9 ms·
Teenagers now better behaved and less hedonistic but lonelier and more isolated
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoIf the downstream consequences of this: > Teenagers are also having less sex, especially of the procreative kind. In 1991, 54% of American teenagers in grades nine to 12 (ages 14-18) reported that they were sexually experienced, and 19% claimed to have had sex with at least four partners. In 2015 those proportions were 41% and 12%. America’s teenage birth rate crashed by two-thirds during the same period. Is this: > As with alcohol, the abstention from sex seems to be carrying through into early adulthood. Jean Twenge, a psychologist at San Diego State University in California, has shown that the proportion of Americans aged 20-24 who report having no sexual partner since the age of 18 rose from 6.3% for the cohort born in the late 1960s to 15.2% for those born in the early 1990s. Japan is a more extreme case. In 2015, 47% of unmarried 20- to 24-year-old Japanese men said they had never had sex with a woman, up from 34% in 2002. I'm not convinced that is a good thing.
- qubex 9y agoWhy? Repudiation of this abhorrent ”hookup culture” that seems to be sweeping through our western societies is to be applauded. I’m not arguing for abstention, but reserving sex for monogamous, committed relationships is, as far as I am concerned, an unmitigated good.
- hateduser2 9y agoI like that for myself but how can you say that is good?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eecc 9y agoWhy? What’s so intrinsically special in monogamy to deserve the label “unmitigated good”?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwawaycanada 9y agoLong term it's the most stable.
- eecc 9y agoHmm, not sure there's enough data to discern confounding factors and assert monogamy guarantees stable and durable relations. Narrative and history actually suggest otherwise, that the constraint or expectation of monogamy eventually undoes the relationship...
- iotscale 9y agoIMHO it's bad, as long as a lifestyle is pushed heavily from people who aren't immediate family. Doesn't matter if it's "hookup culture" or waiting for the prince charming to marry.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago> as long as a lifestyle is pushed heavily from people who aren't immediate family Is a lifestyle pushed by people who are immediately family inherently a good thing?
- iotscale 9y agoI just thought, to a certain age, it may be required. I'm not a parent so I probably don't know what I'm talking about.
- BjoernKW 9y agoThere’s a vast difference between a hookup culture and having consensual, if casual, sex with someone. A relationship without doubt is a good thing but it isn’t the only thing. Modern society for shallow moral reasons conflates committed relationships with sex. This causes a lot of problems and probably is one of the main reasons why relationships break up or people feel miserable in relationships.
- icebraining 9y agoThere’s a vast difference between a hookup culture and having consensual, if casual, sex with someone. Is hookup necessarily (or even mostly) non-consensual? I'm probably missing some cultural context, what's the distinction you're making?
- BjoernKW 9y agoIt's about the way it's painted in the media. Hookups are often depicted as negative, morally questionable and at times non-consensual as well (mostly involving drugs). There's been a moral panic about this in recent years. Having consensual, casual sex with someone on the other hand shouldn't ever be considered questionable, given that you're being honest with everyone involved, which might include someone you're in a committed relationship with at the time. So, doing something consensually never is a bad thing. Lying is, to others as well as to yourself.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago> Hookups are often depicted as negative, morally questionable and at times non-consensual as well (mostly involving drugs). Why on Earth would you conflate hookups and rape? Please stop.
- BjoernKW 9y agoTo those downvoting this comment: Renowned relationship therapists like Esther Perel seem to agree with me on this matter.
- yarrrr 9y agoThe downvotes are telling. They wanted to make heterosexuals as promiscuous as homosexuals to normalise their situation. Now that's being undone. Certain people are scared.
- qubex 9y agoDon’t try to make this into a proxy for homophobia, please. This (or at the very least my comment) has nothing to do with making value judgements on whom you are attracted to or what orientation you subscribe to. There is no attempt at creating moral equivalency and I am definitely not going to let it stand unchallenged that my stance is about denigrating people of differing orientations.
- yarrrr 9y agoI was talking for myself, not for you. Also, homosexuality is abhorrent.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoHow can nature be abhorrent? That's like saying God made a mistake. It would probably be okay for you to say "I find homosexuality abhorrent", and then we can all laugh you out of the room for your anachronistic opinion. But when you say "homosexuality is abhorrent" without owning the statement, you're attempting to make a universal statement of truth. To which case we will laugh you out of the room for your anachronistic opinion anyway.
- qubex 9y agoYou write about God not making mistakes... but also of repudiating ”Judeo-Christian“ doctrine... which is it?
