6 ms·
In a Venezuela Ravaged by Inflation, ‘a Race for Survival’
- yostrovs 9y agoThe word "socialism" is missing from the article. The situation must be a natural disaster.
- cdancette 9y agoThat's not socialism. That's a dictatorship and corruption.
- mmirate 9y agoFunny how socialism always seems to require the amount and kind of force provided by a dictatorship...
- WJW 9y agoLike in most of Western Europe?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BjoernKW 9y agoThere's no socialism in Western Europe, at least not by common standards. It's called social democracy. In contrast to socialism the means of production are largely privately owned and there's no single-party system.
- ptaipale 9y agoWestern Europe is not "socialist countries". The traditional meaning of a socialist state is "means of production are controlled by the state". None of the countries in Western Europe work like this. They are market economies. What people often don't understand is, by the way, that the supposedly "more socialist" countries in North Europe, like Sweden, Norway, Finland and Denmark, are in fact in many ways more market driven and have very free economies, compared to e.g. "non-socialist" Southern Europe. But of course, in all countries the politics meddles with the economy.
- cdancette 9y agoNot at all. Social democracies never needed this amount of force, nor current socialist regimes in Europe.
- Shivetya 9y agobut they are not socialist governments. don't confuse having the word in the government title as being the primary form being exercised.
- dgut 9y agoSocial democracy != socialism. Also, what "current socialist regimes in Europe"? What you mean is that some European countries have a welfare system paid by a highly effective capitalist economy.
- PeachPlum 9y agoNew Lanark (formed before Marx was even born), where the term socialism was coined, didn't need at kind of force. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Lanark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Lanark
- gaius 9y agoHow many socialist regimes need to end in "dictatorship and corruption" before the world realises that the latter is the inevitable consequence of the former?
- cdancette 9y agoI think you're confusing socialism and communism. A lot of Western European countries have or have had in the past decades socialist regimes.
- ekianjo 9y agoThere's often many names for the same ill.
- gaius 9y agoThe Western European countries are social democracies - not in socialism as a transitional phase as defined by Marx and Engels.
- tonfa 9y agoI don't think e.g. wikipedia agrees with such a restrictive view (there are many form of socialism). Also many of those countries have their main left wing party named "socialist party". (I think it's cultural difference between US and rest of world where the US considers socialism ~= communism)
- gaius 9y agoWell, M'n'E used the terms almost interchangeably, from the horse's mouth as it were. The USSR called itself "socialist".
- whistlecrackers 9y agoWhat's that saying about doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results?
- 9y ago
- whistlecrackers 9y agoIf you're not being sarcastic you're a fucking moron.
- sctb 9y agoCould you please re-read the guidelines and then stop posting like this? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ekianjo 9y agoDictatorship is the only natural course of Socialism. Removing/alienating private property go hand in hand with the destruction of elementary freedoms.
- whistlecrackers 9y agoRemoving private property is the destruction of an elementary freedom.
- ekianjo 9y agoYes, but it's not the only one. Hence the "s". And note that Socialists argue that private property is not a natural right as well.
- cdancette 9y agoThat's your belief based on current societies norms. Don't you think that the first tribes, before the agricultural revolution were not free? And yet they didn't have private property.
- gaius 9y agoAnd yet they didn't have private property Ride the chieftain's favourite horse and see what he'd have to say about ownership...
- sebcat 9y agoPrivate property as ownership is unjust according to e.g., Proudhon. Growing a piece of land and reaping the fruits of your labor is different from having a piece of land(/shares of a company/...) and benefiting from the work others do on that land. Not saying that I agree with that, just presenting a different point of view.
- MadSudaca 9y agoActually, it is socialism. If it hadn't been for the increase in power for government that socialism requires, this situation would probably have been averted. I believe this is one of the reasons why centralization of power in the hands of a government should be avoided as much as possible. If you think some of your government officials don't have the same thirst for power that would eventually lead the country in a path similar to that of Venezuela's, then you're putting too much faith in humanity.
- cynicalkane 9y agoSocialism, in the Marxist sense, requires a dictatorship. Specifically, the people are supposed to install a dictatorship to seize the means of production. This dictatorial body has absolute power to "rewrite society", including the abolition of traditional notions of justice, and civil, economic and human rights. How the dictatorship is supposed to be a means of representing the people's will is left unspecified. This is no problem to the Marxist, because their picture of the way the world works is quite different, and the fact that literally every Marxist socialist government became a brutal and incompetent dictatorship is not interpreted as a flaw of their belief system, but a sign that the will of the people was not properly enforced.
