18 ms·
How to Read Mathematics
- jordigh 9y agoOne thing that I really would like to impress upon computer people is that mathematics is not (usually) a formal computer language. Symbols and technical terms change meaning depending on the author, people write with different "accents". There's a little ambiguity and informality at times, but a whole lot less than other kinds of writing. Mathematics is (usually) written for humans, not computers. Don't attempt to read mathematics as you read code. To keep making bad analogies, it's a bit more like reading music. Picking the right tempo, the notes to accentuate, the interpretation -- this all requires a human. Computer still make crude approximations.
- retox 9y agoWhy is that? Why is there not a universal way of writing mathematics that is not ambiguous and can be read by anyone that understands the 'language'? I have a deep dread and fear of numbers and mathematics in general because I don't understand them and I have never learned. Now I learn that there isn't one thing to learn but a vast array? No thanks. I had this apparently romantic view that an equation is an equation (the same equation) anywhere in the world.
- meken 9y agoI think the answer is that such a language would be overly verbose. You could ask the same question about human language and the same answer applies.
- heavenlyblue 9y agoIt probably is also the case that the language used in sci articles is constantly changing, too. We may take advantage of libraries in programming (but even then they may not work on all of the physical platforms), but it's not that well defined, what is "the fundamental language" of mathematics; at least not as of today. Although I find it cool that tools like Coq are getting increasingly popular, so we will eventually get there.
- Smaug123 9y agoWhy is there not a universal way of writing anything that is not ambiguous and can be read by anyone that understands the 'language'? Because humans have a tendency to defy attempts at classification and constraint. Constructed real-world languages (Lojban, Esperanto) haven't really taken off, while non-constructed languages mix and match whenever they feel like it ("le parking", "Schadenfreude"). The same is true in maths: people use what is easiest.
- erasemus 9y agoBecause whenever we read something we have to guess the meaning. To the human mind, all communications are inherently contextual and metaphorical. To put it another way each individual has his own internal private language into which everything he reads must be translated.
- emacsgifs 9y agoIt's as if we truly believe that 0 is positive charged and 1 is negative charged. Or to take us a step further, that a certain arrangements of electrons is "negative" and the inverse arrangement is "positive" I often tell CS people that everything in computing is metaphor and it honestly disturbs me that 80% of the time I get blank looks.
- sevensor 9y ago> I often tell CS people that everything in computing is metaphor and it honestly disturbs me that 80% of the time I get blank looks This is why people think Machine "Learning" means that the Singularity is near.
- Aaargh20318 9y ago> Why is there not a universal way of writing anything that is not ambiguous and can be read by anyone that understands the 'language'? You mean like Lojban (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lojban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lojban) ?
- remus 9y ago> Now I learn that there isn't one thing to learn but a vast array? No thanks. I had this apparently romantic view that an equation is an equation (the same equation) anywhere in the world. It's not as bad as that! You're very unlikely to hit this sort of issue until you're reading research papers (unless you decide you're very interested in mathematical history). Pretty much all the material youll come across up to ~undergrad level will use very, very similar notation.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThe first alternate notation I think in maths, I used was dot (period) notation for scalar multiplication. Next would be different versions of standard form (aka engineering notation). Later, at high-school (UK, 16-18yo) we used both d/dx type notation for differentiation and x-dot (a dot above the letter for each level of differentiation). There would be 3 versions of x= ut + (at^2)/2 that we'd know, this one, d/dx, and dot-notation; primarily the former was used in physics and the latter in maths. We'd also use suffixed numbering, u_0, u_1 on occasions and use u, v, w on other occasions. One important point - they're not different equations, just written differently. You write for your audience, in an advanced paper you can abbreviate and use shorthand because you know the reader (in general) will understand. As an undergrad I found that each department I studied in would tend to use different notation - chemistry, ecology, maths, physics, computing - for the same things. Though sometimes different professors would buck the trend ... they also had different accents and vocabulary, our QFT professor loved the word recapitulation. You also get different symbol use, like rho for density in one domain and d in another; but that's not really notation per se. TL;DR sometimes you come across different notation earlier. Different notation doesn't change the equation.
