9 ms·
I'm not sure why people feel any type of carb is bad for regular weight loss. There is no significant evidence that refined or unrefined carbs are bad for your
by KirinDave 16y ago
I'm not sure why people feel any type of carb is bad for regular weight loss. There is no significant evidence that refined or unrefined carbs are bad for your weight loss (assuming you are not diabetic). Carbs can be bad because carb-rich foods tend to be surprisingly high in calories, but that's about it from a weight loss perspective.
Also, 1,200kcal/day diets are brutal. Caloric restriction diets have overwhelming scientific evidence of being an ineffective strategy in the long term. Even if you have some elaborate food system with rest days, it doesn't matter. They fail for the overwhelming majority of people. They lose weight, fail to maintain the difficult diet, then pop back up.
Your body doesn't defy thermodynamics, but your metabolism is a clever thing. The best way to achieve permanent, long term body-fat loss is to reduce your diet to something reasonable and exercise (both aerobic and weight) regularly. I know hackers desperately want the clever solution, but as it stands there is no evidence-based way to get results that is as reliable as the "eat-less-workout-more" approach.
- desigooner 16y agoany calorie deficit of more than 500 cals a day doesn't really help as you'd be putting those pounds again after you return to your regular diet. A healthy deficit of 500 cals and working out 3-5 times a week should be the best approach as far as the long run goes as it's just not about losing weight but maintaining it as well in a healthy manner.
- KirinDave 16y agoRight. People seem to forget that if you modestly restrict your diet daily and work out 3-5 times a week, you're actually shaving quite a lot of calories off your weight in a weekly or monthly timespan. Halving normal intake daily may look good on a daily ledger, but it's really hard on your body.
- manvsmachine 16y agoI didn't get the idea that he was saying that 1200kcal was an everyday thing; if it was, then I totally agree. I can picture having 1200kcal days here and there when he's not really active though, like his aforementioned 12-15 hour hacking days. The main point being: listen to your body. I you feel like you really need to eat something, then eat something. If you don't, then don't.
- KirinDave 16y agoI can't even picture voluntary 1200kcal days, period. You're going to feel like hell if you're an average male denizen of Hacker News. Even a lot of women would feel bad on that caloric restriction.
- eru 16y agoFasting a day or a few days every now and then is quite bearable for normal people. Lots of religious people do it. (I am not saying that it is a good idea, or that it has health benefits. It may have some or it may not. But it is definitely bearable for some days with the right mindset.)
- xyzzyb 16y agoNot so. Even manage a couple of 500kcal "starter" days is not too bad. http://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/subsubsection1_3_3_0_3_4.html#SECTION0330340000000000000 http://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/subsubsection1_3_3_0_3_... The Hacker's Diet: appropriately named.
- matwood 16y agoNot only that, but you also need to stay at healthy eating habits past the diet. If you're cutting so many calories it's makes it near impossible to keep at it, much less adjust back up to a maintenance level once weight goals are hit.
- starkfist 16y agoThere's a lot of glycemic index nonsense out there today. There is a low carb meme which will have you believe that just a few ounces of "carbs" will throw your metabolism out of whack and you won't lose weight even if you keep calories low. This is bullshit. However, if you are trying to lose weight, it's often good to leave out carbs simply because it is so easy to overeat carbs. I love pasta and could easily eat 1200 calories worth of spaghetti and still have room for more. On the other hand , I almost have to choke down 1200 calories of eggs, fruit and vegetables.
- js2 16y agoJust, fyi, that low-carb meme has been around since 1863: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Banting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Banting Maybe Banting was on to something. :-)
- evo_9 16y agoI disagree - glycemic index is a hugely important factor that a lot of people just don't consider. I certainly didn't until recently and now I'm a convert. Why GI is a big deal is simple: if you eat a lot of high GI foods your spike your blood sugar levels causing all sorts of issues from mood swings to hunger. For me simply paying a little more attention and eating more low GI foods has had a profound effect on my well being. I find I'm more focused and centered mentally and emotionally; I never have mood swings from 'bottoming out' - aka running out of fuel and needing to eat. This use to cause me a lot of stress with my gf and my ex (they have told me in the past they worried about when I would be hungry next because I'd become irrational and argumentative). I think it's easy to think something like the glycemic index is just a new 'fad' diet type of thing. I know I use to think only people with diabetes had to worry about GI. But what I've found is that it is a hugely beneficial thing no matter who you are. Final thought on this - if you really don't think there is anything to the whole GI thing, next time you are hungry eat 8-10 almonds (maybe mix in some raisons or cranberries - they are high GI but together the overall 'load' is low) and see how quickly your hunger vanishes and your mood levels off. This isn't for 10 minutes either; I then have enough time to really think about lunch/dinner and make a really good choice instead of eating whatever is laying around because I'm 'starving'. Anyway, I lost around 35 pounds in the past 2 month using this 'trick', but I also workout 5 days and get out and hike, play hockey and generally try to be active when I'm not coding.
