22 ms·
Does anyone else think it's time for a new and promising operating system? The hegemony of OS X/Windows/Linux has basically gone on for a generation. Shout-out
by pmarreck 9y ago
Does anyone else think it's time for a new and promising operating system? The hegemony of OS X/Windows/Linux has basically gone on for a generation.
Shout-out to BeOS (the old geeks will know of it) which was the last promising new OS I encountered... and that was many moons ago
- baq 9y agoit'd be certainly nice, but writing a kernel is easy compared to having working device drivers - that's hard enough on windows/linux/macos...
- RandomInteger4 9y agoIs it the writing of device drivers that's the difficult part or just the fact that there's so many devices to write drivers for?
- pjmlp 9y agoBoth.
- Const-me 9y agoBoth but I think #1 is harder to solve/workaround. Many modern devices (GPUs are most famous for that but there’re others, e.g. printers) include their microcode/firmware/binary blobs as a part of their device driver. Technically you can reuse these binaries for different OS, but legally, at least if you’re on American soil, you can’t.
- hedora 9y agoIt depends on what device you are writing drivers for. I’ve done a few in userspace, and it can take between 60 minutes (with simulation for testing) and a few engineers a year. That’s ignoring stuff like filesystems, network protocols, shader compilers, or whatever else you need to get basic functionality out of the device. Also, a given chip might require anywhere between 2-3 drivers (for something simple like a power controller) to hundreds + a stand-alone OS (for things with an embedded microprocessor, like a drive or some fpgas) It is tedious work, but I’d love to see the BSD’s band together with a hardware manufacturer to produce a high end consumer-grade laptop with a 4-5 year production lifespan, and well-supported hardware. There haven’t been any noteworthy hardware improvements in that space in the last 5 years (arguably a 2013 MBP is better than a 2018 one in most ways), so this isn’t as crazy as it used to be. These laptops could be similar to Windows laptops also sold by the same vendor, which reduces engineering costs. Dell sort of does this for Linux, but they churn the models too quickly for the BSD’s to catch up, in practice. The vendor could rotate a new model in every 2-3 years (maybe rotate form factors each time), and make it a sustainable business. There is precedent for this in the embedded space. Look at PC Engines, for example.
- StillBored 9y agoBesides the negative side effects in linux of not having a stable kernel API, is the fact that 3rd party OS's have a really hard time leveraging the opensource work companies do for linux. If the linux driver model were stable enough that a linux driver book was accurate more than 3 months after it was published it would be possible for people to write API compatibility layers for certain classes of drivers and leverage that work in other OSs.
- MisterTea 9y agoShout out to Plan 9 and Inferno. Two operating systems that were decades ahead of their times and who's distributed partitioning architecture and ideas are desperately needed in a networked world of ever increasing complexity, bloat, and protocols. And I was a BeOS fan back in the day. Just stumbled across my old R5 box after cleaning out the attic. Very clever design for its time but didn't bring anything to the table in terms of networking, multi-user or distribution. It was a multimedia oriented, multi-threading speed demon and not much else.
- pmarreck 9y agoWas always fascinated by Plan9 and Inferno... from a distance. Way ahead of its time. I’m glad some of its ideas (probably notably UTF-8) made their way to more conventional OS’es.
- MisterTea 9y agoUTF8 is probably the least of them. The really good ideas such as the virtual file system, it's networked counterpart 9p, everything as a file including shared libraries (there is no dynamic linking in plan 9), per-process namespace partitioning (each process gets its own file system and you control what it sees), no root user, modular kernel and system components like CPU, DISK and AUTH services which can be ran on different systems, etc. Too many to name. Plan 9 was so far ahead of its time that I honestly think people just couldn't understand the need for such a powerful OS circa 1990 when the PC world was still on DOS, Apple was a niche, and Unix was something a Student or business professional used.
