24 ms·
The MacBook Air: A Decade’s Worth of Legacy
- kruhft 9y agoBy far my favourite computer ever. I recommend it to everyone that asks me which computer to buy. The battery life is what makes it. The first time I could leave the house without a charger and not be worried. Interactive performance feels the same as my MBP. Development is fine, from JS to Common Lisp. Great systems. I'll keep buying the as long as Apple keeps making them.
- misterpigs 9y agoI took the plunge with the second gen MacBook Air after seeing fellow devs at WWDC haul them around as if they were nothing. I initially noticed the slower HDD and performance hit, but didn't miss it after the first week. The mobility was a huge boon. I was working for myself and often meeting clients or working from the coffee shop, bar, etc. I held on to it until the MacBook caught up in size/weight. Source: me. I write iOS apps.
- saagarjha 9y agoInteresting…the original MacBook Air I know was pretty slow and underpowered. How did it feel developing on it?
- misterpigs 9y agoI was upgrading from a medium spec second gen Intel MacBook Pro so the performance hit wasn't as drastic for me. Development was fine honestly. The Air was my primary development machine for the next 4 years.
- mikestew 9y agoOnce the SSDs became standard (or a reasonably-priced option, I forget), the Air hit its stride, I think. I had a 2010 that I did dev work on (iOS and Mac), and it was great with plenty of power for what I was doing. My wife still has a hand-me-down 2011 that works fine. Getting a bit long in the tooth, and she sees more beach balls than she should, but it does what she needs it to do. I can’t imagine having to work with one with the old iPod drives in them. Those things were dogs what with a small amount of RAM and a severe penalty for hitting disk. But, hey, I’m glad it served your needs! :-)
- jitix 9y agoIt's still a very compelling option as a second computer that you'd want to take around with you. I bought one few months back and its powerful enough for common development tasks. Considering that Macbook Pro RAM has been capped at 16GB for some time now it makes sense to buy a powerful PC for running stuff plus a Macbook Air for portability.
- gxs 9y agoThe only thing holding me back from buying one is the low quality/resolution screen. How has that affected your work? Any thoughts to share?
- mschaef 9y agoI use a 13" MBA as a development machine and find the screen good for the work I do. (Admittedly not anything too graphically intensive.) I do find the 1440x900 a useful improvement over 1280x800, in that the 1440px width allows for 2 side-by-side 80 column text views (assuming 8px character cells and giving some room for controls, etc.)
- sedachv 9y agoThat is a huge font. With X11 fixed 6x10 or 6x13 font you get two 80-column screens at 1024, and three at 1440. At 74 columns you can get three screens on 1366 displays.
- mschaef 9y agoI don't think my eyesight is quite that good, and I've never been impressed with the X11 fixed fonts (particularly at that size.) FWIW, I've used 8px as a benchmark for character cell width for years. The original PC's I used were CGA machines with 640x200 displays. 80 column text implied 8px character cells. (Even then, MDA's 9x14 character cells were much higher quality... I think the reason 8px works better these days is due to anti-aliasing, etc.)
- bluedino 9y ago
- LeifCarrotson 9y ago> The base model shipped with a 4,200-RPM hard drive straight out of an iPod...A 64 GB SSD option was available for a whopping $999. $1k is not expensive for a high-quality Ultrabook...In fact, I'm pretty sure the Macbook Air is still around that price. Have laptops really gone up in price since 2008? ...oh wait. A little research [1] suggests that the optional SSD added $1k to the price, bringing the total to $3100. That is and was expensive. [1]: https://gizmodo.com/345101/adding-a-64gb-ssd-to-the-macbook-air-1300-extra-please https://gizmodo.com/345101/adding-a-64gb-ssd-to-the-macbook-...
- mikestew 9y agoThe originals were, IMO, something for upper management to show off with. It could be argued that the machines could be used for productive work, but it was ungodly high price to pay for such an underpowered machine. For half the price and a pound more in weight, a lot of machines would mop the floor with the Air. That’s not to say that cramming it into a case that size wasn’t impressive, and it was a rough preview of the nice Airs Apple would later build. Just two years later an Air was my main dev machine.
