16 ms·
Driving a Car in Manhattan Could Cost $11 Under Congestion Plan
- saas_co_de 9y agoIt seems like it would be fairer to privatize the roads entirely and force the people who can actually use them to pay the entire cost. Otherwise poor people are subsidizing roads reserved for the rich that they can't even use.
- cujo 9y agoWhat makes you think the best alternative to cut out the poor entirely?
- saas_co_de 9y agoMy point is that charging both fees and taxes means that the poor are excluded, because they can't afford the fees, but they still have to pay part of the taxes.
- turc1656 9y agoAll public goods are taxed even if they don't have associated fees. So, if we were to move everything to a fee-for-usage system, I don't think you'd like the result since the wealthy pay an extraordinarily outsized portion of funding for public goods and services (which they use far less than the average person). The poor would still be excluded because the new fee would be at least the existing tax+fee, plus some additional increased amount to account for the wealthier people who were paying an outsized portion through income tax previously. Now that rich person gets to pay the same $x as the poor person. The poor person is still priced out in your scenario.
- saas_co_de 9y ago> The poor person is still priced out in your scenario. correct, but they haven't been taxed for something they can't afford to use anyway, so they are better off.
- yellowstuff 9y agoEven though this pushes road use into being more of a transaction I still don't believe that we should think about road use as a pure transaction. Infrastructure shapes how people live, work and play. Roads that cost $12 to drive will change the city differently than roads that cost $50 to drive on. Specifically, I'd be worried about driving away tourists and commercial traffic. I doubt a lot of well-off locals would start driving in Manhattan if there were a congestion tax and less traffic, they'd keep taking Uber.
- ghaff 9y agoTourists is probably less of an issue for Manhattan than it would be a lot of places. Sure, there's the family of five from a nearby state that drives into the city for the weekend because the train costs add up for that many people. But, for most, trains, planes, or busses make a lot more sense given parking costs and the fact that driving into New York is pretty much a big pain. I've done it but not when I've had other reasonable options.
- wlesieutre 9y agoEven if we did view normal everyday road use as a transaction, the road infrastructure is critical to other services like police, fire, and ambulance that still make sense to be funded from taxes. If you want to be able to call the police, you're relying on roads being available.
- sp332 9y agoFunding it with a progressive tax makes more sense to me than charging everyone the same flat rate.
- intrasight 9y ago>Otherwise poor people are subsidizing roads reserved for the rich that they can't even use. Welcome to the state of infrastructure everywhere, but especially in big cities like NYC.
- intrasight 9y agoNot so much poor people (who don't pay much if anything in taxes) but middle-class people.
- lmm 9y agoA lot of things are partly public-funded and partly user-funded - museums come immediately to mind. That doesn't seem wrong - the public funding is justified in terms of the public benefit (even a road that's only used by "the rich" can increase productivity enough that the generated tax revenue outweighs the cost), and the user funding is justified because those who use it get the benefit.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoPoor people already don't drive in Manhattan. They use public transportation.
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoAs someone living in Brooklyn who drives to NJ regularly, I wonder if this will increase congestion on the Staten Island bound route to NJ. People will dodge the Holland Tunnel to avoid this surcharge.
- HalcyonicStorm 9y agoAs someone in a similar position, majority of my time in the trip to NJ is spent on getting from Brooklyn to the outerborough bridge.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- herbturbo 9y agoTo be fair that's probably a good thing. The BQE and Turnpike are more appropriate places for large amounts of through traffic than SoHo.
- qnk 9y ago"drivers would not have to pay if they entered Manhattan by all but two of the city-owned East River bridges, which are now free to cross, as long as they bypassed the congestion zone." I don't think I understand this part. Why would you have to pay if you "bypass the congestion zone"? no matter where you're coming from. Now, if what this means is that you don't have to pay the $11.52 fee after having already paid the $15 (if you pay cash) for the toll fee coming from New Jersey, makes sense.
