22 ms·
When should behaviour outside a community have consequences inside it?
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThe answer is simple: never.
- pjc50 9y agoIt's very easy to not read the article, isn't it? Then drop in a sweeping generalisation that says it's completely fine to have a murderer write your filesystems.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoI read the article, thank you. It is completely fine to have a murderer write your filesystems. Accepting patches from someone who writes good code and treats everyone involved with respect is the right approach.
- matt4077 9y agoBut would you marry someone who contributed to FAT?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- watwut 9y agoWhat about accepting non trivial patch from someone who smuggled backdoor for lulz to another project 3 years ago?
- Sephr 9y agoFraud is very different from murder, and I understand why someone would be worried about accepting contributions from a known fraudster. I would not give their contributions extra attention (you should be suspect of all changes, regardless of the author) and I would not ban them from contributing unless they became disruptive or subversive to the project. They served their time; you don't need to punish them further. They are probably even less likely to commit fraud when their employer is aware of a previous fraud conviction. The worst fraudsters don't come with a "convicted of fraud" warning—they have evaded being caught and will seem just like any other contributor.
- mannykannot 9y ago> They served their time; you don't need to punish them further. It is not about punishing them, it is about reducing the risk of others. Having served time is, at best, no indication of whether a person will revert to their former behavior. > The worst fraudsters don't come with a "convicted of fraud" warning—they have evaded being caught and will seem just like any other contributor. This is no reason for not using what information you do have. Note: I see that you have edited your original post to address these points, but I think they still stand, as expanded on in the continuing discussion below. Your statement "they are probably even less likely to commit fraud when their employer is aware of a previous fraud" seems to be in agreement with what I have been saying.
- Sephr 9y agoIt's a reason to be equally suspicious of all code changes regardless of the publicly known reputation of a contributor, as it always comes down to the code itself.
- mannykannot 9y agoYou are still arguing against using the available evidence. You never have the time and resources to fully validate anything of use, so you have to use your judgement as to how best to go about it. If you learn that a person responsible for some aspect of security has been found guilty of defrauding his church's charity drive, it would be prudent to take a second look at his code.
- watwut 9y agoAbsolutely. Then again, code review is never perfect and it is easy to miss hard to see cosequence of something subtle. Especially if I tentionally hidden. So, trust matters. If you have track record of doing such things, then accepting your pull request comes with higher risk.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThis is a good example, I agree that such a person probably isn't welcome - with a few caviats: - Small (and well scrutinized) patches from this person are fine - At some point forgiveness is due, maybe 3 years is at that point depending on the severity of their backdoor
- _qbxp 9y agoDevil's advocate on this - what if the general population of your customers don't want to support a company that pays the salary of a murderer? Then it affects your bottom line. Would you still be ok with it?
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThis is about FOSS projects, which are generally unpaid.
- Sephr 9y agoWhy do you care if a murderer wrote your filesystems? I care about the security and correctness of the code. I only care about the author who wrote it if they are someone known for low-quality, insecure, or malicious code. If Linus Torvalds is convicted of genocide and child abuse tomorrow I'm going to continue using Linux as usual.
- Jonnax 9y agoThat's fine for you. But other people can have objections to it as is their right to. If you're part of a group and a chunk of them decide to leave, there's no point saying "why do you care about X? It doesn't affect the group." It's their right to leave. The other side is that who you associate with defines that group. So if it was a murderer that wrote a file system, then the software project gets defined by that. It becomes hard to attract contributors when the project gets defined by the actions of one of its participants. Project leaders then have to make a decision since inaction is also a decision.
- AstralStorm 9y agoIt is their right to leave, but is it their right to shame unrelated people who do not want to leave? There is a point where the shaming and shunning stops being useful and becomes bullying. We see this all the time in politics worth people liking "their team" too much and denigrating normal citizens just for their opinions and choices.
- VLM 9y ago"It becomes hard to attract contributors when the project gets defined by the actions of one of its participants." I'm unaware of anyone ever making a decision about contributing to a software project based on secret police level surveillance of current team members political or religious opinions. Even classified DoD stuff I've been involved in isn't that creepy. Its important to focus discussion on extremes such as murders when the actual goal is to make sure Republicans are unemployable.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoYou're changing the contents of the article though; it's about "communities", not software products. It's much easier to separate code from persons; strip off the committer name / email and you're left with code which rarely contains anything behavioural besides maybe inappropriate jokes / puns which are usually easily fixed. Not so with communities, which are much more about people and interactions.
