14 ms·
Alexa, are you listening?
- oulipo 9y agoVery interesting, that is why the real privacy is when your assistant does not need an internet connection to play your videos and to turn on the lights in your home Disclaimer: I'm a co-founder of https://snips.ai https://snips.ai we are building a 100% on-device and private-by-design Voice AI platform, which we will open-source over time You can build voice assistants for free and upload them on your Raspberry Pi to run them without an internet access We believe that it makes no sense for Google or Amazon to send data to their servers each time you want to get a coffee with your smart coffee machine We take the privacy of people seriously
- xyzzy_plugh 9y agoYou posted the exact same comment a few moments ago in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15853081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15853081 Both within minutes of the article posting.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe bigger issue is that all they do is promote their tech. https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=oulipo https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=oulipo
- oulipo 9y agoSure, they were both relevant to what we build
- jstanley 9y agoIf you really take privacy seriously why isn't the code that you expect people to run on their own devices in their own homes open source already?
- oulipo 9y agoWe will be open-sourcing code in the coming months
- sctb 9y agoAs other users mentioned, please stop. We ban accounts that post only for promotional purposes. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Xeoncross 9y ago> The Amazon Echo does include a physical mute button that disables the microphone on the top of the device or can be turned off when sensitive information is being discussed (this is a hardwire mechanism and cannot be altered via software). I had wondered this.
- Lionleaf 9y agoYeah, that's good to know. Anyone have some insight on the implementation of the Google Home mute button?
- chadlavi 9y agolooks hardwired: https://medium.com/@justlv/google-home-mini-teardown-comparison-to-echo-dot-and-giving-technology-a-voice-c59a23724a26 https://medium.com/@justlv/google-home-mini-teardown-compari...
- jobigoud 9y agoIt should be called a "deaf" button, with a crossed ear icon...
- smileysteve 9y agodisturbingly, this is clearly not the case for ecobee.
- xyzzy_plugh 9y agoThis is really cool (rooting devices is wonderful -- and they should all be open for home modifications!), but also not something that has any real effect on the average consumer. Physical attacks are, in my opinion, uninteresting, because you may as well just plant an old fashioned bug. Consumers should be wary of purchasing used devices like this generally. I am not, however, aware or any wide spread scams involving physical attacks on consumer electronics.
- djsumdog 9y agoRemember the Valut7 leaks contained an attack via USB on Samsung TVs. If you're targeted, an operative could infect your device in transit before it reaches you.
- BoorishBears 9y agoWhy couldn't they just open your device and implant another device? It wouldn't even have to be conspicuous, maybe just replace a power supply board with something with an extra blob.
- dTal 9y agoThere's a pretty huge difference between "dismantle unit" and "insert USB drive". The latter could be done on a lunch break.
- gregmac 9y ago> Physical attacks are, in my opinion, uninteresting, because you may as well just plant an old fashioned bug. The one benefit is the target is going to specifically locate this device in a location where it can hear them, and will relocate it appropriately if they move furniture, rooms, houses, etc. There's nothing physical to discover to tip them off. It's a listening device disguised as a listening device. No need to hide, even though it's in plain sight.
- rightos 9y ago
- Lionleaf 9y agoI recently got a Google Home, and I've been thinking about how to potentially build a "is-the-microphone-actually-recording?" device. A basic one should be possible just by watching the power draw, but that would probably trigger if it decides to download a firmware update or whatever too. I expect this has been done before?
- the_rosentotter 9y agoOf course it's listening, at all times. Otherwise it would not be able to react to the trigger phrase. What is interesting is whether it sends this data anywhere, and that is probably impossible to ascertain, since it could store it for a while and tunnel it out with innocent looking traffic. It would be interesting if it could be determined if it stores the passively obtained data at all. If one could monitor writes to memory while in passive state it might give a clue.
- Lionleaf 9y agoWell, duh, of course it is. Monitoring writes to memory would be pretty interesting
- icebraining 9y agoSince apparently it can be rooted without affecting the listening process, it should be possible to monitor writes in pure software. Of course, it may detect the monitoring and avoid writing in those cases /tinfoil
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 9y agoI would never have one of these devices in my home, and I'm surprised I see so many of them in homes of people who are in the tech industry. I wondered if people in security would have them and so I contacted one of my good friends who is a security expert. "What's an Alexa device?" He's a Kiwi. Amazon hasn't made it to NZ yet. He's only seen them on TV shows. Interestingly this article is nothing about what gets transmitted, but just hacking the device. It would be kinda cool if we started to see projects to turn Amazon devices into one of the open source variants like Jarvis.