- rubashov 16y ago> There is no significant evidence that refined or unrefined carbs are bad for your weight loss There's a ton of evidence, actually. See GCBC. > there is no evidence-based way to get results High fat diets work. The clinical trials are pretty clear. Eat more saturated fat and less starch, and people get thin. Also, this "refined carbohydrate" and "glycemic index" business is pretty much nonsense. Carbs are carbs. It doesn't much matter if the source is sugar or rye bread. The total resulting insulin exposure is the same.
- Todd 16y agoTrue. However, carbs in the form of whole foods (like whole grain bread) take longer to process and don't cause the insulin spike. The insulin response is part of the problem that these diets seek to address.
- KirinDave 16y agoPlease link citations to real studies instead of a book. If GCBC is a quality, well-sourced work, I'm sure this should be trivial. Saying, "read this book" is not helpful in this discussion. You don't even offer references from the book, you're telling us to read the whole thing just to even address your claims.
- jerf 16y agoIn another of your comments, you claim to be a fan of GCBC. I find it difficult to believe you are a "fan" of GCBC when you are apparently unaware of the tens of pages of citations it has in the back of it. I am not making up that number. And yes, it cites the studies that are not in its "favor" and discusses them too. Your comment is basically "You're being too informative. Could you break it down for me further, again, one more time?" Seriously, no. People have already summarized it endlessly, ask Google about it, or even just poke around this thread a bit. If you want the full effect, go buy it and read it. (That's targeted at everybody reading this, not just you personally KirinDave.)
- pmccool 16y ago
- gxs 16y agoYou are exactly right. >Carbs can be bad because carb-rich foods tend to be surprisingly high in calories, but that's about it from a weight loss perspective. This is exactly right also. The reason I avoid white bread, etc. is only because it is so calorie dense. That said, a carb is a carb is 4cal/gram.
- noodle 16y agoi think its more an issue with the fact that our older food pyramid has trained people to eat lots of carbs, and carbs are a staple in many american meals. over the course of the day, you can eat a lot of carbs if you're not paying attention. the point of counting carbs is to make sure you're not eating 10+ servings in a day from your bagel breakfast, sub sandwich lunch and pasta dinner.
- msluyter 16y agoI don't believe the evidence is on your side. The reason carbs damage us more than merely their caloric content is, to quote Dr. William Davis of The Heart Scan Blog: "Carbohydrates increase small LDL particles. Or, in the cholesterol-speak most people understand, "carbohydrates increase cholesterol." It's counterintuitive, but carbohydrates increase LDL substantially, far more than any fat. Carbohydrates increase blood sugar. Eggs don't increase blood sugar, nor do chicken, raw almonds, onions or green peppers. But a bowl of oatmeal will send your blood sugar skywards. Carbohydrates make you fat. Carbohydrates, whether in the form of wheat flour in your whole wheat bread, sucrose in your ice cream, fructose in your "organic Agave nectar," or high-fructose corn syrup in your dill pickles. They all provoke de novo lipogenesis, or fat formation. They also stimulate insulin, the hormone of fat storage. Carbohydrates cause glycation. High blood sugar, like the kind that develops after a bowl of oatmeal, triggers glycation, or modification of proteins by glucose (blood sugar). This is how cataracts, kidney disease, and atherosclerotic plaque develop. Small LDL is 8-fold more glycation prone than large LDL, providing a carbohydrate double-whammy." I also recommend Good Calories, Bad Calories, by Gary Taubes, which is a well documented indictment of our common wisdom regarding nutrition (ie, things like the preposterous food pyramid). The general point is that not all calories are alike. My own merely personal anecdote: after eliminating all wheat and almost all other carbs from my diet, I lost ~35 points effortlessly. All this while not doing much exercise at all (recent evidence suggests that your body simply adapts to exercise by getting hungrier). I was much hungrier and unhappier on a low fat diet.
- jules 16y ago> (recent evidence suggests that your body simply adapts to exercise by getting hungrier) Interesting. I have experienced the opposite. Exercising reduces my appetite and I have to consciously eat more to avoid losing weight. Do you have references?
- msluyter 16y agoHere's the article I was thinking of when I wrote that: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/04/phys-ed-why-doesnt-exercise-lead-to-weight-loss/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/04/phys-ed-why-doesnt-...
- mrtron 16y agoAvoiding carbs is a hack. What it really should say is avoid 80% of the crappy cheap carbs you get from super refined/processed foods and sugars. Just try eating 1000 calories of these categories: -breads -meat -veggies -fruits Which one is by far the easiest to intake? Breads. An average person eats way too many calories by carbs. So it is undeniably true that cutting down carbs will cut down your calorie intake, and cut down your weight. Not many other cultures eat flour and sugar in such quantities.