8 ms·
Communicating Advanced Mathematics to Kids
- vog 9y agoThis strongly reminds me of the various math magazines we have here in Germany. (I know that other countries have similar magazines, but I only grew up with the German ones, except for one Canadian one.) The most popular seems to be "Wurzel" [1] (translated: "root"). The target audience of the magazines are students (pupils) at school, as well as young students at university. The articles explain advanced math topics. Not too advanced, of course, but still far outside what they see in school. The articles use formalisms only where they make things more clear. They build on common school knowledge. Advanced formalisms are only okay if they are introduced in the article. And the articles aren't too long. The goal is that everything can be understood by students, if they are interested. Also, the magazines usually contain reports about math olympiads and similar activities, usually written by participants (i.e. by students, not teachers). Finally, these contain math exercises. But don't think of school exercises. Think of math olympiad, just that you have more time to solve them. Students send their solutions in and it is published in the magazine which students solved which exercise successfully. The latter one should not be underestimated - it is more or less how all these magazines started: You have math competition, the students go back to school, and you want to keep in touch with them, so you offer them so solche math puzzles in their free time, give them feedback to their solutions, and do everything they don't feel alone with their mathematical interests. You can do that individually only with so many students, so you start a magazine for a more efficient communication. [1] http://wurzel.org/ http://wurzel.org/
- jonnybgood 9y agoYou reminded me of Chalkdust [0]. I would love to see more publications along these lines. [0] http://chalkdustmagazine.com http://chalkdustmagazine.com
- vog 9y agoVery nice site! Too bad they don't offer an RSS feed, so it's hard for me to keep in touch with that site.
- ColinWright 9y agoDoesn't this work? http://chalkdustmagazine.com/feed/ http://chalkdustmagazine.com/feed/
- vog 9y agoThat's strange. Didn't find it, now it's there. Did they just add it? I'm using the TLS version, though: https://chalkdustmagazine.com/feed/ https://chalkdustmagazine.com/feed/
- ColinWright 9y agoDid you try that link/URL earlier? Perhaps you were trying other links, and this one was, in fact, always there. How were you previously trying to find the RSS feed? It's still not obvious to me from the front page that it exists.
- mathgenius 9y ago> far outside what they see in school There's so much cool mathematics out there that school kids can understand given a good enough teacher. It's really disappointing to me the crud that gets taught in school, but then i remember that a big part of this is the teachers just aren't that inspired. All it takes is one or two good teachers to really change a kids outlook on mathematics.
- briandear 9y agoYou also have the problem (at least in public schools,) that teachers are obliged to “stick to the curriculum” and much of a teacher’s time is spent catering to the lowest common denominator lest the test scores fall to an unacceptable level. I might argue that kids should get a double period for math, especially earlier in their school careers — one class to teach the fundamentals, another class to simply explore. The benefit being that critical thinking is enhanced in all academic areas and not just the obvious in mathematics.
- mathgenius 9y agoI hated learning the multiplication table when I was 5. Basically, I boycotted the whole thing. It occured to me recently, why don't they talk about the holes in the multiplication table? These are the prime numbers! So easy to mention this and may have inspired my 5 year old self to dig a bit deeper. My first real mathematical experience was in second grade. My teacher had some hoops on the floor, and was putting coloured shapes inside. Red shapes in one hoop, and triangles in another hoop. But then the problem arose: what to do with the red triangles? It was total magic when she dragged one hoop to overlap with another hoop and placed the red triangle in the overlap. Venn diagrams for six year olds. And I still can't multiply six times eight! I have to work it out every time...
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It occured to me recently, why don't they talk about the holes in the multiplication table? Because there aren't any. The prime numbers would be gaps if you pivoted the table into a division table but, alas, that's not how it's presented (even in the context of teaching division.)
- yogrish 9y agoreddit.com/r/ELIF is also good for explaining any topic in a simple way so even a kid also can understand. Its Not targeted towards maths though but biology / physics/technology etc. Have a look.
- montecarl 9y agoThis reminded me of a math professor during my undergrad. He would print out copies a math problem from some journal that published these kinds of interesting problems that are pretty hard and a little different from what you normally see in class. He would then put the copies in the halls of the math building. If you could bring him your solution and explain it to him he would give you $20 and mail in your answer to the journal, who would then send you back a little certificate and publish your name in the next edition. It was by solving one of these problems (using math that was above the course I was currently taking) that I started to interact more with the math department and decided to take more advanced classes!
- mkesper 9y agoI was reminded of the book 'The number devil' (Zahlenteufel) which showed me you can reason with children about math if only you do away with intimidating language: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Number_Devil https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Number_Devil
- GuiA 9y agoThe French magazine “Tangente” is equally good. http://tangente-mag.com http://tangente-mag.com
- mathgenius 9y agoQuantum journal is also doing a version of this: https://quantum-journal.org/call-for-papers-good-popular-science/ https://quantum-journal.org/call-for-papers-good-popular-sci...
