17 ms·
TLDR: Would anyone care to explain to me pros and cons of net neutrality and Pai's plan? Confession: I have never really understood what net neutrality was abo
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
TLDR: Would anyone care to explain to me pros and cons of net neutrality and Pai's plan?
Confession: I have never really understood what net neutrality was about. So I decided to look it up (again).[1] And also asked the internet what the FCC plans to do to repeal it.[2]
I am interested in seeing actual thoughtful discussion of the issue instead of mudslinging, pretty please. I am open to hearing arguments from both sides. I just would like it served up without name calling and that sort of thing. You know: Like HN encourages routinely.
Then maybe I can decide in some kind of semi informed way if I want to help break the internet or not.
Thanks.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality
2. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/11/21/the-fcc-has-unveiled-its-plan-to-rollback-its-net-neutrality-rules/?utm_term=.17e168e0bca3 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/11/21...
- jayess 9y agoPrepare to be downvoted straight into hell for even questioning the prevailing narrative on HN.
- ajkjk 9y agoWell that's not productive at all. If anything, the HN comment section is the best place on the internet I know of to actually hear reasonable explanation of this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SilasX 9y agoI don't like to admit it, but I'm in the same boat as you. I've heard NN used, depending on the context, to refer to prohibition of: 1) Throttling sites the ISP doesn't like. 2) Any kind of penalty for heavier users. 3) Charging for access to special pipes that are faster, when both sides want to pay a premium for speed and reliability. Unless I ask directly I have a hard time discerning what someone means by NN, and even then I don't know how well it maps to what new regulations will actually do. Edit: Another attempt at clarifying first sentence.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoFrom my #2 link: "Under my proposal, the federal government will stop micromanaging the Internet,” Pai said A favorite pet theory of mine: "That government is best which governs least." Is it really so bad for the government to be more hands off? Discuss. (Preferably people more informed than I am will share their insights.)
- sythe2o0 9y agoLess government regulation makes sense in places that don't endanger people (e.g. food quality) and in fields with a lot of competition. A large number of people in the united states only have access to one ISP, or one fast ISP[1]. Your single ISP available to you could decide that you don't get to access your favorite site(s) without charging an additional fee to access them. They could refuse to offer any unknown sites, and just offer facebook, youtube, etc, each costing some number of dollars to use. Net neutrality prevents this. 1. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/50-million-us-homes-have-only-one-25mbps-internet-provider-or-none-at-all/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/50-mi...
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIf competition is working effectively, then government management usually does more harm than good. The question is, is competition working effectively in telecommunications? In much of the country, I suspect that the answer is no.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThank you. That's very succinct and a good framing of the issue.
- jedmeyers 9y agoAnd the reason for the lack of competition is, again, the government with its enforcement of ISP monopolies. Why don't they stop micromanaging the markets there as well?
- dhimes 9y agoHere's a good non-tldr link- I think your best bet is to go there for a few minutes. I don't agree with everything the eff does, but they are right on this: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/11/lump-coal-internets-stocking-fcc-poised-gut-net-neutrality-rules https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/11/lump-coal-internets-st...
- esaym 9y agoThat article doesn't help anything. That is still a pure FUD based article. It offers no info and just speculates that without regulation, ISPs will just charge you more and have "fast lanes" and packaged plans.... I'm so sick of that argument. We've never seen anything like that in America before NN. Its a pure strawman argument.
- cracell 9y agoI think you are just trolling but for others reading this here's a list of bad things that were net neutrality violations: https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-violations-brief-history https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-vio... There's also lots of examples from other countries that don't have net neutrality like Mexico https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/6x6izw/guys_m%C3%A9xico_has_no_net_neutrality_laws_this_is/ https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/6x6izw/guys_m%C... (certain websites are not available on the lower tiered plans)
- esaym 9y agoI am not trolling and yes I've already read those articles. That is exactly what I am complaining about. There is no evidence that these strawman arguments will come to pass. And even though "bad" things happened without NN, they were ultimately resolved (without NN)
- dhimes 9y agoYou are totally trolling. Yeah, nobody can guarantee that these things won’t happen. But they’ll be enabled. It will increase profits. So it will likely happen. But you know that.
- slg 9y agoI would be curious to hear it as well (EDIT: specifically others' thoughts on Pai's plan). I understand net neutrality and am all for it, but I seem to remember a decent percentage of HN was against accomplishing it through reclassification before it was passed in 2015. I also don't see how going to the regulatory situation before reclassification is an Internet destroying disaster. The Internet seemed to get along just fine before 2015. I worry that maybe we are not focusing on the right thing and the true path to securing a free and open Internet is by increasing competition in the ISP space. Although that is a much harder battle since it must be fought on so many difference fronts in local and state government.
