7 ms·
Amazon’s $23M book about flies (2011)
- jjeaff 9y agoI think this no longer happens. Amazon seems to have implemented an algorithm that suspends listings whose price is too far out of range. Even by a hundred or so dollars in some cases.
- ikeboy 9y agoAs a seller: Yes, sometimes they'll suspend an offer if they think it's a mistake, they send a pricing notification. However, it's easy to relist at that price if you really want to, you just need to put a min and Max price in their system, and as long as your price is in between they'll accept it. The reason for this is if sellers make a fat finger mistake, so it makes sense they have a way to override. Separately, they sometimes suppress the buy box if the price is over MSRP or more than other retailers. For a current example, see https://www.amazon.com/CollEGGtibles-12-Pack-Egg-Carton-Season/dp/B06X9P3Y8V/ https://www.amazon.com/CollEGGtibles-12-Pack-Egg-Carton-Seas... You can still buy, it just shows up as other sellers and needs an extra step to purchase. And it definitely hurts conversions, as I have seen on products I sell.
- exikyut 9y agoI'm curious how you found this example. I don't expect Amazon make it easy to query/list this sort of thing.
- ikeboy 9y agoI knew hatchimals were a popular toy that sometimes had more demand than supply, so I searched for it and went through the results till I found one that was suppressed. I actually have a database with tens of millions of asins that I have used in the past to generate lists of such items, but I just needed one example so didn't bother using it for this.
- ikeboy 9y agoAnd if you check now, you'll see Amazon is back in stock and it's no longer a good example.
- homero 9y agoOh I've always wondered by the other sellers thing happens!
- icantdrive55 9y agoI just saw a watch repair book for $98,900 a few days ago. I see outrageous prices all the time.
- gizmo686 9y agoI just noticed something simmilar to this [0], with three sellers offering a book for $1,499.95 (new), $1,634.06 (used), $3,361.91 (used) (plus shipping, of course). The book itself has other listings, such as [1] for as low as $14.76 used, or [2] for $37.28 new [0] https://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/B015X4RCD0/ref=sr_1_3_olp?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1517096469&sr=1-3&keywords=English+Words%3A+A+Linguistic+Introduction+by+Heidi+Harley https://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/B015X4RCD0/ref=sr_1_... [1] https://www.amazon.com/English-Words-Linguistic-Introduction-2006-05-12/dp/B01NH09YOM/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1517096469&sr=1-2&keywords=English+Words%3A+A+Linguistic+Introduction+by+Heidi+Harley https://www.amazon.com/English-Words-Linguistic-Introduction... [2] https://www.amazon.com/English-Words-Introduction-Heidi-Harley/dp/0631230327/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1517096469&sr=1-1&keywords=English+Words%3A+A+Linguistic+Introduction+by+Heidi+Harley https://www.amazon.com/English-Words-Introduction-Heidi-Harl...
- 1984 9y agoIn 2018, Amazon Own Brand Products will come out of the shadows Amazon has discreetly developed more than forty own brands. 29 of them belong to the textile world, an area where Amazon excels. According to industry experts, Amazon is expected to accentuate this private label strategy in 2018. A way for the e-commerce giant to offer exclusive products while optimizing its costs. more details here https://www.mjobrr.com/2018-amazon-brand-products-will-come-shadows/ https://www.mjobrr.com/2018-amazon-brand-products-will-come-...
- 0x0 9y agoSo if the one seller counts on being able to buy the other seller's book if the first seller actually makes a sale, what happens if someone buys both listings at the same time and the higher priced listing is unable to source the item? Can the seller just cancel the sale for no fee? Why wouldn't everyone with a little time on their hands make 1.2x-priced listings for every single item available for sale on amazon and dropship from the cheaper listings?
- yomly 9y agoEnjoyed this read, reading the comments section makes me wonder how many people have silently made money over the years arb'ing out-of-whack algorithms such as this. Also reminds me of local competitor retailers exploiting Amazon's policies + algorithms to incur cost at Amazon: Amazon promises the lowest price for game pre-orders, and retailers would deliberately drop the price for a game hours before launch, forcing Amazon to honour the low price for all pre-orderers.
- fwdpropaganda 9y ago> arb'ing out-of-whack algorithms How would you arb this?
- agumonkey 9y agoarb means arbitrage ?
- dmoy 9y agoYes
- leereeves 9y agoIf there's only two copies on offer and you believe the higher priced seller is planning to buy from the other: Buy the book from the lower priced seller, list it for sale at a much higher price, and order it from the higher priced seller before they change the price. I wouldn't risk a million dollars on that strategy, though.
- kakarot 9y agoWould a good tip-off be that the higher-priced seller won't have two-day shipping enabled?
