14 ms·
SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoWhat is the benefit of more, smaller rotor blades over fewer, larger ones? I thought that the area of air that the blades worked on scaled with pi-r-squared, which favours fewer larger rotor blades, as seen on most helicopters?
- codeduck 9y agoI can't think of any benefits of this layout other than reducing the size of the landing field you'll need. And I guess less complexity on the part of the rotors, no tail rotor with associated dangers etc. I can think of some significant downsides though. 1. This is fixed pitch, not collective pitch. That means any change in the attitude of the aircraft requires one or more sets of rotors to change their speed of rotation. This means that you need top notch electronic control systems, gyros etc. to mediate between pilot input and what the aircraft does. These electronic systems are sensitive and fragile and degrade with time. And when they let go, it's spectacular. 2. A loss of any one of the 8 motors is a Jesus Christ, yank the ballistic parachute moment. This is likely a hull-loss event as there will be all sorts of load-bearing parts with the job of absorbing the opening shock of the parachute. These will at minimum require inspection prior to the aircraft being certified airworthy again. 3. related to 2 above, this aircraft has no capacity for autorotation whatsoever. A traditional rotary-wing helicopter with collective pitch can autorotate safely in to a controlled landing in the event of an engine failure. If you lose an engine in this, and your ballistic chute tangles or doesn't deploy properly, you are proper fucked. It's cool, and quad-copters are fantastic cargo and gp platforms. But I would never fly in one.
- yetihehe 9y ago> A traditional rotary-wing helicopter with collective pitch can autorotate safely in to a controlled landing in the event of an engine failure. But not in the event of a propeller or pitch-control failure. Also probably single propeller failure in this quad will mean "we lost 1/8 of power, we must land". Also if you lose gasoline engine, you have battery backup for 5min.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoExpanding on your point #1: The inertia of large props means they can't change speed quickly, so there will be lag in the control inputs. (In toy quadcopters, electric motor torque is so high vs prop inertia that lag is a non-issue.) Collective pitch controls don't exhibit this lag. Electronic controls can compensate for inertia lag to some extent, but they have to be carefully designed using control theory, and if they fail the copter will likely be uncontrollable.
- FabHK 9y agoWith multiple smaller rotors you control by differential speed of the rotors, which are then fixed pitch, and much simpler mechanically. Smaller (lighter) rotors allow for quicker speed adjustments. Coaxial counterrotating rotors, as here, have two further advantages: 1. they're much more efficient, as less energy is converted into (useless) air rotation. 2. in forward flight, one side of the rotor "sees" higher relative speed, thus extra lift, while the receding side sees less lift. That's cancelled out by the counterrotating rotor above. Generally, larger diameters are good for hover performance and better autorotation, though autorotation is not really a factor for this design. EDIT to add: Note that the total disc size of one large rotor is of course the same as the one of 4 smaller ones with half the radius.
- asterius 9y agoYou are correct, much better lift, speed, economy from a single large slower moving rotor (or a pair of counter-rotating blades, cost/benefits described in other posts). The reason all the cheap drones use 4 or more engines is that they can individually be very simple, with the motor directly driving a rotor. With no swashplate to alter blade pitch the mechanism is very simple. Short blades are easy to make for a required strength and stiffness, and the torque of electric motors is sufficient to rapidly change rotor speed to change lift for steering. The control system is simple. However efficiency is terrible, both in terms of lift, and maneuvering. The energy to change blade speeds constantly to maintain attitude is a significant cost. But having low rotational inertia, frequent changes are required, especially in windy conditions. As blade diameter increases (and hence inertia) the resulting energy costs to change speed increase too, as does the size/power/weight of the motor.
- dzhiurgis 9y agoI thought gasoline turbine generators are sort of here (used in hybrid buses), womder why they stuck with piston generator. Also, any ideas what battery pack you’d need to do the same 70miles?
- bergesenha 9y agoMy best guess is fuel efficiency at small size scales and is probably the same reason that make them economical in large buses, but not small cars. The usual intuition is explained using the Reynolds number, a dimensionless quantity that can help to predict the possibility of maintaining laminar flow or wether the flow breaks down into turbulence in the generator, drastically reducing efficiency in the compression-combustion-expansion cycle. As a side note, when I did a type rating on the Eurocopter AS350, I learned that the gas turbine could also run on normal automobile gasoline instead of Jet-A 1 for a limited amount of time in emergencies with drastically reduced limits on altitude, torque etc...
