10 ms·
NFL players are at least well compensated and are adults making decisions for themselves. My problem is at the high school and college level. The kids are play
by criddell 9y ago
NFL players are at least well compensated and are adults making decisions for themselves.
My problem is at the high school and college level. The kids are playing with great intensity for nothing more than love of the game and maybe the opportunity to move up. The long term risks seem way too high.
I'd say the same thing about kids playing soccer. I don't think heading the ball should be allowed in high school or college play. I was relieved when my daughter quit soccer.
- bpicolo 9y ago> adults making decisions for themselves That's the crux of the biggest issue. The NFL actively covered up/denied evidence that concussions were damaging for decades.
- criddell 9y agoLots of damage has been done that's for sure. I was mostly thinking about the future.
- x0x0 9y agoThey're not actually well compensated. http://www.businessinsider.com/charts-expose-how-badly-nfl-players-get-paid-2013-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/charts-expose-how-badly-nfl-p... They're not actually protected in any way, because NFL contracts aren't guaranteed. Imagine what you would do if your doctor worked for your boss, and when your doctor asked if you were injured, telling the truth would allow your boss to fire you on the spot with zero compensation. Every time the subject comes up there's lots of whining by the NFL, but somehow the NBA, NHL, and MLB survived with essentially guaranteed contracts. NFL players also don't actually have options. Scholarships are a joke and most of them learn virtually nothing. They started down the path to the NFL well before they were adults capable of making decisions, and by the time they're eligible for an NFL career, they typically don't have the academics to do much else. (Obviously there are exceptions, but Richard Sherman is not your average NFL player.)
- softawre 9y agoAre you making the argument that a $million+/year is not "well compensated"? You can play for 2-3 years and never work again if you're smart with your money.
- x0x0 9y ago1 - many players are not making millions a year. eg in 2017, two rookie quarterbacks in the playoffs were making $450k, the league minimum. All those average salary facts include eg Tom Brady. 2 - even at $1m/year, you may collect $550k after tax. Three years of that is not never work again money.
- ska 9y agoThree years of that is not never work again money. It's worth noting that three years of that gets you a bit over median household income at safe extraction (i.e. 4%) rate. It's not FU money, but as an emergency fall back it is obviously plausibly never work again money.
- criddell 9y agoThe median salary is $700,000. The average career lasts 3 years. Therefore you could say a typical player makes around $2 million playing football. That's gross. The net is probably about half of that. To most of America that will make an order of magnitude less than that in the same time, that sounds pretty good.
- rayiner 9y agoMost players make closer to the league minimum ($500k) for just 2-3 years. After taxes that’s about $500-750k. Even if you’re smart about your money, you’re saving maybe $350-500k. That’s not “never work again” money.
- Consultant32452 9y ago$500k/yr for 3 years is "never work again" money for me. That's $1.5 Million. If you pull out what many financial advisors recommend, 4%, that's $60k/yr for the rest of your life. That's above the US median household income.
- w0m 9y agoThis is one of the key points to me - NFL actively hid the fact from their own fans and players for years. That should have been a much bigger deal I think, criminal negligence.
- unclebucknasty 9y ago>should have been a much bigger deal Yeah, and it's a pattern we've seen before (e.g. Big Tobacco). I think it's a playbook. They string out the lies over a long period, then let the suspicion trickle out slowly. So, there are moments of muted outrage along the way, but by the time the full story comes out the pressure build-up has already been relieved. Beyond that, the finally-admitted truth is something we already knew for so long that our outrage has waned. Basically, a PSYOP.
- gameswithgo 9y ago>Yeah, and it's a pattern we've seen before (e.g. Big Tobacco) And fossil fuel
- conductr 9y agoBig tobacco did the same but many people reasoned that inhaling burnt leaves multiple times a day was probably not a smart idea even if lacking full clinical research saying so. It's bad that they hid it, no doubt. But couldn't people reason that taking thousands of blows to the head over a career was not a smart idea?
- evan_ 9y agoit's not just that the tobacco companies covered up reports, they literally put out ads with actors dressed as doctors saying "smoking is good for you". e.g.: http://tobacco.stanford.edu/tobacco_main/images.php?token2=fm_st001.php&token1=fm_img0002.php&theme_file=fm_mt001.php&theme_name=Doctors%20Smoking http://tobacco.stanford.edu/tobacco_main/images.php?token2=f... Even if you were able to "reason" that smoking was bad, there was a whole dedicated culture jamming operation to push the message "you're wrong and foolish if you think smoking is bad" and it worked very well. Every NFL team had (has?) a bunch of doctors telling players that they can shrug off concussions and other serious injuries, and a deeply-engrained (and specifically engineered) culture to back up that message.
- x0x0 9y agoHell, when I was growing up (not that long ago!) the NFL used to produce and tout official videos of the biggest / hardest hits in a season. Looking at them now, you can literally see the stiff arms sticking in the air that is a symptom of brain trauma, and people getting up concussed as fuck.
