11 ms·
2018 Is the Last Year of America's Public Domain Drought
- sharemywin 9y agoDisney now has until 2023 to figure out how to extend that date once again. Enter Steamboat Willy, the first Mickey Mouse cartoon and the first animated short by Walt Disney in 1928. Under the 1909 Copyright scheme, the Mickey Mouse character had copyright protection for 56 years (with the renewal), expiring in 1984.
- msingle 9y agoThe more relevant deadline is for Winnie the Pooh (first published in 1924). Pooh is worth several billion dollars per year to Disney, so don't be surprised if they try to change the copyright (again) in the next year.
- iMerNibor 9y agoWait, does the copyright not just cover the actual movie/videos/art/... of that time, still having them own the character itself (since they're actively using it)?
- maxlybbert 9y agoI believe that officially only the movies, etc., would fall into the public domain. But people can make derivative works of public domain items, so they wouldn’t be limited to literal copies of Steamboat Willie. They could show Steamboat Willie using a smartphone. However, Disney also has trademarks on Mickey Mouse, etc., so using Mickey’s likeness in commercial ways would still be a legal minefield.
- caf 9y agoI would have thought most of that merch would be based on Disney's visual depiction of Pooh dating from 1966.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoWas this angle of Disney’s schenanigans popularly known last time they pulled the stunt?
- steveax 9y agoI don’t remember how widespread this was, but in many circles, the 1998 bill was referred to as Mickey Mouse Protection Act.
- tim333 9y agoI would have thought an ok way of dealing with these things would be after say 30 years to have an $100 annual copyright maintenance fee you have to pay. It'd be no problem for Disney but for 99% of the stuff out there no one would bother.
- joering2 9y agoThe article doesn't go into how Disney was able to preserve it for so long... and continue. So if I copyright something today, can someone explain how I can make sure it is still covered in 2108 ?
- mindcrime 9y agoBribe enough Senators and House Representatives to pass legislation extending the copyright term to suit your needs. Repeat as necessary.
- joering2 9y agoBut this is not funny. Everyone keep saying about bribes, but yet nothing is being done. This is like everyone would know Johny from 2B raped and murdered Marry from 7C, but yet noone is going to do anything about it.
- bighi 9y agoWhat CAN you do? Take a politician down, and a new one takes its place. If you protest, they put the police to attack protesters. If people get together to fund a campaign to change things, big corporations get 10000x more money on a bigger campaign. What do you suggest people do?
- qbrass 9y agoQuit giving Disney money.
- lisper 9y ago1. Make a ton of money 2. Use the proceeds to bribe politicians to pass legislation to extend the copyright period 3. GOTO 1
- JonathonW 9y agoStrictly speaking, Disney's already done most of the hard work for you-- barring some sort of massive public policy reversal (unlikely) or societal collapse (probably slightly less unlikely), all you should have to do (under current copyright law) to keep something protected under US copyright law until 2108 is just not die before 2038. Or, if you published something today as a work for hire, it'd be covered until 2103. Which isn't quite 2108, but surely Disney and their congresscritters will get you that extra five years at some point before it goes into the public domain.
- cornyNetHandle 9y agoHow any new legislation on this issue may play out over the next year, brings to mind the old theological saw regarding an irresistible force meeting an immovable object, given the large political incompatibility of the current players.
- coldtea 9y agoThere's no "large political incompatibility between the current players" when it comes to passing out corporate favorable legislation.
- cornyNetHandle 9y agoYou may have a point there, but Disney and the Trump administration are, at least publicly, on very different sides in the culture wars currently dominating political discourse.
- bighi 9y agoI would say both Disney and Trump have a political view that the best thing for America is making rich people richer at the cost of everyone else. So... same side?
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe culture wars are largely a distraction behind which class war by the rich against everyone else is carried out. Most forces who seems strongly one on side or the other of the culture wars are on the same side of the real war.
- sohkamyung 9y agoI always bring this up whenever copyright extension is mentioned: Spider Robinson's "Melancholy Elephants" [1], a worthwhile read on the effects of a super-long copyright extension. The story itself is under a Creative Commons license. [1] http://spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html http://spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html
- Endy 9y agoI need to read this one - and the Callahan's series.
- eat_veggies 9y agoThat was a really enjoyable read! Thank you for this. Do you have any other recommendations?
