17 ms·
Plunging costs make solar, wind and battery storage cheaper than coal
- cyberpunk0 9y agoOld news
- virmundi 9y agoI could have missed it, but does this take into account subsidies provided by the Chinese government?
- clort 9y agoFrom the point of view of the australian government, does it matter?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tim333 9y agoWind + batteries came out cheaper than solar + batteries so I guess the chinese subsidies were not that critical.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoAlthough the site is Australian, the cost info is from Colorado, the US already has anti-dumping levies on Chinese solar which will be reflect in bids so yes it does take solar subsidies into account. It doesn't however account for government subsidies of coal.
- virmundi 9y agoI thought the US just added anti-dumping levies. If so, the price wouldn't reflect that change yet. As to the coal, fair point.
- DFHippie 9y agoOr, alternatively, the thumbs put on the scale by any other government for any energy source. Maybe the Trump admin tacking a 30% tariff on non-US solar benefits non-US solar in other markets -- there's less demand for the current supply.
- seren 9y agoI know next to nothing to Power Generation Bid, but I am always puzzled that these articles always mention cost estimation coming from the bidder. Are we sure the lowest bidder can actually deliver at that cost point down the line ?
- postingatwork 9y agothose "estimates" likely get written as hard promises into contracts in the form of long-term power purchase agreements. The bidding, assuming it is competitive, drives down the current price in favor of the utilities. The long-term agreements provide stability in favor of the suppliers in case market prices plunging even further than estimated.
- seren 9y agoI have not followed all EPR nuclear reactor project, but it seems some project have a hard time to deliver. So is there somewhere an example of catastrophic failure ? or on the contrary, wind/solar project tend to be completed on time, with the expected cost for the provider ? Naively I would think that latter kind of project are much lower risks.
- ljf 9y agoNuclear (from what I understand) usually has both far higher bid/pitched costs, plus an agreement to pay those over a longer period. Plus they usually come with finance or arranged finance. The risk is in the building, but once built they are (in theory) a cash cow. But govt seem to find all sorts of ways to subsidise them - offering the clean up etc. P
- philipkglass 9y agoWind and solar projects have the lowest overrun risks of all utility-scale electricity projects: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360544214008925 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036054421... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629614000942 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221462961... A 500 megawatt solar project is, approximately, 100 5-megawatt solar projects tiled together and sharing a transmission line. There are large parts of the project that can be built in parallel without scheduling dependencies. There are multiple vendors available for each equipment component (racking, tracking, inverters, modules) and there's a lot of mix-and-match flexibility. You don't have to buy Panasonic inverters and monitoring software just because you went with Panasonic modules. Large projects usually start generating power before their official commission date, because you can energize completed subsections as soon as they're connected to transmission. Nuclear projects are pretty much the complete opposite. There are tightly coupled dependencies. A delay in one component (like a coolant pump) means that the entire project timeline slips. You can't play mix-and-match with reactor components -- no Westinghouse core plus Mitsubishi containment system. Unlike a large solar farm, a large reactor can't start generating partial power when the project is only 50% (or even 85%) complete, so financing weighs more heavily on the project economics. Reactors that are up and running are great, and I deplore their premature retirement. But building new reactors is a slow process where the payoff comes only at the end.
- rossdavidh 9y agoNotable: "And these prices do not represent just a few one-off, left field offers. All told, there were more than 100 bids combining wind and solar, or both, with battery storage, and 20 gigawatts of such capacity. The “median” means that half the bids were cheaper than the median price cited above." I realize most readers of HN know what a median is, but the fact that this was not just the lowest bid in each group was worth highlighting.
- murph-almighty 9y agoThanks for the pointer, I would not have caught that
- ghostcluster 9y agoDoes this include wear and tear and replacement costs on the battery storage cells?