- conductr 9y agoIt's all true and very bad, I agree. My greater point though is that, throughout all time, people live in a society where someone is trying to take advantage/lie/cheat/steal basically they don't care about what is best for you. People need to learn to think independently. Hell, science still can't agree on if an egg is healthy or not. I eat them because I enjoy them and their are no obvious downsides. If there were some correlation that was known and proved unhealthy I might stop eating them. For example, while big tobacco was doing their thing... people knew their family members smoking were unhealthy, coughing like crazy, getting cancer/sick, so their was some clues in society telling you that you're probably being lied to. I have memories of this as a kid, "Joe died at 55 but, you know, he smoked 2 packs a day" was a valid way of thinking. So the health effects were widely known, just not in a measurable & undisputed scientific way. The same thing goes for tobacco, NFL, climate change, ... all kinds of stuff. The anecdotal information around you says one thing, but the scientist can't agree and some of them are biased/being paid to say something regardless of truth. Years later the anecdotal information turns out to be true and people claim they were victims when really they could have just exercised some common sense.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoFrankly, as an observer (which I am) or as a potential employee of the NFL (which I am not), I would consider the question "does playing football cause massive brain damage?" a much bigger issue than "has the NFL tried to cover up evidence that playing football causes massive brain damage?"
- Pxtl 9y agoWell, the difference is culpability. "Does football cause brain damage" is an important question for current and future players, but "did the NFL conceal this fact" can be interpreted as the NFL murdered its own players through criminal negligence. Players were not given the chance at informed consent. If I put poison in food and offer you millions to eat the food but don't tell you about the poison, what am I?
- thaumasiotes 9y ago"Did the NFL stage a coverup" is only relevant to discussions of whether and how much to punish the NFL. "Does football cause brain damage" is relevant to discussions of whether I should play football, whether my friends or family should play football, whether anyone should play football, whether it's ethical to watch football, whether it's more fun to watch football than golf, whether it's appropriate for educational institutions to promote or participate in football... I'll also suggest that if it turned out that football promoted the better functioning of your brain, outrage at the NFL for covering up research suggesting the opposite would be pretty muted. If you believe that, you should also believe that what everyone sees as "the big issue" is the brain damage, not the coverup.
- khedoros1 9y agoI've always thought of the brain damage as a given; concussions will cause damage, the brain's a little "iffy" on the healing front, and severe concussions are basically unavoidable in football. If you care about whether you get hurt: Don't play, don't let your kids play, and so on. It was much more interesting to hear how much the NFL had covered up, and the degree to which they directly lied about the evidence of the effects of playing the game. The cover-up is the scandalous part, so of course that's the part that people are going to focus on.
- cimi_ 9y ago> NFL players are at least well compensated and are adults making decisions for themselves. One of the arguments in the article is that not even for NFL players, at the highest level, are the consequences made obvious. Here's the last paragraph: > But when all those big hits happened and the fans cheered, did they cheer in spite of knowing a man just greatly increased his risk for dementia? Was anyone worried about an A.L.S. diagnosis or a C.T.E.-related suicide at 40 after their favorite player suffered repeated blows to the head on the field? No, they cheered and they celebrated because they didn’t know. And neither did we.
- pkaye 9y agoWell now they know and can make the decision, how many of them have stopped playing?
- watwut 9y agoLess and less kids play football and parents dont support it nearly as much as before. It seems that people who did not sacrificed whole life to the game yet are leaving it.
- jotm 9y agoUhm, they would cheer even if they knew. Most people know boxers get brain damage, nobody gives a shit.
- acct1771 9y agoCorrect. Which is why my argument is, if we're going to keep having blood sports, let them use the drugs to improve their muscle mass to hopefully protect them slightly better from this stuff, improve recovery/rebuild time, and make the game more exciting, surely.
- rgbrenner 9y agoBut that would also allow them to hit harder.. and there are no muscles around the brain to protect it from impacts or prevent it from moving. I don't see how that would make brain damage less likely.
- twentythree 9y agoRichard Sherman, one of the top NFL players and also a Stanford grad, is very outspoken about this, and agrees with you: https://www.si.com/2013/10/23/richard-sherman-seahawks-concussions-in-the-nfl https://www.si.com/2013/10/23/richard-sherman-seahawks-concu.... His argument is that at this point, everyone playing the game knows the risks, and is taking that into account when making their decision to play. To your second point, there's a recent push to ban tackling at levels below high school football (and play flag football instead). The current theory is that it's not the big hits that cause brain damage, but all the smaller "sub-concussive" hits that happen on every play. Eliminating those until high school would hopefully limit the long-term damage of football, especially for kids who only play through high school or college. I don't think banning tackling at either of those levels is feasible, though; college football is a huge business itself, and a change as dramatic as eliminating tackling there would completely change the sport.
- briffle 9y agoThat protects the running and defensive backs.. but the linemen take pretty substantial hits on almost every play..
- nradov 9y agoOne option would be to require the linemen to stand up and prohibit helmet strikes.
