27 ms·
No Cutting Corners on the iPhone X
- staunch 9y agoApple did a good job of executing on a bad idea with the iPhone X notches. But I don't believe Steve Jobs would've let the iPhone X (or Touchbar) out the door because they're so clearly half-measures. Apple is implementing temporary workarounds (that won't exist in future devices) in their top of the line products. This is the kind of short-term thinking that they're so famous for avoiding. They're still doing quite good overall but this is clearly something they're struggling with.
- sekou 9y agoIn addition to the attention to design detail it speaks to the brand strength of Apple that if any of their competitors released a phone with a similarly unconventional screen shape it would have been a weakness that would drastically affect the acceptance of the phone, even if it was engineered in the exact same way. The notch is truly a feature only Apple would be able to have success with.
- djrogers 9y ago> I don't believe Steve Jobs would've let the iPhone X (or Touchbar) out the door This is a ridiculous trope that needs to die. Among the many ‘half-measures’ people whined about during Steve Jobs’ tenure are things such as the original iPhone not having 3G, the iPhone 4 antennagate, the infamously scratch prone iPod Nano, the crack prone poly MacBooks, etc etc. Apple was never a company that produced only flawless, non-controversial products, and Steve was perhaps the most controversial and opinionated product person to have ever lived.
- bahram_banisadr 9y agoApple's biggest asset has always been design. On a tehnical basis Apple products sometimes beat the competition and sometimes are outdone by the likes of Samsung, Thinkpad, etc. They have dominated the American consumer market because of fit and finish, attention to detail, and overall functional beauty in design. The flaws you're speaking of are a different sort from the, frankly weird looking, notch. While executed as well as possible, its a design compromise.
- stouset 9y agoThe notch is a literal non-issue that only people who don’t actually use this damn device seem to complain about or even notice. I for one am happy that an entire strip of nearly-useless status icons has been shifted upward into the extra area afforded by the notch. The number of times I notice it in a given month easily rounds to zero.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y ago>The notch is a literal non-issue that only people who don’t actually use this damn device seem to complain about or even notice. Do you suppose it's possible that it's no coincidence that people who dislike the notch don't use the phone?
- tedunangst 9y agoCertainly not a coincidence that everybody who hates the notch feels compelled to tell the world about it.
- stouset 9y agoIt’s the same story every time Apple releases a new product. People who overwhelmingly don’t buy Apple products in the first place lose their minds over some nit, while the overwhelming majority of their actual customers never seem to understand what the big deal is. I’m not surprised at all: these people knee-jerk so hard and often, they probably can’t afford Apple products after the paying for orthopedic surgeons. And the “ignorant Apple fanboy” narrative that seems to be the counterargument to this falls laughably short when you realize that the number of Apple’s customers has been increasing exponentially for the last fifteen years, all while they continue to enjoy the top spot in consumer satisfaction surveys across virtually their entire product line.
- 8note 9y agodifferent shapes cause the strength to change in different ways. certain notch designs are much better than others for keeping the screen from breaking.
- 9y ago
- ninkendo 9y agoAnother really obvious half-measure was that the original iPhone didn't have an app store. "HTML5 is your SDK", basically, and adding sites to your homescreen was all you could do. Steve Jobs tried to pretend this was a good thing: > And guess what? There’s no SDK that you need! You’ve got everything you need if you know how to write apps using the most modern web standards to write amazing apps for the iPhone today. So developers, we think we’ve got a very sweet story for you. You can begin building your iPhone apps today. They fixed that the very next release.
- TrainedMonkey 9y agoApple store is primarily a distribution/discovery channel, I would not be surprised if it started as - hey let's build a catalogue of all the websites that work well on iPhones.
- wodenokoto 9y agoAt the time Google was experimenting with off-line apps with their proprietary Google gears. At the time, Google and Apple had a very close relationship and I thought it was odd that Apple didn't implement offline web apps via gears. Most iphone apps are, after all glorified web pages.
- detaro 9y agoOne might argue that it was merely to early for that, since web standards around it didn't exist and weren't provided by Apple either. Not having the required focus on the App Store could have been great!
- staunch 9y agoExcept your list of misfeatures is actually a missing feature and a list of bugs. No one would claim Steve Jobs or Apple was ever perfect, just that he wouldn't have released these blatantly obvious misfeatures. Can you think of anything similar to these weird misfeatures? I'm genuinely curious.
- sbuk 9y agoHockey puck mouse.
- RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u 9y agoFWIW, Job also (allegedly, but probably didn't actually) said "real artists ship" [0]. [0] http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Real_Artists_Ship.txt http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Real_Artists_Ship...
- wvenable 9y agoIf you look at iPhone iconography -- it's always been basically a rounded rectangle with a circle and square for the home button. Easily identifiable as an iPhone with just 3 shapes. With the home button gone, the notch is used to distinctively represent an iPhone. Perhaps the whole thing is purposely form over function.
- kurthr 9y agoDon't believe that their competitors will have notch-less phones... they will copy slavishly! Count on it (unless they have a design latent in the notch).
- kurthr 9y agoYep, no patent on the notch. http://bgr.com/2018/02/01/iphone-x-review-android-copy-design-lol/ http://bgr.com/2018/02/01/iphone-x-review-android-copy-desig...
- twothamendment 9y agoForm over function? I think you nailed it. Would it be less expensive to manufacture using circles? Would sales decrease if they had? Would anyone really notice? I wonder how many man-hours were spent debating the shape of the corners.
- dilap 9y agoI don't know, I have one and I genuinely love the notch (and the other rounded corners). The device feels organic and sci-fi in a way that strictly rectangular screens do not. (But I haven't seen an all-screen phone yet, so maybe I'd change my tune if I did.)
- eanzenberg 9y agoLUL. 20b in 3 months profit and they're struggling!
- eanzenberg 9y agoWhat is wrong with the touchbar? What is wrong with the notch? I've been on a touchbar mac and it's just as usable as having keys, with the added flexibility of changing them around (adding a lock button, etc.). It's mostly a non issue and does everything the prior bar did. The notch essentially houses the 1 feature most people love on their X's, it becomes a non-issue once you use it. Or, if you're like me, you recognize that instead of losing a notch, you gained 2 ears of information.
- Veen 9y agoI find the Touch Bar frustrating. It's probably because of the way use my MacBook Pro on my lap a lot. I find that I often accidentally press buttons on the Touch Bar because my hands naturally rest in that area. My real problem with that model is the sticky keyboard, though. My space bar and several other keys are intermittently unresponsive, which irritates me no end.
- bluthru 9y agoHaving all of the corners be equal is a very Apple thing. The notch will recede over time.
- pelmeni 9y agoThat was an interesting article! Now I'm curious about the machinery needed to fabricate such a screen, and how it differs from standard square screen producing machines.
- phonon 9y agohttp://techon.nikkeibp.co.jp/atclen/news_en/15mk/011801852/ http://techon.nikkeibp.co.jp/atclen/news_en/15mk/011801852/ gives a few details.
- btilly 9y agoAdding 2 little corners at the top was a horrible idea. I upgraded at Christmas. I'm sure that they put a lot of effort into it. But now my phone no longer displays battery percentage, and I keep finding myself noticing the missing chunk. Even after a month I notice it. Squeezing the last square inch is emphatically not worth it. Not even a little bit.
- makecheck 9y agoIt’s a mix of good and bad. With the notch, status space is at a premium and they finally get rid of that completely unnecessary advertising for AT&T, etc. (shows up on lock screen, that’s it). Also, when I’m in the background and using Google Maps for directions or something, it’s actually easier to have the location button in the top-left corner because I don’t hit it by accident. I really don’t notice the notch after a month or so but I also set a wallpaper with a black top (thanks to the OLED, that part of the screen is so dark that it really does hide the notch completely). One thing that’s really stupid is web pages. So many of them have floating bars at the top and buttons at the bottom; then there’s browser UI, and then the notch has the illusion that it’s taking up even more space (when in a way it’s not). In the end each site feels like it’s crapping all over my screen space on the X. Mobile browsing needs to be seriously redesigned from the ground up; anything less than a full screen experience needs to go.
- djrogers 9y agoAll the website top/bottom fixed position junk is one more reason I appreciate the iPhone X - the extra tall screen leaves more room for content than my old 7plus. OTOH, if it gets too bad I use a kill sticky bookmarklet.
- seszett 9y ago> they finally get rid of that completely unnecessary advertising for AT&T Which makes me think, is it easy to know what operator you are connected to? I live on a border, and it's important to know whether I'm on a French antenna or a Belgian one. I know it's an edge case and most people don't need that, but I'm curious and I can't really find screenshots of it. Actually on the screenshots I find you can't even know if you're connected on 4G or not, which matters as some operators here only allow unlimited data on 4G.
