14 ms·
What Thunderbird Learned at FOSDEM
- giancarlostoro 9y agoI hope hey don't only support enigmail for encryption but also S/MIME which is supported by both the native macOS Mail client and Outlook. We have to pay for a plugin at my job for Thunderbird that if I remember correctly lets us read encrypted mail, but not write it, unless I'm miss remembering.
- jcranmer 9y agoS/MIME is natively supported by Thunderbird, unlike PGP (which requires Enigmail).
- giancarlostoro 9y agoOh I must've mixed up in my head Exchange support for S/MIME then. It's been a while since I had to use Thunderbird at work (using Windows recently) so I forgot the reason. I do remember someone mentioning it can only read those emails though, not really write / encrypt them. Edit: Found the plugin we use: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/addon/exquilla-exchange-web-services/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/addon/exquilla-... Looks like the last comment is complaining about not being able to encrypt mail with the plugin working. I am not convinced S/MIME is fully working, or if it is, there's plenty of UX issues with it's current implementation.
- jcranmer 9y agoS/MIME works just fine in Thunderbird, although the UI is pretty poor. I will believe that composing S/MIME doesn't work in Exquilla: Exchange uses a different format for representing messages than MIME, and the hook that it uses to build messages happens before S/MIME gets introduced, and the S/MIME code itself pretty heavily bakes in the fact that it's emitting MIME.
- incognito82246 9y ago> S/MIME works just fine in Thunderbird Mostly, yes, once you jump through the hoops of getting a personal certificate (let's encrypt style automation as plugin would be great!). But there appears to be some issues with adding recipient certificates that are structured in a specific way. Something about the Subject format being valid for s/mime but not recognized by mozilla's cerfificate store as an other-people certificate and as a server cert instead. This was a certificate used by a local government agency. That made it quite difficult to communicate with them securely. This is one of the few times where I really needed secure email and that's when it failed me.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe UI for adding certificates is, as I recall, a massive clusterfuck. That's due in large part to this traditionally being the domain of the certificate manager folks from Firefox, where a) the necessary components are extremely low-usage (when was the last time you used a SSL client certificate?), and b) some of those people don't give a fuck about Thunderbird.
- avian 9y ago> There is not a really good, open source, Email client on mobile. I know that mobile is more than Android, but I find K-9 mail to be a really good, open source, mobile mail client. https://k9mail.github.io/ https://k9mail.github.io/
- arca_vorago 9y agoI'm the sort of person who lives on the cli, I've been considering trying to port some of my emacs/gnus setup to my android device. I wonder how well it would work?
- vidarh 9y agoCheck out Termux. I'm running Emacs on both my phone and tablet on occasion. https://wiki.termux.com/wiki/Main_Page https://wiki.termux.com/wiki/Main_Page
- bergie 9y agoNote: also works on new-ish Chromebooks (so you don't necessarily need to enable developer mode to work offline).
- megaman22 9y agoYou must hook a real keyboard up, right? I can't even imagine trying to run emacs on an on-screen touch keyboard.
- Fnoord 9y agoHacker Keyboard will allow you to achieve a lot. All, with all CLI programs? That I do not know. There is a learning curve either way. You can also SSH out of your machine with a terminal app (recommend to look into Mosh) if you got a good internet connection such as 4G/LTE or WiFi. Then you can run e.g. Mutt remotely. Use with tmux and never close it. As for hook up, there's BT and USB OTG.
- arca_vorago 9y ago
- le-mark 9y agoThe biggest barrier I see to making a forum a core part of the community effort is getting buy-in from MOST of the contributors to the project currently. So, over the next week I’m going to try and get an idea of who is interested in participating and who is opposed. What I've seen work really well in the past is one contributor to lead 'interfacing' with the community via the forum; announce releases, and just generally be a voice for the developers. Maybe you have this person already. Otherwise, if the funds are available, hiring a community manager type person is always as option.
- cs702 9y agoFormer Thunderbird user here. I'm shocked that there's no mention of the need for reliable out-of-the-box synchronization with online calendars and contacts. (At one point, I tried all the available Thunderbird add-ons for syncing with Google's apps; none worked well for me.) Even better than synchronization, I would love to have an alternative to existing online email/calendar/contact services. If Mozilla were ever to offer its own paid email, calendar, and contacts subscription service, powered by open-source code, and backed with strong customer/data/privacy protections, I would sign up in a heartbeat.
- Freak_NL 9y agoIntegration with Google's calendars just works though, has done so for years — use the Lightning add-on and the Provider for Google Calendar add-on.