- jjII2221 9y agoFor context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Reiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Reiser
- codinghorror 9y agoI suspect the answer is not, in fact, that simple.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoI encourage you to submit counterexamples. I'm about to get on a plane, though, I'll have to present my counterargument in a few hours.
- viraptor 9y agoThe article contains counterexamples. You can start from those if you really think they're not reasonable (i.e. the answer is never)
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThe only tangible example I really see in the article is the following: >For instance, if someone acts entirely reasonably within your community but engages in lengthy anti-semitic screeds on 4chan, it's legitimate to question whether permitting them to continue being part of your community serves your community's best interests. s/anti-semetic/anti-abortion/ s/anti-semetic/pro-abortion/ s/anti-semetic/pro-trump/ s/anti-semetic/non-religious/ What do all of these have in common? Answer: absolutely no relevance to the project. If your software is an app that serves the Jewish community and some participant was an anti-semite, then okay, maybe you should eject them. If your project is almost anything else, then leave your opinions at the door and engage with them respectfully so long as they grant you the same courtesy.
- viraptor 9y agoYou're mistaking a claim that a group of people based on their ethno-religious background is either worthless or to be blamed for multiple world issues (which historically led to killing them) with an opinion we can be respectful about.
- 9y ago
- virgilp 9y agoNot really "never". I get where you're coming from, but sometimes, the behaviour outside the community does have consequences for the community; at least in those circumstances, it is appropriate - imperative, even - for the community to react and weigh in on the consequences. And you can easily imagine other cases, too (e.g. where behaviour outside community raises reasonable suspicions about behaviour inside the community - there should at least be the consequence of "increased oversight")
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThis comment appears carefully composed to provide a lot of words that look engaging without much I can actually respond to. How about some examples?
- calcifer 9y agoI'll bite. Let's say I'm in charge of a FOSS project to which you and I are both contributing to. If I find out you are posting white nationalist propaganda on Twitter, I'll kick you out of the project, simply because I don't like white nationalists and don't want the project to appear welcoming to them.
- commenter1 9y agoYou probably wouldn't hire ex-cons either, because, you know, you don't want to appear welcoming criminals.
- Deestan 9y agoThat is a strained corollary. Ex-cons have a shitty past. White supremacists are currently and actively shitty.
- commenter1 9y agoAh, I see! So if one does a crime, but has done the time, one is ok. If one hasn't done a crime but does something you don't agree with, then it's bad. Thank you for clarifying!
- mannykannot 9y agoThis is what is simple: people who have demonstrated a willingness to act in a deceitful or otherwise destructive way cannot be trusted, at least until they have demonstrated rehabilitation. Community does not complicate this simple fact.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThis is precrime. And how do you rehabilitate them without giving them the opportunity to participate in the community? Deal with problems when they occur.
- mannykannot 9y ago> This is precrime. Exactly - a lack of trustworthiness can be demonstrated long before any crime has been committed. > And how do you rehabilitate them without giving them the opportunity to participate in the community? Your use of 'community' in this argument precludes there being an inside and outside, so it is not relevant to the question posed in the article's title. Furthermore, there is an answer - rehabilitation starts in environments where the risk is limited.
- ThrowawayR2 9y agoAnd when public opinion changes so that your political opinions are out of fashion, that same "precrime" argument will be used to lock you out of society. Authoritarian liberals seem to forget that what goes around, comes around.
- mannykannot 9y agoMy mistake - I took 'precrime' to mean simply an act that does not or has not yet amounted to a criminal act, but I see it is a term of art for punishing people on the basis of what they might do. There is nothing very wrong, IMHO, in choosing who you put your trust in and with who you associate on the basis of what they have already done. The first three words of the article are "free software communities...": its not about society as a whole, or any situation where exclusion could reasonably be considered punishment.
- orwin 9y agoIf you're convicted of pedophilia (or rape) in a country, you should not be allowed to be alone with kids (or women) in another (like Polanski in the western world, but other examples exist). Should you? But if you think that "passive" political action (i.e just being present at a rally, not being a speaker) outside a community should not have consequences inside the community, i think i agree with you (for now, i don't have put much thought into it, my opinion is not definitive).