- FabHK 9y agoI'm wondering whether we will see the same evolution with the current thin MacBook line - from underpowered "concept" to main working machine.
- abrowne 9y agoAlmost certainly that's the plan ... unless they can get you to switch to an iPad Pro instead.
- wolfgke 9y ago> The originals were, IMO, something for upper management to show off with. Even at that time I never could understand how the MBA could be used for showing off with. To me (lack of speed, lack of ports etc.) it was rather a device that shows to everyone that the user does not care about good technology or usability and has a desire to throw money down the drain. In other worse: A device that you use when you seriously want to be ridiculed.
- asplake 9y agoThis week I had the battery replaced in my mid 2013 Air. First time I’ve had a computer for anything like this long and not wanted to bin it. A bigger SSD and more RAM would be nice but it remains my ideal laptop. They were definitely on to something.
- Scoundreller 9y agoLast year, instead of replacing my mid-2011’s battery for a few hundred dollars, I sold all the parts and bought a mid-2015 with faster CPU and 8GB RAM. After selling the included Beats Solo3 (academic purchase), it was close to a free upgrade.
- germinalphrase 9y agoIs this to say you deconstructed the machine and sold individual parts (on eBay)? I'm surprised doing so would have such a good return.
- Scoundreller 9y agoYes. Apple keeps a tight grip on its supply chain, so spare parts are hard to find. But I think I sold the wifi card to someone building a hackintosh.
- orf 9y agoAre they that expensive? I mean, after a quick Google I couldn't find anything with a huge price[1]. That WiFi card goes for £13. I'm interested (and I'm sure others would be), where did you sell the parts and did you use any disassembly guides? 1. https://www.ebay.co.uk/p/Genuine-Apple-MacBook-Pro-Early-2015-Retina-WiFi-Card-Z653-0194-BCM943602CS/1179762408 https://www.ebay.co.uk/p/Genuine-Apple-MacBook-Pro-Early-201...
- Scoundreller 9y agoI just pointed out that part as being one that could go into any computer. Sold the parts on everyone's favourite auction house. Lots of repair guides out there, I used ifixit's. Even though it's a 2011, lots of bricked systems out there that you can get functioning again for $0-$200 dollars in spare parts and a few hours of your time.
- paulus_magnus2 9y agoSony’s VAIO X505 had some impressive specs when it first debuted in 2004. It was just 0.38 inches at its thinnest point, and used Intel’s ultra-low voltage Pentium processor. It was the first laptop to feature a "chiclet" keyboard, named for its small rounded keys that resemble Chiclets gum. All of this was packaged into a $3,000 notebook years before Apple unveiled its MacBook Air. https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/6/5385716/sony-vaio-iconic-pcs-photo-essay#photo-5149539-10 https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/6/5385716/sony-vaio-iconic-p...
- dijit 9y agoThat laptop certainly looks revolutionary. But while we're on the subject of Sony ultra-portables: I am a little sad that there's been no update to the Sony VAIO P-Series of laptops which are literally pocket sized. I had one, and aside from the screen refresh it was so crazy how absurdly portable it was. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Vaio_P_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Vaio_P_series
- awiesenhofer 9y agoBoy, i loved those! I remember browsing lots of japanese and hongkong sites to find one with EU-shipping. Does anyone know similar current devices?
- schlarpc 9y agoThere's a couple recent products that hit similar niches: GPD Pocket: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gpd-pocket-7-0-umpc-laptop-ubuntu-or-win-10-os-laptop--2 https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gpd-pocket-7-0-umpc-lapto... GPD Win 2: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gpd-win-2-handheld-game-console-for-aaa-games-laptop https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gpd-win-2-handheld-game-c... Ockel Sirius A: https://www.ockelcomputers.com/sirius-a/ https://www.ockelcomputers.com/sirius-a/ I have the original GPD Win, and it's a surprisingly competent PC for being roughly the size of a Nintendo 3DS XL. The keyboard is terrible for typing on, but that's kind of expected with its gaming focus.
