12 ms·
Internet Chemotherapy
- matthberg 9y agoThe site either went down or was removed, is there an archive anyone knows of?
- alkyl 9y agohttps://archive.fo/RTVpt https://archive.fo/RTVpt
- aalleavitch 9y agoAny tools someone can recommend for de-obfuscating this?
- megous 9y agoThere's no noteworthy obfuscation, aside from weird names of variables.
- nEuralNetS 9y agoWhat's the point of obfuscating then?
- pdkl95 9y agoClean exploit code could be used maliciously (or accidentally) by people that might not understand the true nature of the program. There is a tradition when releasing exploit code to obfuscate it or introduce obvious errors that make the code safe{,er}. This prevents script kiddies from immediately using it, while anybody who should be reading the code should be able to see through the obfuscation/errors.
- aalleavitch 9y agoI suppose a better question might be, then, does anyone have any resources for gaining a better understanding of how this exploit works?
- megous 9y agoMost of the value is in the data (common login credentials). The bulk of obfuscated code is probably stuff doing the network communication and perhaps some other mundane stuff, that you can do manually (over telnet, or whatever) if you like and don't care about creating a botnet.
- AlexCoventry 9y ago> You can download the module which executes the http and telnet-based payloads from this router at http://91.215.104.140/mod_plaintext.py http://91.215.104.140/mod_plaintext.py. Link's not working. Anyone got a copy?
- pdkl95 9y agojust found this: https://github.com/JeremyNGalloway/mod_plaintext.py https://github.com/JeremyNGalloway/mod_plaintext.py edit: I would recommend extreme caution with that file. I'm still reading, but strings like this are worrying: 'busybox cat /dev/urandom >/dev/sda &'
- AlexCoventry 9y agoThanks.
- laretluval 9y agoFascinating. What's up with all the stuff like "if 81 - 81: ..."? Won't that just evaluate to false and never run?
- marten-de-vries 9y agoExactly. It's there to (very mildly) confuse you.
- sattoshi 9y agoperhaps that's how vulnerable devices were bricked?
- Operyl 9y agoHoly obfuscated Python, that's quite the jumbled mess. This is going to be a fun one to pick apart. I don't think the string is .. worrying on its own given that, you know, this thing is meant to kill IOT/etc devices that are insecure. I'd argue that just given the source (the internet) is enough reason to be wary.
- 9y ago
- matthew349hall 9y agoSomeone explain this please.
- nautilus12 9y agoWhat evidence is there that this really is the person responsible for brickerbot?
- eximius 9y agoSomeone with more knowledge may be able to corroborate events, or verify the authenticity of the payload he posted. For what its worth, the name rang a bell and I found this: https://gizmodo.com/this-hacker-is-my-new-hero-1794630960 https://gizmodo.com/this-hacker-is-my-new-hero-1794630960 The writings seem similar, for what little thats worth.
- putinontheritz 9y agoIt’s the same person.
- borromakot 9y agoHow do you know?
- nautilus12 9y agoYou're saying this editor is the hacker or that he fabricated this text? Would he really know enough to sound that credible? If not someone on here should be able to see right through it
- indigochill 9y agoMudge mentioned on his Twitter account (https://twitter.com/dotMudge/status/941373739681189888 https://twitter.com/dotMudge/status/941373739681189888) that a project like this had been requested in the DoD but was held back by politics. Victor Gevers is cited by Bleeping computer (https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/brickerbot-author-claims-he-bricked-two-million-devices/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/brickerbot-au...) as saying there are better ways of solving the problem than forcibly disabling/bricking devices. I'm curious what those are, though, since IoT manufacturers (speaking broadly) don't seem motivated right now to take even basic security precautions with their devices. I know some groups use sinkholes to redirect compromised devices, but while that can be useful for research it doesn't seem like it has the same motivational impact for change.
- yborg 9y agoThere's no incentive for manufacturers to do anything. This actually just increases sales, as dead devices are replaced (probably by the same device/firmware). Insecurity converts the equipment to a consumable that generates an annuity.
- DougN7 9y agoThis is the key problem. The manufacturer might even consider the poor security as a feature (for them)
- bigiain 9y agoThere's a couple of other problems there too - the "manufacturer" is often some unknown and unfindable usually Chinese contract electronics assembly firm, who had little to do with the design or software. The company who contracted them to do it often no longer exists a few years down the track. The place it gets sold can easily be somewhere like Ebay, AliExpress, or Kickstarter - where the vendor really isn't going to care once your payment has cleared. (Source: I was the platform security guy for an IoT startup in 2013/14, for a company who no longer exists and who's only product run is still out there somewhere no longer getting security updates...)