- kazagistar 9y agoThe first part is a separate issue, that of forgiveness and redemption, and if they should be allowed in a society. The second part is about if judgements about smaller issues should spread beyond their original contexts. I think for most people, the lines are determined by the magnitude of the crime, but where those lines lie is a personal and communal preference. At what point is an injustice so great that it cannot be overlooked even in different contexts? And at what point is it so great that it cannot ever be redeemed in thr future?
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y ago>If you're convicted of pedophilia (or rape) in a country, you should not be allowed to be alone with kids (or women) in another (like Polanski in the western world, but other examples exist). Should you? No, but what does pedophila or rape have to do with software? You don't let convicted child molesters hang out with kids for obvious causal reasons but no such relationship exists with software.
- Jonimus 9y agoThis is rich coming from someone who has been banned from as many communities as you have. I've seen at least 3 cases of you joining a community and then getting banned for poor behavior and would think no less of any community choosing to prevent you from joining in the first place.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoAh, the classic ad hominem attack from an old member of the cancerous TI community. Never gets old.
- eponeponepon 9y agoThis is a question worth discussing. But I'm not sure I like the implicit assumption that a "community" is a discrete entity entirely divorced from all other such entities. If you're contemplating a person's activities outside a particular social group, you aren't asking "does this affect my social group?", but rather "what impact does this have on society at large?" I can't see that it's controversial to suggest that someone may act in one context in a way that should have consequences for their activities in another context - we quite happily accept, for instance, that a violent drunk ought not to be permitted to teach children, even if they have never been drunkenly violent towards children. I don't see that a software development project should be any different from any other subset of human society in this respect.
- mjg59 9y agoSoftware development projects are somewhat different in that they frequently include a large number of people from very disparate cultural backgrounds and little in-person social contact. The lack of the sort of social cohesion that we see in more traditional social groups is part of the reason that open source projects are increasingly adopting explicit behavioural guidelines, but the risk there becomes that those guidelines are considered the totality of what should be taken into account when determining whether someone does more harm than good within a community. Coming up with a more formalised set of considerations for external behaviour would help there.
- eponeponepon 9y agoI don't think this is peculiar to software development though. The same is true of discussion fora, gaming organisations, multinational businesses - the extent to which it's an issue in the modern connected world is greater, sure, but it's not a direct result of wider communication. I'm willing to bet it was an issue thousands of years ago in busy trading centres too. edit: this is an interesting aside: "Coming up with a more formalised set of considerations for external behaviour would help there." Isn't this to some extent what religions have been trying to do for millennia?
- 9y ago
- arkades 9y agoProblem with these sorts of discussions is that they torture the meaning of the word “community.” Most of these aren’t. Rephrase as: when should your public reputation among one set of people affect your public reputation among another set of people? When should that latter effect result in consequences? And then the answer is obvious: whenever the latter set of people find your public behavior to be unwelcome, regardless of which context you chose to unveil it in.
- throwaway-hn123 9y agoExactly this. Scenario. - I form a community around developing an open source learning system for children. - some person joins the community and is civil and even contributues patches. - the community find out he is an active child molester, but has not done anything of that sort within my community. - There is not a chance in hell that I would keep him in the community End of story.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vlehto 9y agoI see your point but you didn't really tackle the problem at hand. To detach the situation from current feelings, let's take a time trip back to hypothetical year ~1975. Let's say it's illegal to register a NGO, company or anything that has a rule of "no sexual group X allowed". Now let's say that there is some guy who is absolutely brilliant at playing the violin, but has at some point allegedly done some homosexual approach to straight guy. Which any gay would have just brushed away, but now it was taken as harassment. We have obviously created a situation where it's impossible for that violinist to take part in any orchestra. No "only gays & women orchesta" is allowed by law. Society completely wastes that human resource. Some male musicians somewhere possibly have slightly better work security. But the cost is that millions of people never hear the recordings of that great violinist. You have to pick: A. Allow organizations to be completely self selecting. This would have a set of short term problems and it's currently not kosher at all. B. Allow alleged transgressors to somehow wipe their record clear. Seems practically impossible during internet age and click headlines. C. Force people to be cool about people who have allegedly transgressed in some way in some other social setting. But now you lose productivity of whole teams, not just some individuals here and there. D. Lose a lot of human resources. And probably for petty reasons. If allegation is enough, you can destroy too competitors easily. As shown by the red scare, Stalins purges, etc. This was originally a case about a programmer allegedly groping some women. Seems like if you could start a company of "former sexual harassers inc", you could soon hire lots of splendid talent dirt cheap. Then you just need to somehow hide the origin of the products being made to the consumers. But soon even that won't matter much if there is anything to be learned from the music industry.