- bzbarsky 9y agoThere are at least three different commonly used notations I'm aware of for division.... And that's not counting the long division process, for which I'm aware of at least two different notations (usage varies by country).
- TuringTest 9y ago> Why is that? Why is there not a universal way of writing mathematics that is not ambiguous and can be read by anyone that understands the 'language'? There is one, it's called formal logic. The problem with it is that it's not adequate to explain things, only to prove theorems formally; any strict unambiguous proof written in formal logic looks more like a debug trace than a scientific article. To provide a proper explanation of a mathematical result, at many points in the proof you need to summarize the hundreds of intermediate mechanical steps and write the insight behind them in common language, using potentially ambiguous words.
- rsj_hn 9y agoWhat do you mean by "writing" mathematics? The glib answer is that math is a superset of programming and there are non-computable arithmetic functions, so programming is not rich enough to describe what you need to describe when you are talking about math. I think a more intuitive answer is that in math you are generally talking about relations between infinite sets of objects, whereas in programming you are living in a (in practice) finite space and are evaluating everything into an integer. Programming is about calculating integers, mathematics is about proving theorems. The language has to be very different because what is crucial about evaluating integers unambiguously is peripheral to proving theorems and vice versa. You can ask, why is it so painful to give a formal proof of correctness of your program? It's impossible to do for all but the most trivial programs. You know that a brilliant person, given years of work, might be able to come up with a proof of correctness, but you also know that the language they would use to do that would be very different from the language that you as programmer would use to write your program. So it goes in both directions. Programs evaluate numbers, they are essentially adding machines, and central to that is the erasure of state via addition. Math is about symbolic relations and erasure of state is via relations on infinite sets. For example, you want to prove that if a group has a prime number of elements, then it must be cyclic. So pick a generator, raise it to powers, and get a subgroup. Then by Cauchy's theorem, the order of the subgroup has to divide the order of the main group, and that order is prime, so therefore the subgroup has to be the whole group. There are many things to unpack in that statement. For example, Cauchy's theorem, which says that if a A is a subgroup of B, then the order of A divides the order of B. So Cauchy's theorem + Group is prime order => non-zero subgroups must be the whole group. And then every non-zero group has a non-trivial cyclic subgroup + non-zero subgroups must be the whole group => the whole group is a cyclic group. So it's bit like adding numbers, in that you forget state, but the rules are much more complicated involving quantifiers and a huge universe of sets. To build a computer that could reason that way, you'd need an infinite set of registers, rules for quantifiers, etc. and your unit of memory would be abstract set relations instead of a zero or 1. You can try to simulate special cases of that in software, say with an SMT solver. If you look at the DSL of writing code for SMT solvers, it looks different from the code that a programmer is used to writing, and the best SMT solver can't really do anything too interesting from a math point of view, with very rare exceptions. Moreover in math as practiced, no one (except some logicians) writes in formal logic. It would be too cumbersome. Simple statements like "a harmonic function on a disk achieves its maximum and minimum value on the boundary of its domain" would require thousands of pages of formal symbols and quantifiers. No one can think like that, and so we don't write math that way because we also want to forget things and make compact statements, but what we forget in math is relationships among infinite sets, things like, what are the real numbers, what is a function on the real numbers, what is a differential, what is a harmonic function, what is the maximum of a function, what is a disk, all of that is packed into our statement and replaced with a math statement that is much more compact in the same way that 1 && 0 are replaced by 0 in a computer register, but the computer register is not rich enough to model relations on sets.
- jiggunjer 9y agoI had this reaction to sign language. Seemed like deaf people missed a good opportunity, but then I realized that how we talk and think is shaped very much by our language. Similarly scholars from different backgrounds have different ways of expressing a precise mathematical concept. This one paper I read implicitly treated complex scalars as real vectors, took me some time to clear up the confusion.
