13 ms·
We’re Going to Need More Lithium
- QAPereo 9y agoIt might cost more, but it’s certainly abundant; we’re not going to run out of it. No I would even go so far as to say that a rise in the price of terrestrial lithium would be a good thing. In the short term it will hurt, but there’s a lot of runway in that graph before we hit serious scarcity. As the price rises I could honestly see someone like Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos finally astroid money off the ground. I don’t have much hope for Mars in our lives, but asteroid mining absolutely could happen. This could be a safe source of pressure, partly political if people realize it will be easier to move in space than Afghanistan, to make that happen. For those of us you dreaming of a future for the species beyond Earth, I think this might be the realistic start.
- zzzzzzzza 9y agomining asteroids in our lifetimes would primarily be useful for harvesting raw materials for constructing things in space, not sending the materials back down to earth.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoEither will require a breakthrough in propulsion systems.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoNot necessarily. In the near term, mining asteroids means mining near-Earth asteroids, not those from the belt. The changes we'll need to make to propulsion systems are more about their operations - we need more types of engines that can be frequently shut down and restarted.
- irrational 9y agoIsn't sending things back to earth relatively inexpensive? Wouldn't gravity do most of the work?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYou need to first send equipment to do the mining and sending back - that part is very expensive, and if it's only to be used for sending stuff back to Earth (safely), then mining in space has very bad returns. Asteroid mining is absolutely awesome if you move as much of the process as possible to space - every kilogram you use up there to build something is a kilogram you didn't have to launch upwell.
- mjevans 9y agoWhat you'd really want to do is develop a working zero (natural) gravity solar-furnace process that works. It'd probably involve some kind of centrifuge design... but I wouldn't rule out just making something screaming hot and then suddenly introducing kinetic energy. Then there are two main options... A) Make a crude re-entry shield out of the waste products + some of those other resources you're not keen on harvesting for the primary use of sending to earth, and you put a nice candy core in the middle. Aim the landing trajectory at some shallow ocean. B) Taking things UP in to orbit is expensive. Taking them back down is probably less so, though our current vehicles aren't based on completing that task so they'd need to changed to handle cargo both ways. Option C could also be fun... if we ever get space elevators working things could go a lot like in science fiction. (The orbital elevators and start of a planetary ring from Gundam 00 jumps to mind as a reference; 3001 also had the idea much earlier but in less detail)
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoYou've got to find a way to go from over 20,000k per second to stationary on the ground. For any worthwhile mass of asteroid you bring back to Earth, it's going to require one hell of a heat shield during reentry. So maybe you leave the heat shield in orbit, but you've still got get it there. I think space mining becomes possible when you're no longer cornered by the rocket equation. That is, it's going to require a breakthrough in propulsion systems.
- azernik 9y agoIt may be useful for some raw materials - for example, osmium ($13,000/kg), rhenium ($2,750/kg), and iridium ($30,000/kg). All three of those are elements that are probably common in the Earth's mantle, but nowhere near the surface, and are mostly found in meteorites; all of them are used in high-performance alloys (high-temperature, corrosion-resistant, etc.) Doubling the world production of any of these would greatly reduce the prices of aerospace engines and electronics (iridium is used for crucibles growing high-quality semiconductor crystals). And that's easy, because the quantities involved are so low - under 1 ton of osmium per year, 10 tons of iridium, and 40 tons of rhenium. There are other materials like that. It's all about searching for the competitive advantage, the materials that can't be found on Earth in reasonable quantities. All the nickel and iron and titanium will indeed probably stay up for in-space use.
- dozzie 9y ago> It may be useful for some raw materials - for example, osmium ($13,000/kg), rhenium ($2,750/kg), and iridium ($30,000/kg). Or tungsten, in the form of cylinders 6m long and 30cm in radius, transported gravitationally to their place of use.
- DiabloD3 9y agoRods from God?
- Turing_Machine 9y agoYep. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment#Project_Thor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment#Project_Th...
- disnsj 9y agoThose sabots better land where they are supposed to!