- diafygi 9y agoYes. These bids are usually for a "power purchase agreement", which is a bid to deliver X amount of power over some period of time. All of the maintenance, fuel, wear/replacement costs are included with the bid since it's just a raw end power delivery contract. The interesting thing that's new about this is that these bids are for "dispatchable" renewables. Up until this point, most renewables were not dispatchable since they didn't have cost competitive storage. This means that renewables now can bid for much higher levels of grid penetration in capacity markets.
- wlesieutre 9y agoNote that coal is also not a dispatchable power source. Mostly they're base load plants [1], best case they're load following power plants [2]. No way for them to respond quickly to demand changes like natural gas, hydroelectric, or batteries can. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Load_following_power_plant#Coal_based_power_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Load_following_power_plant#Coa...
- Proven 9y agoOld nonsense never seems to stop.... If you can’t run that shit 24x7, you need coal anyway, and in addition to whatever subsidized crap you’ve built alongside it...
- wonderwonder 9y agoWe live in a strange time where our access to clean power is limited not by technology or product cost but by politics, dedicated lobbying dollars and the entrenched old guard in federal but more importantly state and local level government. I'm still waiting on my clean coal...
- cobookman 9y agoHow does politics prevent electricity companies from building solar plants. While I agree politics could help enable it more through subsidies. However we are capitalisticish where utilities won't build a coal plant if solar is truly significantly cheaper.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>How does politics prevent electricity companies from building solar plants. By whacking massive tariffs on imported solar panels. They pretend it's done for the benefit of American solar manufacturers. It's not. It's done for the benefit of coal and gas. If they just wanted to help American solar manufacturers they'd give them subsidies to offset what they (erroneously) considered "unfair" competition from China.
- KirinDave 9y agoLet's not forget major wind power states literally making it illegal to compete with gas.
- djrogers 9y agoThose tariffs are brand new and in the US, but the data in TFA is fro last year in Australia.
- crdoconnor 9y agoA) Solar tariffs were initially brought in under Obama and B) I figured the question was a general one - not specific to Australia.
- Brakenshire 9y agoWithin the last ten years we've had solar and wind getting below retail rate of grid electricity, then getting below wholesale rate, now below wholesale rate including storage. There aren't too many 'yes, but...' issues which are left to prevent these technologies actually taking over on a pure cost basis. That is, even if you assumed climate change is a hoax, which is incorrect, the alternative technologies are still better. I suppose one issue is the length of storage, in the article the ranges they mention are 4-10 hours, I would have thought wind would be variable enough to require longer term storage to guarantee power output, not so certain about solar in Colorado? Presumably the percentage of storage needed would vary a lot depending on the local microclimate. That presumably will be a wrinkle holding up adoption.
- xPhobophobia 9y agoYes, but...this is the case just for the first-order cost basis. The supply of raw battery materials (e.g. Cobalt) is limited in price and quantity. If we don't invent new battery technologies, we don't have sufficient accessible supply of raw resources. I also wonder how mid term artificial manipulations to the market of these components (i.e. China subsidizing solar cells, America adding tariffs) will keep us on a general decline in solar power costs.
- Brakenshire 9y agoI'm dubious about the resource point, because prospecting and mining are demand-driven. These kind of resource crunches are happening all the time with new technologies. Supply will follow demand, that may even lower prices with new discoveries or technologies. Even if the price has to go up massively to open up new sources, how many orders of magnitude increase would be required to make a dent in the overall cost of a battery for Cobalt? And then, even if there is a serious hard limit there are plenty of alternatives. You can use multiple other materials as an in-place replacement for Cobalt in Lithium batteries, and there are lots of other fundamentally different battery and storage technologies which work using different materials and principles, which have other resource requirements. The peak Lithium or peak Cobalt idea seems quite similar to peak oil, which was sort of right (in the sense of conventional oil) but in a way which turned out not to be especially relevant.
- Robotbeat 9y agoEDIT AGAIN: No, this is the same as the article I thought it was. They didn't actually specify the cost vs duration of the storage. There's a figure which shows duration for another project, but pricing info is not shown, so it's not very useful. But I did manage to find this linked to in the story, which does specify duration in parts: https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/record-low-solar-plus-storage-price-in-xcel-solicitation https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/record-low-sola... This is a continuing pet peeve of mine: "solar plus storage" but very hard to actually parse out how much storage they're talking about.