- sohkamyung 9y agoNot for stories on copyright. Spider Robinson's story is the only one that has stayed fresh in my mind. If you are interested in general stuff on copyright, you might want to try Cory Doctorow's books [1] which talk about information and copyright or the articles he published on it at Boing Boing [2] [1] http://craphound.com/ http://craphound.com/ [2] https://boingboing.net/tag/copyright https://boingboing.net/tag/copyright
- eat_veggies 9y agoThanks for the links! Do you have any recommendations for short stories and books in general that you find cool? I haven't been reading much and I want to change that.
- sohkamyung 9y agoThere are way too many on-line SF sites for me to recommend. Just pick one. :-) Personally, I'm old-fashioned and get my short-story fix via traditional SF magazines like Interzone (UK) and The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction (USA). If it's hard SF you're looking for, one site that might be worth a look is Compelling Science Fiction [1]. Here's a HN post about it some time ago [2]. P.S. Okay, I'll recommend looking at Locus [3], which covers the SF world. You might be able to get some good recommendations of current SF stuff from there. P.P.S. This is self-advertistment, but I maintain a Goodreads list of books I've read and would like to read [4]. It's mostly on SF and Science / Nature stuff, but if you are interested in that, you may find some interesting stuff on it. [1] http://compellingsciencefiction.com/ http://compellingsciencefiction.com/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13106748 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13106748 [3] http://locusmag.com/ http://locusmag.com/ [4] https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/5876605-kam-yung-soh https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/5876605-kam-yung-soh
- jeremyjh 9y agoSure, let's pretend congress won't do what they are paid to do. We really have no chance on this issue, the interests in seeing works enter public domain simply aren't commercial enough to supply the requisite lobbying dollars.
- ianai 9y agoI’m so glad with how well all of the checks and balances in the constitution against the ruling of the minority over the majority worked /s
- mark_edward 9y agoThe Constitution has no checks against that. The founders had the opposite fear and largely detested popular democracy and the "rule of the mob". It is functioning as designed. Edit: role -> rule
- qubex 9y agoGodel (the logician of Incompleteness Theorems fame) almost failed his citizenship exam (or whatever it is called) for pointing out that there’s almost nothing you can’t do with a 2/3 majority in Congress. Apparently the functionary was on the verge of rejecting his application for having made an accurate observation but some higher power dove in for a last-minute save. http://lsolum.typepad.com/legaltheory/2012/02/guerra-pujol-on-gödels-loophole.html http://lsolum.typepad.com/legaltheory/2012/02/guerra-pujol-o...
- Endy 9y agoWell, then the answer is to stop voting for people willing to take lobbyist money, and for those that were already elected, make a public stink over it.
- WaxProlix 9y agoThis is so naive that it sounds like a joke or a parody.
- ekianjo 9y agoI still don't understand why we can even make legislative changes in copyright work retroactively. Changes should only apply for whatever comes AFTER the changes.
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoThere's a very solid argument. The Constitution explicitly says that Congress has the right to grant copyright "[t]o promote the progress of science and useful arts." Since extending copyright after a thing already exists cannot possibly cause it to exist MORE, it doesn't seem to be within Congress's power. And also, if Congress continues to extend copyrights by 10 years every 10 years, it also is no longer a "limited time." Both of these arguments were put before the Supreme Court in 2003 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eldred_v._Ashcroft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eldred_v._Ashcroft), and the argument lost 7-2. Somewhat unusually, the it was not a party-line decision.
- ekianjo 9y ago> Both of these arguments were put before the Supreme Court in 2003 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eldred_v._Ashcroft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eldred_v._Ashcroft), and the argument lost 7-2. Somewhat unusually, the it was not a party-line decision. Can the Supreme Court be lobbied to act in favor of the uber-rich copyright holders? Are they disclosing their conflicts of interest?
- ralfd 9y agoIt is interesting to read Lessigs view and how he thought he lost the case: http://www.legalaffairs.org/issues/March-April-2004/story_lessig_marapr04.msp http://www.legalaffairs.org/issues/March-April-2004/story_le... ------------------------------- There were two points in this argument when I should have seen where the court was going. The first was a question by Kennedy, who observed, "Well, I suppose implicit in the argument that the '76 act, too, should have been declared void, and that we might leave it alone because of the disruption, is that for all these years the act has impeded progress in science and the useful arts. I just don't see any empirical evidence for that." Here follows my clear mistake. Like a professor correcting a student, I answered, "Justice, we are not making an empirical claim at all. Nothing in our copyright clause claim hangs upon the empirical assertion about impeding progress. Our only argument is, this is a structural limit necessary to assure that what would be an effectively perpetual term not be permitted under the copyright laws." That was a correct answer, but it wasn't the right answer. The right answer was to say that there was an obvious and profound harm. Any number of briefs had been written about it. Kennedy wanted to hear it. And here was where Don Ayer's advice should have mattered. This was a softball; my answer was a swing and a miss.
