9 ms·
AI-assisted fake porn are being used by people on Reddit for self-completion
- blunte 9y agoOn the flipside, this gives anyone basic plausible deniability. No baby, that homemade porn video on my phone wasn't me! I just used a program to stick my face on something I found on the internet.
- onion2k 9y agoPlausible deniability doesn't really work in real life though. Very few people are going to give you, or anyone accused of an indiscretion, the benefit of the doubt on the basis that a video might have been faked with AI. That is much less plausible than someone cheating and getting caught. If you think anyone is going to accept that a video is fake, even if it is, then you're woefully naive.
- LV-426 9y agoAs someone with a generally cynical/pessimistic outlook I too, like blunte, want to see something positive in this. Hopefully, since it can't be stopped, it becomes so routinely used against so many people that everyone stops caring any more if it's real or fake. It's sad that our attitudes (if not behaviour) towards sex are still so fucked up and judgemental thanks to thousands of years of religious/Victorian/puritanical brainwashing and guilt-tripping.
- andrepd 9y agoWestern sexual revolution can be said to have happened little more than 50 years ago. Culture takes a lot of time to revert.
- DennisP 9y agoThat's true right now because video fakes are new and rare. Photoshop fakes have been around for years, and now when there's an apparent nude photo of someone famous, people generally assume it's fake unless there's a particular reason to believe it's real, such as a publicized hack. On the other hand, video of an intimate partner may have enough behavioral cues so fakes aren't much of an issue, unless the attacker has started with video surveillance of the target.
- dboreham 9y agoThere’s an episode of Downton Abbey where it goes the other way.
- Izkata 9y agoDoubt could be made if you kept a video of yourself with Arnold Schwarzenegger's body in the same place as that video.
- bambax 9y agoYes, exactly. > It isn’t difficult to imagine an amateur programmer running their own algorithm to create a sex tape of someone they want to harass. If it's trivial to fake a porn video with anyone's face on it, then the burden of proof is on the harasser to demonstrate how this one's real. Or you can take said video and put some famous people's face on it as a response. Also, the source video probably existed before and was more or less publicly available, which is proof that the version with your face is the fake one. (And if you're facing an enemy that has enough ressources to shoot a specially-made porn video just to smite you, you have bigger problems to worry about).
- alsetmusic 9y ago> (And if you're facing an enemy that has enough ressources to shoot a specially-made porn video just to smite you, you have bigger problems to worry about). While there may be a barrier to applying the technology after the fact, shooting a homemade video is something that can be accomplished by anyone with a modern smart phone. In fact, if you want your fake porn to look authentic (for purposes of blackmail or otherwise), this is how you would do it. Then it could be claimed that it was self shot and leaked to the internet via a cloud “hack” or similar.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIn the scenario posited, it would depend a lot on a) the character and reputation of the denier and b) the gullibility of the person being lied to. Of course, people who would both make such a video and also lie to their SO about it tend to seek out gullible easy marks who buy their BS. But sometimes such people get wise to it at some point.
- akerro 9y ago> On the flipside, this gives anyone basic plausible deniability. It's enough to say publicly "X molested me 20years ago" to destroy a person. No proof or witness needed.
- nailer 9y agocelebfakes is the next Reddit hand grenade: the site has 'involuntary porn' as a category for reporting posts, yet simultaneously has a popular subreddit dedicated to involuntary porn.
- Mountain_Skies 9y agoConsistency has never been one of Reddit's management strengths. They seem to have embraced the reactionary model of moderating the site.
- exo762 9y agoSame goes for Youtube - during "ElsaGate" scandal one of the banned channels was in top100 site-wide. I.e. youtube knew, but they didn't cared until their PR took a hit.
- prepend 9y agoSince Reddit admins have no natural morality that they have displayed, they will wait until more press gets launched with bad PR for the site. Then they will selectively respond based on what their loudest commenters say. It seems like they could establish some basic moral rules they prefer and then objectively apply them. But they choose not to for some reason.
- FeepingCreature 9y agoFor what it's worth, I vastly prefer my admins amoral. Morality is diverse enough that for almost any moral framework, they'd be doing things I'd strongly disagree with.
- superkuh 9y agoCitation needed? What subreddits? If you mean the tiny deepfakes subreddit I don't think anything there is involuntary. In case it isn't clear, this isn't leaked videos or celebrities doing actual porn. It's synthetic renders similar to their faces based on publically available material. The celebrities aren't actually involved in any way. It isn't even really photos of them. It's an abstract model. But surely you understood that? And in that case I don't get what you're saying.
- akerro 9y agoSource code: https://github.com/joshua-wu/deepfakes_faceswap https://github.com/joshua-wu/deepfakes_faceswap NSFW posts https://www.reddit.com/user/deepfakes/submitted/ https://www.reddit.com/user/deepfakes/submitted/ (includes porn)
- CapacitorSet 9y agoQuick preview: u/deepfakes, https://www.gfycat.com/UnsungTotalAmericancrow https://www.gfycat.com/UnsungTotalAmericancrow (NSFW). Very cool, it has a few problems with merging the face but the expression is very convincing. Obviously, it doesn't work very well for very different faces (https://imgur.com/gallery/OpD3RXC https://imgur.com/gallery/OpD3RXC SFW).