- pathsjs 9y agoAn exercise that I made during my degree and phd years in maths was to always take notes in a consistent notation across the various lectures, regardless of the convention used by the teacher. It forced me to pay attention and as a bonus I have a consistent set of notes for most undergraduate mathematics :-)
- joppy 9y agoWhy should all mathematics be written using exactly the same language and conventions? Should all computer programs be written in the same language? People modify the language (natural, mathematical, programming) they are using to suit their problem. It is unreasonable to expect that the kind of language you use at the foundations of mathematics for example (set axioms and so on) would be efficient and useful for stating properties of much more complex objects: this exactly parallels computer programming languages. Admittedly, there are no big tables containing "definitions" of these languages. But I think it is common opinion that if you don't understand the language a paper is using, then there is a very large chance you don't know the underlying theory, and the paper will make no sense anyway.
- Firadeoclus 9y agoThere's also a small but non-negligible chance that you could have understood the paper because you know (part of) the underlying theory under a different name, using different notation and concepts but leading to the same results.
- internetman55 9y agoThis is true. The CS folks are my university tended to be quite strict about writing out quantifiers for everything, while a very accomplished math researcher in our department told our class to "please write in English" instead of using those symbols, because he wouldn't be able to read them. I asked a friend why he thought this was, and he suspected that the CS department's focus on formal languages and automatic theorem proving is what lead to their use of logical symbols.
- lostcolony 9y agoMore computers understand only what they're told. You -have- to be exact. Humans can infer. If it doesn't make sense, they realize something is wrong and attempt to make sense of it. As to why the mathematician preferred 'English', I think it's because quantifiers aren't universal. Mathematical notation itself isn't universal. That is, while the student may be internally consistent and exact in their qualifiers, they are not universally consistent between students, nor with the professor's expectation. The professor wanted to immediately grok what the student was trying to do, not have to approach every single turned in assignment as though it was an unfamiliar mathematical paper, using its own notation, that he had to interpret (where some symbols may share a standard meaning across papers, others won't)
- opportune 9y agoI was this guy to certain professors: at the end of the day it's less about formality and more about someone's ability to understand you at a high level and assess you. To me, I was trying to convey my ideas as precisely as possible. To my professor, I was being so verbose that it would have taken him at least an hour to thoroughly assess the rigor with which I had approach my proof, which simply doesn't scale to all students. Your friend in math is definitions. IME clever definitions minimize the sheer amount of rigor you need to get from point A to point B through their abstractions. The more "natural" or easily understandable a definition is, the easier it is to use that definition as a ground truth in your theorems. For example, I have an unpublished proof of a graph/game-theory conjecture. Proving the theorem's correctness is extremely convoluted if you rely on atomic definitions of graphs, valid actions, etc. However, as you define new relationships precisely, it becomes much easier. The more abstractly you approach the problem, the simpler the problem becomes, given the correct abstractions.
- protonfish 9y agoBut humans can't read it, nor can computers. Maybe it's time to ask if we can do better than traditional formal mathematical notation.
- bjl 9y agoPlenty of humans can read formal mathematical notation just fine.
- andrepd 9y agoWhat do you mean by "humans can't read it".
- protonfish 9y agoWhat I mean is that mathematical notation was never developed with the intention of being easily understood. Nobody writes out a formula and then spends time making it more readable. In programming they do - it's called refactoring. How mathematicians typically polish an already correct formula is called "simplification." This usually leads to their collection of symbols being even more inscrutable. But the more mathematical proofs, formulae, and other statements are unintelligible, the more they make you appear really smart, so the natural tendency is to obfuscate mathematical statements as much as possible. And because this notation cannot be executed by a machine, there is no way to easily prove that it isn't complete gibberish.
