16 ms·
Why Tesla's autopilot can't see a stopped firetruck
- altotrees 9y agoSo I read this and cannot help but wonder if we really are 5 years away from a massive sea change. People think truck drivers could be obsolete in 5 years time, the bullish ones anyway. The tech is still developing. We may be in a bit of a hype bubble, but it is as real and clear as it has ever been. I think even as the tech advances rapidly, public acceptance will be way further out than 5, 10 or 15 years. I would venture to say self-driving cars and truck fleets being normalized is 30 years away and in no way because of the tech, but due to all the red tape and public debate that will encase the issue. If you think all truck drivers are going to be displaced in 5 or even 10 years, you may be living in an HN bubble. Sure jobs will be automated away, but this is going to take more time than lots of people think. For instance, one article like this could delay acceptance for months or years, in my opinion.
- cybwraith 9y agoMy take on it as far as truck drivers is that the pay for truck drivers (as they are today) will likely drop as the skill required to drive one drops from partial automation. Similar to how airline pilots of today's advanced jets are typically only "needed" during taxi, take-off, and landing.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoEven once the problem is "solved", there's still an entire industry, one of the biggest, to turn around. Right now we still don't even get software updates for our head units in our car in most cases. As technology improves, how will self-driving cars adapt? We change out our phones every couple years, but may car is five years old and I'm just about to finish paying it off. With a decade being a reasonable replacement cycle for a car, how will the car technology keep pace? Surely people aren't going to start buying iCars as often as they replace iPhones. Even if you adopted a service-only module for the industry, it's not like driving services will want to replace their entire fleet every two years. Will cars have some sort of "technology package" including the computer and some of the sensor modules that can be made plug-and-play removable so you can upgrade your car?
- rsynnott 9y ago> People think truck drivers could be obsolete in 5 years time, the bullish ones anyway. I'm not sure how many people _really_ think that; it's pure fantasy. To be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if they're not obsolete in 20 years. AI stuff has a tendency to get nearly good enough quite quickly, and then improve very little more for decades afterwards.
- ghaff 9y ago>AI stuff has a tendency to get nearly good enough quite quickly, and then improve very little more for decades afterwards. What tends to happen is that some approach, deep learning in the current case, turns out to be very effective for a class of problems. But it turns out that it only gets you, say, 90 percent of the way there to being truly useful in the real world. And there isn't an obvious way to get you the other 10 percent.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis is... as the article says... unsettling. I think it's safe to say Autopilot was enabled. Tesla has never waited to rush out and state that the car's driver was lying and that their system didn't screw up. Presumably they will still blame the driver for not paying enough attention, but as the article says, not being able to detect a stopped emergency vehicle is a pretty giant gaping flaw.
- oxygen0211 9y agoYes, totally, although their reasoning that they must ignore stationary objects to avoid too many false positives sounds pretty reasonable to me. Also, on the other hand not being able to recognize that your car is about to slam into a stopped emergency vehicle is also a giant gaping flaw on the driver's side. Disclaimer to put my last statement into perspective: I have absolutely no relation to Tesla except for being a potential future customer. However I am driving a decent stretch daily and get to experience first person many stupid things people do in their cars due to ignorance/not paying attention/whatever, also I often use the adaptive cruise control of my Audi which shows me quite some false positives and restrictions (such as not letting itself deactivate below 15mph, heck, even deactivating itself without previous notification)
- dx034 9y agoBut how should fully automated driving without lidar ever work then? To me it sounds like the first supplier of a small and affordable lidar system will make a lot of money and everyone not using it will lose out.