- mratzloff 9y agoIn my opinion, the best solution for everyone involved is to allow companies to renew copyrights annually into perpetuity after an initial period, but charge a non-trivial renewal fee and increase it with every renewal. If you're a company like Disney, renewing certain properties should really make you think after it starts to cut into the balance sheet. Most works wouldn't generate enough revenue to justify the renewal and would fall into the public domain. Disney wouldn't be holding thousands of unrelated works hostage.
- josho 9y agoInteresting idea. Except Disney would pay tens of millions to keep the original Mickey Mouse out of the public domain. Hell they might even pay much more to guard against weakening their brand. So, While your idea ensures public domain for many works I fear it extends the biggest players their perpetual rights because they can afford it as a result of their scale.
- plorkyeran 9y agoDisney is already paying tens of millions to do that. The proposal is mostly to make them not keep everything else locked away too.
- djsumdog 9y agoYes, in lobbying costs. And their lobbying efforts hurt the rest of the industry. I really think Mickey, Donald and Goofy should be allowed to enter the public domain. Companies need to grow and old things need to be shared in the commons. They'll lose some initial money of course, if everyone could produce Mickey Mouse shirts, but Disney et. al. would have to come up with new tricks, new icons and try to make new things instead of the constant barrage of rehashed garbage media we get today.
- kbenson 9y agoIt's not the shirts that are the problem, it's a massive I Flux of random Mickey Mouse media that would saturate the market and dilute the media. Do any of us really doubt that there would be a bunch of Mickey Mouse porn? I'm not in favor of long copyrights, but I think in the case there would be a real cultural loss if there was unfettered access to this particular icon. Does that justify full control by Disney at this late stage? Probably not, but some middle ground with increasing costs (maybe an increasing percentage of profit from that brand?) might be worth trying. The whole system is pretty messed up at this point, so why not test out some interesting ideas? As a side benefit, maybe Disney and others like them won't fight it quite so hard, as it would be costly but not the existential threat to their core brand they see come up every couple evades.
- Mountain_Skies 9y agoA few years ago I wanted to read Virginia Woolf's novel "To The Lighthouse" so I searched for it online and discovered it was public domain in her native Great Britain but still under copyright here in the United States. If I downloaded it from an UK server, would I and/or the owner of the UK server be in violation of copyright? If I bought a reprint in the UK that was printed after it entered public domain, would it be legal for me to carry the book back home? What about having it mailed? Is it realistic to expect the average reader to understand all of these details of various copyright laws across the globe especially in an age where data flows so easily and it isn't even obvious where from?
- djsumdog 9y agoAs the person buying the work, you'd think you wouldn't face potential criminal charges; that this would be a civil case where the copyright holder would have to sue the distributor. However we're seeing copyright cases play out criminally now, with Kim Dotcom fighting his extradition from New Zealand.
- njharman 9y agoCopyright violation is a crime. Has been since the right to monopolize the public domain was enshrined in law (before copyright, there was only the public domain). It can also be a civil matter. But the JAIL time and $500,000 per infraction are criminal penalties.
- tim333 9y agoWith a lot of these grey areas it's not really specified in the original laws and you have to look at court cases for legal precedent for how that kind of stuff has gone in the past. I think downloading from a UK server you would be in violation of US copyright law and in principle whoever inherited Woolf's copyright could sue. Also there are customs restrictions on bringing in fake copyright stuff that are sometimes used for fake Rolexes and the like. In practice no one would bother sueing over one copy of a novel.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- darepublic 9y agoWhen is mickey mouse due to enter Public Domain?
- naravara 9y agoMickey is trademarked. Old Mickey Mouse movies, like Steamboat Willie, will be free to copy and distribute but I don’t think other people will be permitted to produce new works starting Mickey Mouse. It’s a bit of a legal gray area. I don’t think anyone has settled the question about whether trademarking characters runs afoul of the constitutional prohibition on perpetual copyright. Based on how much money Disney has put into absorbing every trademarked franchise ever (Marvel, Star Wars, etc.), it seems like they’re willing to bet on those trademarks being enforceable.