- jcranberry 9y agoMost math books construct narratives and have points of view on the mathematics they present. Math texts in particular are constantly "refactored" in order to build around a them, or core idea if present. There is a big difference between code and math in that good code is written with the intent that it be understood as quickly and easily as possible in order to not stymie productivity. Non-referential math texts are written not just to teach you the theorems, but a mathematical perspective, such that the mathematics within becomes intuitive through that perspective. Its both wildly ignorant and insulting to suggest mathematicians only portray their theorems as minimally is possible for no other purpose than mental masturbation.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoHow I read Mathematics. First try to find the paper. First use http://front.math.ucdavis.edu http://front.math.ucdavis.edu . If you can't find it then use google scholar. If that fails then go on the authors academic website. If that fails then see if the author is live and try to contact them. Then repeat for their grad students. If all else fails post it to r/math or HN and ask for the pdf. First you want to see if this paper is even worth reading. Scan the Abstract and the conclusions. If it is still relevant then do a quick scan of the whole text and look for the things you don't understand. For everything you don't understand look up on wikipedia. Once you have found those pages then look on the citations on wikipedia to gain more understanding. If you still can't understand the paper reread it and then attempt to redo their calculations. If all else fails ask someone to help you read it. Whenever you get confused write on the paper questions. If you figure out that this paper is meaningless then look for another one. If you figure out a new question that you want to persue more then try to answer that question. If you don't have access to professor or if they are impeding your work then use stackexchange. Either that or try to invalidate your new theory yourself. Recognize that you can be wrong.
- Iv 9y agoAlso a very good advice I had received a long time ago but that I had dismissed until recently: some articles are just badly written. The author sometimes forget to mention what B actually is, changes the meaning of the multiplication operator implicitly, assumes the formula given is inside an integral.... I could go on. A maths article is an article. A lot are imperfect, quite a few are bad. Some times it is not the reader that is lacking. That being said, do your homeworks and only consider that possibility after giving the article one hour of your time or so.
- nicklaf 9y agoI remember reading this exact piece of advice, but have been trying to remember where. Would anybody be able to provide the blog post I believe we both read, which says almost exactly what Iv wrote? I could have sworn Michael Nielson wrote it, but I was unable to produce it last time I searched. So I am following OP's advice and am asking here. :P
- vinchuco 9y agoI disagree with 'do not read too fast': Skim all. Skim again the next day. But the third time, get pencil and paper and take notes, and effort. If it's neither uncomfortable nor exciting, you're doing it wrong.
- smhost 9y agoSo basically take a couple days to understand the material rather than going all in all at once?
- BeetleB 9y agoFew math professors grok a journal paper within a day. One professor told me he strives for a page a day.
- catnaroek 9y agoJust... no. If you actually have to understand it (rather than, say, peer-review it), then make a honest attempt to understand it right from the beginning. For instance, suppose it takes you 30 minutes to skim through a chapter of a math book. Then you've wasted 30 minutes you could've spent understanding the chapter's first section.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoWhat if everyone learns differently?
- criloz2 9y agohaha true, I envy people that just sit down read a book/chapter/article/blog linearly and then comes enlightened, I can't, I need to first Skim almost 90% of the material, and then start again from the bottom, reading the last part and trying to figure out how the first part is connected or are important for understand what is written. I think that people that read it linearly don't miss important info, but I just can't
- mad44 9y agoGood advice. Here is my advice for reading research papers. http://muratbuffalo.blogspot.com/2013/07/how-i-read-research-paper.html http://muratbuffalo.blogspot.com/2013/07/how-i-read-research...
- sulam 9y agoI’m curious if anyone has advice on how to understand all the symbols used in math papers. Frequently I find this is the first barrier for me in reading them.
- kalid 9y agoShameless plug, I write about math on BetterExplained.com For each symbol, I try to make an analogy. For "e", for example, I have the notion of "continuous growth". The formal definition is this: https://betterexplained.com/ColorizedMath/content/img/E_(mathematical_constant).png https://betterexplained.com/ColorizedMath/content/img/E_(mat... "The base for continuous growth is the unit quantity earning unit interest for unit time." Once you see the role of each part of the definition, the idea snaps into place. I just wrote about it here: https://betterexplained.com/articles/colorized-math-equations/ https://betterexplained.com/articles/colorized-math-equation... Hope that helps!
- catnaroek 9y ago> For each symbol, I try to make an analogy. Analogies are utterly unhelpful without a thorough understanding of the actual definitions.
- kalid 9y agoAnalogies on their own are limited if you don't continue to the technical definition. They are a raft to cross the river.
