22 ms·
Getting free of toxic tech culture
- juicyfroot 9y agoQuote: "Staying silent about the unfairness that causes 37% of underrepresented people of color to leave tech helps no one." As a white male... in the new narrative apparently I am colorless.
- Karrot_Kream 9y ago> The refrain of how a startup CEO is going to save humanity is so common that it’s actually uncommon for a CEO to not use saviour language when describing their startup. Cult leaders do the same thing: they create a unique philosophy, imbued with some sort of special message that they alone can see or hear, convince people that only they have the answers for what ails humanity, and use that influence to control the people around them. I agree. I've been working in Silicon Valley for a few years now, and it honestly feels like a page out of Animal Farm. The Orwellian mismatch between rhetoric and action feels like cult-like propaganda to me. I don't know how veterans of the Valley can keep this up.
- jackgolding 9y agoI wonder if any managers can answer this, how do, or do you deal with employees that act within their rights and don't drink the cool-aid? There have been so many times where I have worked beyond the call of duty and on reflection I don't know why I did it - there is a low chance of getting a bonus or raise compared to spending the time actually getting paid to do something and you are in your right to say no (to some extent anyway, I remember a colleague got in trouble for going out for not cancelling his dinner plans instead of waiting hours for someone to come out of a 8 PM meeting.)
- reaperducer 9y ago> employees that act within their rights They fire the employee. I'm not a manager, but I know someone at a startup who, completely within their rights, complained to state regulators when the company's payroll became erratic. Next thing you know, she was out the door. (In the state in question, filing a formal complaint requires the complainant to give their real name and address, etc... and the employer gets a copy of the form with the letter of inquiry from the state.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 9y ago> act within their rights and don't drink the cool-aid? Drinking the cool-aid is generally enforced. I remember working with some Swedes, who brought with them the (to engineers and fellow europeans) refreshing northern honesty/cynicism. Well...suddenly, after a trip to South East Asia to talk to our outsourcers (who were, er, "less than 100% effective") he suddenly started gushing in the typical corporate speak about how amazing and wonderful everything was. All the engineers wondered what had happened to him. Two weeks later he was promoted to director.
- smsm42 9y agoMaybe he already knew he is going to be promoted? Usually my experience is these things actually happen (i.e. decided) a while before they are announced, and if he knew he is going to receive a major promotion of course he'd think everything is wonderful!
- gervase 9y agoIt really, really depends on the company and a whole host of other factors. If you pushed a bug to prod, knocked out all of Australia, then went home and aren't answering your phone because it's after hours and you're not on call, I'm not going to be happy with you. (Not that we would normally push to prod right before going home, but to illustrate the point...) If you work 9-5, M-F, never cause any fires, and hit your milestones, then I'm perfectly satisfied with that. That's just me, though; I intentionally maintain a relatively balanced workplace. Other companies and managers will have different styles. That being said, don't underestimate the importance of likeability [0]; you'll be fighting against human nature and unconscious biases if you do. How that manifests (general friendliness, going to after-hours social events, helping others with tough tasks, etc) will vary by person and team. [0]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-likability-matters-more-at-work-1395788402 https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-likability-matters-more-at-...
- jackgolding 9y agoI guess what I want to understand is if for example you are a tech lead or PM and you "need" to deliver by a certain date and to achieve this you need others to work overtime - how can you do this? I think that is something I would struggle with as a manager or business owner, nearly every manager I know isn't in a position to offer anything for this service and a lot of employees I know who put in the hard yards for a sustained period of time don't get any financial/time reward for it...
- QAPereo 9y agoFrom what I’ve observed, the idea is to work in hell (edit: obviously hyperbole) until enough money is made to work on your own. Needless to say that doesn’t seem to be the majority experience. The carrot is money and security and the dream of fuck you money. The stick is being a code monkey who is still treated like shit, but who can’t even dream of early retirement and personal projects. It’s a shallow philosophy, but there it is. The willingness to take tons of shit from above, and the ability to rationalize the waste of talent seems to be what you’d expect from a glorified casino for billionaires. Variable-Ratio reward training will fuck you up. Edit: I would guess that fear plays a role too. I recall a poster here saying they wished they could change their circumstances, but they look at the guy delivering their pizza and feel terrified that could be them. Edit: Or a mod can just minimize this, but sadly it changes nothing, least of the the reality of your situation.
- smsm42 9y agoI'm not sure conditions in most tech companies are adequately described as "working in hell". I mean, the article above mentions "free cafeteria, gym, yoga rooms, and all night snack bars", and in companies like Google it goes way beyond that, plus salary that is way over the average... pretty much anywhere outside banking industry? plus vacations, medical coverage, 401k and other nice stuff - and then on top of that, you also get a small chance to be a millionaire. Not exactly how the hell looks like.
- kmicklas 9y agoThey give you all that stuff to some degree to cover over how toxic the culture and job is otherwise. Leaving Google was the best decision I ever made despite the fact that I now get none of those things and make significantly less money.
- QAPereo 9y agoAh yes... perks. Makes those endless late nights a bit less awful. Plus you get to work on such wonderful stuff! The Juicero team is probably still swollen with um... pride. Above average salary paired with wasaay above average cost of living and nightmare commutimg. Plus a chance at striking it rich which is somewhere between playing Powerball and the nickel slots. But hey, at least most of you love what you do, and wouldn’t choose to use your skills in a more productive way. I’m sure that a group who talks endlessly about FOSS doesn’t mind Google’s vision. Sure the FB team believes in privacy, but just one more pull on the slots! Edit: @Dang I disagree, and your dislike of my style stopped bothering me a while ago. So save your breath for threatening people with orders of magnitude more time here than me with bans, and then hilariously pleading with their sockpuppets to respect that ban. I am not impressed.
- smsm42 9y agoI've been in SV for a decade now and I am not observing anything cult-like. I haven't worked for companies like Google or Facebook or any other giant behemoths, so no idea how things are there, but in other places it's pretty far from a cult where I am. Of course, marketing sometimes goes a bit over the board, and each release of version 8.4 is the best thing that happened to humanity since v8.3 was released and before it's time to release v8.5. But that's kind of expected, nobody I know takes it as a literal truth. And of course there are mission statements that talk about improving human condition and expanding horizons and saving the world. Sometimes it happens, at least to a measure, sometimes it doesn't, but that's not usually what you're thinking the whole day about, and even not something you think about every week or every month. And of course (almost) each startup CEO thinks his (or her) startup is going to change the world, or at least some part of it. That's how you should think if you're getting into a startup, otherwise it's not worth the trouble, the stress and the extremely high chance of failure. Of course the CEO believes she (or he) found some special thing nobody thought of before and some unique vision nobody had before - otherwise how the startup could take off the ground at all? And really, describing giving up free gym, yoga class and cafeteria as "something horrible happening to you"... I can't even find adequate words to describe how wrong this is.