- ljf 9y agoIn the article (in an image) - states 4 to 10 hours: http://reneweconomy.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Screen-Shot-2018-01-29-at-12.44.01-PM.png http://reneweconomy.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Screen...
- Robotbeat 9y ago...but doesn't state what costs are associated with those varying durations. This is a basic numeracy/literacy issue. I'm super bullish on solar and storage and follow this issue in the news, which is why it's so frustrating when these things aren't clearly communicated...
- gwright 9y agoIf that is true (costs include just 4-10 hours) then the cost comparisons are absurdly misleading. The reality is that the grid needs to work when there is no sun or wind for days or even weeks.
- Robotbeat 9y agoEven that would be impressive. But it's just not clear that that is what the data says. 4 hours of storage, if the storage is expected to cycle twice per day (once in the morning, when sunlight is still dim but demand has picked up, using fossil/nuclear/geothermal/wind energy generated at night when demand is super low, and once in the evening as sun sets but demand still high, using solar energy generated during the day), then that is a factor of 2 better for costs than if storage is expected to only cycle once a day or worse. But we can't tell because the article doesn't mention any of these details. This factor of two (or more) is the difference between status quo and a revolution, but the article remains unclear.
- thisisit 9y agoI always wonder - do the bid prices really reflect the future? I mean it is entirely possible for these prices to not hold long term and many of these projects shutting down/ending in huge losses. Anyone in the solar energy industry have some insights on the pricing?
- all_usernames 9y agoIs there anything to the notion that the Trump administration putting a 30% tariff on imported solar panels is an attempt to bolster the coal or other fossil fuel industry?
- sputknick 9y agoProbably not. Trump didn't put these tariffs in place, he renewed tariffs Obama had put in place. I think those tariffs are more about protecting American manufacturing.
- bildung 9y agoThat's not true, the tariffs put in place by the Obama administration were targeting only chinese imports (because of suspected subsidies by the Chinese state), Trumps tariffs target every import.
- sputknick 9y agoI appreciate the correction, I didn't know that change was part of it. It still sounds reasonable to believe it's more about manufacturing than about coal. Not saying I agree with it, I don't like it, I want to encourage solar and wind, but I get the desire to protect American workers.
- edaemon 9y agoUnfortunately there aren't very many American solar manufacturing jobs. According to the SEIA, only about 2,000 Americans are employed in solar manufacturing: "The Solar Energy Industries Association, a trade group, said Monday that Trump's decision will kill American manufacturing jobs, not create them. The trade group said that of the 38,000 solar manufacturing jobs in the U.S., only 2,000 involve making cells and panels, which are covered by Trump's import tax. The other 36,000 manufacturing jobs involve other equipment used on large solar farms and rooftop solar installations." https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2018/01/22/trumps-30-tariff-imported-solar-panels-may-cost-jobs/1056440001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2018/01/22/tru... That still doesn't mean that the tariff isn't meant to help American manufacturing, of course, but it does so while harming the rest of the American solar industry. The people I know who work in solar energy were advocating for a subsidy for American panels to make them competitive with Chinese ones as that would benefit the entire US solar industry.
- kapauldo 9y agoBetter hurry up and flag this before someone thinks facts are political.
- sologoub 9y agoCompletely side topic question - are there any studies on how much surface of the planet would need to be covered with solar to make a measurable impact on absorbing and/or reflecting enough sunlight to affect some cooling?
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Completely side topic question - are there any studies on how much surface of the planet would need to be covered with solar to make a measurable impact on absorbing and/or reflecting enough sunlight to affect some cooling? I don't think solar will have any impact here. The whole point is to absorb the light (and energy), not to reflect it. That's one of the reasons solar panels appear black, not white: they're absorbing light. If the alternative is coal, solar energy will warm the planet less, but it's not going to actively cool the planet the way you're describing.