- DanCarvajal 9y agoNo one is saying that they don't expertly engineer things, it's just that their design "solutions" look less like actual solutions with every successive product launch.
- newman8r 9y agoI appreciate their industrial design, but refuse to use their operating systems. I run linux on all my macs and I'll never go back.
- buildbuildbuild 9y agoI anxiously anticipate the day that Adobe products are Linux native.
- AceJohnny2 9y agoOr even work on case-sensitive macOS partitions. As far as I know, they are the only major mac software to explicitly hold that back.
- selectodude 9y agoThey've finally fixed it after 20 years because APFS is case sensitive. But it's been a lovely way for them to force upgrades to the pay monthly creative cloud if you want to ever move off HFS+.
- AceJohnny2 9y agoThis is not actually the case. APFS can continue to behave as a case-INsensitive partition (check the options when creating a new APFS volume), and remains so for the system partition, I guess specifically to avoid any hard-to-debug compatibility issues.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- curiousgal 9y agoI wish the same could be said about iOS11...
- nofunsir 9y agoI thought the official math on the curves was a proprietary secret, no? I recall early iPhone/iPod official case dimension documents never calling out the radius because it didn't exist. EDIT: Maybe it's somewhere in here: https://developer.apple.com/accessories/Accessory-Design-Guidelines.pdf https://developer.apple.com/accessories/Accessory-Design-Gui...
- EpicEng 9y agoI feel like that would be pretty trivial to reverse engineer if anyone cared to.
- wll 9y agoOn iOS 11, CALayer has a `continuousCorners` private property [0]. I did a spartan reverse engineering by recreating the UIBezierPath equivalent of the two types of radii found in the Apple Design Resources [1], then adding a convenience initializer on UIBezierPath that recreates the shape with arbitrary radius of the chosen kind (either UISwitch-like, or App Icon-like). Earlier attempts include the fascinating Unleashing Genetic Algorithms on the iOS 7 Icon [2]. [0] https://mobile.twitter.com/argentumko/status/955773459463790592 https://mobile.twitter.com/argentumko/status/955773459463790... [1] https://developer.apple.com/design/resources/ https://developer.apple.com/design/resources/ [2] http://blog.mikeswanson.com/post/62341902567/unleashing-genetic-algorithms-on-the-ios-7-icon http://blog.mikeswanson.com/post/62341902567/unleashing-gene...
- dingo_bat 9y agoIs this supposed to be impressive? If I remember correctly, Samsung and LG already had rounded corners. And no ugly notch either.
- briandear 9y ago> And no ugly notch either. And no Face ID camera. The "notch" was because of the Face ID components. You're comparing apples and oranges.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> And no Face ID camera. The "notch" was because of the Face ID components. Facial unlocking was introduced in Android phones back in 2011.
- hypervis0r 9y agoYou're comparing apples and oranges, too. OP was talking about functional facial unlocking
- dingo_bat 9y agoNo. They could have made it a simple bezel. You can say this about anything. For example, note8 has an IR iris camera. Still they didn't make the phone look ugly.
- jasonlotito 9y ago> Sweating thousands of minor details is what separates Apple from other companies. Their ability to do that is hard-won, but damn it’s pretty to watch. Wish they would sweat the minor details on their other products that aren't flagship products a swell. Take a look at their USB-C Digital dongle as an prime example. 2-star rating for a $70 dongle, almost universally because of the same fundamental problem. No, the iPhone X is not a minor detail.
- vortico 9y agoA beautiful solution to a completely arbitrary problem that they created. Much like needing a dongle to solve their created problem of removing the headphone port. Or needing updates to their operating systems to solve the problem they created with batteries. Are they still able to solve real problems now, instead of those created by themselves?
- eanzenberg 9y agoIf you're talking about the notch vs. touchid, then no, I vastly prefer the notch/faceid and can't wait for all my apple products to have it. Why? Simple user experience. I don't want to rest my thumb (or any finger) to unlock my phone before I select where I want to go. Screen turns on, notifications are present, phone is unlocked and my finger's first gesture is to select which notification to goto. That whole same user experience with 1 less motion is gold to me.
- MBCook 9y agoI had an iPhone X for about a week but didn’t end up liking it. It ended up being too big, more than anything. However, I want Face ID back. I want gestures back. Both of those were fantastic. I can’t wait to see what they have this year.
- matwood 9y ago> It ended up being too big, more than anything. Interesting. I had a 7+ before the X and I miss the size of the 7+. No way I'm giving up FaceId and the new gestures though.
