16 ms·
Trinitron: Sony's Once Unbeatable Product [video]
- doomlaser 9y agoTrinitron TVs definitely were the best. Famously, the Trinitron as a product was a huge inspiration to Steve Jobs and influenced the design of the Apple II casing. My favorite trivia about them was that, for some engineering reason, every Trinitron screen had a barely perceptible horizontal line artifact about 2/3 of the way down the display. This was true in every Trinitron, from televisions to monitors even through the 1990s.
- DiabloD3 9y agoIt held the aperture grill. It was truly a triumph, a huge success. I wish my Trinitron was still alive.
- lurquer 9y agoIt's hard to overstate my satisfaction with the Triniton. Believe me... it's still alive.
- look_lookatme 9y agoI thought there were two lines?
- bluedino 9y agoSmaller screens only had 1 wire
- IronBacon 9y agoYeah, I still have somewhere a CPD-G400 monitor that used a Trinitron tube and IIRC there were two of them, in the manual they called them "damper wires" and it was related to the use of an aperture grille instead of a slot mask or something like that...
- doomlaser 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aFhzGEBQlk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aFhzGEBQlk — just watched the linked video with a nice Trinitron historical overview. Apparently, there was always one wire 2/3 of the way down, but they would put a second one 1/3 of the way down on larger screens.
- cjsuk 9y agoThey were only barely perceptible until someone told you about them. Then you saw them every time you looked at the screen :) I do miss my 17" FD Trinitron monitor though. That was lovely. I didn't have enough money or room for a 21"
- taneq 9y agoI had the 19", saved up for it for my first computer. I used that screen for years, it was wonderful. Permanently bent my desk.
- cjsuk 9y agoAh yes - mine had a notable bend in the shelf as well :)
- kalleboo 9y agoI was a kid at the time and we had an Apple display that used a Trinitron tube. One of my friends came over and tried to erase the "line" in the paint program. I had no idea what he was on about until I finally noticed what I had missed all along - the support wire.
- seanalltogether 9y agoHe discusses that in the attached video, it was needed to prevent picture vibrations due to audio. https://youtu.be/0aFhzGEBQlk?t=9m9s https://youtu.be/0aFhzGEBQlk?t=9m9s
- Torgo 9y agoThat line drove me bonkers, and I wasn't buying "the line means quality". I couldn't have been the only one. Luckily my studio Trinitron I got second-hand doesn't have the line, or at least is imperceptible to me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- neya 9y agoI urge every one in HN to give this masterpiece a read - "Made in Japan". It's an autobiography of the founder of Sony himself and there is a section in the book where he talks about the engineering and spirit that went behind these TVs. In fact, he talks a lot about the engineering spirit that made Sony the Apple of its era. If you liked Steve Job's biography, you'll certainly love this.[1] Cheers. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Made-Japan-Akio-Morita-Sony/dp/0451151712 https://www.amazon.com/Made-Japan-Akio-Morita-Sony/dp/045115...
- Unklejoe 9y agoCool. This isn't related to TVs, but I have a couple pieces of old Sony HiFi equipment from the very early 1970's and I'm always amazed by the quality and attention to detail Sony had back then. I feel like it's back when Sony had something to prove. This may have been the case for most consumer electronics manufacturers back then though. One is a TA-1130 amplifier, and the other is a reel-to-reel tape player (I forget the model). The most amazing to me is that the reel-to-reel still works fine after nearly 50 years, considering all the moving parts.
- petepete 9y agoThe record player in my dad's mid-80s Sony hifi recently stopped working. He called the local Sony store to buy a spare part and the assistant was born after the part ceased production. Begrudgingly he had to replace the record player. Every (remaining) part of that old Sony is beautiful, unmistakably 80s but so well designed and finished it's still a joy to use; plus it sounds great.
- StavrosK 9y ago> the assistant was born after the part ceased production I can't help but wonder if there's some correlation there. Perhaps the assistant's father was so dismayed at the part's cessation that the only comfort he could attain was in the arms of his wife.
- 9y ago
- KaiserPro 9y agoUp until quite recently sony's grade 1 CRTs were the only* thing you could "grade" on. Even though they had stopped being manufactured in ~2006 there was a strong second hand market up until at least 2011. * well kinda, it was the only thing at the time able to properly display the anywhere near the dynamic range that 10bit log provide.
