17 ms·
Crime in New York City Plunges to a Level Not Seen Since the 1950s
- eurticket 9y agoDoes this cause the NYPD forces to be downsized?
- sschueller 9y agoDo crimes committed by the NYPD count?
- mancerayder 9y agoReported crime. They also reclassified many crimes. Also, cops aren't always eager to take reports (I speak from experience). Yes, there are less homicides than ever, but it's still painful to watch manipulation of statistics in slow motion. On the flip side sex crimes are quite up (again, reported).
- donohoe 9y ago>> cops aren't always eager to take reports Well, that’s not new, so it’s not like cops suddenly stopped reporting even more crime
- cpncrunch 9y ago>cops aren't always eager to take reports (I speak from experience). Perhaps for something like an iphone being stolen, but I doubt that applies to homicides.
- mancerayder 9y agoOf course not. You can't cover those up, or downplay them. Downplaying crimes means less serious crimes on the books, which makes the department commander look better, and improves re-election chances for mayors. In NYC, due to the 1990's and the vivid memories some of us have of what safety was like then, crime is an extremely make-or-break factor in electoral races. Unfortunately, these memories are fading and people's understanding of crime reporting statistics aren't improving, either. Yes, it's official that NYC reclassified many crimes in the last 24 months. Whether or not this was good is subject to debate; but undoubtedly it leads to a 'lower crime rate.' That's the legal, official piece of the puzzle. The unoffocial one comes to play when you try to convince the cops not to downplay a crime you report. No one carries statistics on officers downgrading crimes when they file reports. This became really obvious when sex crime victims started getting press attention and reporting anecdote after anecdote of victim-blaming, indifference and worse.
- danso 9y agoI can also speak from experience that not all NYPD are eager to take in a report of violent crime, but the OP isn't just talking about felonies, but homicides. "The Wire" Season 4 aside, it's much harder for the police to fudge a body count. An increase in reported sexual assaults isn't necessarily a signal of crime trends as it may reflect an increase in willingness of victims to report versus past years. Speaking of Baltimore and its homicide rate, the Sun had a great investigation in 2010 that busted the department for having a sharp drop in reported rapes while having a steady/increasing homicide rate -- a great example of the use of (relatively simple) statistics -- such as how Baltimore was one of the few major cities to have more homicides than rapes -- that effected change: http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/bal-city-rapes-gallery-storygallery.html http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/bal-city-rapes-gal... A followup story reported the "good" news: http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-md-ci-sex-offense-changes-20110630-story.html http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-md-ci-sex-offense-change... > A major category of crime is up substantially in Baltimore, and police and city officials are pleased. > A year after The Baltimore Sun revealed that the city led the country in the number of rape reports discarded by detectives — part of what women's advocates and victims said was a broader pattern of ignoring sexual assaults — the number of rapes being reported is up more than 50 percent.
- phonon 9y ago> but the OP isn't just talking about felonies, but homicides. "The Wire" Season 4 aside, it's much harder for the police to fudge a body count. Yes, but you also need to take into account that emergency rooms have gotten much better at treating gunshot wounds and other serious crime-related traumas. I.e. even with the same exact level of crime, the homicide rate would still have gone down significantly over the last few decades.
- conistonwater 9y agoThat's a pretty strong claim, is the difference significant there? What's your source on that?
- shams93 9y agoYeah here in Los Angeles your tenant can put your building manager in the hospital on a meth induced violence binge and even destroy the property but they won't make an arrest even when there's a victim in the hospital. So for example this crime that really happened was not allowed to be reported.
- mancerayder 9y agoThey don't make an arrest to help the higher ups prevent another crime on the books, because they're lazy/unwilling, or another reason?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> cops aren't always eager to take reports (I speak from experience) Cops have no say in whether to take or not take a report. Call 311, make a police report, meet the officer dispatched to you and sign. I agree that getting the NYPD to actually act on a police report is puzzlingly difficult.
- yellowstuff 9y agoI've heard of NYC cops doing tricks like reporting a bag stolen off the subway as "lost property" if the victim didn't actually see someone take it. There was also an infamous case where a pattern of attempted rapes got reported as lesser crimes like trespassing, so a serial offend who should have gotten a serious investigation never got one, and went uncaught for a long time.
