4 ms·
Bitcoin Miners Fried in Game of Chicken
- dmichulke 9y ago"Fried" as in > If the price doesn't rise, then the average miner is set to lose $3 per week at current levels. (Per week and rig I assume though.)
- philliphaydon 9y agoIf a miner does not make money then they wont mine, if there's no miners cos no one can make money... who verifies transactions then? Or am I just really stupid and don't understand this stuff...
- im3w1l 9y agoA variable number of miners are competing for a fixed reward. So everytime a miner calls it quits, all other miners become a tiny bit more profitable.
- pliny 9y agoIsn't the BTC / hash fixed until the difficulty changes? Like, for a given difficulty you should expect N hashes calculated until a block is mined, so if you kill off half the miners (in terms of hash rate) the time until block mined just becomes twice as long (so now there are half as many miners chasing half as much reward).
- Retric 9y agoBTC Miners make most of their money from transaction fees not block rewards. Fewer blocks = reduced supply = increased costs to get into blocks = higher reward for the same hash power.
- philliphaydon 9y agoAhhhh, this is good to know!
- pliny 9y agoI see, thanks.
- speakeron 9y agoThat's true in the general case, but it only happens after a difficulty drop. Until then, miners dropping out will raise the block time (again, just a tiny bit). For cryptocoins with more dynamic difficulty adjustment, this process happens a lot more quickly.
- philliphaydon 9y agoThis worries me about BTC, because it may get to the point where for the drop in difficulty takes too long that it will no longer be profitable, in this case crypto currencies where the reward is higher and the increase in reward vs difficult increases makes it more profitable means more miners will ditch BTC and go to those... That means transaction verification times just keep raising and then BTC eventually becomes useless. That's my understanding anyway...
- paulgb 9y agoAs long as the currency maintains some value, there's an equilibrium at which it will be profitable for some to mine. To paraphrase Yogi Barra, "nobody mines anymore, the market is too crowded"
- wintom 9y agoMining this stuff is a funny thing, that is a devisive feature even in the crypto space. That being said, this isn’t the first time where mining has plummeted in profitability. Early last year similar articles started popping up and in fact GPUs on eBay we’re being sold at dirt cheap prices because crypto was “plummeting”. I wouldn’t bet on crypto going anywhere, not in this crazy world we live in.
- donquichotte 9y agoI just cannot trust bloomberg on cryptocurrency reporting. They conveniently cut off the price graph (just below "The Big Dip") in Nov 28. Why? Because at the beginning of October 9 2017, the price would have been at 4500$ - then an all-time high, and yet below the current price! It would have destroyed their narrative.
- the_mitsuhiko 9y agoNot sure how that would have destroyed the narrative? The narrative seems to be pretty irrelevant to whatever happened to the price before november? The hashrate is consistently climbing ignoring the actual USD price with very few dips.
- deadbunny 9y agoYou're completely ignoring the increase in difficulty since it was at $4500 last.
- bittcto 9y agoYes, and I believe the actual mining breakeven is closer to $1,250 based on a tweet from Adam Back today.
- shawabawa3 9y agoBitcoin is approaching the next difficulty retarget (in approximately 10 hours) and the difficulty will increase by around 10%. If bitcoin price collapses to say ~$3000 we could see a significant portion of miners give up. This would increase the block time, which in turn increases the adjustment period (which happens every 2016 blocks, ~2 weeks at 10min/block). An extended period of time with very long block times could cause the price to collapse even further, causing even more miners to leave... I think there will be some determined miners willing to mine at a huge loss (due to having large bitcoin reserves) so the difficulty will eventually drop down, but there could be months of barely moving bitcoin which on top of the huge crash in the market right now could kill off bitcoin for good
- Filligree 9y agoI can only hope. I don't care about Bitcoin, but they've been preventing me from finishing this system build. If it had been useful, I wouldn't mind so much.
- pcr0 9y agoThis chicken game won't do anything to dampen GPU prices. All Bitcoin mining is done on ASICs.
- ElCapitanMarkla 9y agoBitcoin not so much, a drop in Ethereum miners etc will have an effect.
- jacques_chester 9y agoBlockchain currencies have correlated price movements. Bitcoin rose and so did the others; bitcoin is falling and so are the others. Other asset classes show similar behaviour. When the share market dives, the individual fundamentals of companies suddenly have much less import. During a surge, ditto.
- numismatex 9y agoBuy directly from NVidia, put in a notification when stock is available.
- singularity2001 9y agoLooking forward to the first deep learning framework that puts all these energy-burning-machines to good use.
- slig 9y agoMiners use specialised hardware (ASIC - application-specific integrated circuit) to mine. They are only useful to calculate hashs efficiently.
- singularity2001 9y agois there no way to make 'good' use of them? whoever comes up with an idea might become a billionair.
- Isomatik 9y agoProof of work is intentionally useless to the miner to increase the cost of attacking the network. There are initiatives like curecoin and foldingcoin which integrate folding@home into their proof of work, but the output of that is still "useless" to the miner and relies on the folding@home team not manipulating the process, which becomes a bigger risk once hard rewards for folding are introduced.
- empath75 9y agoIf the price drops too precipitously, and too many miners drop off at once, bitcoin enters a death spiral as the hashrate drops, and it takes so long to confirm blocks that the difficulty adjustment downwards just never happens, freezing the whole network.
- spuz 9y agoCan you elaborate on why the difficulty would not adjust downwards as transaction rates slow? That seems like quite a flaw in the design.
- pwinnski 9y agoThe difficulty would adjust down, but only when the next milestone is reached. The argument seems to be that if enough miners drop out, the next milestone might never be reached. That seems unlikely to me.