- twentythree 9y agoIn flag football, you generally don't have linemen in the traditional sense; there's no blocking allowed, and the quarterback is protected by a count instead of his blockers. The American Flag Football League is one of the organizations trying to take over this space (they recently played a game in Levi's Stadium with Michael Vick and Terrell Owens, among others). Here are the full rules if you're interested! https://www.americanflag.football/official-rules/ https://www.americanflag.football/official-rules/.
- oreo81 9y ago
- daxorid 9y agoThe argument could be made that high school and college football compensates players with social and sexual capital. It is an extremely effective way to become popular.
- fhood 9y agoDefine well compensated? The average NFL player makes less than any of the other three major american sports, is unlikely to have a wealth of other marketable skills, and may be permanently disabled after what is likely to be a short (average 3.3 yrs) career.
- paulcole 9y agoYou're one of the few people who seem to actually understand this. By comparison, a 4-year degree is probably worth more in the long-term than those NFL earnings. So the players are actually being better compensated in college than the NFL. Edit: The median salary for an NFL player is about $770K and most players are out of the league in under 3 years. https://www.si.com/nfl/2016/03/01/nfl-careers-shortened-two-years-data-analysis https://www.si.com/nfl/2016/03/01/nfl-careers-shortened-two-... http://blog.futureadvisor.com/nfl-players-must-go-long-on-retirement/ http://blog.futureadvisor.com/nfl-players-must-go-long-on-re...
- saalweachter 9y agoIt looks like the average 4-year degree is worth less than the average NFL earnings - the two figures I found Googling were $2.1M for lifetime earnings from a 4-year degree, and $4M for career earnings for an NFL player. On the other hand, engineering degrees tended to hover around $4M for average lifetime earnings, and some engineering fields (petroleum engineer, SV software engineer) averaged ~$6.5M in lifetime earnings.
- tinymollusk 9y agoIn my opinion, the set of players should be inclusive of all football players. By limiting it to the most successful outliers in a power law distribution, we limit ourselves to the players with the best possible outcome. Players don't really get to choose whether they belong in this set; they choose to play highly competitive football. In short, I think we should define the group by factors that result from choice, not outcome.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 9y agoI was surprised by your comment on soccer, but it does seem concerning: https://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2015/nov/01/football-heading-brain-damage https://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2015/nov/01/footba... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0887617702001518 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S088761770...
- roguecoder 9y agoThe reason we have OSHA is because when workplace safety is the responsibility of each individual to negotiate it becomes non-existent. Putting the responsibility on individuals leads to a race to the bottom: every job can be horribly dangerous as long as the alternative jobs are too.
- ryandrake 9y agoOf course, any time you have a so-called negotiation between partied with severely different bargaining power, it will be a race to the bottom to the detriment of the powerless party. This is why we need regulations, OSHA, unions, consumer protection laws, product safety rules, etc.
- criddell 9y agoSurely you wouldn't characterize NFL players as being on the bottom? For most of the recent kneeling-during-the-anthem controversy, people are ripping on the players because they are in such a privileged position. The characterization is that they are at the top of everything.
- khalilravanna 9y agoTotally agree. Another aspect of this is that the decision they're making is one that humans are very bad at: prioritizing their future over their present. "Ok maybe I have headaches when I'm in my 50s but today I get paid way more than everyone I know." Knowing that humans have an unbelievable penchant for putting their present well-being over their future well-being, I think it behooves us (society) to protect these people from making these decision that will in many cases destroy their lives.
- aje403 9y agoThat logic is garbage. We should ban cigarettes? Smoking marijuana should not be legalized (risk factor for lung cancer)? Why not alcohol too? Where else can we stretch that? Maybe we should perform evaluations on people to determine what career paths they should follow to protect their best interests! Society should behoove itself to mind its own business.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWithout looking anything up, I would guess that most NFL players played football in high school and/or college first. If so, you are saying that these already brain damaged people are free to make these decisions because they are past a certain age, never mind that their ability to analyse it all was impaired before they reached the age of majority. Your argument might hold water if most NFL players took up football after reaching adulthood. This seems highly unlikely to me.
- xg15 9y agoI'm not sure. The studies were specifically about long-term effects, so I'd not be sure if a brief stint in school or college sport or occasional matches were already that harmful. If this is true, maybe an alternative to making the game more "safe" were to think about whether practically living for the sport for 20 years as part of a professional career makes sense.
- xkcd-sucks 9y agoIf pre-NFL players are brain-damaged, are they even capable of understanding the risks such that they can give informed consent to play professionally?
- aws_ls 9y ago+1 for soccer. My teenager plays it with his senior school friends, but I always discourage him. Tell him he can pick up any sport, in which he doesn't have to physically directly engage with other persons. I played field hockey in school & college. And once was involved in a head on collision with a friend, who suffered a bloody nose/face and was taken to hospital. And I was shit scared, until I knew he was safe, very luckily for me. I have come to hate all sports like boxing/wrestling/soccer etc. for this reason. There are plenty of athletics and sports where you display your individual skill at a distance from another person to choose from. I think, these sports are simply not probability friendly. When many people play, somebody is bound to get seriously injured.