- noer 9y agoI think one example would be that if you drive over the Brooklyn Bridge or Queensborough Bridge, but get directly onto the FDR, drive north to wherever the congestion zone ends (the last time they floated the idea it was 86th St), exit onto city streets and drive south from there. The Williamsburg & Manhattan bridges have no direct connection to the FDR.
- ghaff 9y agoIt's confusing the way it is written and there's no actual map but: "In turn, that means drivers can enter Midtown and Lower Manhattan by two bridges without paying as long as they go directly to the F.D.R. Drive along the East River and then continue on it until they are out of the congestion zone." I believe what they're saying is that you still enter the congestion zone via those two bridges but you can stay on FDR drive and exit the zone without getting on interior streets [ADDED: and not get charged. FDR Drive is the road that runs along the East River.]
- alistairSH 9y agoPoorly phrased, but I think the overall point is... Previous proposals had the congestion zone covering a larger portion of downtown, which meant paying the toll even if you were just passing through on an arterial roadway. New systems allow finer grained control of where the congestion zone begins. So, a small number of arterial roads/bridges can be left outside the zone, and toll-free.
- nwah1 9y agoCongestion pricing is one of the most economically literate ways to improve traffic, and those funds can be used to improve infrastructure. It isn't so different from surge pricing in ridesharing apps. There is a narrowmindedness on the part of opponents of both congestion pricing and surge pricing, because they are ignoring the obvious point that if they weren't paying the fees they'd be paying in terms of time. Not to mention that congestion has other negatives, like pollution. Infrastructure needs to get paid for somehow. It is fair when it is paid for by the people benefiting from it.
- bob_theslob646 9y agoNot disagreeing with you about the economic point, but will kindly disagree with you in terms of spending. Let's just say New York does not have a great history of spending on infrastructure. A recent New York Times piece, mentioned that the price of labor on infrastructure projects is 5 times more expensive then anywhere else in the world. It just blows my mind that people in the NYC area are willing to put up with that type of congestion. Doesn't Sidewalk Labs( alphabet company) have an office in Manhattan? Where are they in terms of solving traffic problems?
- nwah1 9y agoI agree the costs are high. That is largely a result of the high cost of living. There's additional economically literate funding methods which account for that. For instance, when infrastructure is built, it causes surrounding land values and rents to rise. It is possible to use that rising value to pay for the infrastructure, via a special assessment. There is also an issue where the people with the worst infrastructure would be paying the most under congestion pricing, which means that it would be important to prioritize improvements to the most congested areas.
- morley 9y agoI'm not sure you read the article in question. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-... The costs aren't high because of cost of living, they're high because of cushy agreements with workers unions and construction companies, among a myriad other things.
- liveoneggs 9y agoa friend was once visiting me in manhattan and decided to drive. He came over on the george washington bridge ($15 toll), missed his turn to my block and ended up getting turned around and going over to brooklyn (tunnel, of course: $8.50 toll), realized he was in the wrong place and turned around ($8.50 back through the tunnel). This, of course, was after driving up from Virginia via I-95, which has its own $20+ worth of tolls along the route. -- Where I live now, in Atlanta, we recently closed a $0.50 toll (GA400) because apparently we didn't need the money.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoFreezing temperatures, salt, underground infrastructure, and large amounts of traffic increase costs tremendously. Additionally, sometimes the infrastructure cannot handle the demand, therefore demand has to be reduced, and the easiest (and maybe most optimal way for society) is to implement tolls.
- jimmaswell 9y agoLarge amounts of traffic means more tolls collected. They could get by fine on a normal toll amount. $15 is indefensible. Why is the answer "screw the poor"?
- ethbro 9y ago$15 isn't indefensible if the project is solely or mostly funded with tolls (and therefore not out of state / city budget). But as to toll (flat) vs tax (progressive), you're right: it's definitely screwing over the poor. I'm all in favor of usage based charging, but "unaffordable to live near work on a moderate salary" + "we're going to tax your daily commute, the same as your boss" doesn't feel fair.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThe “fair” answer is get on a train. There are plenty of affordable communities on the Metro North, LIRR and NJ Transit.
- intrasight 9y agoWhy do we still use pennies in commerce?
