25 ms·
America’s Fastest Spy Plane May Be Back and Hypersonic
- atonse 9y agoReading this, I just realized that I bet we do more and more testing of cutting edge aircraft in computer simulations nowadays, waiting until later in the stage to actually build prototypes. This might also explain why we've got fewer "UFO" sightings than we used to even 20-30 years ago, in spite of all of us carrying cameras in our pockets (apart from the fact that many of these were hoaxes to begin with).
- godelmachine 9y agoI don't think even modern day smartphones are fast enough to capture objects traveling at hypersonic speeds. Just a guess, I may be wrong here.
- Retric 9y agoDistance makes speed irrelevant. The moon is traveling 1km every second but that's hard to directly notice. If you every watched a jet moving at ~600mph then I think we can agree something going 10 times as fast would still be easy to notice.
- maxerickson 9y agoPossible to capture if you noticed it anyway. Jets cross out of view in a couple minutes and are big (and probably flying lower). So a little thing in ~20 seconds.
- Retric 9y agoIf it's tiny, dark, and distant then it's hard to see even if stationary. Thus the real issue would not be speed.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah, I was agreeing with that part of you comment and quibbling over "easy to notice". Even with the tiny size the speed is still a big factor because the opportunity to sight the object from a given location will be pretty short.
- SEJeff 9y agoTake something like an SR-71 blackbird... It flew subsonic until it was often near the edge of space. If it was vaguely near takeoff or landing, it would be possible to see with the naked eye. If you're a fan of the SR-71, this hilarious interview with pilot Brian Shul is definitely worth watching: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmyAvRKDvJk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmyAvRKDvJk
- maxxxxx 9y agoThey are able to capture rocket launches so it should be OK. A hypersonic plane will be very high altitude so it won't move across the sky that fast. The ISS needs several minutes to cross the sky.
- akhatri_aus 9y agoIt's not going to be hypersonic 100m from the earth's surface, or it'll burn up. So it wont be because of speed i'tll just be too far away.
- Jtsummers 9y agoFor hypersonic it's been all about computer simulations. The costs are just too high. The tests for such aircraft are very expensive and typically result in catastrophic failure (complete loss of the system). Though they learn a lot about what works and doesn't in each test. A major driver for better CFD has been to better simulate hypersonic speeds and reduce the number of real test flights needed. https://www.google.com/search?q=hypersonic%20flight%20test%20failure&cad=h https://www.google.com/search?q=hypersonic%20flight%20test%2...
- phkahler 9y agoSomeone in the FEA/CFD/Simulation industry upon seeing the SpaceX video on their capability indicated that no commercial product he was aware of could match what they were doing. Firewall won't let me confirm this link is correct: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txk-VO1hzBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txk-VO1hzBY SpaceX has best in class hypersonic combustion CFD capability that runs on a GPU. Written in-house.
- Balgair 9y agoTo be fair, it is a VERY hard problem. 'Most' airplanes are designed in a laminar flow situation. Meaning that turbulence is just left out. This makes the calculations much easier, as you can set boundary conditions. In super-sonic conditions, the air is no-longer in-compressible, so the boundary conditions change and you have to add more variables to the equations. In hyper-sonic flow, the air itself is now a variable, as the molecules are split and recombine along the wing in ways we have not yet even empirically measured. This ads a complexity to the equations that is very large and the 'educated guess' of those chemistries on the wing becomes very important.
- phkahler 9y ago...as the molecules are split and recombine along the wing in ways we have not yet even empirically measured. I'm sure one can speculate. In the video they do talk about all the possible intermediate species, so one might have to add air molecules (which can break apart and add to the reactants) to the mix. But yeah, lots of unknowns. Doing experiments and comparing to the simulations should help figure it out. The problem has traditionally been an inability to do the simulations, but that's possible now.
