13 ms·
The Failed War on Drugs
- wasx 9y agoAt this point articles like this are stale. They don't convince anyone not already convinced, and are really just echo chambers. The thing is, making posts and articles isn't going to change a damn thing, there's such a disconnect between the people in power and your average person that it's hard to see how any real change will come about from writing, airing your criticisms and petitioning. Especially since 21st century activism seems to be more focused on retweets than praxis, which ultimately means that unless people take to the streets and force change, all that's ever going to happen is more articles and more silence from the top. Do something if you believe in change.
- relyio 9y ago>Do something if you believe in change. Ross Ulbricht filed an appeal to the Supreme Court this week (http://reason.com/blog/2017/12/27/ross-ulbricht-files-appeal-to-the-suprem http://reason.com/blog/2017/12/27/ross-ulbricht-files-appeal...).
- r00fus 9y agoWhat does Dread Pirate Roberts trial have to do with legalization?
- jessaustin 9y agoDo you mean to say that you've read that link, and don't find anything in that account of government misbehavior that ought to be changed? That seems... unlikely.
- saas_co_de 9y agoWell, about half the country has legalized cannabis now. There were plenty of people who said that could never happen. What this article proposes is dumb though: > We should also decriminalize the small-scale possession of drugs for personal use ... we should continue to make it illegal to possess large quantities of drugs All that means is letting rich people enjoy getting high while putting poor people in jail. For all practical purposes that is the status quo already since it is almost impossible for non-dealer recreational users to get charged unless they do something really retarded. The only real answer is total legalization. It will happen. It will just take time.
- rabidrat 9y agoLegalization leads to commercialization. Do we really want for-profit corporations working to create demand for heroin and meth? It is already a huge problem that they're pushing opiates when ibuprofen+paracetamol is just as effective.
- 2III7 9y ago"when ibuprofen+paracetamol is just as effective" Liver says no.
- mifreewil 9y ago> Do we really want for-profit corporations working to create demand for heroin and meth? The sensible thing to do would be to bring the supply of drugs out into the open and remove it from the black market. Most of the issues from drugs like crime, violence and overdose deaths comes from the fact that it's a black market that cannot be regulated with standards or restricted to minors. If we regulated it similar to alcohol or tobacco (or stricter even), we wouldn't have so many problems.
- Nursie 9y ago>> Do we really want for-profit corporations working to create demand for heroin and meth? We don't really want them working to create demand for any pharmaceuticals, tobacco or alcohol either. Which is why in a lot of places advertising of such is banned to a greater or lesser extent. >> ibuprofen+paracetamol is just as effective Eh, not really.
- rabidrat 9y agohttps://media.jamanetwork.com/news-item/no-significant-difference-pain-relief-opioids-vs-non-opioid-analgesics-treating-arm-leg-pain/ https://media.jamanetwork.com/news-item/no-significant-diffe...
- Nursie 9y agoWhile that is interesting (and a little surprising), it's one measure on one sort of pain. It doesn't look at speed of onset, length of effect or the health impact of repeated dosing - paracetamol is not all that well tolerated by the body and ibuprofen can irritate the stomach. I'm also surprised because I'm sure I read sometime last year that for some types of pain, paracetamol is indistinguishable from placebo.
- projektfu 9y agoThese articles really do change the conversation in Washington, when the byline is someone like George Schultz. We don't expect to hear this sort of thing from a member of the Nixon and Reagan administrations. In fact, it's not common to hear it from the Clinton and Obama administrations. But if it were from a Green or a Libertarian, it wouldn't reach the NYT op-ed page because it'd be uninteresting, and nobody in Washington would talk about it.
- angel_j 9y agoSo you're saying the NYT, in all it's democracy-loving care and self-importance, can't (or editorially won't) push this issue on it's own, for instance by hammering the point home with continued, determined, journalistic reporting of actual events that the War on Drugs foments, because it's not "fit to print", or not "fit to sway Washington D.C."? But when some washed up D.C. insider millenials never heard of finally wants to admit what we all know, they run the article, as an opinion piece. But the nation can't focus on fixing the problem b/c of all the celebrity "news" and other garbage they did print in place of dogged coverage of decades-spanning, life-taking, community ruining, racist practices led by the federal government... That's exactly why we don't read the NYT. It's part of the oligarchy.
- forgottenpass 9y agoThe parent poster already explained why this position would be seen as run-of-the-mill and ineffectual if comes from the NYT's editorial voice. The NYT choosing to run this is exactly what you want them to do, using their position to push this issue by choosing to run this Op-Ed. Yes, It's a bland position only catching up to the status quo of many statehouses, but what's significant is the byline. In this case, The Times is showing Shutlz and Aspe approve of the steps taken in states to an audience that's not ready to make any baby steps at a federal level.