- darepublic 9y agoAh ok. Does international law vary on this? Can Disney sue IP violators in other countries over this and who would enforce it
- sohkamyung 9y agoYes, they can and they have. You can search for articles on Disney suing people in places like China for selling or featuring images of Mickey Mouse (or lookalikes). A perverse effect (I think) of trademarks is that the owner of a trademark has to sue to protect it from infringement: otherwise, it becomes a common mark, not a trademark, and is usable by anybody.
- sohkamyung 9y agoSherlock Holmes is also a grey area. My understanding is that the original Sherlock Holmes stories written by Conan Doyle are public domain, but not Holmes material written at a later date [1] - "“Sherlock Holmes” Is Now Officially Off Copyright and Open for Business" [ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/sherlock-holmes-now-officially-copyright-and-open-business-180951794/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/sherlock-holmes-no... ]
- shmerl 9y ago95 years after publication is crazy. Copyright term should have never been that long.
- rabidrat 9y agoOriginally it was 14 years. It's only been extended (gradually) over the past 50 or so.
- njharman 9y agoIt's been extended, regularly, several times. The recent 1976, 1998 have extended it massively (doubling it) and applying their extensions, retroactively much further back. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Tom_Bell%27s_graph_showing_extension_of_U.S._copyright_term_over_time.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Tom_Bell%27s_graph_showin...
- ataturk 9y agoThe 1998 one was particularly egregious--we were right on the verge of having some decent content in the public domain and wham! It's not that I think everything should be public domain, but the current duration is absurd.
- solomatov 9y agoIANAL, but as far as I understand the law this is incorrect: > Films are literally disintegrating because preservationists can’t legally digitize them This is fair use. archive.org works on legality of such activity.
- lostapathy 9y agoSure, but the economics of preserving something you can’t redistribute are tough, especially as you get out into less popular media. If you could sell copies of those preserved works, it would provide a means to finance the preservation efforts.
- cooper12 9y agoFair use is not a get-out-of-jail-free card. Financers and their lawyers will be loath to touch anything which does not have a clear rights status, and the concept of fair use is murky and can only be proven once a judge has ruled as such, so most companies will just not take the risk. For a real-life example posted here recently, a scholar on Shel Silverstein's work was forbidden by his estate to quote anything of his. [0] > it forbade me not only from reproducing images for this one article, but from ever reproducing any of Silverstein’s work—song lyrics, poems, images, whatever—in any context. Ever. This is what he had to say on how fair use played into the situation: > You may have heard of something called “fair use.” One would think fair use was custom built to protect scholars and artists who want or need to reproduce excerpts from copyrighted work in the service of education or art or scholarship—and one would be right. But whether we’re protected or not, most presses prefer to play it safe and make scholars request permission. These institutions that preserve films also have donors and institutions they are beholden to for funding. Claiming fair use won't protect you from a massive and costly court case from a Hollywood juggernaut's top lawyers. Film studios especially have an incentive to litigate against work like this because a lot of their back catalog has become relevant and profitable to re-release since people have gotten into classic films and the associated works. [0]: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/books/2013/10/my_shel_silverstein_biography_can_t_quote_shel_silverstein_why.html http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/books/2013/10/my_shel_sil...
- sixdimensional 9y agoI still wonder how much faster parts of the world who do not honor the traditional IP laws can innovate? Not that I'm encouraging ignorance of IP laws, just curious about what happens differently in their absence... how does the system work then?
- djf1 9y agoIgnorance of IP laws would help the developing economy, while hurting the developed economy. Copying is cheap, original invention is expensive, and developed countries have more to lose. In a somewhat relevant WTO dispute between US and China, "The International Intellectual Property Alliance, a coalition of U.S. entertainment and software industry groups, has claimed piracy in China costs them more than $3.7 billion in lost sales." [1] [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-usa-wto/china-u-s-trade-barbs-over-wto-piracy-case-idUSTRE52J3T920090320 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-usa-wto/china-u-s-t...
- bighi 9y agoWhile I'm not saying that is a lie, anyone can claim anything. I can claim piracy in China costs me 18 billion dollars.
- vorotato 9y agoAlso I think it's an absurd argument that just because someone pirated your content that they would necessarily buy it. A lot of content is pirated specifically because they think it's not worth buying.
