28 ms·
Why Did a Billionaire Give $75M to a Philosophy Department?
- megaman22 9y agoWhy not? He can do whatever he wants with his money. He's spent $100M on a yacht already[1]. I was a little surprised that this was the largest donation to a Johns Hopkins humanities department. This may be wrong, but I think of Johns Hopkins as in the upper echelon of schools that tends to have massive endowments and wealthy alumni. [1] https://www.superyachtfan.com/superyacht_utopia_dv.html https://www.superyachtfan.com/superyacht_utopia_dv.html
- mathattack 9y agoThere's a big emphasis towards donating for professional schools. (Medical in the case of JHU) Also - it's a huge donation for just a department, rather than a building or school.
- dalbasal 9y agoWell... Those two go together. They have those endowments largely due to such generous donations.
- xioxox 9y agoTrue, but if your country gives you tax breaks for donations, by giving you're depriving other tax payers of your money. You're saying that what you're donating to is more worthwhile than the average government spending, which may not be true for some "charities". (By the way, this argument is not originally mine but was in an interesting comedy on BBC Radio 4 yesterday: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09ply4y http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09ply4y)
- alextheparrot 9y agoCouldn’t one flip the equation by saying that allowing certain tax deductions is a form of government spending? The government has decided it is OK with non-centralized (you and I can pick) funding to certain classes of organizations, which is as much a part of the tax code (Or was) as the tax rate itself. I find it difficult to place a kinda of moral burden on the tax payer when this is entirely government policy.
- shaki-dora 9y agoThere is a danger in overreliance on private donations, which is that they are rarely targeted well. People tend to rarely donate millions to regabilititation efforts for middle-aged Sex offenders. Conversely, as just one example, there is an immorally well-funded charity for stray cats in my country, mostly financed from inheritances by lonely widows.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThe market solution for that is for rehabilitating middle-aged sex offenders to dedicate themselves to caring for lonely widows.
- dougmwne 9y agoA more accurate way of looking at this is that the government is incentivizing a desirable behavior by matching a portion of any money a person contributes to the common good. You have to give up some of your own after-tax wealth to get the govt to kick in 20-30%. Since an individual is mostly putting their own money into the charity, they will want to maximize their good feelings by chosing a charity that adds a lot to the common good. And this is especially true for people who make large gifts. ...At least for the US tax system(where this gift was made)
- xioxox 9y agoThough many voters may not like government matching a donanation to, for example, the Scientology organisation.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThat's the theory, ut in practice most people give not to charities for others but to schools/clubs/churches they are a member of, so it's a form of nongoverbmental State/Local taxes.
- oftenwrong 9y agoTo answer the baity headline: >William H. “Bill” Miller III ... attributes “much” of his success ... to the “analytical training and habits of mind” his philosophical study at Johns Hopkins inculcated. The way he sees it, more students should have the chance for that intellectual stimulation.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAs SMBC put it - is philosophy valuable? Yes, every day, a thousand times. Is a philosophy credential valuable? No.
- dajohnson89 9y agoFWIW I would consider philosophy degree a plus when reviewing job applications.
- ChrisRR 9y agoDepends what the job is for
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tw1010 9y agoA positive addition, sure. But when accounting for opportunity cost (not getting a degree in something more valuable) then I think the balance shifts in favour of graduating in something else.
- meddlepal 9y agoI have a philosophy degree with a CS minor... it has served me well so in my career and I think it's absolutely a killer combination whether you do it as Phil major/CS minor or CS major/Phil minor or even double major.
- 9y ago
- draw_down 9y agoWhy not? If they gave that to an athletics department nobody would blink.
- gallerdude 9y agoPhilosophy is a great example of something that’s definitely helpful, just tough to lay out concrete benefits. You can give it a lot of ham-fisted examples (philosophy helps with maths), but at the end of the day philosophy is about life itself.
- eddd 9y agoI'd rather say, philosophy is about thinking, it is a tool. Tool that gives you ability to reason about pretty much anything.
- eddd 9y agoPhilosophy today is one of the most undervalued discipline. It doesn't yield any return on investment immediately and is mostly confusing at the beginning, so people don't tend to have interest in it. I think we have some sort global identity crisis because of that. Religions are not sufficient enough and science doesn't even try to answer the question of "why?" but rather "how?". In result of that, we ended up with no ideology and no tools to build one for ourselves. This is laughably ironic, because we really want some change in the way we live and think and yet, we don't turn back and evaluate what people came out with in the history. edit: if you want to start with it: http://philosophizethis.org/category/episode/ http://philosophizethis.org/category/episode/
- humanrebar 9y ago> Religions are not sufficient enough... I don't really draw such a strong distinction between religion and philosophy. I consider theology to be a school of philosophy that deals with certain metaphysical axioms and their implications. If investment in philosophy helps people understand how most controversy is downstream from assumptions they don't know they're making, they might be able to de-escalate from thier religious fervor (a popular "religion" these days is an unhealthy political divisiveness), I welcome that investment.