- remarkEon 9y agoThis essay from Stratechery, and the accompanying podcast, I think sums up the way I feel about it and gets into how emotional people get over this topic [1]. I'm always going to be skeptical of whatever the ISPs are telling me, but I think Thompson's point here about how we don't know what things in the future won't exist if we mandate NN is worth at least considering, so I tend to agree that light-touch is probably a better approach. [1] https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/ https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/
- sushisource 9y agoI think the overall point of the article is solid, but this sentence is laughable: "Again, zero-rating is not explicitly a net-neutrality issue: T-Mobile treats all data the same, some data just doesn’t cost money." Right. Interesting definition of "same".
- tc313 9y agoAt the risk of splitting hairs, Thompson actually argued in favor of mandating net neutrality, but against the stringent Title II regulations. He also argued that re-classifying ISPs would not necessarily lead to the end of net neutrality.
- remarkEon 9y agoYou're correct, and I was perhaps assuming too much that people have kept up with his writing on this topic.
- esaym 9y agoI don't really think any one knows. I've since just figured all the FUD is just because half the nation doesn't like the current president. I've read a large part of the bill and nothing particularly stuck out as bad, though I admit I didn't read the bill that it is replacing. I don't really think anything will change either way. Even though there are few ISPs to choose from, many areas have both a cable company and a telecom company to choose internet from and I think that is sufficient enough to keep either one from filtering or throttling. Case in point, I know plenty of people that will flip flop between spectrum and ATT every year simply because one has an internet plan that is $5 less than the other one for a year contract. Then rinse,wash, repeat on the next year.
- jlgaddis 9y ago> I've since just figured all the FUD is just because half the nation doesn't like the current president. Note that this "battle" started way before Mr. Trump became President.
- sjsotelo 9y agoIn Atlanta I have the option for ether 100mbps Comcast, or 35mbps ATT, sure other city’s have different offerings however Comcast is my ONLY fast option for myself.
- lowbloodsugar 9y ago"Many areas". So fuck everyone else then. I live in an affluent area, schools that score 10/10, and even I don't have two choices for an ISP. I have 100Mb/s with the cable company and 7Mb/s from the phone company. But yeah, I guess you and your buddies are ok then.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAh, you want contrarian! You've come to the right place. As a paying customer, I'd love the ability for streaming sites not to impact my bandwidth quota. I get 1TB a month. That's it. I've run over that limit once, and you can guess where 90% of it went. This is especially true on mobile, where the bandwidth cap is literally 100x lower. 10GB is not a lot, and you can burn it on one long train ride. It's absurd that we have to deal with caps, but... The world has accepted them. So if they're here to stay, why not classify streaming sites into a different mental category? They're bandwidth hogs. I'd rather keep NN in place, but that's one flipside.
- esaym 9y agoBut with NN in place, we still have caps. So what the heck are you talking about?
- Nition 9y agoThey mean the ISP can say "streaming from Netflix doesn't count towards your data cap!", either as a free bonus or at least as a cheap add-on option.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoRepeal NN => youtube/netflix no longer counts toward cap => cap no longer causes problems. Some ISPs (verizon?) do similar things, where if you use their app then you're allowed to stream as much as you want. But I'm not sure whether that runs afoul of neutrality laws. This is admittedly a weak argument, since companies would end up eating the cost, further entrenching the existing monopolies. But they were looking for arguments in favor of NN. There are other contexts where non-neutrality might be useful: A local startup once tried to roll out a lower-latency service for gaming, based on intelligent routing. It was unlikely to succeed, but even if it were technically possible it would definitely violate NN to be prioritizing/rerouting certain classes of traffic.
- cracell 9y ago> It was unlikely to succeed, but even if it were technically possible it would definitely violate NN to be prioritizing/rerouting certain classes of traffic. This is not true at all. Net neutrality rules allow for "Reasonable Network Management" which includes prioritizing classes of traffic. Here's a discussion on it https://www.reddit.com/r/networking/comments/6nddmx/does_net_neutrality_mean_isps_arent_allowed_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/networking/comments/6nddmx/does_net...
- greenpizza13 9y agoIt's really quite simple. Having strong "net neutrality" means that all bits are equal. It's like imagining that your ISP can't see where the bits go, they just come read the meter. In fact, the analogy to your electric bill is quite apt. Imagine if your electric company billed you more for using your toaster than it did for using your refrigerator. Imagine if you had to pay to add devices to your electric plan, or if you had to pay extra to be able to use full power on your microwave. Because the electric company just "reads the meter" and treats all "bits" of electricity as equal, you are free to use your electricity as you choose. This means a guy in his garage can run a server and start a business and break into markets (that actually requires both "electricity neutrality" and "net neutrality." The ramifications of having no net neutrality regulations range from simply throttling certain websites, like netflix, in order to squeeze them for more money, to charging to access certain web sites or selling "packages" of web sites you can access. If that sounds terrifying to you, you're not alone.