- thinkythought 9y agoAnd there's still a very, very strong market for these as retro gaming displays. I scored a few when they were dirt cheap used, and now people are charging $400+ for an old 20in with a ton of hours on it, and even more if it's a high end "broadcast" model
- bcaulfield 9y agoI own and use a Sony FD Trinitron Flat Screen CRT every day. Works great. I need a special adapter to connect it to my SHIELD. But it's outlasted several DVD players and game consoles. It's my family's only TV. Hadn't thought about how long I've owned it, but now realize it's been at least 12-15 years. I'd thought about chucking it for a flat screen, but was waiting for prices to come down. Then waited for HD prices to come down. Lately been waiting for 4k prices to come down. Now, why wait? They're so damn cheap. But after all these years, feels like I just... can't, and I just want to discourage too much TV watching (rationalization). Should I hang on to this thing?
- foobarian 9y agoNewer TVs take a long time to change channels. You probably want to hang on to this one.
- gaius 9y agoYes. I wish I’d kept mine.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoI'm hanging on to a ~2005 Bang & Olufsen 28" MX8000, in my opinion one of the greatest 4:3 CRT TVs ever made (not a flat tube, but absolute TOTL in every other aspect, including sound). I use it primarily for retro gaming, and although I have considered getting an Open Source Scan Convertor and plugging the consoles into my 27" LCD, there's just something about playing games on an SD 4:3 CRT.
- mark-r 9y agoIt probably still has better black levels than any LCD you can buy. Wait for the OLED prices to come down.
- totalZero 9y agoMy parents had a Trinitron when I was a kid; now they have a Samsung Quantum Dot LED display. The Trinitron was nice, but I could spend hours watching videos on the QLED. It's sharper, motion is crisper, and the colors are deep and vibrant. There's really no comparison in terms of picture quality. And the Samsung is light enough that it can be easily mounted from the ceiling. There are reasons why the market has shifted to some of these other technologies. Apart from nostalgia and familiarity, you won't miss the Trinitron if you upgrade.
- baybal2 9y agoI was once a happy owner of last Sony's HDCRTs with hdmi input that I ordered from Japan for almost double the price. Luckily, I soon started my career and was sent as an exchange student to Singapore. That put an end to my Quake 3 obsession,and lust for expensive gaming gear.
- Torgo 9y agoDid it have input lag or artifacting, to your recollection?
- baybal2 9y agoI believe, there was some little extra lag on hdmi, because dac lag was added to hdmi buffering lag, but it was barely noticable
- thinkythought 9y agoThey did, but it wasn't worse than modern TVs. The paradoxical thing is because everything went through the image processor, digital input>processor>analog conversion>screen was faster than analog input>digital conversion>image processor>analog conversion>screen There's a big thread on AVSforum with people whinging about this somewhere. The upside is, they're still nice to play stuff like switch games on EDIT: the processing of analog sources, like 480p dvds, laserdisc, etc was superior to cheap modern TVs. They designed the scaler very well for older formats and it really did look quite nice. I remember being totally disappointed by my "high end" samsung tv in 2013~ or so in comparison. The colors are handled especially nice even on like, VHS. Artifacting/macroblocking/banding wasn't an issue with however they were handling the effects/processing which was a noticeable advantage over the flat screens of the era and even more recently
- jaclaz 9y agoI am probably too much an old-timer, but my TV is actually a Sony Trinitron CRT, bought (for a very steep price) in 2002 or 2003 and still going strong. For the record, it is a "beast", even if it is "only" 32" in size, it is weighing around 70 Kg! I bought it at the time with a specific table/support for it.
- ksec 9y agoConsidering you make it into 15 years of usage I think the price might be well worth it? CRT in the old days, especially Sony's Trinitron CRT were extremely well designed and well made. Pretty much like ALL "Made in Japan" electronics sold were designed to last. I have a LCD TV from Sony that is now on 12 years of services, still going strong. But as tech improves it seems the life expectancy of the product are taken less into account. I would bet the Sony CRT monitor will out last my Sony LCD TV. And OLED is only going to be worst.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoOne response to this is: the market has spoken, it's not interested in paying for product longevity. I'm not entirely sure I agree, but here we are.
- vikascoder 9y agoI dont think it's a choice in the hands of the consumer anymore.
- adrianN 9y agoThe market doesn't have enough information about product longevity to make an informed decision. The only reliable data point I have as a consumer is the warranty. The few brands that advertise longevity usually cost so much more than cheap versions of the same product that it's hard to justify the purchase. Why for example should I pay $150 for Patagonia jeans if I can get ten pairs of El-Cheapo jeans for the same amount?