- sedachv 9y ago> Cops have no say in whether to take or not take a report. One time I tried to report a theft. I gave up after the third time the cop who was answering the phones at the local police station hung up on me.
- nerdponx 9y agoThe other day I tried to report someone who was blatantly trying to sell me a stolen computer. I was disappointed to find that they don't maintain any kind of database of serial numbers of lost and stolen electronics. The implication is that, if you do lose something or have it stolen, there is no way for the police to help you get it back.
- learc83 9y agoThat's mostly because the percentage of people who keep track of the SN of their electronics is close to 0.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> I was disappointed to find that they don't maintain any kind of database of serial numbers of lost and stolen electronics. NYC actually does, but you have to register your number before it gets stolen. Usually this is fine, because most people don't know their serial number after the device is stolen, unless they've thought to register it beforehand anyway.
- forapurpose 9y ago> sex crimes are quite up (again, reported) From the article: rapes were down from last year by one, to 1,417, misdemeanor sex crimes — a catchall for various types of misconduct that includes groping — ticked up 9.3 percent to 3,585 so far In addition, note that this is the year of the #metoo movement
- Simon_says 9y ago"Sex crime" can mean rape, prostitution, or peeing in bushes. Can you be more specific?
- jriot 9y agoI visited NYC a year ago for the first time. It amazed me the amount of police present everywhere. The sheer number of police out and about was shocking.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lev99 9y agoPolice presence seems to be mostly contained to the street level.
- jshaqaw 9y agoAs opposed to?
- donohoe 9y agoMaybe you were in tourist areas (if not, where did you see them)? I would complain that I don’t see enough cops on the street (live in Brooklyn, work in Manhattan)
- jriot 9y agoI went to a Yankees game, saw Blackbird with Jeff Daniels and Michelle Williams (forget the theater), Smalls Jazz Club in the West Village, Nom Wah Tea Palor in the Chinese district, Diwanekhaas in the financial district, walked the Brooklyn Bridge then around Brooklyn. I mention the different locations and where I went because I walked everywhere to and from then around if something caught my eye. The only time I didn't walk is when I took the subway from Smalls Jazz club was back to the apartment I was staying at which was near W 48th and 8th. As I stated that was my first time visiting, so I am not really sure how that covers NYC from a local perspective - I was certainly tired after 5 days. However, I did see police everywhere I went, except at 2am when I was walking from the subway back to the apartment.
- everdev 9y agoIt's surprising to hear this within the context of Chicago experiencing such high levels of homicide. Do they give any context as to why NYC is out performing other large cities?
- revelation 9y agoGentrification is a very successful crime fighting tool.
- danso 9y agoChicago apparently has greater concentrations of poverty, particularly among African-Americans: edit: forgot the URL for this story https://www.thecut.com/2016/07/why-is-new-york-so-much-safer-than-chicago.html https://www.thecut.com/2016/07/why-is-new-york-so-much-safer... > A 2015 study by Rutgers University public policy researcher Paul A. Jargowsky found that more than a third of all poor African-Americans in Chicago live in census tracts with poverty rates above 40 percent, compared with 26 percent of poor African-Americans in New York. The headline news about Chicago homicides and shootigns (e.g. "WAR ZONE: 10 Killed, 28 WOunded in Chicago Over MLK Day Weekend [0]) don't convey how concentrated the violence is in specific areas of the city. I visit (middle-class) friends who live downtown and uptown (along the lake) and it feels as safe as any of the nice parts of Manhattan when I lived there. Chicago Tribune does an excellent job tracking shootings [1]. You can easily see -- after zooming in a little -- on even their overplotted dot map that areas other than Chicago's west and south sides, shootings are virtually nonexistent: [snapshot] https://imgur.com/gallery/uPfSG https://imgur.com/gallery/uPfSG FWIW, according to the Tribune's tracker: In Chicago, 3,543 people have been shot this year. That is 784 fewer than 2016. [0] http://www.drudgereportarchives.com/dsp/search.htm?frompage=1&StartRow=97&maxrows=50&searchFor=Chicago http://www.drudgereportarchives.com/dsp/search.htm?frompage=... [1] http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/data/ct-shooting-victims-map-charts-htmlstory.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/data/ct-shooting-victims-...
