10 ms·
Putting Apple’s iMac Pro Through the Paces
- bonestamp2 9y agoIn defending their choice of macs, a decision that will likely come under fire no matter what, the author didn't even mention lower maintenance costs, which can mean more profit for the business if a machine would have been down otherwise. I suppose "solid and robust" would be the trait that leads to higher reliability. My boss personally hates macs, but he recently switched the entire office to macs because our IT service company's monthly maintenance fee is half price for macs.
- jjoonathan 9y agoAlso, cheap parts and good youtube tutorials are more readily available for mac if you want to DIY.
- walshemj 9y agoI have looked at the diy tutorials for the later macs the ones that are made hard for end users to maintain - and they make installing custom cooling loops with hard tubing look simple.
- jjoonathan 9y agoThere's no comparison to desktop PCs which, as you point out, are as simple as lego to build/fix and have part availability that puts lego itself to shame. I was really thinking more about laptops, where the need to peel/replace some glue is nothing next to the availability of parts.
- walshemj 9y agoOr as call it to much work for the benefit
- jdietrich 9y agoMost enterprise laptops are vastly easier to fix than Apple hardware. The manufacturers of these machines have thought carefully about repairability and designed it in from the start. For example, the Lenovo X270 opens with eight Philips screws. Once you're inside, you'll find an array of standard parts in standard sockets. Lenovo provide a detailed service manual and will sell you anything from a replacement fan to a new LCD from stock. The logic board isn't caked in BGA underfill and has a sensible level of density, so component-level repairs are vastly easier and less time-consuming.
- jjoonathan 9y agoIt's good to hear that Lenovo treats you better than Dell treated me. Is this their policy in general or do you have to buy a megabuck enterprise service contract (i.e. the one bonestamp2 identified as not competitive)?
- lozf 9y agoThat's all standard on all the real ThinkPads (T and X series) since the IBM days. Most if not all of these models have 3 year warranty, and many with next business day on-site. Probably applies to the mobile workstation series too (used to be the 'W' series, now 'P' I think). They also have spill resistant keyboards as standard (drainage channels to prevent catastrophe, rather than making colour-changing stickers so Apple can bill you for water damage should an accident happen).
- jdietrich 9y agoCompletely standard across the Think* line. Service manuals and diagnostic software is available to download directly - you don't even have to log in. You can buy all parts directly from Lenovo or from a distributor without a service contract and regardless of warranty status. Opening the chassis doesn't automatically void your warranty and the terms specifically state which parts you're allowed to replace yourself. The standard US warranty on ThinkPads is one year RTB, but you can upgrade to three years RTB for $99 or three years onsite for $159. International warranty coverage is an extra $10. The standard warranty in Europe is three years onsite. For minor faults, you can usually ask for replacement parts to be shipped for self-installation.
- walshemj 9y agoIs this maintenance costs for traditional corporate use where your user base has a lot of "where's the any key" users, and you may have hundreds of hosts to maintain. I suspect maintenance costs in a high end company with a handful of high end macs vs high end workstations is quite different note that the production company seems to be using the macs in a peer to peer set up. And thus doesn't have all the overhead of domain controllers, exchange servers etc a traditional pc deployment.
- walterbell 9y agoCan iMac be used as an external monitor for a Macbook?
- milankragujevic 9y agoNo, retina iMac models don't support target display mode anymore. You can get a pretty expensive Dell 5K display and use that with a Macbook...
- rsynnott 9y agoOr the somewhat cheaper, if a bit funny-looking, LG Ultrafine.
- JimDabell 9y agoMacBooks don't support 5K resolutions, so it would be a bit wasteful to buy a 5K monitor for one. Are you sure you're not confusing it with the MacBook Pro?
- milankragujevic 9y agoI was using the term "MacBook" to mean a generic Apple laptop, not the 12" Retina MacBook with Core M processor.
- sudhirj 9y agoIt's interesting that development of the iMac Pro was already underway when Apple and pro users (mostly developers) had that big showdown after the touch bar came out. The touch bar seemed like the final slap in the face to the pro crowd, but this was already in the works then. Every pro review I've seen so far has been that's it's excellent - not because they're fawning over this or that, but just that's it's a solid option with a great screen at what's actually a reasonable price for the components inside. If you think the price is unreasonable, you're probably not the sales target for this machine - the ones who really need this, like in the case of this reviewer, are buying three at a time - just because. It's interesting because upgradability doesn't seem like a very big concern to anyone buying this - they're happy with that they're getting at the price they're paying. It almost seems like Apple needn't have promised everyone a new modular Mac Pro. If they'd just announced / launched this machine alongside the pointless MacBook Pro update, everyone would have been happy and with no accusations of taking the name of the Pro in vain.
- walterbell 9y agoNvidia-powered hackintoshes are a counterpoint mentioned in the article.
- delhanty 9y agoSimilar to what the parent wrote, people who buy Nvidia-powered hackintoshes probably aren't the target market.