- robotresearcher 9y agoThe killer feature for me of the 2nd-gen Airs was the battery life. It’s the first time I’d been able to go all day without plugging in (for light management-type work). All day was a step change. I was sad when my new 13in MBP needs plugged in at lunchtime. The screen and other specs are much better of course but I’d become used to leaving my PSU in the office all day while zipping around.
- FabHK 9y agoAbsolutely true. The 2016 MBP sure has a nice screen and all, but basically half the battery life for twice the price.
- fossuser 9y agoThe MBP isn't the successor to the air though - that'd be the Macbook which I think has similar battery life and a nicer screen. I'm not sure why Apple still makes the air since the Macbook seems like the obvious replacement.
- jsjohnst 9y ago> The MBP isn't the successor to the air though The 13” non-touchbar MBP was actually announced as a MBA replacement when it was introduced if memory serves.
- fyfy18 9y agoFrom a design point of view maybe, but the price of the MacBook is far too much for what you get. The 2011 MacBook Air was a good replacement for the discontinued white MacBook. It was a lot more modern, but retained the same price point. It still continued to fulfil the role of the entry level Mac. The current MacBook doesn’t do that though. It’s too expensive to be entry level - similar spec’ed to a MacBook Air, it is $300 more, for some new colours and a slightly better screen? Ok it’s a little more portable, but it’s not like the MacBook Air is bulky... The base model having an underpowered processor definitely isn’t helping it’s reputation - it’s like the original MacBook Air all over again.
- andr 9y agoIt'd be awesome if Apple made an anniversary Macbook Air with upgraded internals, like Lenovo did recently. Would buy one in a heartbeat.
- mmjaa 9y agoI've managed to avoid the Air cult, mostly because I need extra beef, and Air never seemed to have it. But I sure am glad there are machines like the GPD Pocket around. I'm not entirely convinced the two, at each ends of various spectra as well as legacy, are inter-linked, however. Which is to say the Air "was inevitable", its just that Apple did it 'best'. Its taken a fair bit for other vendors of electronic junk to catch up with the Air factor, though, but I do wonder about what the future may hold for the GPD Pocket 2. It has the potential as a 'just as good Air experience', only .. you know .. fully open.
- dm319 9y agoAlso have a look at the Gemini PDA.
- bluedino 9y agoProbably the favorite of any laptop I have ever owned. Lightning fast with the SSD (compared to the 250/320GB spinner in the 13" Pro at the time), very sleek, great touchpad/screen/keyboard... And then 11" was a new level of portability. The 2013 model brought battery upgrades that were so far ahead of the rest of the thin and lights. Perhaps the best part: the low price of $1099 made the 13" Air a bargain. Cheaper than the worse 13" Pro! And the 11" model was another $100 less. Combine that with discounts from retailers like B&H, Best Buy, or MicroCenter and you could get a brand new Mac for $799 at various times. Very unlike Apple.
- FabHK 9y agoAnd great battery life, for such a light machine. I liked it much more than my current 2016 MacBook "Pro".
- ppeetteerr 9y agoI agree about the battery life but the non-touch bar MBP is a gem. It's as light as a MacBook Air and I've bounced it around a few times accidentally (no damage, unlike my Air). The new screen and touch pad are great too.
- simplify 9y agoI still use my air from 2011 and love it. Its slow-ish performance also keeps my code in check :)
- guelo 9y agoThe sad thing is how the Air design has infected all their other laptops including the awful non-pro 2016+ Macbook Pros
- Finbarr 9y agoI just bought another Air after returning a 2016 "Pro". I've been using my 2015 Pro for the last 3 years, and worried about it breaking down so wanted a spare. I've had 2 of them before and they are the best machines I've ever owned. If Apple released a MBA with retina display and 16gb of ram with the same battery life, I've pay at least 2x the current price for it.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoThe new Pros are effectively Airs in weight but not in battery. What about the 12inch MacBooks? Aren't they effectively Airs minus the ports (a dongle could solve that problem).