- jessaustin 9y agoYeah it feels sort of retrograde, mentioning Portugal for some peripheral point but not mentioning its actual policies that would involve anything but Prohibition.
- mifreewil 9y agoI thought this too, my guess is the authors felt going all the way would just seem too radical from the current status quo.
- joeax 9y agoThese articles slowly chip away at an entrenched status quo that "all drugs are bad" and gradually shift public opinion. Just look at California who just legalized recreational cannabis today.
- knieveltech 9y agoDon't overlook the value in trying to manipulate the Overton Window. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
- thomastjeffery 9y agoIn this case, we are at least at the threshold of Acceptable/Sensible, and this article isn't really pushing the subject in either direction.
- nimbius 9y agoits a rather poignant article considering California began legal recreational marijuana sales today. 7 other states have legalized marijuana for medical and recreational use as well. throughout most of the 80s the policy was 'do as i say, not as i do' as far as I can tell. with the government simultaneously financing the contras and fueling a drug epidemic. in the 90s we saw 3 strikes and a nearly terminal myopic perspective that branded drug abuse victims the same as Hillary Clintons "superpredators" and other violent felons. Today the US has become the nation with the greatest number of citizens incarcerated, thanks in part to this endless drug war. Conversely, the opioid crisis in the US has been recognized but almost no convictions of drug executives have taken place for their role in fueling it. It feels similar to the housing crisis. Its also difficult to see the drug war as anything but a proxy for placating voter bases after the 1964 Civil Rights amendment. Michelle Alexanders 'the new jim crow' goes into detail regarding this. I hope 2018 continues the sobering trend of abolishing mandatory minimums and decriminalizing marijuana, a recreational narcotic less dangerous than Alcohol yet one which has managed to become more regulated than methamphetamine.
- QAPereo 9y ago“You want to know what this was really all about?” he asked with the bluntness of a man who, after public disgrace and a stretch in federal prison, had little left to protect. “The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying? We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did.” John Erlichman, via Dam Baum
- cmurf 9y agoThis was a part of the Nixon southern strategy, Lee Atwater discussed it with some detail. https://www.thenation.com/article/exclusive-lee-atwaters-infamous-1981-interview-southern-strategy/ https://www.thenation.com/article/exclusive-lee-atwaters-inf... And in my view the current Attorney General is carrying out the same old ideas and policy effects, which is why he's so neurotically anti-weed, conflating it at every turn with opioid addiction.
- joe_the_user 9y agoIt seems like future may locate the point where America began it's decline with Nixon's war on drugs (though that definitely first of America's wars on substances).
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt definitely triggered very negative developments like mass incarceration.
- manicdee 9y agoThat was a great positive to the industry of incarceration.
- joeax 9y agoWhat's worse, mass incarceration has become the status quo with the American public. Writing new laws and jail seems to be the standard response for every problem in America. This is evident in the current opioid epidemic, where politicians just write up new laws and hope to just legislate the problem away, instead of examining the root cause and legalizing alternative medicines or funding treatment.
- rabboRubble 9y agoOregon resident here... My parents are Baby Boomers. About 2 years ago, I sat down with them and had the "talk" with them about opiates. My talking points were: * I'm a Gen Xer, I did drugs for fun back in the day so I fundamentally don't care if you are taking opioids for whatever reason. * If you get an initial opioid script from a doctor for more than 10 days, you have a 20% chance of being on opioids a year after. Again not a moral failing. [0] * If you do find yourself taking opioids and finding yourself uncomfortable about your use, you can talk to me about it because I don't consider drug use a character failure. Been there, done that. * When my parents visited from a red state, I took them to a cannabis shop and we tried non-pyschoactive CBDs together. They found the shop like visiting a dentist's office with an herby smell. Dad went back to his home state of Montana (fortunately legalized years ago) and got himself hooked up with various relieving CBD and THC compounds. He does not like MJ very much but it's better than tramadol for him as it has fewer side effects for him. This is my contribution to the failed drug war. Screw big pharma... [0] https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/03/with-a-10-day-supply-of-opioids-1-in-5-become-long-term-users/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/03/with-a-10-day-supply...
- katastic 9y ago>* If you get an initial opioid script from a doctor for more than 10 days, you have a 20% chance of being on opioids a year after. Again not a moral failing. [0] It should be noted that people who are bad enough off to need opiods, may continue to be bad off for a long time. Not because of the opiods, but because of having a condition so bad that doctors are willing to give you opiods. A script for more than a few days of opiods is very rare. I had a complete back fusion with 21 vertebrae drilled into and only had ~7 days prescribed.
