8 ms·
As Cell Service Expands, National Parks Become Digital Battlegrounds
- esaym 9y agoWe need to have places where there is no cell coverage. We just have to have that. The alternative is a world where we never can get away, ever.
- graton 9y agoThere is a place in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio_Quiet_Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio_Q...
- CapitalistCartr 9y ago"When a place gets crowded enough to require ID’s, social collapse is not far away. It is time to go elsewhere. The best thing about space travel is that it made it possible to go elsewhere." --Lazarus Long
- colek42 9y agoYou can always leave your phone at home, or put it in airplane mode.
- khedoros1 9y agoCan I please leave everyone else's phone at home too?
- hellbanner 9y agoIf you jam, but that's illegal.
- mikeash 9y agoThere's no chance of that happening long term. We already live in a world where there is no place where without data coverage if you pay for fancy equipment and service. Global coverage for cell phones is just a matter of time.
- teeray 9y agoWhere I am in the northeast right now, it's about -15°F. There are roads passing through unpopulated areas of National Forest that have no cell service. If you break down along these roads and no one drives by to help, what in warmer climates would be just an unfortunate inconvenience would leave you frozen to death by dawn. We shouldn't compromise safety because we lack the self control to turn on Do Not Disturb mode.
- ghaff 9y agoThere are satellite systems if you care enough to get one.
- Casseres 9y agoSounds like an EPIRB for the car would be a good investment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_position-indicating_radiobeacon_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_position-indicating_...
- zkms 9y agoLetting mobile operators build LTE base stations is a far better one; expecting people to buy/carry/test 406MHz beacons (as opposed to a cell phone, which they test by virtue of regularly using it) to call for a tow truck is folly. NIMBY objections to operators installing base stations really shouldn't override people's ability to summon appropriate (a car breaking down in extremely cold weather doesn't need a full-on SAR response, but it does need a response) emergency services. Also if someone is using their phone in a national park, you can always walk the hell away from them; your laziness doesn't entitle you to prevent the buildout of cell service that can save lives.
- Casseres 9y ago> you can always walk the hell away from them; your laziness doesn't entitle you Someone said they had a remote, dangerous drive, and all I did was offer a suggestion to help their safety. When I went backpacking alone in Yellowstone, I carried a PLB. When I sweated buckets working in the engine rooms on ships at sea, we had EPIRBs. I'm not going to retract my statement about investing in an EPIRB/PLB - a life-saving device. I don't see how my previous comment indicated any opinion on my part about the proliferation of cellular coverage. Getting angry at me was uncalled-for.
- tomjen3 9y agoYou can leave your phone at home. However like everyone else you will also have to learn that you don't get to dictate what other people do.
- andrewflnr 9y agoThis is hyperbolic. Turn off your phone, or wrap it in foil, or get rid of it. There's a discussion to be had about phones that don't actually turn off, but it's a much less dramatic one.
- chrismcb 9y agoGet away from what? Nothing says you have to take a phone with you. And there are still a lot of places where there aren't many other people.
- chiph 9y agoThe last thing I want to hear when hiking in a park is someone else's phone ringtone, much less the conversation afterwards. But the point about needing communications for rescue is a good one. Perhaps there could be lockers at the park entrance where you swap your phone for a PLB. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_position-indicating_radiobeacon_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_position-indicating_...
- mehrdadn 9y ago> First responders support the plans Why can't they just put towers that allow emergency calls only?
- anderiv 9y agoThe ROI on that seems pretty bleak from a business perspective. Without paying customers’ usage to bankroll the buildout, I find it highly doubtful that any carrier would agree to emergency-use only stations.
- lucaspiller 9y agoWhen you make an emergency call on a GSM network it specifially uses the tower which provides the best signal, which may be on a different carrier. In most countries you don’t even need a SIM card to make an emergency call. My point is there is no technical reason why the emergency sevices couldn’t put up towers for 911 calls only.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI think the argument is that it's not economical to set up towers only for emergencies. Technically no problem.
- tinymollusk 9y agoI wonder if S&R planes are equipped with a device that can simulate a cell tower. If/when it detects the lost party's phone, it can provide a search radius and potential comms channel (depending on signal strength). Basically a Stingray device for geolocation purposes instead of surveillance.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat requires an S&R plane to actually be in the air. That is usually not the case when somebody has a problem. I have a GPS beacon that sends a distress signal to a satellite which then may a cause a plane to get in the air.