- ivan_ah 9y agoWow nice, thanks for posting this.
- CurtMonash 9y agoThe great teachers of math to kids in the US are of course the Ross Program folks. (When last I checked in I thought Boston University's Promys was actually livelier than the original Ross Program at Ohio State.) They basically take very smart kids and help the rediscover much of abstract algebra and basic number theory. Decades later, I probably couldn't state quadratic reciprocity any more, let alone prove it. But proving the Two Squares Theorem is still one of the best ways to clear my mind of less pleasant thoughts, should I need such a device. It's just a whole lot of fun, even if you go in assuming next to nothing. (I start by proving that the Gaussian Integers are a Euclidean Domain and that all Euclidean Domains are Principal Ideal Domains, and proceed from there. It doesn't take long.)
- beagle3 9y agoTangentially related, this looks amazing, and I wish there were more schools like this http://www.proofschool.org/ http://www.proofschool.org/
- sitkack 9y agoTangentially, I think wikipedia should really focus on increasing the depth and depth(ha) of https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page We need advanced concepts explained in simple clear language so that students have enough context to anchor the knowledge.
- skadamat 9y agoSo many things I could say about this, but I"ll let Alan Kay speak for me - https://youtu.be/p2LZLYcu_JY https://youtu.be/p2LZLYcu_JY Alan talks about how ideas in Calculus could be manifested from an early age and a richness in understanding built up as they aged up: - at very young ages, kids really respond well through "doing" / the enactive channel. When asked to draw a circle, kids in Papert's group would first emulate what a LOGO turtle would do by rotating their body in a circle (making tiny increments in x and y). - as they got a bit older, the visual / iconic channel was more developed and they could understand the abstraction of a circle on pencil/paper and how the concepts carried over there - closer to early teens, symbols were much easier to grasp and relate to, etc. With this context in mind, there have been some cool efforts to mix the second and third channels I just mentioned to communicate advanced math concepts. Vi Hart and Grant Sanderson's youtube channels come to mind. Here are my favorite videos by Grant: - "What does it feel like to invent math": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFDM1ip5HdU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFDM1ip5HdU - On the visual intuition behind a hard problem on the Putnam exam - "The hardest problem on the hardest test": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkmNXy7er84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkmNXy7er84 - From vectors to matrices to vector spaces to higher-level ideas like the link between linear algebra and calculus: "Essence of linear algebra" series: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjBOesZCoqc&list=PLZHQObOWTQDPD3MizzM2xVFitgF8hE_ab https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjBOesZCoqc&list=PLZHQObOWTQ... What I especially like about Grant's videos, is that he often walks through what a mathematician would do, the questions she would ask, etc.
- dboreham 9y agoUnfortunately if you follow the link to the proposed site for publishing kid-friendly mathematics articles, then search with a filter for mathematics, you get zero results :( fwiw I have made some attempts to get my own children interested in 'advanced' mathematics. I found the TV series "Story of Maths" by Marcus du Sautoy to be helpful. I've also had some positive results watching lectures from Harvard's E-222 class[2] with my older son (14). [1] https://www.netflix.com/title/80093836 https://www.netflix.com/title/80093836 [2] http://matterhorn.dce.harvard.edu/engage/ui/index.html#/1999/01/82345 http://matterhorn.dce.harvard.edu/engage/ui/index.html#/1999...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoA good place to promote this would be with secular homeschoolers. Those homeschooling for nonreligious reasons are often dealing with a bright kid interested in advanced subjects. They often need lay explanations that make advanced subjects approachable without dumbing it down. A lot of stuff is intentionally overcomplicated. My oldest was furious when I finally explained to him that algebra is basically renaming the blank space in an equation as X so you can more easily move the blank space around. He had been doing algebra in his head for years to infer stats in games while simultaneously feeling baffled and intimidated by formal math, like the concept of algebra. He had assumed all variables were like E=mc^2 where letters stood for specific concepts, not for floating "=___".
- colomon 9y agoI've actually been trying to explain that exact concept (algebra variables) to some advanced third graders. It's been surprisingly hard to get them to grasp it.
- opportune 9y agoWhen I was a child, the first thing that made sense to me was that "x is the number that makes the statement true". That is, 100 = 100, so if 25 * x = 100, you need to figure out what value of x multiplied by 25 gives you 100. I didn't even understand the manipulations or how you would really solve for x at first, but I did understand that you were trying to figure out the number that would do that. I would just phrase it like a puzzle, like "what plus 9 equals 14" or "3 times what equals 42"? For some reason, one of my earliest memories I have is from when I would try to show off to older kids that I understood algebra.