- shawabawa3 9y agohaha wtf Maybe people just want to enjoy their life without some judgy puritans telling them what to do
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThe idea that there is a hookup culture sweeping through our western societies is directly contradicted by the numbers presented in the very article we are discussing here. And anyway, I reject this prudish Judeo-Christian inspired sexual ethics. Sex is good and good for you. There should be more of.
- qubex 9y agoYou’re most welcome to reject this ”Judeo-Christian prudishness” (or whatever you want to call it) but just keep in mind I’m an atheist, and all for rejecting dogma — including the new doctrines of consumerism that is snaking it’s way into our private sphere, making us all willing to use each other (apparently) for our short-term jollies.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThere is nothing new about us humans having short-term jollies, or even medium- / long-term jollies that are non-monogamous. Short- / medium- / long-term non-monogamous jollies goes as far back as time immemorial. As far back as the beginnings of life itself. I'm willing to bet monogamy is the new normal as far as historical longevity is concerned. I'm no anthropologist, so I'm willing to be corrected on that matter. Also, I'd argue consumerism isn't exactly new either. People have been blowing their pay packets at their local pub since the invention of the local pub.
- vedloseper 9y agoPeople also have been rejecting that since time immemorial, so the strength of your argument just barely suffices to eat itself.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThat some people have been rejecting it since time immemorial doesn't mean those behaviours don't exist. What I'm disagreeing with is this: new doctrines of consumerism that is <snip> making us all willing to use each other (apparently) for our short-term jollies. It isn't the new doctrines of consumerism that are making us do this, it's human nature; we like to fuck. So your argument ... isn't one.
- ParamModule 9y agoI disagree with that completely, like honestly people that prefer monogamy generally do so because they are either afraid to be alone, because it was what they were brought up on, just don't want to deal with being rejected a bunch before hooking up that night, or they are romantics. Monogamy is rarely worth it just because there aren't a lot of people out there in the world that meet the conditions of the sex not becoming boring, and like being interesting enough to you so that you actually want to spend half your free time with them. Like I've only had one long relationship and that was because she met the aforementioned conditions, and I mean we weren't monogamous, like she was basically that one giant slut you knew in high school that got a full ride to Cornell. Like most of the time it doesn't last a month, because I get bored, and just don't see her as worth the maintenance. Especially when like when you are in your 20s like a lot of the pretty attractive girls you built up in your head, actually just lie there once you have sex with them, and because like most young people still haven't fully matured in regards to their interests and knowledge bases they are boring. Before you go on my profile and bring up my post on CPlusEquality, I am not sexist I am just a misanthrope. I find most people boring in large doses.
- tzahola 9y agoDon’t use the word “like” so frequently.
- Fuckthisboard 9y agoDon't tell people what to do
- watwut 9y agoProtip: if you want to argue that non-monogamous sex is cooler and better, your argument will be stronger if you don't call your girl slut. I mean, she is doing what you argue is good, so shaming her weakens that.
- ParamModule 9y agoWell she was really promiscuous, I'm not shaming her but I get it certain words offend certain people so I should filter what I write.
- mcantelon 9y agoThe birthrate in most of the West is sub-replacement. Inter-generation testosterone decreases, and cultural factors, likely play a part. Youth suicides have gone up considerably in the last decade.
- gaius 9y agoInter-generation testosterone decreases It’s not just hyperbole: the youth of today really are soft https://uk.news.yahoo.com/generation-wimps-millennial-men-are-weaker-than-094920561.html https://uk.news.yahoo.com/generation-wimps-millennial-men-ar...
- comstock 9y agoHaving two kids, the answer feels really obvious to me, but I’d love to see data supporting any viewpoint. Raising multiple children in western society is really hard. In many (most?) cases you need to move away from family (parents) so there’s limited support from the community or family. There’s limited childcare available, and on top of that kids are expensive. Often both partners are working (or want to get back to work as soon as possible). So if you can satisfy your procreative desires with one child, you just do that. Compare this to (totally unjust) prior social norms where people didn’t move as far as they do now. Meaning parents could help out. Where it was common to have one non-working partner (so more available time to look after kids). We’ve created a modern society where raising one child is super-stressful. Why would any sane person have two? I predict that as more societies transform toward the western model we’ll see a massive population decline.
- mcantelon 9y agoTrue. Societies may, however, be hesitant to follow our footsteps towards atomization and low birthrate.
- comstock 9y agoI think globally, most societies are follow this trend. My hope would be that we find a way through it. In part, the solution might be more even distribution of the benefits of automation. Less concentration of wealth, lowered cost of living or support which allows both parents to take time off work for the first few grads of their children’s lives.
