21 ms·
The US is the most expensive nation in which to have a baby
- ajsharp 9y agoCapitalism.
- HenryBemis 9y agoWhat I wrote with many many words, you wrote with 1 :)
- jstanley 9y agoThis isn't capitalism. If it was capitalism, somebody would come along and offer to let you give birth in their buildings for less than $32k. I'm not sure what is going on here, but it isn't capitalism.
- FussyZeus 9y agoIt's Capitalism applied to something that doesn't have a market, shouldn't have a market, and who's participants are unable to properly participate in it in any way that resembles a market.
- gohbgl 9y agoThe health sector is one of the most regulated sectors in the US. It has nothing to do with free market capitalism.
- FussyZeus 9y agoAnd yet for profit entities proliferate it at every level, and the constant drumbeat of people against nationalization is for people to be "smart" consumers of healthcare, as if you can make an informed market-based decision about which provider to use while in the back of a damn ambulance.
- a_tractor 9y ago>the constant drumbeat of people against nationalization is for people to be "smart" consumers of healthcare No it isn't. The people who are against nationalization believe a free market would be better, but that excessive government regulation, deeply entrenched administrative/bureaucratic bloat (middlemen) as well as unfair competition with insurance co ponzi style business models prevents an accessible free market for health care from happening. They see corruption and cronyism maintaining the status quo and see through the obvious false choice where the only available options is bankruptcy or socialism. The people against nationalization do not think that health care should cost as much as it does, and do not believe socializing the effects of a bloated, broken and corrupt system will do anything but make it worse. They are also likely to be the same people who would have to pay for it, as if they aren't already, and they are smart enough to see that the ever increasing welfare state (not to mention forced acceptance of mass immigration) will eventually eat them alive. Why would anybody accept much less desire to live in such a parasitic environment?
- gohbgl 9y ago> as if you can make an informed market-based decision about which provider to use while in the back of a damn ambulance. That's a pretty bad straw man argument. Of course you have to pick an insurer before the accident happens otherwise it's not insurance.
- FussyZeus 9y agoHow does the ambulance know where my insurer wants me to go? For that matter, why is it the responsibility of EMT's to, whilist driving at high speed through traffic and attempting to keep my organs in my torso, go through my insurance info and figure out which hospital I should go to and potentially risk both my and their safety with a longer trip, to respect the wishes of a corporation which barely knows I exist? How about instead, we just fix people? And figure out the rest of the BS later?
- jamesblonde 9y agoThis is a good argument for why we should reject meta-narratives for how the world should work. Capitalism (and/or consumerism?) is one such narrative. Ignore or criticize data points that don't fit the meta-narrative. In that sense, Scandinavian policy is light years ahead, as it is pragmatic and have reasonably high amounts of evidence-driven policy (disclaimer, i live in Sweden).
- a_tractor 9y ago>doesn't have a market doesnt have supply and demand? scarcity of skill and resources isn't real? >shouldn't have a market So it does have a market, but shouldn't? >participants are unable to properly participate in it in any way that resembles a market Really? So I am not competing with others for a better doctor's limited time? I'm not working harder to attain more money to buy better insurance or afford better care? What are you talking about? Talk about bureaucratic bloat, regulatory overhead, regulatory capture/cronyism, the need for tort reform, or the fact that the insurance co ponzi business model dominates price negotiation and destroys any semblance of an efficient free market and you make start making sense.
- coldtea 9y agoYou mean it isn't capitalism as it's supposed to work in theory. But it is capitalism like it turns out in practice when the population fears "socialism" and caps on corporate greed.
- psyc 9y agoMiddlemanism? A promiscuous value-chain of “service providers”. The capitalism part is that the top terminates at a public corporation or private equity firm.
- mirimir 9y agoIt's mainly to minimize risk. If everything goes well, home birth is an option, best with a midwife. If it's legal, anyway. But if something goes wrong, you'll end up at hospital, mother and/or child may die or be disabled, and the overall price will likely be greater.
- a_d 9y agoCrony capitalism. "Crony capitalism is an economy in which businesses thrive not as a result of risk taken for them, but rather, as a return on money amassed through a nexus between a business class and the political class." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism (exactly what I explained in a separate comment on this thread :-))
- romwell 9y agoSo, Capitalism.
- arca_vorago 9y agoWith regulatory capture and corruption of the government, isn't our problem a textbook definition of facism (in the academic sense of the word, not in the nazi sense of the word)? Personally I think the word is overused and too heavily charged, and a more appropriate and descriptive term is corporatism. I also agree with Chris Hedges and Sheldon Wolin that inverted totalitarianism is an apt definition. According to the Princeton study of congress, we are also an oligarchy due to the public having almost no influence on legislation, meaning we are not being represented by our elected officials. I would also argue with the increasing disparity of power and resources between the uber-rich and the rest of, and as the middle class is attacked from all sides and shrinks, that our system also matches the definition of neo-feudalism. So, to put it all together, America has allowed itself to become a neo-feudal oligarchical corporate inverted totaltarian surveillance state.