- comstock 9y agoIn my experience the 12inch Macbook is not an Air replacement. The CPU is super-slow, and the keyboard is very poor (maybe I just got a bad one I don’t know... but I find it almost useless).
- Finbarr 9y agoI had one of those too, and ended up returning it. I have large hands and found the form factor very uncomfortable. The CPU is also slow and the keyboard sucks (particularly disliked the arrow key configuration).
- Humphrey 9y agoI switched to Mac with the Mid-2012 i7 Air. Cost me just under A$2000 after updating all the internals It is still my home computer and have not noticed it slowing down! I'm glad I chose this over the newly released 13" pro retina. The low DPI screen means this thing flies! I can't see any reason I would to upgrade in the next year or two - appart from a new battery, and my power adaptor just started fraying. A new Air wouldn't be significantly more powerful & would cost more than my original (Australian dollar doesn't convert as well now). Although, having just got into audio production, I think I'm almost at the performance ceiling. CPU fan gets quite loud while using Logic with 15+ tracks & effects, but it still runs great. I need to replace the battery - I think this will make it like an new computer.
- dbspin 9y agoTry Reaper. Much more efficient processor-wise than Logic.
- CJPD 9y agoI got a 2017 13in Touchbar Pro after getting the top spec 13in MBA in 2013. The battery was worse, it was heavier, same speed, keys constantly got stuff stuck under them. Only benefit was bright screen and better resolution. Returned it immediately. I eventually got the new top spec MacBook, and its the spiritual successor to the air. I can't recommend it enough.
- ambivalence 9y agoDoesn't it have the same butterfly keyboard as the new Macbook Pro?
- remir 9y agoMan I wish the Macbook was 13" instead of 12!
- dzhiurgis 9y agoThe problem with original wasn't only hard drive, but overheating CPU. The heatsink was basically a thin piece of metal, not exactly a heatsink. Watching any flash video was impossible for more than few minutes. Skype calls were impossible for more than a few minutes. HD video was impossible for more than a few minutes.
- njitbew 9y agoThis is so true. I remember that I had to pause video playback after about 30 minutes or you would experience jitter. The next generation did not suffer from this problem, but I'm still kinda disappointed in Apple for selling such a bad product. A $1000+ laptop that cannot play 30 minutes of HD video is just sad, even in 2009.
- thinkythought 9y agoIt wasn't even just the heat either, it was how incredibly aggressively it throttled and how obnoxious the fan was
- wenbert 9y agoFor me my next purchase would probably still be a Macbook Air. Right now, I'm using an Air it I love it. The comfortable enough to work and use anywhere. But I wont be buying any time soon. The one I'm using now is about 3 years old. It's still reliable and haven't noticed a single problem with it. This comparing to my brother's 2 year old MBP riddled with LCD problems. I've had MBPs before and it seems they tend to break easier. They are a bit hot and heavy.
- Tiktaalik 9y agoAlso I can't help but continue to notice the reliability complaints people have about new MBP keyboards. I love my Macbook Air keyboard. I'm still doing fine with my 2012 MBA. The battery was shot, so I replaced it. I'd love to see Apple continue making them...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoUnfortunately it's neglected by Apple now. The 2015 MacBook is nice, but it has a quarter less battery life and two thirds less CPU TDP. Yet the MacBook Air's design hasn't changed in years and features a screen that is not very impressive now. (I don't care about Retina, but contrast and viewing angles matter — somehow it gives me eyestrain if used for long periods.) It also has stopped getting thinner and lighter, though in fairness maybe they've pushed it as far as they can without sacrificing performance. Maybe they'll revive it with Ryzen Mobile, or stuff that into the MacBook. I can dream. For now I want a new laptop but have nothing to buy because, relative to my current 2013 13″ MacBook Air, the new MBAs are virtually identical, the MacBook Pro is too heavy, and the new MacBook is at best a sidegrade (the screen, Rose Gold finish and greater compactness are nice but the performance would be the same or worse).