- sologoub 9y agoNaively thought that by absorbing heat energy and transforming it into electric current, there was some cooling effect when compared to heating the surface of the planet.
- philipkglass 9y agoThere is localized cooling in the cell. Some photon energy that would have been thermalized immediately in a dark-colored simple absorber is carried away as electricity instead. But that electricity is, ultimately, used and thermalized somewhere else on Earth, so it doesn't have a cooling effect on the planet as a whole. Additionally, the albedo of solar modules is lower than e.g. empty desert, so the net effect of installing a large solar array on such land is to slightly increase localized temperature. Accounting for increased albedo is why the IPCC's global warming assessment of utility-scale solar puts its warming impact a bit above that of rooftop solar. Rooftops are already lower in albedo, so adding solar modules doesn't darken them as much. Both rooftop and large desert-based solar have much lower warming potential than any form of fossil combustion, of course.
- colanderman 9y agoAnyone know why the project bids are in units of energy? From my experience with home solar projects are priced in units of power. (EDIT: From further in the article, these look like operating costs, not e.g. initial build-out costs that one would be quoted for a home installation. Makes sense, though I wonder now if they include amortized build-out costs.) And then, why the mixing of MWh and kW·mo? They're similar orders of magnitude, why add in a layer of confusion with the constant factor difference? (For reference: multiply $/kW·mo by 1.39 to obtain $/MWh.)
- scblock 9y agoWhile I am unsure about the different units for conventional vs. renewable energy, pricing for large scale power projects is generally reviewed on a per unit of generation basis, not a capital cost basis. That way the cost incorporates all costs, including operations, maintenance, financing, insurance, and so on, and also includes expected plant performance levels. The $/MWh cost to the utility is the fairest way to compare different sites and different technologies.
- qbrass 9y agoFrom the source document https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4340162/Xcel-Solicitation-Report.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4340162/Xcel-Soli... "Pricing is provided in $/kW-mo terms for those generation types that can be viewed as dispatchable and likely to provide high levels of generation capacity credit. Pricing is provided in $/MWh terms for those generation types or resources that are non-dispatchable or that include a storage component with a non-dispatchable base generation resource." They're paying for whatever wind and solar can provide but require fossil fuel plants to produce what actually need.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoI would love to get solar panels but it feels like the price is artificially high. Panel costs keep going down but I've never seen a set of solar panels for less than $20k, regardless of panel cost. I think the solar companies keep increasing other costs to keep it at the same level, which means there isn't enough competition yet.
- sxates 9y agoDecreases in panel costs result in only modest decreases in residential solar costs, because the panels aren't the bulk of the cost of install. There's all the labor of installing them, the other equipment like inverters and electric panel upgrades, the engineering time to evaluate the site and design an optimized system size and placement, and then just the general overhead that comes with the business (sales, marketing, admin, billing, etc.). The panels themselves might only be 30% of that.
- martinpw 9y agoLooks like even less than 30% - the chart in this article shows panels are only around 10% of total cost for residential, meaning further panel price declines now have very little effect: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2017/06/12/u-s-utility-scale-solar-falls-below-us1-per-watt-w-charts/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2017/06/12/u-s-utility-scale-sol... As you imply, for utility scale the other costs are much lower, so falling panel costs still have a significant impact on total price.
- rconti 9y agohttp://sepbatteries.com/canadian-solar-cs6p-240p-solar-panel?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI-5uy0YX-2AIVSY1-Ch2X0Qe9EAQYASABEgJhvPD_BwE http://sepbatteries.com/canadian-solar-cs6p-240p-solar-panel... <$2400 for the 4kWh I'd need to power my house.