- coldtea 9y agoWhy start with the definitions first? Isn't that backwards?
- arca_vorago 9y agoI don't understand your comment? The question of the post is why does it cost this much? A responder said capitalism, and I am just going further into the various political definitions that describe the current system, which is helpful in inderstanding the original question of the article. If it's an oligarchical corporate state, then it would make sense that hospitals (companies) abuse of their regulatory capture (oligarchism) are exploiting the majority of people financially and otherwise (neo-fuedalism), largley by making them dependent or subservient to their systems. How is that backwards?
- coldtea 9y ago>I don't understand your comment? The question of the post is why does it cost this much? A responder said capitalism, and I am just going further into the various political definitions that describe the current system, which is helpful in inderstanding the original question of the article. That's what I am referring to. Instead of looking into some idealistic "political definitions" and say "according to this this system isn't capitalism", we should look into what's going on (in reality) and say "this is what capitalism looks like". Else it's like those marxists, that instead of accepting that communism can result in a BS bureaucratic state, they said that USSR and co weren't "real communism/socialism", because they didn't match the theory, and that real communism hasn't been tried etc. That's what I call going backwards. One has a definition, and compares reality against it. Instead they should derive their definition from what happens in reality -- and maybe even accept that their idealistic definition can't ever happen anyway. It's like some zoologist had a definition of animal X, and then matched it with various animals and said "this can't be X, because it doesn't match the definition". Well, if that X existed only in theory that's a bad practice. The definition of any X should come from studying actual animals (e.g. this animal species has so and so characteristics, we'll call them an X, e.g. tiger). So, where has this ideal "capitalism" even been seen in the wild?
- qwz4233 9y agoIt is not capitalism. In all the countries mentioned above where child birth is less costly there is significant projected population drop, and governments are under pressure to subsidize families with children.
- dang 9y agoThis manages to combine ideological battle with fluff, the two things that are worst for Hacker News. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't post like this, regardless of which ideology or which fluff.
- HenryBemis 9y agoIn a negative connotation: because insurance companies and hospital owners are taking you for a ride and politicians sit back, sipping their whiskeys and enjoy their lobbying. And if anyone DARES to make such comparisons to Sweden or Finland, some republican will start yelling "down with socialism!!!". One day USA's citizens will "have enough of this" and perhaps do something about this, but this day is anything but close.
- riffraff 9y agoI think it's not just Sweden or Finland, most of Europe has socialized healthcare and birth is one of the things that come free. AFAIU in general you pay for stuff like private rooms or such.
- Carioca 9y agoGermany and Switzerland have complicated systems where you are mandated to have insurance but the state provides you with insurance if you cannot afford it.
- senorjazz 9y agoCan confirm, wife had an emergency c section in the UK, cost $0
- wil421 9y agoWhy does the UK still have private insurance? I had a long conversation with a colleague in London but I couldn’t grasp the use case.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ethnicify 9y agoFor non-national-health-service private care. For the rich, basically. NHS is free, but has its issues with inconsistent service and long(!) wait times. Private is hit and miss, but significantly faster and significantly(!) more expensive. Hence the insurance.
- jvagner 9y agoWhen my son was born, I paid $5K to a birthing center in Boise, a couple of blocks from the hospital. We visited frequently over the 9 months, and each time stayed for about 4-5 days in a birthing room with a hot tub. Also true after my son was born. And then for a few return visits for checkups. And then for a return visit just to visit Boise and hang-out and chill with other parents, expecting parents, etc. $5K, all inclusive. Just like Club Med (been to the one in Cancun... lovely vacation spot). I had insurance... if anything would've happened, an ambulance would've picked us up and taken us to the hospital and then insurance coverage would've kicked in.
- jamesblonde 9y agoThat's not an general option that will have good societal outcomes, if you apply the categorical imperative. The US would rocket ahead from its current lead in infant mortality.
- Retric 9y agoTo be clear, the US has obscene levels of infant mortality overall. But many states are significantly worse than the national average. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/09/29/our-infant-mortality-rate-is-a-national-embarrassment/?utm_term=.7fceb83db755 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/09/29/our-i...
- jamesblonde 9y agoInteresting that the Czech republic are in 5th place. They definitely don't spend $32k per birth.
- jamesblonde 9y agoNearly 1% of children born in Mississippi die in the first year. Insane!
- igravious 9y agoShocking. “ Digging deeper into these numbers, Oster and her colleagues found that the higher U.S. mortality rates are due "entirely, or almost entirely, to high mortality among less advantaged groups." To put it bluntly, babies born to poor moms in the U.S. are significantly more likely to die in their first year than babies born to wealthier moms. ”
- m3kw9 9y agoSo a hospital can theoretically have everything out of network and the patient will risk financial ruin just by using hospitals in America.