- hartator 9y agoIt’s actually illegal in most locations to run commercial servers on your home electric line.
- codefined 9y agoIt might be against terms of service, but I very much doubt it's illegal. Ten minutes of Googling shows nothing about running servers from my home being illegal. How would they know you're hosting a server? I mean, practically speaking a server is just a computer you leave running 24/7. Please could you provide some evidence of your statement, otherwise I don't think it's quite true.
- hartator 9y agoFor example Austin, you have different bills if you use it for residential or commercial: https://austinenergy.com/ae/residential/rates https://austinenergy.com/ae/residential/rates https://austinenergy.com/ae/commercial/rates https://austinenergy.com/ae/commercial/rates
- insickness 9y agoCon net neutrality argument: The first net neutrality rules were implemented in 2015. For 25 years the internet blossomed without any net neutrality rules in place. Yet somehow we're supposed to believe that if this rule is repealed, Verizon will force me to pay extra for Netflix or will prevent me accessing websites they don't want me to see. There were instances in the past of ISPs behaving badly but they were resolved on an individual basis. If you're worried about freedom of speech on the net, edge providers such as Google, Facebook and Twitter are for more of a threat to free speech than ISPs. A longer article that details some of this: https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/ https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/
- fossuser 9y agoThis isn't really true though. NY AG Schneiderman had a good response to this in the earlier AMA (which I've pasted below). "As a preliminary matter, it’s important to recognize that net neutrality principles and protections in different forms have actually been around since 2005 and even earlier. So the flourishing of the internet and everything relying on it during that time occurred under the protections. A few years ago, however, the courts struck down one form of net neutrality protections (those that had relied on Title I of the Communications Act), so then in 2015 the FCC put net neutrality protections back in place under Title II instead (they also expanded the earlier protections, e.g., to include protections against abuses related to interconnection, which had not been the subject of net neutrality protections before 2015). Now, in 2017, the FCC under Chairman Ajit Pai is proposing to repeal net neutrality protections altogether (and the courts’ earlier decisions effectively foreclose a return to net neutrality protections under Title I). So that would be entirely new territory for the internet. Why do we think that’s bad? Well, as I explained in my own public comment in the current proceeding (https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/10717583023587/FINAL%20RIF%20Co... https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/10717583023587/FINAL%20RIF%20Co...), we’ve seen how companies behave in the absence of net neutrality protections, specifically in the area of interconnection before it was regulated in 2015, and their unregulated conduct harmed consumers. In essence, they made a deliberate business decision to let the quality of internet access degrade, knowing that it hurt consumers, to try to squeeze revenue out of edge providers like Netflix and backbone providers like Cogent and Level 3. Plus, we know that many consumers have few ISPs to choose from, so competition isn’t as effective a check as in other markets. So I believe strong net neutrality regulations are needed to avoid harms to consumers." The AMA: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15853374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15853374
- ikeboy 9y agoEconomists favor paid prioritization (one of the things net neutrality bans) by a weighted factor of 3-1 (excluding those undecided) http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/net-neutrality-ii http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/net-neutrality-ii
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIt seems to me that the question they asked is overly broad: > it is a good idea to let companies that send video or other content to consumers pay more to Internet service providers for the right to send that traffic using faster or higher quality service That could just as easily be interpreted to mean the content providers are paying their own ISP for faster service which net neutrality would allow as it could to mean the content providers paying their users' ISP which net neutrality doesn't allow.
- ikeboy 9y agoThe big content providers don't have an ISP in the traditional sense - they interface directly with "users' ISPs".
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThe really big ones that send really huge amounts of data to a really large number of users do that, but that is definitely not a majority of content providers.
- cracell 9y agoHere's a list of bad things ISPs did that have violated net neutrality: https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-violations-brief-history https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-vio... pros: all of that becomes legal so ISPs can increase profits through anti-consumer practices cons: ISPs disrupt commerce through anti-consumer practices
- hartator 9y agoAgainst net neutrality: - It already doesn’t exist. Google pays a fee to install servers in AT&T datacenters for better CDN performance. - The bill mostly repeals rules instituted in 2014. I don’t remember the Internet being that bad before 2014. - Finally, from a classic liberalism PoV, getting the government out of any market is always a good move.