- sebcat 9y agoRevolutionary communism/Marxism (which Chávez identified with) likes the idea of the dictatorship of the proletariat. It is not a requirement for socialism in itself, and a lot of socialists would be directly opposed to it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 9y agoit never is socialism, never ever. it is a common thread when socialism fails it is because it wasn't really socialism. socialism works until you run out of wealth that other people had that was easily accessible. then comes the never ending cycle of finding a new bad guy to take from. all the fans of socialism always forget, the same problem that doomed Venezuela exists in all nations. Politicians. Politicians who are above the law, who are the one percent, who are there to lead and by that requirement deserve special status. Doesn't matter what you call your government type, they always have more power and less restrictions on their actions. the difference is that it is implied in a socialist society that there is no private property or very little. as such what is there to aspire too? some quasi socialist countries try to juggle this issue to some success but are they really socialist or truly capitalist with some "socialist" qualities? when government fails to protect the private property rights of people, to the effort of their work, their physical property, the wealth they create in their businesses, it is only a matter of time before it folds. you can only take until the wealth dries up. once that happens you only have force
- taway8879 9y agoWell, it's only natural to expect a disaster when you oppose the dominant foreign government policy. Not that is expected NYTimes to mention any of that of course.
- whistlecrackers 9y agoThat's why the New York Times isn't to be trusted.
- xienze 9y agoA couple years ago when Venezuela was riding high on the hog people couldn’t wait to talk about this triumph of socialism. Now that reality’s set in, as usual, it wasn’t real socialism. https://www.salon.com/2013/03/06/hugo_chavezs_economic_miracle/ https://www.salon.com/2013/03/06/hugo_chavezs_economic_mirac... The money quote: > When a country goes socialist and it craters, it is laughed off as a harmless and forgettable cautionary tale about the perils of command economics. When, by contrast, a country goes socialist and its economy does what Venezuela's did, it is not perceived to be a laughing matter - and it is not so easy to write off or to ignore.
- seibelj 9y agoWhen the solution to every problem is more government, more redistribution, and higher taxes, this is the inevitable result. A tragedy caused 100% by politics
- ekianjo 9y agoAnd Venezuela was among the richest countries in south America not too long ago (early 20th century). This is a cautionary tale.
- whistlecrackers 9y agoEvery socialist country is or will be a cautionary tale.
- Angostura 9y agoHow are you defining socialist country, here?
- ptaipale 9y agoI'll let whistlecrackers make his own definition, but I'd say: - problem is not that a country has some socialist policies - problem is not that a country has a party with "socialism" in its name in the government - problems definitely start to appear when a country has an autocratic government, whether it was originally "socialist" or "bolivarian" or whatever; an autocratic government then typically adapts some sort of "socialism" in its name in order to justify the autocracy, the choking of free markets, the political redistribution of resources, ad-hoc top-down responses to the economic problems that eventually come up, and the suppression of free media to hide the increasing problems.
- MadSudaca 9y agoYet we still don't learn the lesson after all the countries that have bit the dust.
- dang 9y ago
- RubenSandwich 9y agoThe amount of comments on this thread decrying 'socialism' with very pithy comments is concerning. I guess the whole internet is infected with trolls now, especially political ones...
- whistlecrackers 9y agoOr those who understand economics and history.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoI'd like some of them in here, but you're a troll. Or maybe we're the "fucking morons." Oh well, mods in California will be awake soon enough.
- whistlecrackers 9y agoNeed a safe space?
- thesmallestcat 9y agoYou mean like a forum with certain rules of civility? Yea, I guess so, welcome to our "safe space."
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop making HN worse just because other people are? I know how tempting it is but in the end these comments are just as much the problem as the others.
- dang 9y agoActually you posted so much of this that I've banned your account until we get a commitment to use HN as intended. You're welcome to email us at hn@ycombinator.com if you want to do this.
- 9y ago
- indubitable 9y agoI hate to also add to the cliche, but I think the description of one of the pictures in this article really emphasizes that perhaps it's not just a cliche: "Over 100 people lined up in Caracas to purchase price-controlled chicken. Chicken is highly sought after, yet very difficult to find for sale at affordable prices in Venezuela." Chickens are absurdly easy to farm. They're basically meat grass. Put them in a fenced area so they don't run away, and they pretty much take care of themselves. It doesn't have to a big area. And they grow just about as fast as weeds - growing naturally from egg to butcher time in 3-6 months depending on breed. What is preventing, or perhaps more likely - disincentivizing, people of even moderate means from doing this? It would be a trivial way to add a substantial side income that would simultaneously help out countless people, again as this article emphasizes. I never gave much weight to the stories or failed social systems, but this does seem to be very much a recurring pattern. Venezuela is obviously far from an ideal example, but reality itself is also hardly ideal. If we end up with these sort of collapses when systems are less than ideal -- then that alone is sufficient reason to doubt their viability.