- heisenbit 9y agoBoundaries are imho critical to give structure to society. The advances in technology and more so the pervasiveness and persistence of communication is eroding the previous boundaries between groups, places and time. Past transgressions now have an impact today often way beyond the statues of limitation. In most of these discussions the reason these statues exist are ignored. Discussions in one place affect another place. Behavior that is questionable in a classroom becomes national news. Postings in a closed online forum of sexual nature affects standing in an online collaboration community working on software. When boundaries are torn down cultures clash. Some of it may be healthy. But without boundaries would there be culture?
- candiodari 9y ago> Boundaries are imho critical to give structure to society. Looking at history I would even say that boundaries, as in the "need" to give a superior moral position to a favored class, whether an economic class, intellectuals, a military class, or priesthood, was always where these boundaries were. The thing you can't see is that your/our "boundaries" are no different. And every single time, those boundaries turned out to be, not "for trade" (e.g. the Roman Empire), "for the military" (e.g. the second Islamic dynasty), intellectuals (e.g. the French revolution - the first part, or Communism in Eastern Europe) or "for morality" (e.g. the West in the middle ages). I mean, I'm sure there was a period of, say, a decade, where they actually did what it said on the label. It never lasted. Every single time, those "boundaries" served to guarantee the comfort of a favored class. Firstly, to safeguard their positions of power and comfort, their fortunes, but later even their ideas and egos. The real boundary we are wanting to impose is that "we are right". And it's real, real simple. There is a tiny little issue: We Are Wrong Boundaries do impose structure. The structure does not change, and the world does. That's fundamentally why the boundaries are wrong and the structure will not hold. I do not know how or where exactly we are wrong, but we are wrong (although I have some ideas: any 5 year old, old enough to talk intelligently, but not old enough to be assimilated yet, will tell you when you walk with them through any city what we are terribly wrong about. There's plenty, I might add). And that sucks. If it turns out that we are most catastrophically wrong about a moral issue, it will suck REAL bad. And that's happened before. Plenty of times. It is funny how you see the bay area aging. When we started out, most were in our late teens, early twenties at best. And of course we all felt the same: society is VERY wrong. In all sorts of ways. For instance, women are not different, and certainly not inferior. We KNEW that 20 years ago. But now we're 40, and we feel that, dammit, we're right. And these kids, who seem to prefer economic gains over social issues. Lazy bastards ! And, like the rich 30 years ago, we've decided (whilst having pretty much every creature comfort we like) that moral issues (that just happen to keep our place in society safe and secure) are real important. And these upstart youngsters (who do not in fact enjoy many of our creature comforts), they're bad, mmmkay ! Dammit ! They MUST be stopped. They will, of course, defeat us. Nothing can stop them. And they will clobber more than some of our ideas. And, they will abandon some of our morals. The thing is, this is a good and healthy thing to happen.
- matt4077 9y ago“The private is political” comes to mind... It used to be that you interacted almost exclusively face-to-face, within a small community. One of the better consequences was a sort of instant feedback loop, where your actions that hurt others were quickly reflected back onto you: abandoned your ailing grandmother? The local grocer will stop giving you credit. These were social feedback mechanisms. They have the benefit of being much more subtle than the criminal justice system, and kicking in much earlier. It’s ridiculous how some in the tech community pretend these mechanisms don’t exist, or that they should not exist: every time you have decided who to invite to your birthday party, or who to sit with at lunch, you have taken such considerations into account. People are social animals. They use social cues to reward beneficial actions, and punish even slight misdeeds. This is necessary to establish standards of behavior, or basic human decency. There should be limits to this process, the most important of which is time. No one should be forced to reveal to his neighbors that he is a “sex offender”, ten years after drunkenly taking a piss in a public park. Nor should your teenage shenanigans be the top hit in google for eternity. But standing a front of a synagogue on a Saturday, with a torch, a gun, a swastika flag? Yeah, you better believe your friends and coworkers will look funny at you come Monday.