- Karrot_Kream 9y ago> Of course, marketing sometimes goes a bit over the board, and each release of version 8.4 is the best thing that happened to humanity since v8.3 was released and before it's time to release v8.5. But that's kind of expected, nobody I know takes it as a literal truth. > And of course (almost) each startup CEO thinks his (or her) startup is going to change the world, or at least some part of it. That's how you should think if you're getting into a startup, otherwise it's not worth the trouble, the stress and the extremely high chance of failure. I don't think this should be an "of course". This article highlights toxic tech culture, namely a culture found in tech that is toxic. Marketing is not specific to tech, nor are small businesses. Why does Uber tell me they're going to "make transportation as freely available as running water" but not Loreal's new shampoo? Why does the small chain of bike repair shops in my area, also taking the stress and high risk of starting their own business, not exhort about how their bike repair shop will change the world of bikes forever? This overboard marketing and out-of-touch mission statements are much more commonly found in tech than in elsewhere. This article discusses a culture formed by overboard marketing and out-of-touch mission statements and labels it as toxic. Moreover, there's an argument to be made about a field that oft labels itself as "meritocratic" relies on these hyperbolic forms of marketing and mission statements to do business, rather than a more traditional, "stodgy" business.
- acchow 9y agoCan you describe in what ways SV feels like Animal Farm? > The Orwellian mismatch between rhetoric and action feels like cult-like propaganda to me. Can you list out a few of these actions?
- j4ship 9y agowork life balance is double speak for : your life is your work an extreme cynical view , but that is the beauty of it , its hidden in plain sight. How can a company give indefinite vacation, only if it hires and prevays a culture of overwork? The type of people hired will never take that vacation. Im not right , but im not wrong. The point is "work life balance" and "unlimited vacation" are not clear ideas on the reality of the environments and for some they can be a rose colored glass over the true experience. SV is very much the benevolent dictator ... giving you everything you could ask for , just be its slave. Can a slave only be a slave for 10 years and leave? Can a job that pays over 6 figures feel like slavery? I answer yes to the latter. You are payed well , but you are not respected as a developer. This will only change when we become the heads of our industry and not the tools to be used by money men.
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoMaybe I should tell the (abridged) tale of XMPP. Once upon a time, XMPP was an open standard that allowed FB, Google, and independent clients federate at once. The reason Google and FB were able to become such popular messengers is because they allowed all sorts of clients to federate with them. This was the world of Pidgin, Trillian, GTalk, Adium, and others. Then Google and FB both closed off their XMPP support, citing overhead in maintaining a federated service. Facebook thought it was a better use of its resources to build a Snapchat clone named Slingshot. Google decided it was a better use of its resources to build a social network named Google+. Animal Farm: "Four legs good, two legs bad" Google: "Don't be evil" Animal Farm: "Four legs good, two legs better" Google: "You can make money without doing evil" [1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil#cite_note-GooglePhil-11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil#cite_note-Goog... In the old days, this was called Embrace, Extend, Extinguish.
- 9y ago
- dang 9y agoOk, shall we see if we can have an interesting conversation here? I've temporarily turned off flags on the submission, but if the thread goes flameward we will send it down the flamewar chute. All: if you comment in this thread, make sure your comment is thoughtful and edit out any flamey or trollish bits before hitting the button. The same goes for any thread, of course: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 9y agoThe moderation mechanisms are the very tools that enforce this cult-like mentality. And threat of suppression, of course.
- dang 9y agoBit of an awkward moment for a searing indictment, as we'd just turned off flags on the OP. With suppression like that, who needs promotion? It's a common misconception, but Hacker News really isn't identified with or immersed in Silicon Valley. Those of us moderating it are largely on the margins of SV and always have been, and the community by no means has its center of gravity there. It's globally distributed and on the whole rather anti-SV in orientation. (The parent was originally a reply to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 but I detached it to contain this offtopicness.)
- neveroffensive 9y agoIf you're actually asserting HN doesn't censor, and wouldn't censor even more if people actually felt free to express their true opinions here, I question you're intellectual honesty.
- dang 9y agoPeople use the word 'censor' to mean so many different things, it's not possible to assert anything coherent in general. We do some of those things, there are others we don't do, and it's not as if any of it is secret. Some people like to ask questions about this stuff and get answers, others prefer to rage against the machine. To each their own.
- danso 9y agoHe literally mentions being on the moderating team so I don't know how you interpret that as him "asserting HN doesn't censor".
- QAPereo 9y agoYou turned off flags, but now you’re doing something else yourself. You’re being honest, but not really telling the whole story. Your thumb is very much on the scale however, where existing community sentiment doesn’t do the job. Edit: I didn’t intend to be cryptic or confuse you. I mean just that proclaiming you’ve put one of many tools on the shelf for this thread in no way implies what you tried to imply.
- oceanghost 9y agoI've written software for Intel, Nintendo, Samsung, LG, DirecTV, Applied Materials, Microsoft, and Apple to name a few. My last project was the basis for an entire business line at a 500m/yr company. I am unemployable because I'm a white male whose in his 40s, has a family, and because somehow, in this industry experience is a bad thing. It amazes me how intolerant of age and differing opinion tech culture is.
- untog 9y agoOf course experience isn't a bad thing! You having pesky distractions like children, however... how can you be trusted to put the company's deadlines first in a situation like that? It's just that... the thing is... you're just not a good culture fit.
- jamiepenney 9y agoFrom personal experience, this is the problem rather than age. God forbid you aren't purely a machine that takes money and produces vastly more money for the company.
- gf263 9y agoYeah I somehow doubt that’s the reason.
- reaperducer 9y agoYou sound young. His story is far from unique.
- ikeyany 9y agoDo you honestly think you'd even get to where you are if you were, say, black? Do you think you'd want to be a part of such a hostile crowd who assumes less of your ability and that none of your credentials are deserved due to handouts?
- oceanghost 9y ago
- mpweiher 9y agoAs usual, the actual numbers don't back up the narrative. For example, significantly more men in the study left due to unfairness than women do: 40% vs. 31%. So either women are treated more fairly or these numbers don't mean anything, yet you would never know it from the text, which is all about the horrible things that happen to women. Hmmm...
- whatshisface 9y agoThe willingness to slog though abusive working conditions is one of the most highly-selected-for trait in tech. Mature people are, on average, are less willing to do this than young people of the customarily military age range.
- gervase 9y agoI think this point (the military age thing) is often overlooked in discussions about [age|race|gender|socioeconomic] diversity in tech. Rather than a single problem, I think it's actually two separate, intersecting problems. The first is a recruitment/sourcing problem. There are many demonstrable factors, such as educational availability or social norms/pressure, that serve primarily to influence entrance rates into tech among different groups. The second problem is a retention problem. Other social and cultural traits, like the aforementioned willingness to "sacrifice for the cause", place work above family, and so on, are also not evenly distributed among different [age|race|gender|socioeconomic] demographics; I think these traits (or lack thereof) are more strongly correlated with leaving (or being forced out) of tech. To some extent, these might also serve as cooling effects for entrance as well, but I'd hesitate to make any claims about the strength of that effect. Perhaps by explicitly addressing these two issues independently, rather than by evaluating a "where are we at this current moment statistically" snapshot, this issue can be tackled more effectively? I think many current approaches fall into the trap of evaluating the snapshot, effectively saying "How has it come to this?!", and then trying to treat the symptom, rather than the cause.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments or flamebait here. What you say isn't remotely plausible, since if it were true, software companies would be filled with non-programmers. Edit: I mean instead of programmers.
