4 ms·
I thought "extortion" (ask for money and threat of legal action) was how settlements were supposed to work. Will this set a precedent and have broader consequen
by im3w1l 9y ago
I thought "extortion" (ask for money and threat of legal action) was how settlements were supposed to work. Will this set a precedent and have broader consequences?
- eck 9y agoIANAL but threat of filing a lawsuit and threat of reporting criminal activity to authorities are not equivalent.
- tomohawk 9y agoApparently some believe only prosecutors are allowed to have such discretion. They guard their power jealously. I wonder of the prosecutor who was talking about using his discretion understood the irony of what he was saying or the hypocrisy of his position.
- shkkmo 9y ago> “I heard her pitch, and I just said, ‘No way,’” said Joshua Marquis, the district attorney in Clatsop County, Ore. “The justice system should never be a profit system.” > Mr. Marquis said his office prosecutes serial shoplifters, but police send him few cases involving first-time offenders. When they do, Mr. Marquis is likely to give the shoplifter a citation and order him or her to perform community service, he said. What irony? What hypocrisy? The discretion been referenced in that quote is not the prosecutor's but that of the police who send him cases. The only irony I see here is that a program designed to help first time offenders actually ends up being worse for them, because first time offenders rarely get prosecuted?
- jessriedel 9y agoSettlements are for civil cases, not criminal. This was demanding money in exchange for not revealing evidence of a crime to authorities, which is extortion. It would be perfectly legal for Walmart to settle with the shoplifter under an agreement to not sue them. Criminal cases are the state vs. the citizen, whereas civil cases are citizen vs. citizen. (The same action can result in both types of cases.) You're not supposed to profit by inhibiting the state from prosecuting.
- Houshalter 9y agoThat's an interesting legal difference, but what's the moral difference? "Pay me to drop the lawsuit" and "pay me to drop the charges" feel like pretty much the same thing to me.
- umanwizard 9y agoBecause the state has an interest in punishing criminals whether the victim wants them to be punished or not.
- Dylan16807 9y agoIn theory, but it's hard to punish a criminal in a minor crime when the victim doesn't want to cooperate. So the end result again feels pretty similar.
- will_hughes 9y agoChange the values there a bit and see how you still feel. Walmart won't report you to the police if you agree to - pay them $5000? - undertake a voluntary 'community service program' at a Walmart designated location (store cleaner on the shift nobody wants at Walmart) for 20 hours per week for 12 months Remember, that one conviction for minor shoplifting could permanently impact your life. Eg: limiting job opportunities, places you can live, whether you get to see your children in a custody dispute, whether you are entitled to vote or stand for election. If Walmart knew someone had virtually no other option, they could press their unfair advantage.
- Dylan16807 9y agoA civil suit could easily be $5000, so what's the big difference? And minor shoplifting is not a felony. I'm not sure you understand my point. I'm not saying the extortion is a good idea, I'm saying it's not all that different from civil not-extortion tactics.
- 9y ago
- jetrink 9y agoThe main difference is what threat is being used. It's fine to threaten to sue someone (within reason). It is not ok to threaten to report someone to the police if they don't pay you. It is even worse to hold someone in a room, pressure them into signing a confession and then to threaten to turn that confession over to the police if the agreed payment is not delivered, as Walmart is accused of doing here.
- jnwatson 9y agoStill confused. What’s the difference between this and the typical NDA that a sexual harassee signs?
- adventured 9y agoThere's no conceptual difference. The only consequences difference is the fear being espoused on here that Walmart or similar could frequently abuse it as an extortion point (and that given their scale, it could become a terrifying beast of a problem; such that even if Walmart weren't directly doing the extorting - which they're unlikely to do - others in the system would). For example, you get a person in the Walmart system, a guard or whatever, that has records on people that have commited crimes in Walmart. Joe Consumer gets caught shoplifting and pays a fee for it to go away, and doesn't get turned in to the police. Now, the security guard with the profiles starts going outside the framework and begins blackmailing people like Joe. These will mostly be poorer people and are very easy to prey upon in such a scenario.