- sudhirj 9y agoYeah, but this came out at the last WWDC, I think - https://developer.apple.com/development-kit/external-graphics/ https://developer.apple.com/development-kit/external-graphic... I believe Nvidia drivers are already in beta, this or any other eGPU enclosure should be able to remove that sticking point. There is a slight performance penalty because fo the TB3 bus conversion bus, but it's only applicable for real time work like gaming - pro work should be able to use Nvidia cards just fine.
- rsynnott 9y ago
- poink 9y ago> Secondly, you get a wireless mouse and extended keyboard. Both have to be plugged in to charge. In the case of the mouse, the cable plugs in at the bottom, rendering it useless during charging. Truly a bad design. The Magic Mouse 2 is one of the worst mice I've ever used, but the charging thing is a non-issue. The battery lasts like a month on one charge. Mine has never gone below 50%.
- pm 9y agoHow does it compare to the original?
- DRW_ 9y agoIt's the same, except it has a built in battery and is rechargeable with a lightning cable (which the port is located on the bottom of the device, so you can't use it whilst charging).
- sekh60 9y agoI don't understand battery charge cycles and batter degradation much or really at all, bit could the port on the bottomaybe a subtle way to encourage people to not charge so frequently and weaken the battery prematurely?
- mattkevan 9y agoPretty sure that’s it. Otherwise people would leave it permanently plugged in. When mine dies it’s a good excuse to find a cup of coffee. By the time I get back there’s more than enough charge for the rest of the day.
- tgb 9y agoThere's no need to do that with properly designed circuitry and since discharging fully is damaging, encouraging this behavior is probably harmful to battery longevity. Battery University has so much information on this, but this part is a good summary chart (see the lithium-ion column) [1] [1] http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/how_to_charge_when_to_charge_table http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/how_to_charge_whe...
- phillco 9y ago> At the distance that the editors sit from a 27” display, there is simply little or no difference between the look of the 27” LED display and the 27” iMac Retina screens. Eh?
- sudhirj 9y agoBeyond a certain distance (at which the human eye can no longer resolve pixels), all screens are Retina. https://designcompaniesranked.com/resources/is-this-retina/ https://designcompaniesranked.com/resources/is-this-retina/ The people in the images are likely past the Retina distance https://shop.avid.com/resource/1515153493000/cc_avid_gh_wur/img/tv3-main-image-1862x1040.jpg https://shop.avid.com/resource/1515153493000/cc_avid_gh_wur/... http://www.hillsvideo.com/assets/uploads/2015/08/video-editing-avid-final-cut-hills-video.jpg http://www.hillsvideo.com/assets/uploads/2015/08/video-editi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GuiA 9y agoThe author seems to be well in his middle age, and wears glasses. His visual acuity might make his subjective experience irrelevant on that specific point. I can tell the difference between retina and non retina 27” on a desk (but I have 20/10 vision, which makes my subjective experience irrelevant for most people too)
- matwood 9y agoYeah, I can also absolutely tell the difference and have a hard time using any non-retina monitor now.
- ec109685 9y agoActually I think it is worse with poor eye site. Blurry things look more blurry. I was surprised by that point but perhaps they have multi monitor setup at significant distance away.
- mattbierner 9y agoEven if you never upgrade the machine during its lifetime, you still have to pay Apple’s notoriously high ram and hard drive upgrade costs. Example: when I bought a new iMac last year, Apple was charging $1400 for 64GB of ram. That’s insane, so I went with the base and purchased my own. Took five minutes to install and saved around $800 if I recall
- danieldk 9y agoA large organization might not really care about dropping $1400 on 64GB of RAM if required when your employees cost $100,000 per year.
- walshemj 9y agoNever met a large organisation where purchasing cheaper OEM parts wasn't liked by the CFO
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThat does not improve the situation in the slightest.
- mattbierner 9y agoSure, if they figure that upgrading themselves would have a higher total cost (lost productivity, internal costs, ...) than what they would otherwise save. But blindly spending more than you have to because your fixed costs are high is just irresponsible, no matter how big the organization is
- maxxxxx 9y agoA lot of large organizations will happily waste expensive employees' time to save a few hundred in equipment.
- burntwater 9y ago
- mailslot 9y ago"...there is simply little or no difference between the look of the 27” LED display and the 27” iMac Retina screens." I feel sorry for the author, because your eyes have to be shit to come to come to this conclusion. If I remove my contact lenses, then yes, there is no difference. I'm sure the difference in color gamut is no big deal to someone with colorblindness either.
- walshemj 9y agoWould have been interesting to see the same benchmarks on similarly priced Threadripper workstation.
- revelation 9y agoIn my next test, I took a 4½-minute-long 1080p ProRes file and rendered it to a 4K/UHD (3840×2160) H.264 (1-pass CBR 20Mbps) file. So this is why those media pros need that computing power and resolution..
- burntwater 9y agoFor projection mapping, my large, well-known theater uses a 14,000x14,000 pixel canvas. Every frame is a little over 500MB.
- pvdebbe 9y agoThose sizes surely warrant a small render farm and not just beefed-up workstations?
- amelius 9y agoDoes it have an Intel processor?
- yoz-y 9y agoYes. Intel Xeon. All of the benchmarks use the os already updated for meltdown too.
