8 ms·
> Problem is that they typically lack the proper training and the discipline required, and act too hastily. What you are asking them to be is super human, inde
by freedomben 9y ago
> Problem is that they typically lack the proper training and the discipline required, and act too hastily.
What you are asking them to be is super human, indeed even better than a computer could in the same situation. No amount of "proper training" or "discipline" can prepare you to make perfect decisions based on imperfect data (your sensory perception, plus all the data that isn't present such as must be read from the mind of the suspect). Oh and add to this the stress that if you screw up, one of the following is likely:
1. You get killed
2. You wrongly kill and end up in prison
A different approach is needed. I'm not sure what that is, but asking/requiring certain humans to be super human is a sure way to fail.
- seunosewa 9y ago>> 2. You wrongly kill and end up in prison Actually, part of the problem is that you never end up in prison for wrongly killing.
- Xorlev 9y agoEven when it's not pretty clear it's not an accident. See http://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/news/nationworld/ct-daniel-shaver-police-video-20171208-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/news/nationworld/ct-daniel... (Daniel Shaver killing).
- varjag 9y agoSomehow police in the rest of developed world are able to resist shooting a great deal of suspects on the spot. Find what's different in America and fix it.
- cortesoft 9y agoWe know what is different but we refuse to address it. I understand that many people feel the second amendment is very important, but we at least have to have the intellectual honesty to admit that shootings like this are a consequence of it. We might decide we are willing, as a society, to accept that risk, but we can’t pretend it isn’t there.
- joe_the_user 9y agoI don't see much of a plausible argument that lack of gun control makes American police more trigger happy. And I say that as someone with no particular stake in gun rights. America doesn't have that high a murder rate, it just has a high rate of killings by cops. Lack of training, poor training and overall problematic police-culture seem to be the main offenders.
- sgt101 9y ago3x france 4x UK. The USA has a high murder rate; ok.. not as high as Iraq, but by the standards of developed nations, high. Put it this way, more than 10k people a year are murdered in the USA that would not be should the murder rate be the same as the UK's.
- bww 9y agoEasy access to guns in this country means it’s plausible that anyone the police encounter may be armed. As a result all the police also have guns and are reasonably concerned about being shot themselves – especially in tense situations. That’s a pretty direct connection from more guns in the public to more heavily armed, twitchier police.
- Spooky23 9y agoThere’s more connection to excessive traffic stops than to gun ownership. Guns are definately a problem, but a bigger problem is the idea that we Officers at high risk so that they can be gloried toll collectors. If you cut traffic stops by 80% and used cameras for speed enforcement, you’d dramatically reduce Officer shootings and attacks on officers. Train them to be EMTs and paramedics instead. The police and public should not be afraid of each other.
- ollieshmollie 9y agoI think there's at least a plausible argument to be had. A lot of bad guys get guns through holes in gun control, getting a gun out of state, etc. If it were harder for the wrong people to get guns, maybe there wouldn't be such a need for a militarized police force, or at least officers might not fear for their lives during stressful situations. That said, I'm a believer in the second amendment -- I just think there's definitely an argument to be had.
- freedomben 9y agoI agree. I'm far from an expert in this field, but my general observations is that we have a huge police presence in America. They are also empowered way beyond what our founders intended. That for one needs to change. It may also help if we stopped criminalizing every little thing, and giving our Environmental Protection Agency a freaking SWAT team[1]. [1]: http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/09/14/armed-epa-agents-in-alaska-shed-light-on-70-fed-agencies-with-armed-divisions.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/09/14/armed-epa-agents-...
- Bud 9y agoA biased article, which does not mention any "SWAT team"—only that some gold miner was outraged that the police investigating him had handguns. Big deal. The next substantive, impartial article from Fox News about the EPA will be the first one I've seen.
- gaius 9y agoFind what's different in America and fix it The average American spends several hours a week watching TV and movies where the rule-breaking shoot-first-and-ask-questions-later cop is the hero. Probably most people who join the police see themselves in that role. Here in the UK our cop shows are like Midsomer Murders. Most episodes don’t even feature a gun...
- wott 9y ago> Here in the UK our cop shows are like Midsomer Murders. Most episodes don’t even feature a gun... But your rusty gardening tools seem as efficient and they enhance murdering creativity :-)
- learc83 9y ago>Here in the UK our cop shows are like Midsomer Murders. Most episodes don’t even feature a gun... Midsomer Murders is a murder mystery show, not really a cop show. There are plenty of action oriented Brotish Cop shows. I love Midsomer Murders by the way.
- gaius 9y agoWell, so is NCIS then, and they love guns and rule-breaking...
- learc83 9y agoNCIS is a federal investigative and intelligence service--much like MI5, which leads us to Spooks that also has quite a bit of guns and rule breaking.