- jm547ster 9y agoRedox is interesting and shows promise https://github.com/redox-os/redox https://github.com/redox-os/redox ...but it’s in no way a departure from the status quo, even referring to itself as kernel + GNU/BSD style ecosystem. I wonder if we will see a new paradigm anytime soon. The Hurd?
- busterarm 9y agoThe amount of evangelism around Redox, especially from jackpot51 himself, while it's still really little more than a toy, leaves me nervous backing such claims.
- tormeh 9y agoWell, it's the first OS that isn't built on C/C++ (unsafe languages). That alone is a huge step forward for security and correctness. And it seems to improve on Linux on most ways, which is nice. Sure, besides Rust there aren't any new big ideas going on in Redox, but is there anything better out there? Rust+microkernel sounds like state-of-the-art to me.
- busterarm 9y ago> Well, it's the first OS that isn't built on C/C++ (unsafe languages)... This isn't even remotely true, but we're in the age of short memories. There have been several operating systems built in Java within our (careers') lifetimes. And dozens of operating systems that predate C. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_operating_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_operating_systems There's nothing preventing other operating systems from being written in a safe way -- they just aren't. There are also multiple definitions of the word "safe". As in, "BSD or Linux are safe to bet the software architecture of my multi-million systems budget". No new ideas mean no reason for me to even consider adoption until it reaches critical mass. Maybe in a decade I'll give it a look. Edit: Multics was written in PL/I, which itself just had a new stable release this past September... Edit2: Redox isn't really that safe even. It's pretty cavalier and leaves a lot up to the application. It uses the unsafe parts of Rust a bit. An application can still malloc and forget to free -- so aren't you right where you started? Really every time this comes up, I would like to posit that "people evangelizing Redox don't even know what the f* they're talking about", but I honestly don't have time outside of my real work to dig into the thing. jackpot51 is fantastic at PR for his project though, and I don't want to discourage anyone from working on. It's good that it has an active community, I just don't need to hear about it. Edit3: Checking Redox' source shows that about 1.5% of the code invokes 'unsafe' and they cite this in their documentation, but what I really want to know is how frequently those lines of code are called.
- pjmlp 9y agoNow even with Microsoft introducing WSL, I fear the POSIXfication of OS architectures. However there is still hope, when we look at the ongoing userspace transitions on mobile OSes. I mean, the kernel might still be UNIX or Windows like, but the userspace is quite different.
- amelius 9y agoYes. We need new requirements more than we need new implementations of the same.
- okreallywtf 9y agoMinix is going to take over any day, just you wait and see!
- naner 9y agoApparently it already did. Wasn't it said to be running the management engine on all Intel chips?
- omnimus 9y agoI think that was sarcasm.
- hinkley 9y agoI think he knows that.
- knowThySelfx 9y agoI think too.
- carussell 9y agoHaiku, Minoca, SPIN, Fuchsia, etc. If you're actually interested in alternative computing, choices abound.
- pmarreck 9y agoHaiku is just a rebranded BeOS, no? Minoca is for embedded devices... not really GP SPIN looks... very rough/early-stage Fuchsia looks... interesting, I guess, even if it's going to be subject to the same exact mutation-related bugs and security holes that have plagued C-based OS'es for years
- pjmlp 9y agoWell, Fuchsia has more C++, Rust, Go and Dart code than C.
- rekado 9y agoIt's time for the Hurd to gain more developers. It is a very elegant and flexible system, which de-emphasizes super users and gives more power to regular users. Thanks to NetBSD/rump kernel and the POSIX persona of the Hurd, it can get a whole bunch of device drivers with relatively little effort.
- axlprose 9y agoYep, luckily there are definitely a good handful of interesting OS projects around. HelenOS[0] stands out to me the most due to its component-based design. Though I'm also looking forward to seeing how seL4[1] and Genode[2] might be put to use. [0] http://www.helenos.org/ http://www.helenos.org/ [1] https://sel4.systems/ https://sel4.systems/ [2] https://www.genode.org/ https://www.genode.org/
- Cyph0n 9y agoNot sure about the others, but seL4 is a microkernel, so it likely won't be adopted as a user facing OS.