- djsumdog 9y agoIf what this person says is true, this kind of stuff is really dangerous and can get you in jail, even if your intent was just to show potential exploits. I wonder if this person's real identity is one anyone's radar currently.
- tzahola 9y agoThis is the situation we put ourselves in by constantly complaining that we can’t move fast enough and hiring “talent” straight from coding bootcamps. Brace yourselves, the time to eat your own dogfood is coming! :^)
- twic 9y agoThe devices in this story - routers, cheap IoT devices, etc - aren't products of bootcamp-hiring buzzword-spouting Silicon Valley companies, though. They come from a long tail of decades-old mid-sized electronics businesses with, AIUI, low margins and cultures that don't value software highly. It's not about JavaScript hipsters (for once!); this is much more related to the situation with terrible automotive software.
- mentos 9y agohttps://www.deccanchronicle.com/technology/in-other-news/171217/how-addictive-is-minecraft-it-led-people-to-create-the-mirai-botnet-for-business.html https://www.deccanchronicle.com/technology/in-other-news/171... "Paras Jha, Dalton Norman and Josiah were also a part of this normal Minecraft server entrepreneur game until they decided to force players from other servers on to theirs by clogging their networks. Therefore, Mirai came into existence and started performing for them very well. However, Mirai started outperforming the creator’s expectations, affecting the Internet outside Minecraft badly." "The creators of Mirai found potential in the botnet and therefore went on to fine-tune it to improve its abilities. They even started leasing Mirai to other cybercriminals, who used them around the world for their own vested interests." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirai_(malware) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirai_(malware) "Upon infection Mirai will identify "competing" malware and remove them from memory and block remote administration ports." From an evolutionary perspective its an interesting example of 'fitness'
- golergka 9y agoFrom an evolutionary perspective it's not that different from any start-up that pivoted from it's original goal after finding out it's real effectiveness. The only difference is the criminality of the activity.
- zaarn 9y agoMalware can be reasonably described using evolutionary mechanism (similar to Memetics), AVs and best practises create a evolutionary pressure in which only the fittest and most aggressive malware can win out. A lot of things in computer science and/or on the internet behave in ways not to dissimilar to evolution
- zokier 9y agoMy main feeling about all this is that "let it burn" probably is the only way to deal with the mess. It must have been pretty obvious from quite early on that trying to fight blackhats on level field as a single individual is not sustainable, and the time that he has been buying is in no way enough to employ the major cultural shift needed to improve the landscape. Attempting to suppress the attacks seems just to make people complacent, so it might be better just to let the attacks to do their damage and hope that those spur some improvement.
- rbanffy 9y agoThis is how the forests of California dealt with fires before humans started fighting them. As humans fought fires, there was a buildup of flammable material in the forests, making each successive fire incrementally worse.
- nautilus12 9y agoI was using this exact same analogy to explain this to someone earlier, although I have to admit that I agree with the person above. Going out and starting forest fires in national forests without official government sanction, even if your intention is to create controlled burns and prevent a bigger fire will still land you with a verdict of arson.
- rbanffy 9y ago> Going out and starting forest fires in national forests without official government sanction, even if your intention is to create controlled burns and prevent a bigger fire will still land you with a verdict of arson. No good deed goes unpunished.
- chii 9y agoIf there weren't any forest rangers/firefighters organization to back-burn, then the lone person trying to do some good may be the only way forward. But for forest fires, such an organization does exist, and no-one should be burning by themselves. There is no such organization for the internet. So we are left with lone white-hats who risk personal safety to do some good. I wish there's a better way.
- hi-im-mi-ih 9y agoDo not execute the random, obfuscated python code linked to from this paste. This could be bait, and could PWN you. This must be audited first before anyone runs it.
- quickthrower2 9y agoMy thoughts exactly. The "any programmer worth his salt" statement, followed by this link that you have to download to prove as a programmer you are worthy.
- 2bitencryption 9y agosay what you will, but this person knows how programmers think
- quickthrower2 9y agoYes we agree. That's what I am getting at. If he is genuine then OK. If he is trying to get control of your machine then well...
- lucb1e 9y agoObfuscated python, asking everyone to run it? Hah. Good one. Perhaps if you run it in VMWare which runs in Virtualbox which runs in Qemu... and even then. Never run such stuff bare on a machine you intend to still use afterwards. The irony, if running code from a post from the Brickerbot author would brick your laptop...