- tzs 9y ago> This might also explain why we've got fewer "UFO" sightings than we used to even 20-30 years ago, in spite of all of us carrying cameras in our pockets. At night, though, we can still see a lot better than the cameras in our phones. For instance, I saw something weird one night. It was big enough and bright enough that I had no trouble seeing it, but my iPhone 6 plus camera just got a vague blob. This was not a UFO, since among other things it was on the ground, but it illustrates the limits of the cameras. (In case anyone is curious, I'll describe what I saw at the end of this comment). The most interesting current UFO reports I've seen (interesting in the sense that they are probably something real--not aliens or supernatural stuff of course, just either an unknown natural phenomenon or some manmade thing that is not well known) are where people see what looks like a star, but moving in a straight line (sometimes pausing now and then), that then suddenly changes direction and zooms off over the horizon very suddenly. No way is a phone camera going to capture that. The weird thing I saw: this was the night before the 2017 total solar eclipse in the US. I was parked in a big field that had been turned into a car camping area for the eclipse and the day/night before. A few rows down and a couple dozen spots to the left I saw what looked like two copies of a movie or TV show side by side, kind of wavy and translucent. It looked like either they had hung up a sheet and were projecting video onto it, or they had a couple of flat panel displays and there was a sheet between them and me. Then what looked like an arm poked up. If they had been in a tent I would have said it looked like someone in the tent was pushing up on the top, stretching the tent--but tents were not allowed. (There were some trucks and vans that had tent-like extensions on top, so they may have had something like that). The arm moved back and forth a while, and then was apparently pulled down. Then what looked like a leg replaced it...but it was a huge leg. It looked to be about 2 meters long. The "leg" started moving rapidly back and forth along what would be the length of the vehicle. After it had done this a few times, it disappeared. (There may have also been an arm or two mixed in here). Then a light rose up from the middle of the vehicle. I though it might be a flashlight. It then stopped rising, and started turning. It continued turning until it was pointing right at my car, and then it stopped turning for about 10 seconds. Finally, it resumed turning until it went all the way around, and then it descended, and things were dark, with no activity at that other vehicle. I thought "what the hell was all that?". Then the images came back, and the whole thing repeated! The third time it happened I had my phone out and the camera recording. Unfortunately, all the recording shows is that there was some lights moving around in that direction.
- andrewla 9y agoI don't think there are fewer "UFO" sightings than there were 20-30 years ago. I think there are way more. You don't have to dig very far on YouTube to find giant communities of people who are "seeing" UFOs. Video evidence of UFOs is easy to collect -- all you need to do is not identify the objects in the sky. And there are all sorts of weird things in the sky -- reflected lights and spotlights, weather balloons (and regular balloons), drones, sundogs, regular planes, satellites and the ISS, even the occasional actual meteor. It's also much easier to ignore these things, since most of them are just ordinary things that the person who took the video doesn't know how to identify. If you made a great UFO hoax now, chances are nobody would ever see it who was the least interested in looking at it skeptically, because it would be lost in the noise of people seeing trash bags blowing in the wind. So I think that https://xkcd.com/1235/ https://xkcd.com/1235/ is premature about UFOs, though I think it's pretty conclusive about lake monsters and bigfoot (although if you look around, people see a lot of strange looking mangy bears that people think are bigfoot).
- jandrese 9y agoOne thing that is getting harder is taking really shitty video that is impossible to interpret. Phone cameras are getting better every year so the kind of grainy shaky stuttery video you normally get with these cases becomes harder and harder to justify.
- ggm 9y agohttp://hypersonics.mechmining.uq.edu.au/facilities http://hypersonics.mechmining.uq.edu.au/facilities there are still places which put models into chambers. (I know, I used to work behind this one, and we have a steel membrane punched through by the airblast to make the shockwave from the dumpster out back)
- chrisbennet 9y ago”I know, I used to work behind this one, and we have a steel membrane punched through by the airblast to make the shockwave from the dumpster out back” I can’t parse this sentence. Could you explain? Thx
- BoorishBears 9y agoI think the commenter is trying to say they have a steel membrane that had a hole punched through it by an air-blast. Said membrane came from the dumpster out in back.
- ggm 9y agohttp://hypersonics.mechmining.uq.edu.au/t4 http://hypersonics.mechmining.uq.edu.au/t4 the part called "primary diaphragm"
- chrisbennet 9y agoThanks!
- azernik 9y agoAnd also of engines - one of the reasons relatively small companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin can design their own high-performance rocket engines is that they can simulate combustion and fluid flow using CFD techniques. Back in the F1 days they had to light up the engine and come up with interesting ways to observe the internal processes and debug instabilities; now many of those debug cycles (and associated manufactured test articles) are unnecessary. You still have to build the thing to catch some bugs, but that's gotten much cheaper.
- Gravityloss 9y agoAlso CNC and 3D printing have made iterating hardware more possible with less labor. One person teams now can get liquid rocket motors printed. Of course turbopumps are many levels from that.
- ceejayoz 9y agoThis seems a bit "reading the tea leaves" to me. The statements in the article are easily read as "the technology that would allow this is new".
- jmngomes 9y ago'a Lockheed vice president a “digital transformation” arising from recent computing capabilities and design tools had made hypersonic development possible.' The "digital transformation" part alone gives this up as vaporware...
