7 ms·
The Robots Are Coming and Sweden Is Fine
- mnm1 9y agoWhat I get out of articles like this is that economic policy can easily fix the loss of jobs due to automation, but we will likely never see such policy in the US. In other words, job loss due to automation is a problem caused almost exclusively by the political system in which automation happens, not with the automation itself. Societies that make the right political decisions to accommodate for automation, like Sweden, have an advantage over societies that don't, like the US. Outside of jobs, this is obvious from comparing the different societies' approaches to education, parenting, and other social necessities, IMO.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThis really depends on what you consider to be an advantage. The US already has a massive advantage when it comes to industrial power and economic output. For those in power, does anything else really matter to them?
- mnm1 9y ago"For those in power, does anything else really matter to them?" Probably not, but I'm concerned about society as a whole, not a few hundred or thousand rich people. They'd be fine anywhere in the world. I'm talking about advantages for regular people who want to make something of their lives and don't have millions or billions in the bank. For these regular people, industrial power and economic output doesn't mean shit when they can't get health insurance, education, or jobs. Industrial power and economic output are irrelevant when you're bankrupt because of medical bills which you can't pay because you don't have a decent job since a bachelor's degree costs more than a lot of houses and education below high school level is almost nonexistent.
- whathaschanged 9y agoSweden is 'fine' and yet has to raise the retirement age to cover all the drain on their societal services? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.thelocal.se/20171214/what-swedens-new-retirement-age-means-for-you/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.thelocal.se/20171214/what-s... Please.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWith life expectation rising this seems a reasonable thing to do. How else do you want to deal with this?
- toomuchtodo 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoOk. Now go ahead and implement it. Sounds like a brilliant idea nobody has thought of. Here is a related cartoon: http://dilbert.com/strip/1994-12-17 http://dilbert.com/strip/1994-12-17
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whathaschanged 9y agoStop allowing a flood on migrants for no reason other than a feel good policy. Social safety nets exist for the populace that contributes over time, not for new fully grown males to suddenly appear with or without families expecting benefits they and their predecessors never contributed to. Down votes show HNs continued ignorance to actual world situations.
- 9y ago
- MollyR 9y agoThe title should be "Fine for Now". Maintaining Sweden’s social safety net also requires that the public continue to pay tax rates approaching 60 percent for their current amount of displacement. If automation starts to displace a huge number of people, and there is no job to transition, the social contract will break. I'm really hoping we hit a star trek style utopia (especially in terms of energy and food) before we get close to social contract breakage. I fear we won't though, we already seeing severe signs of the social contract breaking in the United States.
- hydrox24 9y ago> star trek style utopia Utopia and dystopia may be a fine line, but I like the theory that Star Trek is a dystopic, culturally desolate future. [0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1Kju_-1sYM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1Kju_-1sYM
- johnchristopher 9y agoI am in a ds9/voy binge watching and I agree the federeation isn't the utopia as it's often mentionned but the arguments in the video are pretty weak (and uninformed).
- maxxxxx 9y agoSeems this is an experiment in the direction of UBI.
- Dylan16807 9y ago> If automation starts to displace a huge number of people, and there is no job to transition, the social contract will break. Break because of what? If a job is stupendously productive because of automation, it can support stupendously high taxes too.
- MollyR 9y agoOnly if the people pay, it sounded like the one of Swedish economists from the article think there is a limit to what you can tax people before the social contract breaks. I'm assuming this applies to individuals and populations.
- Feniks 9y agoDifference between Northern Europe and the US: we minimised low wage work long ago with automation. As a business you want to AVOID employing people at all costs. The drive for efficiency and productivity is relentless. As for manufacturing: yeah most of that already left for China/Asia in the 70s and 80s. And what remains is already computerised and done by robots.
- pimmen 9y agoIf by "we" you mean the US, you're very wrong. Sweden has one of the lowest rates of "simple jobs" in the OECD, the demands for education and training to enter the Swedish work force are the highest in the EU. Again, if you mean the US. If you meant Sweden, yep, what you said is very true, Swedish industry has a very long history of automation. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/tsdec430 http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/tsdec43...
- celim307 9y agoBruh...he was obviously speaking about Sweden
- vadimberman 9y agoDoes "automation" mean immigrants?
- grzm 9y ago> "Does "automation" mean immigrants?" > "we minimised low wage work long ago with automation. As a business you want to AVOID employing people at all costs."
- vadimberman 9y agoYeah, I read that. It's a nice theory, I am asking about the practice. Given the abundance of low-skilled workforce, I have my doubts.
- SapphireSun 9y agohttp://www.epi.org/publication/robots-or-automation-are-not-the-problem-too-little-worker-power-is/ http://www.epi.org/publication/robots-or-automation-are-not-... "Robots, or automation, are not the problem. Too little worker power is."
- textor 9y agoIronically, the article doesn't really discuss any legitimate reason as to why Sweden is – or indeed will be – fine despite automation. It's all about what Swedes expect and how much they trust their present society to hold. Also, labor union propaganda, but that's tangential. So, the takeaway is that Americans believe business to be cutthroat and competition to be effective at weeding out the least optimized actors, whereas Swedes feel that employers will take care of employees because this is a nice Sweden thing to do, or something. Beliefs, expectations, feelings, self-affirmations. «Everything is fine, we can provide everyone with jobs, we can even support a large and growing number of uneducated refugees and help them get jobs, we just need to innovate faster than anyone to be sure that our market share won't ever diminish, it'll all work out in the end". Well. Guess it's pleasant to be so positive. But how is any of this even relevant to the issue? The issue being, mind you, automation-induced joblessness, not people's anxiety about it.
- WhoBeI 9y agoIf people aren't scared of automation there won't be any political pressure to restrict automation. This will probably increase the adoptation rate so I'd say it matters a lot in the discussion. There will be problems because of automation and I think most Swedes realize this. The safety nets that are in place provide a buffer, and possible solutions, if you should loose your job because of it. I'd say that's where the optimistic attitude in this article comes from. Sustaining those safety nets is indeed going to be hard if unemployment increases. There probably won't be any "silver bullet" solution to the problem either. [edit] spelling
- juicyfroot 9y agoSweden is rape capital of the world now. Hope they enjoy the fruits of their socialism
- ddmma 9y agoDid some HMI before or troubleshooting offshore oil rigs in the North Sea, I can confirm that it is also possible to remotly have fully drilling operations from the shore. This example is perfect for what a working symbiosis man / machine, not tehnology is the problem but value of human labour costs and machine investments. In Scandinavia this is not only fine but normal.