- microcolonel 9y ago> greater concentrations of poverty Aren't there numbers to suggest that poverty itself is negatively correlated with both violent and property crime?
- junkscience2017 9y agoThe poor have been priced out. Go to big cities that still have a large segment of objectively poor people and you will see the attendant crime.
- rocky12 9y agoThat is my hypothesis, as they were gentrified out of NYC they moved to places like Newark.
- yalph 9y agoSorry but thats not true Bronx is quiet poor and its just one subway ride away.
- jronsomers 9y agoThere is also the PATH to consider if you're going to mention 'one subway ride away'.
- jjie2221 9y agoA problem with that. Crime in Newark is going down too: http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2017/12/newarks_crime_decline_and_old-school_policing_di_i.html http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2017/12/newarks_crime_decli... In fact, crime in the whole country is down dramatically from what it was in 1990. So unless the poor are being deported, something else must explain the drop in crime.
- dawhizkid 9y agoAs a former SF resident now living in Manhattan I can definitely say I generally feel much safer in NYC than I did in SF. I’m guessing it’s a combination of the fact that most of Manhattan is so gentrified that there are few pockets of poorer communities where gang-related activity can thrive and the number/visibility of police is comparably much higher. Taxes and CoL are comparable, so I definitely feel like I’m getting more for my $$ as far as security and safety goes.
- Gatsky 9y agoAll this talk about personal safety... there were so many homeless people in SF that clearly had an untreated psychiatric condition. How safe do you think it is for them? Everyone goes on about shit on the streets like it's a normal 'poor person' thing to do. It isn't.
- hueving 9y agoWhat are we supposed to do? People seem to be against institutionalization because it denies them their freedom and they refuse to use the many public and private homeless assistance programs available to them.
- akvadrako 9y agoIt's not like this is a unique local issue, but SF seems to handle it worse than almost any other city in the developed world. All you need is the political will and to copy how other places do it.
- pjc50 9y agoDo they refuse, or are the facilities full or inadequate? What about the process by which people get into this state in the first place?
- DavidSJ 9y agoThe high cost of housing no doubt plays a large role in the Bay Area's homelessness situation. That in turn has a demand side cause -- the continued influx of highly paid tech workers -- and a supply side cause -- the economically illiterate politics which paints housing development as some sort of handout to developers. The supply side of this problem could be fixed through political means, at no real cost to anyone. New York has 6x the population density of San Francisco yet lower housing prices, because it has the capacity to meet the demand.
- l33tbro 9y agoManhattan has increasingly become a gated community since the city neared bankruptcy in the '70s and the banks slowly negotiated more power in running things (as explained in Adam Curtis' 'Hyper-normalization' video essay). It's arguable that the NYPD has almost become a private security force for the city's wealthy residents, given how thin the presence is in places like The Bronx and East New York.
- Sangermaine 9y agoThese numbers are for the entire city, not just Manhattan. The bad old days of the late 70s-early 90s are over, just accept it. It's weird how hard some people fight good news.
- l33tbro 9y agoThe figures don't tell the story of all of the burroughs. Can you convince a cab to take you to the Bronx after 10 pm? I've had quite a few drivers tell me that they refuse to go there. Btw, the 'mourning old New York' thing pisses me off as well, as things have moved on and it's a welcome change that crime is down in Manhattan. I'm observing, not judging, when I say that the the city is playground for the rich.
- ultraluminous 9y agoI've had no trouble taking cabs and ubers to and from the bronx at least a dozen of times (and in particular the south bronx) at all hours of the night and all days of the week. A few times it was an uber pool that had other riders in it (meaning they managed to find a cab too).
- cmonfeat 9y agoCoincidentally, I was just talking to a hack about this a couple of days ago. We came to the conclusion that 311 put alot of the issue of cabs refusing rides to bed. They aren't allowed to refuse a fare based on destination, and if you report them to 311 they will be fined by the TLC. That's not to say it doesn't happen anymore, but the threat of retribution has changed this for the better.