- AlexCoventry 9y agoJust spin up an aws t2.nano...
- Faaak 9y agoCurious question: how was the python code obfuscated ? Does there exists some obfuscation programs that obfuscate the code like that ?
- xwvvvvwx 9y agoIf it's true then this is fantastic work. Should really be the responsibility of the government. If a device is compromised it should be disabled. It could also set up a pretty nice incentive structure. If a device is bricked due to a vulnerability, then the manufacturer should have to either repair or refund the device. Corporations will not respond properly until it impacts their bottom line.
- wybiral 9y ago> If it's true then this is fantastic work. Should really be the responsibility of the government. Imagine the public backlash there would be if people knew that the government was scanning and hacking devices for the purpose of national security... As backwards as it seems I think people like the story of a rogue hacker more than the government protecting them.
- FooHentai 9y ago>Imagine the public backlash there would be if people knew that the government was scanning and hacking devices for the purpose of national security... /s ? If so, chortle chortle.
- megous 9y agoSo, given that he might have prevented more damage than he caused, if even the part of the recent DDoS reduction can be attributed to his activity, what to make of it? It can be more of a judgement on society if this person ends up in jail, while IoT makers keep making hefty profits being rewarded for their negligence, and ISPs keep making profits being rewarded for lying to their customers when shit happens and causing more damage than he ever could overall. It all seems to start and end with technical ignorance of the typical customer. There are popular shows that help pepople choose better food, by exposing shenanigans food makers engage in. Perhaps there could be something similar for tech in the future. Something where a hacker comes on TV and makes a total ridicule of some IoT crap device, and the show uses it to constatntly repeats the basics, like changing default credentials, etc. Same schema that works with food shows, expose someone as an example and add some generally useful advice. Perhaps this might become feasible when IoT is more popular.
- reacharavindh 9y agoWouldn't an intended side-effect of this action be the end-user getting educated about "why the device I bought doesn't work anymore?" and directly impacting the reputation of the company that manufactures that now-bricked device? I can only see it as a win-win. Except the internet connected medical devices that are insecure which if affected by such purging bots would literally impact lives. I hope vigilante script kiddies don't get involved with good intent and cause havoc.
- JChase2 9y agoHell's Kitchen for startups and tech with lots of quality expletives.
- joe_the_user 9y agoIt can be more of a judgement on society if this person ends up in jail, while IoT makers keep making hefty profits being rewarded for their negligence, and ISPs keep making profits being rewarded for lying to their customers when shit happens and causing more damage than he ever could overall. Masked comic book vigilantes aren't ever going to be a reality on the mean non-virtual streets of cities but on the Internet it seems we're confronted with something pretty much equivalent. So here can consult all the old issue of Marvel and DC for a compendium of moral dilemmas and result.
- nautilus12 9y agoIf you aren't a doctor and you start poisoning your friend with cancer's food does it really count as chemotherapy?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI think the analogy is to the entire Internet being a single body, and chemotherapy being a nasty thing done to it that damages it, but destroys even more damaging things in the process.
- rdiddly 9y agoThis is a question of credentials only. Which I don't mean to sound like I'm dismissing it at all - It's actually the whole reason this guy's effort got stranded. Chemotherapy is essentially controlled killing, to mitigate or prevent uncontrolled killing. Just like (as someone said elsewhere in this thread) controlled burning is done to mitigate or prevent uncontrolled burning. And here we have controlled hacking to mitigate uncontrolled hacking. Society doesn't support anybody killing, burning, or hacking, unless there's a way to know and recognize, that the person knows what they're doing. Which (the knowing and the recognizing) is a credentialing problem. It's the only difference between (doctors, police, firefighters, cybersecurity experts) and (quacks, vigilantes, arsonists and some-unknown-hacker), respectively. A guy I don't recognize as a surgeon, is just a masked man coming at me with a knife, even if he actually is a surgeon. If your intentions are good, you should take the trouble to get some kind of credentials, which can take many forms. (If your intentions are not-so-good then it makes a lot more sense to bypass that, but also for the public to put you in the "untrusted" basket.) This guy bypassed credentialing, and that places him in the realm of those who are not trusted no matter what kind of good they do. Now he can't continue. Instead of that, imagine there was a public debate about the relevant issues and this or a similar effort had actual public consensus and resources behind it. Now of course I'll grant there are numerous problems with the political process and consensus-building and all the rest of it. It takes a long time to get anything done, and learning how to hack is actually the easy part. Good news: This is actually not the emergency he claims it is. What's the worst-case scenario, the whole internet goes down tomorrow? Well, it's only the internet. There are ways of getting food, water and shelter without using a network at all. Nobody has forgotten how to use pen & paper. Even blankets will still work without an internet. (Not if these IoT clowns have their way of course.) Whatever, don't listen to me, I'm older and I lived almost half my life quite happily in a world where nobody had the internet, yet still everything got done. Anyway, the other thing is, a "state of emergency" is how all sorts of atrocities and shitty decisions are justified by governments, so it's not something to emulate. The attendant issues deserve to be publicly recognized, debated, decided and then tackled. Maybe it's wishful thinking to demand that much from people today.