- jimktrains2 9y agoThe quality of interconnects is not a net neutrality issue. Net neutrality rules are from 2005, with the basic premise being as old as the protocols we use. Moreover there have been a variety of issues isps have done such as blocking VoIP and payment services to promote their own.
- thisrobot 9y agoTo understand Net Neutrality you first need to have an understanding of how the internet works. The internet is basically composed of a bunch of different networks. These networks interconnect with each other (see Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) for more details). There are basically three different kinds of networks: 1) Networks that primarily host content; azure. 2) Networks that primarily do transit; level three. 3) Consumer Terminating Networks; Comcast. I admit this is a generalization, and some networks fit multiple of these categories, but lets not get too bogged down in the details here, as I don't think it's necessary to understand net neutrality. Given these types of interconnected networks lets go through an example. Let say a consumer wants to watch Netflix. The consumers pays Comcast to access Comcast's network and get some bandwidth. Netflix pays their hosting network, and possibly a transit network for bandwidth. Comcast either directly, or through another networks connects to Netflix's hosting network. Neither Netflix or Comcast necessarily pays anything to these in-between networks. This works because these in-between networks trade about the same amount of traffic (see Peering). This is basically net neutrality; you pay Comcast for some bandwidth, Netflix pays their host and the content flows freely. Without net neutrality Comcast can change you, Netflix, or both more to connect to each other. It can make Hulu free to connect to. It can make youtube inaccessible unless you get the super premium package. No one is just paying for bandwidth anymore, someone is paying for individual services on top of bandwidth. This allows Comcast to either pick the winner by making their services cheaper, or lets the company which pays Comcast the most be most available to their customers. So what it really boils down to is, are you paying for bandwidth that you choose how to use, or not. Personally, I'd rather just pay for bandwidth.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoMy problem is that you're currently not paying for bandwidth either, because ISPs generally don't promise you all of the advertized bandwidth all of the time. There have been times when my ISP has been unable to deliver the bandwidth that was advertized to me without throttling things like BitTorrent. I would be 100% for net neutrality if that problem actually got addressed. Most of the examples I've seen of companies throttling things are actually very high-bandwidth services - it's not just things that people are willing to pay more for or that compete with the ISP. Without that solved, then yes - I'd like to be able to pay more to get my work prioritized over entertainment or piracy.
- showerst 9y agoSo this is something of a multi-part response, corrections appreciated. Full disclosure I am highly pro-Net Neutrality, although I believe the authority problem is complex enough that congress should just pass a bill mandating it, to clarify the situation and make it harder to undo. 0. In the US, there's a legal status for telecom companies called "common carrier", and multiple subcategories (Title I, Title II). Basically common carrier status says that you have to abide by certain regulations around who you serve, and in return your company gains some benefits (among them, they're not liable for illegal material transmitted over their networks). So your phone company, a Title 1 common carrier, can't charge you more to call Best Buy than to call Amazon, but if you plan out a bank heist with your buddies over the phone, the phone company CEO doesn't go to jail. Right now ISP's are classified as the less regulated subcategory, Title II. 1. The first question, orthogonal but critical, is whether the FCC has the legal authority to set and enforce policies around net neutrality to anyone at all, or only Title I common carriers. The exact authority to do this was never enumerated to the FCC by congress (because the FCC was set up long before the internet). There's also a question of whether the FCC can just reclassify ISPs as common carriers at will. There is an ongoing legal dispute that the FCC has currently lost at the DC Circuit court level where the court said that the FCC can't regulate net neutrality without reclassifying ISPs as the more regulated category. The FCC then reclassified them, which is in the courts. I bring this up because it's one argument given by republicans who oppose it: They don't believe the FCC has the authority in the first place, some believing it's the FTC's job, some believing that nobody has that authority until congress gives it out. Those who feel this way generally don't think congress should give that out. The most used reasoning i've read is "Things have been fine for 25 years, why add more rules now?". 2. Assuming you think the FCC has the authority here, net neutrality as it's been laid out since 2010 basically says "all lawful bits are equal, with reasonable allowance for quality of service". You can still charge differently for different amounts of bandwidth, but are not allowed to block or modify traffic by type or source. Wiki has a nice summary here: [1]. Peering agreements between bandwidth providers are also still legal. The quality of service stuff is beyond my level of knowledge, but I believe it's intended to allow for things like blocking denial of service attacks or taking links down for maintenance. Without it, ISPs are free to discriminate based on source, content type, etc. So they can charge you more for just video services, or slow down just netflix but prioritize hulu, etc. The nightmare scenario for many internet advocates is that image you've probably seen of an ISP ad with different packages for allowing gaming, video, etc. [2]. For the record, comcast has promised not to do this. Another worry of open internet advocates is that the ISPs will go to Netflix, Amazon, etc, and ask them to pay more to guarantee quality of service. This could raise prices for these services. If this included speedups over competitors, rather than just slowdowns of big bandwidth users, it would discourage competition from startups who couldn't pay huge amounts like major companies. The counter-arguments vary, but tend to fall in a few camps: a. ISPs have not done this in the past, so why add more regulations and increase their costs of doing business (more legal costs to understand the laws and ensure compliance). b. Market competition will ensure that if one company starts ripping off consumers, another will move in. Regulation is unnecessary and may have nasty second-order effects. c. If Netflix is taking up a non-trivial percent of Comcast's total resources, why shouldn't they have to pay more? Same for game networks, etc. This is especially interesting with file-sharing services, which are a big bandwidth suck are commonly viewed as mostly illegal activity (piracy). d. These companies are afraid to start new lines of business that will employ people and help consumers. I've yet to dig up any good proposed examples, of anyone at HN knows of one that would be cool. Pai in particular has mentioned this a number of times. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality_in_the_United_States#FCC_Open_Internet_Order_(2010) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality_in_the_United_S... [2] http://www.theharlemvalleynews.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/net.jpg http://www.theharlemvalleynews.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/1...