- Izkata 9y ago> and crime will have declined for 27 straight years > But criminologists differ about the cause of the continued declines. Mr. Zimring said that while better policing accounted for much of the decline in crime since 1990, it was no longer a primary driver. New York is “tiptoeing” toward a 90 percent crime decline for reasons that remain “utterly mysterious,” he said. The "27 straight years" caught my eye, and reminded me of something I saw a good decade ago, so may I suggest something controversial? It doesn't perfectly match 27 years ago, but this is across the whole US, not just NYC - (popular) violent video games are highly correlated with the drop in crime: http://oi25.tinypic.com/2r6ns4y.jpg http://oi25.tinypic.com/2r6ns4y.jpg (Correlation <> causation, but I _definitely_ think it merits more investigation... does anyone else happen to know more?)
- sien 9y agoPeople know that there is a drop a drop in crime on the weekend that a big violent movie comes out. It's also known that male participation has dropped in the labour force and in particular young males without many skills who also tend to commit crime: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/7/7/15933674/video-games-job-supply https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/7/7/15933674/vi... Personally I think there is something in this. A big, time consuming engaging hobby appearing that young males take to with great enthusiasm appearing as games got cheaper and better. Here is something on it: https://www.polygon.com/2014/9/12/6141515/do-violent-video-games-actually-reduce-real-world-crime https://www.polygon.com/2014/9/12/6141515/do-violent-video-g... It's a really hard thing to study though.
- Izkata 9y ago> in particular young males without many skills who also tend to commit crime > A big, time consuming engaging hobby appearing that young males take to with great enthusiasm appearing as games got cheaper and better. I wasn't even thinking along those lines, my thought was more about the "violent" part of "violent video games" - that the games acted as a sort of stress release valve, helping people with their self-control when it matters.
- 9y ago
- pfarnsworth 9y agoHaving visited Manhattan several times in the last couple of years, I have to say that it does feel like a police state being there. In some senses it's great, because you don't have to worry so much about crime as much, but it also speaks to the police state that NYC and the rest of the US is turning into. So I'm not surprised that crime has fallen, given the sheer number of police officers present.
- shadowtree 9y agoThey have transferred the poor off the streets to prison cells. Super harsh sentences for serial small crimes, drug dealing, etc. You remove any young male who has potential to become a criminal from the street and all you’re left with is white collar crime. Unpopular facts.
- ch4s3 9y agoThat doesn't explain the similar drops in crime in Canada, most of Europe, Australia, and a ton of other countries. The US is nearly unrivaled in incarceration, but crime hasn't dropped faster of further than in comparable developed nations with lower incarceration rates.
- shadowtree 9y agoMost of Europe never had the crime and murder rates of NYC during the same timeframe. 70s and 80s in Vienna, Berlin, Paris, Madrid, etc very different than in NYC.
- ch4s3 9y agoNYC then should see a larger drop then as it reverts to the mean. Those cities may no have had peaks as high as New York, but their peaks were during the same time period. Half of Berlin was in the GDR where heavy handed surveillance networks tracked most residents, so it isn't really comparable.
- readhn 9y agothis is in direct correlation with higher living costs/rent/food etc. street thugs cant afford to live in new york hence lower crime. its not result of any policies.
- readhn 9y agodrug trade is at all time high in new york. massive amounts of drugs go through the city every day. its a major drug hub. plus its a new generation of thugs out there that understand that killing people attracts unwanted attention. hence lower violence.
- olingern 9y agoWhile I agree that NYC is much safer than when I first moved there five years ago -- threats still pose themselves from time to time (as anywhere will). For example, I fell asleep for the first time on a 2 train last month, and was robbed. It was one of those, "Ah, this is definitely on me," moments. Easily preventable; however, it's still crime, nonetheless. Most importantly, I didn't report this (as many others in similar situations will not), so the statistics are probably not as accurate as headlines would like you to think.
- Animats 9y agoMost of the people with heavy lead exposure are now beyond the age for violent crime. White collar crime is bigger than ever. Today's organized crime operators have better things to do than shake down shopkeepers for protection money, run a numbers racket, or try to resell stolen goods.
- aryehof 9y agoI wonder if people should consider that "freedom" includes being free of fear and threat. Where I live, even children can go out on the streets at night without a second thought. Without having to fear violence, hate, gangs or the authorities. There is something wrong with a society that prioritizes freedom of speech and the right to carry a gun, over the right to not live in fear and to human dignity.
