10 ms·
GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be?
- dmitriid 9y agoThere's adtech, and there's Facebook. Facebook's stance so far can be summarized as "Meh, we don't care, it's you who should comply to local laws, not us". I really really really which the EU actually delivers on its GDPR promise and hits them with a fine of 4% of global revenue[1] [1] https://medium.facilelogin.com/understanding-gdpr-9201e1356418 https://medium.facilelogin.com/understanding-gdpr-9201e13564... "4% of the annual global turnover or €20 Million (whichever is greater)."
- KozmoNau7 9y agoI work in IT at a major telco, and GDPR is our A number 1 absolute top priority, anyything else (barring natural disasters) will get pushed back if the Four Letter Word is brought into the discussion. We are somewhat hampered by a large amount of legacy systems (think COBOL on mainframes, in some cases), so we are taking this very seriously, and are fully expecting the EU to wield the full force of their ability to fine, should we be shown to be non-compliant after the deadline. There will probably be a grace period, but we're taking a "better safe than sorry" approach. As a private citizen, I hope the EU chooses to wield the GDPR Hammer of Doom swiftly and mercilessly against any company found to be noncompliant.
- delibes 9y agoMy understanding is there is no grace period. It starts 25th May, and affects any existing data you have. So for example, if I have 1 million users today with a weaker form of consent agreement, I need to ask them all to re-affirm a much clearer consent statement before May 25th in order to carry on similar data processing.
- danieka 9y agoWhile there may not be a grace period I think that the law allows some leeway with regards to the time it takes to become fully compliant. If you're audited but are not fully compliant it should be enough if you can show how you are working to correct the problems that you have. If for example data is stored in an inappropriate way but you've not yet had time to migrate it you will not be fined if you can show how you are working towards correcting the problem. IANAL and that.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThat is my understanding as well.
- PeterisP 9y agoI'd expect that the regulatory authorities simply cannot have enough capacity to worry about the smaller issues for the first month, quarter or even whole 2018 - they'll have their hands busy with the really big cases.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIs 4% of revenue the maximum even for repeat offenders? It seems like that would be low enough that Facebook might conceivably find it better just to pay the fines as long as their tracking is boosting their ad revenue by enough.
- napoleoncomplex 9y agoAny insight from HN insiders on how seriously companies big and small are taking this? In my experience, the buzz around this is much more serious compared to previous efforts, "the cookie law" for example, though I have no idea on the actual impact. In our company, we've decided to implement the necessary changes, because a lot of them just make sense (be clear with the user on tracking, don't store personal data you don't need...). It could turn out to be a competitive advantage, but only if the rules really are enforced. Otherwise it will be the same as the cookie law, the companies following it had a shittier user experience, and the ones that didn't were never penalized (the cookie law was absurdly bad legislation in my opinion to be clear). So any insight from the HN crowd would be much appreciated!
- cotillion 9y agoGDPR is something completely different. The cookie law was an email from compliance with something like. 'Oh, and by the way we need a cookie warning. Please fix it.' GDPR begun with mandatory briefings for all employees (not just IT) a year ago and the projects spawned have been going full steam since then.
- ust 9y agoHi, I'm involved with GDPR for my work, although in academic context, i.e. the primary motive in processing of personal data is in security, provisioning services, accounting purposes, etc. Also, I'm not a lawyer, and this is just my personal opinion. So, while I do work in academic environment, I do have contact with people from industry, and they are taking this seriously. (Of topic, this actually created a new business opportunity, for compliance with the GDPR). However, GDPR is not that different from the Directive, if you were compliant with the Directive, chances are, you're probably (mostly) compliant with the GDPR. Yes, the conditions for consent are strengthened, and since now we have a Regulation, it is valid in all countries. There are other differences, and it is more stringent now, but it is not drastically different from the Directive. BTW, this link[1] have a nice overview (I'm completely unaffiliated with that firm, I just like how they structured it...): [1] https://www.whitecase.com/publications/article/gdpr-handbook-unlocking-eu-general-data-protection-regulation https://www.whitecase.com/publications/article/gdpr-handbook... One thing that people lost sight of, at least in my opinion, that GDPR is not just about punishment, or stopping the processing of personal data, it is also about transparency. People should not be coy/evasive/unclear about what kind of data one is collecting and for which purpose. This is one of the most important things (again, in my opinion). Processing of personal data has a valid and important purpose, and the GDPR is not there to stop it. And for the question will the GDPR be enforced, I think it will. For the moment, though, all data protection authorities (DPAs) are a bit overloaded, and I suspect that will be the case in the near future. But obviously, EU and EC are taking GDPR quite seriously. Hope this answers your question. (Edited for grammar...)
- majewsky 9y agoWhy do they cram the "View details" part into this tiny box? Oh wait, I think I know why.
- amelius 9y agoHow granular? Per pixel please!
- nodex-alex 9y agoOur company delivers high end recruitment websites and job boards, I can say quite honestly that the recruiters don't really care about GDPR and they won't until they get fined. Recruitment will be hit hard due to the nature of how it works and the data hoarded via resumes.
- danieltillett 9y agoThe thing I really, really, really don't like about the GDPR is how the EU thinks it can impose it on companies that have no presence in the EU. While the GDPR requirements might be reasonable, this is a very slippery slope that will only end in disaster.