- quadcore 9y agoI wonder the impact of social media here again. When I was in high school in 2000, there s been a couple of events that could not be done nowdays: a drunk and naked girl dancing on a table, some other having sex in a bar, oral sex in the middle of a party, etc. You do any of that today, you end up on internet.
- iotscale 9y agoGiven enough eyeballs, everyone becomes shallow.
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoYeah, think of the cam scene in American pie. The gossip that fires through the internet. iPhones are like cctvs per person.
- watwut 9y agoYeah, it is much better for 15 years old to get pregnant, then to not have sex before 18. Or something.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoFrom an evolutionary perspective, that is obviously true. The only reason you wouldn't want to get pregnant is that getting pregnant now reduces the number of children you can have over your entire lifespan. This is clearly not the case in, say, the US.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoFrom a biological perspective, what purpose does sexual maturity serve other than perpetuation of the species? Therefore, it could be argued that the idea of teenage pregnancy being a problem is a cultural quirk. It could also be argued that adulthood starting at age eighteen is a cultural quirk.
- watwut 9y agoAs long as you simultaneously don't yell how those mostly-single moms are poor and their lives (and lives of their children) sux because they were irresponsible and don't deserve any help whatsoever cause they brought it on themselves. And as long as you subsequently don't claim all youth criminality on those young moms and dads.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI have no idea what you're on about. I'm not claiming any of that.
- krastanov 9y agoThe point is that many do, and as such this is inherently part of the "cultural quirk" you mentioned. And this is not even mentioning that important development continues after 18.
- silvestrov 9y ago> they were sexually experienced I would really like to know the precise words they were asked. There might be some Bill Clinton effect going on where a blowjob was considered "active" in 1991 whereas camsex, porn and blowjobs isn't in 2015. They might even be more active todays, just in a different way.
- dominotw 9y agoI wonder if there is co relation to immigrantion from traditional cultures.
- kchoudhu 9y agoTake that, Plato!
- Ritsuko_akagi 9y ago>Teenagers who communicate largely online can exchange gossip, insults and nude pictures, but not bodily fluids, blows, or bottles of vodka. >But they are also lonelier and more isolated Heh. Let's see what effects they have after 10-20 years.
- coldtea 9y agoDepression and domesticity? Health is not be-all end-all, especially when you're younger and can afford to be more loose with your lifestyle.
- blfr 9y agoBetter behaved and less hedonistic or just more passive?
- eecc 9y agoWe’re turning our own human ecosystems into a panopticon, no wonder newbies are scared of straying off. Anything can and will be used against you, eventually. (I’m not talking about fascist-kind repression and dissent wipeout, that’s out of our collective memory anyway and eventually only a problem for politicized individuals. No, it’s the much more concrete and pervasive peer control made possible by Facebook, Instagram and the like. It applies to anyone, even the most bland conformist and disengaged people ) Eventually we’ll develop a concept of public persona that takes no shame for the past. Next generation probably, after recognizing their parents were panicked fawns blinded by headlights.
- SimonPStevens 9y agoInteresting similarity with 'the light of other days'. It's about a privacy invading technology and several sections deal with how different groups evolve that deal with the lack of privacy in different ways, both embracing and circumventing the technology.
- adventured 9y agoThere are only two likely reactions imo. Either the culture of the next generation of youth will have an unspoken understanding that certain shit doesn't go onto social media, and their culture will enforce that rule (people that violate that will be socially punished, exiled). Or it'll get worse yet and young people will come up with behavior / approaches to evade social media. Perhaps including an assist from technology in doing so.
- blfr 9y agoYes, maybe. Although I'm a little older than subjects of this article, coming of age on the cusp of the smartphone era but before Facebook and before any of my friends had even a half-decent camera in their phones, and already suspected that the social energy was much lower than it was for people a few years older.
- stuaxo 9y agoWow, what a lot of boring people we are going to create.
- badpun 9y agoBoring is good.
- jeandejean 9y agoIf you're entertained by people who get drunk, smoke and have irresponsible sex, then yes.
- coldtea 9y agoSo, 3 of the most constant ways to entertain one's self throughout the millennia...
- indy 9y agoPerhaps this means that the generation after them will produce great art
- thescribe 9y agoThe future is finally looking up from my perspective, hopefully this leads to an asetic culture.
- BjoernKW 9y agoIndolent and conformist perhaps is another way to describe this. I fail to see how this a good thing. A young generation perpetuating pointless taboos imposed on them rather than making their own experiences frankly is a sad development.