- oxygen0211 9y agoOf course, this needs to be fixed in one way or the other to achieve fully autonomous cars, as many others like destinguishing red traffic lights from other red lights. But that's why nobody calls it fully autonomous yet. What always boggles me about such news is that people rely so much on these systems and apparently people drift away that they even don't notice an f*ing big red fire truck standing in their way. I often drive with dynamic cruise control (radar based, only keeping distance, breaking and speeding up, no steering), but I am in many situations in which I think "I need full control here" and temporarily disable it. Also, there are many situations where I don't use it in the first place because I know the way it functions is bringing downsides, such as driving on multi-lane roads (read: german Autobahn) since it will hold exactly that much distance to the car infront of me that every idiot will cut in, causing cruise control to decelerate to leave a bigger gap, rinse, repeat.
- alistproducer2 9y agoThe fact that this flaw is known and in production gives credence to some of the AI experts who are saying level 5 is waaaaay further away than we are being led to believe.
- dx034 9y agoIt's not a problem with lidar according to the article. Everyone except for Tesla works with lidar. So the question is just when the systems are cheap and small enough for everyday use. AI doesn't appear to be the issue here, just the data input.
- sambe 9y agoThe article explicitly states that at least Volvo has a similar warning in their manual.
- dx034 9y agoAvailable cars are not fully self-driving. I think this year only Audi will release one where the car takes full control on motorways. All others require you to remain vigilant. If you sell a self-driving car you can't put warnings like this in the manual since the manufacturer is on the hook if anything happens during self-driving (at least if it was the car's fault).
- tobltobs 9y agoIs Volvo already building lidar sensors into their public available cars?
- Symmetry 9y agoVolvo also relies on just radar and a camera. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_cruise_control_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_cruise_control_syst... I don't expect scanning lidar sensors to become common here until solid state scanning lidars reach mass production.
- taco_emoji 9y ago
- BugsJustFindMe 9y ago> Radar knows the speed of any object it sees, and is also simple, cheap, robust, and easy to build into a front bumper. But it also detects lots of things a car rolling down the highway needn't worry about, like overhead highway signs, loose hubcaps, or speed limit signs. So engineers make a choice, telling the car to ignore these things and keep its eyes on the other cars on the road: They program the system to focus on the stuff that's moving. So these car-mounted radar systems can't detect how large an object is or where it is in relation to the road? I don't get how they can be used at all then. That can't be true, right? Because if you can tell how large something is, then the hubcap is out. And if you can tell where something is in relation to the vehicle and/or road, then the signs are out. I mean, hell, the most maniacal situation of climbing a steep hill with clearance under a sign that you just can't see because the sign happens to be mounted just after the rise, which probably doesn't exist anywhere in the world, would be out by other factors, like knowing that you're going up a steep hill. So it really sounds like the only thing left is just not being able to tell how large something is, which sounds wild. > This unsettling compromise may be better than nothing People frequently find disappointment to be worse than nothing.
- Filligree 9y agoThere are physical limits to how good a radar's resolution can be, set by the properties of the radio waves used. Those make it really difficult to detect small size differences -- relative to the radar's wavelength -- though, not quite impossible. It's why everyone else uses lidar instead, or in addition. Really, it has the same limits, but the wavelength of visible light is small enough that they're only an issue for microscopes.
- Someone1234 9y agoThat's why many (most?) other vehicle manufacturers use cameras instead of radar. You physically see what the driver would physically see and react how the driver would react with the same information (just faster). See Subaru, Toyota, Honda, etc. I'm not sure why this article and this discussion seemingly act like the predominant technology used in automatic braking systems doesn't exist?
- dzdt 9y agoI guess the output of the radar is basically a list of relative velocities for nearby large objects, paired with distance and rough direction to those objects. There is always a large object essentially all around you moving with the same relative velocity as your speed : the ground. And there are often other large fixed objects (overhead signs, overpasses, etc) which appear roughly dead ahead. Radar is just a very limited sensor!
