4 ms·
Reading the original Satoshi paper, the point of Bitcoin is to be decentralized/trustless and to enable microtransactions by lowering transaction fees. Both th
by Robotbeat 9y ago
Reading the original Satoshi paper, the point of Bitcoin is to be decentralized/trustless and to enable microtransactions by lowering transaction fees.
Both these goals seem to have failed in practice, the latter spectacularly (although other cryptocurrencies have done better in this regard).
To truly be trustless, you can't generate keys/addresses on some website like bitaddress or use some other online wallet, as you're clearly trusting bitaddress to not be copying your key (and/or have the ability to fully and carefully audit their code... few people have this capability and even fewer have the patience to do so). You have to do something like this:
generate them offline using a computer which can never communicate with the Internet after you use it. And you need to do it at least twice with two completely different implementations to ensure your public and private key truly match.
In practicality, I have to send a picture of my ID to some third party exchange in order to use it. REALLY? Why don't I just use PayPal?
In practicality, Bitcoin is only /ritually/ trustless and decentralized. And it's worthless for microtransactions. (Etherium is better, but not perfect.)
I really do think the whole industry has become too enamored with the cloud and with centralization, but these steps toward decentralization seem self-defeating as they rely on (centralized!) apps from a centralized appstore in practice. Might as well trust PayPal or Apple or whoever. Or even just a regular bank. Or even better, a credit union that you, as an account holder, have voting power over.
If I'm using Windows, I trust Microsoft. If I'm using Ubuntu, I trust Canonical. If I use Android or Chrome, I trust Google. If I use iOS, I trust Apple. On some level, I also trust Intel and/or AMD and/or NVidia and my chipset provider, too. Trustlessness only exists in theory (and even then, only with certain assumptions--like a distributed mining pool or stake that hasn't become centralized), and you can make a good case that in practicality cryptocurrencies actually INCREASE your trust attack surface area.
It all starts looking like a lot of overhead for transactions.
- adventured 9y ago> Both these goals seem to have failed in practice, the latter spectacularly That will stop being the case once people stop treating all the coins as investment speculations. That won't occur until the bubble pops. After that, with the typical trauma that goes with it due to financial losses, it will become almost impossible to convince people to plow large amounts of money into inflating a given coin (as in the case of so many of the lesser crypto-coins that are seeing musical chair speculation booms). The speculation on a stray coin to moonshot next, is no different than the speculation on which beanie baby will soar next circa 1998/99. Once the bubble gave way, you could no longer convince anyone that they all should be worth large sums, or that the musical chairs of inflating one beanie baby to the next should continue. It's classic group hysteria and it tends to reverse violently. Once that occurs, you'll find the exact opposite problem more common: nobody will want to bother wasting any money on nearly any coins, in any regard (whether for transactions or sheer speculation). Group think will shift to nearly all coins as being worthless, as they actually are.
- heurist 9y agoThe bubble pop will come when banks say they refuse to use any public cryptocurrency. If that happens (if, not when) then the hype will disappear rapidly and the market will continue growing organically. If it doesn't, then cryptocurrencies will differ from beanie babies (or tulips) in the sense that they are highly liquid and can lubricate real financial teansactions, and thus have value within the global financial system. The other aspect I think the people calling bubbles are underestimating is the liquidity of information and assets through this network. Speculators will invest primarily in the forefront of cryptocurrencies technology - ICOs, low and middle-tier exchanges - looking for the next 100x. As coins grow the capital from established coins will spread and risk, hopefully, will also spread. Information on every coin is readily available and people are trading and chatting about these things all day every dat, so rumors and news should diffuse and keep prices in line. The technology will improve over time, hopefully to a point where the valuation is justified. I'm not saying that will happen, but in my mind there is a plausible path, and that's enough for me to keep some money in.
- powvans 9y agoThis is a great analysis. The lack of trust as a feature in cryptocurrency is really a bug in society. Bitcoin rose out of the previous financial collapse by appealing to people who have lost trust in institutions. The problem with building a trustless answer to that problem is that (assertions ahead) life isn't compatible with an absence of trust. Trying to build a trustless financial system is a quixotic undertaking at best. It really smacks of a utopian dream where fundamental aspects of human nature are blithely ignored. Of course, as you point out, no one is really trying to do it. Most people will have to trust Coinbase or whichever exchange they choose.
- DennisP 9y agoThe financial system isn't all that dependent on trust. There are all sorts of reconciliations and audits, which wouldn't be necessary if entities trusted each other. Those methods are slower and costlier than what blockchains may be able to offer. On the other hand, 2008 was partly enabled by entities trusting each other. They trusted AAA ratings, AIG, Goldman Sachs, and third party holders of mortgage records. In various ways, all these systems failed the people who trusted them.
- sol_remmy 9y agoOur current financial system does require end-users like you and me to trust each other either. It only requires us to trust the legal system
- imtringued 9y agoBitcoin ended up becoming a federated system instead of being a centralised system or decentralised system. There are multiple providers. If one provider goes bust you can still move to the next. There are a few minor differences. The blockchain retains data accross providers as long as there is at least a single node. Traditional systems like email require you to migrate your data manually from the old provider to the new one. PoW is spam resistant because it costs money to send spam.
- oh_sigh 9y ago> In practicality, I have to send a picture of my ID to some third party exchange in order to use it. REALLY? Why don't I just use PayPal? That's only if you want to exchange fiat<->BTC. If you just want to pay people who accept BTC with BTC, you don't need to use any exchanges.
- root_axis 9y agoRight... but that's not practical. > In practicality
- zodPod 9y agoThis has been how I've seen it for a while as well! It's really hard to convince me that something is decentralized when, like you said, I have to verify my identity on a third party exchange to acquire them. I mean, obviously you could store them locally on a wallet and get them from a friend or something but the fact that these gigantic exchanges came from nowhere seems to indicate that it's not as easy to decentralize money as they'd like us to believe.
- hndamien 9y agoIt doesn't have to be this way though. You can get Bitcoin by downloading some software, generating a key, giving some cash to somebody with Bitcoin and receive it on your wallet. You can do this with no identification points at all. The main trick is finding somebody with Bitcoin which is getting easier all the time. If you are using it as an investment vehicle that is different. But as a currency/ banking this is different. That said, faster transaction speeds and lower fees are very important.