- btbuildem 9y agoBecause they add up to millions over time?
- rthomas6 9y agoThis is one of the only places in the US where public transportation is kind of good. Many people in NYC don't own a car and don't even know how to drive. It boggles my mind the amount of people complaining about how expensive it is to drive to Manhattan. ...Why did you drive in the first place? Unless you need to carry something large/heavy, there's no real reason to drive there. Just park, take a cab/train there, and once you're there, it's faster than driving to use the subway to get places.
- Nav_Panel 9y agoPeople are stuck in old modes of thinking about the city. When my parents lived in the city during the 80s, it wasn't safe to take the subway. Everybody owned a car, even in Manhattan. Now, none of my (20-something) friends own cars, but I imagine a lot of older people don't want to give it up. It does seem pretty nice to drive to work rather than cramming into a subway car for a half hour, even if you're stuck in traffic...
- rthomas6 9y agoI drive to work in traffic, and I would much rather be on a subway. Where I live, there is no public transportation from my house to my office. If I could take a subway, I'd be able to zone out, or read a book, or go on Reddit, etc. for 40 minutes instead of being on constant low-level alert while driving.
- Nav_Panel 9y ago> zone out, or read a book, or go on Reddit Kind of? It can get pretty tight to the point where holding a book up is uncomfortable or not possible due to lack of space. You only get internet at station stops and not in the tunnels, so it's a little bit tough to read Reddit. I usually get around this by pre-loading a bunch of essays I want to read. Yeah, you can put on your earbuds and zone out. But it's dark down there, and given how short the days are in the winter, it doesn't feel nice to be trapped underground for so long. I'd honestly rather take a reliable bus (as if these even exist) in the morning.
- ForHackernews 9y agoThe London congestion charge is £11.50, and it works pretty well.
- gbuk2013 9y agoAnd it's now +£10 if you drive an old banger (T-Charge)
- nikon 9y agoHow does it work well? The roads have never been busier.
- ForHackernews 9y agoThe percentage of private vehicles on London roads is lower relative to other big cities. London streets are packed with buses, delivery vans, black cabs and minicabs. https://www.centreforpublicimpact.org/case-study/demand-management-for-roads-in-london/ https://www.centreforpublicimpact.org/case-study/demand-mana... > There was a 37 percent increase in the number of passengers entering the congestion charging zone by bus during charging hours in the first year. > “Greenhouse gas emission was reduced by 16 per cent from 2002 to 2003. NOX and PM10 within the congestion charging zone decreased by 18 per cent and 22 per cent, respectively, by 2004." > The scheme generated £122 million net in 2005/2006. > By 2006, the congestion charging zone had reduced congestion in central London by 26 per cent from its 2002 levels. > There have been between 40 and 70 percent fewer accidents that resulted in personal injury within the zone.
- lewis500 9y agoThere are so many exemptions and discounts--e.g., for taxis and private hires and residents---that only a fraction of traffic is charged. Also, London has changed its road network a lot to favor buses, pedestrians and cyclists. Speeds today are about what they were in 2002 before pricing, but there is more capacity for other modes. Also there is tons of road construction in London all the time. That harms capacity a lot.
- lclarkmichalek 9y agoLondon has something similar, the congestion charge. Has helped somewhat, and def makes regular driving in central London a 'you did what?' thing. It's lifted on the weekend, which is nice if you want to pop to IKEA or whatever. I think they're planning on pushing something similar all the way out to the north circular, and maybe the M25 for heavily polluting traffic.
- iraklism 9y agoWorth noting that the CC in London operates for 15 years now. I’m sure there is a wealth of data that can be analysed, and I’m even more sure that there are a number of studies and papers that have explored its usefulness and positive/negative impact on traffic/economy/environment/public transportation.
