8 ms·
Apple ‘On Schedule’ to Terminate Music Downloads by 2019
- cpt1138 9y agoWhat are they planning to do when you have no connection?
- tantalor 9y agoYou can also download your content so that you can listen to or watch it when you're not connected to the Internet. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204839 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204839
- heavymark 9y agoAm I missing something? This appears to be some random site with a random source but all the comments here seem to be treating this as a real source.
- shakna 9y ago> Apple has told DMN that no such phase-out plan exists. One source has repeatedly insisted that the plan not only exists, but that it is ‘on schedule,’ or even ahead of the original schedule. Apple denied it when they first said it, and they deny it now. [0] But some anonymous source continues to say it, as of two years ago. I'm not seeing why DMN should be taken seriously. [0] http://mashable.com/2016/05/12/apple-itunes-kill-downloads-music/#E.ClrFTl18qE http://mashable.com/2016/05/12/apple-itunes-kill-downloads-m...
- emerged 9y agoI think you've just described the internet as a whole :)
- ioquatix 9y agoI can't help feel like a customer stuck in a consumer's world sometimes. I love buying and supporting individual artists on Bandcamp.
- mikepurvis 9y agoAgree. All the music I buy online is through artist pages on Bandcamp, and maybe the occasional album from CDBaby.
- stefan69 9y agoThe only problem I have with Bandcamp is that there are already some many good artists / music on Spotify. It's hard to take a stab at a more "amateur" market - it's not like we are running out of pro musicians to listen to. It's a shame because Bandcamp is actually pretty cool.
- slouch 9y agoBut where is the Bandcamp player that competes with Spotify's web player? Bandcamp needs a better player that I can enjoy using all day & in which I can build playlists.
- djeikyb 9y agoWhen Spotify takes the next step of their "incredible journey", I want to have more than memories of the great music I found. So I buy music on Bandcamp. And make backups.
- rexf 9y agoSame, if this article is accurate, it would phase out the channel (iTunes store) that I use to buy singles & albums digitally. I don't buy music files from Amazon or Google, since the UX is better as an iPhone user with iTunes music store. I use Spotify for general listening, but certain tracks, I'll buy on iTunes to have available offline (for what I thought was an indefinite period of time).
- SyneRyder 9y agoIf you download the files to your laptop, you'll still have those files to keep and transfer between your devices. I bought most of my music on iTunes, then copied it across to my Android device via a microSD card. (Incidentally, I'm still looking for a good Android music player for my offline files. Google Play Music works, but it isn't very elegant & it's hard to browse when you have lots of artists. I guess I'm wondering what the modern day Android equivalent of Winamp is.)
- scarface74 9y agoI'm almost sure that Apple still sells more music than movies and almost certainly tv shows. If they have kept those, I doubt they will discontinue music sells. It's not like it costs a lot to support.
- bob_theslob646 9y agoSource?
- scarface74 9y agoWell no direct source but if Apple is going to discontinue sells of music because of declines, then they would also do the same for movies. https://www.wsj.com/articles/apples-itunes-falls-short-in-battle-for-video-viewers-1499601601 https://www.wsj.com/articles/apples-itunes-falls-short-in-ba... And what do you think would be the totally addressable market of selling tv shows when you can get almost any broadcast tv network show on demand a day after it airs through your cable company for free and a week after it airs for free from the websites/apps of AbC, NBC, CBS, and FOX. You can get any TV show on demand the next morning from the CW whether or not you have a subscription. If you have cable and miss a show it's available usually the next day on demand either from the cable company or by signing in using your cable credentials from the individual cable providers apps. Then take into account that almost everyone has a device that they can buy and play digital music on in the optimal method. How many people who want to buy video digitally and would prefer to watch it on a TV have an AppleTV? AppleTV is far from the most popular settop box and it's the only way that you can watch content on a TV (besides connecting your iPhone with a $70 gadget). Both Google Play and Amazon work on the most popular set top box - the roku.
- Spooky23 9y agoPerhaps their contracts with the labels start expiring in the 2019-2021 timeframe?
- bob_theslob646 9y agoIf true, quite shocking for Apple's music's monetization ability. I would consider it a falling from grace since they were "trailblazers" and changed the industry with the iPod. >The iPod is a line of portable media players and multi-purpose pocket computers[2] designed and marketed by Apple Inc. The first version was released on October 23, 2001, about 8 1⁄2 months after the Macintosh version of iTunes was released. As of July 27, 2017, only the iPod Touch remains in production.[3](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod) Music sales have been dying for a while though and turns out , a Apple was apart of it. >Since the introduction the iTunes Music Store on April 28, 2003, music sales have plummeted in the United States -- from $11.8 billion in 2003 to $7.1 billion last year(2013), according to the Recording Industry Association of America. (http://money.cnn.com/2013/04/25/technology/itunes-music-decline/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2013/04/25/technology/itunes-music-decl...)
