11 ms·
Ex-Google Employee's Memo Says Executives Shut Down Pro-Diversity Discussions
- nodesocket 9y agoNote: Amazon, Netflix, and Tesla who have strong founders that don't let bay area extreme political ideologies interfere with their business don't have to partake in these PR nightmares. Lesson should be learned for Google. It is no coincidence the above companies are ruled as a dictatorship and Google is ruled by committee.
- dlp211 9y agoNote: Google makes a ton more profit than those companies.
- nodesocket 9y agoNote: I own $GOOG stock. Just saying these political PR nightmares never happened under Steve Jobs for example.
- pravbeatle 9y agoHeck, even now it doesn't happen in Apple. Btw your point about Tesla was null since it has faced very public allegations from a woman and a black guy.
- virgilp 9y agoThe temptation for "enlightened dictatorship" is strong - both in society & in business. One of the problems with it is that, while efficient, it's fragile. The dictatorship can be effective in moving you in a certain direction - but it's horribly ineffective at adapting & changing direction/finding new directions. Long-term, dictatorships all fail because of that (even though short-term they can indeed be spectacularly successful)
- fortylove 9y agoHow do we feel about this?
- mc32 9y agoGoogle is in a tough spot with this. On the one hand they sincerely want to increase diversity because increasing the pool of candidates means there are more candidates to choose from. Also, having more women see technology as a career path is a good thing for the American workforce --it strengthens it. On the other hand, there are some who then see this initiative to begin their crusades for diversity in their vision. That is, it ends being a means to enrich the pool of applicants but rather a means to play favorites and push agendas. That's to say Google wants to increase women in the workforce but they do not want to make men "unwanted". I have known people there and I am told that the generalities that we hear that conservatives tend to stay quiet and that one side of the political spectrum in encouraged while the other is shunned is true. Beside that, this person left voluntarily, they did not get fired despite their attempts to re-start contentious conversations management had sought to regain control over. By the way, overlooked in all this is the overrepresentation of non-American citizens in the companies, with respect to wanting the companies to reflect the Am pop at large. And, who cares about that stat. I mean, they contribute a whole hell of a lot. Yet, you see, people only care about _their_ interpretation of what is acceptable diversity and unacceptable diversity figures.
- arduanika 9y ago> the overrepresentation of non-American citizens in the companies, with respect to wanting the companies to reflect the pop at large Or underrepresentation, depending on whether you're talking about the US pop or world pop. Or the population of countries where Google is not firewalled, and hence is the dominant gateway to the internet there.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> Or the population of countries where Google is not firewalled, and hence is the dominant gateway to the internet there. I'm sure Google has many Chinese employees as well.
- mc32 9y agoNo one ever, ever talks about int'l workforce representation at Toyota or Lexus or Huawei, or Samsung, or Kubota, or you know Petroleum from the ME. Never. This is only brought up as a distraction from the fact that they are overrepresented with respect to their numbers in America and as participants in the American workforce. Aside from that, it's no country's responsibility to provide gainful employment to non-nationals.
- gedy 9y agoDiscussing politics and religion at work is always, always distracting and divisive. Do it outside work hours please.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoSeriously, the only thing I truly gleaned from all the internal screenshots here is that Google is a horrific place to work where people are fighting about politics and the like with other coworkers. The infighting, the whole idea of blocking or blacklisting fellow employees... Who would seriously want to work in that hostile an environment?
- puzzle 9y agoMost of that is on mailing lists that nobody forces you to subscribe to.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoMailing lists which have a direct and immediate effect on your employment status and ability to be promoted.
- puzzle 9y agoHow so? For the majority of employees, the lists' main adverse effect on promotions is the time sink that they represent, just to read them. When I was there, only a minority of subscribers actually posted in the conversations. The rest would read them, mute them and sometimes frown ("why the hell did I sign up for eng-misc again?"). This is par for the course for any place where you're given a microphone, for good or for bad.
- ben_jones 9y agoI would guess expressing a viewpoint strongly aligned with the individual most responsible for your promotion would help you land that promotion. Likewise voicing an opinion counter to a popular narrative of that individual could prevent you from getting one. If the majority of your team or even just the management level of your department are participating, you must pick a side, keeping in mind silence and abstaining from emotionally charged discussions if often seen as picking a side in and of itself.