- Spooky23 9y agoGreat point that isn't often made. I also had an incredibly painful back problem and spinal fusion. My doctors were aggressive about minimizing opiod use... almost excessively so. I probably had about 5 rounds of hydrocodone in a 5 day hospital stay.
- Yaa101 9y agoSomething what is almost never told in this discussion about drugs in the US is the root cause of drug use and it's epdemics is simply this: Live for a lot of people in the US is shitty, that is why they use drugs. The circomstances that cause these shitty lives is of course debatable but never addressed by the rulers of the US.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wavefunction 9y agoWhat about all the people in other countries that use drugs? What about all the people throughout history that have used drugs over at least tens of thousands of years before the US was around?
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoOf course it doesn't stop all drug use and abuse. I simply enjoy some like folks would enjoy alcohol. But surely you can understand that having a shitty life makes drugs look more appealing. For example, if you can't get proper time off work to heal an injury - which really is an indicator of a shitty life - you go to pain meds to get through. Or maybe your doctor said you couldn't keep working your current job, but you don't qualify for disability or any assistance to find or train for a different one. So you take pain meds in between. Keep doing this and you might find an addiction. Sure, it is better to go to a therapist to get over trauma, but that's more expensive than weed or vodka in the short term - plus either drug is more immediate.
- jdblair 9y agoI'm disappointed by the half measure in this proposal. Shulz and Aspe suggest possession for personal use should be decriminalized while drugs should remain illegal in large quantities. This leaves prohibition intact and supply remaining in the black market. This proposal would give street users a break (a step in the right direction) but would leave the supply chain intact. Cartels would continue to destabilize regions of Mexico.
- goatsi 9y agoPeople seem to forget that private ownership and consumption of alcohol was legal during the US prohibition (at the Federal level). You just had to buy it from Al Capone. We realized the problems that was causing then, but want to repeat them now.
- Stratoscope 9y agoYou didn't even have to buy from Al Capone. People who could afford it built extensive wine cellars and stocked them up before Prohibition began. The head of a household could make up to 200 gallons of wine per year for personal use and to share with family and friends. San Franciscans bought their grapes off the train that came down from Wine Country. If you didn't want the mess of crushing the grapes yourself, Golden Gate Grape & Juice Co. would crush them for you and deliver them to your home in a barrel from Pigiatura Completa Dell'Uva next door. (Scroll up and down in the first link for some photos.) [1] [2] If you didn't have a cellar or a source of grapes, you could mail order a "grape brick" of compressed dried grapes that came with a warning label: "After dissolving the brick in a gallon of water, do not place the liquid in a jug away in the cupboard for twenty days, because then it would turn into wine." [3] You could buy liquor for medicinal purposes with a doctor's prescription. The prescription listed the type of liquor required, how much you needed and how often to take it, and you would get the prescription filled at your local pharmacy. Walgreens grew from a few drugstores in Chicago to a nationwide chain by supplying medicinal liquor during Prohibition. [4] Clergy could buy sacramental wine and share it with their congregation for church services and other needs. California's Sebastiani Winery, founded in 1895, survived Prohibition by supplying sacramental and medicinal wine. [5] Daniel Okrent has written extensively on Prohibition. I highly recommend his book Last Call and related talks he's given. [6] [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=vqFxq6nv4rEC&pg=PA104-IA6&lpg=PA104-IA6&dq=san+francisco+prohibition+grape+juice+delivery&source=bl&ots=lco__A-_ET&sig=hvk64kmRP8ha4Nz1umGnceGsPmE&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiC64iztrjYAhWJiFQKHUOsCfUQ6AEIMDAC#v=onepage&q=san%20francisco%20prohibition%20grape%20juice%20delivery&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=vqFxq6nv4rEC&pg=PA104-IA6&... [2] http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/nativeson/article/Prohibition-was-only-a-rumor-in-S-F-2352835.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/nativeson/article/Prohibition-... [3] https://vinepair.com/wine-blog/how-wine-bricks-saved-the-u-s-wine-industry-during-prohibition/ https://vinepair.com/wine-blog/how-wine-bricks-saved-the-u-s... [4] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/during-prohibition-your-doctor-could-write-you-prescription-booze-180947940/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/during-prohibition-yo... [5] https://www.sebastiani.com/About-Us/Our-History https://www.sebastiani.com/About-Us/Our-History [6] https://www.google.com/search?q=daniel+okrent+last+call https://www.google.com/search?q=daniel+okrent+last+call
- manicdee 9y agoThe war on drugs was a highly successful campaign to entrench racism so deep in the American psyche that you will never be rid of it. The “War on Drugs” was never about drugs.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoRace plays a huge part, but absolute statements like this are not true. You're underestimating just how strong views against drug abuse of any kind are in this country due to religion or whatever. The prohibitionist movement had a strong female component and the argument was based around various forms of domestic abuse that were related to workmen being drunk all day. This had overlap with the abolitionist movement. It was not racist in its origin and it was the strongest legal "war on drugs" we ever had. https://www.nps.gov/wori/learn/historyculture/abolition-womens-rights-and-temperance-movements.htm https://www.nps.gov/wori/learn/historyculture/abolition-wome...