- snvzz 9y agoI'm interested. Please elaborate on your reasoning.
- Cyph0n 9y agoFrom my understanding, it was designed to be a small, verifiable kernel intended for use in applications with high-end reliability requirements (e.g., military, aerospace). In the case of seL4, verifiability comes from a formal specification of its key operations that is proven using a theorem prover. The spec is implemented in multiple languages including Haskell and of course C. As it stands, formal verification is limited to very small codebases: seL4 itself is on the order of 10k lines of C. Extending the proof further outside the current boundary to cover additional functions that are typically found in OS kernels would be prohibitive to say the least!
- snvzz 9y ago>From my understanding, it was designed to be a small, verifiable kernel intended for use in applications with high-end reliability requirements (e.g., military, aerospace). It's immediately and very obviously useful for these fields. It is small indeed, because it follows the principle of minimality, introduced by Liedtke's L4. But do not get this wrong: It is a general purpose µkernel. This principle of minimality (the supervisor mode µkernel should only do something if it can't be done by a service in user mode) is the difference between 1st and 2nd generation µkernels. seL4 is a 3rd generation µkernel: It's designed around capabilities. Genode is building a framework to create OSs based on µkernels. They do support many µkernels, but there's been some serious effort put into their seL4 support. Genode isn't quite there yet for this purpose, but does have ambitions of being the base for a general purpose OS. Here's a 2014 update on lessons learned from L4. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdoaFc5-1Rk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdoaFc5-1Rk If at any point you've thought "sure, but doing things like this is slow", then I suggest reading this. http://blog.darknedgy.net/technology/2016/01/01/0/ http://blog.darknedgy.net/technology/2016/01/01/0/
- has2k1 9y agoWhen it is time someone or a group of people will step up. Then issue will become that of adaptation. Enough people will have to see it through the early and rough stages. Prospective users will have to not get turned off by negative hastily written or outdated opinion pieces. Most people would not be willing to give a chance to what may be a great product in 5-10 years. So the next great operating system will most likely sneak in through a Trojan horse. My bet would be, containers, something, something, something, operating system.
- otakucode 9y agoAbsolutely. But every single new operating system project falls into the trap of following all the same old patterns. It seems to be very difficult to approach problems and realize that the constraints that guided all of the old design choices simply no longer exist. Today different challenges exist and people would rather perpetuate re-creating the limitations of the past and then solving those nice understood problems than they would like to solve the new problems. For instance, today we don't have text terminals. We have high-dpi displays. So why is the first thing you reach for a text buffer? Stop it. Vector-based fonts should be step zero. Raster graphics ought to come along pretty far down the line when you get to texture surfaces. We don't run with video units with basic memory-mapped framebuffers any more. Our storage also isn't seek-bound in most cases, we have RAM that can bust the limits of even old filesystem designs made for bulk storage. We have more now and just like the physicists say, More Is Different. But the next revolutionary OS will probably come along and announce their goal of POSIX compliance and people will still trick themselves into thinking its 'new'. I'd rather see an OS that realizes the things the Internet and web have taught us and integrates it. What people want is search and instant-on application functionality. They don't care if it's "an app" or its "a webpage" or whatever. They want it to work, they don't want to "install", etc. And if you can murder the browser and get back to something native and cut the eye out of every company monetizing themselves through user behavior data sales, all the better!
- shalabhc 9y ago> For instance, today we don't have text terminals. We have high-dpi displays. So why is the first thing you reach for a text buffer? Stop it. +1. The familiar ideas and approaches are 'easy' but not necessarily the best (or even good) today. Lets start with the notion of an operating system and why it's needed? What purpose belongs within the OS vs outside? Some fundamental research along these lines would go a long way.
- bogomipz 9y agoI'm confused, Beos and Linux aren't that far apart, maybe 4 years at most.