- Zak 9y agoIt's my understanding that most gas turbine engines can be convinced to run on a wide range of flammable liquids, with some impact to performance and longevity. That the AS350 is actually designed to do so is interesting.
- wanderfowl 9y agoWait: - Curb Weight: 1100lbs - Max Takeoff Weight: 1500lbs So... you, your passenger, and any cargo combined can't weigh more than 400 pounds? That's a pretty serious limit for people hoping to transport multiple adults. And "precision agriculture" or the sorts of practical uses they discuss all go right out the window.
- googletazer 9y agoIts perfectly fine for two adults + a bit of cargo for immediate use.
- tweedledee 9y agoI'm sure the Max Take Off weight is even lower at altitude and in warm weather. I've noticed most R22 pilots are pretty skinny.
- throwawayjava 9y agoThe BMI chart maxes out healthy weights at 192. So unless you have two NBA players or something, it should work well for most but perhaps not all healthy people.
- Amorymeltzer 9y agoAverage weights (no median, sorry) from the CDC (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/body-measurements.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/body-measurements.htm): >Men: 195.7 pounds >Women: 168.5 pounds So this could carry an average man, average woman, and under 36 pounds. At that point, the weight of your clothing or a bottle of wine becomes very important.
- throwawayjava 9y agoYes, I did say healthy, which a good half of the USA isn't. but that still implies a 100m person market, just in the USA, and people in other developed countries tend to be closer to the "healthy" range. There are lots of healthy people out there. In short, I don't think this will be the make-or-break for flying cars...
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoFlying fixed-pitch copters is risky. The question is: more risky than driving in traffic? More than taking the bus or swimming or eating fatty foods or a hundred other things we do without blinking? Still, it'll have to have a measured safety record before I'd want to fly it. Better yet, automate it to go from heliport to heliport in a crowded city, a sort of aero-lyft. So I don't have the chance to screw anything up. Because I'm thinking the human operator is going to be the root of any accident stats. Imagine a swarm of these over your city, with humans in control.
- jachee 9y agoI think it'd be interesting if it were semi-automated. For example: Get in, start it up, hit the "Go" button, and it automatically hovers vertically to minimum cruising height (i.e. above all the houses, trees, power lines) before granting further control to the pilot^Wuser. Then, either GPS-powered destination selection or mobility with computer-stabilized limited degrees of freedom. The fewer decisions the human in the seat has to make, the safer they are.
- advisedwang 9y agoI'm very skeptical of their claims of "unparalleled safety". Thanks to "autorotation"[1] regular helicopters can safely land in most situations even with complete power failure. The claims of safety of this craft seems to derive from N+1 battery redundancy which isn't that impressive. They say they have 8 independent motors, but don't say how many are needed to stay aloft. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation
- trevyn 9y agoThere’s also a parachute.
- JasonFruit 9y agoCould it be because autorotation requires a skillful, vigilant pilot, and the redundant systems of this machine help avoid urgent need for it?
- asterius 9y agoAutorotation is often taught after only 8 hours of training. It is very feasible to have an AFCS that will do an autorotation, but it is harder to find a place to land.
- mrfusion 9y agoShould be four or less considering each arm has two props. (Unless the motors aren’t powerful enough)
- eddyg 9y agoVideo "tour" here (still doesn't show it flying): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elhiaxMiRuY&t=19s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elhiaxMiRuY&t=19s Also, the inaugural flight at CES was scrapped due to a "light sprinkling" of rain: http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42616034 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42616034
- asciimo 9y agoIt's frustrating, and a bit strange, that there's no (easy to find) video of it in flight.
- rkagerer 9y agoNeat! Although I think it only goes about half the speed, half the flight ceiling and a third the range of an average helicopter. Maybe if these guys get some market traction a ton of other entrants will come and the dream of personal flight will finally “take off”. I wonder what maintenance requirements will be like.