- rthille 9y agoBut what if my teenage shenanigans were really really good? Can I keep the top spot for eternity then?
- Dowwie 9y agoA growing challenge that communities face is where an activist minority act against a member based on an agenda that is not representative of the larger community yet influences as if it were.
- lkerrekfjk 9y agoOpal gate is the canonical example of this: https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 It's interesting the "complainer" ended up being hired by github then fired from the same github.
- rubyfan 9y agoI think having online anonymity and a reasonable ability to create pseudonyms to keep your communities separate is important and often overlooked. I think it’s not OK for one community to be the moral authority over aspects of ones life, most especially a community in which you are volunteering and contributing in good standing.
- croon 9y agoAs with a lot of things, I believe in a balance. I agree that anonymity in a lot of areas are crucial; oppressive regimes, whistle-blowing, private/sexual preferences, whatever have you. But as we've seen in the last year, complete anonymity and untraceability everywhere can have bad consequences; astro-turfing, smurfing, attention-ddos:ing, FUD, anti-net neutrality-comment identity theft. In some of these cases a central e-ID (which a lot of nations have) could have mitigated those issues, in others, not so. Ideas should live on their own merit, in which case the identity of the source is irrelevant, but (pardon my French) idiots make the case that logic and merit of ideas don't take center stage. In those cases I believe it's kind of relevant to know if you're buying into group think that is 80% bots, 5% trolls, 5% adversarial agents, etc. Anonymity is one solution to the problem of being able to keep dissenting opinions, but a solution with severe side effects. Transparency with a strong protection of freedom of ideas is another route. I guess to put it succinctly: I don't need to know the names or faces of the people I carry conversations with, only that they're real, unique people. It shouldn't matter, but recent history shows otherwise.
- rubyfan 9y agoGreat perspective. Without question there are definitely risks that anonymity introduces. But there is an effective tyranny of free expression when parties are forced to use their names. The protections of liberty afforded on paper don’t always play out in real life. In theory we have protections of free association, freedom of religion, free speech and we’re all entitled to equal protection under the law - this doesn’t always play out. Too often mob rule has resulted in oppression of dissenting views and oppression of classes of people. Privacy, private communication, anonymous communication and pseudonymous communications are all essential for healthy society and discourse and cannot be written off because some would use them for nefarious purposes.
- cs1717p 9y agoThis whole question really stems from a sad and pervasive tendency for 'intelligent' people to overestimate their general expertise, and then apply their value judgements to individuals in their social circle, regardless of its utility or relevance. Examples of this: Alan Turing -- father of Computer Science shunned, at the time, because everyone had value judgements regarding his homosexuality (completely irrelevant to Computer Science). The Mozilla CEO fired for his personal donation in opposition to gay marriage. (Again, completely irrelevant to his relationship with the Mozilla project). This, of course, continues further, with things such as Hollywood blacklisting (today) Conservatives, and formerly Communists. The solution is simple: Within a community, individuals should only be judged based on their contributions and value within that community. If I am deeply opposed to gay marriage, but a fantastic coder, that should not affect my standing within a community that is entirely code focused. If I strongly believe in UFO visitations, and disbelieve climate change, but am a great graphic designer, that should not affect my reputation as an artist. Everyone is not expected to be right, or agreeable, about everything, with everyone else. Aiming for this is pointless. This inability to separate emotions and passions from cooperating on a shared focus with others, of differing emotions and passions, but equal interest in the shared focus (community) is deeply damaging. There are enough problems and difficulties getting skilled people together to work on something great -- there is no use at all in reducing that crowd of people further by limiting it to those who share ones views in any number of hot button issues. Leave politics to your political circles, make your own impressions of people before making personal judgements from reputation, find every reason to work together, not any excuse not to.
- pjc50 9y ago> deeply opposed to gay marriage, but a fantastic coder, that should not affect my standing within a community that is entirely code focused Do you think someone can really work effectively with their gay married co-contributors in this case? Being inclusive is great, but you have to recognise that including certain people drives others away from the project.
- cs1717p 9y agoCan a vegan work with someone with a non restricted diet? Can an atheist work with a muslim? In either case, the answer is the same: if the individuals behave professionally, yes. If the married gay couple are the ones freaking out at work about my hiring someone who posted against gay marriage on his blog two years ago, they are behaving unprofessionally and should be let go. If it is the anti-gay marriage advocate who is making snide comments about his colleagues at work (or, in the context of a non work environment, in a shared community forum), then it is he who should be excluded.