- akerro 9y agoThis one is much better https://www.reddit.com/user/tensorfakes/posts/ https://www.reddit.com/user/tensorfakes/posts/ (NSFW porn of course)
- paul7986 9y agoThe girl/guy sex vid... has her face been superimposed? If so is that a celebrities face?
- NelsonMinar 9y agoIt's funny you pick this as an example; the very first thing I see is the cut line on her eyebrows, like some hideous plastic surgery gone wrong. Skin tone doesn't really match either. Perhaps this stuff is less visible if you're distracted by the rest of the scene.
- CapacitorSet 9y ago
- djhworld 9y agoOutside of porn, I'm wondering if this could be used in other ways, e.g. government propaganda. Putting leaders in situations that make them look good or putting their opponents in compromising situations.
- akerro 9y agoIt not only can be, but it was https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ApG1XdI-Dd4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ApG1XdI-Dd4 there were a few months when JA didn't give any sign and people on /r/wikileaks started asking if he's still alive, then this video was posted. It's fake.
- jstanley 9y agoThat's fascinating! There was also a livestream in which he supposedly gave a "proof of life" by reading out a bitcoin block hash, among other things. Do you think that one was faked too?
- neuralk 9y agoNo, that video is real. Those are morph cuts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6wPUtKg-Ac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6wPUtKg-Ac
- squarefoot 9y agoIt could also be used as a convincing tool to dismiss any proof, even legit ones, as fabricated. More or less the equivalent of "Your honor, that picture (of a cop shooting an unarmed civilian) is clearly photoshopped!". I'm excited about the technology though concerned about possible abuses.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIn the U.S, cops are allowed to shoot unarmed civilians, entirely at their discretion. We consider it a privilege of the position, bestowed in exchange for the risk they face. Video doesn’t affect the verdicts even when it is admitted.
- 9y ago
- omeid2 9y agoFor the New Year's day, Hacker News gives you porn links.
- Pica_soO 9y agoYou should check-out Ghandi doing Margreth Thatcher- it has something poetic.
- asdfologist 9y agoWhat does self-completion mean?
- arthurcolle 9y agoPop goes the weasel, friendo
- loooooooooooool 9y agoMasturbation?
- gaius 9y agoWhat does self-completion mean? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs
- naner 9y agoExtrapolating this means companies like Facebook, Apple, Google, and Amazon in the near future should have the technology and the data to be able to recreate almost anyone's voice and likeness in audio and video. Also I guess fake news will be much more if a problem.
- Odenwaelder 9y agoWTF did I just read?
- mabbo 9y agoThis is what's being accomplished by one amateur with a little bit of hardware. Imagine what will happen when you have professional services (legal or otherwise) making altered videos of whoever or whatever you want. Want court evidence of your wife cheating? Fake grainy hidden camera video. Want to discredit a politician? Here he is picking up a male escort and using racial slurs. These sorts of things could be used to start wars. Sure, deeper analysis might prove that this video isn't real, but that won't stop the immediate public reaction and response. The knee-jerk reaction to what the public sees is the end-goal. I'll bet good money that this technology plays a major role in future elections.
- digi_owl 9y ago> Want to discredit a politician? Here he is picking up a male escort and using racial slurs. Worked so well in a recent election... > These sorts of things could be used to start wars. Wars have been started on much flimsier pretexts, unless you are talking about getting the other side so irate that they fire first.
- beisner 9y agoI think we’ll probably have to move to a model where any security footage or images that is used in court must be digitally signed at the hardware level, with a verification process similar to how CAs work now. Of course, this will still be tamperable, but tampering would have to be much more premeditated and sophisticated.
- omeid2 9y agoThe privacy implications of that would be scary. It seems on par with North Korea's Red Star Watermarking which has been dubbed as "dictator’s wet dream". https://qz.com/583311/north-koreas-dissident-tracking-computer-software-is-a-dictators-wet-dream/ https://qz.com/583311/north-koreas-dissident-tracking-comput...
- throwaway2048 9y agothat is absolutely never going to be workable because you can just film another video being played back.
- jamix 9y agoWhat's the big deal? Photoshop has already taught us not to trust photos, so we'll just have to learn to stop trusting videos now. https://singularityhub.com/2016/05/13/new-digital-face-manipulation-means-you-cant-trust-video-anymore/ https://singularityhub.com/2016/05/13/new-digital-face-manip...
- christofosho 9y agoI wonder if this will lead to a trend of people going to see events live, more often. Given that seeing something occur live is going to end up as the only "real way" to trust something to be true. Scary to think that reality has become questionable in itself.
- cryoshon 9y agothe larger issue is that if it's this easy to create fake photorealism, video evidence is no longer valid. not from the government. not from amateur videographers. not even from a video you took yourself-- think of it from everyone else's perspective. but people believe their eyes. we are witnessing the capstone of the national security state's propaganda strategy for the next few decades... when in doubt, construct a false reality.
