15 ms·
Becoming a Lawyer Without Going to Law School (2015)
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoApprenticeships seem to have been very common up until very recently. They offered an alternative path to college, which for many leads to insurmountable debt and poor job prospects. Who is the largest holder of student debt in the United States? The answer to that question explains why apprenticeships and trade schools are not promoted.
- Bromskloss 9y ago> Who is the largest holder of student debt in the United States? The answer to that question explains why apprenticeships and trade schools are not promoted. Could you spell this out for us? Who hold the largest debt? And promoted by whom?
- jsharf 9y agoMost student debt is owned by the US Federal Government. "In 2010, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated 55% of loans fell into this category. Between 2011 and 2016, the share of privately originated student loans fell by nearly 90%." "In February 2016, the U.S. Treasury Department revealed in its annual report that student loans account for 31% of all U.S. government assets." that 31% figure is pretty concerning... https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/081216/who-actually-owns-student-loan-debt.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/08121...
- icantdrive55 9y agoI've always felt if you can pass a notoriously hard Bar Examination, like the CA Bar; you should be allowed to practice law. (Maybe require a few ethics's classes, after a passing grade?)
- angled 9y agoI've just started reading Robert Caro's "Path to Power", and LBJ's father took exactly this route to become a teacher: "He had to quit going to high school because of health problems, and his parents sent him to live on his uncle Lucius Bunton's ranch in Presidio County, Texas for several months.[3] When he returned home, Johnson had ambitions to become a teacher; however, the Texas hill country at that time had no state-accredited high schools and no colleges. He learned that he could get a state-issued teaching certificate without finishing high school by passing a state examination.[3] In 1896, with the thirteen textbooks he needed to study for the exam, he moved to his retired grandfather's nearby home to study in quiet.[4]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Ealy_Johnson_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Ealy_Johnson_Jr.
- wyclif 9y agoSame as in land surveying or any other discipline that requires state licensure. Some surveyors do have civil engineering or geomatics/geodesy degrees, but you certainly don't have to obtain one to practice surveying (state law varies). What's important is that you have field experience under the direct supervision of a PLS and can pass a very rigorous licensure exam that includes demonstrating a deep knowledge of property/boundary law, trigonometry, and calculus. There's no question about your competence if you can pass a PLS exam.
- kenpomeroy 9y agoNot saying I disagree, because I think the bar association is a cartel and everyone should be "allowed" to practice law. However, the reason the CA bar is "notoriously hard" is precisely because they allow anyone to sit for it. If lots of unqualified people take an exam and fail, it causes the passage rate to drop and makes the exam appear "harder."
- gnicholas 9y agoAnother reason the CA pass rate is lower than other states’ is that in CA you can take the bar exam as many times as you want. NY cuts you off st 3, as a comparison.
- hacknat 9y agoLawyers currently have one of the most bi-modal salary distributions of any profession. It seems to me that for folks who want to enter the profession doing low pay work that this should be a more supported and common path as law school is a ridiculous choice for someone who is going to make less than a teacher for the rest of their life. I’ve known a handful of public defenders in my time and almost all of them had some form of alternative support (usually rich spouse or parents). Additionally, the UK has a hybrid system that seems to work well, and they also have two types of lawyers: barristers and solicitors. From what I understand it’s easier to become a solicitor, but your mostly doing small cases and family law and can only argue before certain courts. Barristers have a more arduous path, take more serious cases, and can argue cases in the higher courts. Seems like we could adopt a similar system (though it’s probably too late at this point).
- rxhernandez 9y ago> Lawyers currently have one of the most bi-modal salary distributions of any profession. I understand what you're saying but I feel like the top 50 would be occupied by people in various types of art, food preparation/serving, personal care/service, and writing. It would probably be top 3 easily for the amount of debt most of the lawyers go into for their degree(which seems to be the issue you are getting at anyways). https://www.bls.gov/oes/bulletin_2004.pdf https://www.bls.gov/oes/bulletin_2004.pdf
- ghaff 9y agoYou’re probably not wrong to which you could add sports, entertainment etc. but there’s a distinction between professions that have a fairly large number, if overall minority, of well paid to very well paid members and those that almost have a lottery winner sort of effect.