- 9y ago
- ksec 9y agoDo CRT monitor, given today's technology advance, still offers any benefits? Does it still wins on colouring and latency when we have OLED?
- agumonkey 9y agoA few years back I booted my beloved diamondtron. It felt ... better. It's no scientific measure, but even compared to 4K OLED, there's something pretty that is visually pleasing. Kinda like looking at kodachrome films.
- simonlc 9y agoThey are still sought after by the retro gaming community, although there are many who like the professional studio monitors Sony made (BVM and PVM series) which have a cylindrical tube.
- freshyill 9y agoA friend of mine has one for this reason. He actually manages equipment and medical devices for a company that runs hospitals and was able to get one that one of their hospitals was going to throw away. It’s a really nice display for gaming on a CRT, but, to my eyes, not that much nicer than the Sony Wega he otherwise uses.
- Torgo 9y agoThe Trinitron studio monitors also have RGBS (red, green, blue, composite-sync) BNC connectors, meaning that it's fairly easy to directly hook up bare arcade boards and get that real arcade experience.
- Sholmesy 9y agoThe competitive Super Smash (Melee) community still uses them, and the good ones (like the trinitrons) are highly coveted.
- dagw 9y agoWhy? What actual competitive advantage do they offer? Or is it more an abstract look and feel thing.
- kazinator 9y agoFor the benefit of the kids, let me dredge up how these used to be lovingly pronounced "tri nitron". :)
- Nursie 9y agoI had a 17" Iiyama 'Diamondtron' (really trinitron) monitor through the late 90s and well into the 00s. It had amazing picture quality for the time, put up with a fair amount of abuse and was still working perfectly when I gave it away in '05. But then flat screens hit and all of a sudden I could have more screen real estate and more desk space. No contest really, the future had arrived even if the future was worse colour and response rates for a while. I can't imagine the tonnage of CRT needed to recreate all the flat screens around my home and office now.
- tjoff 9y agoLCDs had much less screen real estate compared to CRTs which could run much higher resolutions. The first generations of LCDs were quite inferior on everything but form factor and power consumption.
- dsego 9y agoMuch higher resolutions at lower refresh rates and way too much flicker.
- tjoff 9y agoDepends on the display, yes you could run too high of a resolution on many CRTs but a good one maintained flicker-free operation and focus.
- Nursie 9y ago> LCDs had much less screen real estate compared to CRT Oh sure, in terms of resolution I went from the CRT being able to do 1600x1200 back to an LCD that could do 1280x1024 (IIRC). But the physical screen sizes were bigger very quickly, that's what I meant. CRTs were certainly superior in terms of image, response time and resolution. But when I could buy a larger flat panel at 1280x1024 with a 16ms response time for a couple of hundred pounds... buh-bye forever CRT.
- tjoff 9y ago
- Tade0 9y agoWe had a Sony Trinitron and I remember them for being sturdy. Ours survived: 1. An assault with a rock to the screen by my then three year old sister. 2. Over 4000km in a shipping container. 3. Putting a blank x-ray plate to the screen, which apparently created a static shock powerful enough to disable the device(not sure about this one because I was five when I did that).
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoThey were very sturdy, but not in all situations. One New Years Eve I was at home and a friend was having a party at his around the corner. He asked if he could borrow my TV which I agreed to, but when he turned up he'd taken far too many pharmaceuticals. I helped him carry it to his house and was at the front crossing the road when I heard what sounded like a huge explosion. I turned round and he'd dropped the TV, it had imploded, and he was gurning and dancing around it. I miss that Trinitron...
- exikyut 9y ago_You_ did #3?! How'd you get access to a blank X-Ray plate? What do you mean by "device" here?
- Tade0 9y agoMy father used to be a lecturer/chief technician at a university and his field is medical equipment in general(the course he was responsible for was something along the lines of "x-ray devices"), so we had a few of those lying around in the house. By "device" I meant the TV set. I remember hearing an obvious zap as the plate glued itself to the screen which went blank even though the TV seemed to be still on.
- gknoy 9y agoI'm really interested in learning why it would do that. I remember my screen generating some static electricity (e.g. paper would stick), but I would not have expected putting something on the screen to blank the tube. Is it a special property of the x-ray plate? (Is it conductive?) This feels like knowledge that will end up feeling obvious in hindsight. ;)
- dmitriid 9y agoTrinitron TVs had a legendary near-mythical status in the USSR beginning sometime in the 80s. It was the TV to measure anything by. To the point that "sonytrinitron" was common enough name everyone understood (much like "xerox" or "jeep" became common names over there).