- hsod 9y agoThis comment crystalizes the paradox of activism in a community of contrarians: after months of build up, we are spending our last organizing hours convincing ourselves (and each other) of something we already know.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI'm not a contrarian. I'm a freelance writer who is less tech savvy than a lot of people here. I am not comfortable with taking action without understanding what I am supporting. I am also not comfortable sitting idly by on the excuse that I don't really understand it. It is a completely sincere question and I very much appreciate all good faith efforts to answer it, from either side.
- hsod 9y agoI'm not questioning your sincerity (or talking about you at all, really). I'm observing that the HN community is a poor fit for activism. It's crunch time (activism-wise) and the top comment chain is a relitigation of the whole issue from scratch, even though we've been talking about it for months (and years).
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOr maybe people are willing to go the extra mile to get a neutral party on board who might otherwise do nothing because I am not comfortable taking action on an issue I don't really understand. I don't see it being relitigated. Most stuff here seems pro net neutrality, but with good explanations instead of the political sniping I was seeing before I asked.
- jancsika 9y ago> Or maybe people are willing to go the extra mile to get a neutral party on board who might otherwise do nothing because I am not comfortable taking action on an issue I don't really understand. So... did they succeed? Do the pro net-neutrality explanations make sense and persuade you? And if so, what do you plan to do in this critical moment before the impending FCC vote?
- mtgx 9y agoNet neutrality = anti content discrimination. It's as simple as that. If the ISP is discriminating against certain types of content, then the internet is not neutral, which many think should be illegal to preserve innovation on the web (allowing small companies to rise up as fast as Google, Facebook, and Youtube did, instead of being bogged down by ISPs charging them fees for "access to their customers" or some nonsense).
- ENGNR 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFkzJc7kJKc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFkzJc7kJKc
- dsp1234 9y agoThe Open Internet Order of 2010 established a set of net neutrality rules based around 3 concepts[0]: 1.) Transparency. Fixed and mobile broadband providers must disclose the network management practices, performance characteristics, and terms and conditions of their broadband services 2.) No blocking. Fixed broadband providers may not block lawful content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices; mobile broadband providers may not block lawful websites, or block applications that compete with their voice or video telephony services. 3.) No unreasonable discrimination. Fixed broadband providers may not unreasonably discriminate in transmitting lawful network traffic. In 2014, in Verizon vs. the FCC[1], the appeals court struck down the No blocking and No unreasonable discrimination sections of the Open Internet Order. The court at the time noted that as long as broadband providers were considered under Title I, those sections could not apply to them. However, the court also noted that, in general, the FCC did have the power to enforce the Open Internet Order using Title II, and that the FCC had the ability to reclassify the ISPs under Title II. Thus in 2015, the FCC reclassified broadband providers under Title II, thus making the No blocking and No unreasonable discrimination sections apply to them once again. The history goes: 2010-2014: Transparency, No blocking, No unreasonable discrimination 2014-2015: Transparency, blocking ok, unreasonable discrimination ok 2015-now: Transparency, No blocking, No unreasonable discrimination What the FCC wants to do now is to repeal the action taken to classify broadband providers under Title II, and move them back to Title I. This would again eliminate the ability of the FCC to enforce the Open Internet Order's No Blocking and No Unreasonable Discrimination sections. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_Open_Internet_Order_2010 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_Open_Internet_Order_2010 [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Communications_Inc._v._FCC_(2014) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Communications_Inc._v....