- eddd 9y agoReligion is a oversimplification of philosophy doctrines. Imagine Moses trying to communicate with regular folk his views on the world in a way that Socrates did. It was much more efficient to translate it to a set of stories that impose specific behavior. The closest religion to philosophy (I can think of) is Buddhism, it is basically a guide to learn about self and the world.
- elboru 9y agoI don't agree, maybe you have have a oversimplified view of religion, do you believe religion only consists of regular folks? Where would you put St. Thomas and his Summa Theologica
- 9y ago
- meri_dian 9y agoThis is why philosophy is important: Education has two related yet distinct purposes. The first is to endow us with specific domain knowledge and reasoning. The second is to endow us with general reasoning and critical thinking skills. The value of natural language philosophy - not formal logic and other mathematically adjacent subfields - is that it teaches us to be as rigorous as possible when reasoning in natural language. Given that so much of our lives and the events of history and society unfold in natural language and that it is in natural language that we do much of our critical thinking and reasoning, it's important that we hold ourselves to as high a standard as is reasonably possible when talking (either to ourselves or others) as when performing mathematical calculations. It's often said that one of the benefits of studying math is that it improves critical thinking skills. I believe this to be true, but I also believe that if our primary concern is improving our day to day critical thinking skills, then we would be better served studying natural language philosphy than mathematics, because on a day to day basis we tend to think and reason and debate and engage with one another in natural language.
- steaknsteak 9y agoAgreed. In my anecdotal experience, imprecise language and simple logical mistakes made in conversation is a pretty frequent source of miscommunication and minor interpersonal conflict. But I can't really tell people to speak more precisely or consider the logical implications of their speech without sounding like a prick
- humanrebar 9y ago> ...it teaches us to be as rigorous as possible when reasoning in natural language. A philosopher should explain to all the natural-language-as-code people why their endeavor is much, much harder than they think it is. If a philosopher isn't available, a lawyer would probably be qualified as well. Point being, I feel like I'm getting some of those benefits just writing code and talking about it on a regular basis.
- meri_dian 9y agoIt sounds to me like you're philosophizing about code then, which is a fine thing to philosophize about. We use natural language to express abstractions formed over a very complex world, so it's guaranteed that when talking we'll be imprecise in some way, but the goal is to try to reduce this imprecision.
- rz2k 9y agoWhy on earth is the entire last paragraph devoted to Lawrence Krauss’s musings on philosophy? It may represent a widespread attitude found among physicists, but not one many people with a background in both disciplines shares. In physics forums, the same dismissive attitude can also be found about pure math for which a use in physics has not yet been found. A fourth paragraph might talk about how any curriculum in financial engineering begins with an even bigger assumption than in physics that the big problems are already mostly understood, and that the rest is computation to fill in a few gaps. And yet this donor thinks the formal study of philosophy is important. My understanding of what he is saying about philosophy and discipline has to do with developing the capability to handle a large problem analytically. This is different than the type of discipline where you break things down into small problems then work through them individually. When Lawrence Krauss talks about philosophy, you get the impression that he thinks it is all people in coffee shops in black turtlenecks being awed by random thoughts rather than people doing anything formal or logically rigorous.
- philip1209 9y agoIt's less interesting of a donation to me because the donor studied philosophy there. It makes it seem more reactive than proactive.
- cornholio 9y agoWhile laudable, it has some ego trip elements - he's not only thankful for the "mind discipline" his training endowed him with, but wants the department to bear his name. Really, a philosophy department named not after a famous local philosopher or distinguished scholar, but a wealthy financier that happened to study there? It a telling sign of our times.
- _rpd 9y agoThere are a lot of ego games. Non-anonymous philanthropy is probably the last one we should discourage.
- nbulka 9y agoOnly a truly great scientist gets mentioned as contributing to the philosophy of science, or is characterized also as a logician on wikipedia. That's often because they were pursuing some philosophical riddle which they were more concerned about than the theories that would later become their legacy. Cantor and Godel wanted to find God, and in their search, provided much of the early work for Turing and computer science to develop. Einstein similarly wanted to know the mind of God, and in doing so contributed to quantum mechanics and invented relativity. Bell's explanation of his theorem in a 1985 BBC Radio interview includes an appeal to the debate between free-will and determinism when interpreting his results. TL;DR — Important scientific and mathematical breakthroughs often come from a deep exploration of metaphysics, epistemology, free-will, and ontological truth.