- lostgame 9y agoI count on performance in my Macs, and for the price, the Air never delivered. If my use case was browsing, emails and word processing, great. But I’m a professional audio producer and film editor. No dice.
- reaperducer 9y agoThat's like saying you passed on a Fiat because you need something to move furniture. Right tool for the job. The Air was never intended for your job.
- cletus 9y agoArgh... I can't talk about the Macbook Air without getting angry. Angry at Apple's direction. I bought the second generation MBA (the first good one) in 2011. It was a fantastic laptop. It was pretty much the right compromise of power vs weight vs cost. I loved how you could get a pretty darn usable Macbook for (eventually) like $1200. For the first couple of years other manufacturers just couldn't compete with that much hardware for that price. But then it got a bit long in the tooth. I, like many, was waiting for a screen upgrade (particularly to a retina screen). Other manufacturers were increasingly producing better hardware and smaller bezel displays. Yet no update from Apple (after about 2015 or so). And then... the Macbook came out, which spelt the end for the MBA (a 12" MB and 11/13" MBAs were too many SKUs for Apple). And the MB was a terrible compromise. One port (also for power!). Terrible keyboard. Horrible performance. And now we have Macbook Pros that have: - Removed the super-useful Magsafe connector - Added a stupid touchbar no one cares about - Used a much worse keyboard and trackpad to save like 0.5mm in width; and - Cost 2x+ as much. Thanks for that, Apple. All I wanted was an updated Macbook Air.
- beefsack 9y agoWhen you tie yourself to a single manufacturer then you're going to be disappointed very often. It's impossible for one manufacturer to have the perfect product for everyone.
- epistasis 9y agoThis is a true statement, but how does it relate to what the other poster wrote? Wishing for Apple to do a better job has nothing to being tied to a single manufacturer.
- igravious 9y agoBecause of the very truth of the statement. It is highly improbable and most unrealistic for a single entity to satisfy the wishes of all people at all times. Therefore tying oneself to a single manufacturer is inevitably in the long run going to result in disappointment. Wouldn't you agree?
- sien 9y agoIt's always interesting how people in the Apple bubble just ignore what the 90% of computers that are not Macs are doing. It's like when people talk about the IPhone as completely new but ignore Blackberry and Nokia Communicators. Sure, they were not nearly as good, but they were there. The Air was Apple's reaction to netbooks which were appearing at the time. I remember seeing an Air for the first time, which instead of an AUD 300 netbook was AUD 1200 or something. But it still looked super neat. The early machines with Celerons or something had pretty dismal performance at high price. But when the i5 machines came out with SSDs they were and are sweet. This is being typed on a MBA from 2013. The battery life is still very good and the performance is fine for most things I do with it. However, if I bought a similar machine now it probably wouldn't be a Mac because well, Apple just don't care about much or perhaps most of the range now and the Windows machines have got better and better. Surfaces are where people most excited. I still have a netbook too. When you're travelling and don't want to take a machine a $AUD 250 netbook is remarkable. A 'real' computer that I do a few things on that is cheap enough to be almost disposable.
- maxsilver 9y agoYes. If you want to see the legacy of the Macbook Air, you probably need to start with Netbooks and end with something like the latest LG Gram or Acer Swift 7 from CES 2018. Apple participated in the space, and put in a great effort, but the story neither starts nor ends with Apple's products.
- sien 9y agoDefinitely. Oh, there was also the failed 'Ultrabook' thing from Intel that was Intel's attempt to certify effectively Air clones.
- xenadu02 9y ago>It's like when people talk about the IPhone as completely new but ignore Blackberry and Nokia Communicators. Nothing anyone else produced held a candle to the original iPhone. Details matter, user experience matters. Dismiss these things at your own risk. I would hate for startup founders to read these sorts of comments and come away with the idea that they can ship dogshit but sell it based on specs anyway.
- reaperducer 9y agoMy MacBook Pro died just after the Air came out, so I went with that. Used it as my primary machine until 2016 when I got a proper desktop. But I still carry it with me everywhere. The battery only lasts two hours now, but it's enough.