- sjy 9y agoIncome in those professions is not bimodal; it follows a power law. The frequency distribution of income for US lawyers has two clear modes (local maxima) at around $50,000 and $160,000 [1], meaning that roughly the same number of lawyers earn each of those salaries. Put another way, a randomly-selected US lawyer is more likely to earn $160,000 than the much lower mean US lawyer salary. [1]: https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/07/16/the-toppling-of-top-tier-lawyer-jobs/ https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/07/16/the-toppling-o...
- ClintEhrlich 9y agoWhile becoming a lawyer without going to law school, I exonerated an innocent man who was serving life in prison for murder. That man was put behind bars by an incompetent prosecutor... who had become a lawyer without going to law school. (Seriously.)
- cperciva 9y agoThat man was put behind bars by an incompetent prosecutor Unless there was prosecutorial malpractice involved, I'd say that the man whom you exonerated was put behind bars by a judge and a jury.
- Larrikin 9y agoSo you're implying a lawyer plays no role?
- ckastner 9y agoThe power to put people behind bars solely rests with the judge and jury. The prosecutor, by definition, played a role in the process, but it's not the deciding role.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoHow bad was the defense attorney then?
- geebee 9y agodepending on the circumstances, I do think a prosecutor can play a pivotal role. There are examples of misconduct where a prosecutor fails to turn over exculpatory evidence that is so convincing as to make prosecution essentially impossible. It's true that the jury and judge make the decision, but there are cases where they would almost certainly have reached a different decision had the prosecution behaved ethically.
- gl00pp 9y ago
- rsbartram 9y agoThat is something I've dream of but in California that is not possible from the research I've done. I live in Los Angeles county. If someone knows something otherwise please let me know. Thanks Rich
- mbreese 9y agoI thought you could do this in California by apprenticing with a lawyer. No idea if this is still the case, but I vaguely remember reading about this a while back. https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/California_Legal_Apprenticeship_Program https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/California_Legal_Apprentices...
- icelancer 9y agoWhat? It literally says that it's possible in California in the article. "In California, this option is called the “Law Office Study Program” (rule 4.29 under the state bar’s legal code). All lawyers seeking to forego law school must meet the following stipulations..."
- coupdejarnac 9y agoMy cousin, who is a former K St lawyer, told me about how in the 80s(?), Texas passed a law that allowed people who fit very narrow requirements to take the bar exam without attending law school. One high profile businessman passed the bar exam this way. So.. If you want to skip law school, have one of your legislator cronies slip in a law school loophole in a bill. Non-lawyers are allowed to take the patent bar exam. It's the same exam IP attorneys take, except if you pass you cannot call yourself a patent attorney without a law degree. You get the designation of patent agent. That's what I plan to do- become one of the few licensed engineers that has also passed the patent bar.
- icelancer 9y ago>> You get the designation of patent agent. That's what I plan to do- become one of the few licensed engineers that has also passed the patent bar. These people often get called as expert witnesses in IP-related cases and get paid a huge amount of money. I am sure you know this, but it's definitely something to investigate.
- farnsworthy 9y agoI thought Vermont permitted this, and according to the article, it is (or was) four states: "Today, only four states — California, Virginia, Vermont, and Washington — allow aspiring lawyers to take the bar exam without going to law school. Instead, they are given the option to apprentice with a practicing attorney or judge."
- brightball 9y agoYou still have to have an accredited BS in engineering or science to take it. I assumed a degree from an accredited school would fit the bill but found out that was not the case when I wanted to take the patent bar years ago. You have to check the website to see if your degree qualifies. I have a BS in Computer Information Systems which is almost identical to the CS degree that I could have gotten. The difference was that it switched out some general classes and the foreign language requirement for business classes...which seemed like a good idea to me. Only the BS in CS was accredited. I also have an MS but the patent bar strictly cares about your BS.
- sreejithr 9y agowhy
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments?
- anfilt 9y agoWhile the American Bar Association certainly dose not use violence the whole system stinks like a protection racket. The fact they pushed states to enact a form regulatory capture is pretty messed up. Then add the fact apprenticeships are not the norm so these lawyers are not making as much. Overall, it's quite silly and sad.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- meddlepal 9y agoYes it's terrible the ABA has created a system that rigorously weeds out unqualified individuals, polices it's professional members ethics and uses education and testing to ensure all lawyers have a solid baseline education. Terrible! I wish software engineerers had an actual equivalent to the ABA, and no the ACM doesn't count.