- joeax 9y agoThe War on Drugs and the Prohibition are two very separate things. While what you say is true about the Prohibition bringing disparate groups together (Church groups, women's' groups, big tobacco), the War on Drugs was an inherently racist tool invented by the Nixon administration to target hippies and blacks. http://www.cnn.com/2016/03/23/politics/john-ehrlichman-richard-nixon-drug-war-blacks-hippie/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/03/23/politics/john-ehrlichman-richa...
- aaron-lebo 9y agoThey can be distinct historical events and still be driven by similar dynamics and precedent. Nixon's war on drugs worked because it was making arguments that had been made before, and it worked because some people liked it for racial reasons, some liked it for religious reasons, and some overlapped.
- gozur88 9y agoYeah, except that Nixon just gave it that name. Drug prohibition in the US started when Nixon was learning to walk. This "drug prohibition is about racism" is all post hoc ergo propter hoc stuff.
- acd 9y agoIt would be good if we reflect on why people take drugs. Maybe US need more holidays so people will feel happier. If people are happy they will probably consume less drugs. In my view drugs are a way to escape pain. Maybe smart phones are making people isolated from each other? We used to watch movies with friends now we watch personal streams. People not feeling a belonging are seeking escape in substances?
- noobiemcfoob 9y agoYou're focusing on the mental/psychological reasons someone pursues drugs over more mundane things like literal, physical pain relief.
- OlivierKessler 9y agoThat is one better lecture. Also, people injecting opioids often have had horrible experiences during childhood. Handling that, offering free psychological/medical support to the people would be a great thing.
- md224 9y agoOver the last few years, due to personal events in my life, I've been thinking a lot about the relationship between drug addiction and emotional pain. Self-medication is a huge factor in drug use, and I hope everyone understands that. From the perspective of self-medication, drug addiction itself isn't the disease: drugs are just a coping mechanism to protect the user from a deeper agony. So when we talk about "reducing demand", we're not going to get anywhere unless we're able to provide people with better ways of dealing with their pain. A stint in detox isn't going to do shit for someone with depression or PTSD besides making them feel guilty and pathetic when they inevitably relapse. And if you actually succeed in making it impossible for this person to get their hands on illegal drugs -- while doing nothing to address their underlying pain -- then you might just end up with a suicide. As strange as it sounds, "drugs of abuse" may actually be the only thing keeping some people alive. In a way, our current drug epidemic is partially a failure of psychiatry. We need to do better in terms of addressing these root causes of psychic anguish. Drug addicts aren't lazy hedonists; they're just people who want relief from their demons. They deserve better options.
- mythrwy 9y agoWhy do people think pain is evil though? Perhaps the pain doesn't need to go away. Perhaps it's there for a reason. Perhaps attitudes need to change. Perhaps embracing and examining pain (within reason) should be a more common reaction. Just throwing out ideas. Slap 'em if you want to. But I will note not every society has needed to use so many pain relievers.
- taeric 9y agoOften the folks experiencing this pain are experiencing the kinda of pain you probably can't really imagine till it hits you once or twice. I used to have questions on migraines. Then I had the kind where you go blind for a bit before the headache. Yes, it is more painful than any normal headache. In a sense, this is like asking why do we treat allergies? Maybe the body is reacting that way for a reason, after all.
- 9y ago
- ggm 9y agoI would ask myself what the cash liberated from the war on drugs could be more usefully applied to, except I suspect it wouldn't get spent on health, mental or otherwise, or on short-circuiting or avoiding paths to jail in the justice system. A shame, because both relate strongly to side effects or direct outcomes of .. the war on drugs.