- irishjohnnie 9y agoVideo from SciTech conference https://livestream.com/accounts/6056055/events/8001237/videos/168229789 https://livestream.com/accounts/6056055/events/8001237/video... starting at around 41 minutes
- vpribish 9y agothe bombshell part is from 00:58:58 - 01:00:28 where his phrasing is as if the hypersonic plane has actually been built within the last 5 years, with a 3-d scramjet engine (and 3-d printed as well).
- madengr 9y agoI’d like to see the modified UH60 used in the bin Laden raid. The only hint of it’s existence is the remains of the tail section.
- mhandley 9y agoInteresting, I hadn't heard about that before, but here's a link to an article about it: https://www.defenceaviation.com/2011/05/stealth-uh-60-black-hawk-revealed-by-death-of-osama-bin-laden-in-operation-neptune-spear.html https://www.defenceaviation.com/2011/05/stealth-uh-60-black-...
- lostconfused 9y agoAlso https://theaviationist.com/2016/05/02/five-years-ago-today-the-raid-that-exposed-the-stealth-black-hawk-helicopter/ https://theaviationist.com/2016/05/02/five-years-ago-today-t...
- peterwwillis 9y ago“We couldn’t have made the engine itself—it would have melted down into slag if we had tried to produce it five years ago,” O’Banion said. “But now we can _digitally print that engine_ with an incredibly sophisticated cooling system integral into the material of the engine itself and have that engine survive for multiple firings for routine operation.” They made a computer model that wouldn't immediately destroy itself. Let's calm down a bit.
- Robotbeat 9y agoI'm not saying they've actually built it. But "digitally print that engine" sounds to me like they're talking about additively manufacturing the engine. "Digitally print" is used as a synonym for "3D print" or "additively manufacture."
- maze-le 9y agoIt is noted in the article that this airplane has no real mission profile. I mean hypersonic cruise speed is an impressive feat on its own, and may result in new methods and applications in space travel. But the military usage of a plane like this is questionable. Recon aircraft have long since been abandoned in favor of satellites, and a fleet of bombers might not be maintainable because of the huge costs involved.
- Xylakant 9y agoRecon aircraft still exist. The USAF for example still operates U2 planes. Satellites lack the critical ability to stay in place and cannot necessarily move to a designated spot at short notice. While spy satellites are certainly more maneuverable than regular satellites, they still must obey orbital physics, a plane is not bound to those restrictions.
- melling 9y agoHow maneuverable are you at 6000 mph? You’ll flyover the US in 30 minutes.
- Xylakant 9y agoYou don’t need to fly 6000mph, however. Planes have the ability to adjust their speed, satellites don’t.
- melling 9y agoSure, and at what speed to you become a target to local missiles? I’d like to see a hypersonic plane for the engineering it will solve, but I think as a spy plane, it has limited utility.
- Xylakant 9y agoIt’s not like satellite killer missiles would be a new thing, they’ve been developed since the 1950s
- bactrian 9y ago“However, Aboulafia noted, such a capability could also be considered a destabilizing development if a U.S. adversary decided to react preemptively to such an aircraft’s existence.” In other words China and Russia may contemplate fighting WW3 now rather than waiting to be leap frogged. Fun.
- melling 9y agoChina is already working on hypersonic weapons. They aren’t waiting for anyone. http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/weapons/a14512512/china-reportedly-tests-new-df-17-hypersonic-weapon/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/weapons/a14512512/c...
- bactrian 9y agoChina is always “working on” whatever the US is. Issue comes down to timing.
- adventured 9y agoSimilar to Russia. The increasing gap there of course is that Russia can't keep up with the US and China on investment, they're going to increasingly fall behind except in a few isolated segments of defense tech. Russia is becoming a second tier military power, if they're not already (that is, closer to Germany, India, France etc. than the US and China). The US and China are now spending $1+ trillion per year on their militaries. The combined sum will likely eclipse the entire value of Russia's annual economic output in the next 15-20 years.
- outworlder 9y agoIs it just a budget game, though? How efficient is each country with their budget? US spending one trillion dollars, and China spending one trillion dollars, it doesn't guarantee that they will be technologically matched. It does not have to be symmetric. You only have to spend as much as you need to nullify an adversary's capability. Ex, one does not need to manufacture an aircraft carrier to counter one, you just need to take it out of action.