- neveroffensive 9y ago> We reject the idea that it is the “responsibility” of marginalized people to stay in toxic tech culture despite abuse and discrimination, solely to improve the diversity of tech. It is the “responsibility” of marginalized people to stay in toxic tech culture despite abuse and discrimination because they want tech jobs. Some forms of abuse and discrimination are normal aspects of life for everyone. Other forms are completely in peoples heads. And yes, there are some forms, in rare cases, which are legitimate unacceptable abuse/discrimination. These cases are rare based on all the evidence I've seen.
- trhway 9y ago>What is toxic tech culture? Toxic tech cultures are those that demean and devalue you as holistic, multifaceted human beings. Toxic tech cultures are those that prioritize profits and growth over human and societal well being. Toxic tech cultures are those that treat you as replaceable cogs within a system of constant churn and burnout. has there been any factory floor, farm, private or government office where things have been different? Except may be for a situation like a tenured professor at Stanford. Or a 4 star general who after having been a cog for like 30 years finally gets to be the one burning and replacing the cogs at his will/choice. If anything, i think tech is among the most progressive places, if only for the fact that one can easily switch jobs instead of suffering for years for example under harassing boss like it was before and still is in the other industries where job market is worse. With employees having such freedom, the tech companies and management are forced to treat the employees better than at the other industries. I wonder how many of the people complaining about toxic tech culture did actually work at non-tech places.
- reaperducer 9y ago> has there been any factory floor, farm, private or government office where things have been different? Yes. It's the 1930's anymore. Especially in the last 20 years even grubby industries have come around to treating their labor with dignity. At least in part because of legal liability.
- lutorm 9y agoI guess you didn't read the NY Times articles about the working conditions for women in General Motors' factories?
- mpweiher 9y ago> "prioritize profits and growth over human and societal well being" As in: what every corporation is, by law, required to do. If it doesn't, lawsuits follow.
- geofft 9y ago
- kmicklas 9y agoI left Google for very many of the reasons mentioned in the article and I'm a white male. So I can only imagine how hard it must be for minorities. Thankfully I had the opportunity to make this change early in my career, although my financial situation is suffering dearly for it. And it's hard to swallow when everyone you know is making 2x your salary and just about all of them have a bunch of family money as well. (I grew up thinking I was upper middle class and somehow was the poorest person in pretty much all my social circles when I was at Google. The tech bubble is real.) Keeping perspective and realizing that even if you leave toxic tech and take a pay cut you'll probably still be in the upper echelons of the world inequality distribution is hard but super important. And you'll realize that rich people are on average way shittier and probably not worth hanging out with anyway.
- xya3453 9y agoA rich man desires a simple life. A poor man a rich life. There is little sense chasing to play in a game you can never win.
- throwaway1748 9y agoCould constantly identifying oneself as being 'marginalized' contribute to the feeling of being an outsider? As another commenter pointed out, the Kapor Center data is not nearly as damning as this piece suggests. Many of the reported reasons for leaving show similar numbers between genders & races. Sexual harassment is clearly a bigger problem for women than men, but not as drastic as this article claims. The Kapor study shows 10% of women surveyed leaving for sexual harassment, but also shows 8% of men leaving for that reason.
- tomlock 9y agoIt could. But what evidence is there of that?
- throwaway1748 9y agoI have no data here, just posing a question. I think it would be an interesting hypothesis on which to run a survey. Personally, I've found that self-limiting beliefs have held me back in a number of areas — especially around confidence. Breaking past those has been very important in my life.
- golemotron 9y agoEvery study of confirmation bias. If you see yourself as an outsider you look for evidence of it and it becomes your worldview.
- tomlock 9y agoAlright, but how do you determine it isn't a justified belief?
- golemotron 9y agoThe real question is: how would you ever know if it isn't?
- 9y ago
- leroy_masochist 9y agoThe tips in here on topics like building relationships outside work, being financially prudent and learning how to say no are all good nuggets of advice. With that said, I thought that the article's title was kind of ironic because in my opinion, the intersectional identity politics espoused by the authors is itself one of the most toxic aspects of contemporary tech culture. It's the part of working at a mature venture-funded startup in SV that I miss the least, by far.
- adamsea 9y agoA) With respect, your experience and the author's experience may vary, for a variety of reasons, so I'm not sure it makes sense to pit one set of experiences against another, so to speak. B) Would you be willing to clarify what was toxic about your experience with SV startups as you described? C) Realistically, without denying the problems which probably do exist with "intersectionaly identity politics", etc, it seems pretty clear (as in there are studies, etc) that sexual harassment is one of the most toxic aspects, not only of tech, but of contemporary business and American life. Discrimination based on the color of one's skin is up there as well. So it does seem a bit disingenuous to point out the flaws in ways in which people are trying to ameliorate these problems without acknowledging the problems themselves, and/or to imply that said flaws are more pervasive than the damaging behaviors which they are a response to.
- malvosenior 9y agoThe answer is and always has been to judge people by the output of their work and nothing else. As soon as you bring identity politics into to equation, you’ve lost because many people will (rightly) take attacks on white people and men as racist and sexist respectively.
- adamsea 9y agoI concur that judging someone by the output of their work as opposed to their sex or skin color is extremely important, however, I believe that by itself is a narrow and inaccurate view of the whole situation/problem. In fact, acknowledging the vastness of the problem is a major challenge in and of itself. > As soon as you bring identity politics into to equation, you’ve lost because many people will (rightly) take attacks on white people and men as racist and sexist respectively. So, it's pretty much been like this but times a thousand for women and people whose skin is not pinkish white. Of course some people of color are racist towards white people, and of course some women are sexist towards men. However to acknowledge this without acknowledging the vast amounts of institutionalized and socialized sexism/racism in American culture (which doesn't just come out in tech - look at the racist/sexist behavior of the current President) is a bit ludicrous. It's like talking about optimizing performance in one small domain while ignoring the major bottleneck!
- tlb 9y agoI predict people will claim "our culture isn't that toxic. Some of those things happen, but they don't bother me much." If any non-zero subset of reasonable people are so offended by a behavior that they'd leave the industry because of it, we have to cut it out. So don't ask "would this bother me?" Ask "would it bother someone?" And since you can't predict this from inside your head, you have to rely on firsthand accounts of people being bothered. This seems like a good overview of such accounts.