- pnut 9y agoUsed to love degaussing mine at work, it was so strong it would have a secondary effect on every monitor in a 6 foot radius.
- Gregordinary 9y agoNot Trinitron (Edit: Yes it is), but I had a pair of Sony FW900 Monitors. I got them free off of craigslist in 2010 when my laptop screen broke, I didn't have an external monitor and I was unemployed. Those things are beasts. A little over 90 lbs each, 16x10 aspect ratio, and supported a resolution of 2304 x 1440 at 80 Hz. https://www.cnet.com/products/sony-gdm-fw900/specs/ https://www.cnet.com/products/sony-gdm-fw900/specs/
- c3833174 9y agoThose are Trinitrons too
- Gregordinary 9y agoEven says that on the page I linked. Thanks for pointing that out.
- chaoticmass 9y agoI have one of these at home in my closet. It was my primary home display from around 2005 to 2012.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoStill remember the small Triniton Sony TV I've connected my Amstrad CPC to. It had a glass in from of the tube and was portable with a handle.
- thirdsun 9y agoI think it's kind of sad that Sony's attention to detail and their status as a premium brand has been fading in recent decades. There are few product categories these days where Sony really is state of the art, although it seems as if they're trying to position themselves as premium manufacturer again (audio players, projectors come to mind) - a development I welcome, as I think there's room for brands in consumer electronics that work with the care of a small shop but can manufacture on a large scale. edit: As other commenters pointed out there are some rather obvious categories I seem to have missed, including cameras and gaming consoles.
- xedarius 9y agoI'd argue they're top of the tree in gaming consoles, but on the whole I agree.
- jrockway 9y agoI'd say they compete favorably with Canon and Nikon with digital cameras.
- lykr0n 9y agoIn my view, they make great-ish Smart Phones.
- pipio21 9y agoSony digital cameras sensors are the best in the market. Guess what the Iphone uses, that is the number one camera in the world.
- ubermonkey 9y agoSony's huge and complicated. Obviously they're still doing well as a purveyor of gaming consoles, and their mirrorless cameras are AMAZING right now, but at the same time their forays into other markets (computing, e.g.) haven't fared well, and they went from market leader to also-ran in displays. The thing that still shocks me, though, is the degree to which they blew their market leading position in portable music players. They OWNED that market in the 80s and 90s with the then-ubiquitous Walkman brand, which they extended into the CD era with "Discman" players that seemingly everyone had when I went to college in 1988. Internal politics (I assume?) kept them from introducing a reasonable MP3 player until far, far too late for them to catch up. Some of their early efforts literally required you to re-encode your music into another weird format to use (ATRAC, I think?) -- and this while smaller players (Rio, etc) had devices you could load by copying MP3s to a memory card. I assume this is because Sony Music was afraid of the Mp3 revolution, but my understanding is that Sony Electronics has always been far more profitable than Sony Music, so it's hard to understand how that tail ended up wagging that particular dog. (Oh, and there's also Sony's bizarre insistence on proprietary formats, like MiniDISC and MemoryStick -- that didn't help them, either.) And then, of course, Apple came in with the iPod and gathered up the high-end, high-margin customers that were Sony's constituency.
- b3b0p 9y agoIn our house hold we had the infamous 40 inch XBR 700 (our neighbors had the 40 inch Mitsubishi equivalent, which was also very nice at the time). A 320 lb glorious spectacle. We loved it. Eventually though it started to wear out and because of it's shear weight and size, dad posted on Craig's List for free, with the caveat the person(s) had to come get it without him helping. The people who came were in for a rude awakening.
- nsxwolf 9y agoBut they have those damned horizontal tungsten wires going across the screen. Once seen cannot be unseen.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abtinf 9y agoI had the same problem with these screens. Even after years of using Trintron monitors at work, I was never able to ignore the lines. I've never heard anyone else complain about them though - others seem to get used to them very quickly.
- triplesec 9y agoexcept they are hardly visible, most people filter them out again and it really doesn't impact the experience for them
- vanadium 9y agoI use a 14" RGB Sony Trinitron medical imaging monitor for retrogaming; PVMs and BVMs are pretty much the gold standard these days, especially the Trinitrons, for their quality and longevity. If you think Trinitron quality is great in your average Television CRT, it's _amazing_ in true RGB. Who knew SCART would keep bare-metal retrogaming alive?