- jessaustin 9y agoNCIS? Don't assume anything based on that show; it is a ridiculous farce of nonsense and made-up bullshit. I have family members who watch it religiously, in all its goofy flavors. Not a minute passes without the seemingly serious portrayal of something that would never happen.
- ouid 9y ago"better than a computer" isn't really a superlative position in human interaction.
- vitalurk 9y agoAs an Infantry soldier who deployed to Afghanistan, I received more training on how to handle this type of situation than most cops seem to ever get. If we require soldiers to be better, why not require cops. Soldiers get to face more stress than cops.
- freedomben 9y agoI also received military training. I don't think it enabled me to make perfect decisions. In fact I saw several poor decisions made by my fellows-in-arms. If you didn't, then you were probably lucky enough to have not been placed in those difficult situations.
- lostlogin 9y agoI broadly agree, but why does the US seem to have a higher frequency of this sort of thing? It isn’t a problem everywhere, so why not do what other places do?
- gaius 9y agoWhat you are asking them to be is super human Here is a cop being fired for NOT shooting someone https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2016/09/12/west-virginia-cop-fired-for-not-killing-a-man-with-an-unloaded-gun/?utm_term=.7f16109a72d8 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2016/09/12/...
- JudasGoat 9y agoThat would be more relevant if it happened on the scale of the Police shooting unarmed people. That is a one off story that you are giving the same weight as something that happens every day in the US.
- lamarpye 9y agoAccording to this article there were 68 unarmed people shot and killed by the police in 2017. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/police-shootings-2017/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/police-shoo...
- anigbrowl 9y agoNo he isn't. Some people are better suited to these situations than others, and people can be better trained for it too. I've talked to more than one Iraq veteran who's troubled by how ready police are to discharge compared to the rules of engagement they used in Iraq, which were more than sufficient for them to maintain public safety. Part of the problem is that police in America offer the default excuse of fearing for their lives in virtually every situation where they shoot someone. I doubt they're actually that cowardly, but it's been a successful formula for them in administrative proceedings.
- throwaway2048 9y agoI like how the police feel threatened and have a hard job is more important than the fact a completely innocent person died.
- trophycase 9y agoIt's more important in terms of solving the issue. Why would we even be talking about this if an innocent person dying wasn't important?
- alsetmusic 9y ago> Oh and add to this the stress that if you screw up, one of the following is likely: I think this sums it up better than if you were trying to make the point that I’m about to attempt. It’s not necessarily “likely” that someone is going to die in all of these situations. It’s a possibility. It’s probably near impossible to tell the difference in the middle of a high-stress situation, but the assumption that it’s going to result in death at the outset is the problem.
- valuearb 9y agoIt's not asking them to be super-human. Its asking them not to shoot until they actually see a weapon.
- computerex 9y agoYea this answer is total and utter crap. We aren't asking law enforcement to be super human, we want them to be educated and competent. The fact that the U.S is both lacking in training and competence is a well established fact. Law enforcement in the United States has proven itself to lack training and discipline by firing on innocent unarmed citizens many many times. I don't believe any other country in the world has this problem to our extent. We have a very dangerously trigger happy law enforcement. These issues correlate with lack of training. Civil crime is not like a battlefield, people should be presumed innocent until proven guilty as is law. If someone can't handle this reality, they shouldn't be allowed to wield a weapon that kills. With great force and power comes responsibility. We should be far more selective at the type of people that can go into law enforcement, only those with a grounded temperament and proven track record should be allowed to use deadly force after extensive training. In the U.S, any Joe shmoe hungry for a power trip can attain a legal license to kill by going in law enforcement. That is the actual problem. I'd love to hear an actual solution or alternative if you have one. But the U.S isn't a special snowflake. It should take a leaf from other countries like Germany, England and France and foster a strong culture of policing by consent rather than the bullshit we have right now. Also when was the last time an American white law enforcement agent was imprisoned for discharging his or her weapon on an unarmed suspect?
- rdiddly 9y agoActual solution or alternative: You and tons more people like you, should apply for jobs in law enforcement, work your way up into leadership, and change policy.
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoI missed the part where perfect decisions were required?
- Spooky23 9y agoThe military often operates on much more restrictive rules of engagement. Example, where a soldier was criminally charged for shooting a likely combatant in the head, after nearly being blown up by a bomb. http://www.micourthistory.org/2013_ms/ http://www.micourthistory.org/2013_ms/
- ivanhoe 9y agoIt's not a binary thing, it's a matter of probability, one can be more or less likely to overreact and training helps with that. You most likely can't fix the problem entirely, mistakes happen, but you can at least reduce the number of incidents.