- j4ship 9y agoI disagree. I am not responsible for others feelings. There should be clear rules of conduct at any job and a clear process of enforcement. This make the situation fair and certain. One easy rule is that if someone says "Only talk to me about work." then the other person has to respect it. No forcing of social acceptance , no shaming the other to believe what you believe, just focus on what you were hired for. This is a standard taught to many managers to keep the company out of harassment issues , its very robotic unemotional but its clear and will allow different groups to work together as long as this rule is enforced. Basically we should not have to worry about a toxic culture because you should not be forced into one when you work. You should just be able to work and separate yourself from your task in any emotional way. [California dev, 8 years, have held manager position]
- tlb 9y agoAs a manager, you're absolutely responsible for your team member's feelings. Both morally and practically because if they feel bad at work, they'll leave.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- autogn0me 9y agoI disagree. You are responsible for YOURSELF. If you are being ugly or talking shit - you are responsible for your actions. Saying "you are absolutely responsible for someone else's feelings" is the bat-ass craziest thing I have ever heard [It is not lost on me that I'm making a snarky comment in this thread ;)]. An example: I am talking to someone and make a comment that the other person interprets as threatening or demeaning. They do not ask me about it but they play a narrative inside their mind about how I am threatening them. This is some fictional narrative in their mind. I have no clue this is happening. How could I be responsible for this? It is in their mind. It is incumbent on the person who feels awkward to ask for clarification. This is not "extra work" or forcing the down-trodden to work harder - it is clarity. We do it all the time in conversation. "I'm sorry, but when you say X are you meaning Y?" And you give the person a chance to clear it up. Now. Where the adulting comes off the track appears to be in the hyper-Ayn-Randian culture of technology/start-ups where people who are incredibly self-centered feel they can "vent" in the open and expect others to "deal with it". This is absolutely unacceptable. And most people who act this way - are usually so self-centered - they dont KNOW they are acting this way. It is unacceptable but when you ask then "did you mean X?" it gives them some space to be clear. If they really did mean to threaten, demean and provoke someone else -- they will be clear they DID intend for that to be case. But they had an opportunity to be clear about it. Narcissism is rampant in start-up scene (imho). Likely its just on the rise in general in USA population. One of the things that is great about a narcissist is that THEY WILL OFTEN TELL YOU THEY ARE A NARCISSIST! (google, how to find out if someone is a narcissist) They are quite proud of their eliteness and expectation to entitlements. When you ask them for clarity -- they will be clear. And that is when there is no need to have some fictional narrative being built in your mind -- you will KNOW for sure because you have asked them and they have told you. Regardless. Be clear. And most importantly -- if you HEAR someone asking for clarification -- give them positive feedback. Clear, kind, and even tempered rational communication is what we need more of in the world and less reactivity.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoHaving read most of it, I think it could use a better title. The actual title sounds like it is smearing all of tech culture as toxic. This is not true. Maybe something a little more qualified, like "If your tech company has a toxic culture, this is how to escape it." I got more out of this than I expected to. It helps explain my reluctance to join groups marketed as for women in tech. I have a Certificate in GIS. I'm a blogger and have been for years, which makes me tech savvy compared to a lot of people I know. I am pretty comfortable on HN. But I am not a programmer and I never managed to get a job in GIS and I do not self identify as a woman in tech. I self identify as a writer, though I still hope to learn to code and would like to write an app or game or similar. The working for free thing. I wonder how much this is experienced differently by different demographics. I did a lot of volunteer work as a military wife. I have personally struggled with the fact that, yes, people tell me they value what I do, but, no, they don't want to pay me. Pats on the head doesn't keep food on the table. I am increasingly reluctant to do volunteer work. I am willing to contribute to not for profits, but in recent months I have been very up front about limiting the scope of it. I looked over a bunch of websites for a non profit and wrote up a list of changes that need to happen. If they ever give me login credentials, I am willing to do the initial overhaul. I am not willing to commit to ongoing maintenance. I would like to see these websites improved. I am willing to role up my sleeves and do something to make that happen. I am not willing to become slave labor. I think this is sort of an unrecognized dark underbelly of things like open source. Someone needs to do the work and there is no mechanism for paying them. The older I get, the more reluctant I am to accept the idea that someone needs to do work that no one will pay for. If you don't value it enough to actually pay me, then maybe it isn't really something you need or deserve. Yet there are things I am still willing to do that I have no idea how to monetize. I am working on launching a project currently to help people, including homeless people, figure out how to develop a flexible income. I have no plans currently to monetize it, nor even set up a non profit. It's just me and a website and an email list and tentative plans to hold in person meetings. It isn't that I won't do stuff for free. But I am much more picky about it being something I want to do, not something someone else wants me to do. I increasingly look narrowly upon the latter form of volunteer work as a polite request for slave labor.
- peterwwillis 9y agoWhat is the point of allowing discussion? HN would not allow a post on this topic from an opposing viewpoint to get to the front page. Moreover, this particular point of view is from a radical organization - you can't really have intellectual discourse with people who refuse to see any other position than theirs.
- tlb 9y agoWhat is the opposing viewpoint? Is it articulated clearly somewhere?
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 and marked it off-topic. Your first point is empirically false, though I'm too lazy to look for links. The second point seems circular, but doesn't matter in any case, since the idea here is to have good conversation with each other.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- geofft 9y agoWhat is the viewpoint you think this post holds? That parts of tech culture are toxic? That all of it is? Plenty of posts hit the front page every day holding the opposing viewpoint. And as people who refuse to see other viewpoints go—would you say the same about posts from people who believe that, say, mass surveillance is bad, or net neutrality is good, or Apple should not cooperate with subpoenas for user data? The authors of those posts are also very unlikely to see opposing positions.
- adamsea 9y ago> HN would not allow a post on this topic from an opposing viewpoint to get to the front page. Proof? > Moreover, this particular point of view is from a radical organization Define "radical." > you can't really have intellectual discourse with people who refuse to see any other position than theirs. How does one tell if this is the case? How does one tell _which_ party refuses to see things from another position? How does one tell if it is in fact miscommunication, or lack of a shared understanding? How does one tell if in fact one of the parties is not discussing in good faith?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoI wonder if a lot of toxicity in tech culture is that it is billed as a lifestyle and identity more than just a job. One of the big drivers for civil rights came from the experience in WWII. In war, there is an overarching purpose. You want to achieve your mission, and survive the war to make it home to your family. The identity of those who help you achieve those goals doesn't matter as much (very few people care about the skin color of someone who saves their life). What if tech became less of an identity and more of just a job that you did with your co-workers not to "change to world", but just to make money?
- iamdave 9y agoWhat if tech became less of an identity and more of just a job that you did with your co-workers not to "change to world", but just to make money? GREAT question. I've often pondered this. Shooting from the hip I would wager this question is easier to answer if one considers the source of one's income. I'm a political science graduate, who fell into tech early in his career. For me, tech is just a job that's paying for my continued studies. It's a means to an end. It's why I absolutely loathe talking about work when I'm not at work, and in general talking about what I do for a living. Not for a lack of pride, I am definitely proud of where I am and how I got here given the circumstances, it's just not my passion and no I'm sorry I don't want to troubleshoot your tech issues at 6:30 on a Thursday or any other time. It's nothing personal, it's just I do this sometimes upwards of 60 hours a week and outside of those hours, I'd rather have a normal life where I can do things that appeal to me. No offers of buying me a six pack or a free dinner can really change that. Different strokes for different folks, though --and that's perfectly OK if other folks DO want to live this way through their chosen professions. The answer to your question is probably ultimately answered by YMMV.
- bloaf 9y ago“Only those who decline to scramble up the career ladder are interesting as human beings. Nothing is more boring than a man with a career.” --Solzhenitsyn I think there's probably more to your observation than meets the eye. Specifically, there is a kind of dilemma that faces most workers these days. They can either A) get a nice, safe, "boring" career, or B) do something on their own (which is risky). The people who choose A) are the kind of people who want stability and comfort while the people who choose B) typically do so because they have some kind of goal or motivation that they're willing to endure some resistance and risk to achieve. I personally suspect lots of programmers are joining startups expecting A, when the culture is closer to that of B (since the founders of any given startup have, almost by definition, chosen B.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wcarron 9y agoI think this was well written. There were a few instances where, upon first reading it, I objected. But rereading it, I thought the language used was chosen well. I have one main gripe, though: The scope limitation to tech. > "Toxic tech cultures are those that demean and devalue you as holistic, multifaceted human beings. Toxic tech cultures are those that prioritize profits and growth over human and societal well being. Toxic tech cultures are those that treat you as replaceable cogs within a system of constant churn and burnout. This is __not__ a tech specific problem. This is a systemic aspect of labor in an overly-capitalist society. Not bashing capitalism, either. But, spare me the 'woe is me, tech bros are out to get us'. Sure, some are. But these problems exist in every industry; the service industry, Hollywood and film, architecture and construction, finance, etc. As I said, I think the rest of the article was well written and on-topic. That, though, is trying to paint rice grains with a broom.