- cs702 9y agoIt's never worked well for me, e.g., when responding to third party calendar invitations, when moving meetings with others, when using two-factor authentication, when adding contacts on multiple devices. Both of those add-ons have always been clunky and brittle for me. They have caused me to miss appointments and have also occasionally messed up my contact data. I would never, ever use these add-ons for work. See viraptor's comment for links to reported bugs: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16340039 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16340039
- viraptor 9y agoIt kind of works, most of the time. On other occasions you'll get meeting reminders you can't dismiss, event cancellations which stack a new crossed out date on the list for every "update" click, events where you can't set attendance, and the annoying "you clicked dismiss, would you like to submit the modified event to the server" dialog. And that's on a good day :-( There's lots of outstanding bugs unfortunately. See https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1314185 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1314185 - earliest dependent bug is 8 years old.
- jamesgeck0 9y ago
- ForHackernews 9y agoFor people who value it, consider donating specifically to support Thunderbird development https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/ https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/ I'm making a regular monthly donation because I use this software every day, and I don't want it to go away. My understanding is that normal donations to Mozilla don't go towards Thunderbird anymore.
- Tharkun 9y agoMozilla has plenty of money. If they truly cared about an open internet as they claim, they would be taking better care of Thundebird. It is by far the most popular open source mail client, and email is something that needs to be saved from the evil clutches of FB messenger and the like.
- ForHackernews 9y agoThat may be, but Mozilla has decided not to pay for development on Thunderbird any more. If we don't contribute to keep it alive, and the project whithers and dies, I guess we can console ourselves with the satisfaction that we proved a point to those bean-counters at Mozilla.
- wink 9y agoIf the author reads this: I was part of the crowd commenting on the "is it dead?" state and thanks for answering my questions and giving me hope! :)
- cryptos 9y agoI really hope that they will build a Thunderbird version for the browser. Something like Horde or RoundCube isn't exactly a joy to use and most people are heading towards GMail and the like just because it is the simplest option.
- acdha 9y agoOn the subject of encryption, S/MIME has broad client support (e.g. the clients shipped in all major desktop & mobile operating systems) and the security model is easier for most people to understand (WoT sadly often means “accept everything without checking” in practice). What's missing is a LetsEncrypt-style effort to make it easy for people in non-managed environments to get and renew certificates. It'd be really nice if Mozilla & the rest of the industry chose to invest in that infrastructure and some usability improvements to make it more manageable. This would be especially useful if it extended to browser integration so a user could trivially prove to a remote website that they had a valid signing certificate for a given address.
- rlpb 9y ago> WoT sadly often means “accept everything without checking” in practice I'd like to see Trust on First Use used automatically, combined with automatic key generation with no prompting. PGP is probably more suited to this. While it's not perfect, it is possible to retrospectively verify a key and on success consider it perfect. A well designed UI could expose this. Details: 1. Generate a key automatically with no prompting. 2. Sign everything outbound automatically with no prompting (if necessary use the header or rely on a multiple email handshake if you're bothered that users will see an "attachment" they won't understand). 3. Expose "identities" in the UI with information about what incoming mail corresponds to what identities, and what trust has been assigned to individual identities. 4. Permit encrypted email to be sent to identities, whether they are trusted or not. 5. Allow retrospective assignment of trust to identities. 6. Allow users to publicly "join" their identities for when autogeneration has happened in multiple places (eg. separately on webmail, my phone and my tablet). 7. Allow import and export of keys and external key agents for users who want to go all the way.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoS/MIME is extremely well suited for this, because it's already supported in many clients natively. You could make it possible to obtain a validated identity (e-mail validation) from a CA. Many of today's clients would natively be able to verify and trust this identity without previous key exchange. You could still slap arbitrary additional verification on top of this - trust-on-first-use, WoT, whatever you feel like - but an attacker would first have to overcome the (relatively weak) CA validation and then the additional fancy thing, while it would be usable for normal users immediately. The only open issue would be multiple identities and joining them. This could be fixed by sharing the key (i.e. if you generate a key on your phone, tablet and PC, you'd have to take each of the three keys and place a copy on the other two devices).
- optimuspaul 9y agoOf course people think it's dead, there isn't even a link to it on the Mozilla site.
- addicted 9y agoThunderbird is supposed to separate from Mozilla, which decided to focus almost exclusively on Firefox. They are sharing resources at the moment, but that appears to be transitionary.
- stewbrew 9y agoThe biggest problem I have with thunderbird is that it fails to render some html mails properly. Above all, they should fix this problem first. Instead of creating a mobile app or whatever, they should get their existing client right. As of today, the 2 things that keep me from switching fully to evolution are (1) evolution's unfriendly keyboard shortcuts that, for whatever reason, I cannot change, and (2) nostalgy.
