8 ms·
I love bitcoin and cryptocurrency as potential solutions to problems with gov-controlled currencies (I've used crypto to buy drugs, for example). But I'm still
by komali2 9y ago
I love bitcoin and cryptocurrency as potential solutions to problems with gov-controlled currencies (I've used crypto to buy drugs, for example). But I'm still confused why people refer to purchasing currency as an "investment." Obviously the rates are going up now, but doesn't everyone expect them to just come back down? I don't convert my USD to Yen and call it an "investment."
- vthallam 9y agoYou would call it an investment, if the USD-YEN prices are so volatile and give you 1000X profit in 6 months. Again, this all goes back to whether Bitcoin is a store of value or a medium of exchange. By now it's very clear, it can't be medium of exchange.
- josephg 9y agoPeople keep saying that, but the lightning network is in testing at the moment and when it gets widely deployed we should start seeing near zero transaction fees on the bitcoin network. You can say what you want about the philosophy of that - the lightning network will add yet another group of people who collectively have an outsized control over the network. But if the scaling issues get addressed I don't see any reason why it couldn't work as a currency. And it looks like they are being (slowly) addressed.
- slindz 9y agoAny successful Lightning Network (at scale) would require a dramatic block size increase. The last (Lightning Network tech) I saw suggested it would need a 133MB blocksize. Blockstream struck down a modest increase to 2MB in November. They have devs who want to reduce the blocksize. I'm not sure where you're finding hope in LN. Bitcoin Cash forked off to get back to scaling, and it's doing great. Check out how well the mempool stress test went this past week.
- notsrg 9y agoAnd Bitcoin Cash will need GB or even TB sized blocks to scale to the size of Visa. If scaling the network was as easy as changing 1 variable it wouldn't be that hard to get consensus on a scaling solution.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- slindz 9y agoGB blocks are basically ready with today's hardware though the need is years out. It won't be long before TB blocks can say the same, testing is underway. Current prevailing theory in BCH land is the block size is an unnecessary hinderance, and will likely be gone in the next 18 months. Exciting times!
- jstanley 9y ago> GB blocks are basically ready with today's hardware What are you smoking? Even 1GB blocks would be 144GB per day of blockchain growth. You can't expect people to tolerate that kind of disk usage, let alone bandwidth.
- slindz 9y agoIt is possible today, thankfully not necessary. By the time they're necessary, it'll be a lot less demanding, relatively speaking....
- dang 9y agoThis breaks the HN guidelines. Commenters here aren't allowed to attack others no matter how wrong someone is. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't do this again.
- imtringued 9y ago7000 transactions per second is a lot of of data. If you're keeping history then you cannot store 4200000 transactions per 10 minutes in less than a 1GB block. The problem isn't the blocksize. The problem is that traditional blockchains grow indefinitively and keep onchain data forever.
- Robotbeat 9y agoAnd what good is a store of value if it's not a medium of exchange and its value is incredibly volatile (and doesn't have some sort of intrinsic industrial value like a metal might)?
- ezzaf 9y agoI disagree that short term returns make it an investment. Speculation is term that much better fits the action of buying a currency with intent to return a profit. "A speculator is a person who trades derivatives, commodities, bonds, equities or currencies with a higher than average risk in return for a higher-than-average profit potential" https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/speculator.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/speculator.asp
- bandrami 9y agoArbitrage is not investment
- jgh 9y agoSome people do though (forex traders), but that is not the primary use-case
- skgoa 9y agoNo honest forex trader would call his trading an investment, though. They/we know exactly that it's just gambling based on very limited data. Also, traders are extremely careful to limit their risk. No sane trader would hold bitcoin for extend lengths of time. Yet hodling is exactly what bitcoin "investors" advocate.
- Jtsummers 9y agoWell, there is actual forex investing (speculating). For instance, the value of the USD versus the Argentine Peso (ARS) is something I track (my girlfriend lives there and long term I would consider moving there, current plan is for her to move here). The USD to ARS conversion is increasingly favorable for the USD, the buying power of ARS hasn't dropped significantly (in country) but the USD is worth more ARS now than 1.5 years ago (1USD:15ARS then versus 1USD:18ARS today). Someone who had currency in ARS at the time, and converted it to the USD, could see significant returns on that investment (assuming reasonable exchange fees). Almost 20% gains, that matches the US stock increases over this past year. It is speculation, however, as you generally don't have the same sort of insight into currency movements as you will into stock movements and commodities in general. Someone watching the Brexit vote in summer 2016 would have made a decent return on ARS had they moved it to the USD before the vote and back after (changed from 1USD:13ARS to 1USD:15ARS practically overnight). But that is speculation and requires watching global and national scale events to predict.
