5 ms·
All the complex illustrations are not telling me that this is the solution to GDPR consent - instead, the illustrations are clearly showing that adtech simply w
by PeterisP 9y ago
All the complex illustrations are not telling me that this is the solution to GDPR consent - instead, the illustrations are clearly showing that adtech simply will not get the consent that they had before and will have to stop using that data. The user will look at all the information that you have to show and say "yeah... why would I ever want to opt-in for that?".
That's the whole point. If you want to keep the whole existing model of many networked partners using all that data for all kinds of interesting purposes, you won't ever be able to explain all that to the users in a manner that somehow motivates them to agree instead of simply choosing not to consent. The question isn't how to get consent for the current practices (which isn't plausible), the question is how to run adtech that doesn't rely on protected personal data.
- _petronius 9y agoI'm really hoping that GDPR enforcement is done in a way that is consistent with the intent of the law, and that we don't end up with a repeat of the cookie regulation (the end result of which was merely training users to click through another popup with reading it at all, and no meaningful improvement in general public understanding of what cookies are, and how or why they are used). The cookie thing was poorly drafted, as a result advice on complying with it was poor, and it became something to be worked around rather than a meaningful improvement on privacy and an understanding for the general public of how and why tracking works. I have higher hopes for the GDPR, although I still think it is too much of a compromise, and worry about what that means for accomplishing its intent.
- meredydd 9y agoGood news - unlike the cookie thing, GDPR mandates that you be able to say no. The cookie thing was pointless because it gave nobody any meaningful choice - "click Accept on everything, or don't use the Internet". GDPR is going to make "Let me use your site, but don't use that fact to track me" an option they are legally required to offer. I cannot wait.
- wav-part 9y agoGDPR Article 7(4) When assessing whether consent is freely given, utmost account shall be taken of whether, inter alia, the performance of a contract, including the provision of a service, is conditional on consent to the processing of personal data that is not necessary for the performance of that contract. So GDPR does not say its illegal, just that it will be determined on case by case basis. For legal experts, is this facebook consent obtaining GDPR compliant ? https://www.facebook.com/legal/terms/update https://www.facebook.com/legal/terms/update By using or accessing Facebook Services, you agree that we can collect and use such content and information in accordance with the Data Policy as amended from time to time.
- PeterisP 9y agohttps://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-32/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-32/ is the definition of consent. Simply having a term in the general conditions fails the "a clear affirmative act" part. Saying "use such content" fails the "informed and specific" part - it needs to detail exactly what uses (explicitly listing each) you're consenting to; and it doesn't list the purpose of the use, which is a key part ("When the processing has multiple purposes, consent should be given for all of them") If facebook has obtained your consent for one (or hundred and one) use-case, it does not mean that it can use it for something else simply by amending ("from time to time") the Data Policy, it would need to get additional explicit, affirmative (opt-in), informed consent to the new processing need of your information.
- amelius 9y agoThat's good news, but aren't there legal ways around that for sites that are not based in the EU? The first question could be: are you in the EU? yes -> no access no -> access, but with tracking So, basically training users to lie about their location.
- BrentOzar 9y ago> The first question could be: are you in the EU? Just to be clear - it's about EU citizens, not EU located-people, and your location can change. You have to ask if they're EU citizens.
- Feniks 9y agoGDPR isn't really a revelation. In many European countries there already was data protection legislation. The only thing that changes is that now its more enforceable in a unified market. American companies had a huge unfair advantage compared to their European competition. Now everyone has to deal with the same laws.