- bzbarsky 9y agoHave you filed bugs about this, with the example emails attached? Thunderbird uses the same exact HTML/CSS renderer as Firefox. To the extent that it's not rendering mails "properly", those mails are clearly expecting to be rendered in a way different from what the HTML/CSS standards say... It's possible to make this work, if needed, but the developers would need to at least know what standard-deviating behaviors are needed.
- gsich 9y agoHTML mails are an abomination, just tell people to use text/plain.
- fs111 9y agohahahaha, you are funny
- u801e 9y agoCould Thunderbird be configured to open a web browser to display the message if it's not rendered properly?
- jcranmer 9y agoThunderbird uses Gecko, the same engine as Firefox, to render emails. This means it's actually generally the most-compliant HTML rendering email of any email client: you can even use MathML and <video> if you want to (assuming that the bug about <video> controls requiring JS has been fixed). The three caveats to this statement that might apply: 1. Thunderbird loads the message in quirks mode. 2. cid: links in CSS aren't going to load properly (and other resource URLs are generally blocked by default). 3. Different HTML sections in a message can leak together, largely due to there lacking a good way to combine multiple HTML documents into a single scroll frame (if any Gecko layout folks are reading this, can you please fix https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=80713 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=80713 ?).
- ronjouch 9y ago> "2. I would like to see a mobile app." Opposite stance: please, Mozilla, do not build mobile Thunderbird apps. That's tremendous effort, and IMHO too much for what you can do with the priority on Firefox, even with these new Thunderbird hires. Focus on polishing and maintaining the existing Thunderbird the best you can with the limited resources you have for the project. You have a large existing userbase that will be extremely thankful for that.
- ekianjo 9y agoand K9 on Android is not a bad client. It seems like people are not aware of it much.
- CaptSpify 9y agoIt's the best mobile client I've used, but thats not saying much. It doesn't make me sad, which is the best I can say about it
- Sylos 9y agoI mean, I don't know about you, but that seems to be the fate of any mail client. "Doesn't make me sad" is the highest rating that any mail client, web-based or not, has ever gotten from me.
- mondoshawan 9y agoIt's not a /good/ client, either. It's adequate, but has a long way to go to clean up it's UX and normal reading flow.
- cvwright 9y agoNo argument here. But is it any worse than Thunderbird?
- Arkanosis 9y agoMy own take on this point: for my neither trivial nor very advanced needs, K9 at least lacks: - hierarchical display of email threads; - search that actually works. That being said, I'm rather happy with K9, and I'd certainly prefer to see energy spent in making it even better than in making a “Mobile Thunderbird” from scratch.
- jrochkind1 9y ago> They pointed out that they were Thunderbird users, but weren’t really into mailing lists. There's some kind of irony in people wanting an email client not being into mailing lists. I wonder if it's because Thunderbird ought to handle mailing lists better than it does somehow, perhaps coming up with some innovative UI rather than trying to copy more popular proprietary (and these days mostly web-based) email clients.
- u801e 9y agoThey could set up a NNTP server to serve as a forum. The problem with mailing lists is that there's no good way to search past messages from before you subscribed (the web based ones don't cut it). A newsgroup does not have that problem.
- jrochkind1 9y agoInteresting idea, I believe Thunderbird even has NNTP support of some kind, although haven't investigated it recently.
- u801e 9y ago> I believe Thunderbird even has NNTP support of some kind, although haven't investigated it recently. It definitely does. Before Thunderbird and Firefox were created, the Mozilla Application suite included a mail & news client (which is what Thunderbird is based on).
- secfirstmd 9y agoI train users all the time on Thunderbird and to be honest, many people really dislike the UI/UX. Even though I'm primarily getting them to use it for security reasons, unfortunately so many of them really hate the transition from Mac Mail or Outlook. Working on that, rather than duplicate K9 Mail, would be my suggestion.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoCould you be more specific about what they don’t like? Besides another layout for widescreen I’m happy with it.
- secfirstmd 9y agoEssentially people get used to a more modern, fresh approach that they feel they get with Mail.app etc and look for something similar with Thunderbird.
- EduardoBautista 9y agoWhat benefits does thunderbird provide over mail.app apart from being open source?
- kzrdude 9y agoWhat about Elementary's mail app? It fits the description, of cloning Apple's Mail, at least superficially.