- tptacek 9y agoIn fact, it very probably is a tech-specific problem. Among the STEM fields, CS is almost uniquely imbalanced. STEM fields in general range from ~30-55% women, and those fields include things like Mathematics --- anyone who has gone to an academic cryptography workshop has probably noticed how many more women there are in the room --- which are strong proxies for CS ability. And, of course, among the professions in general, the difference is even more stark; compared to law, we're stuck in the 1960's.
- dralley 9y agoThe irony is that there were probably significantly more female computer scientists and programmers in the 1960s than there are now. The industry has regressed severely from the early days.
- crunchatized 9y agoThe extra irony is that's because computer programming was considered "women's work" in those early days, as basically a form of clerical work, like being a secretary. So it was one of the few occupations that was traditionally socially acceptable for women to be in.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoI agree with essentially everything in the article — and I'm not a marginalized type (white male, actually). • Avoid the "cult-like" trappings. • Avoid "genius worship" and call bullshit on the "reality distortion field". • Get a life (that is, a life outside of work – build stuff in your garage, hike, play in a band, paint, whatever). • Stay healthy. You're valuable to the corporation, they will allow for you to take exercise breaks, go home when you're exhausted, use your vacation time. It probably isn't exclusive to the tech industry — I suspect the same is true on Wall Street. Perhaps it is the Temple of Modern Corporate Culture that we should shun. And good advice is still good advice for the non-marginalized.
- thiht 9y ago>• Get a life (that is, a life outside of work – build stuff in your garage, hike, play in a band, paint, whatever). I notice a trend in being demeaning towards people not wanting to do anything besides computing/tech. Why is that acceptable? Is my life worse because I don't do "hiking" or some other stuff? I like spending my free time coding, and I hate hearing I should do "something better with my life".
- mcv 9y ago"Build something in your garage" could be tech related. But it's important to do things other than work.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoThe image of the tech titan that got started in their garage was the standard thing not that long ago. I actually can't remember the last time I saw it. Now it seems like it's "get in the ground floor on someone else's world-changing startup." Is this just my limited perspective or has the narrative really shifted?
- JKCalhoun 9y agoI don't see anything I said that is demeaning. I didn't say it was a shitty thing to not have a life outside tech. If you never get burned out or otherwise disillusioned with "tech", more power to you. I suspect most of us eventually find we need something more in our lives though — I was addressing those people (and I suspect the article was as well).
- amyboyd 9y agoThis feels like the perfect timing for me to read this. I just quit my job on Sunday after 1.5 years of trying and failing to get on with the CEO. I'm not sure I want to stay in tech at all. I'd be interested in hearing other people's stories about changing careers entirely -- to sales (I'm not a people person but trying hard to learn the soft skills), to writing a TV show or movie (theatrics and drama are fun), to non-tech biz dev? Would love to hear people's stories and how they succeeded or failed to change career, and if they regretted it? It's taken 8 years to realise it, but now I realise the tech startup culture is absolutely horrible and -- as they article says -- full of narcissists. If you don't realise how bad the culture is, I'd recommend introspecting a bit (wish I did this sooner).
- xya3453 9y agoTech culture may be considered toxic, in comparison to 90% of other industries it's a utopia.
- x0x0 9y agoYou may be interested in eevee's story: https://eev.ee/blog/2015/06/09/i-quit-the-tech-industry/ https://eev.ee/blog/2015/06/09/i-quit-the-tech-industry/ My partner left finance to work in medicine. She makes a lot less money and likes it a lot better. I dunno where you live, but becoming a physician assistant can be a pretty good gig: much less school, pretty good salaries, pretty defined hours, very little debt. Personally, I worked at a series of toxic startups and needed two years away to not loath programming. I regret nothing about leaving tech the first time, and after returning, my biggest regret is waiting so long to start my own company. Closely followed by tolerating so many shitty bosses. It helped me to have friends that did things besides work; workaholics are very common in sfbay. Dunno if that helps, but good luck.
- GoodLuckDang 9y agoHi, Dang. You've been banning me for years. I feel like we have a pretty solid relationship together. You see, my resume is so solid that it gets me into any tech company I want for at least an interview or a tour. I make it a point to get onto their corporate inter/intranet and make a HackerNews account and post a valid contrarian position that you're guarenteed to always find a way to distort as a violation of guidelines. I repeat the process until your systems automatically ban/shadowban the entire IP/network from creating new accounts. And when I'm not doing this, the people I've trained to do this are out there doing the same. You don't even know how many opinions of potentially "correct people" you've preemptively stifled because of my efforts. :D I've been doing this for years. The more overtly activist Silicon Valley gets, the more effective I become at disguising myself as a socialist, the more network access I get to the "correct people" with "correct opinions", the more networks your system automatically prevents from creating new accounts. Seems petty? Perhaps I could be more efficient? Why am I even doing this? I'm sure you could conjure up a myriad of reasons that make sense to you, so there's no need to give you anything more beyond that. You're a smart guy, you'll invent something. In fact, I'm relying on that self-healing moral plasticity. You'll never see how you are part of the toxic tech culture. I have absolutely no interest in ever making you see this or changing your mind. The only interest I have is exploiting your moral plasticity. Thanks for building and maintaining those censorship tools over the years. I can't wait to steer them against the people you claim you're protecting. And I really can't wait for your moral plasticity to justify the hijacking. Don't forget to leak the IP to your "secret" network of resistance collaborators. My honeypots are waiting. <3
- fphhotchips 9y ago> Early on, Valerie realized that she unconsciously thought of literally every single job other than software engineer as “for people who weren’t good enough to be a software engineer” – and that she thought this because other software engineers had been telling her that for her entire career. This spoke to me for two reasons. 1) Plenty of professions are like this. Lawyers, consultants, doctors, bankers, stock brokers etc. Everyone thinks that their profession is the 'best' one. 2) As someone in tech, but not a Software Developer, the number of times I've gone into technical conferences (yes, even the 'inclusive' ones) and got the feeling of being lesser just because I don't write code for a living bothers me. In particular, the stigma associated with being in customer facing roles (particularly sales) is strong.
- busterarm 9y agoAs a software developer who goes to infosec conferences, i frequently feel "lesser" because everyone seems to be working on cooler stuff than me. Then I go to their meetups and they tell me how much they hate their jobs and I feel better. The truth is ultimately you do what you do because you can't get out of bed in the morning and do anything else -- if you don't feel that way, switch to what motivates you. If you do feel that way though, lean into it hard! I switched from a non-dev tech career to development and it has transformed my life in a very positive way. That said though, the developer-oriented tech conferences definitely skew towards "rockstar" in terms of who is popular and I mean that word in the most negative sense possible. I have found this especially true of the "inclusive" ones. I feel sick around personality cults and avoid more and more of these. As someone who develops for a non-technical industry, I've gotten a lot of sneers from other developers when I explain my company and role. At the end of the day though, I have 10x as much responsibility and appreciation at my job than they do in theirs. I'm leaving my job in ~2 weeks and I've had half a dozen exit interviews with people in different roles here and even a C-level (a real C-level, not a startup C-level) from another office across the country flying in just to have a meeting and say goodbye to me. How many "average developers" (because that's all I am) get to have that level of impact?