- DonaldFisk 9y agoWhat about EROS and its relatives? Or Genera? Or even TempleOS? Then there are some older systems worth looking at (e.g. ITS, MCP, VME/B, Oberon). Some ideas: The system language should be the operating system. No need for files if it's image-based, just persistent objects. Atomic system calls. Capabilities instead of access control.
- abecedarius 9y agoI'd love to see KeyKOS on modern hardware. http://www.cap-lore.com/CapTheory/upenn/ http://www.cap-lore.com/CapTheory/upenn/ for docs, http://www.cap-lore.com/CapTheory/KK/Apridos/ http://www.cap-lore.com/CapTheory/KK/Apridos/ for code for old hardware.
- kjs3 9y agoThe L4 ecosystem is interesting and there's a lot of activity going on. If you're just interesting in something 'not OSX/Windows/Linux', there's the IBM Mainframe world (you can use the Hercules emulator to run the software) or the DEC nee HP VMS world (there's a free hobby license). Way out, you can run Symbolics Genera in a VM and see how the world would have been if Lisp had won.
- floren 9y agoAs someone who worked on Plan 9 for over a decade, it would be incredibly difficult. The first question out of everyone's mouth, even back in the early 2000s: "So can you run [Mozilla/Firefox] on it?" No, we couldn't and that was with a very POSIX-like system; the browser is the killer app today and it's also an operating system all its own, meaning it's one of the hardest things to port. We had enough of a basic browser that you could read HTML pages, but otherwise you're stuck with 'linuxemu' which only worked up to a certain (old) version of Debian because the Linux kernel changed shit. If you decide POSIX is a bad paradigm, you're going to have an even harder time getting a browser running. Of course, most of the shit we do with junky web apps today could just be presented as a 9P service with maybe a couple shell scripts in front of it, but the junky web apps already exist and are in use.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmarreck 9y agoI'll give you a lot of credit for working on Plan9 that long... but yeah, you're correct, a browser port would require a fairly large and well-funded team at this point, on any new OS
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAnyone have links to the plan9 propaganda pictures? Some of them were hilarious. https://imgur.com/a/Q4aMc https://imgur.com/a/Q4aMc "There is no fork." Apparently they're from 9front, a fork of plan9: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12617036 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12617036 http://9front.org/img/ http://9front.org/img/ is filled with a bunch of random stuff. The diagram of plan9 at http://9front.org/img/fs.png http://9front.org/img/fs.png seems useful. "Plan9 has been forked": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2772718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2772718 Note the discussion on rc, plan9's scripting language: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2773275 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2773275 Maybe someone can borrow some ideas for their next OS. EDIT: Aha: http://9front.org/propaganda/ http://9front.org/propaganda/
- 9y ago
- danbruc 9y agoThe problem is probably going to be that if you really want to be innovative and not just reimplement decade old ideas then you will break a lot of existing applications. There are certainly hundreds or thousands of nice and well researched ideas out there but if you fundamentally change how you handle address spaces, perform inter process communication, isolate processes, store files or what not you will break applications and have to reimplement or at least adapt them, too. You will also need drivers for hundreds and thousands of components. And thousands of protocols and standards. A billion Dollar and a decade of work will probably not be enough to seriously compete with existing operating systems. Maybe you could build a POSIX layer for compatibility but now you are already building two operating systems.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoSo, after typing this I realized that it is all related to Desktop OSs, not servers, so keep that in mind when reading. I don't think applications are really the big problem these days with virtualization and all. If your OS can virtualize other OSs, that can act as your compatibility layer. Windows 7(?) did it for XP, MacOS X did something kinda like it for classic, etc. The real problem is you have to offer a compelling reason for people to A) want to use it over alternatives, and B) develop for it over alternatives. Personally I think if you can make it really developer and power user friendly a lot of applications might show up just because the system is a joy to work in for the kinds of people who make things. You'll note that this is pretty much the opposite of where Desktop OSs have been heading. Also, drivers. Not sure how to crack that nut.