- syrrim 9y agoBasically, net neutrality prevents ISPs from using a form of price discrimination to sell a lesser internet, where certain sites are blocked or throttled, or where certain sites have to increase service charges to pay back costs imposed on them by ISPs. Eliminating this would enable ISPs to charge lower prices to segments that currently go unserved. This is considered a bad thing because: - In modernity, not having internet is considered untenable. Essential things like applying for jobs, interacting with friends, or performing political activism require the internet. Moreover, a free internet is important for these tasks, becaue only then can the tasks themselves be performed freely. Imagine an internet where the only social network is facebook. This would be extremely limiting, and facebook would love to implement this. - Many ISPs would use this price discrimination to steal customers away from other ISPs, rather than unlock new customers. This is hailed as "competition". The problem is that all ISPs would steal customers from each other roughly equally. Therefore, the effect would be merely to lower prices (for a lesser product) for certain customers. Without a corresponding lowering of costs, ISPs would have to raise prices for the rest of their customers. To get the same price as today, you would have to purchase a non neutral package. Rather than it being merely grandmas and poor people with a limited version of the internet, nearly everyone would have it.
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoThere are a lot of wonderful, elaborate, technical replies to your post. But the simple version is this: The major ISP endgame is to have a cut of every single transaction that happens on the internet over their pipes (from both ends)... well... if they aren't already the ones selling the product in the first place, that is. They are chomping at the bit to flex their monopolist, anti-competitive muscles to achieve that goal. They will go as far as we let them (just as any self-interested party would in their unique position). Net-neutrality rules helped (somewhat) to stop them. If you think that possible future is bad, you probably ought to support net-neutrality.
- deathanatos 9y ago> what net neutrality was about It is the idea that an ISP should not treat different data differently. Their job — what I am paying for — is to deliver data I transmit to the Internet, as efficiently as possible. The only strong-ish argument that I've heard against net-neutrality is that "why shouldn't the ISPs be able to sell off the limited resource of bandwidth to the highest bidder? Does not offering higher-paying individuals result in a more efficient allocation of the resource? I would argue, no, because: 1. Most people don't have a choice about their ISP, and their ISP knows this. Most Americans have a single broadband Internet provider, that's it. The ISP has no competition to encourage setting a fair market price, because no fair market exists. (I think I would be much more inclined on most of these points if ISPs were not local monopolies.) 2. Allowing the ISP to price discriminate (by charging upstream content producers more for getting out of the slow lane) creates a barrier to new entrants to the market. One of the great things about the Internet today is that if someone invents, say, the next YouTube, Google, or Wikipedia, it is essentially on equal footing w/ the other services that exist today. Forcing new services that may be bandwidth intensive to pay up help lock in the established big players who can outbid the smaller fish. This is particularly dangerous in the example that an ISP could sell access to only a subset of the Internet: imagine a package that only allows access to Google, FB, and a handful of other sites. Competitors are now cut off from those customers. (This is not theoretical, either; there are examples of exactly this happening abroad.) 3. ISPs have repeatedly demonstrated that they would like to offer competing products to those offered by non-ISPs, and will abuse their monopolistic position to promote those products. (By offering them at higher speeds, not counting them towards data caps, etc.) 4. The incentives created by content producers paying for bandwidth are perverse: the ISP would get money, but would be disinclined to reinvest that in the local infrastructure. Doing so would increase the available supply of bandwidth, decreasing the price that it would fetch. American's ISP offerings already lag behind the rest of the world, in some cases, by an order of magnitude. This would not help.