- treis 9y agoThere's two problems: (1) The bids include tax incentives. Without those it's much closer: The cost of wind without storage was $18/MWh, while the cost of solar without storage was $29/MWh – both prices benefit from federal tax incentives, and would likely be around $US25/MWh and $US40/MWh without them. (2) Solar and Wind are not 100% consistent producers. There are days where the wind doesn't blow, it's cloudy, or it's winter time. You have to have excess capacity in the grid for these events. So you can't just look at the price per mWh. You have to include this excess capacity in the cost of your wind/solar system
- colanderman 9y agoThe article's purpose is to draw attention to renewable solutions with energy storage (e.g. batteries). "The significance of the tender result is the small additional cost of storage – between $US3 and $US7/MWh."
- treis 9y agoStorage typically is only enough to store energy generated during the day for use at night. It's nowhere near enough to account for seasonal changes or extended bouts of cloudy weather.
- colanderman 9y agoPoint taken.
- blt 9y agoTrue, we need a global grid.
- Consultant32452 9y agoEnergy loss during transmission makes this unfeasible.
- 9y ago
- intrasight 9y agoArguably, the US has Trump as president due to coal interests. But I doubt that the next administration will go as far as Obama did in trying to shut down the coal industry - too politically risky to lose PA again. This political-economic dynamic does imply that there will be a tipping point were coal-fired power plants shut down en masse. I wish that day would come sooner rather than later since our air quality sucks.
- politician 9y agoIntriguing! Maybe Dems should work to bring renewable energy projects to PA, so that in 10 years they can swing the workforce away from coal.
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoI always wondered why this didn't happen in every area with coal. I get many of these areas are not the best for solar or wind but if you provide a way for these people to transition to something different you're far more likely to win their support versus the narrative that ran rampant in the election where no one cared about the coal miners.
- aspaceman 9y agoPeople have been trying to transition coal miners via education programs and funding for a while now. The sad truth is that coal miners want to continue being coal miners because they have wrapped up a lot of their identity into the job.
- ams6110 9y agoWell we're going to continue to need coal in possibly decreasing amounts for the next couple of decades. No way are we decommissioning all coal-fired generating any time soon. That should be enough time for natural attrition to handle the current mine workers. The effort should be in getting young people interested/trained in something else before they follow their fathers into the mines.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoAs the price of renewable energy sources drops it's gonna be harder for states to dismiss the high cost of corruption and incompetence in the energy procurement process by telling consumers "your electricity is so expensive because we buy organic, sustainably farmed, non-gmo, carbon neutral electrons"
- matt4077 9y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?query=solar%20never&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=solar%20never&sort=byPopularit...: "solar will never solve baseline load." "solar will never be able to replace traditional coal and gas-fired plants" "such as wind or solar, can never exceed a certain percentage of the grid's production capacity" "they are never going to be viable but for a small portion of our energy needs" "entirely on solar? never." "Solar will never be cheaper than coal" And that's just the first page of results. There are 49 more... It's quite depressing that it's the tech community that has been badmouthing renewables for years, and the politicians were the one that made it happen.
- shoguning 9y agoMaybe I'm missing it, but I don't see an indication of how much storage they are talking about here. The problem with renewables is still intermittence, and geographic dependence. Solar does no good at night, and there are days the wind doesn't blow. The costs of storage for that bulk application still don't seem to make sense, and I don't see it addressed here. The Tesla battery replaced power on the order of seconds, which is still a success, but not enough. In general, solar has been great for reducing peak demand, since it has highest output during the middle of the day when electricity demand is also greatest. Not clear how much farther it can go, though. Wind may be able to replace some, but wind isn't strong everywhere.
- bitoneill 9y agoSo I gather you don't believe batteries will succeed as a solution
- shoguning 9y agoNot clear. If costs really continue to decline, batteries will make up a bigger and bigger part of the solution, but costs and uncertainty of the massive scale battery projects still seem high to me. Decreasing demand, nuclear, carbon capture, batteries, etc will all play a role IMO.