- jasode 9y ago>These systems are designed to ignore static obstacles because otherwise, they couldn't work at all. >But it also detects lots of things a car rolling down the highway needn't worry about, like overhead highway signs, loose hubcaps, or speed limit signs. So engineers make a choice, telling the car to ignore these things and keep its eyes on the other cars on the road: They program the system to focus on the stuff that's moving. I don't know about the sensors on today's semi-autonomous cars but it seems like there's already enough data there to prioritize collision avoidance over forward motion. It seems like the Wired story is very incomplete about the details. It needs a more "Ars Technica" in depth treatment or more ideally, an actual Tesla engineer to explain the self-driving computer's decision tree. How do today's sensors that advertise their ability to "maintain distance" between cars work? What's the difference between the following to scenarios to the front-mounted sensor? - 60mph Tesla slamming into a slow-moving road cleaning vehicle at 20mph - 40mph Tesla slamming into a stopped vehicle at 0 mph. Isn't the ongoing computation of dy/dx to determine a "safe" gap between cars the same? EDIT to summarize replies with a possible technical explanation... The resolution of the radar sensor treats overhead signs (like highway signs[1]) as being on the "same 2-dimensional plane" as cars directly in front of you. This would generate false positives. It's not 3D radar which would yield spherical data inputs of impending collisions. Without 3D data, you can't write a rule that ignores objects not 0 degrees in front of the car. The resolution of radar treats surface level signs (such as the double-arrow[2] at T intersections) as being the same harmless mass as a stationary car. The low resolution cannot distinguish between the shape/footprint of small signs that are supposed to be there vs (large) stationary cars that are not. This object categorization requires LIDAR instead of radar. Therefore, programming an unambiguous algorithm to prioritize "collision avoidance" is not possible with the current radar sensors. Is that an accurate summary of the technical limitations? [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=overhead+green+highway+signs&source=lnms&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=overhead+green+highway+signs... [2] https://www.google.com/search?q=2+direction+traffic+sign+double+arrow&source=lnms&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=2+direction+traffic+sign+dou...
- ZoFreX 9y agoThe difference is (according to the article) that there is an abundance of objects at 0mph - signs, litter, barriers - so the system filters all of these out to avoid constantly braking. There is no such abundance of ignorable items going at 20mph.
- woliveirajr 9y ago> "a stationary vehicle or object is in front of you instead" So it isn't that Tesla and volvo don't see a stationaty vehicle: they might not see objects as well. Evil plan: you, in the front car, drive against a wall, and turn in the last second to avoid the collision. The autopilot behind you will accelerate against the wall. Evil plan 2: you, in the front car, see a car/truck stopped in the lane. You waint until the last second to turn and avoid collision, the autopilot behind you will accelerate against it and crash.
- dx034 9y agoIsn't "blinding" self-driving cars with radio waves much more dangerous? Not sure how today's systems work in that case. But for a fully self-driving car, losing radars would probably cause emergency breaking.
- melling 9y agoThis has been debated for years. https://insideevs.com/elon-musk-tesla-doesnt-need-lidar-will-tweak-radar-to-be-lidar-like/ https://insideevs.com/elon-musk-tesla-doesnt-need-lidar-will... https://9to5google.com/2015/10/16/elon-musk-says-that-the-lidar-google-uses-in-its-self-driving-car-doesnt-make-sense-in-a-car-context/ https://9to5google.com/2015/10/16/elon-musk-says-that-the-li...
- DiThi 9y agoIIRC Model S only has cameras while Model 3 also has radars (maybe in response to the first death with autopilot, which didn't see a white truck against white sky).
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoYes, my 2017 Subaru with EyeSight behaves this way. A couple of other scenarios when adaptive cruise is on: cars changing lanes into the lane ahead of me at short distances do not cause it to react quickly enough. It seems there's too much lag in the time to capture the interloper; and, if I'm approaching a car quickly that is moving much slower than I and I signal a lane change but don't execute it, I'll collide with the slower car. (or so it seems to me, the system did not slow down and I had to apply the brake to avoid colliding). Another related problem with vision-based systems, these random type of road artifacts that fool the system. This image shows a false left-side lane marker (formed by a partial re-paving and the shadow cast by the center barrier). It sounded a lane departure alert. If the car were autonomous, it likely would have swerved right trying to center: https://imgur.com/a/KnsXU https://imgur.com/a/KnsXU
- stevenwoo 9y agoThat last situation gives me problems - my least favorite is that combined with jersey barriers so the old marking goes straight into the jersey barriers versus the new marking.