- craig1f 9y agoI think like, with most things, it's all about the tradeoff. I have one in my house in the living room. It basically exists to have an easy way of turning on Spotify. We don't have sensitive conversations in the living room. If someone were listening, they'd mostly get me scolding my children and asking what's for dinner. The might also steal a token to connect to Spotify. My AWS account isn't linked to the same account as my Alexa, and requires TFA, so that's safe. I wouldn't put this device in my bedroom. I also was less interested when my kids were young enough that I might actually have a sensitive conversation anywhere. I'd considered putting one in my tv room to control the tv, but that's about it. I don't regard the Alexa as a greater vulnerability to my house than my phone, and I already accept owning a smart phone. I am concerned about the same things you are, but I view it as more of a trade-off than a simple "just don't do it!" attitude.
- politician 9y agoDepending on who's listening (post-processing recordings in bulk) and your tone, scolding your children might get you a visit from the authorities if over-eager busibodies are listening. Do we really need more of that?
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI consider that a feature, not a bug - if mining data from always-on devices protected kids who were actually being abused, that would be a win. False positives can be tuned out.
- monochromatic 9y agoIt baffles me that anyone would allow such a device in their home, let alone pay for the privilege.
- jderick 9y agoHow is it different from a cellphone really, though?
- ggg9990 9y agoI have one. Do I like the privacy aspect? No. But my wife breastfeeds our baby for 3 hours a day and she needs music and audiobooks that she can control without using her hands. It's a simple trade off. My privacy is worth something but not infinitely valuable.
- amelius 9y agoSince you are a geek (I suppose), can't you figure out a way for her to play audio without sending private information to Amazon? Anyway, pretty soon we'll have open source speech recognition, so I guess then you'll really have no excuses left.
- kodt 9y agoWhat private information is getting sent to Amazon apart from your musical interests in that case?
- monochromatic 9y agoEverything that is ever said within earshot of the device, potentially.
- kodt 9y ago"Potentially" but we can examine network activity and verify that it is not in fact sending data all the time.
- baldeagle 9y agoI solve the sensitive conversation problem by having my device hit an IFTTT task to disconnect itself from the lan. Then I have another task to turn it back on.
- eesmith 9y agoCouldn't the intermediate conversation be stored and sent when there's connectivity?
- kodt 9y agoAre you talking about a hypothetical hacked Echo, or a standard unmodified Echo device?
- eesmith 9y agoAhh, I was talking about a hypothetical hacked Echo as described in the article, or perhaps the sort of Echo modified by Amazon due to court order. I think now that the top-level comment concerned a standard unmodified Echo device, so my comment doesn't apply.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Daycrawler 9y agoThis requires physical access. You can plant surveillance gear all over the place if you have physical access.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhat's with the glut of anti-alexa articles recently? Am I just in the minority of security conscious people who think Alexa is pretty benign?
- originalbryan2 9y agoYeah, I think we are a minority.
- unobtaniumstool 9y agoTechnological ignorance? Most people who are afraid of technology don't seem to understand it very well. God knows why they'd be here though.
- Fifer82 9y agoI honestly just expected better from HackerNews folks. I am not irritated oh_sigh, I am just very disappointed.
- 6d6b73 9y agoGreat, now you could simply buy Echo for someone on your Christmas list, hack it, and give it to them. And you could always blame it on "hackers".
- icebraining 9y agoOr you could give them any electrical device, and stick a mic and transmitter inside it.
- eesmith 9y agoPhysically modified devices are harder to blame on "hackers".
- nulagrithom 9y ago"The $foo is vulnerable to a physical attack that allows an attacker to gain a root shell..." This is true for nearly any device, including your cell phone, your MacBook, etc, etc, ad nauseam. And every time these devices come up there's so many comments on how they would never have one in their home, ostensibly because "it's always listening". This is sickeningly naive in my opinion. Any device with a microphone is capable of the same thing. You shouldn't be trusting your phone any more than an Alexa device.
- dsp1234 9y agoYou shouldn't be trusting your phone any more than an Alexa device. I don't
- unobtaniumstool 9y agoSickeningly naive is a good description. Especially on technology forums. It's like the recurring conspiracy theory about the Facebook app literally listening to people's conversations -- if you're reasonably technical, you already understand how silly that is.
- jnwatson 9y agoLeaving debug pads is not a vulnerability that most people care about. Expecting physical tamper resistance is unnecessary for regular appliances. Even if the debug pads weren't available, one could replace the flash, or use a scanning electron microscope to modify bits in the main microprocessor. This isn't a smart card. Here's a vulnerability that almost every device has: an attacker with physical access can replace the device with an identical looking device. The new device might even have explosives!
