- tossaway1 9y ago>I have consistently done better retail interesting on individual stock than my IRA well ever do Your comment doesn't make sense to me. Don't IRAs allow for investing in individual stocks...?
- paulie_a 9y agoIt was a managed IRA, I figured I'd let the professionals handle it. I only play around with the markets
- rebuilder 9y agoWhat's the timeframe? It's entirely possible to beat the index for a time by flipping a coin. A lucky streak early on can set you up for success, for example. I've found www.chartgame.com quite illuminating in this regard. You can beat the average for "years" just randomly bashing buttons, but of course most of the time you don't.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsacco 9y agoIf you are a programmer with a good understanding of statistics, you can get access to legal data not reflected in market prices and profit on smaller capacities than hedge funds. In fact, you can achieve a Sharpe ratio comparable with the best modern trading strategies (albeit without specialized knowledge, infrastructure and a full team you won’t be doing it on billions in AUM). I gave a basic guide for doing this with equity prices just yesterday in a comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16349011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16349011 The short version is that you need to find actionable data that reliably maps to the revenue of companies without many revenue streams, collect the data (basic programming skills), build a timeseries and forecasting model from that data (statistics and basic financial knowledge), then take a contrarian position when expected earnings are very far off from what your data predicts. This outline is structurally similar for non-equity securities. Obvious caveat: I still basically recommend people invest in diversified index funds. But speaking as someone who has done what I just outlined, I see no reason not to give a clear-eyed explanation if you’re already set on active trading.
- eksemplar 9y agoOr buy after crashes and sell when you see nice gains. It requires patience but the market has been really silly since the 2007 crash. Like the diesel crisis for German autos. Stock plumeted but it’s not like VW is going to stop being successfully at selling cars over a political scandal, so it was obviously going to recover. When Trump talked about regulating foreign green tech in December the entire world dumped their stock in solar and wind companies. A company who had just signed two billion dollar contracts in China and India went down 150 points in one day, it’s already made 50 of those back. It’s honestly behaving more and more like crypto currencies, so maybe now is a good time to get out?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoOr buy after crashes and sell when you see nice gains. The trouble with that is you can be out of the market for a long time waiting for the crash, all the while missing gains.