- koolba 9y agoIt's well beyond theoretical. The system is total nonsense. I think a sane first step would be a N-month statute of limitations on bills. Anything you're going to be billed for should be sent within N-months. I'm not saying that it should take that long. I'm saying right now there's no limit whatsoever. You could receive a bill for some itemized sub portion (lab work, specialist, a different doctor, etc) a year after a hospital visit and you have no clue what it's for.
- nsxwolf 9y agoThis happened with our first child on our PPO. We kept getting bills for over a year. I had no idea what half of them were for or who any of the doctors mentioned were. I wouldn't be surprised if some of those bills were scams from people who look for birth announcements in the paper. Subsequent children were under an HMO, and we never saw a bill.
- eesmith 9y agoIf scammers do use those announcements, then you would have gotten their fake bills for the subsequent children, because those scammers wouldn't know about the HMO coverage. (One of the hospital staff could be in on the scam, and target based on insurance coverage, but then they wouldn't need the birth announcements in the paper.)
- TallGuyShort 9y agoAnd this happened to me. Got a call from a collection agency claiming I owed them money a year after the birth. I called the hospital and got a written confirmation that they had no record of an unpaid or even late bill. I called my insurance and confirmed they had never received a bill for the amount claimed. Upon getting details from the debt collector (later than required by law), I saw a doctor's name. So I went to the hospital, and they had no record of a doctor by that name ever working for them. The bill turned out to be legitimate, in that the doctor was a "traveling anesthesiologist" and was never an employee of the hospital. And they billed separately, and were never given my insurance information. The whole case ended up relying on my wife's signature on a long legal form that she signed while she was dilated to an 8. All the contact information (address, phone, company name) on the documentation led to people who could not confirm any details on the bill. The hospital told me that they have had a lot of reports of doctors who do their own billing not sending bills for months because they're not very organized. Eventually the anesthesiologist billed it to my insurance correctly and I paid 10% of it. I later found out I could sue the debt collector for not providing details fast enough, but the statute of limitations on their violation had expired.
- a_d 9y agoIn India, there are small boutique hospitals that solve this very problem (e.g. https://www.cloudninecare.com/; https://www.cloudninecare.com/; https://www.motherhoodindia.com/; https://www.motherhoodindia.com/; http://ovumhospitals.com/ http://ovumhospitals.com/ and hundreds more in every city). I have always been so surprised by how "broken" maternity is in the U.S. and just how overtly "scammy" some of the things are e.g. if one needed breast-pumps, there is a 'company representative' that would deliver it to your hospital room and you get charged separately - by the company - and nurses get a kick-back; There is a nexus of private practitioners roaming the hospital wards helping mom's with early care - most of them looking for 'repeat business', after one is discharged. This is from experience in San Francisco. Not to mention the 'baby-product-industrial-complex' where one is convinced that highly special, safe and pink or blue colored equipment is needed for baby care. So there is a LOT of money made in the U.S. from every birth by a vast nexus of companies. Just the product choices one is forced to make drives millions of panicked google searches a year (with 'listicle-focused-SEO-hog-blogs' feeding off of this) -- just to search for the "right" equipment. Why can't just one company consolidate this -- and offer a one-stop-solution? Naked Capitalism is on its full-show during the birth process in America. It is indeed very strange. Finland has 'baby boxes' delivered by the govt: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-22751415 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-22751415 Sweden has a govt sponsored program for end-to-end support for new parents: https://sweden.se/society/10-things-that-make-sweden-family-friendly/ https://sweden.se/society/10-things-that-make-sweden-family-... The reason for this comment is that HN has a 'startup' bent to it, so I hope some entrepreneur just Warby-Parkers (is it a verb?) the baby birth process. There is definitely room for massive simplification. Make each decision simple -- that alone is a giant opportunity.
- grkvlt 9y ago> Finland has 'baby boxes' Interestingly, Scotland now has 'baby boxes' too [0] - but not the rest of the UK, it is an initiative by the devolved Scottish government only it seems. 0. https://www.mygov.scot/baby-box/ https://www.mygov.scot/baby-box/
- stevekemp 9y agoI moved from Scotland to Finland, with my Finnish wife, and I admit I cried when I unpacked our baby-box: https://imgur.com/a/I0NYI https://imgur.com/a/I0NYI The box itself is great, but the reason that Finnish mortality rate for babies fell so sharply after the box was introduced was because to qualify for one you had to visit a doctor early in your pregnancy. Having early contact with healthcare, when pregnant, means you're more likely to do well. The doctors/nurses/midwifes/assistants can frown at you, tell you to eat your vitamins, stop smoking/drinking, etc. For what it is worth healthcare is not free in Finland, but we paid about €300 for mother, father, and baby to stay in a private room for 3-5 days. (Just over a year ago, I can no longer remember that period. I just remember in the 3-5 days I drank a full bottle of whisky, and smoked a cigar in the car-park, in subzero temperatures. Finland, remember?)