- patch_collector 9y agoNot necessarily -- if the first seller has it enabled, the second seller would just order it to be shipped directly from the first seller to the buyer, and never have it touch their inventory. Fun story! A family member wanted to buy an air-fryer online. She found it on Walmart's site, then found it for $20 more on amazon. At first she tried to buy it from Walmart, but got frustrated with the process (setting up an account and stuff) and so she just went and paid the extra to order it from amazon. A few days later, she gets an air fryer in a Walmart box! At first she's super confused, and thought she'd mistakenly bought it from Walmart, so she went to cancel it from Amazon, and saw that that one had already arrived. What had happened was the Amazon seller was getting orders on their page, then immediately going to Walmart, ordering the fryer, then shipping it directly to the recipient. Kinda genius. Basically no overhead, no stock, just acting as a hidden walmart portal and pocketing a percentage.
- dantillberg 9y agoThis makes me wonder if it might be possible, for certain commodities, to buy out the entire market (across all retail websites) and immediately offer the items for resale at a higher price in order to expose naked offers. Though unlike doing the same on commodities exchanges, it would probably never be a profitable enterprise, as these naked sellers will simply cancel orders they can't fill.
- shawnz 9y ago> these naked sellers will simply cancel orders they can't fill. And risk the negative feedback?
- paulcole 9y agoThey won’t get negative feedback but run a very real risk of getting booted off the platform. Preshipment Order Cancellation is a big part of the Order Defect Rate. Let that get too high and you won’t be selling on Amazon again. In most cases it’s worth taking a loss on an order to avoid canceling it.
- ikeboy 9y agoI've bought Amazon out on some items when they have a sale and then sold later for a profit. The best items to do this on is discontinued items that will still be in demand, as you can sure that eventually there will be no stock. Or when they have a significant sale on items that still sell reasonably well at regular price. The significant shipping fees for reselling mean you need to have a large discount. You also have costs of returns, storage, etc. You typically want a minimum of 15-20% gross ROI after those fees. For example, I've bought shavers at $180 and resold at $290-$300, from Amazon and on Amazon.
- amelius 9y agoI appreciate the frankness, but this is a lot like the usurious trade of concert tickets: not a very noble thing to do, to make an understatement.
- dang 9y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2475854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2475854. 2015: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10289742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10289742
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI found the first discussion before posting, but I figured after 7 years there would be enough people who hadn't seen it the first time around to warrant a new post. Is that not OK? I didn't notice the second conversation. If I had, I'd probably not have re-posted it so soon. Edit: Actually, I can't find the 2015 conversation in the search.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoRe-posting is fine here really, as long as it's innocent (!). The system the site runs on actually has an automated re-poster AIUI that puts stories back on to the front page if it looks like they missed out on the attention they deserved. It seems the couple of mods have the power to change the placement of stories at will too, not sure, moderation is opaque here.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> Re-posting is fine here really, as long as it's innocent (!). Well, I mean. Obviously I noticed that the first posting of the story had a very high upvote count. But I was going to post it anyway by that point (I got the story from another article I read today on HN, discussed in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16243067 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16243067, and thought it would definitely be interesting). I can see that being an exploitable tactic (search for very old articles with high number of votes) but not "by hand"- one would have to scrape HN for that sort of thing to work. I digress- I don't know how I'd prove my post was "innocent". I do try to maximise my karma so the high upvote count on the original story was definitely a motive. I try to use karma as a guide for what to post. Not that it's working :)
- Animats 9y agoThere was someone who saw his own product being resold at a higher price. So he placed an order with the reseller while substantially raising the price of his own product. They had to buy from him at a big loss or take a hit on their reputation.
- jshap70 9y agoI feel like this is illegal... not sure specifically for what though. maybe racketeering?
- jmaygarden 9y agoWhich part do you think is illegal? Reselling at a higher price like that is called arbitrage, and it is perfectly legal.
- Shamiq 9y agoThat's neat -- similar to a short squeeze.
- javajosh 9y agoClever. Would only work if the offending seller didn't already have inventory, but the downside (temporarily depressed sales) is not very large.
- WhyNotHugo 9y agoThis is a very common scam in Eve Online. A buy order for an extremely rare item in one place, and slightly cheaper sell order elsewhere. People notice this, and try to buy the item, intending to move it and sell, but as soon as it's sold, the buy order disappears.
- masonic 9y agoSuch speculation happens in a lot of resale marketplaces. Stubhub, for example, allows speculative selling (selling tickets you don't have). There are "brokers" who see tickets listed elsewhere (like Ticketexchange), create mirror listings on Stubhub at a higher price, then buy the tickets from the other site if they get an order. That's why you can see +/-40% of listings vanish from a Stubhub event page at the 4-hour-before-start mark -- sellers generally have to pre-fill listings after that. If an order is placed and the tickets don't exist (or the seller can't get them at a price that allows profit after all and chooses to flake out), Stubhub can just refund the buyer and wash their hands of it. Easy peasy.