- steveax 9y ago“Industrial Tourism is a threat to the national parks. But the chief victims of the system are the motorized tourists. They are being robbed and robbing themselves. So long as they are unwilling to crawl out of their cars they will not discover the treasures of the national parks and will never escape the stress and turmoil of those urban-suburban complexes which they had hoped, presumably, to leave behind for a while.” ― Edward Abbey, Desert Solitaire: A Season in the Wilderness
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI support more towers but agree there should be limitations. If they were private towers, requiring people to pay a fee to the park for data, then that would cut down on use. However all emergency traffic is free. Might also help in geolocating or triangulation of people who are lost.
- Dowwie 9y agoHiking and backpacking is my time to unplug and tune into nature. I bring my smart phone with me but only use it for photos. If cell phone reception were available, I still wouldn't use it. I've hiked all over North America in front and back country. The people who hike beyond the first half mile of trail aren't the type to ruin their time outdoors with cell phones. I suspect the Telecom providers are lobbying for this. The language really screams special interest:. "advocates for increased cell service, including many NPS officials, say the parks can’t cling to an earlier era" Who the hell are these Advocates, other than Telecom providers, their lobbyists, and Alphabet? Also, no one in the NPS is advocating cell phone reception. They've gotten on just fine without it. They are afraid of being fired by the Trump stasi for speaking truthfully, though.
- WhitneyLand 9y ago>If cell phone reception were available, I still wouldn't use it. Yes you would - if it were a matter of saving someone’s life. I agree with you about unplugging to the point I don’t want to see anyone out there if I can help it, but there’s there are a lot of interests to balance here.
- Dowwie 9y agoYou don't extend cell phone coverage across millions of acres of protected national park space for edge cases like "saving someone's life". How many deaths in National Parks in the last 10 years can be attributed to lack of cell phone coverage? You've just made up a non-issue. There aren't, as you say, a lot of interests to balance in this case. Your argument is like that used by the State about exercising its massive surveillance project for the sake of catching child molesters. Sure, some good will be made but at great cost and for primary motives other than those brought to light.
- WhitneyLand 9y agoThe point is, you misspoke, you would use it. By other factors I mean I prefer to judge it based on the impact rather than the concept. What would it mean to the environment, the beauty, the silence, the safety however insignificant you want to make it. For you it seems to be an issue of principle, for me it’s matter of what would be the real and practical effects. If it’s as bad as you’re suggesting I’d be against it, but not for spiritual reasons.
- djflutt3rshy 9y agoI realize I'm an edge case, but as someone who loves both hiking and location-based games (Ingress! Pokemon Go! Geocaching!) this would be awesome! No more having to download a ton of offline maps on my phone, and all those National/State park portals are no longer inaccessible :)
- EdwardDiego 9y agoIn the national park in NZ where I have done most of my tramping, there is limited cell reception around the main village in the park (population 38), and the mountains surrounding this village are where 90% of overseas visitors experience the park - and get into trouble. The introduction of that cell coverage, limited to the one valley as it is, dramatically decreased the amount of search and rescue call-outs with helicopters etc., often people can be guided off the mountain by phone. I miss the wilderness aspect in that area - getting texted an hour above the bushline is weird, but luckily I have plenty of other valleys to choose from. So yeah, limit it to the rescue hotspots, I reckon.
- WhitneyLand 9y agoDensity of visitors and their respect for the resources, seem more important that whether or not cellular exists (leaving aside visual impact since it was not described). Lots of voice call pollution can only come from lots of people. Besides what’s the point when within a few years, multiple next gen satellite systems will be up that make that avenue a lot more practical than it is today. Regulate traffic, visual and environmental impact, noise pollution, whatever. If all of that is done right what’s the benefit of cutting off what will actually save a few lives over the years?
- nradov 9y agoIn the long run someone will eventually succeed in building out a low-cost satellite communications service. At that point any objections to cellular service in national parks will become mostly moot. SpaceX is making plans to deploy a constellation to compete with Iridium. They might not succeed right away but launch costs are dropping every year.
- greglindahl 9y agoOneWeb and SpaceX are both planning pizza-box sized antennae.
- chrismcb 9y agoI don't get it... So you might be hiking and overhear a conversation? Does it matter if that conversation is between two other hikers or a hiker on a phone? The outdoors might sound like McDonald's? Other than the signs of the kitchen I've never thought of McDonald's as noisy places. Most people are eating and chatting with their meal mates. I guess I don't find a phone much different than noiser than two people chatting. As far a ringtones go, how often do you hear them. Go to a city park... How many ringtones do you hear? This is such a non issue.