- Testudio 9y agoYou know why patents and drugs have short terms, but copyright is very long? Because the thing it is protecting is a luxury. It is unnecessary. No one will die if Mickey Mouse remains copyrighted in perpetuity, and the progress of humanity won't be stunned because you can't make youtube clips out of Winnie the Pooh. You can just stop buying Disney merchandise if you don't like them. There is more public domain art than you can consume in a hundred years. Disney will stop lobing for copyright extensions once it no longer profitable. Oh, and stop using Facebook while you are at it.
- Asooka 9y agoThe concept of "Public Domain" sounds absolutely bonkers to me. You own something and then suddenly you no longer own it. It would be like if you woke up one day to see a family of squatters living in your house, that you can't get rid of, because the person who built your house died 70 years ago and your house is now "Public Domain". We should just get rid of the public domain exception and recognise intellectual property as normal everyday property, not something that can magically becomes ownerless one day. Communism has been tried and it doesn't work. Let's not repeat the mistakes of the past. On the other hand, I do hear the plight of preservationists &c. There should be a lot more rights granted to people to use copies of other people's property. For starters, all non-commercial use should be allowed, so that old movies could be digitised and stored in better formats. After all, the studio doesn't own the tape or the DVD that contains the movie, it owns the movie itself and the type of media it's stored on shouldn't matter. This probably would also mean that noncommercial free peer-to-peer filesharing would also be legal, but honestly, if you can't compete with torrent sites, which blast thirty porn popups and show you a dozen false download links, your business probably deserves to die.
- Can_Not 9y ago> It would be like if you woke up one day to see a family of squatters living in your house, that you can't get rid of, because the person who built your house died 70 years ago and your house is now "Public Domain". It wouldn't be like that.
- bighi 9y ago> sounds absolutely bonkers to me. You own something and then suddenly you no longer own it. The fact that companies can own IDEAS don't sound bonkers to you? We should begin the conversation at that, not at the fact that the owning of ideas expires after some time. > It would be like if you woke up one day to see a family of squatters living in your house It's definitely nothing like that. A proper analogy would be saying you woke up one day to see someone else has the permission to copy (and sell copies of) your house. While you might not like it, it doesn't take away things you already have.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoNot having the public domain is what is bonkers. Can you imagine if Shakespeare was prevented from writing Romeo and Juliet because of the copyright on Luigi da Porta's Romeo and Giuletta or if he couldn't write The Merchant of Venice because of the copyright on Il Pecorone? That is the world that our copyright laws are now creating.
- ataturk 9y agoThe copyright mess is another example of how corporations have sucked the life out of America. Disney (and others) lobbying for that law is perhaps the definitive example of regulatory capture and how it has an affect on all of us. It makes citizens cynical, breeds distrust in our (wholly bought) government, and it illustrates how tyranny can arrive from any direction, not just the expected ones.
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago2018 is the last year of the drought... unless the rules change again. Here's how it's likely to happen. Somebody will float a trial balloon to extend copyright. We will try to oppose it. Because it's an election year, our opposition will have some leverage - the threat of immediate retaliation on those who don't vote the way we want. If our opposition is loud enough, the bill will stall... ... until after the election. Then it will pass, despite the howls of outrage, because then we'd have to remember who betrayed us for two years before we can do anything about it, and they suspect that our memories aren't that long. (And if our memories are that long, we'll have two years of other issues to dilute our outrage on this one.) I hope I'm too cynical.
- whiddershins 9y agoOne thing I’ve never understood about the whole Disney/Mickey Mouse discussion is Trademark doesn't expire. If Disney can hold a trademark on Mickey Mouse, all the old movies could enter the public domain but you still wouldn’t have a right to make your own Mickey Mouse movies or t-shirts. So it seems what they are really trying to protect is Fantasia or whatever. Specific movies. Not iconic characters.
- regulation_d 9y agoI think we're losing sight of the goals of intellectual property law. Society as a whole benefits greatly from a rich public domain. The starting point in IP law is that there are no rights in ideas. Then from that starting point, we start to carve out exceptions that make sense from a market perspective. We grant trademarks, because the market benefits from being able to identify the source of a thing. We grant patents and copyright protection, because they incent innovation, and innovation is good for the market. The protections that copyright law affords have more than rewarded Walt Disney for his innovations. The Constitution specifically requires that copyright protection be limited in term. In my mind, the time has come for Mickey to drop into the public domain.
- vorotato 9y agoIf you can't survive after 20 years without any competition, perhaps you don't deserve the copyright in the first place.