12 ms·
Poverty-Fighting Startups
- quadrangle 9y agoThere's no sacred cows in this case, just groupthink. Incidentally, Silicon Valley isn't at even typically anti-government. That bit isn't even in the groupthink even if there's a particular anti-government dogma that isn't absent from the milieu. (note: I'm not in SV or it's groupthink, I'm speaking as an observer of it)
- sbierwagen 9y agoIs it... a "startup"? Do they make money? Is Propel even a for-profit company?
- Anderkent 9y agoNon-profits can be startups too, if they're attempting to build new business models.
- tomjakubowski 9y agoI don't see why a company has to be profit-seeking to be considered a "startup". But Propel is indeed for-profit.
- IncRnd 9y ago> Is it... a "startup"? Do they make money? Is Propel even a for-profit company? A startup is a newly established business - that is to say, just starting up.
- zachlatta 9y agoI'm a fan of PG's view: http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html
- IncRnd 9y agoI'll put forward that PG is using his own definition that aligns with his business. His definition differs from that of the dictionary's definition. There's nothing wrong with that, as it helps him achieve day-to-day his goals. But, the definition is otherwise limited in that it is not correct or useful outside of direct investors who are looking for fast growing companies that want to be called startups in order to get startup funding.
- splitrocket 9y agoFor profit. FreshEBT raised a round from A16Z.
- Top19 9y ago>“One of my ambitions is to help our users put more food on the table,” says Jimmy Chen, the founder of Propel. This app has some short-term benefits, but it’s hard to see long-term benefits. What if every government aid program was super easy to sign-up for and instantly check whatever you need. What would change? Less taxes from all the gov workers we’d no longer need?
- Anderkent 9y ago>This app has some short-term benefits, but it’s hard to see long-term benefits. What if every government aid program was super easy to sign-up for and instantly check whatever you need. What would change? Less taxes from all the gov workers we’d no longer need? A lot of people who could receive aid but don't have the time / ability / don't know that they could receive aid would get help? How is that not a good result? And yes, it'd also mean that there's less effort required to find people who need help and verify them, and thus the overhead is reduced.
- rebuilder 9y agoLess taxes as you point out, and more time for aid recipients to spend improving their lives instead of dealing with bureaucracy.
- lazyasciiart 9y agoTo make the most simplistic possible point, having a society where everyone is adequately fed is a longterm benefit. Perhaps you'd be interested in the history of the American school lunch program.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> This app has some short-term benefits, but it’s hard to see long-term benefits. What if every government aid program was super easy to sign-up for and instantly check whatever you need. What would change? More of the people who need those services would be able to get them?
- nico 9y agoLove that this could start becoming a thing. There's a very similar incubator[1] in Chile with the same hypothesis, poor people also have problems that can be resolved through tech/startups and there are plenty of good business opportunities there. [1]: http://www.socialab.com http://www.socialab.com
- mc32 9y agoAt first blush it would seem that coordinating or collaborating with cooperative government agencies might be of benefit as many of these apps seem to streamline and make processes more effective for the ultimate beneficiary of the programs. Obviously this is a benefit for both the recipient and the government organization which wants to serve its pop as well as possible. As someone mentioned in the thread, efficiency could lead to either better benefits to the recipients of the government benefits or they could result in contraction of the government workforce. To that latter concern we must figure out whether people are employed by the government (or companies in general) to do a job or they're there also equally as a part of a social contract to keep the most people possible in gainful employment --which if the latter is true, SV startups are an anathema by design. People for the most part aren't building startups in order to require more people to keep things running --they tend to be in business to save their customers money.
- lazyasciiart 9y agoWait til you hear about the manufacturing industry using machinery!
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- lazyasciiart 9y agoIt's hard to identify what 'unsubstantive' might mean when it apparently doesn't include the idea that businesses are not created in order to employ people.
- aphextron 9y agoFighting poverty is a social and political problem. It is simply a question of will. We have enough wealth on earth to provide food, clothing, and housing to every single human being. Why don't we do it? That's a political question. The technology is trivial. >“One of my ambitions is to help our users put more food on the table,” says Jimmy Chen, the founder of Propel. His company makes a mobile app called FreshEBT that helps people among the U.S.’s 43 million recipients of the electronic benefit transfer (EBT) service to stretch their food-stamp benefits as far as possible. I read "we're here to somehow insert fees between you and your food stamp money". The self delusion of these people is incredible.
- john_moscow 9y ago>Fighting poverty is a social and political problem. It is simply a question of will. We have enough wealth on earth to provide food, clothing, and housing to every single human being. Why don't we do it? That's a political question. The technology is trivial. Because there is a huge and complex domain of human motivation, appreciation for hard-earned things vs. taking them for granted and so on. USSR tried doing exactly that with the planned economy and trying to distribute the wealth more or less evenly and failed miserably. Mostly because people lost motivation for achievement and started blatantly faking numbers and statistics since the connection between the results of their work and their life quality was completely lost. As someone who survived that crash, I would really hope that SV can learn from others' mistakes rather than repeating them.