- xya3453 9y agoApparently the driver of the Tesla didn't have time to react to the firetruck as their field of view was obscured by a large pick-up truck that changed lanes seconds beforehand. If Tesla's autopilot can't detect upcoming stationary objects, it should in the very least keep enough distance between itself and the vehicle ahead in order to allow the human at the wheel to have an unobscured view of the road ahead.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>Apparently the driver of the Tesla didn't have time to react to the firetruck as their field of view was obscured by a large pick-up truck that changed lanes seconds beforehand. That changes the story a lot, do you know where you got that information?
- xya3453 9y agohttps://as.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/7s9b9p/tesla_allegedly_on_autopilot_hits_firetruck_with/dt7fgq6/ https://as.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/7s9b9p/tesla_al...
- Someone1234 9y agoSo unverified, and if verified the auto-pilot system was following dangerously closely?
- tbirrell 9y agoI was in a crash some time ago where the car in front of me jumped out of the way because the guy in front of him was at a dead stop. A "safe distance" for following a car that will have to decelerate to stop moving is a lot different if you are approaching a stationary object. It's not fair to expect either a human or computer to meet the latter standard on a highway were you expect everything to be moving at a speed close to the speed limit. There is a reason you can get a ticket for driving too slow.
- jws 9y ago
- adav 9y agoWhy doesn't the camera system take over from the radar sensor to spot the stopped vehicle?
- tomxor 9y ago> And it's not much of a problem if every human in a semi-autonomous vehicle followed the automakers' explicit, insistent instructions to pay attention at all times, and take back control if they see a stationary vehicle up ahead. While their technical reasoning is fine... this statement shows a complete failure of reasoning about human beings and UX. In essence they are asking people to stay alert without being active, this is actually really fucking hard to do as a human being. Noticing an object that needs to be avoided while you are already actively engaged in driving is easy, you are naturally alert and there is no "intervention time" because there is nothing to intervene with. Trying to achieve the same level of response while letting a machine drive kind of defeats the purpose of letting the machine drive. Yes I'm basically making the argument that semi-autonomous driving is not safe. Make it fully autonomous or not at all. Two modes, keep it simple, because human concentration is complex.
- jacquesm 9y agoThere are mountains of evidence to back this up, quite a bit of it stems from the problem of keeping airline pilots engaged and alert while the autopilot functions as it should.
- ghaff 9y agoAnd people deskill when they don't get enough practice as well. I know I got better over time as a driver and it wasn't just because I wasn't a teenager any longer. It's easy to imagine we'll end up with a lot of people on the roads with not-quite autonomous systems who actually haven't actively driven all that much.
- rsynnott 9y agoApparently some airlines now encourage pilots to do certain tasks that the autopilot can and normally would do from time to time, to avoid this.
- aaronmdjones 9y ago
- devit 9y agoWhy not just have a system that produces a full 3D model of the surroundings and their velocity (using something like doppler radar) and then just do a geometric computation in 4D spacetime to find out a path that doesn't intersect with the trajectory of anything? (assuming their speed is unchanged) That should prevent all such trivial accidents and allows to actually mathematically prove that the software works, as it should be required for such a critical system. Machine learning can be added for object detection to allow more sophisticated trajectory prediction.
- Crespyl 9y agoIndeed, "why not just"; I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not. I'll assume the latter: Even if you were able to perfectly maintain an accurate 3D model of the surrounding geometry (and associated trajectory of all moving objects), it doesn't mean you have enough information to make 100% accurate predictions. For example, a frozen over road often has very nearly exactly the same physical geometry and color, but extremely different behavior to cars trying to drive on it. Other weather effects like fog or snow bring their own challenges. You're right though, that precise and accurate 3D models do do a lot to make driving easier and more correct, the problem is that the hardware necessary to produce those models is still very expensive (LIDAR). Most (all?) of the advanced self-driving prototype cars use LIDAR, while Tesla has decided that they can do without for their consumer models, sticking with just the simpler and less expensive RADAR and cameras. In theory, Tesla's right, since humans get by just fine with only two "cameras", but we're clearly a long way from automating that level of performance.