- oliv__ 9y agoA part of me thinks this is really cool tech and it would be amazing for anyone to be able to just hop aboard their personal helicopter and fly wherever they want, but then another part of me thinks of the future this would create, skies no longer clear, filled with objects buzzing around and what hell that would be, on top of the already stressful and crazy life we have now. It's the kind of situation where I think I'd actually rather the tech never exist.
- rkagerer 9y agoI empathize but I think that attitude is an artifact of the age we grew up in. I'm sure equestrians felt the same way when those rackety automobile contraptions started zooming around.
- oliv__ 9y agoI don't know. Just because I haven't been exposed to it yet and it's not the new normal doesn't necessarily mean it's an objectively better world. And speaking of automobiles, I feel like a lot of cities are actually fighting back against that now, creating pedestrian-only areas etc... I like the autonomy and mobility that cars offer as much as anyone else, but I sure do enjoy the peace of a quieter country side, and I'm afraid with this technology, even that would go away: there would be no place left to escape the madness. In my opinion, progress is what makes the world a better place overall for humans, as in better quality of life, not what makes the world a shinier place with new toys, even though we might be getting better and better at creating those. At the end of the day, the cons far outweigh the pros here for me.
- originalbryan2 9y agoThose rackety automobile contraptions! Don't get me started! :) I am half serious though, cars are annoyingly loud and (obviously) dangerous. I'm loving the eerily quiet electric vehicles. And cities creating carless areas of town or carless days.
- nothrabannosir 9y agoI still feel that way about cars. Those horse riders were right.
- bri3d 9y agoWhy this and not single-rotor collective pitch? There's no good explanation in the marketing material.
- skykooler 9y agoProbably to make maintenance simpler? That's the most expensive part of operating a helicopter.
- FabHK 9y agoThat's the whole point of these drone-like copters: instead of one engine and main rotor with mechanically complicated collective pitch, you have many fixed-pitch variable speed rotors sitting directly on an electric motor. The complexity thus wanders from hardware to control software.
- bri3d 9y agoHaving written both (albeit only at a hobby scale), I'd argue that the control software for a collective-pitch helicopter is substantially more complex than for a quadcopter, and especially this style of over/under counter-rotating octocopter. To me this almost seems like an effort to simplify the automation and control software at the expense of safety and efficiency. I do agree that the mechanicals are much simpler. I can see some maintenance and inspection safety gains but the airframe as a whole seems more dangerous. The over/under counterrotating prop design is both inefficient and prone to cascading failures mandating deployment of the airframe parachute.
- FabHK 9y agoInteresting. Now, clearly, humans can (with considerable training) fly helicopters with controls that influence the mechanics fairly directly (cyclic, collective, rudder, thrust). Can humans fly quadcopters with controls that influence the mechanics fairly directly, or do they always require mediation via complicated control software? Come to think of it, presumably you can (as you have 4df in the controls, and you could have rotors next to each other rotate in opposite direction, and then control the sum of all speeds (=height), sum of left vs sum of right (=lateral movement), sum of front vs sum of back (=forward movement), and sum of diagonal 1 vs sum of diagonal 2 (=rotation) independently, thus translating human inputs into your 4df. Nice!) > simplify the automation and control software at the expense of safety and efficiency. At any rate, I continue to think that the much simpler mechanics and motors are the main drivers. Let's see how the accident rates turn out, but I'm optimistic. > The over/under counterrotating prop design is both inefficient How is it inefficient? I understand that over/under counterrotating props are more efficient, inducing less air rotation.
- JoblessWonder 9y agoMost of the work of the helicopters I see involve long flight times and/or the ability to carry some sort of not-insignificant payload (camera/sensors/pesticides/people). This doesn't seem to address either of those situations very well. And with 1 seat to sell, you aren't going to be getting many short charter flights.
- JasonFruit 9y agoThe rest of your comment seems right to me, but the title says "personal helicopter"; charter flights are not personal use.
- dmitrygr 9y ago> 1 hour of fuel > 70 mph speed This means that the maximum legal range with FAA-mandated fuel reserves is 46 miles (assuming no wind). Also despite shots of it on a driveway, it would most likely be impossible to actually take off or land on your driveway due to local ordinances in most cities. Oh and it doesn't appear to be properly equipped for IFR, so clear weather operation only.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 9y agoelectric transmission vs mechanical and 8 tiny inefficient props? 1 hour flight with 30kg of fuel? I can make something more efficient in a garage...