- danbruc 9y agoIf you virtualize applications then there will be no real benefit for using your new operating system, it just adds complexity and degrades performance over running natively and will hardly be able to make use of features setting your operating system apart. Maybe you could really attract developers but that would not change anything fundamentally, normal users wouldn't come until the developers have native and better replacements for applications users want to use. It just shifts the burden a bit from you building the operating system and the applications to you building the operating system and other developers hopefully building the applications. It won't change the amount of time and money required, maybe even increase both because it is no longer a single concerted effort.
- bunderbunder 9y agoI do, but I'm not confident that the Linux monopoly will go anywhere. It's a network effects thing. Everyone demands POSIX compatibility, and it's getting to the point where software doesn't even try to be cross-platform anymore; it just assumes you've got POSIX and a GNU environment. Possibly even specifically Linux -- Docker will run on other OSes, but it does so by launching a Linux VM to run all the containers in.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoSo what happens now that systemd is dragging Linux away from POSIX compatibility?
- mcguire 9y agoPOSIX itself doesn't matter (it really hasn't since there were competing UNIXes and portability was important.)
- JdeBP 9y agoPOSIX is an interface contract between users/programmers and the operating system, and very much matters.
- pjmlp 9y agoNot really, nowadays Linux compatibly seems more relevant than plain old POSIX, and even then only when coding in C or C++. "POSIX Abstractions in Modern Operating Systems: The Old, the New, and the Missing" http://www.cs.columbia.edu/nsl/papers/2016/posix.eurosys16.pdf http://www.cs.columbia.edu/nsl/papers/2016/posix.eurosys16.p...
- y4mi 9y agoIt's true that web applications are very Linux-centric, there are however a lot of business solutions that run on Windows. ELO, DATEV, SAP comes to mind.
- woolvalley 9y agoThere has to be some market need to make a new OS. Right now there isn't much of one. What will it practically accomplish that the current infrastructure doesn't? The future of OSes is stuff like android, iOS, Qubes (security) or MirageOS (simplicity for security)
- nextos 9y agoAnd NixOS, a fantastic functional way to administer machines. And ready for prime time.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThat's the vision of the future that makes me want to give up computing and live in a cave.
- woolvalley 9y agoThe thing is the benefits are not big enough for the costs compared to other more exciting things like self driving cars and machine learning. Also 'make a new os' is much like 'rewrite vs improve in place'. Most mature engineers do improve in place. New systems research innovations come through improve in place operations. Change a filesystem, change that subsystem and eventually you have a new way of doing things.
- fh973 9y agoMarket need likely, but it is hard to get people to pay for software licenses.
- woolvalley 9y agoOh they are willing to pay for it, if it can be delivered properly. What do you think sysmantec and a million other enterprise security and it management companies are part of?
- danbruc 9y agoHere is another thought. One has to realize that nobody wants an operating system. People only use them because it is the only way to run the applications the users actually wants to use. If you could run an office suite, a browser and a mail client without Windows or Linux, that is what people would do. At best an operating system is absolutely invisible, realistically it causes additional pains over those inflicted by the applications. I can not really imagine how this could work, but a new non-OS would probably be a better idea than a new OS.
- pjmlp 9y agoEasy, that is how we used to program in the old days on systems where the language runtime was the OS.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoApplication management, window management, resource management, document management, etc. OSs are more than just the applications they run, they provide the user ways to manage their workflow. On the other hand, you know what OS was practically invisible? DOS. And DOS was pretty great, so maybe you're on to something.