- devit 9y agoUsing multiple separate emitters and detectors it should be possible to determine how every point reflects light (i.e. sample its BRDF for a limited angular range and set of wavelengths), which should allow to distinguish at least between a limited set of materials such as snow, solid ice, liquid water and asphalt. Cameras alone seems unsuitable, since it doesn't seem possible to make a camera-based system that works correctly all the time, ideally provably so, as required for a life-critical system.
- Symmetry 9y agoI'm sort of surprised that the camera wasn't able to identify an object based on visual flow, unless this happened at night?
- jVinc 9y ago> Tesla didn't confirm the car was running Autopilot at the time of the crash" That essentially means that it was. If it wasn't they would have denied it and released data. > but its manual does warn that the system is ill-equipped to handle this exact sort of situation: “Traffic-Aware Cruise Control cannot detect all objects and may not brake/decelerate for stationary vehicles, especially in situations when you are driving over 50 mph (80 km/h) and a vehicle you are following moves out of your driving path and a stationary vehicle or object is in front of you instead. Just for those unaware of Teslas previous handling of other crashes, this is them waving a huge flag saying "We fucked up and we know it". I wonder how that call went "Hi Tesla, my self-driving car just drove head-on into a stationary firetruck" "Ohh... did you read the manual? It's supposed to do that, so it's basically your fault!"
- joekrill 9y ago> That essentially means that it was. If it wasn't they would have denied it and released data. What kind of ridiculous, half-assed logic is that? There could be any number of reasons they can't confirm this yet. I haven't officially confirmed I'm not an alien being from a far away planet -- so that must mean I am one!
- mdavidn 9y agoTesla owners using the Autopilot feature on the freeway is far more likely than you being extraterrestrial.
- toast0 9y agoBased on past experience, Tesla PR tends to respond within 24 hours to push the blame on their customer. In the court of public opinion, a change in behavior like this is a pretty good indication.
- nkkollaw 9y agoI understand that these systems must ignore stationary objects or they'd break all of a sudden at every road sign you encounter, but is there no way to tell a road sign (albeit a big one) from a fire truck that is 20 times bigger than a road sign, and 2-3 times bigger than your car? No one is going to pay that much attention if your car is on auto-pilot. That's just how people are, no matter what's written on the manual (which no one reads).
- Retric 9y agoRoad signs are huge. Also the problem is a road sign or overpass over a crest of a hill. It's stationary directly in front of you, the road simply curves away. EX: Here is a car in-front of a road sign. http://iowahighwayends.net/ends/June06/16/34exit263_99_halfmi.jpg http://iowahighwayends.net/ends/June06/16/34exit263_99_halfm... We assume the sign is not on the actual road, and the software makes the same assumption. It's just not always true. EX2: https://i.pinimg.com/736x/f7/11/eb/f711ebb462449a422151daab63f3fa1c--chesapeake-bay-bridge-west-virginia.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/736x/f7/11/eb/f711ebb462449a422151daab6... again perfectly safe but it looks like a static object blocking the road up ahead.
- nkkollaw 9y ago> Road signs are huge. As big as a fire truck, and in the middle of the street, at the same level as your car!? > Also the problem is a road sign or overpass over a crest of a hill. It's stationary directly in front of you, the road simply curves away. Isn't the autopilot aware of where the street is, and knows that you are not going to hit it? I'm not convinced. Of course, I know there are a lot of much-smarter-than-me people working on this for years, but I still don't get it.