- asterius 9y agoWell, Colin Furze can make it in his garage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soxxPyaAT1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soxxPyaAT1k
- clebio 9y agoWell that's going to kill someone.
- ourmandave 9y agoIs this the next Uber vehicle? Or Amazon delivery "drone"?
- euyyn 9y agoHow am I supposed to "store it inside a standard garage" if it doesn't have wheels to move it in?
- joncp 9y agoIt looks like casters could easily be added. Or you could even land it on a dolly.
- foxyv 9y agoA lot of light helicopters are transported on dollies or trailers.
- nradov 9y agoRobinson light helicopters have mounting points on the skids where you can temporarily attach small wheels to move them around on the ground.
- hangonhn 9y agoCan anyone verify if this thing is actually built and not just some rendering? The shallows in some of their pictures don't seem right so I was wondering if those are pictures of an actual craft or just a Photoshop.
- Hasz 9y agoThere is a video of it at a trade show on YouTube. The craft definitely exists, whether or not it flies is a different question. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ll-3jDTibSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ll-3jDTibSQ
- mannykannot 9y agoIt is cute to show it in a parking lot, but with those unprotected blades it is unlikely you will be able to operate it anywhere but on an airfield, helipad or private land, for safety reasons. And with four sets of contra-rotating blades (small, therefore turning fast) and a gasoline engine, it will be noisy as hell.
- Shivetya 9y agodumb question, but why would it not be a good idea to enclose the blades so anyone walking up to it won't be hurt? (just a simply loop / bumper arrangement? on a side note, I hope to be around where a Blade Runner like Spinner is a thing or at least a possibility
- iamleppert 9y agoI'm skeptical of a company that is doing so many different projects, and none of them seem particularly well developed, far along, or consistent within the framework of some core vision. That being said, I'm jealous. Where do people actually get money to finance these pet projects?
- _ph_ 9y agoFor drone-style helicopters, I find the Volocopter (https://www.volocopter.com/de/ https://www.volocopter.com/de/) the most intriguing concept. The designers of the Volocopter took extreme care for redundancy. It can keep flying with up to 6 of the 18 rotors failing. Even the electric system and the controls have multiple redundancies. The first craft already got licensed for flying in Germany.
- FabHK 9y agoMuch prefer the Volocopter as well. Better redundancy, further down the line (manned flights since 2016, negotiations with regulators progressing), not vapourware, more visually pleasing (though that's subjective, obviously). In this design, I like the compactness (foldability), counterrotating rotors (for efficiency), the fact that the rotors are not in knee-height (like in this eHang 184 abomination), and the electric/fuel hybrid system. BTW, I like PEVA as a name for this type of vehicle: Personal electric VTOL aircraft. EDIT to add: Volocopter and eHang 184 have been around for years, and SureFly "reinvented" the helicopter? Right...
- ravitation 9y agoJust reading through the about page... Where is the aircraft/rotorcraft experience in upper management? There are many reasons that helicopters are dominant at the scale of human transport (some of which have been brought up in this comment thread) and multicopters are prevalent at smaller (drone-size) scales... All of this is to say I'm extremely skeptical.
- asterius 9y agoAll that is missing is mention of blockchain.
- foxyv 9y agoI have to say, I've never worried about being hit by a helicopter while riding my bicycle.
- nkkollaw 9y agoSo cool, it looks like a huge drone.
- frisco 9y agoIs there any data on the sound profile of this thing? As the rotors become smaller the disc loading increases, making them much louder and more shrill. If that's effectively mitigated here, this looks really cool; if not, I think it will be hard to negotiate take off and landing rights with most communities.
- asterius 9y agoAs well as being higher pitched, contra-rotating designs also produce more noise. The sound field is non-uniform (mostly axial), and there are claims of being able to reduce it through special phasing of the two rotors, using different numbers of blades on each, etc. But I wouldn't be particularly hopeful.
- 659087 9y agoAs both a rotorcraft and fixed wing pilot, I really don't want this to succeed. Most people have no business on the road, let alone in the sky. That's without even getting into the safety issues with this thing that are being conveniently glossed over in the marketing material, which would lead anyone who didn't know better to think a BRS is some kind of foolproof sure thing.