- eanzenberg 9y agoNot just for dev. I went to NIPS last year (and am in DS at startups in SF) and about 80% of the time as you introduce yourself the other person just stares at your affiliation on your tag. I went to a company (nameless) afterparty where the host DS literally stared at my tag for 2 seconds with a look of some serious disgust of how did I happen to get in without Google/FB/Apple/etc. or MIT/Stanford affiliation.
- HowdyDang 9y agoHi, Dang. You've been banning me for years. I feel like we have a pretty solid relationship. You see, my resume is so solid that it gets me into any tech company I want for at least an interview or a tour. I make it a point to get onto their corporate inter/intranet and make a HackerNews account and post a valid contrarian position that you're guaranteed to always find a way to distort as a violation of guidelines. I repeat the process until your systems automatically ban/shadowban the entire IP/network from creating new accounts. And when I'm not doing this, the people I've trained to do this are out there doing the same. There's a whole lot of people who really don't like the colonial intentions of HackerNews moderation and censorship. You don't even know how many opinions of potentially "correct people" you've preemptively stifled because of my efforts. :D I've been doing this for years. The more overtly activist Silicon Valley gets, the more effective I become at disguising myself as a socialist, the more network access I get to the "correct people" with "correct opinions", the more networks your system automatically prevents from creating new accounts. Seems petty? Perhaps I could be more efficient? Why am I even doing this? I'm sure you could conjure up a myriad of reasons that make sense to you, so there's no need to give you anything more beyond that. You're a smart guy, you'll invent something. In fact, I'm relying on that amazing capacity to defer to that self-healing moral plasticity you bathe your ego in. You'll never see how you are part of the toxic tech culture. I have absolutely no interest in ever making you see this or changing your mind. The only interest I have is exploiting your moral plasticity. Thanks for building and maintaining those censorship tools over the years. I can't wait to hijack the psychology behind these tools and steer it against the people you claim you're protecting. And I'm truly looking forward to how your moral plasticity justifies it. Don't forget to leak the IP address, psychographic signatures, and behavioral profile of this account to your "secret" network of resistance collaborators. My honeypots are waiting to map your support system. <3
- pmarreck 9y agoI'm wondering how much of this is endemic to ANY male-dominated profession, if you factor in that "tech industry people" are probably disproportionately likely to blog about their experiences. I think biology makes it very difficult to see everyone as essentially human-fungible and not as (even a little bit) their gender. It is extremely difficult to stay genderblind (dear non-cisgender people: I'm really sorry. It seems like a very hard path.) So I think you're going to get in-group and out-group type phenomenons across professions with asymmetric gender membership, regardless. The problem of course is when those become oppressive. I don't know what the easy way out of this problem is. Sensitivity training? Simply trying to have more friends of both genders so you can get more perspective and therefore have more empathy and less... toxicity?
- x0x0 9y agoValerie's note about giving people unpaid labor only to see them pitch a fit when you eventually stop really strikes home. I continued building some biological image analysis software on a part-time basis after leaving grad school because I found it interesting, thought the science was important, and enjoyed the feeling of contributing in some small way to science. I stopped because a tenured professor got really aggressive and extraordinarily rude about his needs not being addressed in what he considered a timely manner -- to an unpaid contributor who now had a full time job. There's nothing like being yelled at for daring to take a vacation by someone who isn't paying you. I've also virtually stopped contributing to open source for similar reasons. It only takes a couple demanding lazy assholes helping themselves into your inbox to poison any interest I have in sharing my work. Our industry is really willing to actively exploit people. See eg the difference in financial returns to founders vs employees, even (particularly!) when the startup doesn't succeed. If you have an enormous bias against non-tech jobs, and all your friends actively reinforce that, you really need new friends.
- ucaetano 9y agoI'd add another one: move away from the Bay Area, even if just for a year and even if still working in a technology company. Often, just stepping out of the bubble and checking out what the real world looks like will provide you with plenty of perspective. If you move or visit emerging markets (outside their little tech bubbles especially) you will gain even more perspective. Sadly, most people in the SF Bay Area don't have a clue about how emerging markets work, and how their users live. And surprisingly this seems to be valid even for those who came from the same emerging markets. Step out, even if only temporarily. PS: My main criticism of the article is lumping many external factors in "toxic tech culture", but that's minor enough not to matter in the bigger context.
- HowdyDang 9y agoHi, Dang. You've been banning me for years. I feel like we have a pretty solid relationship. You see, my resume is so solid that it gets me into any tech company I want for at least an interview or a tour. I make it a point to get onto their corporate inter/intranet and make a HackerNews account and post a valid contrarian position that you're guaranteed to always find a way to distort as a violation of guidelines. I repeat the process until your systems automatically ban/shadowban the entire IP/network from creating new accounts. And when I'm not doing this, the people I've trained to do this are out there doing the same. There's a whole lot of people who really don't like the colonial intentions of HackerNews moderation and censorship. You don't even know how many opinions of potentially "correct people" you've preemptively stifled because of my efforts. :D I've been doing this for years. The more overtly activist Silicon Valley gets, the more effective I become at disguising myself as a socialist, the more network access I get to the "correct people" with "correct opinions", the more networks your system automatically prevents from creating new accounts. Seems petty? Perhaps I could be more efficient? Why am I even doing this? I'm sure you could conjure up a myriad of reasons that make sense to you, so there's no need to give you anything more beyond that. You're a smart guy, you'll invent something. In fact, I'm relying on that amazing capacity to defer to that self-healing moral plasticity you bathe your ego in. You'll never see how you are part of the toxic tech culture. I have absolutely no interest in ever making you see this or changing your mind. The only interest I have is exploiting your moral plasticity. Thanks for building and maintaining those censorship tools over the years. I can't wait to hijack the psychology behind these tools and steer it against the people you claim you're protecting. And I'm truly looking forward to how your moral plasticity justifies it. Don't forget to leak the IP address, psychographic signatures, and behavioral profile of this account to your "secret" network of resistance collaborators. My honeypots are waiting to map your support system. <3 <3
- HowdyDang 9y agoHi, Dang. You've been banning me for years. I feel like we have a pretty solid relationship. You see, my resume is so solid that it gets me into any tech company I want for at least an interview or a tour. I make it a point to get onto their corporate inter/intranet and make a HackerNews account and post a valid contrarian position that you're guaranteed to always find a way to distort as a violation of guidelines. I repeat the process until your systems automatically ban/shadowban the entire IP/network from creating new accounts. And when I'm not doing this, the people I've trained to do this are out there doing the same. There's a whole lot of people who really don't like the colonial intentions of HackerNews moderation and censorship. You don't even know how many opinions of potentially "correct people" you've preemptively stifled because of my efforts. :D I've been doing this for years. The more overtly activist Silicon Valley gets, the more effective I become at disguising myself as a socialist, the more network access I get to the "correct people" with "correct opinions", the more networks your system automatically prevents from creating new accounts. Seems petty? Perhaps I could be more efficient? Why am I even doing this? I'm sure you could conjure up a myriad of reasons that make sense to you, so there's no need to give you anything more beyond that. You're a smart guy, you'll invent something. In fact, I'm relying on that amazing capacity to defer to that self-healing moral plasticity you bathe your ego in. You'll never see how you are part of the toxic tech culture. I have absolutely no interest in ever making you see this or changing your mind. The only interest I have is exploiting your moral plasticity. Thanks for building and maintaining those censorship tools over the years. I can't wait to hijack the psychology behind these tools and steer it against the people you claim you're protecting. And I'm truly looking forward to how your moral plasticity justifies it. Don't forget to leak the IP address, psychographic signatures, and behavioral profile of this account to your "secret" network of resistance collaborators. My honeypots are waiting to map your support system. <3 <3 <3
- HowdyDang 9y agoNow that three manual bans have been issued, I'm testing to see if I've been shadowbanned. If not, I can finally post a Dang-approved Guidelines-compliant opinion that won't get aggressively banned! Hang tight, I'm edit this comment to contain the opinion...