- okreallywtf 9y agoCarbon capture seems like a bigger wildcard to me than battery technology. Battery technology has been improving pretty steadily and will likely continue to do so. Capturing carbon from coal power plants adds cost to something that is already not cost effective. Capturing carbon in the atmosphere likely will require huge amounts of power - and if its not 100% renewable power its kind of pointless. Nuclear is better than coal or natural gas, but there have been some high profile failures lately and the lead time on new nuclear is so high, as well as the sticker price.
- ams6110 9y ago
- chris_va 9y ago(disclaimer: I work in a Climate and Energy R&D group) I just want to jump in here because these numbers are all strange. The author mixes units all over the place (e.g. MW vs MWh). The article confuses nameplate capacity and marginal cost. And there is no mention of capacity factor or dispatchability. Very simply, the current state of the world: - Renewable energy is getting more popular, and has zero marginal cost. That means they always sell to the grid, regardless of cost, and drive high variability in daily demand. - Coal and nuclear have higher capital costs, and thus require 90%+ utilization to stay competative with natural gas. However, demand is low for a quarter the day now, so they are out. There is no saving coal, no matter how much political rhetorical goes into it, the economics do not work out. - Renewables by themseles are not dispatchable. Do not confuse them with natural gas/coal/hydro/nuclear. - Renewables+storage would be dispatchable (especially if you add HVDC to lower variability), and this gets us into the actual numbers from the article... Lets do some math Batteries currently cost about $150/kWh. That will continue to come down, but let's say we want to build a plant in the next 5 years, so maybe $100/kWh if we are really lucky. For a 200MW dispatchable solar/wind plant, we'd have: - ~25% capacity factor would be very optimistic (they aren't building in an ideal location in CO). - That means 800MW of nameplate capacity to get an average of 200MW output. - $1/W nameplate for solar these days => 800MW nameplate plant at $800M for just the solar. - $100/kWh for batteries. Even if we only needed 24h of storage (though realistically you need more like 3 days), that means 200MW24h$150/kWh => $480M => Total plant cost is $1.28B, for 200MW of output, or $6400/kW. Let's say we have For 30 years, with a 5% rate of return on capital (3% over inflation), and a 1% O&M/y cost (this is really low, just to give it a fighting change, 3-6% is typical), that ends up as.... 5.5 cents/kWh. Which is way above natural gas (4 cents/kWh), so they'd never take it without federal subsidies. Any bid below that isn't likely to be fully dispatchable, which makes it even less competative with natural gas, even if it is cheaper. It's hard to compete with a low-capital cost power plant that has nearly free energy flowing out of a hole in the ground.
- philipkglass 9y agoI'd be very surprised if these bids came with more than 4 hours of storage. That's enough to prevent a California-style "duck curve" and to serve the early evening peak demand. It's also enough storage to severely dent the economics of new fossil peaker plants -- perhaps even those of already-built peakers. These solar + storage proposals are not 1:1 complete replacements for traditional dispatchable power. But with 4 hours of storage a solar plant can run for hours after sunset, serving the highest-demand period of the day (which is also the most lucrative period in deregulated electricity markets). Just a few hours of storage significantly increases the upper limit to solar generation's share on a grid without excessive curtailment. EDIT: you probably know this. I'm just using your comment as a jumping-off point to elaborate.
- JBlue42 9y agoCan someone provide a bit more details about this. Is this only if you have a massive solar farm (which I assume is cheaper due to land value + large quantities) or does it also include solar for residential (which I assume is more expensive due to installation, limited area, etc)? When looking at a satellite image of LA, I wonder how much power we could generate by having panels installed on the flat/near-flat rooftops of apartment buildings, at least in the sunnier parts of the city.
- wavegeek 9y agoSolar with batteries $40 (that only last 10 hours max then blackouts). Gas turbines $4.80. > renewables are cheaper Storage prices have fallen by about 7% per annum over a long period, with some fits and starts. This is no Moore's law. This article is very slanted, expected from a player in the process.
- sfink 9y agoHah. These shortsighted "renewable energy" fanatics will sure be sorry when the sun burns out, and we have to fire up all those old mothballed coal power plants that they have heaped such scorn on.