- Retric 9y agoSize varies, but it's not unusual for them to be 10 feet tall and 20 feet wide. They can also be stack on top of each other or be placed side to side. To give an idea individual letters can be 16" tall. http://onlinemanuals.txdot.gov/txdotmanuals/fsh/images/Figure%204-10.gif http://onlinemanuals.txdot.gov/txdotmanuals/fsh/images/Figur... And sizes are rounded to nearest 1/2 foot.
- mattlondon 9y agoFor a 65mph crash into a stationary object, that looks like fairly light damage considering! Isn't this precisely the scenario that automatic emergency braking systems are designed to prevent? The article suggests that no system can handle this, but the EuroNCAP system specifically tests cars driving at up to 80kph (~50mph) into a stationary vehicle (https://youtu.be/AJ4WXgWaNgs?t=2m40s https://youtu.be/AJ4WXgWaNgs?t=2m40s protocol: https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/32278/euro-ncap-aeb-c2c-test-protocol-v201.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/32278/euro-ncap-aeb-c2c-test-...) Is this sort of safety equipment not a "thing" in the US? It looks like AEB is not fitted to the model S in the EU as standard. https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/tesla/model-s/7897 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/tesla/model-s/7897 (expand safety assist section - no AEB listed, c.f. XC90 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/volvo/xc90/20976 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/volvo/xc90/20976) I wonder if AEB was installed and activated in this crash, despite what the cruise control was doing? Surely it must have done otherwise I'd have expected significantly more damage, particularly to the fire truck getting a 2t lump slamming into it @ 65mph?!
- Symmetry 9y agoPresumably when the car got within a certain distance of the firetruck the cone of the radar was narrow enough that the radar could tell that the truck was definitely in the road and triggered braking - too late to avoid a collision but early enough to slow down some.
- ajmurmann 9y agoLast year or so there was a article about what sounds like exactly the same problem with radar. Overhead traffic signs and very reflective small objects confusing it. The argument was that Tesla is in a great position to deal with it because they have so much human driver data. If humans keep driving through the giant obstacle it's probably not a problem. Apparently Tesla instead decided to ignore the problem...
- rexreed 9y agoIsn't the solution some sort of collision avoidance system that is used in airplanes? Or perhaps as a stop gap, some sort of add-on (passive?) device for operators of vehicles that are frequently stopped can use to signal to autopilot vehicles that they are an obstruction to be avoided? It's a hack, but perhaps a necessary one?
- mikelbring 9y agoI think we need some sorta public domain tech that allows car sensors to talk to each other real time.
- yAnonymous 9y agoThe amazing thing here is the "no injuries" part in a frontal crash at 65 mph.
- tbirrell 9y agoI think this shows that autopilot won't truly be a thing until the cars start talking to each other. If the firetruck was broadcasting a stationary signal, the autopilot would not have to relay of cameras and radar to figure out what is where.
- herodotus 9y agoI have Adaptive Cruise Control on my VW Golf, and I must say that I preferred my old Honda Accord vanilla cruise control. I found with the old system that I could relax if the road ahead was fairly clear. If car changed lanes in front of me, I immediately touched the brake, which disabled cruise control. I could relax and yet know I could regain control immediately. Even before reading this article, I have not been able to relax with my new automatic cruise control. The problem is that I don't have a solid intuition for it - so instead of relaxing, I remain nervous and alert while it is on. In reality, I use it way less than I used the vanilla system.
- michrassena 9y agoWhat is the safety record for semi-autonomous cars per mile driven? I worry that even if it's better than human piloted vehicles, progress could be short-circuited by the fact that since this is a novel technology, it makes the news every time an accident occurs. On the other hand, while it seems that we're on the cusp of an autonomous vehicle revolution, and we'll see commercial use adopting early, consumers are going to be wary. The failure modes are very different than what drivers are used to. The systems appear "dumb" and make mistakes that humans rarely do. I see more promise in the short term for collision avoidance systems, or other systems which augment the driver's ability. For example anti-lock brakes have been an almost complete win, almost to the point of invisible ubiquity. I'd love to have something on-board my car that can help me safely avoid hitting a deer at 75mph.