- signa11 9y ago> ... They are a raft to cross the river. or rather like net to catch the fish. once you have the fish, you can forget about the net. this is not far removed from words, which are used to convey meaning. once you have meaning you can forget about the words ;) edit-001 : fmt changes.
- 9y ago
- wimagguc 9y agoFeynman’s method to understand complex problems is so simple and elegant! Surely you’re joking, mr Feynman: ”I can’t understand anything in general unless I’m carrying along in my mind a specific example and watching it go. Some people think in the beginning that I’m kind of slow and I don’t understand the problem, because I ask a lot of these “dumb” questions: “Is a cathode plus or minus? Is an an-ion this way, or that way?” But later, when the guy’s in the middle of a bunch of equations, he’ll say something and I’ll say, “Wait a minute! There’s an error! That can’t be right!” The guy looks at his equations, and sure enough, after a while, he finds the mistake and wonders, “How the hell did this guy, who hardly understood at the beginning, find that mistake in the mess of all these equations?” He thinks I’m following the steps mathematically, but that’s not what I’m doing. I have the specific, physical example of what he’s trying to analyze, and I know from instinct and experience the properties of the thing. So when the equation says it should behave so-and-so, and I know that’s the wrong way around, I jump up and say, “Wait! There’s a mistake!”
- therein 9y agoI read that in Feynman's voice in my mind. His tone is unmistakable with each word he utters you can hear him smile with astonishment at the complexity of things. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqtuNXWT0mo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqtuNXWT0mo
- malmsteen 9y agoSo. much. Using simple examples, low dimensions and physical analogies is really a key to advanced math.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sundarurfriend 9y agoAlso from the same book: "I had a scheme, which I still use today when somebody is explaining something that I’m trying to understand: I keep making up examples. For instance, the mathematicians would come in with a terrific theorem, and they’re all excited. As they’re telling me the conditions of the theorem, I construct something which fits all the conditions. You know, you have a set (one ball) – disjoint (two balls). Then the balls turn colors, grow hairs, or whatever, in my head as they put more conditions on. Finally they state the theorem, which is some dumb thing about the ball which isn’t true for my hairy green ball thing, so I say, ‘False!’"
- wiz21c 9y agoFTA : >>> One can now check that the next statement is true with a certain amount of essentially mechanical, though perhaps laborious, checking. I, the author, could do it, but it would use up a large amount of space and perhaps not accomplish much, since it'd be best for you to go ahead and do the computation to clarify for yourself what's going on here. I promise that no new ideas are involved, though of course you might need to think a little in order to find just the right combination of good ideas to apply. I hate that. When I program my computer, I specify all the steps to accomplish something. If it's too verbose, then I abstract it in a function. I even add comments to make sure that a human reader easily and completely understands what I do. I do that because I want the computer and the human reader to be productive in their understanding of what I do. And because I want the human reader to see that it's either elegant or just mechanical. I'm not that pretentious to say "hey, I've hidden a few details because if you are as smart as I am, then you'll understand easily". I had this when learning maths. As a student I was sometimes lost because I always thought maths were hard. Should I have had all the details, I'd seen it was indeed much easier than I thought and wouldn't have been intimidated. Now, I'm older, and I know all of that and I'm much better at mathematics. But what a waste of time. And the space argument, come one. Just put all the stuff in annexes and it'll be fine.
- klibertp 9y ago> I hate that. When I program my computer, I specify all the steps to accomplish something. If it's too verbose, then I abstract it in a function. > I even add comments to make sure that a human reader easily and completely understands what I do. Yeah, honestly, any single time I read a maths-related paper I feel like I would be better off with an example, well-written, implementation in any programming language. Then I recall what the code, written by mathematicians, tends to look like, and I'm not so sure anymore... Seriously, the fact that math people choose to ignore the last 50 years of software engineering development, which was in a large part focused on readability and maintainability, instead of incorporating the techniques for themselves is really baffling. As it is, aside from a couple of really well-written articles, reading any paper has a high chance of frustrating me to tears...