- wisty 9y agoThe risky assumption seems to be "we're the ones with all the power, and we'll only use that power to punish people who deserve it". Also, just for fun, google "Ted Ts'o".
- joncrane 9y agoAFAICT, the guy went a little too far out of his way to say that lots of rape accusations are fake? But the guy still has job and status, right? Just some social ostracism?
- syshum 9y agoBehavior outside a community should very little consequences inside of it. Of course there are some extreme cases where this might be a problem however those cases are extremely rare and should not generally be used for the basis of creating a Code of conduct or rule set The wider political climate in world today is making have to be that simple. While the article talks about more extreme cases like actual physical sexual assault, today far far far too many communities are using simple political disagreement and criticism and framing that as "harassment" using that "harassment" as method to remove any political dissenters from their ranks I have seen it attempted (some times with great success) in several open source projects. Personally I dislike the very concept of Codes of Conduct and I generally oppose most of the terms in many of the more modern Code of Conduct being pushed forward, likely as a result of my very libertarian political views. That said Codes of Conducts (should a community or project adopt them) should only be enforced based on actions WITH IN that community and/or toward people that are IN THAT community. Not generalized actions of people taken in other communities with a different set of conventions and rules. Code of Conduct should be seen as a contract of Behavior that all people agree to when voluntary associating with the community to treat all other MEMBERS of that community based on that code of conduct, it should not apply to conduct when interacting with people not a part of that community and thus never agreed to the code of conduct.
- naturalgradient 9y agoI completely agree, the code of conduct has been used multiple times as a trojan horse in the sense that it only contains things nobody could reasonably disagree with (because who would not want a welcoming environment), only to then be used to shun /outcast people based on views particularly on gender and diversity. This is one of the issues Sam Altman referred to in his blog that simply cannot be talked about in Silicon Valley currently.
- throwwayirony 9y agoNice post. But remember, there is default option that can not be turned off by any community, despite how bad/wrong their community standards: "When you can identify someone". Simple rule: Don't give same name twice. Practice safe opinions - don't reuse names. By the way much of post about opinions, not behavior. = thoughtcrime.
- DanielBMarkham 9y agoI'm going to upvote this, even though it's another in a long line of "I don't understand classical liberalism or the roots of our modern secular society" posts by various authors, both famous and not. At the heart of a lot of this is the simple question: is our larger world supposed to be one big social group? Some folks think yes. For those folks, if you have a small community, it's a legitimate question as to how much "control" you should have on members when they are outside that community. To me this is an answered question and the answer is no, small groups and large groups of people are completely different things. Trying to shoe-horn experiences and ideas about one group into the other group leads to nothing but heartache and disappointment. But since so many folks are struggling so much, it's a conversation that needs to continue for a while. Hopefully it will lead somewhere positive. ADD: I will, however, admit to having much frustration watching my tech friends struggle so much with concepts that should have been part of their early education. Speaking humorously, I reserve the right to buy an inflatable copy of "On Liberty" and start beating a few of them about the head with it if things don't change.
- adrienne 9y agoMake sure you also hook them up with a copy of Popper's essay on "The Paradox of Tolerance".
- danschumann 9y agoWell, when the inner community relies heavily on trust, such as a company where you handle peoples' money, or even teach them about money, I think integrity is such a highly valued quality, that you would be extremely sensitive to any sign that an individual lacks it ( ie acting differently in different situations, or cheating on their spouse, for example ). "If a spouse can't trust a person, why should I trust them as their boss?" -Dave Ramsey
- alexandercrohde 9y agoI think this article doesn't take a broad enough view of the question. As stated, it's a very large (and non-trivial) question. For example, as stated, the question includes questions like: - Should America care if somebody is convicted of a crime by a foreign nation? - Should a school care if a candidate to be a teacher was discovered viewing child pornography? - Should a job care if/why you got fired from your last job? - Should you care why your ex's last relationship failed? The answer to all of these is obviously "depends on the specifics." It's tempting to draw hard boundaries so as to prevent people from weaponizing politics. Unfortunately, I just don't think hard-boundaries are coherent here.