- JaggedJax 9y agoThe author makes the assumption that some buyers will pick the higher rated seller. This can certainly happen, but almost everyone buys from whichever seller Amazon puts in the buy box and so this would lead to virtually zero sales. However the buy box does not always list the cheapest price. Amazon uses seller rating as a large portion of the decision of who gets that buy box. By having a better seller rating and a higher price, Amazon will sometimes give you the buy box and you will get the sale. So in the end this method works not because the buyer is shrewd with regards to seller ratings, but because Amazon doesn't always suggest the lowest price. If you always want the best price you need to click through to look at all sellers.
- snowpanda 9y agoLooks like its on sale :P https://smile.amazon.com/Making-Fly-Genetics-Animal-Design/dp/0632030488/ https://smile.amazon.com/Making-Fly-Genetics-Animal-Design/d...
- joering2 9y ago> But Peter Lawrence can now comfortably boast that one of the biggest and most respected companies on Earth valued his great book at $23,698,655.93 (plus $3.99 shipping). I was wondering if pricing on Amazon would be sufficient evidence to get into a Guinness World Records for the most expensive book offered in public??
- Johnny555 9y agoIf there is such a category, then I think they'd have to actually sell it at that price, otherwise an author could just put his book up on eBay with a billion dollar starting price.
- nathanvanfleet 9y agoI've noticed this on Amazon. I searched for a fiber supplement which I buy at Walgreens for 22$. One day I saw it for sale on Amazon for 15$! So I put it in a wishlist and waited. When it came time to buy it the price had changed to 30$, which was of course more expensive that going down the street. It was really strange. I have kept it in my wishlist and the price has gone between $20-$30 and the price seems different every time I look, sometimes up, sometimes down. It's kind of mind boggling but I think I'll stick with my local Walgreens.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThere are probably all sorts of arbitrage scams that make things look weird. For example I could imagine you could get in to baskets and lists by having a low price whilst not having product available to ship; then increase the price: sufficient buyers don't want to search again so you sell at the higher price fulfilling the order by purchasing from the lower priced seller ..? Amazon probably can't pick up all such systems, possibly they don't even try for low grossing sellers??
- thaumasiotes 9y agoWho says it's a scam? Most things fluctuate in price. Amazon themselves sold me this sapphire ring ( https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00OJ2BS10/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00OJ2BS10/ ) for $6. As I type this, they're charging $35 for it. It's the same product and the same vendor; the price varies intentionally.
- JasonFruit 9y agoI wrote a hymnal[1], and currently Amazon has a copy for sale at double the price of a new copy from my website. That put me in the unusual position of leaving a three-star review of my own book. I sell the book as nearly at cost+shipping as possible, as I don't want to profit off a religious book — but that doesn't mean I want someone else to profit off it, either. [1]: http://olpbhtb.com http://olpbhtb.com
- exikyut 9y agoBased on the other replies in this subthread, I think it's safe to say the following link won't be used to order. But I was very curious what the Amazon listing contained nonetheless, so: https://www.amazon.com/B06W56HNPQ https://www.amazon.com/B06W56HNPQ
- duiker101 9y agocould you sell it on amazon yourself for the same price you have it on your website? That would discourage anyone to sell it for a profit
- JasonFruit 9y agoHonestly, it's not worth the time for me to do that; it mostly sells by word of mouth. I'd rather say, "I wouldn't recommend buying it this way," and let people carry on doing as they wish. I'm not that worked up about controlling others' behavior.
- hakanensari 9y agoYou have no ISBN, right? It's fascinating that this bookseller took the time to create by hand an entry for your book in Amazon's product database. In a way, not even not having an ISBN is a sure way to "withdraw from the international book trade"[1]. [1]: http://www.anagrambooks.com/no-isbn http://www.anagrambooks.com/no-isbn
- JasonFruit 9y ago
- Vibrelli 9y agoI'm an Amazon Seller myself - the reason that other sellers add to the listing with products for sale (with crazy price), is they get access to all the metrics on the listing, traffic, conversion rate etc etc. It's a ploy to get access to the sales data.
- hawktheslayer 9y agoI like how they were still charging $3.99 for shipping. Maybe Amazon can implement Excel's useful circular reference warning (/s)
- k_f 9y agoFor anyone wondering where that weird 1.27059 factor comes from: Amazon takes 15% commission (+ a fixed commission fee) for book sales. 1.27059 * 0.85 = 1.08(00015), so (practically) exactly 8% price difference (or possible profit margin).
- DrScump 9y agoTo be fair, the Kindle version is only $4.3M.