- MBCook 9y agoI had a 7 so it was a much bigger jump for me.
- aidenn0 9y agoI'm curious, do you wear baggy pants or not keep your phone in your pocket? I use android phones, but anything much over a 5" screen is too large for me to get in or out of my pocket while sitting down. Also I know my hands are on the small side, but various phones/phablets the size of the 7+ are uncomfortable for me to hold, and obviously impossible for me to use with one hand.
- delhanty 9y ago>Apple has been doing this to the corners of laptops and iMacs for years, but this type of rounding didn’t penetrate iOS until version 7. This shape has classically been difficult to achieve, because it wasn’t available in 2D design editors, though that’s starting to change. (My emphasis) However, bizarrely, it has been available in full 3D in parametric mechanical CAD for at least 20 years thanks to the advanced 3D blending functionality in the underlying modeling kernels: Parasolid, ACIS, ShapeManager etc. Meanwhile, the 2D sketching environment in those programs has lagged w.r.t. curvature continuous fillets. Witness this Solidworks 2012 tutorial on GrabCAD by Leandro Fernandes[0]. Because of the relative weakness of the 2D sketcher compared to 3D with respect to filleting, Leandro does (roughly) the following strange hack: 1. creates the profile of the wheel rim in the 2D sketcher 2. rotates the profile to form the 3D rim 3. fillets the profile in 3D 4. merges all the faces into one face 5. intersects the filleted 3D profile with a section plane to get back into 2D [0] https://grabcad.com/tutorials/tutorial-how-to-model-a-bbs-lm-wheel-in-solidworks-and-show-design-intent--1 https://grabcad.com/tutorials/tutorial-how-to-model-a-bbs-lm...
- andybak 9y agoFunnily enough I wrote an Illustrator script to draw superellipses decades ago. It sat on the Adobe website for a long time until Adobe decided that they wanted to scrap years of useful add ons and content in one of their pointless reorganisations. A lot of good code died that day...
- iamleppert 9y agoWhy didn’t they just make the front part of the OLEDs transparent, and then turn them off when using those sensors? Surely it couldn’t be that much more difficult considering it’s already possible to make optically clear OLEDs.
- kgabis 9y agoTransparent OLEDs are not 100% transparent (especially for IR) and it would impact camera quality and face detection used in faceID.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stesch 9y agoI always thought the cut corners in "Battlestar Galactica" were stupid. And then Apple came along with the iPhone X.
- EugeneOZ 9y agoBest phone. I tried Samsung Galaxy Note 8 and it was disgusting even to hold in hands. Absolutely personal opinion. Also it's so annoying when people say "iPhone buyers buy it just for elitism" - hell no, I just love Apple's attention to details, to small things.
- whywhywhywhy 9y agoThe author mentions the "Squircle" but doesn't mention the actual reason this has made an appearance in iOS. Apples Industrial Designers use this shape for corners on their laptops because the reflection is creates is a smooth gradient across the entire curve of the laptop, if you use a basic bevel it creates an ugly hard shine. So the reason this has moved to iOS is because the ID team and Ive have much more influence there than they did in the early iOS days. As for the notch and the screen edges my personal belief is this is all down to industrial designer bravado. The brief for the iPhone X is "Equal margins on all edges at any cost" this is why Touch ID had to go and they justify the notch because to the left and right of it there is a margin to the device edge that is equal to the bottom and the sides of the device so in the Industrial Designers eyes they have achieved the perfect symmetrical device (Look at Apples recent laptops to see how much emphasis the current put on symmetry above all else). My theory is the ID team at Apple would look at the "edgeless" Galaxy S8 screen and scoff that it's not truly edgeless because the margins are uneven.
- wodenokoto 9y ago> Squircle Isn't this a super ellipse? ... oh, it is. It is even mentioned as a squircle on Wikipedia [1] as a super ellipse with n = 4, a = b = 1! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superellipse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superellipse
- louislbnc 9y agoFor those interested in a deeper dive in the geometry, curvature continuity is the underlying concept. There's plenty of programming work to be done to improve how CAD software build surfaces that follow those rules.
- fiatpandas 9y agoMore reading on surfacing at Apple: https://hackernoon.com/apples-icons-have-that-shape-for-a-very-good-reason-720d4e7c8a14 https://hackernoon.com/apples-icons-have-that-shape-for-a-ve... Apparently they use Autodesk Alias. Same techniques are used for surfacing in the auto industry.