- rwbcxrz 9y ago> Flight ceiling: 4000ft I’m wondering if that’s the absolute service ceiling or it’s legal operational ceiling due to its classification. I suppose they won’t be selling them in Denver if it’s the former.
- danaliv 9y agoI don't recall there being anything special about 4000' from a regulatory perspective so I suspect that's the service ceiling.
- owenversteeg 9y agoCouple of people mentioning the Robinson R22 (a 2-seater small helicopter that costs about $280k.) I didn't see any mentions of the Yo-Yo 222 though, which seems very interesting and only costs €135k. The SureFly is substantially slower and has a lower payload compared to both. It's worth noting, though, that any small aircraft will have very similar payloads (300-400 lbs max.) This will almost certainly not get better in the near future, even with battery improvements (you'll note that all current light aircraft, including this one, are gasoline powered.) Speed is also difficult to increase for VTOL aircraft like this one. I build custom VTOL (and sometimes horizontal) aircraft, typically electric, usually smaller than this one. If anyone else here builds VTOL aircraft/large drones, send me an email! I'd be curious to talk to other HNers doing the same thing. (And if you're just curious about the subject in general, feel free to send me an email also - it's in my profile.)
- Animats 9y agoYet another really big personal quadrotor-type drone. Its a lot like the eHang 184, from 2016.[1] That flies, but they don't trust it with a live passenger yet. Here's one with a passenger, but they don't want to get any altitude.[2] There are five or six projects like this. Few have flown with a human on board yet. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPARvS31Oq0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPARvS31Oq0 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3pi4HfQ0Gc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3pi4HfQ0Gc
- zaroth 9y agoIf they wanted to prove the design, why can't they offer package delivery services with the drones and ramp up volume to at least 100 flights a day until it's proven?! If they've proven it works, they should get the money necessary to test it and deploy it. They need to get to market and see if it sells. I think the problem is crashing over populated areas, even if it's not occupied? Hard to make deliveries if you can't fly over actual people. But in any case, let me know when they are doing at least 10 flights per day (no days off for bad weather, they should be testing in multiple locations and climates too).
- nradov 9y agoIt would be difficult to get FAA approval to offer cargo delivery services with a large drone due to the risk it would pose to manned light aircraft flying under VFR. They would have to carve out controlled airspace in a specific area and temporarily ban VFR flights there.
- fao_ 9y ago> target price: $200,000 That's 148,019.4 GBP. The average wage here corrected for a proper living standard is about 22,000 GBP give or take. If everybody that could afford this took that money and gave it to homeless foundations, what a world we could live in...
- Edmond 9y agoprice could go down if more affluent people buy, eventually it can become something the average people could "afford"...there are of course other arguments against everyone owning their own flying machine.
- fao_ 9y agoIs that even the ethical approach here, though. If you can afford a flying machine, you can afford to keep a roof over a family for 3 years (Assuming two earners earning 22,000 GBP / year (Which is far more than my parents ever earned in their lives)). Or you could pay 6 people's expenses off for a year. If you have that much disposable income, and you spend all of it on something that benefits only yourself, what does that say about you as a person?
- bparsons 9y agoThe fully electric Lilium out of Germany is a far more interesting project. Without a gas engine, the noise and cost problems are greatly mitigated. I don't know how far away it is from commercialization, but it would appear that the the proof of concept is coming along nicely. https://lilium.com/ https://lilium.com/
- Avshalom 9y ago2 props per arm, contra rotating. Eight motors...Gasoline Piston Engine drives dual generators...Dual Lithium Battery Pack...Full computer and electrical system redundancy...Ballistic Parachute... for simplicity
- twobyfour 9y agoSo what sort of fuel mileage does it get?
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoI think I'll wait for like... version 5.
- ggg9990 9y agoGuaranteed vaporware. If these guys had even a fraction of a clue they would have gone with a 6 rotor design.
- asterius 9y agoI'm almost sure this is a champion satirical comment.
- inamberclad 9y agoI'm always extremely skeptical of these things. The engineering is difficult, but the person at the controls is an even larger problem.
- timtas 9y ago“One hour of flight time available per tank of gasoline” So like what, $70 round trip commute? Hmm.