- dsl 9y agoI wonder if Medicaid dropping coverage for births would increase the overall acceptance of contraceptive use among the poor.
- cooper12 9y agoI wonder if I can shitpost on HN all I want and state any moronic personal opinion as long as I preface it with "I wonder" to pretend I was actually interested in discussion rather than spewing my vileness onto my keyboard. You don't actually want an answer to that considering you already have some preconceived harebrained notion of poor people somehow avoiding contraceptives because of medicaid (doubly stupid considering Medicaid is what helps many people get checkups for reproductive health from doctors). Because clearly the solution to whatever problem you perceive is to cut health funding rather than actually increasing education. I'm more surprised you didn't just outright say "I wonder what would happen if we sterilized the poor" and go on a spiel about welfare queens since that's where your real motives lie. But guess you gotta veil that bigotry. I know in the "This is why Drumpf won" era, we're all supposed to engage you and respect your utmost right to freeze peach, but nah, take that shit elsewhere.
- dang 9y agoIt was a shitty comment, but replying with another shitty one is the wrong thing to do. You've been abusing this site for a long time and ignoring our requests to stop, such as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15672810 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15672810. Even if you're 100% right about everything, it's not ok to vandalize HN with uncivil, unsubstantive comments. I'm not going to ban you right now because you've also posted good comments. But if you want to keep commenting here, please fix this. You know how to use HN properly; would you please do that exclusively from now on? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- dang 9y agoFlamebait is not welcome here; please don't post it.
- peapicker 9y agoI don't recall what the itemized bill was before insurance took care of it, but with health insurance, each of my kids actual cost to me was $100 out of pocket. In the US. I'm sure the quoted price before insurance was probably ridiculous, though.
- notadoc 9y agoYou must have great insurance. Are you in Congress?
- peapicker 9y agoNope. Software Engineer. The reason it was so low is the youngest was born 18 yrs ago - long before current cost skyrocketing. Things used to be a lot better.
- jonathankoren 9y agoNo one knows how much healthcare costs in the United States. Not the insurance companies. Not the hospitals. Not the doctors. No one. The prices vary widely across providers, and insurance companies. I was reading a few years ago (alas, I can't find the link, but I think it was in the LA Times. KQED was also working on this recently.[1]) where the author tried shopping around and found where same provider would come up with different itemized breakdowns depending on the insurer. It came down to the provider and the insurer negotiated prices. Say the insurer provider agrees that a procedure costs $1000, but says an x-rays can only cost $500, so the doctor fee is $500. Another insurer says treatments can cost $800, and x-rays can only cost $!00, so suddenly the doctor fee is $700. What's the true price of anything? Under America's about the only thing you can tell is that total costs are much higher than the rest of the world, and outcomes are actually slightly worse than the rest of the OECD countries.[0] [0] http://beta.latimes.com/nation/la-na-healthcare-comparison-20170715-htmlstory.html http://beta.latimes.com/nation/la-na-healthcare-comparison-2... [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/11/17/364719763/in-california-that-mri-will-cost-you-255-or-6-221 https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/11/17/3647197...
- 9y ago
- burfog 9y agoA free-standing birth center, without a financial incentive to divert you into an associated hospital, could run you $700 out of $3000. (you pay $700, insurance pays $2300) Some of these places are very nice, feeling far less like a prison or mental institution than a hospital. I know one where the laboring mother can open the door to her room, then step out on to a patio that is separated from the street only by some large bushes. There is no feeling that the place is ready to lock you in and call social workers over a bit of dark humor. A midwife at home would be perhaps $1000 out of $5000. (you pay $1000, insurance pays $4000) Residents of California may have trouble finding this; the obstetricians got their competition mostly outlawed. Doing things by yourself is of course free. I did that with twins and with a 10-pound (4.5 kg) kid. With all of the above, you are far less likely to be subjected to time pressures that will lead to drugs and ultimately to major surgery. Surgery is not just an expense; it is a hazard to both mother and babies because it impairs the ability to maintain and deliver future pregnancies. Surgery rates in the USA are improperly high because of how an uneducated jury is thought to respond; death and injury from surgery ("at least they tried everything") looks better than death and injury from non-action. Except for the do-it-yourself option, there is emergency equipment. People greatly overestimate the chance of having a fast-developing problem, and they overestimate the ability of a standard hospital to respond effectively. If you truly need surgery, the time to travel for it can overlap nicely with the time it takes a hospital to prepare.
