6 ms·
The value systems of the people running this must be severely distorted. Can't torture at home so let's fly people to some dictatorship to get it done there. I
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The value systems of the people running this must be severely distorted. Can't torture at home so let's fly people to some dictatorship to get it done there. I guess it's the same mindset that caused a democratically elected president in Iran to be overthrown and replaced by a dictator in order to save freedom and democracy.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt is the same value system that created Guantanamo Bay Prison.
- maxxxxx 9y agoYep. Forgot to mention that.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoAnd the Phoenix Program: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_Program
- matte_black 9y agoI wouldn’t say it’s their value system, rather it’s a result of the enormous pressure they face. Torture should only be used as a last resort, and when there’s no other hope of getting information that is needed ASAP.
- narrowingorbits 9y agoWhat you describe there is a broken and unusable value system.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt's the value system. Either you follow the laws and values of your country always or you don't. You can't protect values by violating them.
- matte_black 9y agoEasy to say, but in the real world there is a conflict between values and results. Values don’t need protection, they are intangible. In the end what you are protecting is people.
- catawbasam 9y agoPeople must speak up for values and ideals. Otherwise their power will fade. Results without values are hollow.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhile utilitarian arguments can be a factor in an ethical framework they are not beneficial in isolation and will lead to grave injustices. If protecting people would be the real goal then many actions that were committed ostensibly for 'the greater good' were in fact ultimately net negatives and effectively harmed far more people than were protected. Part of the problem with utilitarian arguments is that we never have all the variables. It also should be noted that 'people' tends to be silently redefined as 'our people' and that this further skews the outcome towards the horrific. Before you know it you're torturing people, gassing them or doing other unspeakable things to them because you've worked out some kind of equation where your predicted outcome justifies your horrible actions. Values only matter when there is a price attached to them, it is very easy to have high standards for morality when they are essentially free.
- ImSkeptical 9y agoI think that's a bit extreme and a black and white way of thinking. For example, suppose you're heading an FBI group, and you've got a suicidal terrorist in custody who is part of a plot to detonate a nuclear bomb in LA. You have excellent evidence this guy is involved, and that the terrorists probably have a nuclear bomb in the country, and, if they realize their coconspirator has been captured, they are likely to detonate immediately. The terrorist demands to see his lawyer. Your specialists say you should deny that request, because his lawyer may signal, intentionally or otherwise, the other terrorists. Should you allow the terrorist to meet with his lawyer? Our society's laws say he should be able to see his lawyer. We value that kind of thing. And yet, if you would risk millions of lives to protect this right... Well, that seems perverse to me.
- paganel 9y agoTorture doesn't provide any valuable intelligence results for those doing the torturing, we're not living in "24", the TV series. I know for sure that if I were to be tortured I'd be ready to recognize even the killing of the biblical character Abel if those doing the torturing would ask that from me, and I guess I'm not the only person so predisposed.
- matte_black 9y agoThat’s a myth, if you’re looking for objective verifiable facts you can get some useful information. Also, if you have enough statistical data on torture methods, you can have a probability that a person doesn’t know something based on how long they’ve been actively tortured.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xenadu02 9y agoAll the scientific evidence disagrees with you and so do many former employees and directors of intelligence agencies, so I'd like to see some citations. You don't even have to go into physical torture: recent history is filled with cases where people confessed to crimes under police interrogation, only to have iron-clad evidence show up that they couldn't possibly be responsible. The most effective technique is befriending the suspect, doing nice things for them, then allowing the natural human tendency to reciprocate (and a desire for positive social interactions) work for you. It takes time but gets you much more reliable information - and much more extensive information.
- mcguire 9y ago"...probability that a person doesn’t know something based on how long they’ve been actively tortured." I, actually, have nothing I can say to that. Are you listening to yourself?
- xkcd-sucks 9y agoI mean, the APA does promote good research and also supported torture up until recently when it started attracting attention and became politically untenable. To the extent that it is possible to optimize torture, it has probably been optimized by some pretty competent people.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Can't torture at home so let's fly people to some dictatorship to get it done there." People are tortured in the US all the time. All the time. Ordinary prisons are well-known example, where one can be subject to solitary confinement, denial of medical care, subjection to temperature extremes, beatings, and rape so common that it's the subject of the most common prison-related jokes. Military recruits are often tortured to "toughen them up", as punishment, or ostensibly to prepare them for possible torture at the hands of "The Enemy". Hazings at colleges and universities are often effectively torture.
- remind_me_again 9y agoSo what's your take on why did they fly them overseas. I'm not saying I disagree with you, but why did they do it really?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jonnybgood 9y ago> Military recruits are often tortured to "toughen them up", as punishment, or ostensibly to prepare them for possible torture at the hands of "The Enemy". That couldn’t be further from the truth. It use to be that drill instructors/MTI can hit you. Not anymore. The worse they can do to you is yell in your face and give you a spit shower. They're even required to give you 8 hours of sleep except in special cases. There are many other rules as well and these rules are a big deal these days.
- taxicabjesus 9y agoI suspect "I don't make the rules, I just enforce them" is the general way to get good people to go along with the government's schemes. One of my passengers got 'ordinarily-renditioned' [0] to the county jail. They let her go after a few hours, when the city cops found someone else who actually matched the description of the petty beer thief they were looking for. [0] http://www.taxiwars.org/2017/10/ordinary-rendition-public-servants.html http://www.taxiwars.org/2017/10/ordinary-rendition-public-se... Last month I learned (via facebook) that another of my passengers got arrested (outstanding warrant - he'd missed a court date 2.5 years ago), and is suffering in jail. He's a diabetic, and has to submit to the time-release insulin injection they think he needs or they send him to solitary... I think time-release insulin is probably quite harmful when combined with the jail's starvation diet. It seems to only take a handful of people to start a government-racket. Thereafter they seem to basically keep themselves going, and it takes acts of heroism to shut them down.
- JetSpiegel 9y ago> I suspect "I don't make the rules, I just enforce them" is the general way to get good people to go along with the government's schemes. This did not go well in Nurenberg.
- e12e 9y agoBecause Germany was defeated (largely by Russia, who was promptly fitted as "new" enemy). No one has been convicted for fire bombing dresden, or Hiroshima and Nagasaki - or the fire bombing campaigns in Japan. No one has been convicted over nan king. No one (afaik) have been convicted of us support for the coup in Chile. There's atrocities to go around, only the weak at the international levek gets prosecuted. And while it didn't "go well" in neurnberg - it certainly helped nazi Germany meet many milestones.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 9y agoYes. People don't want to know how the sausage is made, they don't want to break the law, they want to feel good. Delegating to some place outside the legal jurisdictions and and away from their backyards lets them do that. You'd be surprised how many people condone and support it. Even people who on the surface would be opposed to it, they'd vote against if presented in elections. If it happened in the next town over, they might call the politicians. But if they have a way of denying that it is happening at all, they'd be happy to not ask questions and turn the other way.