3 ms·
Interesting use of language: 'Recent reports that these exploits... are unique to Intel products are incorrect... Intel is committed to product and customer se
by mannykannot 9y ago
Interesting use of language:
'Recent reports that these exploits... are unique to Intel products are incorrect... Intel is committed to product and customer security and is working closely with many other technology companies, including AMD...'
Someone new to the issue might think AMD also has this problem.
Similarly (replacing the first elision in the above quote):
'Recent reports that these exploits are caused by a “bug” or a “flaw”... are incorrect.'
So, working just the way you want it to, eh, Intel? But then, why would you describe them as exploits?
- thezilch 9y agoNot defending Intel here, but devils advocate... You will find many clients asking how to disable, for example, the Linux patch. Linux is releasing with a flag to disable it, so there is some merit. Why would you want that? There are a lot of times you trust everything running on your box and don't need to take the perf hit. Intel (and possibly other archs/families) found a perf win that ends up having security implications. A perf nonetheless. If you're willing to bet on your userspace not reading kernel pages, does Intel have a feature for you!
- mannykannot 9y agoIntel is certainly entitled to make and promulgate an objective assessment of the impact of the problem, but a problem is still a problem even if it doesn't affect everyone.
- thezilch 9y agoWho says they won't? The issue is embargoed, but that's, as usual, not keeping everyone from speculating. That's fine too, but also realize the layman (even people in this thread) is getting pummeled with ideas like "my new laptop is going to be 30% slower tomorrow; WTF!!!"
- mannykannot 9y ago> Who says they won't? Not me. My comments are restricted to certain things Intel did choose to say. And as you are concerned about rumor and disinformation, I cannot imagine you are pleased with Intel's insinuation that AMD processors are also affected. UPDATE: It seems AMD may be being misleading in this case...
- Dylan16807 9y ago> There are a lot of times you trust everything running on your box and don't need to take the perf hit. This is true. > Intel (and possibly other archs/families) found a perf win that ends up having security implications. A perf nonetheless. If you're willing to bet on your userspace not reading kernel pages, does Intel have a feature for you! This I'm more skeptical of. My best guess is that this is something that saves nanoseconds, but the mitigation is massively more expensive than simply not having the feature.
- marcosdumay 9y ago> Intel found a perf win that ends up having security implications. Every Intel CPU has a lower perf than you will find on current benchmarks, but yes, there's a perf enhancement that will make the chip as fast as expected, but has security implications.
- mannykannot 9y agoCorrection: it seems that AMD processors are also vulnerable to one variant of this type of attack, which either mitigates or refutes my first complaint. AMD is crying foul, claiming that Intel is creating a bogus equivalence, as the risks are not comparable, but it is itself using awkward phrasing: "AMD is not susceptible to all three variants" rather than the more straightforward "AMD is susceptible to only N of the three variants."