- mturmon 9y agoHave you looked at the Dragon Box app?
- corysama 9y agoI shill DragonBox every chance I get ;) It does a great job of teaching abstract algebra to children who don’t even know arithmetic.
- laderach 9y agoMy son is now 4 years old, he has been showing a great deal of interest in playing with numbers and puzzles, so I have been thinking quite a bit about this lately. The other day I ran across an issue of Scientific American from the late 70s (http://flowcytometry.sysbio.med.harvard.edu/files/flowcytometryhms/files/herzenbergfacshistory.pdf http://flowcytometry.sysbio.med.harvard.edu/files/flowcytome...) and I was super impressed by the quality and educational value of the content. Much superior to its current version. They have a ton of super interesting "mini" papers about all sorts of topics. In that issue alone I learned about: - The metabolism of alcohol - The meteorology of Jupiter - Simpson's paradox Take a look at it. I think you might be impressed too. The other site I have fallen in love with recently is Fermat's Library (https://fermatslibrary.com https://fermatslibrary.com). They essentially publish an annotated paper every week (usually physics, cs, math). Reading their papers is now a part of my weekly routine.
- todd8 9y agoI grew up in an inner city Detroit neighborhood. The junior high school that I attended was pretty rough so, to avoid the gangs that formed after school, I quickly ran over to the near by public library and stayed there until it was safe to walk home around dinner time. A friend showed me a magazine at the library; it was Scientific American and it completely hooked me. This was 1963 and SA was then a great magazine. I read every current issue and then read the bound volumes of past issues. My favorite monthly columns were Martin Gardner's Mathematical Games and the Amateur Scientist. I read every one of those two columns ever published. The schools I attended were not very good, but I learned a lot of math and science during those years at the library. I went on to score very high in math and science, got into great colleges and ended up with a very successful career.
- laderach 9y agoThank you for sharing your story! I am going to google Martin Gardner's Mathematical Games later this afternoon!
- nileshtrivedi 9y ago
- kirillzubovsky 9y agoHonestly, this is a fantastic idea. As a dad of a toddler I am starting to look for more math-oriented materials, and this will definitely be on the reading list. I especially love the "How to write for this audience" section. It says: be concise, convey the excitement, say exactly what is important and why, and draw the reader in. This is how most concept should be explained, to adults or kids, doesn't matter. As someone who's gone through an engineering degree, so much of it was written/presented in convoluted "this is going to be difficult" format, instead of this playful "here, try something tasty" one. Wish more educators would adopt this kid-friendly way for older kids too :) Edit: Do you know any dads who have been very successful teaching kids math at home, better than they are taught in schools? I'd love interview them for my podcast.
- mncharity 9y agoI'm interested in insightful descriptions of the physical world for young kids. For illustration, what might it mean to teach friction well? Is it memorize-and-regurgitate of bogus definitions in late primary? Or plug-and-chug of Arrhenius's law of large objects sliding on pig fat in high-school? Or instead, could we talk about sock nubbies in K-3? Their similarity to cleats and crampons and klister. How to avoid slipping and falling. Sliding and slipping and sticking - pervasively surrounding us. Nanoscale origins connecting nicely with macroscale behavior. And for the numerate, a feel for reasonable order-of-magnitude values. So physics, but coming from sort of an engineering perspective - hands-on, pragmatic, rough quantitative. Could we approach math similarly? What might it mean to teach category theory to young kids? Perhaps math as a vocabulary for describing similarities among everyday things? "Oh, you missed the square, but you can get it the next time you go around the board":"It's almost one o'clock now, so we'll wait for lunch-time tomorrow":"Missed the parking space, so we'll drive around the block". Movement around short loops is a theme of everyday experience. Could it be taught? Now, or with future AR/VR tech? In preK-1, learning to describe physical properties is a thing. Rough, smooth, etc. But instead of drawing on well designed vocabularies from industrial design or material science, it's left to dysfunctional ad hoceries. Similarly, K-12 physics education leaves students having seen almost no physics. What about math? Could math be taught not as a random fun thing to do, like crossword puzzles and fashion magazines, but as a deeply insightful and broadly illuminating vocabulary for describing everyday experiences?