- jachee 9y agoAll of those things would be fine, if there wasn't an explicit financial barrier that also weeds out otherwise-well-qualified individuals.
- anfilt 9y agoI was not implying letting unqualified individuals practice law. They still have to pass the bar apprentice. Are we seriously going to claim school is the only way people can learn? I would also like to see some certification for actual software engineers. Also wish that businesses would not be allowed cheap out and rush software development. Partly, why I prefer hardware. The timelines why still may be fast are more reasonable.
- meddlepal 9y agoThere is a fair bit more nuance to the law than just memorizing some stuff and passing a test. I have a couple close family members that are lawyers and their general thought is law school is: 1.) shaping a person's mind to be critical of presented facts and evidence. 2.) develop good skills in the art of arguing. 3.) develop good skills for legal research and dealing with changing laws. Personally, I am skeptical someone who has not gone to law school is going to be good at those things and that's why I think law school sets a high baseline and is a good thing even if it is expensive.
- Bromskloss 9y ago> “I have some clients who look up on my wall and say, ‘Where did you go to law school?’ and aren’t too happy with the answer.” Hehe, having your degree on display on the wall!
- pseingatl 9y agoFirst, this article only addresses the USA. If you don't want to practice in the US, there are lots of options. See Korshak, Landing a Legal Job Overseas. Law school is an American anomaly. In Canada/UK/Ireland, you can major in law as an undergraduate. You can't do so in the US. With a LLB degree, you can do legal work in lots of countries--and even qualify to take the bar in the U.S. The author leaves out little details like the "diploma privilege" in Mississippi and other Southern states--but never Florida--if you graduated from a state law school there was no need to take the bar exam. And during WWII time in law school was reduced or relaxed.
- jlos 9y agoNot true in Canada. Law degree's first require an Undergraduate degree prior to entrance into the law faculty: https://www.law.utoronto.ca/admissions/youth-outreach/so-you-want-become-lawyer https://www.law.utoronto.ca/admissions/youth-outreach/so-you...
- pseudolus 9y agoThat's not entirely correct. In Quebec, medicine and law are first degrees. The bulk of law and medicine graduates from French language universities do not have an undergraduate degree but rather enter with what is roughly equivalent to the first year of an undergraduate degree. Also, many English language universities accept applications from students who have completed the second or third year of their undergraduate degree.
- coldtea 9y agoDidn't work so well for Mike Ross.
- lucb1e 9y agoWho is Mike Ross? When searching such a common name (at least it sounds common to me, a non-native speaker), I see a politician, someone who got capital punishment, and a bunch of other people. Adding lawyer to the query doesn't seem to help.
- elthran 9y agoHe's referencing the main character of the TV show "Suits" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suits_(U.S._TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suits_(U.S._TV_series)
- coldtea 9y ago>Adding lawyer to the query doesn't seem to help. Maybe it's your search engine that's to blame? In Google the whole first page if full of relevant results when searching for either Mike Ross and Mike Ross lawyer.
- lucb1e 9y agoMaybe I wasn't looking for a TV show but for a Wikipedia article on a lawyer. Thanks to another comment I know now.
- beegeezuz 9y agoNext: Becoming a medical doctor without studying medicine
- maddy1512 9y agosomebody share this link with Mike Ross
- senatorobama 9y agoWho has switched from Software Engineering to Law? I'm considering it because of the lack of women in software engineering, and the multitudes in Law.
- VanL 9y agoI did, although I have never really given up engineering. Happy to help if you have questions. See my email in my profile.
- DannyBee 9y agoDon't trust this guy, now he just spends his time writing good books and speeches on open source law.
- atwebb 9y agoWell, Senator.... I'm neither a lawyer nor female, I am married to someone who is both and considered law initially (family of them). Are you missing working companionship or feel pushed out as a female in SW? Is there a specific type of law you'd like to go into, similar to medicine or even software, there's many many different paths. Best of luck, curious why you're looking at switching, I still flirt with it sometimes. Personally, I think the unreasonableness of some of the dealings/proceedings would irk me too much. It is very interesting though and the lawyers I know genuinely help better other people's lives, directly, while making a decent living.
- grepthisab 9y agoI did lightweight eng to law to heavyweight eng. It's really set me up (or at least changed peoples' perception of my skills) to do big picture stuff and make technical recommendations, like a CTO style role.