- encoderer 9y ago> Residents of California may have trouble finding this; the obstetricians got their competition mostly outlawed. I live in Berkeley. In our recent birthing class, of 9 couples, 3 had home births. YMMV in more far flung places of California but I've not heard of any problems here having talked in detail about birth stories with these families. (We were not one of them, we opted for Hospital birth and it cost around $12k)
- burfog 9y agoIndeed, "mostly". There are ways to make it work, most obviously by the "midwife" actually being an obstetrician. There are a large number of midwifes practicing illegally in California, and I would bet that Berkeley is a hotbed of this. There are a few other ways too, but generally is it sort of banned.
- jkingsbery 9y agoI'm not arguing it's cheaper to give birth in America, but it doesn't seem like this article makes fair comparisons. What an insurance company or hospital charges includes some amount of mark-up, so is more than just the "cost." Likewise, in countries with socialized medicine, the hospital might charge the patient nothing, but it _cost_ someone something (people's time, depreciation on equipment, electricity, and lots of other things). Adjusting for these probably doesn't make everything come out the same, but it would make the claims less sensational.
- nvahalik 9y agoIt doesn't. We paid <$4K when my daughter was born for a midwife. The hospital wanted $5K before even seeing my wife just to schedule an appointment. All because she is "advanced maternal age" (whatever that means).
- 1123581321 9y agoIt means she would be at least 35 when delivering, but I agree; 5k upfront isn’t justified by that.
- nvahalik 9y agoWell I get the age bit but haven’t been told why exactly things are different. Especially if this is not your first child.
- 1123581321 9y agoI think the idea is that since older mother age increases complications, the average cost is higher and so the hospital risks to lose more if you don’t pay. I don’t agree if this is the thinking, though, since $5,000 as insurance against non-payment is too large a step, and I would imagine older parents, on average, are more likely to be able to, and choose to, pay their bills. I don’t know how being on one’s second or third child affects the likelihood of complications.
- giarc 9y agoIncreasing age increases complications. Old papers, but just the first that came up during a google scholar search. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199510123331501#t=article http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199510123331501#t=a... https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/17/6/1649/2919231 https://academic.oup.com/humrep/article/17/6/1649/2919231
- notadoc 9y agoWell for starters... https://i1.wp.com/investingdoc.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/admin-jobs.jpg https://i1.wp.com/investingdoc.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/0...
- T4NG 9y agoI like how everyone forgets about this particular issue when talking about healthcare
- notadoc 9y agoIgnoring the elephant in the room is a traditional component of discussing healthcare in America.
- jostmey 9y agoWow! I bet plot looks the same for the costs of higher education!!
- RGamma 9y agoWhat do these administrators do (i.e. what's their value)? Are they like physicians with a leading/management role?
- jbooth 9y agoThey apply "MBA 101" to the system, best summarized as "extracting more money with better care as a distant second". Was chatting with the doc during our second birth, the admins had just pulled a bait and switch on the practitioners. Instead of better equipment and surgery rooms, they were getting a few hundred more beds. Beds are easy to bill for. Surgery and actual care are way less profitable.
- mnm1 9y agoIf anything, the administrators should go down in that time period that just happens to coincide with the mass adoption of computers by all businesses. What this graph is saying is that while the US population grew about 50% in that time (203-308 million), administrator incompetence grew 2300% over that time despite the mass adoption of computers. In other words, one administrator from the 70's could easily replace dozens if not hundreds of administrators today and get the same amount of work done. This kind of incompetence is beyond comprehension both at the administrator level and the executive level that hires them.
- fredrikcarno 9y agoRegarding sweden We had premature twins and it cost us zero. The taxes are sky high but I feel ok that others get ot free also since I got it
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- craftyguy 9y agoI think there are two sides to this. You paid nothing because you were subsidized by others. I can definitely see the other point of view from folks who do not have children and/or do not want children. Here in the US, I don't particularly want to pay for the masses of folks who refuse to use contraceptives and are up to 4+ children already. There are already way too many people here (and on Earth in general). On the other hand, people should be entitled to free healthcare to a MUCH larger extend than we currently have here. There's a big difference between having a child and you catching the flu, breaking a bone, or getting cancer. The environmental and social impact of having a kid is much larger, and I can see how some folks don't want to subsidize this.
- simonblack 9y agoHow about all those heavy haulers who pay for your usage of the roads? Most countries have 'socialised roads' and 'socialised healthcare, but the US sees 'socialised roads' as something good but 'socialised healthcare' as something bad. Whereas most other countries, even the so-called 'poor' countries can afford their single-payer 'socialised healhcare', the US finds that too difficult.
- henrikschroder 9y ago> I can definitely see the other point of view from folks who do not have children and/or do not want children. The society you live in needs to replace its dying citizens with new citizens. The easiest way to do that is by existing citizens having children. If having children is too expensive such that the birth-rate shrinks below replacement levels, your society will shrink, and your economy will shrink. This is bad for you, regardless of you having children or not. Therefore, it's in your interest that society uses some of its pooled resources to ensure that the birth-rate is kept above replacement level, i.e. use your taxes to subsidize children.