- pcnix 9y agoProps for the title. This is not a very big problem for all the big name miners though, as they're all betting on prices rising soon. This has happened before, and will happen again until either everyone adapts some alternative to proof of work. Everyone seems to just be mining altcoins and hodling for a rise.
- patrickaljord 9y agoAccording to this web site, all you need is 11th/s to not lose money, that's an investiment of $2.5k in mining hardware https://www.cryptocompare.com/mining/calculator/btc?HashingPower=11&HashingUnit=TH%2Fs&PowerConsumption=1293&CostPerkWh=0.2&MiningPoolFee=1 https://www.cryptocompare.com/mining/calculator/btc?HashingP... How can any miner lose money unless prices reach ~$3k? Edit: why am I being downvoted? Let me know if I'm mistaken.
- spuz 9y agoThe calculation you did on that website shows an annual profit of $413.25 which is still a lot less than the initial investment of $2.5k. At today's price ($ 6,976.14), you'd have to be mining for over 5 years before getting that investment back again. I'm not sure how you come to the conclusion "how can any miner lose money".
- patrickaljord 9y agoFor $2.5k you can get 13th/s, that's $935 annually, that's a 40% gain annually. If you know of any investment that can give you a passive 40% yearly return, I'm all ears. And that's only if bitcoin doesn't go up. Again, I fail to see how this is a bad investment. Plus, with the latest all time high, most existing miners already paid for their hardware and are just all profits now. https://www.cryptocompare.com/mining/calculator/btc?HashingPower=13&HashingUnit=TH%2Fs&PowerConsumption=1293&CostPerkWh=0.2&MiningPoolFee=1 https://www.cryptocompare.com/mining/calculator/btc?HashingP...
- rottyguy 9y agoAre there mining algos that also help to solve real world problems (say gene mapping)? It seems that you could leverage some of the gamification happening here to better some social facet of society.
- Y_Y 9y agoA simple search would find several of these.
- lozenge 9y agoNo. The problem in that suggestion is, who is going to provide the problems? It would be a central actor who can opt to pre-work on the problems and use those solutions to issue themselves "money".
- votepaunchy 9y agoNo, it would simply require solving a function dependent on the previous solution. Preferably more complex than double SHA.
- croon 9y agoFoldingCoin is doing something like that, but I'm not involved enough to speak authoritatively about specifics.
- dantillberg 9y agoIt's a little bit simpler than the psychological drama described. If your marginal/flexible operating costs (i.e. electricity, temp staff, etc) are higher than your expected revenue, then you shut off your miners temporarily. It's a simple rational decision: if you want bitcoins, they're cheaper to buy on an exchange. If your total operating operating costs (building rent, etc) are higher than your expected revenue, then you lose money due to paying down liabilities. You might try to trim long-term operating costs (laying off staff, move to smaller building, move to place with cheaper electricity), or you might try to exit (sell mining hardware). There's very little psychological drama in all this: the market for hashing power is very predictable, and it will adjust over time to provide narrow profit margins to the most efficient operations. The profitable periods were only ever going to be temporary aberrations in response to cryptocoin price fluctuations. If your operation is not efficient, your own balance sheet will tell you when it's time to pack up.
- braddeicide 9y agoI wish I could buy Bitcoins on the exchange and convert them back into power.
- bryanlarsen 9y ago"and it will adjust over time to provide narrow profit margins to the most efficient operations" Unlike actual mining operations where costs are dominated by sunk capital costs. They can stay hugely irrational: once you've invested a few billion in a highly automated mine those billions are gone and you keep the mine operating even if the market collapses since your marginal + fixed costs are still lower than the price. Or worse: sometimes a mine operates in the red since that's cheaper than the cost of decommissioning it...
- maxerickson 9y agoThe market for hashing power is only as predictable as the price of bitcoin. (it's really the aggregate profitability of mining all cybercurrencies that have competitive rewards, but the price of bitcoin is close enough)
- 9y ago
- fiiyi 9y agoThousands of companies go bust every day in our "great" economy; retailers, startups, etc.. Now the price of crypto-currencies has dropped and it's called a "Game of Chicken". There seems to be a tendency to laugh and write bad about miners, almost like bullying. Why is this? Mining is business as usual, nothing different than many other businesses. There is investment, risk, profit and loss.
- contrarian_ 9y agoInvestment in mining hardware whose value is tied to a speculative asset without fundamental value beyond utility. None of the current implementations can scale, so even their utility is questionable. There is a way to make a scalable trust-less digital currency by using a mutable leder, but none of the current coins that I know of are heading that way. The main difficulty will be how to distribute ledger space in a way that cannot be monopolized by the richest. That is a simple technical problem to solve though, because storage capacity will eventually surpass the ratio of richest to average wealth. Then you can allocate ledger space in exchange for an affordable deposit, redeemable when the balance is emptied.
- mavhc 9y agoDoes anything have fundamental value beyond utility?
- thisisit 9y agoLet's see how the analysis was derived: > Note: Assumes China wholesale price ($0.06/KWh), using listed specifications for Antminer S9 (13.50 TH/s), adds 30% cooling & operational costs, assumes retail is 30% markup from wholesale hardware price, 52-week depreciation schedule (Bitmain offers 180-day warranty). No transaction fee or pool fee. Hash rate and computational difficulty as of Feb. 6, 2018. The biggest sunk cost is on the hardware price. Assuming 30% markup that too in China on a China build product seems too high for me. Anyone based in China can confirm the retail markup on Antminer S9?
- prostoalex 9y agoAt ~$7,500 we're roughly back to mid-November price levels, so it seems like it would affect only newish entrants.