- Symbiote 9y agoThe limit for polluting traffic has been in place for a few years, it's called the Low Emission Zone. Only some larger vehicles are affected, and the fee is either £100 or £200 — I assume the idea is that you can move your rarely-used special construction equipment, but for pretty much everything else one should either upgrade or replace the vehicle: https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/low-emission-zone https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/low-emission-zone But the additional charge for the worst diesel cars is new: https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/emissions-surcharge https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/emissions-surcharge
- Yhippa 9y agoThis is what I first heard of when I saw this article. Question: is your charge dynamic based on actual traffic or is it statically priced?
- blibble 9y agoproblem is now levels are back up to what they were before the charge happened
- javindo 9y agoSince surprisingly nobody has mentioned it in the comments here yet, we have a similar scheme in place in London, and have done for quite some time. It's only for the most central/congested zone and has had a hugely beneficial impact on congestion. That being said, it almost never makes sense to drive a car inside central London anyway as the public transport is very reliable and has almost full coverage, and it's dealing with a very different problem in the first place (old horse and cart windy roads adjusting for the modern age).
- cseelus 9y agoI find concepts of road space rationing like in Beijing to be more fair.[1] This plan for Manhattan will obviously only stop people with low financial power from driving, although they might already have paid for these roads via taxes and duties. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_space_rationing_in_Beijing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_space_rationing_in_Beij...
- ufo 9y agoSão Paulo has a similar system in place since 1996, where each vehicle has one day a week where they are banned from using the roads during peak times. My understanding is that it doesn't really help that much because even with the rationing the tendency is still to saturate the roads with cars. São Paulo is one of the cities with the worst traffic congestion in the world. Additionally, rich people can bypass the rationing by purchasing additional vehicles.
- bigjimslade 9y agoMore money for politicians. There's a novel idea. I'm sure it'll pan out spectacularly.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y ago> In a key change from past efforts, drivers would not have to pay if they entered Manhattan by all but two of the city-owned East River bridges, which are now free to cross, as long as they bypassed the congestion zone. The West side should get the same benefits. They should also increase the motorcycle toll discount back to 20% like it was years ago.
- setgree 9y agoWeighing in as a Manhatto who works in midtown -- I welcome this! But another fruitful option is curbing the very worst behavior attendant to driving. Blocking the box -- apparently being policed heavily in Queens! [0] -- is typically addressed (near times square) by having traffic cops in the streets guiding traffic. How about tickets that scale up by orders of magnitude for each repeat offense, i.e. $1 for the first offense and $10K for the fifth and after that you lose your license? The next thing I'd want to tackle is rampant honking. Not sure how to police this but it should probably cost $10 per second that your horn is making noise. that seems to me like a fair pricing of the externalities produced. And if you're honking to save someone's life i.e. if they're walking into traffic while looking at their cell phone -- ok that's a tough one. [0] http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2017/09/21/ridgewood-ticket-trap/ http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2017/09/21/ridgewood-ticket-trap...
- alkonaut 9y agoTraffic violations fees should be proportional to income to really be painful to rich people. See e.g Finland.
- ghaff 9y agoProbably the worst horn honkers in Manhattan are the taxi car drivers. Not the wealthy guy driving his Mercedes.
- ebikelaw 9y agoIn theory there is a $350 fine for needless honking in New York. In practice this is never enforced, and five years ago the city took down all the "no honking" signs. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/29/nyregion/new-york-removes-no-honking-signs.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/29/nyregion/new-york-removes-...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- weatherlight 9y agoManhattan is 2 miles by 14 miles. Unless you are moving something heavy, there really is no reason not to use the Subway, it's faster, cheaper, and runs all night and all day. Not only that, the majority of New Yorkers do not own cars. I don't even know how to drive. I do, however, take buses and ride my bike. (In NYC you'll get ticketed if you ride your bike on the sidewalk ) In NYC, real estate is extremely limited. Why should such real estate, which is paid for with city taxes benefit so few?
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> there really is no reason not to use the Subway East-West across the park can be a bit of a pain on the train. If you're trying to get from the Upper West Side to the Upper East Side, a bus is going to be a faster choice than taking a train to midtown, transferring, and taking a train back up.