- Brendinooo 9y agoFirst kid was no cost to us. My wife was on insurance with her employer. Long day, but no complications. I kept waiting for a bill that never came. Couldn't believe we didn't pay anything! By the time the second kid came around, we were self-insured on the healthcare.gov marketplace. We ended up paying $5000 out of pocket - $2k for the prenatal care and doctors' services, $3k for the delivery and stay at the hospital. We made a $1500 mistake. My wife had a really fast and normal delivery, but it was so fast that they didn't have time to administer an antibiotic that they otherwise would have. They wanted to monitor her for a day to look for an infection. We said okay, but if I had more closely read my policy I'd have learned that the policy had a $1500/day copay for labor and delivery. We'd have taken our chances and gone home had we known. Kid three is coming! And this year's marketplace plan says that we're on our own up to the individual deductible of $6950. That's a bronze plan that carries a $950/month premium for 4 people; financial assistance from the government drops that down to $700/month. So we pay $8400/year for the privilege of not paying more than $7000 for an individual ($14,000 for the family) on our plan. I don't think state-run healthcare is the only solution here (nor is it an inherently bad solution; I'm no libertarian), but I have to think that I'm living in the worst of all worlds here. I'm forced to buy an expensive product that I'm afraid to use, a product that costs more than the roof over my head per month but delivers a fraction of the value. It's expensive because it's violating basic principles of insurance, because the people who made the law are trying to implement universal healthcare in a system that's not built for that idea (at least not in the way it currently exists). If I lived in a more market-based system there'd be price transparency, presumably a better way to monitor outcomes, and a lot more say in what kind of policy I could get to better accommodate the needs of my family. Anyways, there are alternatives and means for assistance out there, and we're exploring them. But we like our doctors and our hospital; it's a shame that we have to look elsewhere. Not looking for sympathy, just adding a data point! My takeaway from that article was that maybe we should price out a trip to Spain sometime late in the third trimester :)
- rsfern 9y agoHave you and your wife considered using a birth center for #3 if there are no complications or high risk factors? My wife and I had our son at a midwife center in the US, and our prenatal, delivery, and postnatal care combined ran about $3k (of which our insurance covered about 2/3). The midwives were great, and overall I think it was a less stressful experience than the hospital might have been.
- lamarpye 9y agoFor some reason the article didn't mention the cost of malpractice insurance. I wonder why? My cousin, a doctor in Pennsylvania, said at one point, the insurance was getting so expensive, it was driving obstetricians from the state.
- EvanAnderson 9y agoMy wife ended up w/ an unplanned C section to deliver our daughter in 2013 in Dayton, Ohio. Both mom and daughter had reasons for two extra days in the hospital. The bill to my wife's insurance company was just under $60,000 for her portion. My daughter's portion was out-of-pocket (because she was on my insurance) and was around $12,000 after the hospital's "cash discount". A lot of factors contributed to our decision not to have any more children, but the cost of maternity care, birth, and follow-up medical care figured-in prominently. My wife was leaving her job after the birth and everyone was going on my insurance (self-employed, have bought my own insurance since 2004). Had the costs been less I'm not sure we would have opted to have any more, but it would have changed the calculus.
- briffle 9y agoOur insurance had excellent coverage, but I remember being excited when I payed a bill for my wife, and thought that we were good, since we hit the $3,000 max out of pocket per person. And then bills started arriving in my Son's name.. So another $3k..
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI've long suspected that a driver of the cost of medical care in America is the middle-people. Everyone who wants to take a cut, and tack on a fee, and increase profits. From the drug maker to the bandaid company. There was a really fascinating article here recently on doctors who only take cash, and I think it really hits to the idea that we're being taken for a ride from a lot of these companies, hospitals, insurers, etc.
- lamarpye 9y agoInteresting, lets look at a link from the article: <i> Results—In 2010, the U.S. infant mortality rate was 6.1 infant deaths per 1,000 live births, and the United States ranked 26th in infant mortality among Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Devel opment countries. After excluding births at less than 24 weeks of gestation to ensure international comparability, the U.S. infant mortality rate was 4.2, still higher than for most European countries and about twice the rates for Finland, Sweden, and Denmark. U.S. infant mortality rates for very preterm infants (24–31 weeks of gestation) compared favorably with most European rates. However, the U.S. mortality rate for infants at 32–36 weeks was second-highest, and the rate for infants at 37 weeks of gestation or more was highest, among the countries studied. About 39% of the United States’ higher infant mortality rate when compared with that of Sweden was due to a higher percentage of preterm births, while 47% was due to a higher infant mortality rate at 37 weeks of gestation or more. If the United States could reduce these two factors to Sweden’s levels, the U.S. infant mortality rate would fall by 43%, with nearly 7,300 infant deaths averted annually. <i> How much does treating babies with low-birth weight add to the average cost?
- tathougies 9y agoIt cost us $2000+ for the hospital to help my wife deliver our dead baby. The shitty part is that it would have been free under our insurance if the baby were alive. Yay insurance...