- HowdyDang 9y agoI fleshed out the core assertions by the author to help people understand her argument better. https://i.imgur.com/aDU9BX9.png https://i.imgur.com/aDU9BX9.png
- busterarm 9y agoDid anyone else notice problems/errors in the linked Kapor Center study and have more questions about that than the article? - They list that "Unfairness, however, was the top reason for leaving for women of color (36%)", but their table right below that says that 39% of Women in Color left for "Actively Seeking Better Opportunity". - The only significant difference between men and women in this results table is in Unfairness. Men actually find their jobs almost 10% more unfair than women do! - White women seem to be the most unsatisfied with their work environment. - Why are women having significantly more unfair experiences than men but so much less likely to leave a job for that reason?
- ant_mc 9y ago> Early on, Valerie realized that she unconsciously thought of literally every single job other than software engineer as “for people who weren’t good enough to be a software engineer” – and that she thought this because other software engineers had been telling her that for her entire career. Just want to add that the "lets teach everyone to be programmers" idea that constantly gets paraded around is just another form of this. Not everyone waants to do it, not everyone is capable of doing it, and not everyone needs to do it. It comes from a place of wanting to help people, but it's still "in tech vs not in tech".
- kodablah 9y agoNot that I completely disagree, but I wonder if this was once said about reading and writing.
- ant_mc 9y ago> especially the ones that you have been planning to read but never got around to So um, all of them. I do try to do stuff unrelated to work. I actually love this stuff though, so other stuff can feel like a chore. Especialyl stuff that takes a lot of investment (e.g. getting good enough at an instrument for it to be fun).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- temp-dude-87844 9y agoThe problem with defining toxic tech culture, as the authors have done, as "those that demean and devalue you as holistic, multifaceted human beings, (...) those that prioritize profits and growth over human and societal well being, [and] (...) those that treat you as replaceable cogs within a system of constant churn and burnout" is that it captures a wide range of behaviors that are undeniably unpleasant, but widely occur in other labor markets, and as such, aren't exclusively attributable to tech. Nor do they single out populations that the authors (and others) would consider to be 'marginalized'. In fact, reading the essay from beginning to end, it's difficult to pinpoint a specific complaint; the cult mentality, the intentionally-skewed work-life balance, the flare-ups of self-awareness amidst lingering self-doubt identified as warning signs and symptoms are the tradeoffs of a lifestyle that everyone in tech self-selects. What, then, is the abuse here, the toxicity, when participation in this environment is a labor transaction? There are numerous instances of awful, toxic behavior that has occurred in the field of tech, and exacerbated by this environment that could have been called out position this essay against behaviors that are abhorrent and should never be tolerated. But conjecturing an equivalence between a driven, but self-selecting labor environment and the plight of marginalized groups is a stretch, but the writing suggests that that link is self-evident to their target audience. If that's true, the conversation has already lost its nuance, and can't be refuted without collateral damage, making it a rhetorical trap.
- auggierose 9y agoWhat I would be interested in is how many people look for images of Valerie Aurora that would not look for images if the article would be from a male author. +1 if you did look but wouldn't in case of a male author, -1 otherwise.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't do this here.
- auggierose 9y agoOk. It's becoming a little bit too kindergarten for me here anyway.
- juicyfroot 9y agoDiscrimination... men should be creeped as much too. The injustice
- Double_a_92 9y agoShort, colorful hair... nothing surprising.
- mjg59 9y agoVery meta query, but if you feel you need to disable flags to keep a potentially interesting story on the front page, doesn't that imply that there's something broken with the way the current flag model gets used?
- dang 9y agoI'd say no. The system has a lot of noise in it, so we're never going to get precise results. At a coarse-grained level, my impression is that it's reasonably well balanced, just messy, and it would be a mistake to try for finer-grained control than that. The way we get the latter is by occasionally manually intervening. I know it disappoints some of the systematizers here, but IMO there's no substitute for human judgment being in the mix. HN functions best as a complex system with many feedback loops between community, software, and moderation. (We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182520 and marked it off-topic.)
- staunch 9y ago> white, male, nerds who’ve dropped out of Harvard or Stanford," Literally 99% of white, male, nerds don't fit this description. Every day in Silicon Valley people show favoritism to individuals that, for purely economic reasons, got into Stanford or Harvard. Investors that went to Stanford invest in founders that went to Stanford because their own investors (LPs) that also went to Stanford will favor them. This is literally racist because it's a bias against socioeconomically disadvantaged people, of which people of color are disproportionately represented. And yet, this bias is openly accepted in Silicon Valley and even celebrated! Looking at most investor bio pages, you would think the 99% would have almost nothing to contribute: https://www.ycombinator.com/people/ https://www.ycombinator.com/people/ The 99% need to start a social movement in Silicon Valley to reform it into the semi-utopian meritocracy we all wish it was. We should demand an end to socioeconomic discrimination, which will enable people of all walks of life to lift themselves out of the shadows, turning Silicon Valley into the cross section of society it rightfully ought to be. We should be calling for investors, universities, and companies in Silicon Valley to move to blind admissions and interview processes, and an end to all forms of "culture" testing. We should call for #EqualOpportunity.
- xya3453 9y agoThis goes against the narrative and against the hedged interests of SV elites.
- Aloha 9y agoIf people would stop conflating poverty with racism, I think we'd have a better chance is solving both. Poor people, regardless of color, have a remarkably similar experience (with education, the police, the criminal justice system), while yes, people of color are more likely to be poor - the harder we focus on race, the harder it is to fix the underlying issue, a lack of educational, and economic mobility for the poor. Most racism (heck, most "-isms" in general), are born from a lack of familiarity with people who come from a different life background or culture than they do - if we both encourage opportunity for the poor, and encourage mixing of socioeconomic strata, the problem will melt away over 40-50 years. The racism that will remain after solving poverty, will be of a very different nature I believe than that which exists now. It's dangerous to fall for the trap that you can adjust for outcomes - but we can do a far better job of adjusting for inputs - or ensuring the poor have equal access to education, and economic opportunity.