- SiVal 9y ago"...ALLEGATIONS made by former Google employees James Damore and David Gudeman in a discrimination lawsuit filed against their former employer. Damore and Gudeman CLAIM that Google encouraged pro-diversity voices within the company and stifled conservative views. However, THE NEW DOCUMENT ILLUSTRATES that employees who spoke out in favor of diversity initiatives were reprimanded as well..." [ALL CAPS added by me] So, the consistently left-leaning analysts at Gizmodo inform us that James Damore, whom Google themselves say they fired for the opinions expressed in a memo we can all read and see for ourselves what he was fired for, is still only alleging and claiming that the company that SAYS they fired him for expressing these views stifles conservative views. But a MEMO written by a guy whom Google didn't fire at all, much less for expressing a pro-diversity opinion, but simply quit becomes a NEW DOCUMENT that ILLUSTRATES facts about Google not otherwise in evidence. I lived in a country once with a state-controlled media that would begin its evening news reports with statements such as, "US President so-and-so claimed such-and-such today, but our-glorious-leader set the record straight, pointing out that blah-blah." I wondered how people in that country could hear that template and not see that it was blatantly biased at the template level. It wasn't just a biased interpretation of the issue, but was biased on the face of it, even before anything about the actual issue was inserted in the blanks. But I discovered that people who consistently heard media talking this way couldn't detect even this blatant a bias in format, much less in the content of the actual issue, so the writers didn't have to even pretend superficially. With government-controlled media, most people lived in a bubble. Everything they were told agreed with everything else they were told, so it was just common sense, and anything I said that contradicted "the narrative" was considered utter nonsense. What does it say about the tech audience Gizmodo is writing for that they are as confident as the state media in that small, tropical dictatorship, that they can be this blatant and their audience lives in such an ideological bubble, self-imposed in our case, that they'll approve of it and want more like it?
- MisterBastahrd 9y agoIt's common practice in media when dealing with court cases which have not been resolved to use language consistent with the non-resolution. So yes, they use the words "alleging" and "claiming," because it is consistent with what is going on in the courts.
- 40acres 9y agoGoogle and workplaces in general are in a very tough spot here. "Diversity & Inclusion" are grenades in the current political environment and more often than not any discussion in a non monolithic setting where ideas from both sides will be argued (ie. a large multinational) will probably end up with mudslinging and fire throwing. I've seen it within my own companies forums and I have no doubt this was going on at Google. I definitely understand where HR and senior executives where coming from, I'm sure more than one post went off the fucking rails. I'm all for diversity & inclusion within the work place but in general I would suggest companies do it in a more "covert" manner -- reach out to HBCUs, re-evaluate your interview process, talk to your employees who are "underrepresented minorities" to see how they feel about working for you. In general I think a lot of companies are simply inviting too much scrutiny by plastering diversity on the walls and screaming to high heavens.. press releases and chief diversity officers will not make you a more diverse company.
- calculusftw 9y agoThe position Google and other company leaders are in should not be tough at all. Google's VP was right when he said, "Google is not a debate club or a philosophy class. We are a workplace and we have an obligation to make sure our discussions remain respectful. Debates around topics like product excellence can support a wide variety of viewpoints and are great to have. I don’t think the same can be said for debates around sensitive issues such as gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation." If Google's in a tough spot, it's because their leadership is too passively "respectfully asking that everyone stop engaging on this [debate] thread," when they should be more assertive; e.g. like simply informing Googlers that the counterproductive behavior will no longer be tolerated. What's most disturbing to me about this situation at Google is that these adult professionals––the creme of the creme of the crop, right?--whether they're progressives, conservatives, SJWs, liberals, libertarians, librarians, or whatever, can't seem to respect one another, and conduct themselves at work without descending into polarizing debate which is clearly interfering with business operations. Google's situation is also reflective of the country's current cultural crisis. It's so poignantly ironic that in the midst of this ongoing (unending) cultural debate we're having--about equality, diversity, inclusivity, "social justice," in which everyone is so relentlessly (and not so subtly) implying what good people they are--the apparent result of it all is that we're more divided as a nation than we've been in half a century.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jancsika 9y ago> The post also pointed to an external blog post written by a Googler that stated, “Blacks are not equal to whites.” Here's what Altheide’s document quotes a "Googler" as writing on an external blog: > Blacks are not equal to whites. Therefore the “inequality” between these races is expected and makes perfect sense. (This also explains why progressives are unable to come up with a black martyr who was not killed while committing a crime.) Was this really written by someone who works for Google? > “As far as I can tell Urs is of the ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ school with regards to diversity topics,” he added. “This is best summed up by him saying ‘if the majority of your coworkers are Nazis, it is better if you don’t know about it’ because productivity.” Altheide wrote that he remembered the quote verbatim, and told Gizmodo that he was so struck by the comparison that he jotted it down after the meeting. That's also quite an accusation. Are there any other reports of Urs saying anything in that ballpark of crazy? edit: clarification
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- totalZero 9y ago> This also explains why progressives are unable to come up with a black martyr who was not killed while committing a crime. That's just braindead. Not that it's necessary to point out the falsehood of a quote so obviously motivated by hate and bereft of truth, but... Vernon Dahmer offered to pay the $2 poll tax for those who could not afford it. His home was doused in gasoline and set on fire, and he died a few hours later as a result. I guess sleeping in your own house is a crime. Harry Moore and his wife Harriette were killed by a bomb detonated directly below their bedroom on Christmas. I guess Christmas is illegal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- supreme_sublime 9y agoTo play a little devil's advocate, while he didn't specifically say this, I think he was referring to police shootings. Interestingly enough Walter Scott was killed less than a month after he posted this. Someone I'd argue could be a bit of a martyr. While he had committed a crime, it still wasn't justifiable in any sense. Of course, the offending officer was also convicted to 20 years in prison.