- hueving 9y agoWow, that's a terrible emergent cruelty from a complex labyrinth of years of backroom negotiations. I'm sorry for your loss and that you had to pay for it like that monetarily as well.
- vasilipupkin 9y agothis trope about how much things cost in the US vs other countries never dies. Things are not free in Spain, they are paid for by heavy taxation, which then results in a massive unemployment rate of 17% AND a lower birth rate than US.
- alkonaut 9y agoSo cherrypick any other country with a working universal healthcare system and lower unemployment rate. You can almost pick any tax rate too, and there’s a country with that.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoSo, why don't you do if then? Which country has lower unemployment rate and higher birth rate than US where taxation is low ? Can you name one ? I love the downvotes. I make a factual statement that Spain, which is referenced in the article, has higher tax burden, a 17% unemployment rate and a lower birth rate than US and they freak out.
- alkonaut 9y agoAlmost all other modern democracies (e.g OECD) have universal healthcare. Almost all have lower unemployment rates than Spain (if not all). Taxation varies. Was my point. Those that have the healthcare as a public insurance on the side of taxes can have low taxes. Those with tax funded single payer obviously have higher taxes. My example of choice of low-ish taxes, high birth rate and universal healthcare would be Ireland. There are others.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoYou are missing the point. Yes, countries have lots of benefits, what I am having issue with is the claim those benefits are cheaper. No, they are paid for in different ways. There aren't any others. US has a lower tax burden than almost all OECD countries except for Ireland. http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-do-us-taxes-compare-internationally http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-do-us-taxes... Technically, Ireland fails my test because it has a higher unemployment rate than US. Safe to say, Ireland is an exception due to being probably most catholic country in the western world, which keeps birth rate high My specific test is, find me a developed country with lower unemployment rate, lower taxes and higher birth rate than US. There isn't one. And that's how those benefits are paid for
- sercand 9y agoI had seen https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ra3w4/the_cost_of_our_babys_birth_csection_in_the_us_oc/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ra3w4/the... this on reddit a couple of days ago. Guy calculated the all the cost.
- aidenn0 9y agoAt the company I work for, our previous insurer doubled our premiums, so we switched. It went from so-so to terrible. My daughter cut her hand and needed stitches; I took her to the ER; their surgeon was booked, so they sent me to a different one. I got a $160k bill for an "elective surgery." It took a couple of phone calls to get the point across that stitches for a hand bleeding through 3 dressings is not elective. 6 months later, the surgeon still has not gotten paid (I know this because sometimes get copied on the "request for extra information" that is sent out by the company). Also I get about 3 letters from the insurance company for every visit that involves insurance (PT after the hand injury was weekly, so this was a lot). I asked if I could get those electronically, and apparently my plan doesn't qualify for paperless...
- factsaresacred 9y ago> a $160k bill Damn, America. What is wrong with you?
- mnm1 9y agoI feel you. I got an out of network ambulance bill when I was picked up unconscious. As if I had a choice about it ...
- GordonS 9y ago$160k?! Was this seriously just for stitches? How come an actual surgeon was doing something as simple as stiching?
- aidenn0 9y agoA tendon needed reattaching too; that's why they needed an actual surgeon (and the ones at the ER were booked).
- rak00n 9y agoThat's horrible. What happened to the 160k bill? Is that still pending on your name?
- 9y ago
- hiyer 9y agoIs there any medical procedure/medicine for which the US is not the most expensive nation (or among the most expensive)?
- Consultant32452 9y agoYes, my local grocery chain gives away a large number of medications including antibiotics and some heart meds free, not even paid for by taxes. The drugs are so cheap on the free market that they make it up by people just buying groceries there.
- GordonS 9y agoWow, are antibiotics not controlled in the US? Here in the UK you can only obtain them with a prescription, and I just assumed most/every developed nation would be the same.
- alkonaut 9y agoI hope the grandparent post meant they are prescribed but not charged for. Not that you can buy antibiotics over the counter.
- Consultant32452 9y agoYes, you have to have a prescription. It's just free as in $0.
- phil21 9y agoJust lasik and plastic surgery
- BaronVonSteuben 9y agoCoincidentally things that insurance isn't involved in ...
- wwweston 9y ago
- bfrog 9y agoHealthcare here is a joke. No clear pricing, no clarity on what is or isn't actually covered, mega bills that get delivered a year late then you then have to argue over. The only way to not go bankrupt is to not get sick, ever.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIt's often not even clear who you will be paying much less how much it will cost.
- freedomben 9y agoIsn't this the truth. I had a test done and got bills from 3 different people, at 3 different times, separated by a couple of months. Some submitted to insurance, others didn't.
- remotedreamer 9y agoI agree that our healthcare system is messed up but the insurance company paid for 95% of her bill. Seems like she got her money's worth from the insurance company.