- 9y ago
- a-saleh 9y agoOne good advice our calculus lecturer gave us was: "Proofs are not meant to be understood by reading them from beginning to end. They are usually meant to be `checked` that way. Most of the time, I start reading the proof from the conclusion and work backwards. Often I write my proofs that way as well."
- dan_mctree 9y agoIt's too bad in the majority of cases you won't have someone besides you answering all the questions. Without that, the reader would've gotten stuck long ago.
- Dowwie 9y agoThis advice could be adapted to more general advice on learning
- nathell 9y ago> The author usually spends months discovering things, and going down blind alleys. At the end, he organizes it all into a story that covers up all the mistakes (and related motivation), and presents the completed idea in clean neat flow. The way to really understand the idea is to re-create what the author left out. Read between the lines. Pity there's little mathematical writing that actually _does_ contain these blind alleys and mistakes. Part of why I enjoy "Concrete Mathematics" by Graham/Knuth/Patashnik is that it's one of the rare counterexamples.
- chestervonwinch 9y agoI was thinking of ideas for a talk recently, and I thought of "Things I tried that didn't work and one that did" or something to that effect. However, when I looked through my old failed approaches, I found the amount of documentation was proportional to the level of success of the approach, making such a talk nearly impossible.
- tomerbd 9y agoI would add - draw!
- Kaka4 9y agoPure mathematics is, in its way, the poetry of logical ideas - Albert Einstein
- g00gler 9y agoI’ve been struggling with this lately as I’ve been studying ML/Stat. Thanks ColinWright!
- lostcolony 9y ago"Mathematical ideas are by nature precise and well defined, so that a precise description is possible in a very short space" "A well-written math text will be careful to use a word in one sense only" So many papers are not that careful, and thus, not so precise. There are only so many greek letters, so they end up overloaded. I can't count the number of times I've struggled over an equation, only to find out that the reason it made no sense and/or the value for a specific example came out differently was because the author assumed one variable to mean something differently than I did (and my assumption was perfectly valid in another context. Sometimes another context in -the same paper-). The whole experience is incredibly frustrating. Echoing another point here, if you just show a sufficiently non-trivial example and walk me through it, I grok it quickly. -Then- give me the equation if you must.
- vidarh 9y agoMy main exposure to mathematics is via CS papers, and this is doubly true there it seems to the point where my warning bells go off if they present their solutions in equations - it's all to often a sign that they're going to hand-wave away essential details that'd be obvious were missing if they presented code or even pseudo-code. E.g. I did my MSc. on statistical approaches to reducing error rates in OCR, and so many of the papers I reviewed for my literature review suffered from leaving out absolutely critical information when they presented equations etc. that most of the time I spent implementing a lot of the methods presented tended to be to try to reverse engineering missing information (and often that was only possible because many of the papers used one of a few well established public datasets for their experiments). To me, for those CS papers, maths was a warning what was lying ahead was likely not precise or well defined. It's incredibly frustrating as there were generally no good reason to do so - it wasn't a matter of leaving out large bulks of complicated code. Often it could be as simply as leaving out the concrete values of given parameters. I'm not implying maths have no place in CS papers, but the CS papers that I've seen that have used it best have tended to also present code fragments, or use maths very sparingly and coupled with painstakingly defining variables etc.
- lostcolony 9y agoYeah, my attempt at a master's in CS (before deciding the time would be better spent elsewhere) left me feeling largely the same. "Oh, isn't that equation elegant. Oh, wait, actually trying to implement it...what the hell, where is all the other information I need?! That's a gaussian...but where do the parameters for that gaussian come from? What is this variable? WHAT IS THIS VARIABLE?!" etc. I had a 4.0 departmental in CS from the same school I tried to get a master's in, but yeah, the master's experience was so bad, and working through those issues so time consuming, I just said "Screw it, I can get a better return on this amount of time doing my own things". Even if it's learning the same things, but to an explicit goal rather than just 'understanding' (and an eventual test/assignment that may or may not relate to what I care about), and where I'm not constrained by an academic policy that prevents me from going to others to have them explain exactly what I need to know.
