15 ms·
Living in a parking lot in Santa Barbara
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoI've written recently on this site about my difficulty in finding a job as a recent college grad, and was bombarded with comments suggesting I relocate. This is precisely why I won't. Income inequality means that those areas are incredibly risky to move to without a nice financial cushion, and with a child on the way, I'm not going to make that risk. What can be done about regional inequality? Because such economic trends will do nothing but continue to destabilize our country in the future. Edit: To those downvoting me, can you please explain? I don't understand.
- cletus 9y agoSerious question: why are you having children in such a financially precarious situation when it’s only going to increase your living costs? EDIT: by “financially precarious” I mean that above you said you were a new grad having difficulty finding work. I assume it is your intent to work after the baby is born (rather than being the primary caregiver) or it wouldn’t matter so much about finding work. If your wife returns to work and you work you’ll need to pay for care and/or rely on family support. If she doesn’t return to work and she’s the one with steady employment then that’s a problem (financially). Hence my question.
- Xavi 9y agoNot everyone "decides" to have kids. Sometimes it just happens.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DanCarvajal 9y agoEveryone who has kids decided to do so, the only thing that varies is the amount of options considered.
- dnautics 9y agooccasionally a deity will impregnate you in the form of a swan, or through the ear.
- nradov 9y agoSpontaneous parthenogenesis?
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoAssuming I'm in a "financially precarious situation" is a bit presumptuous. My wife is an employed college grad, and we have much more saved than the average American. We have health insurance, and have already completely paid off the medical bills for her birth. We are fine. It's still too risky and difficult for us to relocate, though. Our family all lives nearby, so we have a support structure here. My wife has an established career in a low cost of living area. Housing is incredibly cheap. We mesh with the culture here. When I get a job, we'll be able to buy a house pretty easily. It's just tough for me to get an IT job, because most low level positions have been outsourced in my area.
- istorical 9y agoThe circumstances of your area are so individual that without specifying a specific city or town you're pretty much not going to get any useful advice. And generalizing the Bay Area to all other higher salary + higher CoL places is also going to yield no useful insight. Or in other words - your parent comment about how articles like this are why you don't consider relocating neglects the fact that there are likely middle ground locations where you could be paid a higher wage while still paying a lower rent. One simply can't extrapolate that much when looking at CoL or salary.
- disnsj 9y agoYou don’t have to justify to anyone why you are having a child. (As a parent, I can see by you’re set up better than most) If for no other reason having children is our biological raison d’être. Go tell a squirell it’s not rich enough to procreate! Children are brought up with very little means everyday; they don’t need rich parents. Children are seen by our rich society as a luxury good that only the well off are worthy of buying. Instead what children need are strong loving parents. (I’m so anoyed at the parents of my kid’s spoiled friends, and she not even three) I lived for three months in Cali (Santa Barbara) and it is one of the last places in N. America I would raise my daughter. Only the despair from the poorest, heroin addicted, countries in WV would rank lower. A well employed parent, a well educated spouse and grandparents to help. We should all be so lucky!
- foobarian 9y ago
- kenning 9y agoThis is a sad article with unfortunate subjects. However I'm not convinced that the movement of people from apartments to vehicles is always a "sort of homelessness." I personally know people who are planning to move into a van to work remote, and there's definitely no shortage of blogs and instagrams from those people. Many of them are doing it to save money, but could live in a home if they chose to. The real issue, as always, is the absurdly inflated real estate market.
- jlg23 9y ago> I personally know people who are planning to move into a van to work remote, and there's definitely no shortage of blogs and instagrams from those people. This is a very small minority. Even 10 years ago this was a hot topic in the communities concerned. I lived in Venice Beach at that time: People being force out of their homes into their cars or RVs, police harassing them and finally even suicides were a daily topic within the local community.
- BurningFrog 9y agoEspecially, the especially broken California housing market.
- cletus 9y agoI can’t help but think of Snow Crash where Hiro Protagonist (and many others) lived in the U-Store-It former storage facility. This is the the real cost of allowing (particularly foreign) capital to be parked in real estate in the developed world. In NYC for example most new developments are ultra-luxury not because building affordable apartments is uneconomic, it’s just that the ultra-luxury end is way more profitable. But sure let’s just pass a massive tax cut for the wealthy instead at a time when corporations are making record profits.
