4 ms·
“The problem is a 1969 tax law that bars foundations from owning more than a small stake in private businesses.” So this isn’t exactly news, and it certainly w
by mikestew 9y ago
“The problem is a 1969 tax law that bars foundations from owning more than a small stake in private businesses.”
So this isn’t exactly news, and it certainly wasn’t news when Newman’s lawyers wrote his will. As much as I want to sympathize and scream “those Republican bastards!”, I kinda think this is a problem of Newman’s (be it the man, the company, or the foundation) own doing.
- tomcam 9y agoUpvoted, probably futilely, because it's unpleasantly true
- mikestew 9y agoI kinda posted that hoping someone with a qualified opinion would come along and say, “no, you fscking idiot, you’ve got it all wrong, and here’s why...”. Because I like the products, and the Newman entities at least appear to do good stuff. Alas, 28 points of upvoting later, no one’s calling me an idiot.
- sitkack 9y agoBeing correct != being right
- rashkov 9y agoThat may be so, but don't we want a company like newman's own to exist and do good in the world? Maybe they shouldn't exist under the current tax regime, but it's not the company that's in the wrong but rather the system that it operates under.
- adventured 9y agoPlease explain, if you would, why you think a charity should be able to own majority positions in for profit operating businesses and shield the profits from that private business behind a charity-based tax approach. That can enable, among other things, vast abuses by companies that set up charities just to act as a front for private businesses to shield profits from high tax brackets. The charity still has to distribute a certain modest percentage of their assets per year, and that pales in comparison to paying 30% or more in taxes. So you set up Burger Charity (or call it McDonald's Charity), which owns BurgerStand USA (operating restaurants). BurgerStand generates profit and kicks it back to Burger Charity almost entirely tax free. Burger Charity uses the tax free proceeds to accumulate vast amounts of real estate, which it then leases to BurgerStand (at an artificially cheap rate made possible by the low tax structure, providing a competitive advantage) for restaurant locations. Then they can do the same for equipment in the restaurants as well (Burger Charity owns the equipment and leases it to BurgerStand at an artificially low rate). Perhaps you set up Burger Equipment Corp that you own, and Burger Land Holdings Corp that you own, they all work with BurgerStand USA (the profits of which all kick back to Burger Charity mostly tax free). Cycle and repeat for an astounding tax avoidance scheme that provides a blatantly unfair advantage to an entity willing to abuse the charity approach.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>That can enable, among other things.. You're entirely missing the point. The point is that our tax laws should be written in a way to enable an entity like Newman's Own to operate without enabling the many abuses you describe.
- Ntrails 9y ago> The point is that our tax laws should be written in a way to enable an entity like Newman's Own to operate without enabling the many abuses you describe. People have this naive view that tax law is insanely complex and full of loopholes for fun and/or profit. It isn't. It's largely because well intentioned people tried to do a "right thing" for some specific circumstance and unintended consequences made the outcomes wrong. So you plug two holes when there's an outcry but 2 months later some other politician has a great idea and accidentally makes three new ones.
- Shivetya 9y agoour tax laws should be written in the simplest form possible with the least amount of exceptions so that people or corporations don't violate rules by what at times appears to be random chance nor be so complicated that spending millions looking for a specific set of rules is a viable pursuit. personally outside of individual and religious groups I don't see why others should be excused from taxation for being charitable. businesses get name recognition for their activities and it should be part of being a good corporate entity instead of a payoff
- lotsofpulp 9y agoNo one should be exempt from taxation, period.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoMeaningless. Taxes are a complex system with no foundation other than "collect the most feathers with the least squawking". There's no moral basis to who pays how much.
- Retric 9y agoPaying taxes does not equal not exist. Yes, private organizations can provide positive outcomes, but so do taxes so the option to just keep going and pay remains.
- a3n 9y agoThis is not regular "paying your fair share" taxes, it's intentionally punitive at 200%. Would you exist economically if your tax bill was 200%?
- Retric 9y agoI am not a company. As companies pay taxes on their profit after expenses a 40% or 80% tax rate only reduces but does not eliminate their profits. That said, they will probably be significantly better off to sell the company, but it's simply not required.
- isleyaardvark 9y agoIt was also a decision by the Parliamentarian, which is a non-partisan position. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_States_Senate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentarian_of_the_United_...