- disnsj 9y agoThe price would probably collapse unless we find a huge market for it
- QAPereo 9y agoThat really depends on the assumptions you’re making about why it’s done. Large scale mining for building materials and fuel requires an existing space industry for demand. Saving on Dv only makes sense if you have something proven so out there... like mining. Either way there needs to be a truly enormous initial investment in propulsion, and so much more. Making an absolute fortune, and/or breaking foreign control over vital resources could be the key to getting that funding.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoLithium can be extracted from the ocean at commercially viable costs, no asteroid mining required.
- Robotbeat 9y agoCorrect! However, since lithium is abundant, there are so many other cheaper sources of lithium (for instance, geothermal brines) that ocean extraction will never be the cheapest source (although it is sufficiently cheap if it were the only option).
- QAPereo 9y agoAt what environmental cost? How many gallons/sec are you processing, how much energy is used per gram of Li? Without burning fissile fuels or building expensive new nuke plants, how will it work?
- jmnicolas 9y agoI don't see how asteroid mining can be viable economically. You still need an enormous quantity of petrol to send things in space and judging by the rarefaction of said petrol its price is bound to increase a lot.
- liotier 9y ago> You still need an enormous quantity of petrol to send things in space You need to think out of that box - I'm investing my savings in hevea plantations !
- Manglano 9y agoCryogenic engines burn hydrogen from electrolysis and their fuel can be produced from renewable resources. All their atmospheric fuel is returned to the ocean by the water cycle, so little fuel is lost to the vacuum. Engine tuning limits greenhouse emissions. Magnetic projectiles can reach escape velocity with the right design. Instead of one giant rocket, imagine swarms of small, reusable, low-emission projectiles whose payloads assemble into larger apparatuses in space.
- srtjstjsj 9y agoIt's irresponsible to say that you want something to become absolutely more expensive just so some other amusing method of production becomes comparatively less expensive. The idea behind solving problems is to make life better, not make live hard so it can be made almost as good as before.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoSounds like these companies are good investment opportunities? No?
- knappe 9y agoI have a bit of SQM and it is a wild ride. It jumps around a lot, but has done quite well for me as a long term investment.
- QAPereo 9y agoThe potential returns are enormous, but so are the risks. Remember any number of things could disrupt the price, from novel battery tech, to new mining opportunities. That’s the long term, the short term is just crazy.
- jogjayr 9y agoDoesn't the efficient market theory ensure that any outsized future returns are already reflected in the price?
- ScottBurson 9y agoAny engineer knows that nothing is perfectly efficient.
- baq 9y agoan efficient market is a model that assumes the same information is available for all players, so don't put too much weight on it. it's an approximation that's sometimes useful.
- disnsj 9y agoWell doesn’t that make no sense at all? Through what mechanism could a market know about the future? The market isn’t God or an oracle. It’s just a bunch of actors going back and forth. You and I can’t predict the future, why would averaging out guesses be any better? And if we’re both using the average of our initials guesses to correct our guesses, then the spread is reduced.... which looks like less uncertainty when in fact nothing fundamental has changed! What the market is very good for is as a heuristic to solve the NP hard problem of how much to produce. (Misses first worked on this and then Hyek got the bank Of Sweden prize in economics).
- robbrown451 9y agoHow sure are we that some new tech won't replace lithium ion batteries? I'd want to know that if I was investing in a mine.
- nsnick 9y agoThe reason lithium is used for batteries is that it is an excellent anode the lightest metal. Lithium will always be used for batteries that need to be light.
- snowmaker 9y agoRelevant article from 11 days ago on sodium battery development: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15938642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15938642
- NicoJuicy 9y agoComment from there: If price was the only factor that matters, we could be using nickel-metal-hydride batteries. They also last longer. + Lithium is safer as it seems: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IT2I3LtlNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IT2I3LtlNE
- Robotbeat 9y agoSodium is not fundamentally better material than lithium, though. It's just a bit more abundant (but lithium is very abundant and can be extracted from actual ocean water, though because of lithium's abundance, that will never be the cheapest way to get lithium). Lithium is the third lightest element and the lightest (regular) metal. Sodium is much heavier.
