9 ms·
Underground freeways? Wow. I didn't realize that was the target of The Boring Company. I thought it was a start at making Hyperloop a thing. That would have (to
by falcolas 9y ago
Underground freeways? Wow. I didn't realize that was the target of The Boring Company. I thought it was a start at making Hyperloop a thing. That would have (to me) made more sense than underground freeways.
This is a scathing review, but I can't really find anything inaccurate in it. Perhaps I didn't try hard enough, but the thought of riding hundreds of miles underground doesn't make me enthusiastic about looking for ways to make it more real. I've seen what happens when Lithium batteries catch on fire, and I wouldn't want to be stuck in a tunnel when that happened.
- akgerber 9y agoMostly-underground ultra-high-speed railways are nearing commercial implementation in Japan soon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen Experientially, it'll probably mostly be like a very long subway ride— but much comfier than the the tiny-tunnel, tiny-car Hyperloop, since at least you'll be able to go to the bathroom.
- falcolas 9y agoThat looks like a pretty cool project. My problem with tunnels is mostly related to being in a car: no room to stand, it's easy to be locked into the car in an accident, and nice big windows to let in the absolute darkness (or to "trap" you inside a reflection if you turn on your interior lights). That train is also looking to go about 2.5x faster than the Boring Tunnel cars, resulting in a much shorter trip.
- tfha 9y agoNo I think it's generally right. The boring company seems like a really silly idea. It's an extension of a broken transportation system. Cities scale with busses and trains. For some reason, the boring company wants to scale a city with cars. You build this big expensive tunnel to get 1/10th or even 1/50th the throughput that you could get with a train system. Maybe that's not the California way though.
- chrischen 9y agoIt's because he owns a car company. You can pretty much throw any idea he has for transit out the window there. If he had his way, he'd probably put rentable self-driving cars back-to-back in those tunnels. It'll be like aluminum and steel train cars, except each one is a Tesla.
- adventured 9y ago> Cities scale with busses and trains. You're missing that the boring premise is to utilize electric mass-transit units within the tunnels as well. That could dramatically scale the transit systems. It becomes a defacto variation of a subway system. Musk keeps pointing this out and it keeps getting ignored for some reason.
- hacknat 9y agoBecause it’s an absurd idea. He’a trying to solve an already solved problem with an inferior consumer solution. When you look at the commuter trains of the major metro areas you’ll notice some very well off people that could afford to drive, but choose to ride in a comfortable train and focus on reading or catching up on email. Driving is an inferior mode of transportation. And before you yell, “but driverless cars!” Consider that many folks don’t want to buy a car in some of these bigger metro areas or to pay for the parking to maintain one. For so many reasons, beyond technology, traditional mass transit is the superior option. I couldn’t care less whether Musk achieves his technological goals with the Boring Company. It’s hawking an inferior product even if he does.
- namelost 9y agoTunnels are dangerous. Elon is proposing to build really narrow tunnels that are hard to evacuate and then allow every random vehicle inside it. Yes it's on a sled but who is certifying that my fellow tunnelgoers' vehicles won't leak fuel, spontaneously catch fire, or find some other special way to kill me? Elon has some good ideas and some stupid ideas, this is of the latter category.
- sudhirj 9y ago