- ikeyany 9y agoIs there anything wrong with waiting to have sex with someone you're invested in? I've found those types of experiences to be worth it, long-term. It's interesting that some see that as naive--it's the opposite if anything. Easy sex is fun but it would seem hard to invest in anyone but myself.
- qubex 9y agoYup, I’m being savagely down-voted for voicing my opinion... apparently by people who embrace the shallowness that’s the hallmark of consumerism extended all the way into the realm of our social experiences, making us mutual fungible products to each other.
- icebraining 9y agoWhy would investing in someone but yourself require giving up sex with others? That dichotomy between the unattached bachelor and the loving monogamous spouse seems to be just another of those taboos.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ikeyany 9y agoYou're not required to "give up sex with others" if you don't want to. Hell, many people are okay with polyamory or casual sex in general. I was merely stating that committing sexually can in fact be a good thing, and that the parent comment cannot speak for everyone.
- andai 9y agoWat?
- zrth 9y agoCan someone explain why less hedonistic is seen as better?
- a_humean 9y agoThat's the debate in the article body. Less hedonistic meaning they are having less sex and so fewer unintended and teenage pregnancies, less drinking and drugs and so less violence and anti-social behavior, better relations with the parents and in particular their fathers, and more pursuing further education. Basically every metric of bad behavior that used to be a cause of concern for 80s and 90s teenagers is across the board at record lows for the current generation of teenagers. Downside is they are more likely to be depressed, stressed, sexless and lonely with weak connections to their age peers.
- gtt 9y agoI don't think drinking less and doing less drugs makes you more depressed, stressed, sexless and lonely. I think the reverse is true with possible exception of loneliness, but you are better off without the type of company booze and drugs provide.
- mantas 9y agoIf company sans booze and drugs exist. Online gaming doesn't count as company.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoBooze and drugs are often social activities. If everyone's busy there's less time to go get high with your friends.
- darepublic 9y agoMore social isolation could lead to both less drugs and sex. Less drugs is probably good but if it is only because people are becoming depressed shut-ins, that's bad
- b6 9y ago
- partycoder 9y agoCould be because of many reasons. e.g: prior generations were exposed to tetraethyllead, which is known to make people aggressive.
- thisacctforreal 9y agoFurther reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#Effect_on_crime_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#Effect_on_crime...
- tzahola 9y agoTeenagers have always rebelled against the rules and ideas imposed on them by their parents/grandparents. This does not mean that they will be more lenient/hedonistic than their parents though! We’re seeing the counterexample in the coming generations. It’s pretty funny to see people’s dismissive reactions in this thread. So much for not being bigoted like your parents, eh? :)
- schiffern 9y agoNot saying I fully buy into it, but this shift is exactly as predicted by Strauss–Howe generational theory.[1] The younger, more conformist Artist archetype generation ('Gen Z,' b2005-????) shows different behavior from the older, more individualistic Hero archetype generation ('Gen Y,' b1982-2004). The cutoff isn't exactly distinct (some people put it after 9/11/2001), so depending on who you ask either Gen Z is just entering teenage years (2005), or most teenagers are already Gen Zers (2001). Heck, it even predict HN's (Gen Yers) general reaction of disdain for the "overprotected" and "timid" generation. Take comfort though: it also predicts that Gen Y will be a dominant generation ("independent behavior + attitudes in defining an era"), while Gen Z will be recessive ("dependent role in defining an era"). Here are the descriptions. I added the actual and projected dates of the latest cycle in parentheses: > Hero generations enter childhood after an Awakening (1961–1981), during an Unraveling (1982-2004), a time of individual pragmatism, self-reliance, and laissez faire. Heroes grow up as increasingly protected post-Awakening children, come of age as team-oriented young optimists during a Crisis (2005-2025), emerge as energetic, overly-confident midlifers (2025-2044), and age into politically powerful elders attacked by another Awakening (2045-2064). > Artist generations enter childhood after an Unraveling (1982-2004), during a Crisis (2005-2025) a time when great dangers cut down social and political complexity in favor of public consensus, aggressive institutions, and an ethic of personal sacrifice. Artists grow up overprotected by adults preoccupied with the Crisis, come of age as the socialized and conformist young adults of a post-Crisis world (2025-2044), break out as process-oriented midlife leaders during an Awakening (2045-2065), and age into thoughtful post-Awakening elders (2065-2084). "History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss-Howe_generational_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss-Howe_generational_theo...
- kjgkjhfkjf 9y agoAlternatively, perhaps the trend is that teenagers nowadays tend to lie less when they're asked about how much sex they have.