- Clubber 9y ago>The high black-market price for illegal drugs has generated huge profits for the groups that produce and sell them, income that is invested in buying state-of-the-art weapons, hiring gangs to defend their trade, paying off public officials and making drugs easily available to children, to get them addicted. Drugs are cheaper now than they every have been. I'd argue it's the lack of regulated competition, leading to a handful of cartels that take the lion's share of the market (and money) that gives them such power. https://www.alternet.org/drugs/price-illegal-drugs-dropping-purity-increasing-and-global-war-drugs-failing https://www.alternet.org/drugs/price-illegal-drugs-dropping-...
- pitaj 9y agoIt's not that the competition is unregulated really. It's more that to enter the market as a supplier you need the resources to fight the government's involved and the other cartels which will happily just murder you instead.
- skydv 9y ago> What, then, can we do? .... Only then can we engage in rigorous and countrywide education campaigns to persuade people not to use drugs.... We still have time to persuade our young people not to ruin their lives. Yeah you should've persuaded Steve Jobs not to use drugs and especially LSD. Then you could also invent iPhone yourself
- danieltillett 9y agoThe thing about the “War on Drugs” is it has never been a real war, more a minor skirmish fought with the equivalent of paintball guns. Not that I am suggesting any of these are good ideas (sometimes the cure is worse than the disease), but if you really wanted to go to war on drugs and win you could do any of the following: 1. Spike the drug supply with a slow acting poison. Lots of poisons to choose from to make this work. 2. Conduct continuous drug testing of the entire population (say once a week) with harsh penalties for failing. 3. Apply a mandatory death penalty for any drug use (especially if combined with 2). 4. Immunise the population to induce anaphylaxis if drugs are consumed (this one is technically possible, but it would need further research). I am not advocating for any of these (far from it), just pointing out that it is meaningless to say you have failed at something that has never been tried. Edit. Rather than clicking the inverted arrow, how about engaging in a discussion.
- askafriend 9y agoThis is a very interesting comment. I had not considered this perspective before and I haven't really heard anyone else use this line of thinking before either - so I appreciate what you wrote. But if you look at a bit of the historical context of the war on drugs, you see that a significant part of it was originally racially motivated. Having a pseudo-war instead of a real war gave the people in control more leverage to selectively target the consequences of banning certain substances like Marijuana or Cocaine.
- danieltillett 9y agoYes the “war on drugs” has been a sideshow of the forever war on the underclass.
- askafriend 9y agoUgh, I wish that weren't the truth.
- Nursie 9y agoIt comes up frequently in such discussions, in my experience. Usually when someone cannot any longer argue that the current war on drugs is anything but a failure, but still feels that drugs need to be driven from society by force. Usually the poster has some pretty abhorrent views about the value of human life and 'druggies'. (Note I am not saying that's the case here, it appears at least on the surface to be a devil's advocate type of argument.) Usually it's a simple call to either poison or execute "them". To which the answer is usually "what the hell gives you the right? These are people we're talking about". The other trope in this direction is someone will suggest drug use centres where people can access all the drugs they want, but they get locked in forever, and can thus take all the drugs they want until they die, hopefully soon. People proposing such things appear to be entirely devoid of either empathy or understanding of drugs and addiction.
- mrarjen 9y agoIn my opinion it's best to legalize drugs to the point where people are educated about it's use. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvRQKXtIGcK1yEnQ4Te8hWQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvRQKXtIGcK1yEnQ4Te8hWQ And when they feel they need help getting off the drugs they can go to any clinic or government point to help them get clean and back on their feet. This has proven quite successful in any country that has done this so far.
- kingmanaz 9y ago"Not prone to ill, nor strange to foreign guest, They eat, they drink, and nature gives the feast The trees around them all their food produce: Lotus the name: divine, nectareous juice! (Thence call'd Lo'ophagi); which whose tastes, Insatiate riots in the sweet repasts, Nor other home, nor other care intends, But quits his house, his country, and his friends. The three we sent, from off the enchanting ground We dragg'd reluctant, and by force we bound. The rest in haste forsook the pleasing shore, Or, the charm tasted, had return'd no more. Now placed in order on their banks, they sweep The sea's smooth face, and cleave the hoary deep: With heavy hearts we labour through the tide, To coasts unknown, and oceans yet untried." Life's a journey. More should face it sober.
- cobbzilla 9y agoFrom a memetic/selection perspective, the war has been phenomenally successful in perpetuating its own existence.
- thomastjeffery 9y ago"Drugs" is not a belligerent. So who is this war "on"? Distributors? Users? Creators? Even these are vague groupings. How can you fight a war if you can't even specify who the enemy is? The short answer: You can't. We have the same issue with "Terror".