- rory096 9y ago>What is preventing, or perhaps more likely - disincentivizing, people of even moderate means from doing this? Well that's an easy one. >price-controlled chicken Price controls (caps) lead to shortages. It's an Econ 101 concept that's been proved out dozens of times - from the oil crises to the Great Depression.
- friedButter 9y ago>What is preventing, or perhaps more likely - disincentivizing, people of even moderate means from doing this? Its more of a lack of incentive than disincentive. When making profit is essentially outlawed ( https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/15/venezuela-army-occupy-shops-profiteering https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/15/venezuela-army... ), what would motivate people to work and generate stuff?
- pandaman 9y agoThere was a joke in the USSR: Q. How can we eliminate the Sahara desert? A. Establish a socialist republic in the area and wait a bit for the shortages of sand.
- EGreg 9y ago“Something so simple as taking money out of a bank machine or buying a coffee or taking a taxi has become a race for survival,” Mr. Sandoval said. How much of this race to the ATM etc. would be a problem if the money supply was digital and everyone could use their phone to make purchases. I would like to propose a thought experiment and solicit opinions on whether situations like this can be mitigated by using a LOCAL digital (crypto) currency. Suppose the prices are marked up constantly but there is also a constant increase in the money supply available to the public. A user of an app could choose to view the prices in their preferred currency (eg dollars) while using the underlying currency so everything would seem more stable. Then it becomes an engineering problem of storing the amounts as two integers: 1. The number of cents 2. The power of 10 to which to raise the price. I would love to get feedback on the following: how to get the new money into the hands of the people? What if there was a system that automatically calculated eg the median amount people spent on food, and issued (a percent of) that amount the next day as Basic Income to everyone in ther account? Automatically issuing Basic Income based on Local CPI would organically allow people to prioritize necessities such as food before other transactions. Of course, unilateral issuance of money by the government (eg to pay debt) would rob people of the savings power in that currency. But they could buy non perishable assets as investments and a store of value, including bitcoin. Under such a system, the currency would then still be usable as a medium of exchange, which can be decoupled from its role as a store of value. However, if the newly issued money was solely issued to pay the foreign debt, it would not be available for the local population to use. This is the real problem with austerity. The currency is devalued on global markets, making imported goods more and more expensive. Runaway inflation is exponential. The government would have to BALANCE printing money to satisfy foreign interests with issuing money to its own citizens (eg as UBI to all citizens - which even Ron Paul himself suggested as a better alternative to bailing out the banks). In other words for every X amount you print to satisfy foreign debts you issue 2X to your own citizens, so they can still buy necessities. This is not ideal -- but it does allow a country to soften the blow of austerity. Incurring such debts is the underlying problem. They should just default, like Iceland. And issue a new currency to all their people. They still keep paying their debts, even as the price of oil plummeted and they do not have enough real assets to back their foreign promises anymore. By defaulting on their debts, they can once again get control of their own money supply, which is probably far more valuable to each citizen than the country's credit rating -- paying debts on the verge of bankruptcy isn't doing any of the citizens any favors. That's the real mistake of the Maduro government in my opinion. Disclaimer: my company is building a technology to power all the things I said for communities -- doesn't have to be countries. Cities like Detroit or even a remote unbanked village in Africa should be able to have their own local currency and run their own monetary policy, and hopefully using DIRECT democracy rather than representative democracy which can lead to stuff like this. Much of the economic analysis and fundamentals should be automated and available to every citizen, making them informed enough to choose what they want to do, instead of watching their leaders mess it up. PS: Why is this being downvoted? Do we just have to say "socialism -- so bad -- sigh" and move on without any substantive analysis of possible real solutions to existing problems?