- lsc 9y agoeh, You can have a very strong welfare state that provides minimal food, shelter, medical care and clothing to everyone who needs it without having a planned economy. They really are different issues. there's a big difference between a welfare state and full out socialism; the difference is largely about power... Socialisim is about giving the workers control over the means of production. The welfare state is merely about seeing to it that people don't starve. We're rich enough, in America, at least, that with tax increases, we could provide the minimum for everyone, and pay for it out of the sorts of taxes we pay now (only, of couse, somewhat more) There was a lot of effort in that direction here and in the UK in the '70s; there was a lot of criticism that the public housing, for instance, wasn't very nice, but what really ended it was the rise of the political movement that backed Thatcher (in the UK) and Reagan (in the US)
- noobermin 9y agoI'm not from Silicon Valley, so the only sampling I have of SV culture comes from this site[0]. From what I see, the article has a refrain that being anti-libertarian goes against the SV gain, but I see political opinions from across the political spectrum here, and my leftist opinions are often upvoted. So, while I can see investors being skeptical, would the tech community as a whole be anti-welfare? I don't necessarily think so. Regardless, that's just a nitpick about the article. I'm happy that these businesses are doing what they are doing. [0] FWIW, the article cited a comment from here, so this place must be important enough to cite as an example of SV attitudes
- azernik 9y agoI think SV culture tends to be politically extremist, or to be more accurate fundamentalist, in whatever ideology it pursues. I see more hard-line libertarians, but also more hard-line socialists, than in other subcultures. There's a long tradition of political extremism among engineers in cultures around the world; something to do with seeing society as a system simple enough that a single human being can understand the solutions to its problems. Hayek (who I disagree with on many points) even wrote a whole essay on it, with this very lovely point: "It is this awareness of being part of a social process, and of the manner in which individual efforts interact, which the education solely in the sciences or in technology seems so lamentably to fail to convey. It is not surprising that many of the more active minds among those so trained sooner or later react violently against the deficiencies of their education and develop a passion for imposing on society the order which they are unable to detect by the means with which they are familiar." https://mises.org/library/engineers-and-planners https://mises.org/library/engineers-and-planners Gambetta and Hertog tried to quantify this, and found that engineers were over-represented (drastically) in Islamist terrorist networks, and (less drastically) in Western right-wing extremism; and that Western left-wing extremists tended more towards a humanities education. I've read lots of newspaper write-ups of the book, but haven't gotten my hands on a copy, so I don't know their speculation on the causes of the left-right split they observed in studies. https://press.princeton.edu/titles/10656.html https://press.princeton.edu/titles/10656.html They also have older scholarly write-ups, which I should probably take a look at, e.g. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-journal-of-sociology-archives-europeennes-de-sociologie/article/why-are-there-so-many-engineers-among-islamic-radicals/91ED8BEFDE3793834667750B31575422 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-journal-of-... EDIT: So, looked at that paper at last, and it seems the right-wing stereotype of SV people is likely true. They looked at Westerners to try to make comparisons, and while they found no overrepresentation in violent groups, they did look at surveys of political views of educated people by degree. The best data they could find was about faculty members from 1984, so keep the age and restricted subset in mind. "The results are startling (Table 7). The proportion of engineers who declare themselves to be on the right of the political spectrum is greater than in any other disciplinary group: 57.6 % of them are either conservative or strongly conservative, as compared to 51.1 of economists, 42.5 of doctors and 33.5 % of scientists, 21.4 % of those in the humanities, and 18.6 % of the social scientists, the least right-wing of all disciplinary groups. Only 1.4 % of engineers are on the left, as opposed to 12.9 % in the social sciences and 16.7 % in law. Perhaps this is an uncanny coincidence, but the four fields at the top of the conservatism scale – engineering, economics, medicine, and science – are the same four secular fields we found at the top of our main jihadist sample." They also cited a more recent Canadian study (1999) with similar results. Anyway, there are many other interesting findings in that paper; highly recommended.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sax 9y agoPropel (and bunch of other ventures) have their genesis at the Blue Ridge Labs. Blue Ridge Labs focuses on bringing together people who are interested in product, design and engineering to go out and apply tools of empathy and discovery to understand the problems faced by low-income and socially disadvantaged Americans. For anyone who is at crossroads in their career, I would highly recommend reaching out to @BlueRidgeLabs. I vouch for and support the sincerity of their mission. Have questions about Blue Ridge Labs? Reach out to @cromulus. Looking to find an engineering position in NYC reach out to @FreshEBT. I am @rksio
- ksk 9y agoHow are these startups planning to pay back the VC money? The poor don't exactly have a lot of money. Where are they going to get the money from? I am skeptical anytime a VC invests in "solving poverty".
- dishwishy 9y agoContrary to how it sounds, you can't eat a double-byte character. This does seem to feel slightly like rent seeking on behalf of these companies.