- mrob 9y agoTrue, but we can't be sure that no breakthrough in fuel cells or supercapacitors will make batteries obsolete.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago
- Manglano 9y agoPneumatic cars.
- mlvljr 9y agoVapourware.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoA novel idea for lithium is that much of our lithium recycling is done in other countries. If the government were to classify lithium as strategic security material, it would severely limit its exportation. Ergo retaining more of it domestically and encouraging domestic recycling. Lithium may arrive but it can never leave, so to speak.
- jeffdavis 9y agoThis seems like a simple case of "demand increases, price increases in the short term, production increases, things balance out" -- a textbook example of how a market is supposed to work. Did I miss something?
- sametmax 9y agoYes. You missed that it's an ad disguised as an article. Maybe someone need people to invest in lithium, or to make lithium based companies look good, or to divert attention to lithium from other things... All in all, someone from an entity with a lot of money involved sent a PR guy with a story to tell to journalists. And the journalists were happy to write it down because it's interesting enough, serious enough, and doesn't require too much work.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIt clearly worked as there are several questions here about where to invest, we are easily manipulated aren't we.
- NicoJuicy 9y agoI invested a year ago and it is a interesting resource. As all car companies need Lithium. Renewable energy is also in the same ballpark
- sametmax 9y agoWell made ads are actually selling to people that would want to buy, not just any target that could buy, so it makes sense.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI'm not doubting that, it may well be a good investment, it's just reacting to an advert isn't a good methodology for picking your investments.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 9y agoThis may be a silly question, but can't the lithium be recharged and reused? Or it's discarded and useless after a battery is tossed? Why mine more?
- NegativeLatency 9y agoBecause greater numbers of devices and batteries are required.
- lucaspiller 9y agoTypically when a lithium-ion battery is recycled some metal parts are extracted (the battery contains metal plates which are relatively easily separated), but the lithium usually is not as it’s a lot more complicated to extract. Economically it is a lot cheaper just to mine new lithium, so proper recycling facilities don’t often exist. In the U.K. lithium-ion batteries are usually discarded in a landfill, and often treated as hazardous waste: https://app.croneri.co.uk/feature-articles/dealing-waste-lithium-batteries-0 https://app.croneri.co.uk/feature-articles/dealing-waste-lit...
- dharma1 9y agofeels like such a waste.. would it be possible to design lithium-ion batteries in a way that's easier/cheaper to recycle?
- Robotbeat 9y agoYes. Tesla's standardization on one or two cell types allows them to build specialized machines that can efficiently and quickly disassemble and recycle the components of the cell. (EDIT: That's the idea Musk presented, at least. I do know Tesla has done some battery recycling, but I don't know if they've implemented this method at scale, yet.)
- EGreg 9y agoThat's what I was getting at. The world is running out of fresh lithium and meanwhile this used lithium is polluting landfills. Crazy!!
- pscsbs 9y agoIf I wanted to invest in lithium, what companies or ETFs should I look at?
- joshuamcginnis 9y agoGlobal X Lithium ETF (NYSE:LIT) https://www.globalxfunds.com/funds/lit/ https://www.globalxfunds.com/funds/lit/
- kogepathic 9y agoAt 0.76% management fee and an average return over 5 years of 8.09%, you're better off just investing in an index ETF. Their own comparison shows the index matching or beating the Lithium ETF in every metric. * LIT since inception: 38.48% * Index over same period: 45.82% You also have zero diversification with a resource ETF. If you really want to buy into only Lithium then I won't try to talk you out of it. But maybe consider Vanguard Growth ETF (VUG), the average return over 5 years is 14.4%, or nearly double that of LIT. [1] [1] https://institutional.vanguard.com/iippdf/pdfs/FS967R.pdf https://institutional.vanguard.com/iippdf/pdfs/FS967R.pdf
- jwblackwell 9y agoYou’re assuming OP wants to invest all of his money in Lithuum. And that past performance remains the same
- saguro 9y agoHe's also assuming that ETF is going to perform the same way in the future, when the whole point of TFA is that lithium demand is about to surge.
