11 ms·
>Because curcumin's anti-inflammatory properties may protect the brain from neurodegeneration My very first question was: Please provide a possible physiologic
by mrguyorama 9y ago
>Because curcumin's anti-inflammatory properties may protect the brain from neurodegeneration
My very first question was: Please provide a possible physiological pathway for this. I'm so glad it was answered in the very first sentence. So many of these "Superfood does X" studies are just trials with 10 people over a month, with no explanation as to __how__ it could possibly happen. It significantly increases the skepticism I have whenever something like this comes up
I also did not know Turmeric had anti-inflammatory properties. I guess I have reading to do.
Also interesting that they used (what seems to be) a name brand supplement instead of Turmeric
- vondur 9y agoI vaguely remember reading that the physiology of acetaminophen is still not completely understood. I doubt we will be lucky to figure this one out quickly. I also remember reading that the level of dementia in India is much lower than western nations and turmeric was thought to be part of the reason for that.
- IntronExon 9y agoGiven what we’re learning about the impact of gut microbiome on CNS, immune system, and other systems I wonder if the GI effect is it, but with secondary effects related to activity of bacterial colonies.
- tudorw 9y agofound this, 'Biochemical mechanism of modulation of human P-glycoprotein (ABCB1) by curcumin I, II, and III purified from Turmeric powder' https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0006295204004800 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000629520...
- noir_lord 9y agoGut biome is insanely important, I've had digestive issues for over a year and it's been depressing that they couldn't find the cause. I finally gave up waiting and decided to experiment myself, started drinking a yakult every morning and last thing at night, within two weeks things started... Moving and now 6 weeks in its like it used to be, bloatings gone, regular as clockwork, energy levels are up and I generally feel better. I still have other issues that are more serious but the medication handles those ok. I started taking vitamin D a few weeks before that as well and that seemed to help as well.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoFor all the claims of bioavailability, I was surprised to see that Theracumin(R) doesn't seem to contain piperine[1] or any perines (which are usually in curry powder courtesy of black pepper). The 90mg dosage also seemed low, I have been taking 500mg of 95% extract daily for a couple of years. 1: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9619120 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9619120
- orf 9y agoWould you say your supplement regime has helped you? Can you offer any insight into this?
- adamc 9y agoHow do you take it?
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI buy bulk 95% powder, pop a piperine tablet, and dump 3/4 tsp of powder in my mouth - eating something with it to get it down. I experimented with mixing it with various things, but it's hydrophobic and stains everything bright yellow, so the quicker the better. I was mostly interested in the anti-inflammatory properties, my family is full of arthritis, and between climbing and typing, I started noticing some in my hands once I hit 40. I do think it helps with that, and any improvements to memory or mood are a plus.
- michael_h 9y agoEating a spoonful of powder sounds like a nightmare I sometimes have.
- swapsmagic 9y agoTry mixing it with honey and have it, it will be much better.
- tomcam 9y ago
- rdlecler1 9y agoThis is how science works. You start with an anomalous discovery. Publish it, write a grant to do more research.
- bcaulfield 9y agoLooking through the comments, I'm really glad I posted the paper itself to HN, rather than the various writeups of it.
- sp332 9y agoHere's a little more detail https://news.uci.edu/2014/09/10/brain-inflammation-dramatically-disrupts-memory-retrieval-networks-uci-study-finds/ https://news.uci.edu/2014/09/10/brain-inflammation-dramatica... and a lot more detail https://experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/interleukin-6-facilitates-lipopolysaccharide-induced-disruption-i https://experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/interleukin-6-f...
- 40acres 9y agoMore it more I'm learning that inflammation is a huge problem in modern health. I'd be very interested in a list of anti-inflammatory foods, supplements and behaviors.
- Nomentatus 9y agoBeware. We don't know that the inflammation is not compensatory. Since we know its purpose IS to be compensatory, it seems more reasonable to default to it being compensatory, than the original problem; or better, to withhold our judgement.
- jensvdh 9y agoInflammation is a symptom of most auto-immune diseases. Usually the inflammation is caused by your own auto-immune system attacking your healthy cells. Some examples Uveitis (eye inflammation), Crohn's (bowels), Reumatoid Artritis (Joints). Usually these diseases come in pairs, so some people are just more susceptible to whatever causes these diseases. Right now there is no cure but in the last decades huge progress has been made in suppressing these diseases using biologics, but they have the side effect of suppressing your immune system which may be dangerous.