- songzme 9y agoIts important to know that you don't need millions of dollars to help people and do good. My salary was 145k with it I started a non profit that pays low-income earners minimum wage while they learn how to code. These people could really benefit from learning how to problem solve but they don't have the luxury to quit and join a bootcamp. With my salary, I was able to help 3 people at first but now (after getting a new job and selling my vested stocks) we are able to support 13 students. When I visited CalWorks (local government assistance program) to see if they could help my project financially, they were really excited and agreed to refer students (who are on the poverty line) and also pay the students so I don't have to. Before we joined, the only kinds of job training they were able to offer were the likes of Amazon warehouse packaging and hotel cleaning. I hope to empower more low-income earners to have the ability to simplify complex problems and problem solve.
- songzme 9y agoJust in case someone likes the vision and wants to donate, here's a donation link: https://secure.givelively.org/donate/garage-script https://secure.givelively.org/donate/garage-script
- maged 9y agoAre you accepting/looking for volunteers?
- songzme 9y agoYes! Please send me an email (in my profile)
- Fuckthisboard 9y agoCircle jerking startups
- CapacitorSet 9y agoPoverty-fighting? They're quite literally poverty-exploiting.
- splitrocket 9y agoThey save people money on their groceries. They save people time looking up their balance (previously it was a phone call). How are either of those things exploitative?
- ptaipale 9y agoThe road out of poverty is through what is called "exploitation" in Marxist theory - particularly, international trade. As British economist Joan Robinson put it :"The misery of being exploited by capitalists is nothing compared to the misery of not being exploited at all."
- k__ 9y agoIf a poverty fighting startup would work it would be a huge plus for capitalism, I think. How to get poor people at least to an average income while making some money yourself. I'm from Germany and at least here I have the feeling that the issue is mostly missing education opportunities for older people. Sure, the "really" poor without any job have more time on their hands, but there are probably a huge bunch of people who could work as taxi diver or waiter, who can make 1000€ a month without the need of too much education. While you probably can mingle with the "Arbeitsagentur" (part of the public service for unemployed people) to get the people without income paid by them while you re-educate them, the much bigger part are the people who work but simply don't make enough money to have an okay life. Also, while you have to get the second part of the people like 1000€ a month so they can do their re-education fulltime, you also have to make money yourself. All I found today were some models, where the re-educated had to pay like 10-20% of their first income as payment later. This doesn't sound too bad, since it forces the education-company to get them ready for jobs, but on the other hand it maybe prevents people from getting good jobs? I don't really know. The other model could be more like Mozilla does it, getting big sponsors, but then you are working for the sponsors and not for your customers anymore :/
- known 9y agoGovt should go for https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income Citizens can opt for https://www.givedirectly.org/efficiency https://www.givedirectly.org/efficiency
- RickJWag 9y agoDoes anyone else find it odd to make a smartphone app for EBT users? If I were broke, one of my first moves would be to go to a cheaper phone, maybe a flip-phone style. But maybe that's what the author meant by the trade of time and convenience for cost.... I really, truly believe that money skills lead to the accumulation of wealth, and that they are acquirable (teachable) skills.
- blackrock 9y agoThe greed of the rich and well-connected, is beyond belief. Capitalism has failed for a segment of the population. Democracy has failed for them. You need money to make money. You need education, skills, connections, and health to get and maintain a job. Have you seen the pictures of Skid Row in Los Angeles? http://ww2.kqed.org/news/wp-content/uploads/sites/10/2016/01/HomelessFoodLine-800x518.jpg http://ww2.kqed.org/news/wp-content/uploads/sites/10/2016/01... https://world.wng.org/sites/default/files/styles/three_col_full_width/public/carousel-images/SkidRow82-w.png?itok=W3O9S67- https://world.wng.org/sites/default/files/styles/three_col_f... This is the reality on the ground in Los Angeles. There are several blocks in downtown Los Angeles, where when you step into it, it feels like you stepped into a land that time forgot. The people are destitute. They have failed at one thing or another in life, and that has brought them to this point. And what is the result of this? It has created a micro-3rd-world-country, right in the heart of one of the richest cities in the world. Where people drive by in expensive Mercedes, BMW, and Tesla cars. The rich don't care about this, because they will never drive through the poor parts of town. But for everyone else, it makes life miserable for all. At some point, you just have to cut your losses with these people. They are not going to get any corporate job. They pan-handle, beg, and harass people on the streets. Society, the city, the state, and the federal government, must step in to provide a baseline for these people. Give them a damn fake job, give them money, give them food, give them shelter. Just get them off the streets. If society cannot do this for them, then take the next step, and go extreme. Incarcerate them. Make it illegal to be homeless. Throw them into a prison. At least that way, they will get fed, have a jumpsuit for clothing, and a warm shelter. This is a human rights issue. And for the United States to claim that they are the greatest at human rights, then all you have to do is to look at the homeless, the underbelly of society, and see the people that has failed in society. And here, you will see the hypocrisy of a society that has no desire or inclination to help them.