- slyzmud 9y agoI live in Argentina. I want to add that we don't invest in dollars, we save in dollars. We don't expect to have more money after some time, we just expect not to loose money by inflation. Although it might seem that buying dollars have a return of 20% or more in a year, by the time you sell it everything cost more in ARS because most prices are tied to US dollars. So you end up having the same. If you have saved in ARS, with the same money you could buy a lot less things
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- philipov 9y agoI believe strongly that the word 'invest' should be used to distinguish one's activities from speculation, rather than be a superclass of it. Discourse is poisoned when people promote semantic overlap and create ambiguity, rather than using words to create meaningful distinctions. Investing is what you do when you're not merely speculating on short-term returns, but are instead focused on long-term value creation. It is right to call it currency speculation, because instead of investing capital to create sustainable growth in something, you're just skimming the fluctuations using massive leverage.
- slindz 9y agoWell, the circulation limit/deflationary part is pretty key to that. How many dollars/yen/what-have-you are printed every year leaving your existing dollars/yen/what-have-you with less buying power? Thinking the world will flock to a fixed pool of frictionless digital exchange does not seem insane to me. I'm talking about the ones you can transact for less than a penny (BCH), not the old guard (BTC).
- matthewbauer 9y agoBut what makes you think BCH is the one? You might like my soon to be released coin Bitcoin Cash Cash. Fees will be 0!
- slindz 9y agoIt's a collection of everybody who made Bitcoin great to begin with. Great community. I believe it's a bunch of doers and not talkers. Fees are less than a penny. System works great, like Bitcoin used to.
- xur17 9y agoI'm curious, and I haven't found the answer yet - what's the scaling plan if Bitcoin Cash runs out of block room? Just keep increasing the size? Is there an upper limit before the chain increases in size too quickly to be sustainable?
- slindz 9y agoIt's the usual combination. Block size as much as makes sense, optimizations where possible, if lightning works (it won't) - use it. Gavin Andresen has published about his latest work 'Graphene' which shrinks block sizes dramatically. They'll take/use any good ideas so long as it doesn't cripple basic onchain functionality.
- stale2002 9y agoThe reason is simple. Blocksize and fees are a tradeoff. 1 cent fees are a significant advantage over 20$ fees. But 0.0001 cent fees aren't really that much more useful for your coffee transactions. Sure, maybe someone will come up with another chain that is used for true micro transactions. But what we are saying is, that each of these fee levels are good for different use cases. Bitcoin's high fees and high security are great for a digital gold product that isn't traded much. Bitcoin Cash made a different tradeoff in the attempt to go after the daily spending market. Pros and cons.
- scotty79 9y agoIf you earned Venezuelan currency you might consider buying USD with it an investment.
- mancerayder 9y agoMight some argue that some of the capital being placed in these currencies, whether they're by clever millionaires who studied whitepapers, or Uber drivers (as the anecdote goes) who jumped in after taking out a line of credit on the house, is investment in some of the companies behind the tech? For example, BTC companies like Blockstream funded things like satellites, while the Ethereum founder has been donating money to companies that help the Ethereum future. Perhaps it's 'accidental investing with a dose of roulette number thrown in'. Perhaps it's a new type of investment/gambling hybrid that requires a new category.
- jstanley 9y agoNo, by buying some cryptocurrency you're not investing in the company behind the tech (if there even is one) at all. If the currency does well but the company does badly, you still win. If the currency does badly but the company does well, you still lose. You're exposed to the fluctuations of the currency, and completely unexposed to the valuation of the company.
- mancerayder 9y agoSure, there's that aspect. But the angle here is that they can take some of the capital transferred to them via crypto currency purchases to then use to directly invest in, and one thinks that by doing so they could well choose to invest in the ventures or areas that might increase the likelihood of the potential success of the currency. Which theoretically goes back to you. I'm not trying to sugar-coat or rationalize the mania, only trying to explore the idea that this is both and neither gambling and investing. I think people object to the idea that money used to purchase crypto currency in the first place is capital.
- bandrami 9y agoIt depends on the currency in question, but for most of them, specifically no: they aren't "issued" by the company in question or even really related to them in any way. They're only in a position to gain from a coin purchase if they happen to have done the mining themselves (which they generally don't). All these ICOs are just blockchains branded by a certain company.
- fnord77 9y agoit's useless as a currency while speculators are making its value so volatile. The sooner this bubble pops and the get rich people go away, the better.
- dagw 9y agoOnce the current batch of speculators cash out, volatility settles and it starts getting used as a currency then its price will start to edge up again, bringing in a new wave of speculators who drive up volatility making it less useful as a currency and loop starts over.
- average_person 9y agoI don't convert my USD to Yen and call it an "investment." As stated below, some people do treat it as an investment to some extent. The other thing is, in my opinion more interesting, how you define crypto. They aren't really currencies even though people call them this way. They are a different kind of asset. Sometimes compared to gold, sometimes to stocks but it might be that they are just a new type and we just don't know how to value them. And by supporting them people support the technology behind.
- chrismcb 9y agoWell you might not call converting USD to yen an investment, there are some people that do. That is some people's job. It isn't that much didn't than investing in the stock market
- hndamien 9y agoThat is because those currencies are inflationary. Without a moderate interest rate, putting it in the bank wouldn't even be considered "saving".