- Alekanekelo 9y ago> Bell's explanation of his theorem in a 1985 BBC Radio interview includes an appeal to the debate between free-will and determinism when interpreting his results. That sounds very interesting. Is the radio interview (or a transcript) still available? I tried searching for it and found a possible match for a show on BBC Radio 3 in 1983 [1]. [1] http://genome.ch.bbc.co.uk/7c8c2aba48024a5e925d0aca69c57b21 http://genome.ch.bbc.co.uk/7c8c2aba48024a5e925d0aca69c57b21
- nbulka 9y agohttps://books.google.com/books?id=KHezRs7nsAgC&pg=PA45&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=4#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=KHezRs7nsAgC&pg=PA45&sourc...
- mygo 9y agoThis is probably just me being nit picky but... Einstein didn’t invent relativity. It existed before he was born. He discovered it... and told other people about it... in a formal manner.
- Retra 9y agoHe invented an accurate and useful description of it. Which is as much as anybody does to invent something.
- pnathan 9y agoNice! My opinion is that philosophy is the undervalued discipline in American life today. To back that up: I would rather work with a philosopher than an arbitrary "other degree" holder outside of the Math/CS preference. Particularly as the person grows in seniority, the education becomes more and more useful.
- vlunkr 9y agoI believe that at least an introductory philosophy course should be required for all college students. (maybe high school, I don't know). Philosophy has a bad reputation because 1) it's seen as the most pretentious of fields and 2) getting a degree in it is not a quick path to making any money. But in my experience, most people who haven't taken a course don't really know what philosophy is about. I took a few courses and I consider them among the most valuable parts of my college experience. You look at some of the oldest questions(and various answers) around, and use those to learn how to really form and analyze arguments objectively. I may be preaching to the choir here, but if you haven't studied any philosophy, try it out!
- dcow 9y agoBack in the seventies, physics was called natural philosophy. In college, it amazed me how many people study sciences without even asking or caring why. They don't know the limits of the knowledge they seek or of the tools (repeatable observations) in their belt because they never learned how to ask uncomfortable questions or learn formal logic. Most certainly some of this is by design as colleges evolved into little businesses obsessed with crafting financially successful students before well rounded ones. On the other hand, some is probably just a reflection of the rationalist zeitgeist—philosophy became supernatural. To me, it's sadly dogmatic. You stop asking existential questions when your peers stop challenging your belief system.
- allemagne 9y agoAnecdotally, the world of science really opened up for me in a way that counteracted the kind of blindness you're describing when I took a class on statistics in high school. It finally clicked for me both how much scientific knowledge can be trusted and, paradoxically, how much we still need to be careful about trusting it. This is due to a teacher who actively pushed this kind of thinking instead of teaching us to blindly recite the mathematics behind calculating p-values, which certainly could have been an option. It might help to require a few lessons directly on epistemology for high school or college curricula, but in the end you can't teach kids who don't want to learn effectively with teachers who don't want to teach effectively.
- sevenfive 9y agoInteresting to read all the responses in this thread observing incidental correlations between intellectual or practical accomplishments and philosophy. Famous scientists are sometimes interested in philosophy, philosophy majors score high on the GRE, etc. It does not follow at all that studying philosophy helped cause those accomplishments. The situation is similar to brain training games like Lumosity. They do not make you smarter in general, just better at that particular game. People who are already smart will do better. Personally, my argument for philosophy is that I enjoy it.
- nbulka 9y agoMany famous scientists were interested in philosophical questions like the nature of reality or "is God real?" and are only known as scientists because they had these ultimately philosophical concerns.
- sevenfive 9y agoThis is such a lame argument. Nobody is going to cure cancer or build a better tokamak because they attended a fancy wood-paneled lecture on God at Johns Hopkins.
- nbulka 9y agoWell ... The Institute for Advanced Study is perhaps best known as the academic home of Albert Einstein, Hermann Weyl, John von Neumann and Kurt Gödel, after their immigration to the United States. ... founded in 1930 by American educator Abraham Flexner, together with philanthropists Louis Bamberger and Caroline Bamberger Fuld. Why not Johns Hopkins?
- snambi 9y agoWhy do we need philosophy?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- primodemus 9y agoPhilosopher Michael Huemer considers this one of the most wasteful charitable donations: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2018/01/huemer_on_ultra.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2018/01/huemer_on_ultra....
- mygo 9y agoAll roads link to philosophy. At least, all Wikipedia articles do.