- sarmad123 9y agomathematics good for brain
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rkachowski 9y agoI like this approach. I've always been stumped by the exact phrases like "it follows easily" and my eyes tend to glaze over whenever I encounter that latex math formula typeface. Breaking it down like this suddenly helps me appreciate the other layer of communication in math writing, which isn't just about expressing a specific mathematical idea - but also about expressing how to appreciate it. One gripe is the circular > Before you start to read, make sure you know what the author expects you to know. How can you know what the contents of the text require before you know (read) the contents of the text?
- ColinWright 9y agoAs others have said elsewhere, skim it once or twice, ignoring the detail, reading the text, getting an overall gist of the way it goes. Then brew a fresh coffee, grab pad and pencil, roll up your sleeves, and make notes as you go.
- billfruit 9y agoMathematical notation is often too vague, informal and too dependent on context.Frankly there is too much ambiguous overloading of symbols.It seems the language has evolved to be succinct and short to write, rather than being explicit and unambiguous.I know maths people say that it is meant to be read by people and not by computers. More people are acustomed to reading code than ever before.I feel that math notation needs reform that makes it formal, unambiguous and capable of describing imperative manipulations rather than be merely declarative, with clear annotations of type information of entities.
- kachnuv_ocasek 9y agoThat's what type theory is for. There have been some very interesting developments in the last 40 years that you might want to check out.
- ocfnash 9y agoA rather obvious but often overlooked piece of advice is to "read the masters". IMHO it is very easy to waste tonnes of time reading papers / books that are OK but still vastly inferior to an account of a master. Want to learn index theory: read Atiyah and Singer's original papers. Interested in the classification of quadratic forms: read Serre's course in arithmetic. Need to learn about the recent breakthroughs on prime tuples: read Tao! Find time to read Weil, insist on reading Poincare, come up with an excuse to read Scholze etc. Top mathematics literature is often spectacularly well written. See also: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/28268/do-you-read-the-masters https://mathoverflow.net/questions/28268/do-you-read-the-mas...
- agentultra 9y agoWhat I most enjoy about reading mathematics is convincing myself that what I'm reading is true. I like to keep a pad of dot-graph paper and a pencil with me as I read to break down the theorems, lemmas, and expressions as I go; try derivations, etc. Martin Gardner got me into the habit as I read his articles while I was growing up. These days I can even toy with the idea in Lean[0] or TLA+ and find different ways of formulating the results. What a time to be alive! [0] http://leanprover.github.io/ http://leanprover.github.io/
- killjoywashere 9y agoThere's a contrast between the comments here about Feynman, and the author's example of birthdays. The birthday data is totally random, and the author's assert this is the sort of thing mathematicians enjoy. It strikes me that Wolfram does this too, he'll demo something by saying "let's get some data" and then generate a big pile of random numbers. I usually space out at that point. I understand the utility of it, but I find it worthless in most cases. I'd rather understand a concrete example well, then check my understanding by trying the random case, then try to think of some clever or experience based edge case or counterexample. I think Feynman, especially later in life, probably had the gift of jumping straight to step 3: he understood that his most valuable contribution could often be simply expanding the space of possible examples. And random doesn't really get you the whole space, and certainly doesn't get you the interesting parts of the space.
- x14 9y agoJust my perspective, but mathematics seems like badly-written software to me. Shitty single-letter variable names with all the code in main() without any separation of concerns.
- platz 9y agotry reading some proofs in coq to see how badly software does in making mathematics readable. nevertheless, i agree for things like white papers the overloading of identifiers is frustrating.
- dekhn 9y agoAfter many years of frustration not being able to read physics papers, a helpful physics guy told me: when it's bolded, that means it's a matrix, and that other one, they didn't say so, but it's a vector, so this step is a vector matrix operation. (that's why, today, I use numpy, where the operations are much easier to see).
- nullsmack 9y agoAlso here: http://web.stonehill.edu/compsci/History_Math/math-read.htm http://web.stonehill.edu/compsci/History_Math/math-read.htm In fact, I think this must be the original source.