- leetcrew 9y agoif you can't advocate for yourself or defend yourself, any freedom from fear or human dignity afforded to you is a happy accident. it may last for a while, but what will you do if things change? i concede that the sea may change for guns sometime in the next century; they can make things very chaotic as population density increases. still, i maintain that freedom of speech is a necessary, if not sufficient, condition for a stable and free society.
- cletus 9y agoSo I've lived in NYC for 7 years now so have some personal experience with this. Note that I live and work in Manhattan so my experience is probably skewed and is only really anecdotal anyway. My personal experience with the NYPD has been very good. - As others have noted, heavy police presence in heavily frequented areas, particularly by tourists. - During Sandy I was in the area without power. At night a police cruiser would go down my street every couple of hours (IIRC) with the lights on but no siren, I guess looking for looters. - I had a car alarm go off at 1:30am early Sunday morning right outside my window. While I was figuring out what to do and calling 311, a police van turned up (around 1:50am) and broke into the car and disabled the alarm. I went out to speak to the officers and they said just call my local precinct and any unattended car alarm is cause for the police to come up (defined as >10 minutes). That all being said, there's a pretty dark side to policing and the criminal justice system in NYC too, most notably in the treatment of minorities. Some examples: - New York's ridiculous gravity knife law [1], which seems to be used by police selectively to target minorities. The New York legislature has now twice overwhelmingly passed reforms only to have this (now twice) vetoed by Governor Cuomo on thin justification [2]. One can only presume he's kowtowing to the law and order crowd. - Alleged racial bias in pedestrian stops, seemingly often under the guise of seeking a mysterious African-American male suspect in his 20s who is 5' 10" (which can be pretty much anyone). - The appalling case of Three Years in Riker's Island Without a Trial [3], as win-rate obsessed prosecutors use stalling tactics, the imbalance of power, the ignorance of suspects and plea deals to deny people due process. - The arrest of James Blake [4]. - Chokehold death of Eric Garner [5] for a relatively minor offense. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/31/opinion/new-yorks-outdated-knife-law.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/31/opinion/new-yorks-outdate... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/24/nyregion/gravity-knife-cuomo-veto.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/24/nyregion/gravity-knife-cu... [3] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law [4] https://www.boston.com/sports/tennis/2017/09/19/ex-tennis-star-james-blake-testifies-about-his-mistaken-arrest https://www.boston.com/sports/tennis/2017/09/19/ex-tennis-st... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner
- FuckPaywalls 9y agoHas paywall, please remove from HNN
- jshaqaw 9y agoNYC is a wonderful and safe place to visit or live. People raised on too many cop shows may miss this. It’s not perfect -no place is - but it is quite safe.
- forapurpose 9y agoThis is especially good news: As of Dec. 20, police officers intentionally fired their service guns in 23 encounters, a record low, down from 37 in 2016. The Police Department said officers were relying more on stun guns, which were used 491 times through November, compared with 474 times during the same period in 2016.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gyrfalcon 9y agoMust be because of Trump!
- dworrad 9y agoSurely most crime is done online these days.
- RoutinePlayer 9y agoThis isn't surprising at all for anyone who has read Better Angels of Our Nature by Steven Pinker. The decline of violence is a ongoing trend in the species.
- almost_usual 9y agoSt. Louis had almost as many homicides as NYC this year. Population of St. Louis: 312,000 Population of NYC: 8,537,673 http://amp.kansascity.com/news/local/crime/article191211704.html http://amp.kansascity.com/news/local/crime/article191211704....
- DerfNet 9y agoSt. Louisan here. What's really impressive about our murders is that basically ~95% of them take place within two small neighborhoods inside St. Louis city limits, which itself is but one small subsection of the metro area, which actually has a population hovering around 3 million. Those two neighborhoods, Dutchtown and North City, are impressively dangerous, so dangerous that even diluting them with the rest of the city still places us at the top of "most dangerous cities" lists year after year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zero_intp 9y agoSeriously, Lead Pb. [0] [0] - http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2016/02/lead-exposure-gasoline-crime-increase http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2016/02/lead-exposure...