- jjeaff 9y agoThe thing is, this money being parked from overseas isn't even benefitting the local economies. It just props up property values for a select few homeowners. The people buying these houses are just leaving them empty. There has been some private investigation of some of the homes being bought and built in BelAir right now. One home was found to be owned by a Nigerian politician through multiple layers of shell companies. This politician has no business owning an $80 million home. If we simply cut out the corrupt and stolen money flooding into these markets I think we would find it is making for a large chunk of it.
- TuringNYC 9y agoFor those interested in the topic, NYTimes did a great article: Towers of Secrecy Stream of Foreign Wealth Flows to Elite New York Real Estate By LOUISE STORY and STEPHANIE SAULFEB. 7, 2015 https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreign-wealth-flows-to-time-warner-condos.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreig...
- cletus 9y agoIt’s worse than that: they’re not even payin* their fair share of property taxes either. For example: - 157 West 57th St #77, asking $49m, paying $4,200 in monthly taxes [1] - 301 West 53rd St #3E, asking $1.85m, paying $1,681 in monthly taxes [2] Why is an apartment asking 25 Times as much only paying 2.5x the property taxes? You can largely blame Bloomberg and Andrew Cuomo for this. [1] https://www.elliman.com/new-york-city/one57-157-west-57-street-77-manhattan-xmokzyz https://www.elliman.com/new-york-city/one57-157-west-57-stre... [2] https://www.elliman.com/new-york-city/fifty-third-and-eighth-301-west-53-street-3e-manhattan-rcnnhns https://www.elliman.com/new-york-city/fifty-third-and-eighth...
- santaclaus 9y agoI've met tenured computer science professors at UC Santa Barbara who couldn't afford to live in Santa Barbara. That place is nuts. Similar situation with Stanford and Palo Alto.
- SilasX 9y agoIIRC, planning commission members couldn't afford to live in Palo Alto.
- beamatronic 9y agoThe official poverty line is $250k household income in Palo Alto.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoI believe this is a misinterpretation of a news story about Palo Alto considering subsidizing housing for households making under $250k. It is not the poverty threshold, it is just a hypothetical cutoff for qualifying for housing subsidization in one housing plan that Palo Alto considered.
- sjg007 9y agoWhich is still nuts... a quarter million a year and you qualify for subsidized housing.. yet they won’t build condos.
- s0rce 9y agoMakes sense if you let the locals control zoning decisions, if you have a house in your nice quaint suburb and are extremely selfish you probably would try to block condo developments.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoYou don't qualify for it. They considered it. They didn't actually enact that plan.
- tempz 9y agoThere is a linguistic problem here - extending the term 'middle class' to hide prevailing poverty in the US. You are not middle class if: - you will lose home, car if you are out of job for 6-10 months; - you don't take 30 days vacation a year; - you cannot afford health services without going to debt; - you cannot send your kids to university; - your diet is mostly junk food because you can't afford fresh stuff. If some of the above is true, you are poor.
- solotronics 9y agoby your measure most people in the USA are poor I would guess about 80%+
- johnchristopher 9y agoWhich bullet points - if not all- would you exclude from the list to make it relevant ?
- jaggederest 9y agoThe only one which is not a routine part of the middle class experience these days is eating strictly junk food because you can't afford anything better. Every other part of that entire list is, sadly enough, "normal middle class" in the US.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoOne interesting factoid I know is that 50% of Americans represent 2% of the income in America. “The shrinking middle class” is a phrase that is part of common discourse here for a reason - I wouldn’t be surprised if 80% of Americans fit the parent comment’s definition.
- orangecat 9y agoOne interesting factoid I know is that 50% of Americans represent 2% of the income in America. More like 15%: https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-household-income-of-quintiles-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-househo...
- etr-strike 9y agoKeep doing what you’re doing central banks! Your policies of persistent inflation have robbed us of our ability to save our wealth and accurately plan for the future. You’ve decided that devaluing our wages 2% per year is in our best interest meaning we must perpetually fight with our employers to keep our wages we fought for the previous year. Your policies of QE have driven asset prices so high we have no hope of ever owning them without becoming a debt slave. Congratulations.
- iak8god 9y agoOver the last four decades, the slow and steady annual inflation looks very easy to plan for: http://www.inflation.eu/inflation-rates/united-states/historic-inflation/cpi-inflation-united-states.aspx http://www.inflation.eu/inflation-rates/united-states/histor...
- etr-strike 9y agoYou’ve lost your mind if you really believe inflation has only been roughly 2% the last decade.
- iak8god 9y ago> You’ve lost your mind if you really believe inflation has only been roughly 2% the last decade. Do you generally find that being insulting without providing evidence for, or even explaining, your position usually brings people around to your point of view?