- taspeotis 9y agoYeah sure but streaming is where it's at now, and Apple have a piece of that pie. So I don't know why it's a fall from grace. They know which way the wind is blowing. https://www.ft.com/content/94c5cdb0-4a26-11e7-a3f4-c742b9791d43 https://www.ft.com/content/94c5cdb0-4a26-11e7-a3f4-c742b9791... > Streaming revenues will rise 37 per cent to $9.1bn in 2017, PwC estimates, while sales of physical formats will drop 10 per cent to $7.7bn
- x0x0 9y agoLetting Spotify, rather than Apple themselves, cannibalize music download sales was stupid. Also, it's the end of one of Apple's moats: your previous purchases. Spotify works on any device. I will say that Spotify is pretty shit on Android, but that's just laziness on their part. (Issues I've had, all on stock Nexus or HTC android phones: crashing. Muting google maps. Not pausing when disconnecting headphones. My laptop and phone fighting over who controls the playlist. Playlist corruption. Their Android team is, at best, C players. And lazy ones. Every time I get suckered into letting Spotify update there's a new bug.)
- 9y ago
- fernly 9y agoSeems like it should be technically feasible to capture the bits of a streamed song. Are there rogue players that can divert the content to a file?
- LeoPanthera 9y agoiTunes will happily stream Apple Music to an AirPlay device, and AirPlay is unencrypted ALAC. Alternatively simply play through a digital audio output and capture it that way.
- devwastaken 9y ago>Alternatively simply play through a digital audio output and capture it that way. You have no way of knowing what the data's original quality is at, and its introducing artifacts from analog output back into a digital form, which is then outputted to analog again. Its an option, sure, but its like saying "get all your music on youtube."
- namelost 9y agoThey are suggesting going digital-out (on the source) to digital-in. No analog. But as pointed out Audio Hijack does the same thing virtually with a kernel extension.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoYou misunderstood. I said digital capturing the digital audio output.
- DigitalJack 9y ago>and AirPlay is unencrypted ALAC. That won't last. And with the removal of the headphone jack, we lose our last analog (and unencrypted) path for capturing audio.
- goalieca 9y agoThe dongle works.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoWell I guess I have to go back to buying CDs, then? I will always want to own my music collection.
- stefan69 9y agoOr vinyls :)
- stefan69 9y agoSo what happens to all these albums we've bought on the iTunes Store? Despite the money we've poured in, we are on the same level than the next kid who just joined the Apple Music streaming service last month? That will push people to reconsider their loyalty to the company and their service.
- otterley 9y agoNothing AFAIK; they’re plain old AAC files. Apple eliminated FairPlay DRM on its iTunes Store purchases ages ago.
- BashiBazouk 9y agoMy guess to what the GP is asking is if the files will still be downloadable from Apple even if they are not selling the tracks anymore. My reading of the article, makes the answer to that question vague, saying: “But you can always go back and listen to the downloads, they always will work,” Does that mean if you still have the files, they will work (which is obviously the case) or does that mean they are available to download at anytime once bought from Apple, but will not be available to be purchased in the future...
- rconti 9y agoThe re-download feature is actually relatively new (though my hazy memory is thinking it's probably more like 10 years old now...)
- foobiekr 9y agoit will be interesting if apple removes downloaded media from itunes on the iphone. at that point I'm not sure how much value these would have.
- kirykl 9y agoSo this is just a rumor with anyonymous source reported by a single site?
- benmarks 9y ago> "All of that is raising concerns about an overloaded iTunes, especially among Apple engineers who are increasingly frustrated with the platform." How were they not frustrated before? I can't be the only person (engineer or civilian) who finds iTunes to be among the worst applications Apple's produced, and it's been that way for years.
- dieterrams 9y ago"[I]ncreasingly frustrated" suggests they were frustrated before, and are more so now.
- benmarks 9y agoFair point, for sure. Though if they've been paying attention, I'd expect them to be beyond mutiny at this point!
- ksec 9y agoShould be Corrected as : I can't be the only person (engineer or civilian) who finds iTunes to be among the worst applications ever been produced, and it's been that way for years.
- benmarks 9y agoAgree, was trying to come up with examples of worse software and failed.
- Reason077 9y agoI terminated music downloads in about 2009 - right about when Spotify came out. I do frequently use the offline playlists feature, however.