- jhoechtl 9y agoIs there currently a TV/panelntechnology to rule them all? I am very fond of OLED technology - superb contrast and vivid colors, even on UHD.
- homero 9y agoI mostly remember the two thin support wires crossing the screen. Loved my Sony vaio desktop.
- m3kw9 9y agoHad one of these at my parents and they just out lasted most of my friends TVs and it was still working like new the day we finally was urged to switch to LCD tv after they had it 20+ years
- mschaef 9y agoOne of my first large purchases of computer hardware was a Sony GDM-17SE1 monitor. This was in 1994, when a 17" display was unusual, and the display went along with an 8MB 486DX/33 machine. The display was expensive at the time ($2,300 in 2017 dollars), but lasted me a good 6 or 7 years. By the time 2000 rolled around, I was doing most of my computing on employer-owned machines and laptops, so my need for a desktop display was minimal. (That didn't stop me, though, from a briefly owned 19" Dell rebrand of a Trinitron display.) Display quality on those CRTs was excellent, although the thin horizontal wires were indeed noticeable if you looked.
- Brockenstein 9y agoI ended up with a refurbed trinitron monitor in 2005 or so, it was 19 or 20 inches, 1600x1200, so sweet at the time. Thing weighed like 100lbs. After a while you developed wire blindness, but people who saw it for the first time would see the wires straight away... and would recoil in horror.
- dang 9y agoUrl changed from https://hackaday.com/2018/01/03/why-sonys-trinitron-tubes-were-the-best/ https://hackaday.com/2018/01/03/why-sonys-trinitron-tubes-we..., which points to this. Generally we prefer to link to text rather than video, but there really isn't much in that article, so it doesn't seem justified to link there. The HN guidelines ask for original sources: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- busterarm 9y agoI still sorely miss my GDM-5010PT monitor. It gave up the ghost in about 2006, losing the ability to display green. I didn't bother to service it and I'm kicking myself because it was a reasonable repair. That said, it really was a boat anchor as far as weight goes.
- dsego 9y agoPrevious discussion 1 day ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16048202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16048202
- jdblair 9y agoI've had multiple Trinitron monitors over my career. Until LCDs got good I would insist on having one. They had the least distortion and the best color. 2 monitors stand out in my memory: In 1998 I bought myself a 19" name-brand Sony monitor, for $650! I used it for 10 years, until I finally replaced it with a pair of LCD monitors. In the early 00s I worked for Sun Microsystems, and worked mostly from home. I bought a 27" Sun-branded Trinitron monitor off an internal surplus equipment auction and had it shipped to my home. It was so heavy it came on a shipping pallet!
- Digital-Citizen 9y agoI appreciate the quality of the screen, but I think the Mitsubishi flat screens were a step up from Sony's Trinitrons. If I recall, the Trinitron were a section of a cylinder (vertically flat) but the Mitsubishi 2040U (and later short-neck version, 2060U or something like that) used a strategically distorted picture to ultimately hit a flat screen (both vertically and horizontally flat) and appear focused. Sony would, in my opinion, ruin their name by mistreating people (both customers and would-be customers) by publishing what we now call "fake news" in the form of movie reviews by "David Manning" (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Manning_(fictitious_writer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Manning_(fictitious_writ... for more) and distributing malware to Windows users on some audio CDs (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk... for more). The latter means that Windows users who may have legally acquired a copy of the affected 58 known audio CDs (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Compact_Discs_sold_with_XCP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Compact_Discs_sold_wit... for the list) and inserted them into their Windows OS computer may have contracted software now identified as either spyware, a trojan horse, or a rootkit called "XCP" that could not easily be removed even if the user refused the EULA presented to them. Some of the software on these CDs appeared to be copyright infringements from FLOSS as well. And to cap it all off, the uninstaller for the malware only hid the software's entry in the Windows add/remove software list without uninstalling the software. Even Sony BMG's initial rootkit removal software exacerbated the problem further mistreating users. Ostensibly this was all done in the name of preventing people from making a copy of the audio tracks to their computers. I don't recommend running Windows or any other nonfree software. But that's no excuse for Sony's abuses. There's no good way to justify committing copyright infringement against developers who are respecting a user's software freedom. Nor is there good reason to justify Sony's choices to repeatedly subject users to malware, stand in the way of a non-infringing use, or make malware hard to remove. I'm not keen to distinguish between the various arms of Sony, so I choose not to do business with any of them. I also notice that despite all this malicious behavior the people who run the various arms of Sony are apparently not keen to distance themselves from the name "Sony".