- _petronius 9y ago> companies that have no presence in the EU Just because you don't have a business presence (in the form of an office and employees) doesn't mean you don't have a presence: collecting data from, and making a profit on, users and customers in the EU is a presence. The alternative would be to surrender the obligation to regulate business practice and the protection of citizens to other countries, with no political accountability.
- danieltillett 9y agoNo political accountability is what the EU is doing right now. As a non-citizen of an EU country I have no say in this regulation or its enforcement, but somehow I am supposed to abide by it because the EU says so. The EU is trying to imposing a huge regulatory burden on companies over which it has no authority. Why do I or any other non-EU company have to put up with this? What happens when the laws in my country conflict with the laws the EU imposes on me from afar?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> Why do I or any other non-EU company have to put up with this? You don't have to. Just don't do business in the EU / with EU citizens. > What happens when the laws in my country conflict with the laws the EU imposes on me from afar? You have a choice - either break the laws or your country, or... just don't do business in the EU. (I do hope GDPR doesn't affect your company much; it seems to be doing God's good work, unlike most of the companies GDPR is targeted at.)
- danieltillett 9y ago
- PeterisP 9y agoAll the complex illustrations are not telling me that this is the solution to GDPR consent - instead, the illustrations are clearly showing that adtech simply will not get the consent that they had before and will have to stop using that data. The user will look at all the information that you have to show and say "yeah... why would I ever want to opt-in for that?". That's the whole point. If you want to keep the whole existing model of many networked partners using all that data for all kinds of interesting purposes, you won't ever be able to explain all that to the users in a manner that somehow motivates them to agree instead of simply choosing not to consent. The question isn't how to get consent for the current practices (which isn't plausible), the question is how to run adtech that doesn't rely on protected personal data.
- _petronius 9y agoI'm really hoping that GDPR enforcement is done in a way that is consistent with the intent of the law, and that we don't end up with a repeat of the cookie regulation (the end result of which was merely training users to click through another popup with reading it at all, and no meaningful improvement in general public understanding of what cookies are, and how or why they are used). The cookie thing was poorly drafted, as a result advice on complying with it was poor, and it became something to be worked around rather than a meaningful improvement on privacy and an understanding for the general public of how and why tracking works. I have higher hopes for the GDPR, although I still think it is too much of a compromise, and worry about what that means for accomplishing its intent.
- meredydd 9y agoGood news - unlike the cookie thing, GDPR mandates that you be able to say no. The cookie thing was pointless because it gave nobody any meaningful choice - "click Accept on everything, or don't use the Internet". GDPR is going to make "Let me use your site, but don't use that fact to track me" an option they are legally required to offer. I cannot wait.
- wav-part 9y ago
- mschuster91 9y agoSo, basically, adtech will be dead for Europe soon. No one will implement such an overlay on the start site as required by the law. Thank God, and good riddance. And to those who will complain: well, it's your greed and total lack of transparency that prompted EU legislators to actually do something about an issue that concerns their citizens in the firs place.
- cjsuk 9y agoCouldn't agree more. Now people will have to start delivering value instead of clicks and content will be worth what it's worth rather than the advertising leverage. This should remove a lot of pointless mind consuming junk as economically not viable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- virgilp 9y agoDon't know what to say, man. I work for a big company that could be described as "adtech", and, while there's significant investment in GDPR and what it will mean/how to become compliant, nobody I talked to perceives it as existential threat. It's just one of the important, but still secondary issues. Maybe legal & product are wrong about the impact GDPR will have - that's certainly a possibility. But if I were a betting man, I wouldn't bet on GDPR upending the industry. If anything, I'd say it's partially seen as an opportunity: we could help other, less-technical customers, become assured that they are GDPR-compliant (while still continuing their - necessary! - digital marketing activity).
- mschuster91 9y ago> But if I were a betting man, I wouldn't bet on GDPR upending the industry At least many of the shady players will be forced out. IMHO that alone will be a boost for general quality of ads. > we could help other, less-technical customers, become assured that they are GDPR-compliant I believe that a valid "you are compliant" statement can only be issued in a couple of years once there has been a solid foundation of court judgements which show how the stuff works out in practice.
- jstanley 9y agoI hate those sliding radio buttons with text. If I click "off" does that turn it off, or does that turn it on? And this example is even worse: am I turning on GDPR protection or turning on invasive tracking?
- calcifer 9y ago> If I click "off" does that turn it off, or does that turn it on? It is required to be off by default, so you'll be turning it on by clicking. > am I turning on GDPR protection or turning on invasive tracking? You'll be protected by default unless you explicitly opt-in to tracking.
- majewsky 9y ago> It is required to be off by default It's not a good sign when knowledge of data protection law is required to understand the UI.
- calcifer 9y agoBut it's not? Let me try to rephrase that: If you do nothing at all your privacy will be protected by the GPDR. You, as the consumer, are not required to know or do anything if you want your privacy.
- thisacctforreal 9y agoYou need to know to do nothing at all. Even when presented misleading UX.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoMisleading UX would presumably violate GDPR because it requires that consent be "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous".
- flipbrad 9y agoBear in mind that there are many legal grounds for collecting, using and sharing personal data under the GDPR (depending on the circumstances), and consent granularity is just one of the issues you'll face if you decide to rely on consent rather than the alternatives.