- ghaff 9y ago>I'd love to have something on-board my car that can help me safely avoid hitting a deer at 75mph. I wouldn't hold my breath for that. Faster reflexes notwithstanding, automated systems don't change the laws of physics. If anything, I'd expect a human--at least during daylight hours--would be more likely to notice a deer at the side of the road and react accordingly before they ran in front of the car.
- projektfu 9y agoThe problem with Autopilot is the name and the marketing. Tesla markets it as more advanced than other systems, which is not true, and the name suggests to people that it is a more or less self-driving vehicle, which they are encouraged to believe with the Summon feature as well. The responsible thing for Tesla (and other adaptive CC makers) to do is to do studies on how many people feel safe browsing the web when they enable their cruise mode. If it is significant at all, it is a sign that they should perhaps disable these modes of operation or make them require more activity from the user.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoI don’t know the tech well, but the article doesn’t explain why it can’t differentiate between say, a sign post on the side of the road and a large object in the direct path of the vehicle, and slow down in the latter case.
- GoToRO 9y agoI doesn't look like they try to explain it. They just try to put the blame on others because the alternative would be to come out and say "We lied (about "AutoPilot").", "We don't know how to create good software". Move fast and break things indeed.
- cr0sh 9y agoOne reason might be a lack of datasets. There are a ton of datasets out there for things like traffic sign identification, and vehicle/pedestrian/etc identification - but most of those vehicles in those datasets are: 1. From the rear (or oblique rear angles) 2. Of mostly automobiles and small trucks There likely aren't many real-world datasets of vehicles facing the vehicle and stopped in the road, and/or of larger vehicles (buses, semi-trucks/lorries, emergency vehicles, bulldozers/tractors, etc). Without having such datasets, the AI you have trained won't have any way of knowing about those objects, and they may be odd enough that they can't be easily extrapolated from the datasets you do have to train on. And by "dataset" - I mean you need massive amounts of data; 50,000 images would be a "small" dataset. Ideally you want many times that, plus you want to "generate" synthetic views for more training data (by skewing/warping the existing images, it helps the system generalize on the data). That's a possible explanation, but I don't know if that's the reason, part of the reason, or no reason at all. Plus, it's not to say they are "at fault" - or to absolve the driver of any responsibility. I'm just throwing it out there, based on my knowledge and experience - which isn't much, I admit (I completed the Udacity Self-Driving Car Engineer Nanodegree last year, plus Udacity's CS373 course, and what is now the Coursera Machine Learning course - but I took it as ML Class in 2011 before Coursera existed).
- mixmastamyk 9y agoHmm, would have expected something “more simple” like a sensor every 15? degrees. When a medium+ object is headed at high speed towards 0 degrees the car should slow, if on a different vector it ignores. The type of object is somewhat irrelevant, e.g. don’t want to run into a road sign either.
- dgreensp 9y agoThis article is fluff/FUD when it comes to the implications about autonomous driving. “Autopilot” is a marketing term for a kind of cruise control. The article repeatedly tries to make the point that if “the best system available” doesn’t stop for stationary vehicles, how will self-driving cars ever work? However, Tesla’s Autopilot is not a self-driving system, it’s a cruise control system. Emergency braking systems are also not self-driving systems. The comparison is meaningless. I say the same thing to the comments about the irresponsible “UX” of Autopilot for not handling this case. It’s more about irresponsible marketing, capitalizing on the enthusiasm for self-driving cars, potentially lulling overzealous customers to trust a cruise control system or emergency braking system with their lives.
- potta_coffee 9y agoI'm driving a '97 Miata now. No cruise, no ABS, basically no safety features other than questionable 90's airbags. It does have an LSD which is great. I find that being in touch with the road contributes to better control and safe driving on my part than when driving bigger vehicles with automatic trans, cruise, etc. Also driving with the top down feels pretty scary at first, and being that exposed really makes me think about how I'm driving.