- spc476 9y agoMS-DOS wasn't that great. Oh, don't get me wrong, it's great at being a singer user, non-reentrant interrupt handler on a painful to program architecture [1]. A lot of applications skipped using device drivers entirely for things like the keyboard, video and serial I/O (using such made the program run more slowly). Do you know how much work it was to redirect the input/output of an MS-DOS application? It can get pretty insane [2]. [1] You had to pick a memory model to compile against for one thing---tiny, small, medium, compact, large or huge. You had to deal with FAR and NEAR pointers, and it really drove home the point that sizeof(int) != sizeof(long) != sizeof(void *) when writing C on that system. [2] http://boston.conman.org/2015/12/13.1 http://boston.conman.org/2015/12/13.1 More info here: https://github.com/spc476/NaNoGenMo-2015 https://github.com/spc476/NaNoGenMo-2015
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- orionblastar 9y agoI think rather than reinvent the wheel and make an OS from scratch, just get involved with one already being developed. Haiku is an open source free rewrite of BeOS and they are trying to make an OS that can run BeOS apps. https://www.haiku-os.org/ https://www.haiku-os.org/ AROS is an open source and free AmigaOS 3.X rewrite, it can run old Amiga apps. http://aros.sourceforge.net/ http://aros.sourceforge.net/ OSFree is an open source and free OS/2 clone. http://www.osfree.org/ http://www.osfree.org/ ReactOS is an open source and free OS to try and be like XP/2003 in a way and has made some progress recently. https://reactos.org/ https://reactos.org/ If I was in charge of Microsoft or Apple, I'd look into one of those OSes to fund and exchange code with instead of creating one from scratch. While they are not ready for prime time if some billion dollar company invests one million USD in just one of them, it could get it to get out of the alpha stage and go beta or retail in a few years or so.
- elihu 9y agoYes, and more than that we need a good, better thought-out modern successor to POSIX-type interfaces. For instance: I think a process ought to be able to have more than one current working directory and possibly more than one user-ID at a time. It should have the option to insert data in the middle of a file without having to manually shift the rest down. Shell scripts should be able to interact with the filesystem via transactions that can be rolled back if anything fails. Programs should be able to have typed input and output, checked by the shell and/or OS, which could also enable command-line tab-completion to search installed programs for any that match a desired type. I have a bunch of other random gripes with POSIX-style OS interfaces and find it a bit frustrating that these interfaces haven't changed much in decades and seem to have attained a lot of inertia of the "we do it this way because we've always done it this way" kind.
- pmarreck 9y agoForget the fallacious appeals to tradition- Are there any competing (possibly superior) specs to POSIX?
- spc476 9y agoWell, there is Synthesis OS [1] where the kernel can rewrite itself on the fly to provide synthesized system calls (think of a specialized `read()` call that can return a file line-by-line for just a simple example). But even that is (was?) almost 30 years ago. [1] http://valerieaurora.org/synthesis/SynthesisOS/ http://valerieaurora.org/synthesis/SynthesisOS/
- renox 9y agoThis OS was much superior from a latency POV but if I remember the article it had no security so..
- rollcat 9y agos/specs/PoCs/ Write one.
- StillBored 9y ago
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoOS isn’t that interesting anymore. We take them for granted, and can’t imagine them doing anything more than they do now that can’t be done well enough in user space. BeOS was exciting because it was doing something that other OSes weren’t doing yet, now it would be old hat.