- peteypao 9y agoWhat's heavyweight eng?
- aseba 9y agoAre you telling me that everything that happened in SUITS could have been avoided if Michael Ross passed the bar in some other state?
- gnicholas 9y agoNo, he still would have had to apprentice for years...
- sk2104 9y agoIt's always interesting to hear discussions of the apprenticeship system in this day and age. Law school is an extremely valuable experience, but the problem is not all law degrees are created equal. A T14 (the top tier of schools) can employ the majority of their students into legal jobs, while a equally pricey, but less well known school could fail to employ even a small subset of their student population to JD-advantaged jobs (a job that makes use of one's law degree). Prospective law students today should aim to maximize their application strength, and take advantage of the plethora of scholarships given out at just about every reputable law school (excluding HYS). Furthermore, attending a reputable school gives students access to public interest programs within the schools that support their high debt-relatively low -income students.
- caffeine5150 9y agoI come from a family with several California lawyers (I am a lawyer as well) and see this transition from apprenticeship to law school in my family. My great, great uncle was a lawyer and a judge in a small town in the Bay Area. He never went to law school. His nephew, my grandfather, went to law school, but only needed a 2 year college degree to attend law school. He became the judge in the town after his uncle retired. Both were successful and well regarded professionally. Reading this article, it’s easy to conflate bar passage success with being an effective lawyer. Law school is probably better training for passing the bar than it is for practicing law. Thus, it wouldn’t surprise me that apprentices have lower passage rates than law school grads. Apprentices are training to practice – not to take tests. It is well understood among lawyers that law school may give you some discipline, some research skills, and some understanding about how to think about fundamental aspects of “the Law”, but that it doesn’t by itself result in being able to practice law. That happens over the course of about the first 5 years of practicing law. Becoming a lawyer or a doctor both take about 8-9 years, but with law, you do most of it out in practice. So in this sense, all lawyers are apprentices. Another thing that illustrates this point is the fact that a lawyer’s effectiveness has much less to do with the quality of their law school than is generally thought. I know many excellent attorneys who attended local law schools here in San Diego that do not rank well. What they did in their first 5 years (and other factors) mattered more than law school. I see the arc of the profession as one that used to be more tuned toward apprenticeship in the context of a much slower overall pace of business and life toward one where it is increasingly hard to access that critical one-the-job training. Historically, clients would essentially subsidize the training of new associate attorneys, but, particularly since the belt tightening post-2008, clients increasingly refuse to do so and many law grads are left to figure it out themselves. Some have rules that no attorneys with e.g. less than 3 years’ experience are allowed to work on their matters. Another challenge are the strict laws in California on unpaid internships. I would be happy to provide training to a new lawyer in exchange for some unpaid help and know many new attorneys who would jump at the chance, but that is not allowed in California.
- nkw 9y agoThis is a very insightful comment. In my opinion one of the largest shortcomings of our system of minting new lawyers is a lack of practical training. While doctors generally must both go to medical school and complete an internship and/or residency in order to treat patients, a freshly licensed lawyer can represent someone without previously having ever entered a courthouse, drafted a will, or taken a deposition. I think most recognize this is a problem and there are some law schools that are doing an excellent job of addressing the issue by requiring 3rd year practice court, externships, or clinics that actually give lawyers some experience in the things they will be doing after law school. Bar associations are trying to address the issue through mentor programs and CLEs aimed at new lawyers. No longer can the profession depend on mid to large law firms to bring lawyers up through the ranks, both because their clients aren't really interested in subsidizing it and the firms cannot or will not put in the resources to train all those entering the profession.
- technovader 9y agoThis is fascinating to me because of the parallels to my own experience. Getting a high paying career in IT without even a college diploma. I've always felt IT was one of the only industries where this can fly (merit based rewards vs paper based reward system). Almost every job I've got in this industry (support, cloud, TAM, solutions architect) had steep requirements on paper that I did not meet, yet I got the job.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoIt's not just merit-based rewards; it's the lack of a professional standards body. Anyone can call themselves an IT professional, but not everyone call themselves, e.g., a doctor or a civil engineer.
- pc2g4d 9y agoMakes me think of "The Captured Economy" https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-captured-economy-9780190627768?cc=us&lang=en& https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-captured-economy...