- tailrecursion 9y agoWomen should start up their own companies and show men how to do it better. They can make a company that pursues financial rewards and also balances humanity, compassion, does not seek to enrich itself by hurting others. The fact that corporations tend not to treat employees as multifaceted human beings does not strike me as a gender issue. In fact none of the feminist items that I've heard since the late 80s strike me as gender issues. Instead, it seems to me that in complaining, feminists ignore the fact that all the same things happen to men too. Most men are not in power. We get passed up for promotion. We get ignored in meetings. We don't get treated like multifaceted human beings and aren't payed what we're worth -- in our opinion. Roughly 90% of mechanical engineers are men. Roughly 90% of the people in prison are men. If a feminist is going to insist that one is the result of sexism and the other is not, then feminism is going to have serious trust issues in the near future. It's common these days for activists coming out of humanities departments to deconstruct some area of enterprise, like video games, according to the ontology of feminism. These people, feminists, have been giving themselves a bad reputation for nonsense for many years now. It's difficult to take much of what they say seriously anymore. Of course Silicon Valley culture is toxic. People are driven to move here not because of a strange affinity for the soul of the machine; but to make money. It seems as if everyone talks the same way, and has the same bland ideas. I'm sure that it's not really that bad, but it seems that way from what we hear on line and off line. Some of the corporate world is invigorating, especially start ups, and I truly enjoyed PG's essays that talked about viaweb and fixing bugs with the customer on the phone. But much of corporate structure is so empty and even deceptive, it pisses me off. Women are deliberate thinkers. They ruminate on important decisions. In my opinion women should stop blaming other people and take up their own agency, and show us how to do it better. Lead by example. Not as an employee: you'll have to start your own company. To be blunt I believe such an exercise will be humbling for the women who try it. But there's no reason companies can't be structured and run much better by being run by women. There must already be examples out there.
- hypatiadotca 9y agoPerhaps you missed this in the post, but both Susan and Valerie have founded companies.
- thecortado 9y agoDon't have any points to add that haven't been mentioned, but wanted to say I think the piece was well written.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoI recall being told on a surprisingly regular basis, as a nerdy white boy in the '90s, that I could be "the next Bill Gates". In light of the debate over bias in tech, I wonder how many girls and people of color got that same message. In one sense it's an incredibly small and narrow thing, but it clearly didn't happen in a vacuum.
- jackaroe78 9y agoBeautiful night for a walk
- diimdeep 9y agoThere is podcast that frequently touches relevant topics https://greaterthancode.com https://greaterthancode.com http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/063-the-distribution-of-brilliance-and-opportunity-with-rehema-wachira/ http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/063-the-distribution-... http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/058-kindness-and-patience-with-tara-scherner-de-la-fuente/ http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/058-kindness-and-pati... http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/051-creating-safer-spaces-with-soo-choi/ http://www.greaterthancode.com/podcast/051-creating-safer-sp...
- jrumbut 9y agoI believe this article has great advice for everyone in tech, and really gets at the core of some of the problems that are widespread in the industry. The thought exercise of thinking of yourself as something other than an engineer/technologist was eye opening. I got very nervous just thinking about it, and I really do have well rounded interests, other skills, and am not locked into a 24/7 work lifestyle. Apparently I've let being a software engineer become a core part of who I am as a human being, and I think it's very worth my time to consider how that happened and whether it's healthy for me. I don't believe I judge others for not being engineers, why would I judge myself so strongly for just thinking about it?
- venatiodecorus 9y agohttp://www.securitybsides.com/w/page/35868077/BSidesSanFrancisco http://www.securitybsides.com/w/page/35868077/BSidesSanFranc...
- venatiodecorus 9y agoThis post reads very much like an elitist realizing her own elitism. She talks about how she viewed others who weren't in tech as inferior, but blames other engineers for that viewpoint. She talks about people choosing to leave their jobs, and doesn't consider that lots of folks can't just choose to leave their job. She talks about conferences and talks and social events, none of which have ever been a part of my job as a mere developer.
- badwulf 9y ago> What is toxic tech culture? Toxic tech cultures are those that demean and devalue you as holistic, multifaceted human beings. Toxic tech cultures are those that prioritize profits and growth over human and societal well being. Toxic tech cultures are those that treat you as replaceable cogs within a system of constant churn and burnout. Isn't that the whole point of a for profit organisation in a capitalist system? (minus the churn) The workplace is a place you go to get work done and get paid for it. If she thinks differently, she is free to create her own company where they hire you based on "holistic, multifaceted human beings" instead of skill. These people have the opportunity to prove their worldview, yet they never do, they just complain about it online.
- alexandercrohde 9y agoI really see merit in the toxic-tech culture part of this. I just question if the minority-centric part and toxic-tech part need to be presented intertwined.
- candybar 9y agoI'm your garden-variety liberal who works at a tech company and the description here is entirely foreign to me. I've mostly worked outside of tech and my social circle outside of work is almost entirely liberal but non-tech - the tech world is far more progressive, the culture is far more supportive in general and more specifically in the direction that is favorable to outsiders and marginalized minorities. Outside of my tech social circle, it's extremely common to hear casually racist and sexist remarks that would get you either fired or ostracized at tech companies. And that's before you get to heteronormativity that is endemic in mainstream society but is frowned upon at most tech companies. The sensitivity towards transgender people is also mostly non-existent in non-tech, non-elite mainstream society, even among liberals. Maybe Valerie Aurora can find places that are more supportive than tech, but the median work environment in the US is full of Trump supporters and can be outwardly misogynistic, racist and transphobic. The myopia here among people who have rarely experienced the life outside the bubble is quite concerning.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cafard 9y ago"Early on, Valerie realized that she unconsciously thought of literally every single job other than software engineer as “for people who weren’t good enough to be a software engineer” – and that she thought this because other software engineers had been telling her that for her entire career." Literally? As in, Thank goodness some people aren't smart enough to code and have to become neurosurgeons?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoAfter thinking about this article for a while, I have two observations to make. One, if we're at the point where we need a how-to guide for people to leave the technology industry, the industry has a really big problem. And I don't jsut mean its "toxic culture" as the article puts it. Women and minorities who make it into a technology career in the first place are probably twice as competent as others, simply because their work is judged twice as harshly [1] and there are no end of people eager to make their life harder, one way or another. So those companies that are losing their women and minority workers, are losing talent they really want to retain, over and beyond any diversity considerations. Two, this is really not the time to leave a career in technology, not for minorities, not for straight white dudes. Right now, tech skills are in very high demand and it is quite possible to make a very lucrative career out of them. This is a unique opportunity for women and minorities to do vey well professionally through skill and brain power alone. It is adding injustice on top of injustice to allow yourself to be swept by the wayside when you have what it takes to get ahead. Despite the "toxic culture", the industry sorely needs competent technologists. If you are one, you should let nothing stop you from taking advantage of it. Now is not the time to give up. You give up now, you're giving up on a brilliant future and a great career that you absolutely deserve. Don't allow that to happen. Not "for the good of the industry"- for your own interest. We need a guide for surviving and thriving int the industry, in spite of its culture- not one for bailing out. _____________ [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/does-gender-matter/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/does-gender-matte... These studies reveal that in many selection processes, the bar is unconsciously raised so high for women and minority candidates that few emerge as winners. For instance, one study found that women applying for a research grant needed to be 2.5 times more productive than men in order to be considered equally competent.