- quotemstr 9y agoThe answer is clearly "never" --- the attitude expressed in the article leads toward totalitarian control over people's personal lives. Toleration, as Europe took hundreds of years to painfully discover, is the way you build a cohesive society around people who disagree. When you ban cooperation among people with divergent political opinions, you not only lose out on any positive-sum productivity gains from the interaction, but also intensify these political differences and turn them into real rifts in society. I am disappointed in the contemporary trend to invest imaginary "harms" and propose remedies that, in the end, boil down to persecuting people for their beliefs. Altman is definitely right about the social atmosphere in tech. Imagining that we should, say, ban contributions to an open source project from someone who also participates in 4chan is part of the problem.
- saalweachter 9y agoSATSQ. Behavior outside a community should have consequences inside it when it has consequences inside it. If your behavior outside of a community causes an uproar and crisis inside the community when it becomes known, it has already had a consequence inside the community. It will already have future ramifications. All you can do at that point is decide whether you want the future ramifications to include a commendation, condemnation or silence from the community. Communities are not hermetically sealed environments. In my opinion it is silly and childish to pretend they are.
- fzeroracer 9y agoThis is one of the issues with this debate. As you mentioned if your behavior has caused an uproar/crisis, then it already has and will have consequences. People might quit, they might get angry and so forth. When people seem to talk about consequence in this manner they seem to mean that 'People should stop caring about what other people have said or done', even if it means ignoring things like how a person believes you are literally a lesser human being due to some trait you were born with. 'Diversity of Thought' as a statement has been latched onto as being an excuse rather than its original purpose.
- explainplease 9y ago> when it becomes known When "it becomes known" is a matter of one person going on a moral crusade to destroy the other person's reputation and position because of something about them, wholly unrelated to the project, which they personally dislike--is it still valid for there to be "consequences" within the community? If so, it seems like only a matter of time for all of us, because surely all of us do things or hold opinions that someone else in a community we participate in would find unacceptable. Therefore, all that is required for anyone to destroy anyone else is to "cause an uproar and crisis" about them. What will you say when someone causes an uproar and crisis about you?
- saalweachter 9y agoI'm not going to say it doesn't suck. Unrequited love sucks. Losing an election sucks. Being kicked out of a community sucks. Losing your job sucks. Doesn't matter if you "deserve" it or not. Still sucks. Maybe it sucks more when there's malice in the revelation, than if someone just sent an email to the wrong mailing list or if two people unexpectedly ran into each other somewhere neither expected the other to be. But the bell has been rung. What do you want people to do, to treat their feelings like jurors, "that evidence has been obtained improperly, you are instructed to disregard it."?
- junkscience2017 9y agoits quite simple really, if you are a conservative at a Silicon Valley company, just lie to anyone who tries to reveal your belief system. real shame we don't have a President Sanders...yes, really, oh yes I agree...
- geebee 9y agoThere's a difference between behavior and speech, though it can become a fuzzy line (is a large donation behavior or speech?). One thing some of the comments have touched on is the notion of "beyond the pale" - a term that somewhat ironically (for this discussion) refers to occurrences outside the bounds of British law. There are opinions that fall outside the standards of decency, and this can, legitimately, make organizations reluctant to work with some people. Many issue positions, over time, can go from widely accepted, to controversial, to widely discredited, to beyond the pale, essentially and uncontroversially indecent. If this is the case, it's almost certain that we're going through this process right now. Unfortunately, there is also a strong political tendency to scold and smear and be as uncharitable as possible to the other side. In aggregate, people get accused of being on the "wrong side of history" at least twice as often as they actually are, since these accusations go in both directions on virtually every controversial topic.
- stillhere 9y agoOnly when it is brought into the organization.
- CM30 9y agoI still think the answer here is 'never', communities should be as self contained as possible and not try and take over personal lives. To do otherwise reminds of those schools that try and punish students (and sometimes teachers) for actions done in their free time; an absolutely ridiculous overreach that makes things worse rather than better. And I stick by that for communities I run. On every site I'm an admin/founder, the rule is that (legal issues excepting), we won't punish you for things done outside of the community. It's not our place to do so, and we have no interest in witch hunting or trying to find reasons to deplatform people for things they do in their free time elsewhere.
- smoyer 9y agoThis is an interesting post - not because of the content provided by the author but because of this discussion thread!