- mamcx 9y agoWeirdly I dream recently about this (all start imaging a relational language, then it get bigger and bigger), with new CPU arch, memory, etc (with full sci-fi capabilities) The main problem is compatibility. The solution is virtualize. Let's say at least provide headless linux (Docker?). This is enough to start. Imagine that linux run not too bad here (ie: fast enough), just to keep dreaming. The next is why? Why build for this OS if I "just" can run linux here? The conventional narrative is that the OS is "boring" "invisible" etc. I think instead that is only true because most OS are boring. If we think as a master integration then is more cool. Consider the posibility to turn the unix text stream/pipelines as the actual UI paradigm (like react) and have the ability to connect not only apps, but components inside. For example, If I'm in mail and wanna crop the image I just put here, I need to detour a lot to Photoshop then return to mail. Why? I think is possible to say "This is a image. Any app/component that could operate on it can do it". So, in short, is a UI manifestation of: MailApp.currentMail.images | PhotoShop.crop > returnBack So, like in a REST API, the apps publish their URIs with ACCEPT/HEADERS like "json", "xml", "img" etc and this allow to match to others apps that operate on them. Having also the apps operate on "docker-like" containers by default (fully isolated) yet communicate as Erlang Actors (send messages) to any other app that "Accept: FORMAT", allowing to express to the USER what we do now on the terminal. --- Other thing that totally need a revamp is the whole file exploring. Is just not rigth that google answer faster than a local disk search. Also, why not isolated in containers the files of SYSTEM, APP + CONFIGS + TEMPS/CACHES, USER_DATA so if I wanna do a backup just copy the USER_DATA container and be worry free? This is just some random ideas. Is about time to think of the OS as APP too, and start doing cool things :) -- In the area of security is also a lot to do. A minimal thing is to acknowledge that most users perform multiples roles on a system, and the case where exist a dedicated user to be admin or dba is just a special case. So, is reverse the roles/user. I'm jhon. Now, I change hat to be admin. Then change to be normal user, then change to be developer. I don't need 3 user accounts to be all of this. Because I'm all of this.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIt turns out all those things can be done in userland, you don’t need a new kind of kernel to support it. Likewise, most of the interesting things going on systems research today (e.g. distributed computing) don’t really touch the kernel either.
- dnautics 9y agoI used to use beos... Got through college using it. Wrote a web server in it and ported it to Linux for the one CS class I ever took in college and was appalled by greenthreads relative to bthreads. Extra credit was "make it multithreading".. well, already had that done. I think something interesting would be an os based on BEAM as a underlying threading and memory management model, if you could put in security guarantees.
- perl4ever 9y agoI remember reading about EROS (Extremely Reliable Operating System) [1] years ago. The killer feature was that you could shut the computer off at any time, and it would always recover a consistent state of everything that was running when you restarted. It also had an advanced security system. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EROS_(microkernel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EROS_(microkernel)
- rohan1024 9y agoIf BCI become mainstream we might need new operating system anyway.
- Razengan 9y ago> Does anyone else think it's time for a new and promising operating system? iOS is the new and promising operating system. It challenged and made us review many of the assumptions that everyone considers to be universal for an OS, even though they have no reason to be: - The need for a user-accessible "file system." - The need for multiple, customizable windows on the screen. iOS dared to go against the grain and people rallied against it. Even though the vision seems to have gotten somewhat muddled post-Jobs, and some of the trademark stubbornness giving way under Tim Cook, and despite the annoying bugs and inconsistencies lately, iOS has actually worked surprisingly well; the iPad is the first computing device that many of the older people in my family can comfortably and confidently use. It still has some way to go, but if you give it an honest chance, you'll see that an iPad [+ Smart Keyboard + Pencil] can easily perform 70%-90% of the task that most people ever need to do on a computer, without many of the jags associated with traditional desktop operating systems. With the recent rumors about unifying iOS and macOS while still keeping desktop and mobile user interfaces distinct, I'd like to believe that Apple have some exciting plans ahead for a future OS made up of the best features from iOS+macOS.
- StillBored 9y agoOriginal palmOS didn't have a filesystem. Apps just sort of took care of any data they had there was never a "save" or "load file" option in those apps. There are other systems that are similar in that regard (AS400 is somewhat similar, and much older, and MVS doesn't really have a filesystem either). And multiple overlapping windows was the big breakthrough with the original macos. Even then it was quite restricted (only desk accessories could overlap) until system6/multifinder added the ability to run more than one application at a time. So, while I agree the ipad model works well for a lot of things, I think the dedicated tablet model is sort of dying now that ~6" phones are everywhere. When the ipad broke, no one missed it..
- fh973 9y agoSure, but how would you solve the hardware drivers problem?
- rcarmo 9y agoHaiku OS now boots on modern hardware (like my 2015 ThinkPad), and aside from the usual niggles like trackpad support and some browser weirdness it “works”. Of course, it’s nowhere near polished enough for day-to-day use as macOS or Windows.