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI wouldn't even call leaving debug pads a vulnerability; I'd call it being not totally anticonsumer.
- joshuas 9y agoI don't get the fear mongering. It seems infinitely more likely my computer is compromised than some single purpose device that doesn't load code from third party developers or visit random web pages. If we're expecting that Apple/Google/Amazon/Microsoft are the people attacking us then they have easier ways. If we expect it's outsiders then how do they even get to my Alexa?
- pavement 9y agoJust because they have easier ways, doesn't mean they need more ways.
- DerfNet 9y ago100% my stance on it. To expand, these devices do not offer enough convenience in exchange for so thoroughly triggering my paranoia.
- shawn-butler 9y agoThey raise the issue of having Alexa devices in semi-private places like hotel rooms[0]. I think people have an expectation of privacy in a hotel room. And I assume major hotels have security measures in place to catch consumer-level eavesdropping devices. Rooting an Alexa device in this manner seems like something that could easily be done by a prankster requiring no specialized equipment. Has anyone stayed in Wynn hotel in Vegas? Are the alexa devices just out in the open or built into the room somehow that might easily show tampering? Or, maybe they have only the latest version with the debug pads disabled? [0]: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/wynn-las-vegas-announces-the-addition-of-amazon-echo-to-all-hotel-rooms-300377995.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/wynn-las-vegas-anno...
- thanatropism 9y agoThat's entirely orthogonal to smart devices. Tape recorders have been used for... a long time.
- joshuas 9y ago
- escapologybb 9y agoI may have posted this same sentiment on the other threads on this topic so please feel free to ignore. I see some confusion as to why anybody would want these devices in the houses whatsoever and would like to offer an answer: Quadriplegia. Imagine walking into your house one day and all of the keys had been taken off your keyboard, every light switch is smooth, all of the doorknobs have disappeared, the controls on your stereo have disappeared and every other switch, lever and/or physical method of interacting with your devices had disappeared. That was what it was like to be me as a quadriplegic Geek. Then came the Amazon Echo and its ilk. The Echo coupled with Home Assistant[1] has absolutely revolutionised my life and enabled me to do all of the things above that I wasn't able to do before. It's a pretty compelling reason for me. Am I worried about my privacy? Absolutely. Am I any more worried about the Amazon Echo than I am about the microphone in my iPhone, television, MacBook Pro, iMac and weirdly my fridge? Nope. As others have pointed out it's a trade-off, I could be completely private and not be able to do anything or I could accept this somewhat Faustian bargain and be able to control almost every aspect of my house. Crappy situation to be in, but there is. There are a few open source alternatives coming through which keep everything within the wire, but until they get traction enough to be out interact with all my other devices I can't use them. Which sucks. Anyway, hopefully this comment was helpful and am available to answer questions on any topic other than physics. I'm rubbish at physics. :-) [1]: https://home-assistant.io/ https://home-assistant.io/
- notyourday 9y ago> Quadriplegia Damn, and no VC went into that huge market?!
- gamblor956 9y agoYour sarcasm aside, his comment extends to pretty much all persons with limited mobility, which includes the sick, injured, and elderly.
- escapologybb 9y agoI don't think they were being sarcastic, were they? Or am I hopelessly naive and operating under the Principle of Charity? ;-) /sarcasm [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity Edited to add: corrected stupid voice dictation mistakes.
- Verdex_3 9y agoI expected a scare piece on privacy but I got an in depth technical break down of an alexa security bug.
- larrykwg 9y agoSeriously as others have pointed out thats NOTHING. Anyone can do this to pretty much any device, I did that to my ISP's router even and don't feel its any less secure because of it. Its an interesting hack but its not proof of any insecurity of Alexa. I don't think its such a good idea to over-dramatize these things for personal gain (like the author) because it hurts the security researcher community as a whole. I've already lost ANY trust of any security guys talking about the end of the world vulnerability they found, 99% of the time its bullshit like this. But I can read their disclosure and quickly discern whats irrelevant, I can imagine most non-IT people not able to do this and thus becoming MUCH more desensitized to ACTUAL vulnerabilities. Yet another boy who cried wolf security guy, they should've published this as "how to root your alexa" that would've been actually cool, this is just garbage.
- Incanus_uk 9y agoDid you actually try reading the article? It is an in depth guide on how to root the device and a far cry from a scare piece.
- EADGBE 9y agoI'll worry about this when I need to worry about someone breaking into my home and finding a reason to modify electronic devices utilizing the debug ports on stationary products. I also don't take myself so seriously when I don't find a need to.
- joshstrange 9y agoI think I might be one of the few people in this thread who now want to buy an echo specifically to root it and play with possibility connecting it to my own servers...