- geofft 9y agoFrom https://twitter.com/GossiTheDog/status/941462338233946112 https://twitter.com/GossiTheDog/status/941462338233946112 : Before anybody else sends me the “Internet Chemotherapy” link or retweets it - it appears to be a wonderful piece of fan fiction. Deutsche Telekom suspect was arrested earlier this year, key details wrong, TR069 modem stuff was bad implementions crashing devices etc. (I haven't confirmed this myself)
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoWrong person, those are different incidents
- cjbprime 9y agoCan you elaborate?
- wybiral 9y agoI do regular scans myself and the number of these vulnerable DVR devices, printers, and routers you find exposed out there is mind-boggling! Run just a single instance something like this [1] (which isn't even well optimized) and within minutes you'll find vulnerable devices. It shouldn't be that easy to build a botnet. [1] https://github.com/wybiral/dex https://github.com/wybiral/dex
- lucb1e 9y agoYour readme doesn't say much. Looking at the scanner.py code, it appears you just send a GET HTTP/1.0 request and see what comes back. How do you determine vulnerable devices, response headers with versions?
- wybiral 9y agoThe response headers are kept in a SQLite db that you can perform regex queries on. It's surprisingly easy to find particular devices based on the headers. And, yes, it's just making basic HTTP requests on port 80 so it's overlooking tons of devices. But I run this from my own devices and doing blast scans of ports other than 80 can look a bit suspicious.
- AFNobody 9y agoDo you happen to know something similar that just targets LAN subnets?
- dang 9y agoThis made a brief previous appearance: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15931325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15931325. You guys will have to figure out what to make of it.
- sguav 9y agoAnd I'm still wondering why that got flagged while this got 100+ comments so far...
- dang 9y agoWho can fathom the mystery. That sort of wondering is an async call that will never be called back.
- thinkythought 9y agothe link died really fast
- angel_j 9y agothat's a lot of text; could be be used to analyze the authors writing style and match it to public {github, twitter,...} profiles
- gldalmaso 9y agoAren't people specially concerned to keeping anonymity already keen to this by now? The author can be deliberately mimicking style or going through translation in order to avoid this kind of analysis.
- javajosh 9y agoThis guy is a hero. He bricked vulnerable device before they could be used for DDOS, or worse. And he did it at great risk to himself. I say well done. The one point I disagree with is blaming the consumer. The simple truth is that security protocols have terrible UX, and until that improves nothing will change. Personally, I think it's time IoT was regulated and, in particular, we require a secure protocol at the time of deployment: IoT devices must be provably wiped, and then put into physical contact with an "owning" device before deployment. This, in turn, requires that people start using what I call a "Home Brain", a device who's primary purpose is to coordinate and secure all other devices that you physically own. I imagine simple versions to be as sophisticated as a router, and hackers might want to put together their own, something like a little home theater box. I suppose in a pinch your smartphone could work, too.
- baybal2 9y agoI suspected something like that from the beginning
- pwdisswordfish2 9y agoAuthor sounds like former US law student or someone who likes do do amateur legal research. "Attractive nuisance" is mentioned here and in a past missive.
- jhiska 9y agoThis guy knows he's in trouble for what he's done and decides to rewrite history to make himself out to be a "good criminal". Re-framed bragging about his criminal exploits and hilarious (in his mind) escapes from detection ensue. Frame it as ISP "conditioning" or as "criminal attack", fact of the matter is he committed crimes and now he's feeling the heat so he's putting out re-framed confessions to get the jump on his accusers and try to save his skin. Then again, people can be more complicated than I give them credit for, and he might actually be a good hacker. It has happened before. I don't know. Let the investigators find out the truth. We have no reason to trust him.