- disnsj 9y agoThe op is a bit bombastic. That being said his point is true. They printed money and that money had to increase the price of something. If you give printed money to state employees consumer goods go up. If you give it to banks (QE) the price of financial assets goes up. The financial bubble we’re in is huge (pray, what great increase in productivity has occurred in the last ten years that the stock market has gone up so much). If the CPI included financial instruments (ie my retirement) this inflation would be easily spotted. QE is maybe the most pernicious inflationary policy yet since at least the previous inflationary spending gave money to normal people but now financial oligarchs are the only ones who make money!
- flembat 9y agoA good definition for middle class; is that you make a significant income from your capital investments. In that case it doesn't matter if you stop working for a few months; your stocks and shares still pay dividends and your tenants still pay you rent; your capital still keeps on working for you. A good clue is this: if your money all comes from working for someone else; and it all stops when you stop working; then you are working class. Like most people in the world.
- BlanketApple 9y agoI don't think that's anyone's typical definition of the middle class. It usually refers to work autonomy and relying on expertise to sustain yourself (as opposed to menial labor). Merely having liquid capital to begin with (i.e. not tied up in your primary residence or retirement vehicles) almost certainly puts you on the higher end of the middle class. I don't think re-defining "middle class" to mean the top 10% (or less) of earners is helpful.
- s0rce 9y agoWhile the definition of working class (https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/working_class https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/working_class) does seem to include everyone who works, it points out that it is "especially in manual or industrial work". Wikipedia consensus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_class) also disagrees with your definition in that the working class are engaged in manual labor and not in any wage generating employment. Further, most people who have adequate capital to sustain them are basically financially independent and could effectively retire, unless they are 60-70 and have been saving for years this isn't an accurate representation of the middle class, upper middle class, possibly.
- edward 9y agoIf you're interested in this topic I recommend you read Nomadland by Jessica Bruder.
- drdrey 9y agoAlso: https://www.topic.com/life-inside-the-rvs-of-silicon-valley https://www.topic.com/life-inside-the-rvs-of-silicon-valley
- lisper 9y agoTen years ago I made an attempt to get a homeless person off the street and made a movie about it: http://graceofgodmovie.com/ http://graceofgodmovie.com/ My main subject had a masters degree in psychology.
- base698 9y agoReminds me of this: https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/11/hipsters_on_food_stamps_part_2.html https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/11/hipsters_on_food_sta... > Why does her PhD make her more deserving that a welfare queen? Because to The Chronicle, the PhD has value. It doesn't. I'm not saying she isn't smart, I'm saying the PhD in no way communicates to me she knows medieval history better than any D&D player. She may know more, but how do I know? I don't even find "MD" particularly valid, but at least you can sue a doctor. > But my reason for showing you her is to highlight the perverse logic of the university which will doom us all: since the only maniacs who would ever hire these PhDs are universities, then the solution to their unemployment is more money for universities:
- aphextron 9y agoI'll be facing this soon as well, at least they've got RV's. After getting back from my third open house for the week, with double digit atendees, I think the bay area just isn't for me. A perfect credit score and a job making double the median wage is not enough to land a 1 bedroom apartment apparently. I'll probably end up sleeping on someones couch for a few months to finish my work contract, and get out of this hellscape for somewhere people can actually live.
- justherefortart 9y agoMove outside the city. I lived in Pacifica. Pretty much anything along BART is easy to get into the city. I parked at Colma where fortunately the dead don't drive :-) Pacifica was awesome because you're just a hill from the hustle and bustle but it felt like a detached town. So many nice people there. Hwy 1 is annoying at rush hour (or most hours) but it was a really nice community.
- pj_mukh 9y agoSame. Moved out to Oakland, I can easily get studios and 1Bdrm apt's (they cannot fill my condo). Takes me 20mins to get into work on BART. I don't like the term "Fake News" because journalism is alive and strong today, but the media certainly has its narratives and loves picking and choosing stories. The reality is just a lot more boring.
- hashkb 9y agoI don't think you're facing what they're facing. Sounds like you make quite a bit more than the people profiled in this article.
- losteric 9y agoHis anecdote is more powerful because of his income. You'd expect someone with low income to have trouble finding housing... that's a problem, but the situation makes sense. When someone struggles to find housing while making multiples of middle income, something is deeply fucked. That says a lot about how bad it is for everyone else.