- kogepathic 9y agoThere was another quote in TFA about the potential to over build mining capacity and flood the market. But sure, buy this and hope it "surges" more than the general market. Given that billions of devices already have lithium cells in them and the historical performance of the Lithium ETF is still quite disappointing compared to the broader market, I wouldn't hold my breath that this time is any different.
- MrBorough 9y agoThis is why the imperialists countries like USA, Britain, France etc are going to foment war in countries like Congo where people live like animals and work for peanuts to dig out cobalt: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4764208/Child-miners-aged-four-living-hell-Earth.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4764208/Child-miners... Let's make a million dollars no matter who dies. It aggravates me that I don't see any comments here relating to what is happening in Congo and all the multinationals supported by the all good US/Britain/France etc. Why do you think the arena of war is being shifted to Africa? Are you ready to wake up? Or do you care about what is happening as long as you have a new toy/mobile to play?
- GordonS 9y agoDo you have a more... reputable source than the daily mail?
- totalZero 9y agoTHE COBALT PIPELINE: Tracing the path from deadly hand-dug mines in Congo to consumers’ phones and laptops. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/congo-cobalt-mining-for-lithium-ion-battery/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/c...
- Manglano 9y agoI actually don't doubt the Daily Mail about this particular story. Mining abuses in Africa include some of the worst crimes committed by Western civilization (vide: the concept of "Western Civilization" may be outdated), over things some of us in technology would consider essentially valueless today. Chocolate is almost as serious a concern as cobalt and diamond. The legacy of colonialism created a food and infrastructure vacuum in Africa which is typically filled by mineral extraction and labor exploitation.
- grinsekatze 9y agoI feel exactly the same and am amazed by how readily some people invest their money into and anticipate owning products that are based on slavery and other kinds of suffering as well as the destruction of our planet.
- tomxor 9y ago> The next dozen years will drain less than 1 percent of the reserves in the ground That's actually an extremely large portion for such a short length of time (this is the entire planet we are talking about). That projection doesn't paint a very sustainable future compared to oil (yes I hate oil), I hope it's efficiently recycled or replaced with better tech.
- thecabinet 9y agoAssuming lithium reserves work anything like oil reserves, the quantity of reserves depends on market process. When oil sells for $20/bb, oil that costs more than that to extract doesn't count towards the reserves. As the price goes up, the reserves increase, because you can extract oil from more challenging circumstances. This is why we've had 20-30 years of oil reserves for the last 50 years.
- monort 9y agoOil alarmism existed as early as 1919: http://papers.sae.org/190011/ http://papers.sae.org/190011/
- sgift 9y agoSo, it took almost 100 years until the mainstream understood what should have been blatantly obvious to anyone who thinks about it: Oh right. Oil is limited. I mean, sure, if we search long and hard enough we will probably almost always be able to find/produce something, but I don't think asking 1 million per liter of gas would be such a great idea. Hoping that there will always be a scientific breakthrough just "right in time" to solve our resource problems is great. I love optimism. It's also extremely irresponsible to depend on it.
- coldtea 9y agoYou mean "oil cautionism" based on the very well established fact that reserves are limited (and it took the billions of years to be created)?
- castle-bravo 9y agoCan anyone comment on the feasibility/state of the art for extracting lithium from seawater? I've found an article [0] which describes a specially made membrane which allows lithium ions to pass, but nothing larger. If it's really possible to scale this up cheaply, the supply of lithium will be constrained by the supply of power, not scarce mineral deposits. [0] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0011916414006560 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0011916414...
- lev99 9y ago“People used to think gold was worth fightin’ over, and that shit gets made by every supernova, which means pretty much every planet around a G2 star will have some. Stars burn through lithium as fast as they make it. All the available ore got made at the big bang, and we’re not doin’ another one of those. Now that’s scarcity, friend.” ― James S.A. Corey, Cibola Burn