- paulie_a 9y agoSo you still download music then.
- dzhiurgis 9y agoHow do you tolerate 192kbps?
- Yetanfou 9y agoReally? - how do you 'tolerate' driving over less than perfectly flat roads? - how do you 'tolerate' looking through a window which was cleaned more than half an hour ago? - how do you 'tolerate' using last year's PC? - how do you 'tolerate' linving in less than a full democracy? - how do you 'tolerate' ... well, anything 'less than perfect'? 192 Kbps is perfectly usable for most occasions. You're not going to hear the difference while listening in a car, using a pair of 'less than perfect' headphones, in a noisy environment. If you want to listen to music with high dynamic variations in ideal listening conditions you might want to use something better but that's about it.
- dzhiurgis 9y agoIn all of those cases I have no choice. I do, however, have a choice for listening using high-end system while most headphones and cars make no difference in fidelity. Then there is problem of fragmentation. Far from all artists use same network, so you'll end up paying for multiple services to get the same thing.
- Yetanfou 9y agoThere is no fragmentation if you insist on getting downloadable content. Storage is cheap, get your own server and stuff it with your music. Install a streaming server (something like Subsonic/Madsonic/etc comes to mind, mpd also works when configured correctly) and point your devices at it.
- api 9y agoTomorrow I cancel Apple music and start using Bandcamp more. Something I've been meaning to do for a long time and this pushes me over the edge. Bandcamp needs an app where I can listen and buy with one click.
- __david__ 9y agoI don't understand how that follows from the story. Can you explain your thinking here?
- dzhiurgis 9y agoI keep catching iTunes use over 1GB of memory without even playing any music. Additionally, playing and managing the music you OWN is becoming harder and harder with each release. I’m sure they’ll kill this feature eventually.
- sandworm101 9y ago>>> and the grayed out collection becomes de minimis. Ya, it's de minimus until my favorite tunes go away. You don't have to be a conspiracy nut to understand what is going on here. They don't want old music on their new devices. Me listening to an old MP3 of my favorite band is, to Apple (or google or anyone else) a waste. Every minute I;m listening to that I'm not listening to <<hip new pop song 12>> via a streaming service. No data to extract. No products to pitch. No data plan to top up. No need to link my car's stereo to the cell network. We are free to listen to anything we want, so long as its on today's list of approved tracks. Just forget what you were listening to yesterday. Pretend it never existed, because it doesn't exist and never did. I cannot think of anything more antithetical to rock and roll than calling any music 'de minimus'. My car's stereo plays mp3s. It plays them when I am in the mountains and out of cell range. It plays them when I am on the lower deck of a car ferry. It plays them when my phone is dead and I don't have a charger. It plays them regardless of what boarder I cross. It will play anything I ask regardless of where it came from. And it won't tell anyone what I listen too alone in the car on my way to work. Nothing in Apple's walled garden shows that sort of loyalty.
- freeloop3 9y agoThe world is being fractured right now into too many individual groups. It used to be that if you strayed to far from the opinions of your peers, you would be isolated, and forced to come back to the center. This restricted freedom, but allowed for unity and made for a stronger, more cohesive and well adjusted population. Nowadays, there is no center. No matter where your individual preferences lead you, there is a group on the internet to validate them. With everyone pursuing different goals and interests, there is no center anymore. This leads to disharmony and chaos. By Apple controlling what you listen to and when, they are attempting to help society. If you, me, and everyone else was excited about the new Miley Cyrus album, think of how much more together we'd be as a whole. We'd have something in common with our physical neighbors, something to talk about and share. Being part of a collective, IRL, is far better than the poor substitute of some Reddit group. In the end, what Apple is doing is helping people. And, I for one, can't see how anyone can so readily dismiss what they are doing as bad, simply because they limit the functionality of their products a little bit.
- bhauer 9y ago> Pulling out lower-performing formats, especially music downloads, helps to solve the issue. Yeah, that's the problem with iTunes. The ability to play local music files really bogs it down. /sarcasm I don't use iTunes, so I don't care if they do this as long as the vendors I do use (Amazon, Burning Shed, Bandcamp, etc.) continue to provide downloads.
- jlgaddis 9y agoTL;DR: Unsubstantiated clickbait.
- ksec 9y agoI really wish we could have a different Model. I dont really like Streaming Music because I am not owning the Music at all, I am merely getting some access to it. And many times Music Label decide they stop providing access on the Platform, that means some parts of my music collection are gone. I really wish we could have a hybrid approach. For the same price per month, I can only listen to the same song maximum of 15 times a month, and it gives me some credit to buy music. And those Credit are accumulative.