- sologoub 9y agoLA really needs to work on providing restrooms. The RV convoys aren't really that much of a problem themselves (some individuals are, but so can be those with homes). Instead what they leave behind is a problem - feces, urine and trash. I'm sure most people would rather not do this on a sidewalk or under an overpass, but if they have no other option it's hard to blame them. To add insult to injury, city has proven uninterested in increasing sanitation work to at least clean this up. Now LA and San Diego are facing diseases most developed countries only read about. I'm sure the city could organize a service to place mobile restrooms at a reasonable cost. I'd be more than willing to pay extra sales tax for this and it would generate jobs for companies that maintain them. EDIT: It's worse than I thought - in skid row (granted this might be an extreme) 9 toilets for roughly 1800 people! Source: http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-bathroom-protest-20171024-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-bathroom-protest...
- nradov 9y agoSan Diego has been suffering a hepatitis outbreak and city health workers have had to sterilize downtown streets. It's hard to believe this is happening in an affluent country. http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/health/sd-me-hepatitis-update-20171031-story.html http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/health/sd-me-hepati...
- paulus_magnus2 9y agoYou have no business being in #1 cities if you don't have monetary capital to go along your skills. In London home prices (average) increases every year by more than average salary. If you've not bought in, you're being better off somewhere else. No point in earning $200k (gross) if $50k (net) is hoovered up by someone in rent.
- pjc50 9y agoLand of opportunity, eh? I bet there are plenty of people arguing that if you ever want to make decent money you have to be in the #1 cities.
- sbuttgereit 9y agoYeah, doesn't mean they're correct in taking that position. I hear a lot of people talking in raw dollars about what they make, or what someone else makes, or what differences are in what people make etc. and the arguments miss a lot of important context and the important motivators. Most important is not what you make, but are you producing enough to be happy? And more important to that question is what purchasing power do you have on any given salary/location. If you make 6 figures, which I'm pretty sure still today is, on a U.S. national level, still making decent money... but can't afford even to rent your own apartment... then so what? If your low six figure income gives you a lesser standard of living in a #1 city than a mediocre five figure income in a lower tier city... to me the lower income city is more appealing. What a #1 city can do for you is give you a much higher chance of a very, very good income: those #1 cities are where the movers and shakers and related money are.... but the number of people that will ultimately reap those benefits are small and the competition is very stiff because of the point you've made. I'd also wager that if you aren't already very clearly/obviously on the path to a mover and shaker role by the time you're getting out of college (because of who is in your sphere of solid relationships or what you've already accomplished, or both) you're very unlikely to ever get there even if you go to a #1 city. Or as they taught me in music school... if you ain't made it by thirty, you ain't gonna. Me, I'd take the lesser city and work towards being the big fish in a little pond. I've done this with choice of companies to work for over my career and probably have done well because of it; more varied and interesting work for me individually, as well as more influence over what actually gets done... and not bad pay by any means. Just not prestigious. You still have to have something to offer even then, though, but the competition is much less stiff and so the odds for achieving happiness, the real goal vs. money, can be much better.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIts always sad to hear how people doing the right things getting caught up in circumstances that puts them on the wrong side of the power curve with respect to keeping their heads above water. I looked into the safe parking initiatives a bit. I've noticed more folks living in RVs around town in various parking lots or on quiet side streets. It seems a bit like a no-brainer that if you have some extra land that isn't doing anything you should be able to just let people park on it without the fear of being hassled by the police or community members. But when you look at it closely what you are talking about are re-inventing the trailer park. Try to get a permit to build one of those in the bay area, not easy.
- stickfigure 9y agoBut when you look at it closely what you are talking about are re-inventing the trailer park. I really feel it's a shame that this isn't more accepted. What is a trailer park but cheap high-density housing? We have people living in tents under bridges. Surely cheap temporary housing with proper sanitation would be a major improvement.
- gimmeminusnow4 9y agoIts sad, that people found this kind of living as "normal" these days. Question is, why do you live for in this lifetime ? .. are you living to work only ? Is your value as human measured in work ? ... oh my this is sad to read. People, lets make something together.. lets make sure, that we do not have to be sleeping in streets, while megabillion companies are using and abusing people much as possible.. then they put you out without any warnings.. oh my how sad life is today. Also, can you say technology sector is your favourite work ?? I am starting to thing little by little, manual job and services are going to keep you still in business after 10 years also. This technology job and industrial sector is waaaaay to hyped.