- icefogAlex 9y agoSSN Restore and Funding !!!!! SSN Restore and Funding !!!!! For the 65/35 program please make sure you get this app for other clients submitted: Corps both PG and NO PG and all types of Funding http://realestatelendingsearch.com http://realestatelendingsearch.com 10% per month Guaranteed http://realestatelendingsearch.com http://realestatelendingsearch.com Our team also provides the following additional services. Catch a cheating significant other by hacking social media, messengers and more How to remove negative information online and hack search results How to hack a degree in 30 days How to hack your credit score Take back control of your social media And more We want to make sure you understand what WE CAN do and what WE CAN NOT do: We can not: Hack people's personal information or accounts for personal gain WE CAN: Help create a detailed profile of your subject's online and electronic activity, including location, pictures, chats etc. We can not: Hack an account and give it to you WE CAN: Recover or delete stolen accounts and return its control to you. We can not: Hack your credit report on Experian, Transunion, and Equifax WE CAN: Work with you and your credit report to remove negative entries, insert positive ones and even help you create an all new credit file. We can not: Hack your university to get you straight A's WE CAN: Work with you to get you straight A's in almost any degree, course or certification. We can not: Hack what's app to help you catch a cheating partner WE CAN: Help you find out if your significant other is or is not cheating using their online media and electronic footprint. We can not: Hack Google to get your content removed from search results. WE CAN: Remove content from its source and help you control your search content so the negative content disappears or is suppressed. We can not Hack into a system or account you do not own or have LEGAL permission to access. WE CAN: do penetration tests, phishing attacks, code injections and more to test the security and accessibility of accounts and systems you own or do have Legal permission access. We get a lot of calls a day so we may not respond to you right away. Paid member brokers get priority access and are called back first. Prosperous Regards, Contact us on : Telephone: Email:icehackerzz@gmail.com
- icefogAlex 9y agoDiamond Club Credit Card Topup & More! All Brokers and Clients NOW have access to some amazing breakthrough methods to release some of the hardships present today in many households and businesses. Many today are simply maxed out with no other options and are at risk of financial ruin, divorce, and unfortunately suicide. DONT LET IT HAPPEN TO YOU OR YOURS Imagine today for a moment that you can go from running on fumes to same day debt relief no matter your credit score or personal history. We have 100s of individuals that have gone from broke to having a cash flow injection of $25,000 to $100,000 in days NOT months. CREDIT CARD TOPUP | LOADING SERVICE We are currently doing credit card TopUp for Reloadable Cards and loading for regular cards. Our topUp and loading is done using our own Offshore servers for Total Funds reflection. Funds may take up to 2 hours to reflect due to server location but they are 100% clean and zero charge backs. * Bank Wires to ANY BANK ACCOUNTS ACCEPT... ( Bank Of America or Wells Fargo ) BANK LOGIN | TRANSFER SERVICE It is Our Responsibility to transfer the required amount into your account using our own Personal Offshore Servers and techniques so you have abosolutely no charge back. Your funds are clean and ready for use once they reflect in your account. Currently we are transfering all over the world except african countries.. All our transfers are safe and secure so you have nothing to worry about. All Inquiries are Anonymous and will be answered personally one at a time. Send an Email to diamondbrokersclub@protonmail.com with your full name and best contact phone. Kindly include a brief message explaining your need and one of our associates will contact you within the hour. Kindest Regards, Broker Services Send an Email to icehackerzz@gmail.com This is my ad, do you guys want to add anything to this before I send it to my clients...
- joeengxx 9y agoOur team also provides the following additional services. Catch a cheating significant other by hacking social media, messengers and more How to remove negative information online and hack search results How to hack a degree in 30 days How to hack your credit score Take back control of your social media And more We want to make sure you understand what WE CAN do and what WE CAN NOT do: We can not: Hack people's personal information or accounts for personal gain WE CAN: Help create a detailed profile of your subject's online and electronic activity, including location, pictures, chats etc. We can not: Hack an account and give it to you WE CAN: Recover or delete stolen accounts and return its control to you. We can not: Hack your credit report on Experian, Transunion, and Equifax WE CAN: Work with you and your credit report to remove negative entries, insert positive ones and even help you create an all new credit file. We can not: Hack your university to get you straight A's WE CAN: Work with you to get you straight A's in almost any degree, course or certification. We can not: Hack what's app to help you catch a cheating partner WE CAN: Help you find out if your significant other is or is not cheating using their online media and electronic footprint. We can not: Hack Google to get your content removed from search results. WE CAN: Remove content from its source and help you control your search content so the negative content disappears or is suppressed. We can not Hack into a system or account you do not own or have LEGAL permission to access. WE CAN: do penetration tests, phishing attacks, code injections and more to test the security and accessibility of accounts and systems you own or do have Legal permission access. We get a lot of calls a day so we may not respond to you right away. Paid member brokers get priority access and are called back first. Prosperous Regards, Contact us on : digitaldawgpoundhackergroup at gmail.com Telephone: (732) 639-1527
- perseusprime11 9y agoWhat about Art? Are there any good sites for parents and kids to get really deep into art such as drawing, painting, etc?