- ashayh 9y agoThe entire point of the original sky high price tag is to make your final share seem reasonable. Also, you still pay hundreds if not thousands per month in premiums.
- paulcole 9y agoIsn’t this kind of like TJ Maxx or Ross labeling clothes at insane “retail” prices so you feel like you got a good deal when you saved 95% but still spent $50?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoNot if she gets bankrupted by the $50k that the insurance didn't cover.
- nojvek 9y agoInsurance can put whatever number they want to make you feel you got a great deal. It’s like car sales people showing fake papers about how much the car cost them. “They are selling to you at cost”. There is absolutely no way a simple hand X-ray costs multiples of thousands of dollars.
- YetAnotherNick 9y agoWhy don't insurance companies lead the change towards transparent pricing?
- ebragg09 9y agoBecause their profits are limited as a percentage of revenue (aka "they must spend x% of their revenue on patient care"), and thus there's a huge incentive for prices to go up across the board to increase their dollar amounts that don't have to be spent on patient care.
- vadym909 9y agoYup- Wanted to burn off some blackheads and a US skin specialist charged $175 to take off 1 using a Ultrasonic machine, went to Mexico and took off 20 for $5 using the same machine.
- dopeboy 9y agoHow did you find & vet the provider in Mexico?
- pwaai 9y agoIt boggles my mind, that a country with the most billionaires still has not addressed gun laws and universal healthcare.
- vixen99 9y agoIt seems you're assuming a causal connection between the existence of billionaires and the issues you mention else why would the statistic boggle you? But what is the connection? Is this a plea for equality of disposable income?
- pwaai 9y agowell the US is the richest country in the world is it not? reflected by having the most amount of high net worth billionaires? is raising the safety net for the citizens of a rich country that other poorer country have such an existential and threatening notion? you used the term, plea to describe such safety nets, which is a request made in an urgent and emotional manner. So you recognize that these are the voices of desperate people but still deny their rights.
- refurb 9y agoSure the US has addressed gun laws. It has maintained that firearm ownership is an individual right and the laws reflect that.
- pwaai 9y agoI see you ran with a different notion of what I meant by "addressed". I'm certain victims of mass shootings will beg to differ. Individuals also have a right to not be deceased or live in fear of mass shooters whom you are right, has been addressed with individual right to carry. Having laws that favor one side heavily is not a standard for 'addressed'. Take a look at Australia, that is proper 'addressing' the issue.
- refurb 9y agoMy reply is your position on what "addressed" means is no more correct than mine.
- shadowbantruth 9y agoIn return you get a citizenship though.
- gaius 9y agoHaving a baby should be expensive. There are nearly 8Bn people in the world; "making more people" is not a problem that the human race has. The problems we do have with pollution, climate change, resource depletion, extinction of other species, food and water supplies are entirely caused by there being too many of us competing for too little of everything else. This is especially the case in the US where individuals are extremely high-impact on the environment in terms of natural resources consumed and pollution generated. Those externalities have a real cost attached, that isn't reflected in the current price, which would be much much higher if parents had to pay their child's say CO2 impact up front.
- theaeolist 9y agoYou are arguing against overpopulation and nobody would disagree with you. What you should argue is that extortionate hospital bills and overall poor natal health care are an effective and humane way to fight overpopulation. Can you?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zxcmx 9y agoI find it hard to read your argument and not feel that the nations and individuals who follow your advice will be replaced by those who don't. I suppose this is "wrongthink" and I'm troubled by it because it's hard not to feel it's semantically close to nationalism and racism. In the anglosphere though, fertility is universally below replacement already. This is also true in countries where the cost of birth is much less than the U.S. Everyone is making up the shortfall with immigration. To follow your argument through to its conclusion we should also make immigration to wealthier countries more difficult and expensive because it comes with a corresponding increase in personal resource consumption. Still troubling.
- dictum 9y ago> Having a baby should be expensive (...) This is especially the case in the US where individuals are extremely high-impact on the environment in terms of natural resources consumed and pollution generated. So those who benefit the most from resource depletion (i.e. those who can afford the hypothetical Baby Tax) would be free to have as many babies as they want, while the poor, already impeded in most activities and burdened by the cost of livinng, would make a sacrifice. Sorry if my reading is too harsh.
- Neil44 9y agoWhen we had our daughter I was annoyed that I ended up paying about £50 for parking for the week that recovery from the cesarian took. Looking back I guess that was a bit short sighted!
- GordonS 9y agoHospital parking has been free in Scotland since 2008, so just the cost of fuel for getting to/from the hospital!
- CannisterFlux 9y agoBoth my kids were born in Spain between 2006 and 2011 when the government gave €2500 per child! I still can't believe this was a thing.
- nojvek 9y agoIn Australia I believe my cousins got $10k per child from government. Those were great times.
- boubiyeah 9y agoLiving in France, these comments are all so sad :(