- malchow 9y agoI read in one review that, in addition to the non-upgradeability of the new iMac Pro, there is one real coup de grace: the beautiful integrated screen is not capable of being used as an external display for any future computer. If true, doesn't this strike you all as truly unnecessarily egregious? Why should an iMac Pro stuffed full of chemicals to show beautiful 5K images, never be capable of being used as just a display? Is there a good reason Apple customers have to buy brand new displays? This is worth asking because, unlike the components in the new machine, the display will probably be state of the art for a while.
- prawn 9y agoIsn't this already true of recent iMacs? I don't think you have been able to use them as dumb displays for at least 1-2 generations?
- malchow 9y agoI think you're right. But just as insane in that situation. Think of the work necessary to prevent that screen from ever being used to display a nasty video signal from –– gasp! –– another computer. It's just such an insult to customers. Am I crazy here? And isn't Apple supposed to be a company of environmentalists?
- userbinator 9y agoThink of the work necessary to prevent that screen from ever being used to display a nasty video signal from –– gasp! –– another computer. It's just such an insult to customers. They just didn't bother adding the circuitry for "video in", due to cost; there is no active opposition here. For many years now, you can buy "LVDS converter" boards[1] which will let you use any display panel as a monitor. I'm sure demand will mean such boards appear for the iMac Pro displays soon, if the existing ones aren't already compatible. I haven't looked too closely at this but the display might even be eDP or similar, which means only a physical converter is necessary if you want to connect a DP output to it. That's been done with iPad displays before[2] [1] http://www.ebay.com/bhp/lvds-hdmi http://www.ebay.com/bhp/lvds-hdmi [2] https://hackaday.com/2013/04/22/connect-a-retina-display-to-a-regular-computer/ https://hackaday.com/2013/04/22/connect-a-retina-display-to-...
- duncan_bayne 9y agoPeople wondering about the unit construction, lack of upgradability, etc. may be interested to know that the "sealed box appliance" mentality has been in Apple's DNA since the design of the _first_ Macintosh: https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Diagnostic_Port.txt https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Diagnostic_Port.... "Apple's other co-founder, Steve Jobs, didn't agree with Jef about many things, but they both felt the same way about hardware expandability: it was a bug instead of a feature. Steve was reportedly against having slots in the Apple II back in the days of yore, and felt even stronger about slots for the Mac. He decreed that the Macintosh would remain perpetually bereft of slots, enclosed in a tightly sealed case, with only the limited expandability of the two serial ports."
- imagetic 9y agoI'm happy to see something with professional specs coming from Apple. I have serious concerns with the iMac Pro in terms of heat while rendering for many days of the year. The Mac Pro trash can is notorious for overheating, so I'm not sad to see it go and I look forward to a new Mac Pro in 2018. The market for that unit will pay a premium for serviceability as well. I'm expecting a heavy price tag. It's nice to see a real world example of the iMac Pro in use. I do a lot of sustained renders for TV and feature length content. Our PCs run laps around our trash cans, but a mixed environment is far from ideal. We spend more time troubleshooting with editors than anything. I have more concerns about macOS High Sierra than anything at this point though. I've upgraded a few machines and we're seeing more crashes than ever. Sierra might have to be my staple for a long while.
- nottorp 9y ago> The AME version kicked in the fans on the iMac. Interesting... so they're noticeable. Anyone around who has (access to) an iMac Pro and can comment on the fan noise?
- Apocryphon 9y agoUltimately, isn't the iMac Pro just a stopgap pro because the true upgraded desktop is coming out this year?
- macintux 9y agoPlenty of people will be happy with the iMac Pro. If the number of people who'll pay $5k for a computer that will be much less useful in 3 years is relatively constrained, the number who'll pay $5k for a computer they expect to treat as a stopgap for a few months is miniscule. There's no indication that Apple thinks it's a one-off: there's a lot of custom engineering in there.
- microcolonel 9y ago> But is this really an issue? I’m sure Apple has user research numbers to justify their decisions. They also have a direct incentive not to make user memory upgrades an option. It's a bit too charitable to think they're not supporting it because they somehow know nobody would want to do it anyway.
- nickpeterson 9y agoI want to see an apple designed chip running full out (no real thermal restrictions like in iPads/iPhone/Apple TV). Those chips already compare pretty favorably to Intel, and running at 3+GHz would likely have great single threaded performance. I actually believe we're going to see MacOS for arm and a mac mini running an arm chip, it makes too much sense for Apple not to do it.
- JohnBooty 9y agoI know what you mean, but I'm not sure that's the way forward. My understanding is that when you start really cranking up CPU speed -- let's say, with an imaginary 3.5ghz version of whatever their latest iPad Pro CPU is -- now you're just spending all your time waiting for RAM. So you need fancier and fancier speculative execution hardware in order for the CPU to have something, anything to do. You get into that game, and you wind up with as many transistors on a chip as Intel and AMD, hitting the same performance walls as Intel and AMD have been hitting for a long time. What Apple could do is just go super wide, of course. Instead of bumping up the clock speed, they could cram 16 of those iPad Pro cores into a Macbook or whatever. Which would be fun, but for most workloads, those cores will just be idle most of the time.