- ianamartin 9y agoFor a good read on both sides of the issue that are historically informed and cogent, I'd recommend these two posts. Anti (meaning in support of the FCC's plan): https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/ https://stratechery.com/2017/pro-neutrality-anti-title-ii/ Pro (meaning in support of the 2015 changes to protect net neutrality: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20171127/01044438683/ajit-pais-big-lie.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20171127/01044438683/ajit-... The anti article is by Ben Thomson, who has a deep and interesting insight into quite a number of things about how businesses on the internet work. I don't always agree with him, but he usually states a sane, informed case. His biggest claim to fame is his work fleshing out an economic idea called Aggregation Theory, which was in part a response to/criticism of Clayton Christinsen got wrong about New Market Disruption. On the pro side, Mike Masnick is an intellectual property attorney who now, I think, runs techdirt full time. He's been working on the legal issues surrounding the internet since the 90s. Interestingly enough, his attitude was similar to Thompson's around 10 years ago, but the way things have evolved, he's come around to seeing things this way. I find myself unconvinced by Thompson's argument. It's a wait and see argument that basically says, "We know regulation sucks. But we don't know exactly how bad the ISPs are going to be when they are unregulated." The reality is that Internet Access is the defining technology that will drive the global economy for the next few generations at least. It's not unreasonable to compare it to access to coal, oil, or electricity (at different times in the last few hundred years) in terms of how it enables people and companies to create jobs as well as go about their daily business. I don't think the electricity analogy is particularly good. It's oversimplified, and it doesn't exactly frighten anyone because no one can imagine anyone charging more for running one appliance rather than another. But it would improve that analogy a little if it went like this: you pay x amount for running your fridge if it's a Samsung smart fridge. You pay 10x if it's not. I think a better way of explaining it is in a way that really resonates with people's pocket books. The price of gas. Imagine that gas stations charged variable rates depending on where you do your shopping, where you go for entertainment, or where you go to dinner because the companies that provide these things are allowed to subsidize your travel to them. Want to buy your groceries at Super Walmart this week? Yay! Your gas is free! Oh, you want to go to the local farmer's market? Your gas is $10/gallon. Want to go see a movie at your local AMC GigaPlex 42 in 5D? 50 cents/gallon. You want to go see a small modern dance performance at your local community theater? $8/gal. Hey! Go eat at an Applebee's 40 miles from you. Getting there is free! And you can stop at any of these participating shopping malls along the way to pick up some clothes from Banana Republic. Oh, you want to go to a local diner run by some of your friends? Fuck you. Gas is going to be $50/gal for that. Worst of all in this analogy is this: If you'd like to go vacation at a Disney resort, gas to get there is free no matter where you are. But wait, you'd like to go to the MOMA and look at art? Well, a lot of artists are pretty shady people. They do drugs and have sex. We're not selling you any gas at all for any price if you're going to drive there. And to take it mildly political and back to technology, wait until news media companies get a chance to buy in. Do you want to live in a world where visiting Fox News is free and visiting nytimes.com costs 5 cents per click? (Or vice versa depending on your political leanings). If we're somewhat concerned about the role that advertising and social media are playing in our political discourse now, just wait until you add traffic shaping through cost incentives into the mix. Not having this regulation is the equivalent of letting a few companies create and OPEC-like cabal that sets the price of a vital resource for the U.S. and the U.S. only. In my opinion, it's a guaranteed disaster for our country economically, politically, and socially. And by the way, I'm including examples of zero-rating here (making certain internet resources free) because I think that's a vital part of net neutrality. The rules put in place need to be strengthened, not eliminated to maintain a neutral internet service. I think Thompson's arguments on that point are way out of line.
- racer-v 9y agoEvery business wants the services they rely on to be commodity, but they don't want to be a commodity to the layer above them - they want to extract some of the value those upper layers provide. For example, a toll bridge is a commodity; it charges the same fee for a truckload of diamonds as a truckload of coal. If you were a bridge owner, you'd prefer to be able to charge more for people getting a lot of value out of your bridge. Similarly, people who own the Internet pipes want to claim part of the value of new innovations build on them - to charge differential pricing for, say, streaming movies, vs less profitable types of content. The people building those innovations say, no way - charge us by the bit and it's not your business what those bits are doing.
- indubitable 9y agoNet neutrality is simply requiring that all packets and data are treated identically by ISPs. They can offer faster speeds to all sites, but Comcast cannot offer faster speed to only Comcast Video on Demand, for instance. Or similarly Time Warner, who owns CNN, could not decide to throttle down all news sites except CNN. It's extremely desirable at a glance, which is why this issue is so divisive. A glance is all most people give most issues! If you'd like to understand Pai's argument, you're going to need to read unedited interviews with Pai himself. The media in general is giving a very one sided view of this issue. I tend to agree with the desire to keep net neutrality as well, but I think Pai's view is also perfectly cogent and deserving of more than the mob-driven straw manning that it's been given. So what is his view? Let's start with Google Fiber as an interesting case study. Google Fiber has effectively been a failure. In the ~6 years of operation to 2016 it managed an estimated 0.07million television subscribers, 0.45 million broadband subscribers. They've since rolled back further plans for expansion and engaged in lay offs and downsizing. Why did it fail? There are quite a large number of reasons but the most fundamental issue is that they didn't attract anywhere near the number