- apo 9y agoThe story here isn't porn. It's that we can no longer trust video evidence - of anything - in isolation.
- yupyup 9y agoHaving just watched season 4 of Black Mirror I jump to Hack News and find this. I have found the subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/deepfakes/ https://www.reddit.com/r/deepfakes/ (quite NSFW) and I'm somewhat conflicted by it. People are using this porn as an entry to learn about Deep Learning, but I find it disgusting using the faces of other people fot this without their consent. At least it seems like the male drive for masturbation can be used for learning about new tech... :-/ EDIT: Added this gold nugget from /r/deepfakes "well you will be amazed..on sunday i had never touched Python..not even heard of python..lol..saw gal gadot video..came here..Followed Every single Requirements..First i had no clue..it took me 4 days to completely install All the requirements of this project... i have Python 3.5+opencv+tensorflow(Gpu Version which was pain in the ass but i had it installed after several tries) Then finally keras 2..which is Backened Using tensorflow....i have verified all the packages VIA import..All is well now..tired now..Tomorrow ...my 2nd goal would be..."That first post" of Deepfakes which is 300mb or something..haven't used any scripts before...Learning is a game..lets see how i end up"
- okman 9y agoThe deepfakes subreddit is remarkable - people without any prior background in machine learning or programming are asking tons of questions and learning all about deep learning. I've always thought applications-first was the best way to teach complicated material, this might be great evidence of that.
- jmkni 9y agoPorn has always been a factor in driving technology forward. People who weren’t motivated before to learn machine learning or programming suddenly are. This is no different!
- NelsonMinar 9y agoI can't wait to see what creepy thing they do next!
- flycaliguy 9y agoFinally, people willing to publically sexually humiliate others are being empowered to code. I hope the girls who sit across from them in IRL school are able to catch some of these creeps capturing their face.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- allengeorge 9y agoMaybe performers will start to license out their face for use in adult videos. You don't have to participate in the porn itself, but you'll get a tiny royalty from each view. It's an interesting way to monetize your appearance without having to be physically present. I can totally see people coming up with performer "mod packs".
- brango 9y agoI can think of a few non-porn applications for this. It also seems like it wouldn't be a million miles from this to being able to generate the 3D armature of a person in a video, kind of like a kinect in reverse (i.e. video file goes in, character armature comes out). Does anyone know of anything doing this? I want to be able to do motion capture from flat videos with AI building the armature.
- touchofevil 9y agoI've worked in the visual effects industry for many years and this is incredibly interesting. In vfx to create a face replacement, we would have to create a 3D model of a head and then texture it with photos/scans of a the desired face. Then we would 3D track this cgi head onto an actor in the shot and then animate the face either by hand or using motion capture data from the stand-in actor's face. Then you'd light and render the cgi head and composite it into the shot. This video shows the process: https://youtu.be/rsPq2qp_Z-E https://youtu.be/rsPq2qp_Z-E And here's an article about it: https://www.fxguide.com/quicktakes/di4d-in-la/ https://www.fxguide.com/quicktakes/di4d-in-la/ It's pretty incredible that there's a completely different way to do a head swap. Of course, the vfx method gives the artist complete control over what the face/head does.
- yarg 9y agoWho cares about the pornography aspect? Of significantly more concern is our societal reliance on video evidence in general. Ultimately there's no software solution here; adversarial networks will be capable of generating high quality simulations that even they cannot distinguish between. I'm also struggling to think of any viable hardware solution that doesn't involve in camera black boxes with asymmetric encryption - which is a hack at best.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoThe user in question is here: https://www.reddit.com/user/deepfakes/submitted/ https://www.reddit.com/user/deepfakes/submitted/ You can see the examples of their work at the bottom of that list. It's very, very obviously not the actual actresses. It's impressive, but not "holy shit, could that really be..?" impressive - there are artefacts scattered all over the faces.
- tedivm 9y agoI just read the post and there are points where it flat out lies about what a source said. From the article- > There are studies that demonstrate that porn viewing desensitizes ones genitals and reduces white matter in the brain. https://www.wired.com/2014/06/is-it-really-true-that-watching-porn-will-shrink-your-brain/ https://www.wired.com/2014/06/is-it-really-true-that-watchin... Then from the article they linked to in order to justify that claim it says the opposite- > It's just as likely that men with less grey matter in their striatum are more attracted to porn, as opposed to porn causing that brain profile. The researchers know this. "It's not clear ... whether watching porn leads to brain changes or whether people born with certain brain types watch more porn,” Kühn told The Daily Telegraph
- jamaicahest 9y ago> I just read the post and there are points where it flat out lies about what a source said. Thank you. I was just about to comment the same. But I suppose accurately quoting the Wired article didn't support their opinion, so they decided to make up their own conclusion in the Wired article and ignore the one actually written in the article.
- tzakrajs 9y agoVideo itself is not enough information. We need a cryptographic way to capture and archive corroborating signals at the time video is recorded. Perhaps there is a verifiable means of determining the geographic location, background radiation and orientation of the cameras taking the video which would be nigh impossible to spoof.