- Top19 9y agoI won an essay contest in college that NASA set up regarding the future of supersonic and hypersonic aviation. Even back then, supersonic, let alone hypersonic, aviation was such a pipe dream for civilian aviation. Not saying it can’t be done, but I can’t imagine the breakthroughs that need to be made would be made outside of any context short of a World War. Let me list the problems: 1. Materials Science. Very hard to design materials that survive those kind of stresses, and that you know will last 30+ years. Airplanes routinely have 60 year life cycles, so 30 years of material survival is the minimum. The stresses on these things are huge. The Concorde would actually expand 10 inches from head-to-tail during flight because of the heat. 2. Overpromising dating back 40 years. My favorite example is Ronald Reagan promising an “Orient Express” that would be 90 minutes New York to Tokyo. That was in his 1986 “State of the Union”. 3. Acceleration. Flying Mach 6 is one thing. Having a plane that can accelerate up to that speed fast enough that the flight doesn’t already end, AND THEN slow down an equal amount, is another thing. 4. Sound. This sounds like a nuisance thing, until you hear one of these aircrafts in action. THEY ARE SO DAMN LOUD. It’s a health and safety issue almost. I would compare it to being around artillery fire, maybe worse. It stays with you for days. The Japanese and Australians from time to time do some good work on this kind of aviation. Boeing had a civilian supersonic project in the 70’s, but it’s all been given up except for the occasional private jet or military experiment.
- gaius 9y agosupersonic, let alone hypersonic, aviation was such a pipe dream for civilian aviation. Not saying it can’t be done One word: Concorde.
- AmVess 9y agoThis has been known for a while. Seismologists discovered it and tracked one at 5000 MPH. The ability to be anywhere in the world in a very short time is a compelling tool for the military.
- thatcherc 9y agoCan you elaborate on that? I'd be very interested to see how seismologists tracked a plane. Can you pick up high-altitude shockwaves from seismographs?
- vpribish 9y ago1992: 4,000mph, Los Angeles http://articles.latimes.com/1992-04-17/local/me-607_1_spy-plane http://articles.latimes.com/1992-04-17/local/me-607_1_spy-pl... USGS on seismographs and sonic booms generally: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/learn/topics/sonic-booms.php https://earthquake.usgs.gov/learn/topics/sonic-booms.php
- dsnuh 9y agoThere was something about the SR-71 Blackbird that really captured the feeling of the time. Whenever I drive the 215 past March AFB and see the one they have on display, it reminds me of the age of movies like Firefox and War Games.
- kazinator 9y agoI can't see how even America's seventh fastest spy plane could be anything less than hypersonic, let alone the fastest one. :)
- linkmotif 9y agoThis is obviously cool on many levels but fundamentally this is very sad. This, while places in the US don’t have clean running water. The best national defense is creating a next generation that’s healthy, worldly and educated. Instead, this.
- rayiner 9y agoI’m not sure what your point is. We already spend more on education and healthcare per capita than almost every other developed country. At what point is it appropriate to spend the incremental dollar on defense instead?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- linkmotif 9y agoI was with you until you called it the "incremental dollar". We spend 3x more on defense than the nearest competitor[0]—0.6 trillion dollars per year. Given that we only collect $3 trillion per year[1], after debt service we're not really left with that much. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_... [1] https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-budget-101/revenues/ https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...
- fehfehfoo 9y agoI'm under the impression that if the USA doesn't maintain a significant level of military superiority, it will quickly find itself under duress from myriad sources. This is a path which once you start down, you're somewhat committed to in perpetuity.
- linkmotif 9y ago> I'm under the impression that if the USA doesn't maintain a significant level of military superiority, it will quickly find itself under duress from myriad sources. Is England under duress? Is France under duress? Are the Dutch under duress? Is Spain under duress? Most importantly, at what point do we ask ourselves what it is that we are even defending? 50% of the population making less than 5 richest people?
- trhway 9y agoin my view the first stage of SpaceX Falcon is the thing which is most close to the hypersonic transport today. One can imagine that such reusable stage would accelerate the high-altitude/suborbital plane thus solving the task of having engines for different regimes. Cost-wise - the few millions such a reusable stage launch would cost isn't that far from ~$35K/hour costs of SR71 on missions of 10+ hours.
- vpribish 9y agoHaving a degree in aerospace engineering and being a lifelong air and space fan this discussion is mostly disappointing. hacker news comments are of distinctly poorer quality outside the subjects of software and startups - sensation, urban legend, and ignorant story-telling is rising to the top instead of explanation, context, and insight. 8 of the top 10 comments are inane (UFOs! Movies! tinfoil-hats! Sophomore-year economics!). Makes one wonder how much the mainstream hacker news threads are suffering from similar problems that I just can't perceive.
- touristtam 9y agois that the follow up to the Aurora project ? https://www.defenceaviation.com/2007/06/sr-91-aurora-aircraft.html https://www.defenceaviation.com/2007/06/sr-91-aurora-aircraf...