- currymj 9y agoi think reading about people suffering misfortunes like is naturally very frightening. my instinct is to scramble for reasons why this is abnormal, or the result of avoidable mistakes, or due to a unique situation that isn't likely to be repeated. the just-world fallacy in action. the fact is, there are lots of stories like this. maybe you're immune because you live in a more reasonable place or your strong technical skills or whatever. then again, 30 years ago being a paralegal was a good job and working people could afford to live in places like Santa Barbara. it's a fact that you could be next. we can't predict the future, there will only be more and more upheavals and disruption in the economy, unless things change drastically. employers and investors are working very, very hard all the time to devalue and deskill engineering. maybe your RV will be self-driving though.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoI was an exchange student at UCSB for 1 year. The US government caused me a lot of visa issues because I didn't have $25,000 cash, which meant that I couldn't get a job and had to pay $900 in fees for a visa application that was eventually denied. Due to family issues, I also wasn't getting support from my parents that year. AS CAB (the Associated Students Community Affairs Board) gave out free hot dogs on Tuesday nights to people who attended a lecture. The Engineering department had companies coming to give careers talks, where they gave out free pizza. There were free concerts by Storke Tower on Thursday lunchtime where free ice cream was provided. CAB also organised a breakfast for homeless people (including the legendary Pirate) in the park on Wednesday mornings. KGCC is a Korean Christian group that has food at every event. The ISA International Student Association has cookies on Friday afternoon every week, and ISI (International Students Inc, a Christian group) has a proper meal once a month. Two other people (one from Europe, one from Asia) were attending all these activities, so we soon became friends. One of them heard about free pizza being given away at the store at Buchanan when it's closing time. So we went down there, and sure enough, there was food. Every day! This went on for weeks. But one time, we came too late. All the pizza and daily sandwiches, each wrapped in plastic, were already put inside a black trash bag. That was my introduction to dumpster diving, which continued for the rest of that year. The weird thing was that because my rent was pre-paid, I wasn't homeless - just completely broke. Transport wasn't too much issue because hitchhiking up and down the coast was quite easy. I slept outside in LA during one of those travels, but after that, my dumpster diving friend told me about CouchSurfing. I now host the weekly CouchSurfing meetup, and have a guest staying today. So short-term accommodation was free too. Meeting people at the homeless breakfast made me realise how was to their situation, though. There's nothing like praying "Give us today our daily pizza" and "Thank you for this food", when God is really the only one taking care of you. America is a land of extremes. There are some incredibly wealthy people, but there's also poverty right next door. I think that situation breeds crime. My situation now is much more comfortable - I earn much less, but I feel totally safe not locking my bike when I go into a convenience store.
- stevenwoo 9y agoWhere did you go for the situation to change so drastically?
- d_burfoot 9y agoCalifornia has the highest rate of poverty in the US, when you factor in cost of living: http://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2017/jan/20/chad-mayes/true-california-has-nations-highest-poverty-rate-w/ http://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2017/jan/20/... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_poverty_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_poverty...
- brandonmenc 9y ago>Phil said people may wonder why vehicle dwellers like himself don't move in with family. Well, good for those who are able, but easier said than done, said Phil. His son is already sharing space because of the high cost of housing. Again, this just boggles my mind. I understand there are people who are on bad terms with their family, but sans that, I cannot imagine a situation where my 60+ year old parents living alone in a van is in any way better than all of us sharing a studio apartment, even if we were sleeping on the floor.
- jstarfish 9y agoDealing with your parents' alcoholism, drug abuse and/or mental illness for 18 years and being none too enthusiastic to continue to do so is one situation. It gets worse when they start stealing, destroying property and procuring drugs, and you find it's too late to get rid of them thanks to eviction/tenancy laws. Not everybody's families are Rockwell portraits.
- brandonmenc 9y agoI addressed those cases in my comment, but I'm specifically talking about stubborn boomers grasping on to shreds of independence and wanderlust when they don't have to. It seems a significant number of the people featured in these articles fall into that category.
- davidw 9y agoAlways worth mentioning on these threads: http://www.sfyimby.org/ http://www.sfyimby.org/ - these people are doing real work and getting stuff done. In San Francisco, Sonja Trauss is running for supervisor: http://www.sonja2018.org/ http://www.sonja2018.org/ - well worth a donation if you care about housing in that area.
- domenukk 9y agoReminds me of the few months I lived in Santa Barbara, it took over two weeks to find an overpriced room, during that time we also slept in the car close to the beach... It's fun in the beginning then it gets really tough.