- tuna-piano 9y agoThis whole situation is so sad, because it is 100% human caused. This is not a natural disaster! Socialism does not work and it is not moral. Hundreds of millions of people have died and suffered under this economic and governmental system, and many more will die in Venezuela to re-learn this lesson. And yet, even in the face of overwhelming evidence, the appeal of socialism still somehow permeates to otherwise succesful countries. Sure, the lines between Social Security+Medicare vs Denmark vs Venezuela aren't so black+white, but it's clear to me that the desire to destroy capitalism continues to be strong. It is quite scary to me that people can be so delusional even with the overwhelming evidence of the success of capitalism for the poor and the absolute failure of socialism for everybody. "Thanks Hugo Chavez for showing that the poor matter and wealth can be shared. He made massive contributions to Venezuela & a very wide world." -Leader of the Labour party in the UK[1] "These days, the American dream is more apt to be realized in South America, in places such as Ecuador, Venezuela and Argentina, where incomes are actually more equal today" -Bernie Sanders[2] [1] -https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/309065744954580992 https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/309065744954580992 [2] - https://www.sanders.senate.gov/newsroom/must-read/close-the-gaps-disparities-that-threaten-america https://www.sanders.senate.gov/newsroom/must-read/close-the-...
- cdancette 9y agoSo you think that the huge inequalities we have today in developed countries are a "huge success"? When the richest man in the world has 100B$, and yet 12% of Americans live under the poverty line?
- mmirate 9y agoYes. The richest people have produced orders of magnitude more value than those under the poverty line. And yes I'm talking about value for their customers. You know, the people who paid for their products and thereby made them rich.
- pistoriusp 9y ago"value" at the cost of the environment isn't value. It's debt.
- pingec 9y agoThe situation seems very worrying. How can people from the outside help? What is the situation with internet access over there? Are there any bloggers or reporters who report frequently on the situation and struggles frequently?
- tudorw 9y ago"The US has a long and bloody history of meddling in Latin America's affairs" http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/cia-venezuela-crisis-government-mike-pompeo-helping-install-new-remarks-a7859771.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/cia-venezue...
- BjoernKW 9y agoWhenever socialism goes awry there’s this True Scotsman argument: “Well, that’s not true socialism.” According to those standards there probably hasn’t been a true socialist society or state yet. The often mentioned Nordic model isn’t socialism by any narrow definition because it still involves free market capitalism and private ownership of the means of production.
- dwaltrip 9y agoWell, clearly, there is something going on very differently in the European socialist democracies, at the very least. Hmm, I just did a quick google search... this Quora question [1] seems to have some consensus that Venezuela is actually closer to a dictatorship that has some socialist aspects and some capitalist aspects. I don't know many details about the Venezuela situation, so I can't say too much more at this time. [1] https://www.quora.com/Is-Venezuela-a-socialist-or-communist-country https://www.quora.com/Is-Venezuela-a-socialist-or-communist-...
- BjoernKW 9y agoOne definition of communism or socialism in its more extreme varieties is that the state becomes the only remaining capitalist. So, having some capitalist aspects doesn't necessarily preclude socialism. Every real-world implementation of socialism (in the true sense of the word, not the Nordic / social democracy kind of system) to this day seems to either have had some features of a dictatorship right from the start or devolved into a dictatorship over time. The only instance of socialism I can think of where this wasn't the case is the Allende government in Chile and that unfortunately didn't last long enough (less than 3 years) to see how it would've evolved in the long run.
- sctb 9y agoMany of the comments in this thread violate this guideline: > Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents. This is particularly difficult to avoid on these controversial topics, but we have to try because the quality of the discussion when we do this is way below what this site exists for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- friedButter 9y agoHow can inflation be so rampant when the army enforces price control? https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/15/venezuela-army-occupy-shops-profiteering https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/15/venezuela-army...
- greeneggs 9y agoThe price controls can't be enforced everywhere, or trade would just move to the black market. They are presumably only enforced on stores that are not politically connected, and that are large enough to draw notice. When they are forced to sell below cost, these stores won't stock anything, so the price controls have no positive effect.
- nopinsight 9y agoA key contributing factor appears to be the capability to produce. The handout system in Venezuela had destroyed a large portion of that capability and thus when its stock of wealth in the form of oil becomes less valuable, the disaster ensues. Well-managed capitalism is much more efficient than socialism in inducing people and organizations to develop and upgrade their production capabilities. One of its unfortunate side effects is much larger inequality than socialism. Still, history has shown that over the long run, capitalism tends to be better even for the poor. Most poor people in the US still live better than many average people in certain countries (Example: a small fraction of people in India own a car; many poor people in the States do). On the other hand, pure capitalism is clearly not the most efficient system because it perpetuates the status quo, suffers from negative externalities, and underdevelops certain resources, especially those that require a long lead time and mostly yield social rather than private benefits. Prime examples include public infrastructure and talents born in underprivileged families. Capitalism that works well should maintain these two components that resemble socialism: 1) Long-term public investment to develop shared infrastructure, production capabilities, and talents, and 2) Redistribution to alleviate people from poverty trap and allow people to help themselves and become a contributing member to the community