- JoelQ 9y agoThis is so suspicious it's comical. Just when it seems like Google has been humiliated by the embarrassing screenshots in Damore's lawsuit, a mysterious new document, from the summer of 2015 to 2016, never-before-released until right now, showing Google's top brass handle controversy over diversity smoothly and professionally. No bickering, no cursing, no hostile workplace. No booing of White males, no anti-Trump memes, no antifa recruitment, no "sexually identifying as a wingless dragonkin." Just the professionalism of Google. And who discovered this document that totally vindicates Google and refutes Damore's lawsuit? Why, it's Gizmodo! The very same people who originally leaked Damore's memo (out of context, with all of the sources removed) kicking off all of the outrage and accusations of sexism against him in the first place.
- siliconc0w 9y agoWhen you try to emulate a college environment and change work from a job to a lifestyle this seems to be what happens. People want to change their environment to reflect their values. Engineers especially. Both this guy and Damore seem to have sincerely good intentions, and if Google really was a college campus, their discussions might work but they're just incompatible with the reality of a workplace as-is.
- mankash666 9y agoCollege parties is where these conversations happened. Not in math or database classes. Converse all you want with your peers off the clock and off record if you truly want to emulate college
- calculusftw 9y agoThis is a good point. I live on the East Coast and have never worked for Google, so I hadn't considered how the work environment and their unique company culture might have been significant factors. There's just not that many (if any) companies here which have taken such a radical approach (I mean this in the most positive sense) to intentionally crafting a company culture so focused on employee satisfaction and retention. But, I hadn't thought about how those features which seem like extraordinary perks from the outside--like, no-charge gourmet meals on campus, on-site laundry, and a college-environment, might transform the culture in totally unanticipated ways. Anyway, oddly enough (now that I think about it), the Navy was remarkably similar in their approach: they did provide a "campus" (ship), with no charge ~~gourmet meals~~ chow, on-site laundry, and pretty good security. ;)
- skybrian 9y agoLink to the doc: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4347486-What-Happened-to-Cory-at-Google.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4347486-What-Happene... It might be worth sharing that when some Googlers made a custom Cards Against Humanity deck, one of the cards just said "Cory Altheide". (Or so I heard.) Let's just say the man is neither shy nor politically correct. "Worrying pattern of posting topics that are divisive" is understating things because it leaves out the "gleeful" part. I miss his G+ feed.
- pavlov 9y agoWhy does Google encourage discussions of these policies in the first place? What’s there to gain? It’s up to the owners of the company to communicate the values they want to promote in the workplace; management to implement specific policies; and employees to suck it up (and talk to HR if they feel their rights are being violated). To take an example from the other end of the spectrum, I don’t imagine that fundamentalist Christian owned Hobby Lobby has an internal mailing list for discussing their policies. Why should Google feel any more compelled to seek employee approval?
- oculusthrift 9y agothey want to for brownie points
- skybrian 9y agoBecause people like discussing things, plus dogfooding. There was a time when a company could create an internal mailing list called "politics" without worrying too much.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThat was a long time ago.
- fragmede 9y agoI'm sure the regexp /[gG]od/ shows up in corporate Hotel Lobby email, and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that Friday night fellowship is organized via Hotel Lobby company email lists (to discuss how better devote yourself to the Lord). The same way that after work alcohol parties (colloquially known as "drinks") or board games at the office after a hard day of coding are organized via Slack; humans are going to talk to each other about idle activities.
- numismatex 9y agoAnd also anything remotely resembling anti-diversity discussion as well. IE "No Equal Time"
- prepend 9y ago“The document, which was written in 2016 and shared publicly this week, provides a striking counterpoint to allegations made by former Google employees James Damore and David Gudeman in a discrimination lawsuit filed against their former employer.” These two actions by Google are not necessarily in conflict. It’s possible to discourage both opinions without showing any kind of biased agenda.
- petraeus 9y agoPathetic attempt of another white hetro male trying to demonize diversity in a shallow and transparent attempt at retaining white privilege through the world.