- olivermarks 9y agoI am writing this on a 2011 macbook air -it's my battered lightweight notebook computer and still my main device. My next laptop will be a chromebook. I only really continue to use the mac for a small handful of mac specific hard drive run software programmes such as Adobe Creative Suite 4 (the last disk based version). I replaced the battery last year and am unimpressed by newer Mac products. Apple have completely lost me as a customer after years of my buying their hardware. I use an Android phone and consider Google to be the new Apple at this point in history.
- mmphosis 9y agoI am writing this on a handed down 2003 PowerBook G4 12" — it's my battered lightweight notebook computer and still my main device except for when I am being paid. I am not sure what my next laptop will be. I am looking at overpowered fan-less mini PCs, but have decided to wait for breakthrough CPUs, maybe massively parallel open cores — I could be waiting a while. I use the PowerBook mostly to type, code, and debug. The code most often runs on other hardware, although from time to time I have compiled the latest modern versions of software I use for the PowerBook. I keep it plugged in as much as I can and have yet to replace the battery. I am also unimpressed by newer Mac products as the iPhone appears to be their focus. Apple never really had me as a customer after decades of my using their hardware. I sometimes use an old Android phone without data and consider Google to be the new Microsoft at this point in history.
- m_mueller 9y agoWhat are you running on your PowerBook? Linux? MacOS with Firefox? If it's the latter, do you still get browser updates? Do you never have the urge to watch web videos at native resolution, or do you use it precisely because those kinda distractions are not available? I'm asking because I still got a 2005 G4 12'' somewhere, and I'm wondering whether I should do anything with it.
- olivermarks 9y agoI'm on a gigabit connection which helps my old Air chug along, but I can't watch 1080 video without herky jerky interruptions and fan huffing and puffing. That's a drawback... I have managed to cut MSFT out of my life for the most part but in many ways I agree that Google are now their equivalent...
- dreamfactored 9y agoThe huge flaw with the 13" MBA was that although thinner and lighter, it had a bigger footprint than the 13" MPB. Particularly crucial with confined deskspace such as coffee shop, flying, on a train. Add in lack of RAM and retina and it was never compelling for me much as I adore thin and light (and happy with new 12" MBP for it's further reduced footprint, although the RAM situation is maddening).
- egypturnash 9y agoEvery time I pick up my new 13" MBP some tiny part of me notes that it just feels so much bigger than the 13" Air it replaced. I hope Apple brings it back by the time this one is ready for replacement.
- kristianp 9y agoIt's showing its age now. My partner's work Air is so much bigger and heavier than my xps 13, it seems obscene that so many Airs are still sold as standard issue at many workplaces.
- schuke 9y agoLet's not forget the Air kept a non-IPS screen for ten years, too.
- ElCapitanMarkla 9y agoMy air is my main development machine. I've got the mid 2013, the only think I'd need to be happy using this for more years to come is more ram.
- gwilkes 9y agoI have the mid 2012 model, it's okay. Definitely was never usable for me as a primary computer with 4GB of RAM. It was just something light that I can bring on the road. I find a Chromebook is better for this use case now. The keyboard is good, I will give the MBA that. But open Gmail in Chrome (with no other tabs or apps opened) and the MBA starts tapping out like that is some kind of big ask.
- ksec 9y agoAfter All these discussions and comment over and over again, it is clear the problem is simply: Pricing / Product Position, and Trade Offs. Most wanted a updated MBA, which many has pointed out that is basically MBP. And that is right, the MBP is what we wanted except the pricing. The same goes to Macbook, it doesn't replace MBA. Then there is the issues with trade off on Keyboard, thinness, and single port with Macbook I.e Keyboard Issues and Port aside, people have problems with its value proposition against the MBA. It is either MB Pro is too expensive, or the MB Air offers too much value. It was also noted that the discontinued MB Air 11" was the best selling Laptop at its time, simply because it was the cheapest . There are also lots of consumers buying the Macbook Pro simply because the current Macbook is inadequate for them. Be it size or power. Really, the MBA is Mac Mini, used to be the most valuable in the lineup, but is now neglected.