- Fnoord 9y agoFWIW, it is part of Elementary's Pantheon DE, and it is a fork of Geary [1]. Code here [2]. The calendar client is called Maya, code here [3] [1] https://wiki.gnome.org/Apps/Geary https://wiki.gnome.org/Apps/Geary [2] https://launchpad.net/pantheon-mail https://launchpad.net/pantheon-mail [3] https://launchpad.net/maya https://launchpad.net/maya
- Sylos 9y agoThere is a UI/UX update in the pipeline, hopefully cleaning things up, but at the very least it'll give Thunderbird a UI with a more modern style, similar to Firefox Photon's.
- yxhuvud 9y agoMobile app? WTF. Give me a calendar and/or calendar integration that doesn't suck and I'd be really happy.
- robert_foss 9y agoPersonally I'd like to see improved performence. I really don't see why a CPU core would have to be pegged at 100%. JMAP support would be nice too.
- ronjouch 9y agoHell yes, especially during Calendar syncs. Also: startup time. Currently, to reach a fully usable state, on my Linux SSD machine, - Firefox 59 needs 2s. - Thunderbird 59 needs 8s.
- WalterGR 9y agoHell yes, especially during Calendar syncs. Also: startup time. I completely agree. I have so many calendars that after launching Thunderbird, it takes around 3 minutes 30 seconds to become responsive to user input, pegging a CPU core the entire time. And when calendars sync while the app is running (which happens all at once rather than being staggered,) it becomes unresponsive for about a solid minute, again pegging a CPU.
- hoppelhase 9y agoIs there anything planned for adopting the UI (visible and technical) changes of Firefox?
- superkuh 9y agoI really, really hope not. That'd be the one sure way for me to stop using Thunderbird (like I have stopped using FF).
- Piskvorrr 9y agoThe visible changes meaning "all extensions stop working for no apparent reason"? Great way to kill the project altogether.
- hoppelhase 9y agoI just updated to the latest beta (57). Thunderbird has now the Photon UI. Enigmail dies not work anymore. It's only supported until version 55.
- pixelbeat__ 9y agoIt's been getting slower over time with noticeable stalls. Performance is a feature
- digi_owl 9y agoOn the forum thing. Best i can tell, mailing lists are nice for when you want to be involved day to day, but forums allows you to search the history of discussions (yes there are third party sites that offer list searches, but i have found them noisy at best).
- Faaak 9y agoI would love for Thunderbird to support Exchange 365. I use Linux at work but sadly we've got office 365 and use a lot the calendar built in. I have to use Evolution as its the only mail client that supports, and didn't really want to try ExQuilla.
- HeadlessChild 9y agoHave you looked at exchangecalendar (EWS) https://github.com/ExchangeCalendar/exchangecalendar https://github.com/ExchangeCalendar/exchangecalendar?
- braderhart 9y agoDavMail is a gateway that does exactly this, and can be run locally or as a server: http://davmail.sourceforge.net http://davmail.sourceforge.net
- burnte 9y agoTen years ago I interviewed for the head QA and Community Manager position. I flew out, did interviews, got back, even received an offer for the job, but then I was told the offer was rescinded because they felt they didn't need to fill that position. Ten years later, people don't know the project exists, it doesn't have a forum or community.
- mcbits 9y agoThe only item on my wishlist is a tiny 100KB daemon with a status bar icon to watch for mail so I don't need to keep a 150MB behemoth open in the background all day. Otherwise Thunderbird is already more than I'll ever want from an email client. Calendars, contact managers, and other nonsense should really be independent programs cooperating via IPC.
- ronjouch 9y agoI use https://github.com/pulb/mailnag https://github.com/pulb/mailnag for "simple mail watching", does the job and features a discrete icon and/or a sound notification. Frontends available for Shell or Unity.
- mcbits 9y agoThanks, unfortunately I'm not using Gnome/Unity, but that looks like something to try if I do switch.
- Fnoord 9y agoTinymail/Modest? Not sure if its still developed or has a spiritual successor. Modest used GTK back in the days. What does Sailfish use for this purpose? KDE Mobile?
- abrowne 9y agoIt's a Messaging Menu indicator front-end, not something Unity-specific, so it works on Ubuntu MATE and Xubuntu, for example (and Elementary OS AIUI). There's also a third-party Cinnamon frontend.
- grandinj 9y ago150m. lol. Try using an electron based app and that will seem incredibly svelte
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dugite-code 9y agoMy biggest bug bear atm is damned tnef or the dreaded winmail.dat attachments. Too many people we work with have been upgrading their exchange servers and outlook upgraded without bothering to check to see if they are sending out usable emails.