- jeandejean 9y agoFor once, an article that doesn't stigmatize teenagers too much, but rather speak about society changes. Usually it's all about criticizing teenagers because they do this or that badly, but when they're better behaved, adults necessarily try to explain how that's wrong... Just give the teens a break! Let them live, learn and play the way they want.
- sideshowb 9y agoI think it's right to ask whether observed changes are healthy, so long as you don't default to saying "change is bad, mmkay".
- spodek 9y ago"Our youth now love luxury. They have bad manners, contempt for authority, they show disrespect for their elders and love chatter in place of exercise; they no longer rise when elders enter the room; they contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up their food and tyrannize their teachers." This quote is hundreds of years old, often misattributed to Socrates, but applies perennially. It describes not values degrading, but changing. To people who value one thing, a younger generation valuing other things feels like degradation since other values seem worse, but there aren't that many human values. Eventually generations cycle through them all and repeat.
- coldtea 9y agoWhen things are often repeated across generations, they can: a) always be true (we generally go to lower standards from the viewpoint of the previous generation, or even from an absolute viewpoint). b) always be false c) Sometimes be true and sometimes be false. I'm not sure why people immediately jump to (b). Perhaps it's comforting to dismiss any worry of decline, and to always attribute it to change. Or it's not fashionable these days to even think about decline (it marks one as old and not "going with the times"). I find (c) much more plausible. After all, whether Socrates said this or not, some such decline happened after Socrates (the dissolution of the Athenian state and its eventual collapse) -- and several other times (in later Rome, etc). And conversely, for huge periods of time people have not had much to complain regarding their children having some different lifetimes, because unlike ancient Athens or Rome or the US 50s and 60s or so, nothing much changed between generations -- a rural family in most of the world would have the exact same day in day out things to do, the same customs, etc, for centuries, with the very subtle and slow occasional imported innovation. It's also funny those that while many would say that steady cultural decline couldn't possibly be happening, as many as all convinced for steady cultural progress -- like history is like some kind of march towards more and more enlightenment. Of course those people have never read history, or experienced how a steady and advanced country (or world, in 1939) can turn backwards in a moment's notice.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoThe problem is that "values changing" looks an awful lot like "values degrading" to those who held the older values, so it's impossible to tell which is which, until perhaps much later on when you have the benefit of hindsight. E.g. gradually increased acceptance of homosexual behavior is considered an obvious sign of moral values degrading among many (perhaps most) of the elderly (and percentage-wise this is even more obviously the case if you go back to the 90's).
- noobermin 9y agoSomething I think that needs to be discussed more is the fact that loneliness in society is actually starting to become a real social issue. People who are lonely are seemingly told by society that their loneliness is internal and must ultimately be their fault...but given the fact that studies like the above show that it is becoming much more prevalent in society seems to suggest there might be societal/structural causes that are effecting the trend, or at least positively affecting its growth in society. I don't see many articles pointing it out so I think it's good seeing one that does.
- jimktrains2 9y agoI wonder how much of it is the rise of the exurbs, where you live by many people, but never talk to them and there is very little community to speak of.
- manigandham 9y agoIt's even worse in dense cities where you may share a building with thousands but not know any of them. It seems the more crowded a location is, the more isolated the people within become.
- jimktrains2 9y agoI've always found the opposite to be true.
- 5555624 9y agoI think it's more of why don't you talk to them -- there are more demands on our time or different demands. I get home from work and I normally don't go back outside to socialize with anyone. I might talk to my neighbor when I am going in or out; but, that's about it. In addition, are newer houses designed for causal chats with neighbors? I recently moved. On my street are houses that are over 100 years old and houses only a couple of years old. Most of the older ones have been well kept or renovated. What's the easiest way to tell the old ones from the new ones? All the old ones have porches big enough for at least a couple of chairs. When I was first looking at my house, I saw people hanging out on their porches and people walking by stopping and chatting or people waling across the street when they saw their neighbor out on the porch. It's a lot easier to stop and talk to someone when you see them outside, than going up and knocking on their door.
- aor215 9y agoI’m surprised no one has brought up how extreme punishment has become for engaging in these behaviors. I don’t have data to back this up, but my sense when I was in high school in the mid 2000s was that any slip up in any of these areas - smoking, drinking, etc. - would result in professional ruin. If caught, the punishment in many “zero tolerance” schools is expulsion and no top college admits students who have been expelled, except in very special cases.
- sunstone 9y agoWhen almost anything you do or say can (and will) be captured at the flick of a switch it modifies behaviour. Big brother is everywhere now if you're a teenager.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]