of signups they likely anticipated. Why not? The most basic reason is that they announce they're coming to an area. They then spend billions of dollars setting up their infrastructure, advertising, hiring, and getting ready to launch. The day before they 'flip the switch', Comcast/Time Warner announces they are price and speed matching them. Some people sign up out of spite, but most do not. The thing about competition against a monopoly is that you need to not only be able to beat what they are charging, but what they can charge. Or you need to create a different, somehow more compelling offering. So what does this have to do with net neutrality? Net neutrality in essence requires that ISPs behave identically to one another. Their only distinguishing factor is supposed to be speed and cost. This, in turn, means companies have to be able to offer prices or speeds that Time Warner/Comcast simply could not match. And this isn't really possible. Given their size, these companies could even afford to run at a loss to drive out competition if necessary. A recent NYT article stated something that seems to contradict everything I just stated. In particular they imply that France and the UK have strong net neutrality, yet also have some 13 and 50+ telecom companies, respectively, competing for business. I asked people why that was here [1]. The responses there are very informative, but I also found them somewhat ironic. It's about bundling, per site performance in some cases, and more. In other words, the behaviors that eliminating neutrality would overtly allow are already what is helping drive competition in these areas. If Pai is right then disabling net neutrality will help drive competition and investment in telecoms. If he is wrong then instead you'll simply see the doomsday scenarios I described in my first paragraph. So that gamble is disconcerting. There are rules and regulations in place for anti-competitive behavior that could help preempt some of these scenarios, but that's certainly hardly a relief given the current state of telecom operation in the US is presumably completely legal. But on the other hand before you assume the doomsday scenarios do come to pass, how do you think that would change the calculus for competition from an upstart? When Comcast/Time Warner only need worry about the price/speed of things, the determination of consumer perception is simple. When it starts coming down to far more nuanced issues of service management and packages, it's not so easy for them to simply say "We match this, exactly." In some cases that may not even be possible - an upstart ISP with agreements with various companies could create offerings that would be money losers for other ISPs. [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15903647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15903647
- crooked-v 9y agoThe problem with what you want is that there are only two extremely obvious sides in the argument: 1. ISPs, who without net neutrality get to nickel and dime everyone else. (Subscribe to Internet Plus for +$25/month to get access to Facebook and Reddit! Subscribe to Internet Pro for +$80/month to get access to VPNs!) 2. Literally everyone else, including every individual internet user and every non-ISP business in the world.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- friendzis 9y agoAs far as I personally understand, net neutrality is mostly about disconnect between content and src/dst - under perfect net neutrality only source and destination should matter for packet delivery. Does not matter whether this is a last mile connection or tier 1 intercontinent connection. I personally believe that DNS/IP site blocking is against net neutrality. Net neutrality, common carrier, DMCA safe harbour and similar are based on similar non-discrimination provisions. All analogies I can think of are a bit leaky, but the closest to my mind is package shipping. Under perfect net neutrality, a resident purchases two mailboxes from last mile provider (ISP) under certain fee. Last mile provider commits to emptying outbound box and filling inbound box two times a day. If everything destined to resident does not fit into mailbox - packages will be redelivered at next scheduled delivery. Obviously resident can only send as much packages at a time as they can fit to the mailbox (connection speed). Last mile provider commits to delivering wherever the packages are destined to be delivered even if the package smells of dead dead bodies and make geiger counter scream. If they have to hand off packages to peers - that is their problem and their expenses. Continuing this analogy, FCC's plan is to allow shipping companies to make clients submit unpackaged parcels (meaning subcontractors can open packages and inspect contents and both last mile carrier and original sender) at packaging station where company can inspect the parcel, source, destination and charge/queue packages differently based on these criteria. Some practical consequences of that could be for example shipping time dependency on retailer/product. You could get a WD drive from Amazon in a day, but Seagate drive in a week. The same company could ship Seagates from Wallmart in a day, but WDs in a week. As a customer you could have no idea. Net neutrality, on the other hand, does not allow to deliver packages from you to your neighbor (which is obviously cheaper) at reduced price. If your neighbors constantly fill their outbound mailboxes to the extent that pickup truck has to ride back to distribution center, come back to to your street and resume collection, net neutrality does not allow pickup truck to skip packages to pick your once in a month package for faster delivery. If the package is too big to fit into mailbox it has to be split into smaller packages and assembled by recipient. If you received your large machine critical to your business in small pieces over a month, assembled and are only waiting for batteries to arrive, net neutrality does not allow to ship your batteries under higher priority than hair tie to your neighbor who has moved out a week ago.
- turc1656 9y agoThis is a great piece. https://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=232617 https://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=232617 It's written by a disagreeable, cantankerous man, but he used to be the CEO of an ISP in Chicago years ago. He knows what he's talking about.
- anon11082016 9y agoThink of it this way, NN is like the post office being forced to charge the same shipping price and provide the same speed for two varying weight packages. A dumbbell vs a letter. The post office is a unique situation because it's crappiness is subsidized by the government and it can continue operating at a loss.