- rdtsc 9y agoDriving 10 miles from Northern Virginia to DC on I-66 could cost you $40: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/dr-gridlock/wp/2017/12/05/i-66-toll-in-virginia-reaches-new-high-of-36-50-on-day-2/?utm_term=.ae68bc50c0f0 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/dr-gridlock/wp/2017/12/0... Is it wrong? I don't know, usually it is not as bad. But when it got that high and people were still jumping into the lane one has to wonder what's going on. Granted the nearby counties are the wealthiest in the country, so maybe it shouldn't be that shocking.
- hartator 9y ago> East river bridges Making poor people pay as always.
- ebikelaw 9y agoThis framing of the issue is typical for the mainstream press, however readers should note that this scheme changes nothing about the cost of driving. It only changes who pays, and how. Today everybody pays the costs associated with driving in Manhattan, even though driving in Manhattan is only practiced by a tiny minority of people. Congestion pricing will shift part of that burden to the people who cause it, which is perfectly fair.
- rbcgerard 9y agoAlso not noted is the portion of people driving in new york city that do not live in new york city...
- SamReidHughes 9y agoThey're driving in so that the people living there don't have to drive out.
- DontTrustOver25 9y agoCenters of work and business go wherever the majority goes. They're driving in the city because they don't want to live in the city but they want to work there.
- rayuela 9y agoI know guidelines frown against this kind of response, but this is one of the stupidest rebuttals I've ever seen on here...
- SamReidHughes 9y agoMaybe it went over your head. The point that people live outside the city evaporates when their driving is useful to people inside the city. Only if they were driving through without stopping would there be validity to the idea that outsiders are taking advantage of the city.
- rbcgerard 9y agoA couple of things to note: 1) is who is actually causing the congestion in NYC - its my understanding that the bulk of the congestion is caused by non-NYC residents 2) a large unaddressed component is parking - the large amount of free parking available, especially to non-residents, creates a distorting subsidy in favor of commuting in many areas. If you want to read a great book on the broader subject, check out Traffic by Tom Vanderbilt http://tomvanderbilt.com/books/traffic/ http://tomvanderbilt.com/books/traffic/
- lewis500 9y agoI wrote a history of downtown congestion pricing a few months back: https://medium.com/@lewislehe/a-history-of-downtown-road-pricing-c7fca0ce0c03 https://medium.com/@lewislehe/a-history-of-downtown-road-pri... Since then I've written it as an academic paper with a lot more material.
- ebikelaw 9y agoThanks, that is a great contribution to the discussion. I hope in the coming years these charging schemes will be so common that cataloging them becomes impossible!
- lewis500 9y agoCurrently Vancouver is also seriously considering a scheme. I do believe they are going to implement one. Singapore is also switching over to a satellite-based per-km charge.
- MBlume 9y agoWow, that's not nearly enough
- ramblenode 9y agoI won't take a position on this plan until I see the details. There are plenty of neighborhoods south of 60th that aren't congested. And congestion varies greatly by time of day. It would be pretty unfortunate if entities which aren't actually contributing to congestion get swept into this scheme. Delivery trucks need to service businesses in busy areas, but they usually operate in the early morning when traffic is light. Likewise, taxis and rideshares that operate during off-off hours are filling in for the reduced service of the MTA without actually contributing to congestion. A congestion pricing scheme that increases the efficiency of the total transportation system would be excellent, but I am skeptical. Congestion, whether on the subway or the road (or even the sidewalk), is already a negative feedback loop that encourages seeking alternate routes/times. If people are taking congested roadways, they are doing so _in spite_ of all the other options available to them in a city with extensive public transit. I am curious what kind of data informs this plan and whether it is primarily a solution to transit times or just another source of revenue for the MTA.
- stmfreak 9y agoThe article claims there are fewer cars entering the city than a year ago and yet traffic has gotten worse! Seems we can predict the outcome of additional incentives against driving: even worse traffic!
- pimmen 9y agoWe've been implementing these schemes across Europe for a long time. In my home country, both Stockholm and Gothenburg has them and they're unpopular but actually do a lot of good. My parents have finally started taking the train and the tram again which was something they never did before and the data shows that people are driving less in both cities now.