- mhils 9y agoFrom the linked document: > Deutsche Telekom Mirai disruption in late November 2016. My hastily assembled initial TR069/64 payload only performed a 'route del default' [...] AFAIK this is not what happened. Deutsche Telekom had one major incident on November 27th 2016, but that incident was caused by a denial of service attack [1]. Given that the routers in question don't even run Linux, 'route del default' is not really an option anyways, making the first claim of the story likely to be fabricated. This seems to be a good fictitious story, but nothing else. [1] https://comsecuris.com/blog/posts/were_900k_deutsche_telekom_routers_compromised_by_mirai/ https://comsecuris.com/blog/posts/were_900k_deutsche_telekom...
- eyeareque 9y agoLinux isn’t the only is with ‘route’
- Fej 9y agoWe as humans are pretty bad at responding to threats proactively. It takes some damage before we'll take action. In this case, IoT devices are going to have to take down some major infrastructure before we start regulating them.
- orliesaurus 9y agoI'm sorry to leave you in these circumstances, but the threat to my own safety is becoming too great to continue. I have made many enemies. If you want to help look at the list of action items further up. Good luck. This sounds scary - like it came straight out from a movie
- rixed 9y agoSo apparently I am the only one who think that device manufacturers shipping unsecure devices is not an excuse for an unrelated third party to damage it? The same as the fact I did not lock my door do not allow anyone to rob my home, that I did not replace my fire detector batteries is no excuse for anyone to set it alight, etc. To me good security starts by catching this guy and if he had done the damage he claims he had then make him pay for it. Only when one had been hold accountable for what he has done should we go after companies for negligence, no? "I discovered this security hole then proceeded to exploit it and damage some random system/workflow for the sake of demonstration" should not be acceptable.
- TadasPaplauskas 9y agoForgetting to lock the house or batteries in detector running out is an accident. Not providing secure and up-to-date firmware for devices which are known to be an easy targets is a company policy, which comes out of incentives (the cost of security is huge compared to the cost of a breach to IoT manufacturers). While we cannot/should not legislate against accidents, we sure can and must legislate against harmful policies. Shifting blame from companies to hackers simply is not as productive as making companies responsible for the quality of their product.
- bufferoverflow 9y agoYour unlocked door affects only you, buggy IoT devices affected thousands of devices and networks. It's more like discovering a remote-controlled car can be hacked and allow terrorists to drive it into crowds of people, and you have an option to brick such cars. I'd brick them all.
- golergka 9y agoI don't have a final opinion of who's right in this debate, but I can come up with a counter-argument. Your "lock my door" analogy is not complete. Imagine if you don't only don't lock your door, but also abandon your home, so criminals squat in there - and they end up terrorizing the whole neighborhood. Wouldn't it be logical for the police to at least barricade the place somehow? May be even fill doors and windows with cement, or take other measures to prevent squatting. It would still make it unusable for you, and you'd have to renovate if you ever return - but many would argue that it's a reasonable way of preventing the damage to the whole community around you.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoIm sure free market man is going to save us. Any second he will plunge through the clouds, his invisible fist coming to save us all..
- jodrellblank 9y agoFree market man isn't out to save people, he's out to adjust the market to be most profitable. Suffering is more profitable than not-suffering.
- yipopov 9y ago> his/her/hir Stopped reading there.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- HIPisTheAnswer 9y agoThe Host Identity Protocol (HIP) is the answer to this, and many more problems. We do not need to disable the dangerous devices if we can have an identity based network which allows us to whitelist the nodes we allow to interact with our devices. HIP would also allow mobility to work properly, and would render the network too opaque to efficiently spy upon. The Internet is incomplete: It is missing an Identity layer ... HIP!
- peterwwillis 9y agoThere are technical solutions for these problems, but nobody will adopt them. There are political solutions for these problems, but nobody will vote for them. There are social solutions for these problems, but nobody wants to take responsibility. Personally I'm waiting for a power plant to explode after someone runs a fuzzer on the internet. And for the inevitable law making security research illegal. And propaganda claiming foreign nations or terrorist organizations instigated the attacks (instead of bored 14 year olds, the more likely cause) used to support new pointless wars. And the intellectually flaccid xenophobic public, clamoring for more jobs and Internet-dependent TVs, fervently supporting it. But it could be worse.
- carapace 9y agoPretty much the only important part of this (tremendous!) message is the bit at the end: > "The real point is that if somebody like me with no previous hacking background was able to do what I did, then somebody better than me could've done far worse things to the Internet in 2017." One person.
- gspetr 9y agoYeah, that gave me a pause too. Then again, he might not have a "hacking background" but might have a strong embedded/networking background so he knows where to look, considering how he found exploits that blackhats missed. So either he's that good or blackhats are two-bit[0] criminals. [0] No pun intended.