- dumbneurologist 9y agoI am a neurologist. this is actually the exact opposite of what you should care about, which is "does it work to treat ___" In this trial, and 99% of other trials, there is no mechanism provided by the study, only a measurement of causality (which is the same thing as effectiveness). The authors may think they know based on other, prior, basic science research (as they are postulating here), but it does not affect the conclusions of the trial ( whether they do or don't (or even if they are wrong). Obviously it's intellectually satisfying to understand WHY, but it's not as important as "is it true?"
- bashcoder 9y agoIn your view, does this study fall short of answering the “is it true?” question?
- randomsearch 9y agoThe problem with “is this true?” Investigations is that there are tons of potential pitfalls and a combination of experimental limitations, poor academic incentives, and insufficient statistical and scientific training make this very hard to do well. I think it’s bad science, that will one day retrospectively be viewed as invalid scientific method. I think the way to combat this is to avoid studies that solely attempt to demonstrate an effect, but to complement that part of an investigation with additional studies that demonstrate a plausible explanation. This reduces the risk of false positives and increases our confidence in the result. The additional studies could take the form (for example) of deliberately intervening such that the effect should be manipulated by the intervention in a predictable and measurable way. Essentially, come at the hypothesis “from another angle”.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jeffdavis 9y agoI somewhat agree, but "is it true?" is all that science can answer. A mechanism is really just a narrower example without irrelevant distractions or confounding variables. Kind of like the difference between the bug reports: "run this complex workload on this specific machine and it will orobably crash after a few hours" versus "run these three commands when the cache is cold and it crashes".
- maxxxxx 9y agoTurmeric has helped me quite a bit with my inflamed joints after learning about it at a yoga ashram. Now I cook a lot with it. What i have noticed though is that supplements do nothing for me. I only feel a difference when it's fresh powder or even better ground from a root. I have done several experiments where I stopped taking it. Every time my joints got worse and then better after resuming cooking with Turmeric. No idea how it works but it seems to work.
- smt88 9y agoIt's almost guaranteed that some of your experience is the placebo effect, but it's impossible to know how much.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAs I wrote before I have tried a few times back and forth with consistent results. Maybe it's placebo but it works reliably for me. As long as it works I am happy.
- e12e 9y agoThe thing with placebo is that it is an effect. As you say, if it actually helps (and does no harm, or replaces something that helps much more...) - then placebo can be useful and beneficial. It can be difficult to prescribe however...
- danmaz74 9y agoThe thing about placebo is that you can't measure it on yourself - you can only find out with large enough double blind tests. But as long as it works for you - placebo or not - good for you!
- Flow 9y agoIt common among men with low testosterone to have aching joints. Have you checked your levels? Also funny that some men on TRT take turmeric(with some black pepper) to lessen the amount of estrogen converted from testosterone.
- jeffshek 9y agoI post this whenever HN brings up a comment about supplements -- but I created a site to help track people trying out a lot of supplements and how it impacted health and sleep. HN and QuantifiedSelfers find this as a niche site to record correlations and habits for self improvement. https://betterself.io/ https://betterself.io/ (Open sourced)
- neeleshs 9y agoI agree. "How" is a difficult question to answer, and involves basic research. "X does Y" studies need a hypothesis, a bunch of test subjects, and some statistical wrangling. Far easier than basic research. I'm now at a point to take all statistical studies with a pinch of salt. Molecular studies are more interesting and while micro and may miss the macro picture, are more promising.
- kumarvvr 9y agoIm from India. Whenever I get a throat infection, my grandmother gives be a spoonful of turmeric powder mixed with very hot milk, no sugar. Till date, it has not failed once to cure the inflammation/infection/pain. The infection is gone within a day or atmost a couple of days.
- hondo77 9y ago> The infection is gone within a day or atmost a couple of days. As they usually do on their own.
- kumarvvr 9y agoYes. However for me, when not using the turmeric milk thing, it lasts upto a week. There was a clear reduction in the time it took for the infection to subside. Now I am not saying this is proof that it's a magic medicine. Just an observation. It could as well be a placebo effect.
- stordoff 9y agoNot to say it's not useful (a plausible method of action + weak evidence is more suggestive that further study is needed than weak evidence alone, and that understanding could lead to further developments), but the question of does this work is far more important, and can be answered without knowing the how.